national
cable
telecommunications
association
et
al
brand
internet
services
et
argued
march
decided
june
consumers
traditionally
access
internet
connections
provided
via
local
telephone
lines
internet
service
providers
isps
turn
link
calls
internet
network
providing
physical
connection
also
offering
consumers
ability
translate
raw
data
information
may
view
computers
transmit
others
connected
internet
technological
limitations
local
telephone
wires
however
retard
speed
internet
data
may
transmitted
narrowband
connections
broadband
internet
service
contrast
transmits
data
much
higher
speeds
two
principal
kinds
broadband
service
cable
modem
service
transmits
data
internet
users
computers
via
network
television
cable
lines
owned
cable
companies
digital
subscriber
line
dsl
service
uses
wires
owned
local
telephone
companies
ways
transmitting
internet
data
including
wireless
networks
also
emerging
communications
act
amended
telecommunications
act
defines
two
categories
entities
relevant
information
service
providers
offering
capability
processing
information
via
telecommunications
subject
mandatory
regulation
federal
communications
commission
common
carriers
title
ii
act
conversely
telecommunications
carriers
offering
telecommunications
fee
directly
public
regardless
facilities
used
subject
mandatory
title
ii
regulation
two
classifications
originated
late
commission
developed
rules
regulate
services
offered
telephone
wires
regulated
telecommunications
service
act
analog
basic
service
prior
regime
computer
ii
rules
rules
defined
service
pure
transparent
transmission
capability
communications
path
enabling
consumer
transmit
message
another
point
without
computer
processing
storage
information
via
telephone
facsimile
act
nformation
service
analog
enhanced
service
defined
computer
ii
rules
applications
act
subscriber
information
voice
data
storage
services
well
protocol
conversion
ability
communicate
networks
employ
different
formats
declaratory
ruling
review
commission
classified
broadband
cable
modem
service
information
service
telecommunications
service
act
subject
mandatory
title
ii
regulation
commission
relied
heavily
universal
service
report
earlier
classified
isps
transmission
facilities
use
connect
end
user
internet
solely
providers
internet
access
capability
manipulating
storing
information
commission
concluded
information
service
however
integrated
nature
access
wire
used
provide
led
commission
conclude
cable
companies
providing
telecommunications
service
providers
adopting
universal
service
report
reasoning
commission
held
cable
companies
offering
broadband
internet
access
like
isps
offer
end
user
telecommunications
service
merely
use
telecommunications
provide
end
users
cable
modem
service
numerous
parties
petitioned
review
judicial
lottery
appeals
ninth
circuit
selected
venue
challenge
granted
petitions
part
vacated
declaratory
ruling
part
remanded
proceedings
particular
held
commission
permissibly
construe
communications
act
exempt
cable
companies
providing
cable
modem
service
mandatory
title
ii
regulation
rather
analyzing
permissibility
construction
deferential
framework
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
however
grounded
holding
stare
decisis
effect
decision
portland
held
cable
modem
service
telecommunications
service
held
commission
conclusion
broadband
cable
modem
companies
exempt
mandatory
regulation
lawful
construction
communications
act
chevron
administrative
procedure
act
pp
chevron
framework
applies
commission
interpretation
telecommunications
service
pp
chevron
governs
review
commission
construction
see
national
cable
telecommunications
gulf
power
chevron
requires
federal
defer
agency
construction
even
differs
believes
best
interpretation
particular
statute
within
agency
jurisdiction
administer
statute
ambiguous
point
issue
agency
construction
reasonable
commission
statutory
authority
execute
enforce
communications
act
prescribe
rules
regulations
may
necessary
carry
act
provisions
give
commission
power
promulgate
binding
legal
rules
commission
issued
order
review
exercise
authority
dispute
order
within
commission
jurisdiction
pp
ninth
circuit
applied
chevron
framework
instead
following
contrary
construction
adopted
portland
prior
construction
statute
trumps
agency
construction
otherwise
entitled
chevron
deference
prior
decision
holds
construction
follows
unambiguous
terms
statute
thus
leaves
room
agency
discretion
see
smiley
supra
portland
held
best
reading
cable
modem
service
telecommunications
service
permissible
reading
communications
act
unambiguously
required
ninth
circuit
erred
refusing
apply
chevron
pp
commission
construction
telecommunications
service
definition
permissible
reading
communications
act
steps
chevron
test
pp
commission
question
whether
cable
companies
providing
cable
modem
service
offe
telecommunications
within
meaning
turned
nature
functions
offered
end
user
seen
consumer
point
view
commission
concluded
cable
wire
used
access
world
wide
web
newsgroups
rather
transparently
transmit
receive
messages
without
computer
processing
storage
message
integrated
character
offering
led
commission
conclude
cable
companies
make
transparent
offering
telecommunications
pp
commission
construction
permissible
chevron
first
step
asks
whether
statute
plain
terms
directly
addres
precise
question
issue
conclusion
follows
ordinary
meaning
offering
communications
act
regulatory
history
pp
statute
plain
terms
admit
two
reasonable
ordinary
usages
commission
choice
one
entitled
deference
see
verizon
communications
fcc
common
usage
describe
company
offers
consumer
consumer
perceives
integrated
finished
product
even
exclusion
discrete
components
compose
product
cable
companies
providing
cable
modem
service
offer
finished
internet
service
though
using
discrete
components
composing
end
product
including
data
transmission
functionally
integrated
components
need
described
distinct
offerings
pp
commission
traditional
distinction
basic
enhanced
service
also
supports
conclusion
communications
act
ambiguous
whether
cable
companies
offer
telecommunications
cable
modem
service
congress
passed
act
definitions
background
regulatory
history
may
assumed
parallel
terms
telecommunications
service
information
service
substantially
incorporated
meaning
basic
enhanced
service
history
least
two
respects
confirms
term
telecommunications
service
ambiguous
first
computer
ii
order
establishing
terms
basic
enhanced
services
commission
defined
terms
functionally
based
consumer
interacts
provided
information
commission
order
review
cable
modem
service
transparent
terms
interaction
information
transmission
occurs
connection
information
processing
therefore
consistent
statute
terms
commission
assume
parallel
term
telecommunications
service
likewise
describes
pure
transparent
communications
path
necessarily
separately
present
integrated
service
perspective
second
commission
application
service
distinction
isps
also
supports
conclusion
commission
historically
subjected
providers
common
carrier
regulation
history
suggests
turn
act
unambiguously
classify
nonfacilities
based
isps
offerors
telecommunications
act
unambiguously
classify
providers
offering
telecommunications
also
unambiguously
classify
providers
cable
companies
relevant
definitions
distinguish
two
types
carriers
act
silence
suggests
instead
commission
discretion
fill
statutory
gap
pp
commission
interpretation
also
permissible
chevron
step
two
reasonable
policy
choice
agency
make
respondents
argue
unpersuasively
commission
construction
unreasonable
allows
communications
provider
evade
regulation
simply
bundling
information
service
telecommunications
result
follow
interpretation
adopted
declaratory
ruling
commission
classified
cable
modem
service
solely
information
service
telecommunications
input
used
provide
cable
modem
service
separable
service
capabilities
part
parcel
service
integral
capabilities
therefore
telecommunications
offering
construction
leave
offerings
unregulated
title
ii
plain
example
local
telephone
company
escape
regulation
packaging
telephone
service
voice
mail
packaging
offers
transparent
transmission
path
telephone
service
transmits
information
independent
capabilities
voice
mail
provides
contrast
transmission
used
provide
cable
modem
service
functionally
integrated
component
internet
service
transmits
data
connection
processing
information
necessary
provide
service
commission
construction
therefore
limited
respondents
assume
respondents
argument
cable
modem
service
fact
provide
transparent
transmission
consumer
perspective
also
mistaken
characterization
offering
internet
access
consisting
access
cable
company
service
web
page
ability
provides
create
personal
web
page
conflicts
commission
reasonable
understanding
nature
internet
service
end
user
accesses
third
party
web
site
commission
concluded
equally
using
information
service
provided
cable
company
accesses
company
web
site
service
personal
webpage
commission
recognized
service
internet
access
providers
offer
public
internet
access
transparent
ability
perspective
