vaca
sipes
argued
november
decided
february
petitioners
union
officials
sued
state
union
member
alleged
wrongful
discharge
employer
violation
collective
bargaining
agreement
union
arbitrary
refusal
take
grievance
arbitration
fifth
final
step
bargaining
agreement
grievance
procedures
employee
whose
duties
required
strenuous
activity
discharged
ground
poor
health
fourth
grievance
step
union
sent
employee
physician
complete
examination
report
unfavorable
employee
union
decided
take
grievance
arbitration
jury
verdict
employee
trial
judge
set
aside
verdict
ground
nlrb
exclusive
jurisdiction
controversy
kansas
city
appeals
affirmed
missouri
reversed
ordered
jury
verdict
reinstated
held
since
union
duty
exclusive
agent
fairly
represent
members
designated
unit
based
federal
statutes
federal
law
governs
employee
cause
action
breach
duty
pp
although
nlrb
recently
held
union
breach
statutory
duty
fair
representation
unfair
labor
practice
national
labor
relations
act
follow
broad
doctrine
defined
san
diego
building
trades
council
garmon
holding
nlrb
exclusive
jurisdiction
activity
arguably
subject
act
applicable
thereto
pp
doctrine
rigidly
applied
fairly
inferred
congress
intended
exclusive
jurisdiction
lie
nlrb
pp
rule
applied
activity
regulated
merely
peripheral
concern
labor
management
relations
act
doctrine
fair
representation
protects
individuals
arbitrary
union
conduct
might
jeopardized
nlrb
failure
act
certain
cases
doctrine
applied
oust
courts
traditional
jurisdiction
curb
arbitrary
union
conduct
pp
practical
matter
employee
suit
employer
breach
contract
labor
management
relations
act
employee
may
well
find
necessary
prove
breach
duty
union
facet
case
destroy
jurisdiction
even
employee
joins
union
defendant
result
different
employee
sues
employer
union
separate
actions
pp
breach
duty
union
breach
contract
employer
proven
action
must
fashion
appropriate
remedy
defendants
pp
union
breaches
duty
fair
representation
conduct
toward
member
designated
unit
arbitrary
discriminatory
bad
faith
breach
duty
merely
settles
grievance
short
arbitration
missouri
erred
upholding
jury
verdict
solely
ground
evidence
supported
employee
claim
wrongful
discharge
pp
matter
federal
law
evidence
support
verdict
union
breached
duty
employee
absolute
right
grievance
arbitrated
failed
prove
arbitrary
conduct
union
processing
grievance
pp
claimed
damages
primarily
suffered
result
employer
alleged
breach
contract
charged
union
liability
found
apportioned
employer
union
according
damages
caused
fault
pp
david
feller
argued
cause
petitioners
brief
henry
panethiere
russell
jacobson
jerry
anker
george
west
allan
browne
argued
cause
filed
brief
respondent
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
solicitor
general
marshall
robert
rifkind
arnold
ordman
dominick
manoli
norton
come
albert
woll
robert
mayer
laurence
gold
thomas
harris
american
federation
labor
congress
industrial
organizations
robert
hecker
earl
spiker
swift
justice
white
delivered
opinion
february
benjamin
owens
filed
class
action
petitioners
officers
representatives
national
brotherhood
packinghouse
workers
kansas
city
local
union
circuit
jackson
county
missouri
owens
union
member
alleged
discharged
employment
swift
company
swift
kansas
city
meat
packing
plant
violation
collective
bargaining
agreement
force
swift
union
union
arbitrarily
capriciously
without
reasonable
reason
cause
refused
take
grievance
swift
arbitration
fifth
step
bargaining
agreement
grievance
procedures
petitioners
answer
included
defense
missouri
courts
lacked
jurisdiction
gravamen
owens
suit
arguably
basically
unfair
labor
practice
national
labor
relations
act
amended
stat
within
exclusive
jurisdiction
national
labor
relations
board
nlrb
jury
trial
verdict
returned
awarding
owens
compensatory
punitive
damages
