ladner
argued
november
decided
december
petitioner
convicted
federal
district
two
different
counts
assaulting
two
federal
officers
deadly
weapon
violation
ed
sentenced
imprisonment
years
conviction
assault
sentences
run
consecutively
upon
completion
first
sentence
moved
district
correct
second
consecutive
sentence
alleged
evidence
trial
showed
fired
one
discharge
shotgun
wounded
two
federal
officers
contended
circumstances
guilty
one
assault
holding
wounding
two
officers
single
discharge
shotgun
constitute
separate
offense
officer
statute
district
denied
motion
appeals
affirmed
held
single
discharge
shotgun
alleged
petitioner
case
constitute
single
violation
petitioner
entitled
opportunity
sustain
allegation
conviction
two
assaults
rested
upon
evidence
wounding
two
officers
resulted
single
discharge
gun
judgment
reversed
cause
remanded
proceedings
pp
question
scope
collateral
attack
upon
criminal
sentences
circumstances
case
decided
since
appear
government
raised
question
courts
tendered
question
presented
decision
pp
clear
statute
even
read
light
legislative
history
congress
intended
single
act
assault
affecting
two
officers
constitute
two
offenses
statute
pp
hold
many
assaults
committed
officers
affected
produce
incongruous
results
meaning
criminal
statute
ambiguous
policy
lenity
construction
criminal
statutes
requires
less
harsh
two
possible
meanings
adopted
pp
since
district
hold
hearing
petitioner
motion
proceedings
petitioner
trial
transcribed
necessary
hearing
motion
reconstruct
trial
record
order
determine
whether
petitioner
properly
convicted
one
offense
pp
harold
rosenwald
acting
appointment
reargued
cause
filed
two
briefs
petitioner
leonard
sand
reargued
cause
brief
solicitor
general
rankin
warren
olney
iii
assistant
attorney
general
beatrice
rosenberg
julia
cooper
justice
brennan
delivered
opinion
petitioner
convicted
district
southern
district
mississippi
assaulting
two
federal
officers
deadly
weapon
violation
former
sentenced
petitioner
maximum
punishment
years
imprisonment
conviction
assault
sentences
run
consecutively
upon
completion
first
sentence
petitioner
made
motion
district
correct
second
consecutive
sentence
supported
motion
allegations
evidence
trial
showed
fired
single
discharge
shotgun
front
seat
automobile
pellets
wounded
two
federal
officers
transporting
arrested
prisoner
contended
circumstance
guilty
one
assault
within
meaning
former
accordingly
subject
one
punishment
district
denied
motion
appeals
fifth
circuit
affirmed
courts
held
wounding
two
federal
officers
single
discharge
shotgun
constitute
separate
offense
officer
statute
granted
certiorari
consider
construction
light
principles
applied
construe
federal
criminal
statutes
involved
bell
universal
credit
prince
affirmed
appeals
equally
divided
vacated
judgment
set
case
reargument
petition
rehearing
granted
reargument
term
suggested
remedy
available
petitioner
circumstances
case
record
disclose
government
raised
question
district
appeals
government
tender
question
presented
decision
brief
often
reached
merits
case
involving
questions
statutory
construction
similar
presented
case
former
proceedings
way
collateral
attack
upon
consecutive
sentences
snow
petitioner
brought
habeas
corpus
proceeding
serving
seven
months
three
consecutive
sentences
claimed
sentencing
misinterpreted
applicable
statute
committed
single
offense
punishable
single
sentence
held
objection
may
taken
habeas
corpus
sentence
one
convictions
sought
enforced
bell
supra
case
fours
present
case
reached
question
statutory
construction
objection
government
brief
opposition
petition
certiorari
question
raised
motion
cases
reached
decided
questions
statutory
construction
although
questions
raised
collateral
attack
consecutive
sentences
include
tinder
gore
prince
supra
federal
rule
criminal
procedure
ebeling
morgan
habeas
corpus
morgan
devine
habeas
corpus
fact
often
reached
merits
statutory
construction
issues
proceedings
suggests
availability
collateral
remedy
jurisdictional
question
sense
properly
raised
nevertheless
determine
sua
sponte
moreover
meagre
argument
question
availability
remedy
case
government
submitted
short
discussion
question
body
brief
made
passing
reference
toward
close
oral
argument
question
scope
collateral
attack
upon
criminal
sentences
important
complex
one
judging
number
decisions
discussing
district
courts
courts
appeals
think
benefit
full
argument
dealing
question