transmit
information
pp
rejects
respondent
mci
argument
commission
treatment
cable
modem
service
inconsistent
treatment
dsl
service
therefore
arbitrary
capricious
deviation
agency
policy
administrative
procedure
act
see
mci
points
local
telephone
companies
began
offer
internet
access
dsl
technology
commission
required
make
telephone
lines
used
provide
dsl
available
competing
isps
nondiscriminatory
terms
respondents
claim
commission
adequately
explained
decision
regulate
cable
companies
similarly
thinks
commission
provided
reasoned
explanation
decision
traditional
reason
computer
ii
treatment
carriers
telephone
network
primary
exclusive
means
information
service
providers
gain
access
customers
commission
applied
treatment
dsl
service
based
history
rather
analysis
contemporaneous
market
conditions
commission
declaratory
ruling
contrast
concluded
changed
market
conditions
warrant
different
treatment
cable
modem
service
unlike
time
dsl
order
substitute
forms
internet
transmission
exist
today
including
wireline
cable
terrestrial
wireless
satellite
commission
therefore
concluded
broadband
services
exist
minimal
regulatory
environment
promotes
investment
innovation
competitive
market
nothing
arbitrary
capricious
applying
fresh
analysis
cable
industry
pp
reversed
remanded
thomas
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
stevens
kennedy
breyer
joined
stevens
breyer
filed
concurring
opinions
scalia
filed
dissenting
opinion
souter
ginsburg
joined
part
national
cable
telecommunications
association
et
petitioners
brand
internet
services
et
al
federal
communications
commission
petitioners
brand
internet
services
et
al
writs
certiorari
appeals
ninth
circuit
june
justice
thomas
delivered
opinion
title
ii
communications
act
stat
amended
et
subjects
providers
telecommunications
servic
mandatory
regulation
order
review
federal
communications
commission
concluded
cable
companies
sell
broadband
internet
service
provide
telecommunications
servic
communications
act
defines
term
hence
exempt
mandatory
regulation
title
ii
must
decide
whether
conclusion
lawful
construction
communications
act
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
administrative
procedure
act
et
seq
hold
traditional
means
consumers
access
network
interconnected
computers
make
internet
connections
provided
local
telephone
facilities
see
cases
inquiry
concerning
access
internet
cable
facilities
fcc
rcd
hereinafter
declaratory
ruling
using
connections
consumers
access
internet
making
calls
computer
modems
telephone
wires
owned
local
phone
companies
see
verizon
communications
fcc
describing
physical
structure
local
telephone
exchange
internet
service
providers
isps
turn
link
calls
internet
network
providing
physical
connection
also
offering
consumers
ability
translate
raw
internet
data
information
may
view
personal
computers
transmit
computers
connected
internet
see
joint
board
universal
service
fcc
rcd
hereinafter
universal
service
report
huber
kellogg
thorne
federal
telecommunications
law
ed
hereinafter
huber
technological
limitations
local
telephone
wires
however
retard
speed
data
internet
may
transmitted
end
users
connections
connections
therefore
known
narrowband
slower
speed
connections
broadband
internet
service
contrast
transmits
data
much
higher
speeds
two
principal
kinds
broadband
internet
service
cable
modem
service
digital
subscriber
line
dsl
service
cable
modem
service
transmits
data
internet
users
computers
via
network
television
cable
lines
owned
cable
companies
see
dsl
service
provides
access
using
local
telephone
wires
owned
local
telephone
companies
see
worldcom
fcc
cadc
describing
dsl
technology
cable
companies
telephone
companies
either
provide
internet
access
directly
consumers
thus
acting
isps
lease
transmission
facilities
independent
isps
use
facilities
provide
consumers
internet
access
ways
transmitting
internet
data
homes
including
wireless
networks
also
emerging
declaratory
ruling
ii
issue
cases
proper
regulatory
classification
communications
act
broadband
cable
internet
service
act
amended
telecommunications
act
stat
defines
two
categories
regulated
entities
relevant
cases
telecommunications
carriers
providers
act
regulates
telecommunications
carriers
providers
common
carriers
telecommunications
carriers
example
must
charge
reasonable
nondiscriminatory
rates
customers
design
systems
carriers
interconnect
communications
networks
contribute
federal
universal
service
fund
provisions
mandatory
commission
must
forbear
applying
determines
public
interest
requires
providers
contrast
subject
mandatory
regulation
title
ii
though
commission
jurisdiction
impose
additional
regulatory
obligations
title
ancillary
jurisdiction
regulate
interstate
foreign
communications
see
two
statutory
classifications
originated
late
commission
developed
rules
regulate
services
offered
telephone
wires
regime
computer
ii
rules
distinguished
basic
service
like
telephone
service
enhanced
service
service
offered
telephone
lines
amendment
section
commission
rules
regulations
second
computer
inquiry
hereinafter
computer
ii
order
computer
ii
rules
defined
basic
enhanced
services
reference
consumer
perceives
service
offered
particular
commission
defined
basic
service
pure
transmission
capability
communications
path
virtually
transparent
terms
interaction
customer
supplied
information
pure
transparent
transmission
commission
meant
communications
path
enabled
consumer
transmit
message
another
point
computer
processing
storage
information
processing
storage
needed
convert
message
electronic
form
back
ordinary
language
purposes
transmitting
network
via
telephone
facsimile
basic
service
subject
regulation
nhanced
service
however
service
computer
processing
applications
used
act
content
code
protocol
aspects
subscriber
information
voice
data
storage
services
well
protocol
conversion
ability
communicate
networks
employ
different
formats
contrast
basic
service
commission
decided
subject
providers
enhanced
service
even
enhanced
service
offered
via
transmission
wires
title
ii
regulation
commission
explained
unwise
subject
enhanced
service
regulation
given
competitive
market
offered
definitions
terms
telecommunications
service
information
service
established
act
similar
computer
ii
classifications
telecommunications
service
analog
basic
service
offering
telecommunications
fee
directly
public
regardless
facilities
used
telecommunications
transmission
among
points
specified
user
information
user
choosing
without
change
form
content
information
sent
received
telecommunications
carrier
subjected
mandatory
title
ii
regulation
defined
provider
telecommunications
services
information
service
analog
enhanced
service
offering
capability
generating
acquiring
storing
transforming
processing
retrieving
utilizing
making
available
information
via
telecommunications
september
commission
initiated
rulemaking
proceeding
among
things
apply
classifications
cable
companies
offer
broadband
internet
service
directly
consumers
march
rulemaking
culminated
declaratory
ruling
review
cases
declaratory
ruling
commission
concluded
broadband
internet
service
provided
cable
companies
information
service
telecommunications
service
act
therefore
subject
mandatory
title
ii
regulation
support
conclusion
commission
relied
heavily
universal
service
report
see
declaratory
ruling
citing
universal
service
report
report
universal
service
report
classified
isps
transmission
facilities
use
connect
end
user
internet
solely
providers
see
universal
service
report
unlike
isps
cable
companies
cable
lines
use
provide
internet
access
nevertheless
declaratory
ruling
commission
found
basis
statutory
definitions
treating
cable
companies
differently
isps
offer
single
integrated
service
enables
subscriber
utilize
internet
access
service
realize
benefits
comprehensive
service
offering
declaratory
ruling
internet
access
provides
capability
manipulating
storing
information
commission
concluded
information
service
ibid
integrated
nature
internet
access
wire
used
provide
internet
access
led
commission
conclude
cable
companies
providing
internet
access
telecommunications
providers
conclusion
commission
reasoned
followed
logic
universal
service
report
report
concluded
though
internet
service
involves
data
transport
elements
internet
access
provider
must
enable
movement
information
customers
computers
distant
computers
customers
seek
interact
also
offers
end
users
capabilities
inextricably
intertwined
data
transport
universal
service
report
isps
therefore
offering
telecommunications
directly
public
properly
classified
telecommunications
carriers
see
words
commission
reasoned
consumers
use
cable
modems
transmit
information
transparently
using
telephone
instead
obtain
internet
access
commission
applied
reasoning
cable
companies
offering
broadband
internet
access
logic
like
isps
cable
companies
offe
telecommunications
service
end
user
rather
merely
us
telecommunications
provide
end
users
cable
modem
service
declaratory
ruling
though
commission
declined
apply
mandatory
title
ii
regulation
cable
companies