trial
judge
set
aside
verdict
entered
judgment
petitioners
ground
nlrb
exclusive
jurisdiction
controversy
kansas
city
appeals
affirmed
missouri
reversed
directed
reinstatement
jury
verdict
relying
decisions
international
assn
machinists
gonzales
automobile
workers
russell
appeal
owens
died
respondent
administrator
owens
estate
substituted
granted
certiorari
consider
whether
exclusive
jurisdiction
lies
nlrb
whether
finding
union
liability
relief
afforded
owens
consistent
governing
principles
federal
labor
law
american
federation
labor
congress
industrial
organizations
swift
filed
amicus
briefs
supporting
petitioners
although
conclude
state
courts
jurisdiction
type
case
hold
federal
law
governs
governing
federal
standards
applied
judgment
missouri
must
accordingly
reversed
armed
medical
evidence
fitness
owens
sought
union
help
securing
reinstatement
grievance
filed
swift
behalf
grievance
processed
third
fourth
step
grievance
procedure
established
collective
bargaining
agreement
swift
adhered
position
owens
poor
health
justified
discharge
rejecting
numerous
medical
reports
reduced
blood
pressure
proffered
owens
union
swift
claimed
reports
based
upon
sufficiently
thorough
medical
tests
february
union
sent
owens
new
doctor
union
expense
see
get
better
medical
evidence
go
arbitration
case
examination
support
owens
position
union
received
report
executive
board
voted
take
owens
grievance
arbitration
insufficient
medical
evidence
union
officers
suggested
owens
accept
swift
offer
referral
rehabilitation
center
grievance
suspended
purpose
owens
rejected
alternative
demanded
union
take
grievance
arbitration
union
refused
contractual
remedies
thus
stalled
fourth
step
owens
brought
suit
grievance
finally
dismissed
union
swift
shortly
trial
began
june
charge
jury
trial
judge
instructed
petitioners
liable
swift
wrongfully
discharged
owens
union
arbitrarily
without
cause
excuse
refused
press
owens
grievance
arbitration
punitive
damages
also
awarded
trial
judge
charged
union
conduct
willful
wanton
malicious
however
jury
must
return
verdict
defendants
judge
instructed
find
believe
evidence
union
representatives
acted
reasonably
good
faith
handling
processing
grievance
plaintiff
jury
returned
general
verdict
owens
eventually
reinstated
missouri
ii
well
established
exclusive
bargaining
representative
employees
owens
bargaining
unit
union
statutory
duty
fairly
represent
employees
collective
bargaining
swift
see
ford
motor
huffman
syres
oil
workers
international
union
enforcement
resulting
collective
bargaining
agreement
see
humphrey
moore
statutory
duty
fair
representation
developed
years
ago
series
cases
involving
alleged
racial
discrimination
unions
certified
exclusive
bargaining
representatives
railway
labor
act
see
steele
louisville
tunstall
brotherhood
locomotive
firemen
soon
extended
unions
certified
see
ford
motor
huffman
supra
doctrine
exclusive
agent
statutory
authority
represent
members
designated
unit
includes
statutory
obligation
serve
interests
members
without
hostility
discrimination
toward
exercise
discretion
complete
good
faith
honesty
avoid
arbitrary
conduct
humphrey
moore
obvious
owens
complaint
alleged
breach
union
duty
grounded
federal
statutes
federal
law
therefore
governs
cause
action
ford
motor
huffman
supra
although
enacted
nlrb
miranda
fuel
interpret
breach
union
duty
fair
representation
unfair
labor
practice
miranda
fuel
board
majority
held
gives
employees
right
free
unfair
irrelevant
invidious
treatment
exclusive
bargaining
agent
matters
affecting
employment
section
act
accordingly
prohibits
labor
organizations
acting
statutory
representative
capacity
taking
action
employee
upon
considerations
classifications
irrelevant
invidious
unfair
board
also
held
employer
participates
arbitrary
union
conduct
violates
employer