therefore
proceed
construe
former
without
however
intimating
view
availability
collateral
remedy
another
case
question
properly
raised
adequately
briefed
argued
constitutional
issue
presented
question
decision
construction
given
former
circumstances
alleged
petitioner
congress
mean
single
discharge
shotgun
constitute
one
assault
thus
one
offense
regardless
number
officers
affected
congress
define
separate
offense
federal
officer
affected
act
congressional
meaning
plainly
open
question
face
statute
originated
act
may
stat
government
seriously
contend
otherwise
emphasizes
legislative
history
shows
statute
designed
protect
federal
officers
personal
harm
threat
personal
harm
performance
duties
account
performance
duties
premise
government
argues
must
offense
officer
put
immediate
apprehension
personal
injury
assaulted
officer
thus
defines
unit
prosecution
position
summed
government
brief
follows
legislation
aimed
protecting
federal
officers
promote
orderly
functioning
federal
government
whose
efficiency
diminish
proportion
number
individual
officers
affected
also
protect
individual
officers
wards
federal
government
personal
harm
legislative
objectives
make
individual
officers
separate
unit
protection
however
unable
read
legislative
history
clearly
illumining
statute
meaning
history
scant
consisting
largely
attorney
general
letter
recommending
passage
legislation
sheds
real
light
congress
intended
unit
prosecution
although
letter
mentions
need
legislation
protection
federal
officers
also
speaks
need
legislation
legitimate
purposes
federal
government
appears
argument
least
plausible
government
may
made
congressional
aim
prevent
hindrance
execution
official
duty
thus
assure
carrying
federal
purposes
interests
protect
federal
officers
except
incident
aim
support
meaning
may
found
fact
makes
unlawful
assault
federal
officers
engaged
official
duty
also
forcibly
resist
oppose
impede
intimidate
interfere
officers
clearly
one
may
resist
oppose
impede
officers
interfere
performance
duties
without
placing
personal
danger
congressional
aim
course
served
considering
act
hindrance
unit
prosecution
without
regard
number
federal
officers
affected
act
example
locking
door
building
prevent
entry
officers
intending
arrest
person
within
act
hindrance
denounced
statute
find
clearly
statute
even
read
light
legislative
history
congress
intended
person
locking
door
might
commit
many
crimes
officers
denied
entry
find
meaning
supposed
case
find
congress
intended
single
act
assault
affecting
two
officers
constitutes
two
offenses
statute
government
frankly
conceded
oral
argument
assault
treated
differently
outlawed
activities
single
act
hindrance
impact
two
officers
one
offense
act
assault
act
assault
one
offense
even
though
impact
two
officers
moreover
interpretation
many
assaults
committed
officers
affected
produce
incongruous
results
punishments
totally
disproportionate
act
assault
imposed
often
case
number
officers
affected
little
bearing
upon
seriousness
criminal
act
assault
ordinarily
held
committed
merely
putting
another
apprehension
harm
whether
actor
actually
intends
inflict
capable
inflicting
harm
thus
meaning
government
contends
one
shoots
seriously
wounds
officer
commit
one
offense
punishable
years
imprisonment
points
gun
five
officers
putting
apprehension
harm
commit
five
offenses
punishable
years
imprisonment
even
though
fire
gun
officer
actually
suffers
injury
difficult
without
clearer
indication
materials
us
provide
find
congress
intended
result
therefore
apparent
may
reasonably
read
mean
single
discharge
shotgun
constitute
assault
without
regard
number
federal
officers
affected
may
read
mean
many
assaults
committed
officers
affected
neither
wording
statute
legislative
history
points
clearly
either
meaning
circumstance
applies
policy
lenity
adopts
less
harsh
meaning
hen
choice
made
two
readings
conduct
congress
made
crime
appropriate
choose
harsher
alternative
require
congress
spoken
language
clear
definite
derive
criminal
outlawry
ambiguous
implication
universal
credit
bell
expressed
policy
follows
congress
leaves
judiciary
task
imputing
congress
undeclared
ambiguity
resolved
favor
lenity
see
also
prince
supra
gore
policy
lenity
means
interpret
federal
criminal
statute
increase
penalty
places
individual
interpretation
based
guess
congress
intended
congress
desires
create
multiple
offenses
single
act
affecting
one
federal
officer
congress
make