invited
comment
whether
title
jurisdiction
require
cable
companies
offer
isps
access
facilities
terms
numerous
parties
petitioned
judicial
review
challenging
commission
conclusion
cable
modem
service
telecommunications
service
judicial
lottery
appeals
ninth
circuit
selected
venue
challenge
appeals
granted
petitions
part
vacated
declaratory
ruling
part
remanded
commission
proceedings
particular
appeals
vacated
ruling
extent
concluded
cable
modem
service
telecommunications
service
communications
act
held
commission
permissibly
construe
communications
act
exempt
cable
companies
providing
internet
service
title
ii
regulation
see
rather
analyzing
permissibility
construction
deferential
framework
chevron
however
appeals
grounded
holding
stare
decisis
effect
portland
see
portland
held
cable
modem
service
telecommunications
service
though
case
reviewing
administrative
proceeding
commission
party
case
see
nevertheless
portland
holding
appeals
reasoned
overrode
contrary
interpretation
reached
commission
declaratory
ruling
see
granted
certiorari
settle
important
questions
federal
law
cases
present
iii
first
consider
whether
apply
chevron
framework
commission
interpretation
term
telecommunications
service
conclude
also
conclude
appeals
done
instead
following
contrary
construction
adopted
portland
chevron
held
ambiguities
statutes
within
agency
jurisdiction
administer
delegations
authority
agency
fill
statutory
gap
reasonable
fashion
filling
gaps
explained
involves
difficult
policy
choices
agencies
better
equipped
make
courts
statute
ambiguous
implementing
agency
construction
reasonable
chevron
requires
federal
accept
agency
construction
statute
even
agency
reading
differs
believes
best
statutory
interpretation
chevron
framework
governs
review
commission
construction
congress
delegated
commission
authority
execute
enforce
communications
act
prescribe
rules
regulations
may
necessary
public
interest
carry
provisions
act
iowa
utilities
provisions
give
commission
authority
promulgate
binding
legal
rules
commission
issued
order
review
exercise
authority
one
questions
order
within
commission
jurisdiction
see
household
credit
services
pfennig
mead
christensen
harris
county
hence
past
apply
chevron
framework
commission
interpretation
communications
act
see
national
cable
telecommunications
gulf
power
verizon
respondents
dispute
conclusion
ground
commission
interpretation
inconsistent
past
practice
reject
argument
agency
inconsistency
basis
declining
analyze
agency
interpretation
chevron
framework
unexplained
inconsistency
reason
holding
interpretation
arbitrary
capricious
change
agency
practice
administrative
procedure
act
see
motor
vehicle
mfrs
assn
state
farm
mut
automobile
ins
agency
adequately
explains
reasons
reversal
policy
change
invalidating
since
whole
point
chevron
leave
discretion
provided
ambiguities
statute
implementing
agency
smiley
citibank
south
dakota
see
also
rust
sullivan
barnhart
walton
scalia
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
initial
agency
interpretation
instantly
carved
stone
contrary
agency
must
consider
varying
interpretations
wisdom
policy
continuing
basis
chevron
supra
example
response
changed
factual
circumstances
change
administrations
see
state
farm
supra
rehnquist
concurring
part
dissenting
part
doubt
chevron
deferred
agency
interpretation
recent
reversal
agency
policy
see
therefore
difficulty
concluding
chevron
applies
appeals
declined
apply
chevron
thought
commission
interpretation
communications
act
foreclosed
conflicting
construction
act
adopted
portland
supra
see
based
holding
assumption
portland
construction
overrode
commission
regardless
whether
portland
held
statute
unambiguous
reasoning
incorrect
prior
judicial
construction
statute
trumps
agency
construction
otherwise
entitled
chevron
deference
prior
decision
holds
construction
follows
unambiguous
terms
statute
thus
leaves
room
agency
discretion
principle
follows
chevron
chevron
established
presumption
congress
left
ambiguity
statute
meant
implementation
agency
understood
ambiguity
resolved
first
foremost
agency
desired
agency
rather
courts
possess
whatever
degree
discretion
ambiguity
allows
smiley
supra
yet
allowing
judicial
precedent
foreclose
agency
interpreting
ambiguous
statute
appeals
assumed
allow
interpretation
override
agency
chevron
premise
agencies
courts
fill
statutory
gaps
see
better
rule
hold
judicial
interpretations
contained
precedents
demanding
chevron
step
one
standard
applies
reviewing
agency
construction
blank
slate
judicial
precedent
holding
statute
unambiguously
forecloses
agency
interpretation
therefore
contains
gap
agency
fill
displaces
conflicting
agency
construction
contrary
rule
produce
anomalous
results
mean
whether
agency
interpretation
ambiguous
statute
entitled
chevron
deference
turn
order
interpretations
issue
construction
came
first
construction
prevail
whereas
agency
came
first
agency
construction
command
chevron
deference
yet
whether
congress
delegated
agency
authority
interpret
statute
depend
order
judicial
administrative
constructions
occur
appeals
rule
moreover
lead
ossification
large
portions
statutory
law
mead
supra
scalia
dissenting
precluding
agencies
revising
unwise
judicial
constructions
ambiguous
statutes
neither
chevron
doctrine
stare
decisis
requires
haphazard
results
dissent
answers
allowing
agency
override
believes
best
interpretation
statute
makes
judicial
decisions
subject
reversal
executive
officers
post
opinion
scalia
since
chevron
teaches
opinion
best
reading
ambiguous
statute
agency
charged
administering
authoritative
agency
decision
construe
statute
differently
say
holding
legally
wrong
instead
agency
may
consistent
holding
choose
different
construction
since
agency
remains
authoritative
interpreter
within
limits
reason
statutes
respects
prior
ruling
remains
binding
law
example
agency
interpretations
chevron
inapplicable
precedent
reversed
agency
federal
interpretation
state
law
said
reversed
state
adopts
conflicting
yet
authoritative
interpretation
state
law
appeals
derived
contrary
rule
mistaken
reading
decisions
read
neal
establish
prior
judicial
construction
statute
categorically
controls
agency
contrary
construction
see
also
post
scalia
dissenting
neal
established
proposition
neal
declined
defer
construction
adopted
sentencing
commission
conflicted
one
previously
adopted
chapman
neal
supra
chapman
however
held
relevant
statute
unambiguous
see
emphasis
added
see
also
lechmere
nlrb
decisions
allow
prior
interpretation
statute
override
agency
interpretation
relevant
decision
held
statute
unambiguous
background
appeals
erred
refusing
apply
chevron
commission
interpretation
definition
telecommunications
service
prior
decision
portland
held
best
reading
cable
modem
service
telecommunications
service
permissible
reading
statute
see
nothing
portland
held
communications
act
unambiguously
required
treating
cable
internet
providers
telecommunications
carriers
instead
noted
presented
case
involving
potential
deference
administrative
agency
statutory
construction
pursuant
chevron
doctrine
invoked
rule
construction
rule
lenity
requiring
conclude
statute
unambiguous
reach
judgment
judicial
construction
statute
whether
contained
precedent
may
trump
agency
must
hold
statute
unambiguously
requires
construction
portland
dissent
points
logically
necessary
us
reach
question
whether
appeals
misapplied
chevron
us
decide
whether
commission
acted
lawfully
see
post
opinion
scalia
nevertheless
great
mystery
reaching
point
ibid
genuine
confusion
lower
courts
interaction
chevron
doctrine
stare
decisis
principles
petitioners
informed
us
certiorari
stage
litigation
see
pet
cert
federal
communications
commission
et
al
pp
pet
cert
national
cable
telecomm
assn
et
al
pp
point
briefed
see
brief
federal
petitioners
brief
petitioners
reaching
point
undermine
purpose
grant
certiorari
settle
authoritatively
whether
commission
declaratory
ruling
lawful
uphold
declaratory
ruling
without
reaching
chevron
point
appeals
strike
commission
rule
based
portland
decision
portland
least
arguably
compel
appeals
reverse
commission
despite
decision
since
conclusion
reasonable
read
communications
act
classify
cable
modem
service
solely
information
service
leaves
untouched
portland
holding
commission
interpretation
best
reading
statute
decided
similar
questions
strictly
speaking
necessary
disposition
see
agostini
felton
requiring
courts
appeals
adhere
directly
controlling
precedents
even
rest
reasons
rejected
decisions
roper
simmons
slip
scalia
dissenting
criticizing
reaching
question
whether
missouri
erred
failing
follow
directly
controlling
precedent
though
conclusion
necessary
decision
prudent
us
today
iv
next
address
whether
commission
construction
definition
telecommunications
service
permissible
reading
communications
act
chevron
framework
chevron
established
familiar
procedure
evaluating
whether
agency
interpretation
statute
lawful
first
step
ask
whether
statute
plain
terms
directly
addres
precise
question
issue
statute
ambiguous
point
defer
step
two
agency
interpretation
long
construction