union
may
violate
respectively
arbitrary
irrelevant
reasons
upon
basis
unfair
classification
union
attempts
cause
cause
employer
derogate
employment
status
employee
board
miranda
fuel
decision
denied
enforcement
divided
second
circuit
however
local
rubber
workers
fifth
circuit
upheld
board
miranda
fuel
doctrine
opinion
suggesting
board
approach
judicial
cognizance
fair
representation
duty
suits
light
developments
petitioners
argue
owens
state
action
based
upon
union
conduct
arguably
proscribed
potentially
enforceable
nlrb
therefore
garmon
line
decisions
garmon
recognized
broad
powers
conferred
congress
upon
national
labor
relations
board
interpret
enforce
complex
labor
management
relations
act
necessarily
imply
potentially
conflicting
rules
law
remedy
administration
permitted
operate
enacting
national
labor
relations
act
later
labor
management
relations
act
congress
merely
lay
substantive
rule
law
enforced
tribunal
competent
apply
law
generally
parties
went
confide
primary
interpretation
application
rules
specific
specially
constituted
tribunal
congress
evidently
considered
centralized
administration
specially
designed
procedures
necessary
obtain
uniform
application
substantive
rules
avoid
diversities
conflicts
likely
result
variety
local
procedures
attitudes
toward
labor
controversies
multiplicity
tribunals
diversity
procedures
quite
apt
produce
incompatible
conflicting
adjudications
different
rules
substantive
law
garner
teamsters
union
doctrine
however
never
rigidly
applied
cases
fairly
inferred
congress
intended
exclusive
jurisdiction
lie
nlrb
congress
carved
exceptions
board
exclusive
jurisdiction
section
labor
management
relations
act
stat
expressly
permits
anyone
injured
violation
recover
damages
federal
even
though
unfair
labor
practices
also
remediable
board
act
stat
permits
suits
breach
collective
bargaining
agreement
regardless
whether
particular
breach
also
unfair
labor
practice
within
jurisdiction
board
see
smith
evening
news
amended
title
vii
reporting
disclosure
act
stat
permits
state
agencies
courts
assume
jurisdiction
labor
disputes
board
declines
pursuant
paragraph
subsection
assert
jurisdiction
compare
guss
utah
labor
board
addition
congressional
exceptions
refused
hold
state
remedies
activity
regulated
merely
peripheral
concern
labor
management
relations
act
touched
interests
deeply
rooted
local
feeling
responsibility
absence
compelling
congressional
direction
infer
congress
deprived
power
act
san
diego
building
trades
council
garmon
see
linn
plant
guard
workers
libel
automobile
workers
russell
violence
international
assn
machinists
gonzales
wrongful
expulsion
union
membership
local
wisconsin
employment
relations
board
mass
picketing
see
also
hanna
mining
marine
engineers
beneficial
exceptions
way
undermine
vitality
rule
applicable
demonstrate
decision
federal
state
jurisdiction
given
class
cases
must
depend
upon
nature
particular
interests
asserted
effect
upon
administration
national
labor
policies
concurrent
judicial
administrative
remedies
primary
justification
doctrine
need
avoid
conflicting
rules
substantive
law
labor
relations
area
desirability
leaving
development
rules
administrative
agency
created
congress
purpose
applicable
cases
involving
alleged
breaches
union
duty
fair
representation
doctrine
judicially
developed
steele
progeny
suits
alleging
breach
duty
remained
judicially
cognizable
long
nlrb
given
unfair
labor
practice
jurisdiction
union
activities
moreover
board
declared
miranda
fuel
union
breach
duty
fair
representation
henceforth
treated
unfair
labor
practice
board
adopted
applied
doctrine
developed
federal
courts
see
finally
dissenting
board
members
miranda
fuel
pointed
fair
representation
duty
suits
often
require
review
substantive
positions
taken
policies
pursued
union