meaning
clear
thus
hold
single
discharge
shotgun
alleged
petitioner
case
constitute
single
violation
follows
petitioner
entitled
opportunity
sustain
allegation
conviction
two
assaults
rested
upon
evidence
wounding
two
officers
resulted
single
discharge
gun
district
hold
hearing
motion
view
single
discharge
admitted
resulted
two
assaults
appeals
affirming
ground
correctly
acknowledged
erroneous
view
law
necessity
determination
factual
question
must
hearing
petitioner
entitled
present
see
hayman
walker
johnston
proceedings
petitioner
trial
transcribed
necessary
hearing
motion
reconstruct
trial
record
decide
issue
tendered
parties
intimate
view
whether
petitioner
may
entitled
correction
consecutive
sentence
different
fact
situation
reconstructed
trial
record
may
disclose
judgment
appeals
reversed
case
remanded
district
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
footnotes
whoever
shall
forcibly
resist
oppose
impede
intimidate
interfere
person
federal
officer
designated
engaged
performance
official
duties
shall
assault
account
performance
official
duties
shall
imprisoned
three
years
whoever
commission
acts
described
section
shall
use
deadly
dangerous
weapon
shall
imprisoned
ten
years
ed
ladner
convicted
jury
three
separate
counts
one
conspiring
assault
officers
second
assaulting
one
officers
third
assaulting
officer
sentenced
two
years
conspiracy
count
sentence
run
concurrently
sentence
assaulting
one
officers
sentence
imposed
assault
second
officer
run
expiration
first
two
sentences
thus
ladner
sentenced
total
jail
term
years
proceedings
instituted
ladner
one
cameron
relief
reported
supp
letter
january
senator
ashurst
chairman
senate
committee
judiciary
follows
dear
senator
wish
renew
recommendation
department
legislation
enacted
making
federal
offense
forcibly
resist
impede
interfere
assault
kill
official
employee
engaged
account
performance
official
duties
congress
already
made
federal
offense
assault
resist
officers
employees
bureau
animal
industry
department
agriculture
engaged
account
execution
duties
sec
sec
title
assault
resist
officers
others
customs
internal
revenue
engaged
execution
duties
sec
sec
title
assault
resist
beat
wound
officer
person
duly
authorized
serving
attempting
serve
process
sec
sec
title
assault
resist
immigration
officials
employees
engaged
performance
duties
sec
immigration
act
stat
sec
title
three
statutes
cited
impose
increased
penalty
deadly
dangerous
weapon
used
resisting
officer
employee
need
general
legislation
character
protection
federal
officers
employees
specifically
embraced
statutes
cited
becomes
increasingly
apparent
every
day
federal
government
compelled
rely
upon
courts
however
respectable
well
disposed
protection
investigative
personnel
congress
recognized
fact
least
extent
indicated
special
acts
cited
department
found
need
similar
legislation
adequate
protection
special
agents
division
investigation
several
assaulted
course
year
performance
official
duties
cases
resort
must
usually
local
police
affords
little
relief
us
circumstances
effort
legitimate
purposes
federal
government
seem
preferable
however
instead
extending
piecemeal
legislation
statute
books
enact
broad
general
statute
embrace
proper
cases
within
outside
scope
existing
legislation
cases
point
assaults
letter
carriers
cover
post
office
department
several
years
past
sought
legislation
serious
wounding
couple
years
ago
warden
federal
penitentiary
leavenworth
escaped
convicts
outside
federal
jurisdiction
latter
case
possible
punish
escaped
convicts
federal
law
escape
punished
federal
law
shooting
warden
honor
therefore
enclose
herewith
copy
introduced
request
department
congress
urge
reintroduction
present
congress
express
hope
may
receive
prompt
serious
consideration
committee
respectfully
homer
cummings
attorney
general
concession
government
seems
necessary
view
lack
indication
assault
treated
differently
light
present
recodification
lumps
assault
rest
offensive
actions
statute
provides
whoever
forcibly
assaults
resists
opposes
impedes
intimidates
interferes
designated
federal
officer
engaged
account
performance
official
duties
committing
crime
reviser
note
indicates
change
wording
intended
substantive
one
see
burdick
law
crime
clark
marshall
law
crimes
miller
criminal
law
view
trial
judge
recollection
one
shot
fired
car
officers
riding
say
impossible
petitioner
properly
convicted
one
offense
even
principles
govern
although
