doremus
board
education
argued
january
decided
march
statute
new
jersey
provides
reading
without
comment
five
verses
old
testament
opening
day
declaratory
judgment
action
instituted
two
appellants
state
held
statute
violate
federal
constitution
appellants
appealed
one
appellants
sued
parent
child
sued
taxpayer
held
appeal
dismissed
want
jurisdiction
pp
cause
moot
far
relates
rights
child
question
since
graduated
public
schools
appeal
taken
pp
facts
stated
appellants
taxpayers
sufficient
constitute
justifiable
case
controversy
within
jurisdiction
show
direct
particular
financial
interest
necessary
maintain
taxpayer
case
controversy
pp
declaratory
judgment
action
instituted
appellants
new
jersey
test
constitutionality
statute
state
state
held
statute
violate
federal
constitution
appeal
dismissed
heyman
zimel
argued
cause
filed
brief
appellants
theodore
parsons
attorney
general
henry
schenk
deputy
attorney
general
argued
cause
appellees
filed
brief
state
new
jersey
schenk
also
filed
brief
board
education
borough
hawthorne
appellee
briefs
amici
curiae
supporting
appellants
filed
leo
pfeffer
maslow
shad
polier
american
jewish
congress
kenneth
greenawalt
martin
schenck
arthur
garfield
hays
morris
ernst
herbert
monte
levy
american
civil
liberties
union
briefs
amici
curiae
supporting
appellees
filed
robert
woodside
attorney
general
harry
stambaugh
commonwealth
pennsylvania
denis
hurley
michael
castaldi
seymour
quel
daniel
scannell
arthur
kahn
city
new
york
behalf
board
education
city
new
york
albert
mccay
state
council
junior
order
american
mechanics
new
jersey
justice
jackson
delivered
opinion
action
declaratory
judgment
question
federal
constitutional
law
prosecuted
state
courts
new
jersey
sought
declare
invalid
statute
state
provides
reading
without
comment
five
verses
old
testament
opening
day
rev
issue
raised
state
constitution
act
claimed
violate
clause
first
amendment
federal
constitution
prohibiting
establishment
religion
trial
held
findings
fact
trial
denied
relief
merits
basis
pleadings
pretrial
conference
record
contains
meager
notes
new
jersey
appeal
rendered
opinion
act
violate
federal
constitution
spite
jurisdictional
doubts
pointed
condoned
follows
one
us
asserting
religious
practices
interfered
right
worship
accordance
dictates
conscience
suppressed
religious
sect
party
cause
representative
spokesman
religious
body
attacked
statute
one
plaintiffs
citizen
taxpayer
interest
asserts
words
set
forth
complaint
followed
specification
proof
conceded
citizen
taxpayer
charged
neither
conceded
proved
brief
interruption
day
schooling
caused
compliance
statute
adds
cost
school
expenses
varies
incomputable
scintilla
economy
day
work
plaintiff
addition
citizen
taxpayer
daughter
aged
seventeen
student
school
facts
asserted
case
violated
rights
urged
charged
practice
required
statute
conflicts
convictions
either
mother
daughter
apparently
sole
purpose
function
plaintiffs
shall
assume
role
actors
may
suit
invoke
ruling
upon
constitutionality
statute
respondents
urge
circumstances
question
moot
declaratory
judgment
statute
may
properly
used
justification
proceeding
cf
new
jersey
turnpike
authority
parsons
massachusetts
mellon
sup
ed
point
substance
nevertheless
concluded
dispose
appeal
merits
view
facts
taken
though
entitled
respect
bind
us
may
make
independent
examination
record
find
nothing
substantial
support
jurisdiction
appellants
apparently
seeking
bring
within
illinois
ex
rel
mccollum
board
education
assert
challenge
act
two
capacities
one
parent
child
subject
taxpayers
burdened
requirements
support
relationship
complaint
alleged
appellant
klein
parent
pupil
hawthorne
high
school
bible
reading
practiced
pursuant
act
assertion
injured
even
offended
thereby
compelled
accept
approve
confess
agreement
dogma
creed
even
listen
scriptures
read
contrary
pretrial
stipulation