negotiation
collective
bargaining
agreement
handling
grievance
machinery
matters
normally
within
board
unfair
labor
practice
jurisdiction
doubted
whether
board
brings
substantially
greater
expertise
bear
problems
courts
engaged
type
review
since
steele
decision
addition
considerations
unique
interests
served
duty
fair
representation
doctrine
profound
effect
opinion
applicability
rule
class
cases
federal
labor
laws
seek
promote
industrial
peace
improvement
wages
working
conditions
fostering
system
employee
organization
collective
bargaining
see
amended
stat
collective
bargaining
system
encouraged
congress
administered
nlrb
necessity
subordinates
interests
individual
employee
collective
interests
employees
bargaining
unit
see
case
labor
board
recognized
steele
congressional
grant
power
union
act
exclusive
collective
bargaining
representative
corresponding
reduction
individual
rights
employees
represented
raise
grave
constitutional
problems
unions
free
exercise
power
racial
discrimination
since
landmark
decision
duty
fair
representation
stood
bulwark
prevent
arbitrary
union
conduct
individuals
stripped
traditional
forms
redress
provisions
federal
labor
law
hold
petitioners
government
urge
courts
foreclosed
nlrb
miranda
fuel
decision
traditional
supervisory
jurisdiction
individual
employee
injured
arbitrary
discriminatory
union
conduct
longer
assured
impartial
review
complaint
since
board
general
counsel
unreviewable
discretion
refuse
institute
unfair
labor
practice
complaint
see
electrical
contractors
assn
ordman
cert
denied
existence
even
small
group
cases
board
unwilling
unable
remedy
union
breach
duty
frustrate
basic
purposes
underlying
duty
fair
representation
doctrine
reasons
assume
nlrb
tardy
assumption
jurisdiction
cases
congress
enacted
intended
oust
courts
traditional
jurisdiction
curb
arbitrary
conduct
individual
employee
statutory
representative
also
intensely
practical
considerations
foreclose
judicial
cognizance
fair
representation
duty
suits
considerations
emerge
intricate
relationship
duty
fair
representation
enforcement
collective
bargaining
contracts
fact
question
whether
union
breached
duty
fair
representation
many
cases
critical
issue
suit
charging
employer
breach
contract
illustrate
let
us
assume
collective
bargaining
agreement
limits
discharges
good
cause
contains
grievance
arbitration
provisions
purporting
restrict
access
courts
employee
discharged
without
cause
either
union
employee
may
sue
employer
section
courts
jurisdiction
suits
enforce
collective
bargaining
agreements
even
though
conduct
employer
challenged
breach
contract
also
arguably
unfair
labor
practice
within
jurisdiction
nlrb
garmon
like
cases
application
suits
smith
evening
news
rule
regard
bargaining
agreement
contains
grievance
arbitration
provisions
intended
provide
exclusive
remedy
breach
contract
claims
employee
discharged
without
cause
violation
agreement
employer
conduct
may
unfair
labor
practice
preclude
suit
union
employer
compel
arbitration
employee
grievance
adjudication
claim
arbitrator
suit
enforce
resulting
arbitration
award
see
steelworkers
american
mfg
however
wrongfully
discharged
employee
resorts
courts
grievance
procedures
fully
exhausted
employer
may
well
defend
ground
exclusive
remedies
provided
contract
exhausted
since
employee
claim
based
upon
breach
collective
bargaining
agreement
bound
terms
agreement
govern
manner
contractual
rights
may
enforced
reason
settled
employee
must
least
attempt
exhaust
exclusive
grievance
arbitration
procedures
established
bargaining
agreement
republic
steel
maddox
however
contractual
remedies
devised
often
controlled
union
employer
may
well
prove
unsatisfactory
unworkable
individual
grievant
problem
determine
circumstances
individual
employee
may
obtain
judicial
review
claim
despite
failure