reasonable
policy
choice
agency
make
commission
interpretation
permissible
steps
first
set
forth
understanding
interpretation
communications
act
commission
embraced
issue
commission
whether
cable
companies
providing
cable
modem
service
providing
telecommunications
service
addition
information
service
commission
first
concluded
cable
modem
service
information
service
conclusion
unchallenged
act
defines
information
service
offering
capability
generating
acquiring
storing
transforming
processing
retrieving
utilizing
making
available
information
via
telecommunications
cable
modem
service
information
service
commission
reasoned
provides
consumers
comprehensive
capability
manipulating
information
using
internet
via
telecommunications
service
enables
users
example
browse
world
wide
web
transfer
files
file
archives
available
internet
via
file
transfer
protocol
access
usenet
newsgroups
declaratory
ruling
universal
service
report
like
forms
internet
service
cable
modem
service
also
gives
users
access
domain
name
system
dns
dns
among
things
matches
web
page
addresses
end
users
type
browsers
click
internet
protocol
ip
servers
containing
web
pages
users
wish
access
declaratory
ruling
features
commission
concluded
part
information
service
cable
companies
provide
consumers
see
also
universal
service
report
time
commission
concluded
cable
modem
service
telecommunications
service
telecommunications
service
offering
telecommunications
fee
directly
public
telecommunications
turn
defined
transmission
among
points
specified
user
information
user
choosing
without
change
form
content
information
sent
received
commission
conceded
like
providers
cable
companies
use
telecommunications
provide
consumers
internet
service
cable
companies
provide
service
via
wire
transmits
signals
end
user
computer
declaratory
ruling
commission
however
question
whether
cable
broadband
internet
providers
offer
telecommunications
involved
whether
telecommunications
one
necessary
component
cable
modem
service
instead
whether
service
also
includes
telecommunications
offering
tur
ned
nature
functions
end
user
offered
emphasis
added
statutory
definition
telecommunications
service
res
particular
types
facilities
used
see
definition
telecommunications
service
applies
regardless
facilities
used
seen
consumer
point
view
commission
concluded
cable
modem
service
telecommunications
offering
consumer
uses
wire
always
connection
capabilities
provided
internet
access
transmission
necessary
component
internet
access
provided
end
user
telecommunications
part
parcel
cable
modem
service
integral
capabilities
declaratory
ruling
wire
used
words
access
world
wide
web
newsgroups
forth
rather
transparently
transmit
receive
messages
without
computer
processing
storage
message
see
supra
noting
computer
ii
notion
transparent
transmission
integrated
character
offering
led
commission
conclude
cable
modem
service
transparent
offering
telecommunications
declaratory
ruling
construction
passes
chevron
first
step
respondents
argue
ground
cable
companies
providing
internet
service
necessarily
offe
underlying
telecommunications
used
transmit
service
word
offering
used
however
unambiguously
require
result
instead
offering
reasonably
read
mean
offering
telecommunications
offered
service
user
perspective
transmits
messages
unadulterated
computer
processing
conclusion
follows
ordinary
meaning
word
offering
also
regulatory
history
communications
act
cable
companies
broadband
internet
service
business
offe
consumers
information
service
form
internet
access
via
telecommunications
inexorably
follow
matter
ordinary
language
also
offe
consumers
data
transmission
telecommunications
input
used
provide
service
held
statute
plain
terms
admit
two
reasonable
ordinary
usages
commission
choice
one
entitled
deference
see
verizon
agency
construction
entitled
deference
alternative
dictionary
definitions
word
issue
term
offe
used
definition
telecommunications
service
ambiguous
way
common
usage
describe
company
offers
consumer
consumer
perceives
integrated
finished
product
even
exclusion
discrete
components
compose
product
dissent
concedes
see
post
opinion
scalia
one
might
well
say
car
dealership
offers
cars
offer
integrated
major
inputs
make
purchasing
car
valuable
engine
chassis
fact
odd
describe
car
dealership
offering
consumers
car
components
addition
car
even
linguistically
permissible
say
car
dealership
offers
engines
offers
cars
shows
term
offer
applied
commercial
transaction
ambiguous
whether
describes
offered
finished
product
product
discrete
components
well
show
usage
permitted
question
whether
transmission
component
cable
modem
service
sufficiently
integrated
finished
service
make
reasonable
describe
two
single
integrated
offering
see
ibid
think
sufficiently
integrated
consumer
uses
wire
always
connection
capabilities
provided
internet
access
transmission
necessary
component
internet
access
supra
telecommunications
context
least
reasonable
describe
companies
offering
consumers
discrete
input
necessary
providing
always
used
connection
finished
service
think
misuse
language
example
say
cable
companies
providing
internet
service
offer
consumers
dns
even
though
dns
essential
providing
internet
access
declaratory
ruling
likewise
telephone
company
offers
consumers
transparent
transmission
path
conveys
message
necessarily
data
transmission
facilities
also
transmi
information
user
choosing
physical
elements
facilities
used
provide
telephone
service
like
trunks
switches
copper
wires
cable
companies
providing
cable
modem
service
telephone
companies
providing
telephone
service
offer
internet
service
telephone
service
respectively
finished
services
though
using
via
discrete
components
composing
end
product
including
data
transmission
functionally
integrated
components
need
described
distinct
offerings
response
dissent
argues
transmission
component
necessary
providing
cable
modem
service
necessarily
offered
internet
service
cable
modem
service
like
offering
pizza
delivery
service
together
pizza
offering
puppies
together
dog
leashes
post
opinion
scalia
dissent
appeal
analogies
underscores
term
offer
ambiguous
way
described
entire
question
whether
products
functionally
integrated
like
components
car
functionally
separate
like
pets
leashes
question
turns
language
act
factual
particulars
internet
technology
works
provided
questions
chevron
leaves
commission
resolve
first
instance
commission
candidly
recognized
question
may
always
straightforward
whether
one
hand
entity
providing
single
information
service
communications
computing
components
hand
providing
two
distinct
services
one
telecommunications
service
universal
service
report
term
offer
sometimes
refer
single
finished
product
sometimes
individual
components
package
offered
depending
whether
components
still
possess
sufficient
identity
described
separate
objects
post
statute
fails
unambiguously
classify
telecommunications
component
cable
modem
service
distinct
offering
leaves
federal
telecommunications
policy
technical
complex
area
set
commission
warring
analogies
also
share
dissent
certainty
cable
modem
service
obviously
like
pizza
delivery
service
combination
dog
leashes
dogs
commission
reasonably
thought
otherwise
post
example
unlike
transmission
component
internet
service
delivery
service
dog
leashes
integral
components
finished
products
pizzas
pet
dogs
one
pick
pizza
rather
delivered
one
dog
without
buying
leash
contrast
commission
reasonably
concluded
consumer
purchase
internet
service
without
also
purchasing
connection
internet
transmission
always
occurs
connection
information
processing
event
doubt
statute
example
subjected
offerors
delivery
service
federal
express
parcel
service
regulation
unambiguously
require
companies
offer
delivery
services
common
carrier
basis
commission
traditional
distinction
basic
enhanced
service
see
supra
also
supports
conclusion
communications
act
ambiguous
whether
cable
companies
offer
telecommunications
cable
modem
service
congress
passed
definitions
communications
act
background
regulatory
history
may
assume
parallel
terms
telecommunications
service
information
service
substantially
incorporated
meaning
commission
held
see
joint
board
universal
service
fcc
rcd
noting
definition
enhanced
services
substantially
similar
definition
information
services
services
previously
considered
services
commissioner
keystone
consol
industries
noting
presumption
congress
aware
settled
judicial
administrative
interpretation
terms
enacts
statute
regulatory
history
least
two
respects
confirms
term
telecommunications
service
ambiguous
first
computer
ii
order
established
terms
basic
enhanced
services
commission
defined
terms
functionally
based
consumer
interacts
provided
information
commission
order
see
supra
explained
internet
service
terms
interaction
information
computer
ii
order
transmission
occurs
connection
information
processing
therefore
consistent
statute
terms
commission
assume
parallel
term
telecommunications
service
likewise
describes
pure
transparent
communications
path
necessarily
separately
present
end
user