student
parents
request
excused
bible
reading
case
excuse
asked
however
agreed
upon
argument
child
graduated
public
schools
appeal
taken
obviously
decision
render
protect
rights
may
sit
decide
arguments
events
put
rest
alaska
steamship
complaint
similarly
niggardly
facts
support
taxpayer
grievance
doremus
alleged
citizen
taxpayer
state
new
jersey
township
rutherford
relation
township
litigation
disclosed
one
familiar
local
geography
klein
set
citizen
taxpayer
borough
hawthorne
state
new
jersey
alleged
hawthorne
high
school
supported
public
funds
school
bible
read
according
statute
allegation
activity
supported
separate
tax
paid
particular
appropriation
adds
sum
whatever
cost
conducting
school
information
given
kind
taxes
paid
appellants
averment
bible
reading
increases
tax
pay
taxpayers
possibly
pocket
state
raised
defense
appellants
showed
standing
maintain
action
pretrial
conference
perhaps
premonitions
success
waived
acquiesced
determination
federal
constitutional
question
whether
facts
amount
justiciable
case
controversy
decisive
jurisdiction
held
interests
taxpayer
moneys
federal
treasury
indeterminable
remote
uncertain
indirect
furnish
basis
appeal
preventive
powers
manner
expenditure
alabama
power
ickes
massachusetts
mellon
et
seq
latter
case
recognized
however
interest
taxpayer
municipality
application
moneys
direct
immediate
remedy
injunction
prevent
misuse
inappropriate
indeed
number
provide
statute
decisional
law
causes
entertained
federal
courts
crampton
zabriskie
see
massachusetts
mellon
supra
without
disparaging
availability
remedy
taxpayer
action
restrain
unconstitutional
acts
result
direct
pecuniary
injury
reiterate
said
federal
statute
equally
true
state
act
assailed
party
invokes
power
must
able
show
statute
invalid
sustained
immediately
danger
sustaining
direct
injury
result
enforcement
merely
suffers
indefinite
way
common
people
generally
massachusetts
mellon
supra
true
found
justifiable
controversy
everson
board
education
everson
showed
measurable
appropriation
disbursement
funds
occasioned
solely
activities
complained
complaint
undertake
say
state
may
render
opinion
federal
constitutional
question
even
circumstances
regarded
advisory
jurisdiction
cast
terms
case
controversy
accept
basis
review
basis
conclusive
disposition
issue
federal
law
without
review
procedure
constitute
taxpayer
action
meet
test
pocketbook
action
apparent
grievance
sought
litigate
direct
injury
religious
difference
appellants
established
requisite
special
injury
necessary
taxpayer
case
controversy
matter
dominant
inducement
action
religious
mercenary
question
motivation
possession
requisite
financial
interest
threatened
injured
unconstitutional
conduct
find
direct
particular
financial
interest
act
may
give
rise
legal
case
controversy
behalf
appellants
obtain
decision
feigned
issue
taxation
motion
dismiss
appeal
granted
justice
douglas
justice
reed
justice
burton
concur
dissenting
think
case
deserves
decision
merits
group
interested
operation
management
public
schools
taxpayers
support
parents
whose
children
attend
certainly
suit
taxpayers
enjoin
practice
authorized
school
board
suit
vital
parties
interest
able
show
two
present
taxpayers
done
reading
bible
adds
taxes
pay
right
contentions
merits
establish
public
schools
deflected
educational
program
taxes
raised
seems
adequate
interest
maintenance
suit
taxpayers
apparent
reason
less
may
interest
present
case
issues
feigned
suit
collusive
mismanagement
school
system
alleged
clear
plain
suit
enjoin
federal
law
maintained
reason
massachusetts
mellon
new
jersey
fashion
rules
governing
institution
suits
courts
wants
give
taxpayers
status
sue
analogy
right
shareholders
enjoin
ultra
vires
acts
corporation
see
nothing
constitution
prevent
clash
interests
real
strong
odd
indeed
hold
case
controversy
within
meaning
art
iii
constitution