secure
relief
contractual
remedial
procedures
obvious
situation
employee
limited
exclusive
remedial
procedures
established
contract
occurs
conduct
employer
amounts
repudiation
contractual
procedures
cf
drake
bakeries
bakery
workers
see
generally
corbin
contracts
situation
may
course
others
employer
estopped
conduct
rely
unexhausted
grievance
arbitration
procedures
defense
employee
cause
action
think
another
situation
employee
may
seek
judicial
enforcement
contractual
rights
arises
true
union
sole
power
contract
invoke
higher
stages
grievance
procedure
alleged
prevented
exhausting
contractual
remedies
union
wrongful
refusal
process
grievance
true
employer
situation
may
done
nothing
prevent
exhaustion
exclusive
contractual
remedies
agreed
collective
bargaining
agreement
employer
committed
wrongful
discharge
breach
agreement
breach
remedied
grievance
process
benefit
union
breach
statutory
duty
fair
representation
employee
leave
employee
remediless
circumstances
opinion
great
injustice
believe
congress
conferring
upon
employers
unions
power
establish
exclusive
grievance
procedures
intended
confer
upon
unions
unlimited
discretion
deprive
injured
employees
remedies
breach
contract
think
congress
intended
shield
employers
natural
consequences
breaches
bargaining
agreements
wrongful
union
conduct
enforcement
agreements
cf
richardson
texas
reasons
think
wrongfully
discharged
employee
may
bring
action
employer
face
defense
based
upon
failure
exhaust
contractual
remedies
provided
employee
prove
union
bargaining
agent
breached
duty
fair
representation
handling
employee
grievance
may
assume
present
purposes
breach
duty
union
unfair
labor
practice
nlrb
fifth
circuit
held
employee
suit
employer
however
remains
suit
jurisdiction
courts
destroyed
fact
employee
part
parcel
action
finds
necessary
prove
unfair
labor
practice
union
fact
suit
may
involve
unfair
labor
practice
employer
free
determine
whether
employee
barred
actions
union
representative
proceed
case
facilitate
case
employee
joins
union
defendant
situation
substantially
changed
action
still
suit
jurisdiction
courts
garmon
principle
least
holding
humphrey
moore
supra
respect
petitioners
recognize
brief
insofar
adjudication
union
breach
duty
concerned
result
different
employee
owens
sues
employer
union
separate
actions
little
commend
rule
permit
missouri
courts
adjudicate
union
conduct
action
swift
action
union
reasons
obvious
courts
compelled
pass
upon
whether
breach
duty
fair
representation
context
many
actions
breach
duty
union
breach
contract
employer
proven
must
fashion
appropriate
remedy
presumably
least
cases
union
breach
duty
enhanced
contributed
employee
injury
possible
sense
rule
permit
litigated
fault
employer
union
fashion
remedy
respect
employer
rule
either
employer
compelled
pay
union
wrong
slight
deterrence
indeed
future
union
misconduct
injured
employee
forced
go
two
tribunals
repair
single
injury
moreover
board
compelled
many
cases
either
remedy
injuries
arising
breach
contract
task
congress
assigned
leave
individual
employee
without
remedy
union
wrong
given
strong
reasons
duty
fair
representation
suits
general
fact
courts
many
suits
must
adjudicate
whether
union
breached
duty
conclude
courts
may
also
fashion
remedies
breach
duty
follows
missouri
courts
jurisdiction
case
course
quite
another
problem
determine
remedies
may
available
union
breach
duty
proven
see
part
iv
infra
unique
role
played
duty
fair
representation
doctrine
scheme
federal
labor
laws
important
relationship
judicial
enforcement
collective
bargaining
agreements
context
presented
render
garmon
doctrine
inapplicable
iii
holding
evidence
trial
supported
jury
verdict
favor
owens
missouri
stated
essential
issue
submitted
jury
whether
union
arbitrarily
refused
carry
said
grievance
fifth
step
concluded