perspective
integrated
offering
commission
application
service
distinction
isps
also
supports
conclusion
commission
long
held
provide
form
transmission
services
necessarily
common
carriers
computer
ii
order
see
also
acknowledg
ing
existence
communications
component
offerings
example
commission
subject
regulation
service
providers
offered
enhanced
services
telecommunications
facilities
underlying
facilities
providers
see
universal
service
report
examples
services
included
database
services
customer
used
telecommunications
access
information
dow
jones
news
lexis
well
value
added
networks
lease
wires
common
carriers
provide
transmission
well
service
wires
see
amendment
sections
commission
rules
regulations
third
computer
inquiry
fcc
rcd
supra
explaining
protocol
conversion
services
combin
ed
communications
computing
components
yet
commission
held
always
deemed
enhanced
therefore
subject
regulation
universal
service
report
following
traditional
distinction
commission
universal
service
report
classified
isps
leased
rather
owned
transmission
facilities
pure
providers
respondents
statutory
arguments
conflict
regulatory
history
claim
communications
act
unambiguously
classifies
telecommunications
carriers
entities
use
telecommunications
inputs
provide
information
service
respondent
mci
concedes
argument
subject
mandatory
regulation
providers
use
telecommunications
input
provide
information
service
public
brief
respondent
mci
example
subject
regulation
isps
transmission
facilities
see
universal
service
report
isps
provide
consumers
transmission
facilities
used
connect
internet
see
supra
respondents
argument
necessarily
offer
telecommunications
consumers
respondents
position
entities
necessarily
offering
telecommunications
therefore
entails
mandatory
regulation
entities
commission
never
classified
offerors
basic
transmission
service
therefore
common
carriers
computer
ii
see
universal
service
report
noting
past
commission
policy
computer
communications
industry
assn
fcc
cadc
noting
upholding
commission
computer
ii
finding
enhanced
services
common
carrier
services
within
scope
title
ii
doubt
parallel
term
telecommunications
service
unambiguously
worked
abrupt
shift
commission
policy
respondents
analogy
cable
companies
provide
cable
modem
service
providers
providers
transmission
facilities
used
provide
services
fares
better
respondents
stress
computer
ii
rules
commission
regulated
providers
heavily
providers
commission
required
example
local
telephone
companies
provided
enhanced
services
offer
wires
basis
competing
providers
see
amendment
sections
commission
rules
regulations
third
computer
inquiry
hereinafter
computer
iii
order
respondents
argue
communications
act
unambiguously
requires
treatment
cable
companies
cable
companies
also
facilities
use
provide
cable
modem
service
therefore
information
service
disagree
think
improbable
communications
act
unambiguously
freezes
time
computer
ii
treatment
providers
act
definition
telecommunications
service
says
nothing
imposing
stringent
regulatory
duties
providers
definition
hinges
solely
whether
entity
offer
telecommunications
fee
directly
public
though
act
elsewhere
subjects
carriers
stricter
regulation
see
imposing
various
duties
local
telephone
companies
computer
ii
rules
commission
subjected
providers
duties
nature
offering
made
carriers
rather
concern
local
telephone
companies
abuse
monopoly
power
possessed
virtue
bottleneck
local
telephone
facilities
owned
see
computer
ii
order
computer
iii
order
verizon
describing
naturally
monopolistic
physical
structure
local
telephone
exchange
differential
treatment
carriers
therefore
function
definitions
basic
service
instead
choice
commission
regulate
stringently
discretion
certain
entities
provided
enhanced
service
act
definitions
however
parallel
definitions
enhanced
basic
service
grounds
policy
choice
based
commission
remains
free
impose
special
regulatory
duties
isps
title
ancillary
jurisdiction
fact
invited
comment
whether
see
supra
sum
act
fails
unambiguously
classify
providers
use
telecommunications
inputs
provide
information
service
offer
ors
telecommunications
also
fails
unambiguously
classify
providers
offerors
relevant
definitions
distinguish
carriers
silence
suggests
instead
commission
discretion
fill
consequent
statutory
gap
also
conclude
commission
construction
reasonable
policy
choice
commission
make
chevron
second
step
respondents
argue
commission
construction
unreasonable
allows
communications
provider
evade
regulation
expedient
bundling
information
service
telecommunications
respondents
argue
commission
construction
telephone
company
example
offer
information
service
like
voice
mail
together
telephone
service
thereby
avoiding
regulation
telephone
service
need
decide
whether
construction
resulted
consequences
unreasonable
believe
results
follow
construction
commission
adopted
understand
declaratory
ruling
commission
say
telecommunications
service
priced
bundled
information
service
automatically
unregulated
title
ii
commission
said
telecommunications
input
used
provide
information
service
separable
capabilities
service
instead
part
parcel
information
service
integral
information
service
capabilities
telecommunications
offering
declaratory
ruling
see
supra
construction
leave
information
service
offerings
exempt
mandatory
title
ii
regulation
plain
example
local
telephone
company
escape
title
ii
regulation
residential
local
exchange
service
simply
packaging
service
voice
mail
universal
service
report
telephone
company
packages
voice
mail
telephone
service
offers
transparent
transmission
path
telephone
service
transmits
information
independent
capabilities
provided
voice
mail
instance
person
makes
telephone
call
ability
convey
receive
information
using
call
trivially
affected
additional
capability
equally
telephone
company
add
announcement
played
every
time
user
picked
telephone
transparent
information
transmitted
ensuing
call
trivially
dependent
information
service
announcement
provides
contrast
transmission
used
provide
cable
modem
service
functionally
integrated
component
service
transmits
data
connection
processing
information
necessary
provide
internet
service
commission
construction
therefore
limited
respondents
assume
respondents
answer
cable
modem
service
fact
provide
transparent
transmission
consumer
perspective
argument
mistaken
respondents
characterize
offering
internet
access
consisting
access
cable
company
service
web
page
ability
provides
consumers
create
personal
web
page
consumer
goes
beyond
offerings
accesses
content
provided
parties
cable
company
respondents
argue
consumer
uses
pure
transmission
less
consumer
purchases
phone
service
together
voice
mail
argument
believe
conflicts
commission
understanding
nature
cable
modem
service
understanding
find
reasonable
end
user
accesses
web
site
commission
concluded
equally
using
information
service
provided
cable
company
offers
internet
access
accesses
company
web
site
service
personal
web
page
example
commission
found
part
information
service
cable
companies
provide
access
dns
service
see
supra
user
reach
web
site
without
dns
among
things
matches
web
site
address
end
user
types
browser
clicks
mouse
ip
address
web
page
host
server
see
albitz
liu
dns
bind
ed
internet
user
dns
must
early
internet
network
services
use
dns
includes
world
wide
web
electronic
mail
remote
terminal
access
file
transfer
least
reasonable
think
dns
capability
acquiring
retrieving
utilizing
making
available
web
site
addresses
therefore
part
information
service
cable
companies
provide
similarly
internet
service
provided
cable
companies
facilitates
access
web
pages
offering
consumers
ability
store
cache
popular
content
local
computer
servers
see
declaratory
ruling
cacheing
obviates
need
end
user
download
anew
information
web
sites
time
consumer
attempts
access
thereby
increasing
speed
information
retrieval
words
subscribers
reach
web
sites
via
world
wide
web
browse
contents
service
provider
offers
acquiring
storing
retrieving
utilizing
information
universal
service
report
quoting
service
internet
access
providers
offer
members
public
internet
access
universal
service
report
transparent
ability
end
user
perspective
transmit
information
therefore
conclude
commission
construction
reasonable
respondent
mci
urges
commission
treatment
cable
modem
service
inconsistent
treatment
dsl
service
see
supra
describing
dsl
service
therefore
arbitrary
capricious
deviation
agency
policy
see
mci
points
local
telephone
companies
began
offer
internet
access
dsl
technology
addition
telephone
service
commission
applied
computer
ii
classification
required
make
telephone
lines
used
transmit
dsl
service
available
competing
isps
nondiscriminatory
terms
see
supra
describing
computer
ii
classification
providers
deployment
wireline
services
offering
advanced
telecommunications
capability
fcc
rcd
hereinafter
wireline
order
classifying
dsl
service
telecommunications
service
mci
claims
commission
decision
regulate
cable
companies
similarly
title
ii
inconsistent
dsl
policy
conclude
however
commission
provided