stat
provides
recording
proceedings
criminal
cases
enacted
january
congress
appropriated
funds
payment
reporters
time
trial
june
see
ricard
vickers
justice
clark
dissenting
dubious
route
permitting
collateral
attack
made
old
judgment
proceedings
reaches
merits
agree
fully
ladner
contentions
see
enlargement
jurisdiction
subject
trial
dockets
rash
applications
prisoners
completely
overturn
purpose
congress
adopting
procedure
lieu
habeas
corpus
moreover
appears
adopting
ladner
view
merits
clearly
informs
criminal
might
permitted
borrow
phrase
assaults
lives
federal
officers
come
cheap
dozen
nearly
fourteen
years
ago
two
federal
officers
ambushed
seriously
wounded
ladner
shot
shotgun
sat
front
seat
vehicle
transporting
prisoners
arrested
raid
illicit
distillery
convicted
assault
officers
ladner
contends
fired
single
charge
shotgun
therefore
guilty
one
offense
regardless
number
officers
assaulted
principal
issue
see
case
procedural
one
namely
whether
allow
collateral
attack
ladner
sentence
important
question
argued
briefed
government
think
wrongly
decided
proceedings
motion
correct
consecutive
sentences
ten
years
imposed
counts
indictment
count
charges
assault
officer
james
buford
reed
count
charges
one
officer
frost
record
unclear
points
many
discharges
shotgun
ladner
fired
vehicle
hence
determination
issue
must
made
trial
remand
case
clearly
error
raised
appeal
undermine
jurisdiction
original
trial
allegations
indictment
counts
clearly
state
separate
offenses
raises
constitutional
issue
history
clearly
reveals
attach
authorized
reference
hayman
gives
us
complete
picture
judicial
conference
proposed
remedy
practical
problems
arisen
administration
federal
courts
habeas
corpus
jurisdiction
conference
submitting
measure
congress
noted
motion
remedy
broadly
covers
situations
sentence
open
collateral
attack
remedy
intended
broad
habeas
corpus
hayman
supra
today
holds
trial
may
committed
error
law
require
reconstruction
evidence
number
shots
fired
ladner
indicated
may
require
retrial
case
indictment
judgment
admittedly
regular
faces
dispute
entirely
facts
incident
issue
therefore
squarely
governed
principles
sunal
large
habeas
corpus
proceeding
attacking
conviction
admittedly
obtained
result
error
trial
neither
jurisdiction
trial
claimed
constitutional
violations
issue
speaking
justice
douglas
said
congress
provided
regular
orderly
method
correction
errors
granting
appeal
circuit
appeals
vesting
us
certiorari
jurisdiction
every
error
potentially
reversible
error
many
rulings
trial
spell
difference
conviction
acquittal
defendants
accept
judgment
conviction
appeal
later
renew
attack
judgment
habeas
corpus
litigation
criminal
cases
interminable
wise
judicial
administration
federal
courts
counsels
course
least
error
trench
constitutional
rights
defendants
involve
jurisdiction
trial
cites
seven
cases
decided
questions
statutory
construction
although
questions
raised
collateral
attack
upon
consecutive
sentences
cases
point
position
collateral
attack
made
error
sentence
apparent
facts
alleged
four
corners
indictment
admitted
parties
five
cases
snow
tinder
gore
prince
ebeling
morgan
error
sentencing
apparent
face
indictment
remaining
two
cases
bell
morgan
devine
facts
admitted
importance
distinction
indicated
prince
goes
way
point
admitted
respondent
robbery
charged
count
performed
immediately
entry
bank
charged
count
majority
point
single
case
collateral
attack
consecutive
sentences
permitted
facts
dispute
none
law
long
settled
formerly
habeas
corpus
contrary
however
even
surprising
runs
counter
understanding
efficient
judicial
administration
statement
holding
today
considered
intimating
view
availability
collateral
remedy
another
case
question
properly
raised
adequately
briefed
argued
find
counterpart
handling
precedents
implicit
therein
suggestion
come
another
case
point
properly
raised
adequately
briefed
argued
conclusion
different
meanwhile
says
ladner
precedent
question
availability
collateral
remedy
despite
permits
use
ad
hoc
disposition
keeping
good
business
conduct
necessary
administration
reach
merits
congress
however
may
correct
error
ad
hoc
manner
today
disposed
case
shall
us
always
precedent
others
follow
though
issue
mentioned
government
reply
petition
certiorari
bell
question
briefed
argued
merits
point
raised
government
devoted
four
pages
brief
discussing
separate
cases
research
question
indicates
little
add
government
discussion