sufficient
substantial
evidence
jury
reasonably
found
foregoing
issue
favor
plaintiff
notable
physician
actually
testified
case
sides
content
rely
upon
written
statements
three
physicians
certified
plaintiff
able
perform
regular
work
three
physicians
certified
taken
plaintiff
blood
pressure
readings
approximately
may
inferred
reading
indicate
blood
pressure
dangerously
high
moreover
plaintiff
evidence
showed
actually
done
hard
physical
labor
periodically
four
years
following
discharge
accordingly
rule
point
adversely
defendants
breach
statutory
duty
fair
representation
occurs
union
conduct
toward
member
collective
bargaining
unit
arbitrary
discriminatory
bad
faith
see
humphrey
moore
supra
ford
motor
huffman
supra
considerable
debate
extent
duty
context
union
enforcement
grievance
arbitration
procedures
collective
bargaining
agreement
see
generally
blumrosen
worker
three
phases
unionism
administrative
judicial
control
relationship
rev
comment
federal
protection
individual
rights
labor
contracts
yale
suggested
every
individual
employee
right
grievance
taken
arbitration
others
urged
union
given
substantial
discretion
collective
bargaining
agreement
provides
decide
whether
grievance
taken
arbitration
subject
duty
refrain
patently
wrongful
conduct
racial
discrimination
personal
hostility
though
accept
proposition
union
may
arbitrarily
ignore
meritorious
grievance
process
perfunctory
fashion
agree
individual
employee
absolute
right
grievance
taken
arbitration
regardless
provisions
applicable
collective
bargaining
agreement
stat
congress
declared
final
adjustment
method
agreed
upon
parties
desirable
method
settlement
grievance
disputes
arising
application
interpretation
existing
agreement
providing
grievance
arbitration
procedure
gives
union
discretion
supervise
grievance
machinery
invoke
arbitration
employer
union
contemplate
endeavor
good
faith
settle
grievances
short
arbitration
settlement
process
frivolous
grievances
ended
prior
costly
step
grievance
procedures
moreover
sides
assured
similar
complaints
treated
consistently
major
problem
areas
interpretation
collective
bargaining
contract
isolated
perhaps
resolved
finally
settlement
process
furthers
interest
union
statutory
agent
coauthor
bargaining
agreement
representing
employees
enforcement
agreement
see
cox
rights
labor
agreement
harv
rev
individual
employee
compel
arbitration
grievance
regardless
merit
settlement
machinery
provided
contract
substantially
undermined
thus
destroying
employer
confidence
union
authority
returning
individual
grievant
vagaries
independent
unsystematic
negotiation
moreover
rule
significantly
greater
number
grievances
proceed
arbitration
greatly
increase
cost
grievance
machinery
overburden
arbitration
process
prevent
functioning
successfully
see
nlrb
acme
industrial
ross
distressed
grievance
procedures
rehabilitation
labor
arbitration
industrial
change
proceedings
annual
meeting
national
academy
arbitrators
well
doubted
whether
parties
collective
bargaining
agreements
long
continue
provide
detailed
grievance
arbitration
procedures
kind
encouraged
supra
power
settle
majority
grievances
short
costlier
steps
limited
rule
permitting
grievant
unilaterally
invoke
arbitration
see
substantial
danger
interests
individual
employee
statutory
agent
given
contractual
power
honestly
good
faith
settle
grievances
short
arbitration
reasons
conclude
union
breach
duty
fair
representation
thereby
open
suit
employee
breach
contract
merely
settled
grievance
short
arbitration
reasons
standard
applied
missouri
sustained
union
decision
particular
grievance
lacks
sufficient
merit
justify
arbitration
constitute
breach
duty
fair
representation
judge
jury
later
found
grievance
meritorious
union
incentive
settle
grievances
short
arbitration
seriously
reduced
dampening