reasoned
explanation
treating
cable
modem
service
differently
dsl
service
already
noted
see
supra
commission
free
within
limits
reasoned
interpretation
change
course
adequately
justifies
done
traditional
reason
computer
ii
treatment
carriers
including
dsl
carriers
commission
explained
telephone
network
primary
exclusive
means
information
service
providers
gain
access
customers
declaratory
ruling
emphasis
original
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
commission
applied
treatment
dsl
service
based
history
rather
analysis
contemporaneous
market
conditions
see
wireline
order
noting
dsl
carriers
continuing
obligation
offer
transmission
facilities
competing
isps
nondiscriminatory
terms
commission
order
review
contrast
concluded
changed
market
conditions
warrant
different
treatment
cable
companies
providing
internet
access
unlike
time
computer
ii
substitute
forms
internet
transmission
exist
today
esidential
access
internet
evolving
multiple
electronic
platforms
including
wireline
cable
terrestrial
wireless
satellite
declaratory
ruling
see
also
telecom
assn
fcc
cadc
noting
commission
findings
robust
competition
broadband
market
commission
concluded
services
exist
minimal
regulatory
environment
promotes
investment
innovation
competitive
market
declaratory
ruling
commission
reasoned
warranted
treating
cable
companies
unlike
providers
past
find
nothing
arbitrary
commission
providing
fresh
analysis
problem
applied
cable
industry
never
subjected
rules
adequate
rational
justification
commission
conclusions
respondents
argue
effect
commission
justification
exempting
cable
modem
service
providers
regulation
applies
similar
force
dsl
providers
need
address
argument
commission
decision
appears
first
step
effort
reshape
way
commission
regulates
providers
may
tentatively
concluded
dsl
service
provided
telephone
companies
also
classified
solely
information
service
see
appropriate
framework
broadband
access
internet
wireline
facilities
fcc
rcd
commission
need
immediately
apply
policy
reasoning
declaratory
ruling
types
providers
apparently
decided
revisit
longstanding
computer
ii
classification
providers
incrementally
inconsistency
order
review
commission
treatment
dsl
service
adequately
addressed
commission
fully
reconsiders
treatment
dsl
service
decides
whether
pursuant
ancillary
title
jurisdiction
require
cable
companies
allow
independent
isps
access
facilities
see
supra
page
express
view
matters
particular
express
view
commission
lawfully
may
classify
dsl
service
questions
commission
resolved
order
review
involve
subject
matter
technical
complex
dynamic
gulf
power
commission
far
better
position
address
questions
nothing
communications
act
administrative
procedure
act
makes
unlawful
commission
use
expert
policy
judgment
resolve
difficult
questions
judgment
appeals
reversed
cases
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
national
cable
telecommunications
association
et
petitioners
brand
internet
services
et
al
federal
communications
commission
petitioners
brand
internet
services
et
al
writs
certiorari
appeals
ninth
circuit
june
justice
stevens
concurring
join
opinion
full
add
caveat
concerning
part
correctly
explains
appeals
interpretation
ambiguous
provision
regulatory
statute
foreclose
contrary
reading
agency
explanation
necessarily
applicable
decision
presumably
remove
ambiguity
national
cable
telecommunications
association
et
petitioners
brand
internet
services
et
al
federal
communications
commission
petitioners
brand
internet
services
et
al
writs
certiorari
appeals
ninth
circuit
june
justice
breyer
concurring
join
opinion
believe
federal
communications
commission
decision
falls
within
scope
statutorily
delegated
authority
though
perhaps
barely
write
separately
believe
important
point
justice
scalia
view
wrongly
characterized
opinion
mead
held
mead
unspecified
degree
formal
process
agency
required
courts
accord
agency
decision
deference
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
post
dissenting
opinion
see
also
ibid
formal
process
least
safe
harbor
justice
scalia
correctly
characterized
way
dissent
characterized
mead
opinion
said
opposite
agency
action
qualifies
chevron
deference
congress
explicitly
implicitly
delegated
agency
authority
fill
statutory
gap
including
interpretive
gap
created
ambiguity
language
statute
provisions
chevron
supra
mead
supra
said
mead
delegation
may
shown
variety
ways
agency
power
engage
adjudication
rulemaking
indication
comparable
congressional
intent
emphasis
added
explicitly
stated
absence
rulemaking
decide
case
sometimes
found
reasons
chevron
deference
even
administrative
formality
required
none
afforded
repeated
recognized
variety
indicators
congress
expect
chevron
deference
emphasis
added
surprising
hold
existence
formal
rulemaking
proceeding
neither
necessary
sufficient
condition
according
chevron
deference
agency
interpretation
statute
necessary
condition
agency
might
arrive
authoritative
interpretation
congressional
enactment
ways
including
ways
justice
scalia
mentions
see
mead
supra
sufficient
condition
congress
may
intended
leave
matter
particular
interpretation
agency
irrespective
procedure
agency
uses
arrive
interpretation
say
unusually
basic
legal
question
issue
cf
general
dynamics
land
systems
cline
rejecting
agency
answer
question
whether
age
discrimination
law
forbids
discrimination
relatively
young
thus
believe
justice
scalia
right
emphasizing
chevron
deference
may
appropriate
absence
formal
agency
proceedings
mead
give
cause
concern
national
cable
telecommunications
association
et
petitioners
brand
internet
services
et
al
federal
communications
commission
petitioners
brand
internet
services
et
al
writs
certiorari
appeals
ninth
circuit
june
justice
scalia
justice
souter
justice
ginsburg
join
part
dissenting
federal
communications
commission
fcc
commission
attempted
concoct
whole
new
regime
regulation
competition
guise
statutory
construction
mci
telecommunications
american
telephone
telegraph
actually
cases
might
accurate
say
commission
attempted
establish
whole
new
regime
make
less
competition
depending
upon
whose
experts
believed
important
fact
however
commission
chosen
achieve
implausible
reading
statute
thus
exceeded
authority
given
congress
first
sentence
fcc
ruling
review
reads
follows
cable
modem
service
provides
access
internet
well
many
applications
functions
used
access
cable
system
facilities
inquiry
concerning
access
internet
cable
facilities
fcc
rcd
hereinafter
declaratory
ruling
emphasis
added
omitted
mean
cable
companies
offer
access
internet
surprisingly
commission
believed
happens
service
popular
precisely
access
provides
connected
internet
subscribers
often
use
internet
applications
functions
providers
cable
company
nevertheless
purposes
classifying
cable
company
commission
approval
puts
emphasis
rest
package
additional
applications
functions
claiming
cable
company
offe
customers
internet
access
offers
access
conjunction
particular
applications
functions
rather
separate
ly
offering
focus
term
offer
appropriately
derives
statutory
definitions
issue
cases
telecommunications
act
stat
involves
capacity
generate
store
interact
otherwise
manipulate
information
via
telecommunications
turn
defined
transmission
among
points
specified
user
information
user
choosing
without
change
form
content
information
sent
received
finally
defined
offering
telecommunications
fee
directly
public
regardless
facilities
used
question
whether
providers
offe
telecommunications
fee
directly
public
subject
title
ii
regulation
common
carriers
like
chief
competitors
provide
internet
access
technologies
concludes
word
offer
ambiguous
sense
dictionary
might
relevant
ante
quoting
national
railroad
passenger
corporation
boston
maine
seems
however
analytic
problem
pertains
really
meaning
offer
identity
offered
relevant
question
whether
individual
components
package
offered
still
possess
sufficient
identity
described
separate
objects
offer
whether
changed
combination
components
longer
reasonable
describe
way
thus
agree
adapt
example
ante
odd
say
car
dealer
business
selling
steel
carpets
cars
sells
include
steel
frames
carpeting
water
company
sell
hydrogen
pet
store
water
though
dogs
cats
largely
water
molecular
level
sometimes
true
seems
assume
always
true
instances
ridiculous
deny
one
part
joint
offering
offered
merely
offered
basis
ante
example
call
pizzeria
ask
whether
offer
delivery
common
sense
common
usage
ante
prevent
answering
offer
delivery
order
pizza
us
bake
bring
house
logical
response
something
order
offer
delivery
may
continue
deny
obvious
explain
paraphrasing
fcc
even
though
bring
pizza
house
actually
delivery
delivery
provide
end
users
parcel
service
capabilities
cf
declaratory
ruling
ante
reasonable
customer
conclude
point
interlocutor
either
crazy
following
legal
advice
short
inputs
finished
service
qualify
objects
offer
term
reasonably
understood
perhaps
sufficient
surely
necessary
condition
seller
offer
separately
discrete
input
necessary
providing
finished
service
ante
pet
store
may
policy
selling
puppies
leashes
customer