effect
entire
grievance
procedure
reduction
union
freedom
settle
claims
good
faith
surely
substantial
since
union
statutory
duty
fair
representation
protects
individual
employee
arbitrary
abuses
settlement
device
providing
recourse
employer
suit
union
severe
limitation
power
settle
grievances
neither
necessary
desirable
therefore
conclude
missouri
erred
upholding
verdict
case
solely
ground
evidence
supported
owens
claim
wrongfully
discharged
applying
proper
standard
union
liability
facts
case
uphold
jury
award
conclude
matter
federal
law
evidence
support
verdict
union
breached
duty
fair
representation
stated
owens
established
breach
duty
merely
convincing
jury
fact
fit
work
must
also
proved
arbitrary
conduct
part
union
processing
grievance
evidence
revealed
union
diligently
supervised
grievance
fourth
step
bargaining
agreement
procedure
union
business
representative
serving
owens
advocate
throughout
steps
swift
refused
reinstate
owens
basis
medical
reports
indicating
reduced
blood
pressure
union
sent
another
doctor
choice
union
expense
attempt
amass
persuasive
medical
evidence
owens
fitness
work
examination
proved
unfavorable
union
concluded
establish
wrongful
discharge
encouraged
swift
find
light
work
owens
plant
effort
failed
union
determined
arbitration
fruitless
suggested
owens
accept
swift
offer
send
heart
association
rehabilitation
point
owens
grievance
suspended
fourth
step
hope
might
rehabilitated
administering
grievance
arbitration
machinery
statutory
agent
employees
union
must
good
faith
nonarbitrary
manner
make
decisions
merits
particular
grievances
see
humphrey
moore
ford
motor
huffman
case
owens
supplied
union
medical
evidence
supporting
position
union
might
well
breached
duty
ignored
owens
complaint
processed
grievance
perfunctory
manner
see
cox
rights
labor
agreement
harv
union
processed
grievance
fourth
step
attempted
gather
sufficient
evidence
prove
owens
case
attempted
secure
owens
less
vigorous
work
plant
joined
employer
efforts
owens
rehabilitated
efforts
proved
unsuccessful
union
conclude
arbitration
fruitless
grievance
dismissed
evidence
union
officer
personally
hostile
owens
union
acted
time
good
faith
concluded
individual
employee
absolute
right
grievance
arbitrated
collective
bargaining
agreement
issue
breach
duty
fair
representation
established
merely
proof
underlying
grievance
meritorious
must
conclude
duty
breached
iv
appropriate
remedy
breach
union
duty
fair
representation
must
vary
circumstances
particular
breach
case
employee
complaint
union
wrongfully
failed
afford
arbitration
remedy
employer
established
collective
bargaining
agreement
damages
sought
owens
primarily
suffered
employer
alleged
breach
contract
assuming
moment
owens
wrongfully
discharged
swift
defense
direct
action
breach
contract
union
failure
resort
arbitration
compare
republic
steel
maddox
smith
evening
news
failure
violation
union
statutory
duty
employee
reason
exempt
employer
contractual
damages
otherwise
pay
see
pp
supra
difficulty
lies
fashioning
appropriate
scheme
remedies
petitioners
urge
employee
restricted
circumstances
decree
compelling
employer
union
arbitrate
underlying
grievance
true
employee
action
based
employer
alleged
breach
contract
plus
union
alleged
wrongful
failure
afford
contractual
remedy
arbitration
reason
order
compelling
arbitration
viewed
one
available
remedies
breach
union
duty
proved
see
reason
inflexibly
require
arbitration
cases
cases
example
least
part
employee
damages
may
attributable
union
breach
duty
arbitrator
may
power
bargaining
agreement
award
damages
union
cases
arbitrable
issues
may
substantially
resolved
course
trying
fair
representation
controversy
situations
free
decide
contractual
claim
award
employee
appropriate
damages
equitable
relief
difficult
question
portion
employee
damages