say
offer
puppies
leashed
puppy
still
puppy
even
though
offered
basis
despite
mighty
labors
prove
otherwise
ante
telecommunications
component
service
retains
ample
independent
identity
must
regarded
offer
especially
seen
perspective
consumer
end
user
purports
find
determinative
ante
commission
ruling
began
noting
service
provides
access
internet
applications
functions
declaratory
ruling
exactly
reasonable
consumer
perceive
consisting
two
separate
things
consumer
view
matter
best
assessed
asking
products
service
substitutes
marketplace
broadband
internet
service
provided
cable
companies
one
three
common
forms
internet
service
two
access
broadband
digital
subscriber
line
dsl
service
ante
two
physical
transmission
pathway
internet
sold
indeed
legally
required
sold
separately
internet
functionality
access
physical
pathway
comes
telephone
company
internet
service
provider
isp
provides
functionality
case
internet
access
end
user
utilizes
two
different
distinct
services
one
transmission
pathway
telecommunications
service
end
user
purchases
telephone
company
second
internet
access
service
enhanced
service
provided
isp
th
functions
provided
isp
separate
transmission
pathway
data
travels
pathway
regulated
telecommunications
service
enhanced
service
offered
oxman
fcc
unregulation
internet
fcc
office
plans
policy
working
paper
july
available
http
visited
june
available
clerk
case
file
acknowledges
ante
dsl
service
similar
service
respect
physical
connection
internet
must
offered
separately
internet
thus
customers
shopping
dsl
service
able
use
internet
unless
get
someone
provide
physical
connection
someone
provide
applications
functions
web
access
therefore
inevitable
customers
regard
competing
service
giving
computing
functionality
physical
pipe
functionality
comes
computer
pizza
delivery
service
nondelivery
pizzerias
require
purchased
cab
since
delivery
service
provided
cable
connection
customer
computer
cable
company
facilities
downstream
facilities
question
merely
serves
conduit
information
services
already
assembled
cable
company
capacity
isp
relevant
statutory
distinction
information
service
telecommunications
former
involves
capability
getting
processing
manipulating
information
latter
contrast
involves
change
form
content
information
sent
received
information
enters
cable
delivery
subscriber
information
service
already
complete
information
statute
requires
generated
acquired
stored
transformed
processed
retrieved
utilized
made
available
remains
information
final
unaltered
form
delivered
via
telecommunications
subscriber
reveals
insubstantiality
fear
invoked
commission
fear
happen
isps
provide
physical
pathway
internet
access
yet
still
use
telecommunications
acquire
pieces
necessary
assemble
information
pass
back
customers
according
reductio
ante
providers
deemed
provide
telecommunications
service
must
isps
use
telecommunications
providing
internet
functionality
connecting
parts
internet
including
internet
backbone
providers
example
terms
pizzeria
analogy
equivalent
saying
pizzeria
offers
delivery
restaurants
offer
delivery
ingredients
food
serve
customers
come
places
matter
customers
get
food
whether
eating
restaurant
coming
pick
still
consume
product
delivery
necessary
input
nonsense
concluding
delivery
finished
pizza
constitutes
offer
delivery
require
conclusion
serving
prepared
food
includes
offer
delivery
analogy
even
point
justice
since
defined
offering
telecommunications
fee
directly
public
emphasis
added
isps
use
telecommunications
processing
information
offered
directly
public
regulatory
history
depends
much
ante
provides
another
reason
regulation
isps
worry
computer
inquiry
rules
foreshadowed
definitions
information
telecommunications
services
ante
commission
forbore
regulating
common
carriers
networks
providers
leased
basic
services
common
carriers
bundled
enhanced
services
said
unlike
providers
deemed
provide
enhanced
services
ante
result
achieved
today
commission
statutory
authority
forbear
imposing
title
ii
regulations
fact
statutory
criteria
forbearance
include
reasonable
necessary
protection
consumers
consistent
public
interest
correspond
well
kinds
policy
reasons
commission
invoked
justify
peculiar
construction
telecommunications
service
exclude
service
also
puts
great
stock
conclusion
subscribers
avoid
using
information
services
provided
cable
company
isp
capacity
even
isps
ante
even
subscriber
uses
another
isp
designates
page
provided
cable
company
home
page
takes
advantage
none
standard
applications
functions
provided
cable
company
still
using
cable
company
domain
name
system
dns
server
goes
popular
web
pages
perhaps
versions
stored
cable
company
cache
argument
suffers
least
two
problems
first
context
telephone
services
recognizes
de
minimis
exception
contamination
telecommunications
service
information
service
ante
similar
exception
seem
apply
functions
question
dns
particular
scarcely
routing
information
expressly
excluded
definition
information
service
second
apparently
possible
sell
telecommunications
service
separately
although
conjunction
services
precisely
happens
dsl
context
commission
contest
done
context
cable
impediment
appears
commission
failure
require
cable
companies
unbundling
required
providers
computer
inquiry
finally
must
note
notwithstanding
commission
paean
deregulatory
largesse
brief
federal
petitioners
concluded
declaratory
ruling
asking
paraphrases
whether
title
jurisdiction
commission
require
cable
companies
offer
isps
access
facilities
terms
ante
see
also
reply
brief
federal
petitioners
tr
oral
arg
words
commission
hath
given
commission
may
well
take
away
unless
wonderful
illustration
experienced
agency
assistance
credulous
courts
turn
statutory
constraints
bureaucratic
discretions
main
source
commission
regulatory
authority
common
carriers
title
ii
commission
rendered
inapplicable
instance
concluding
definition
telecommunications
service
ambiguous
current
view
apply
service
contemplates
however
altering
unnecessary
outcome
changing
law
construction
title
ii
definitions
reserving
right
change
facts
undefined
sparingly
used
ancillary
powers
commission
might
conclude
order
cable
companies
unbundle
telecommunications
component
presto
title
ii
apply
finally
offering
telecommunications
service
course
commission
still
statutory
power
forbear
regulating
already
tentatively
concluded
declaratory
ruling
reasoning
mocks
principle
statute
constrains
agency
meaningful
way
said
done
regulatory
cant
translated
smoke
agency
expertise
blown
away
remains
perfectly
clear
someone
sells
service
offering
telecommunications
simple
reason
set
forth
statute
affirm
appeals
ii
part
opinion
continues
improvisation
project
began
four
years
ago
mead
extent
set
forth
comprehensible
mead
drastically
limited
categories
agency
action
qualify
deference
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
example
position
taken
agency
full
approval
agency
head
qualify
rather
unspecified
degree
formal
process
required
least
safe
harbor
see
mead
supra
scalia
dissenting
meant
many
issues
appropriate
agency
determination
reach
courts
without
benefit
agency
position
entitled
chevron
deference
requiring
courts
rule
issues
de
pointed
dissent
turn
meant
law
understood
today
many
statutory
ambiguities
might
resolved
varying
fashions
successive
agency
administrations
resolved
finally
conclusively
forever
federal
judges
producing
ossification
large
portions
statutory
law
today
moves
solve
problem
creation
inventing
yet
another
breathtaking
novelty
judicial
decisions
subject
reversal
executive
officers
imagine
following
sequence
events
fcc
action
challenged
ultra
vires
governing
statute
litigation
reaches
way
solicitor
general
sets
forth
fcc
official
position
approved
commission
regarding
interpretation
statute
applying
mead
however
denies
agency
position
chevron
deference
finds
best
interpretation
statute
contradicts
agency
position
holds
challenged
agency
action
unlawful
agency
promptly
conducts
rulemaking
adopts
rule
comports
earlier
position
effect
disagreeing
concerning
best
interpretation
statute
according
today
opinion
agency
thereupon
free
take
action
found
unlawful
bizarre
probably
unconstitutional
held
chicago
southern
air
lines
waterman
article
iii
courts
sit
render
decisions
reversed
ignored
executive
officers
case
appeals
determined
jurisdiction
review
order
civil
aeronautics
board
awarding
overseas
air
route
statute
orders
subject
presidential
approval
order
question
fact
approved
president
order
avoid
conflict
president
powers
appeals
concluded
review
board
action
regulatory
agent
congress
results
review
remain
subject
approval
disapproval
president
noted
mead
dissent
bristled
suggestion
judgments
within
powers
vested
courts
judiciary
article
constitution
may
lawfully
revised
overturned
refused
faith
credit
another
department
government
waterman
supra
today
decision
effectively
allows
even
agency
party
case
construes
statute
agency
able
disregard
construction
seek
chevron
deference
contrary
construction
next
time
course
like
mead
today
novelty
belated
remediation
mead
creates
many
uncertainties
bedevil
lower
courts
interpretation
conclusive
says
holds
interpretation
permissible
reading
statute
merely
holds
best
reading
ante
mean
future
cases
involving
statutes
courts
must
specify
presumably
dictum
two
holding
many
cases
decided
past
dictum
requirement
established
apparently
silence
point
means
decision
subject
agency
reversal
judicial
construction
statute
whether
contained
precedent
may
trump
agency
must
hold
statute
unambiguously
requires
construction
ibid
made
far
know
made
calculation
many
hundreds
past
statutory
decisions
failure
include
unambiguous
finding
suspect
number
large
much
extra
work
entail
confronted
statute
determine
whether
reached
right
best
result
permissible
result
standard
unambiguous
new
rule
standard
unambiguous
step
one
chevron
course
every
case
reaches
step
two
chevron
unambiguous
dictum
produce
stare
decisis
effect
even
affirming
rather
reversing
agency
action
future
agency
must
adhere
affirmed
interpretation
victorious
agency
right
appeal
appeals
judgment
favor
ground
text
question
fact
appeals
held
unambiguous
agency
able
change
view
future
indeed
wonderful
new
world
creates
one
full
promise
professors
need
tenure
articles
course
adhere
rule
past
interprets
statute
without
chevron
deference
agency
views
interpretation
whether
asserted
rest
upon
unambiguous
text
law
might
add
great
mystery
relevant
whatever
stare
decisis
effect
portland
ninth
circuit
surely
govern
decision
despite
peculiar
suggestion
contrary
ante
ninth
circuit
already
obliged
abandon
portland
holding
face
decision
commission
construction
telecommunications
service
entitled
deference
reasonable
sadness
go
far
way
make
bad
law
respectfully
dissent
footnotes
together
federal
communications
commission
et
al
brand
internet
services
et
also
certiorari
footnotes
ip
addresses
identify
computers
internet
enabling
data
packets
transmitted
computers
reach
see
universal
service
report
huber
dissent
attempts
escape
consequence
respondents
position
way
elaborate
analogy
isps
pizzerias
post
opinion
scalia
analogy
flawed
pizzeria
delivers
nothing
isps
plainly
provide
transmission
service
directly
public
connection
internet
service
example
service
isps
process
electronic
signal
travels
local
telephone
wires
transmit
internet
see
supra
huber
dissent
therefore
deny
position
logically
require
applying
presumptively
mandatory
title
ii
regulation
isps
dissent
claims
access
dns
count
use
capabilities
internet
service
dns
scarcely
routing
information
expressly
excluded
definition
service
post
opinion
scalia
definition
information
service
exclude
routing
information
instead
excludes
use
capability
management
control
operation
telecommunications
system
management
telecommunications
service
dissent
argument
therefore
begs
question
assumes
internet
service
telecommunications
system
service
dns
manages
point
contrary
dissent
assertion
post
need
take
view
purposes
response
respondents
vigorously
argue
commission
purported
inconsistent
treatment
reason
holding
commission
construction
impermissible
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
inconsistency
bears
whether
commission
given
reasoned
explanation
current
position
whether
interpretation
consistent
statute
footnotes
myth
pizzeria
offer
delivery
becomes
even
difficult
maintain
pizzeria
advertises
quick
delivery
one
advantages
competitors
course
case
cable
broadband
see
also
joint
board
universal
service
fcc
rcd
end
users
obtain
telecommunications
service
local
exchange
carriers
use
information
services
provided
internet
service
provider
web
site
operators
order
access
web
dsl
context
physical
connection
generally
resold
consumer
isp
taken
advantage
telephone
company
offer
consumer
knows
well
however
physical
connection
necessary
component
internet
access
context
provided
isp
contends
analogy
inapposite
one
need
pizza
delivered
ante
whereas
one
must
purchase
cable
connection
order
use
cable
isp
functions
isp
functions
provided
cable
company
used
without
cable
delivery
accessing
internet
connection
cable
merger
physical
connection
internet
functions
cable
offerings
nothing
intertwined
ante
nature
two
like
car
carpet
artificial
product
cable
company
marketing
decision
offer
two
separately
commission
declaratory
ruling
review
exempt
status
commission
says
forbearance
explain
networks
regulated
providers
given
power
forbear
reply
brief
federal
petitioners
true
commission
ruled
networks
statute
explicitly
provide
forbearance
provided
categories
basic
enhanced
services
computer
inquiry
rules
established
forbearance
applied
circuit
however
long
since
recognized
commission
discretionary
power
forbear
title
ii
regulation
computer
communications
industry
assn
fcc
commission
also
says
computer
inquiry
rules
apply
cable
developed
context
telephone
lines
brief
federal
petitioners
see
also
ante
extent
statute
imported
computer
inquiry
approach
basis
applying
differently
cable
telephone
lines
since
definition
telecommunications
service
applies
regardless
facilities
used
says
invoking
explicit
exception
definition
information
services
applies
management
control
operation
telecommunications
system
management
telecommunications
service
begs
question
whether
service
includes
telecommunications
service
ante
think
cite
exception
demonstrate
incidental
functions
prevent
cable
including
telecommunications
service
otherwise
qualifies
rather
begs
question
saying
exception
apply
cable
telecommunications
service
commission
assumption
providers
providing
telecommunications
services
reason
doubt
whether
use
title
powers
impose
requirements
since
specifically
provides
telecommunications
carrier
shall
treated
common
carrier
chapter
extent
engaged
providing
telecommunications
services
emphasis
added
chapter
includes
titles
ii
description
confusion
mead
produced
circuit
alone
see
vermeule
mead
trenches
geo
rev
concluding
inadvertently
sent
lower
courts
stumbling
land
justice
breyer
attempts
clarify
mead
repeating
formulations
sometimes
found
reasons
give
chevron
deference
variety
ways
variety
indicators
ante
concurring
opinion
internal
quotation
marks
emphasis
omitted
also
notes
deference
sometimes
inappropriate
reasons
unrelated
agency
process
surprising
thought
decision
defer
agency
general
dynamics
land
systems
cline
depended
conclusion
serious
question
purely
textual
ambiguity
statute
justice
breyer
seemingly
attributes
decision
exception
chevron
deference
one
unusually
basic
legal
question
ante
today
thankfully
follow
approach
bases
decision
sees
statutory
ambiguity
ante
without
asking
whether
classification
service
unusually
basic
legal
question
true
even
broad
basis
deference
propose
agency
position
plainly
approval
agency
head
see
mead
scalia
dissenting
interpretive
matters
decided
de
novo
without
deference
agency
views
rare
occurrence
however
level
least
respect
matters
significance
agency
seeking
achieve
agency
control
ambiguous
provisions
complicated
method
proposes
worth
incremental
benefit
unanimous
holding
neal
plainly
rejected
notion
form
deference
cause
revisit
prior
holding
determined
statute
meaning
adhere
ruling
doctrine
stare
decisis
assess
agency
later
interpretation
statute
settled
law
attempts
reinterpret
plain
language
dissecting
cases
neal
cited
noting
referred
previous
determinations
statute
clear
meaning
lechmere
nlrb
quoting
maislin
industries
primary
steel
cases
reveal
today
focus
term
clear
revisionist
oldest
case
chain
using
word
maislin
industries
rely
prior
decision
held
statute
clear
statutory
interpretation
contained
decision
maislin
industries
referred
prior
determination
statute
clear
meaning
referring
fact
prior
decision
made
statute
clear
conducting
retrospective
inquiry
whether
prior
decision
declared
statute
clear
terms
contends
reversal
judicial
holdings
involved
opinion
best
reading
ambiguous
statute
authoritative
ante
fails
appreciate
difference
de
novo
construction
statute
decision
whether
defer
agency
position
even
purport
give
statute
judicial
interpretation
mead
supra
scalia
dissenting
decided
upon
de
novo
construction
statute
longer
different
construction
consistent
holding
ante
available
adoption
agency
suggestive
chaotic
undermining
prior
judicial
decisions
explicitly
renounce
ambiguity
explanation
agency
departure
prior
judicial
decision
amount
overruling
agency
may
consistent
holding
choose
different
construction
since
agency
remains
authoritative
interpreter
within
limits
reason
ambiguous
statutes
charged
administering
ante
may
already
way
hinted
agency
construction
unworthy
chevron
deference
may
able
trump
one
holdings
edelman
lynchburg
college
found
need
resolve
question
deference
equal
employment
opportunity
commission
rule
position
adopt
even
interpreting
statute
scratch
nevertheless
refused
say
whether
agency
position
one
permissible
quotation
marks
omitted
justice
appropriately
doubt
ed
possible
reserve
question
whether
regulation
entitled
chevron
deference
simultaneously
maintaining
agency
free
change
interpretation
future
opinion
concurring
judgment
response
cryptically
said
deference
deference
chevron