may
charged
union
particular
may
award
union
include
damages
attributable
solely
employer
breach
contract
think
though
union
violated
statutory
duty
failing
press
grievance
employer
unrelated
breach
contract
triggered
controversy
caused
portion
employee
damages
employee
difficulty
recovering
damages
employer
explained
hide
behind
union
wrongful
failure
act
fact
employer
may
probably
joined
defendant
fair
representation
suit
humphrey
moore
supra
real
hardship
union
pay
damages
even
union
given
right
indemnification
employer
employee
assured
direct
recovery
employer
see
merit
requiring
union
pay
employer
share
damages
governing
principle
apportion
liability
employer
union
according
damage
caused
fault
thus
damages
attributable
solely
employer
breach
contract
charged
union
increases
damages
caused
union
refusal
process
grievance
charged
employer
case
even
union
breached
duty
almost
owens
damages
still
attributable
allegedly
wrongful
discharge
swift
reasons
even
union
properly
found
liable
breach
duty
clear
damage
award
improper
reversed
known
national
brotherhood
packinghouse
dairy
workers
punitive
damages
reduced
amount
claimed
owens
complaint
agreement
created
procedure
handling
grievances
steps
one
two
either
aggrieved
employee
union
representative
presents
grievance
first
swift
department
foreman
writing
division
superintendent
step
three
grievance
committees
union
management
meet
company
must
state
position
writing
union
step
four
meeting
swift
general
superintendent
representatives
national
union
grievance
settled
fourth
step
national
union
given
power
refer
grievance
specified
arbitrator
notice
dismissal
given
owens
time
filed
second
suit
swift
breach
contract
suit
swift
still
pending
pretrial
stage
see
also
cargo
handlers
local
rubber
workers
enforced
cir
maremont
galveston
maritime
hughes
tool
see
ford
motor
huffman
huffman
nlrb
submitted
amicus
brief
stating
assumed
jurisdiction
fair
representation
duty
issues
mem
nlrb
nos
oct
term
syres
oil
workers
international
union
reversed
dismissal
suit
claimed
breach
duty
fair
representation
despite
express
reliance
one
respondent
exclusive
nlrb
jurisdiction
brief
resp
gulf
oil
oct
term
see
hughes
tool
chairman
mcculloch
member
fanning
dissenting
part
public
interest
effectuating
policies
federal
labor
laws
wrong
done
individual
employee
always
board
principal
concern
fashioning
unfair
labor
practice
remedies
see
amended
stat
phelps
dodge
labor
board
thus
general
counsel
refuse
bring
complaints
behalf
injured
employees
injury
complained
insubstantial
see
administrative
decision
general
counsel
case
cch
decisions
transfer
binder
grievance
arbitration
procedure
included
contract
parties
intend
exclusive
remedy
suit
breach
contract
normally
heard
even
though
procedures
exhausted
see
republic
steel
maddox
corbin
contracts
occasionally
bargaining
agreement
give
aggrieved
employee
rather
union
right
invoke
arbitration
see
retail
clerks
lion
dry
goods
cert
denied
accord
hiller
liquor
salesmen
union
cir
hardcastle
western
greyhound
lines
cir
cert
denied
fiore
associated
transport
supp
bieski
eastern
automobile
forwarding
supp
aff
cir
ostrofsky
steelworkers
supp
aff
per
curiam
cir
cert
denied
jenkins
wm
kurdle
md
assuming
moment
swift
breached
collective
bargaining
agreement
discharging
owens
union
breached
duty
handling
owens
grievance
case
illustrates
difficulties
result
rule
courts
remedying
union
breach
duty
swift
participate
union
unfair
labor
practice
board
jurisdiction
remedy
swift
breach
contract
yet
might
equally
unable
give
owens
full
relief
suit
swift
award
damages
swift
owens
full
loss
even
concludes
part
loss
caused
union
breach
duty
award
owens
partial
recovery
hoping
board
make
whole
remedy
problems
difficult
enough
one
tribunal
parties
impossible
two
independent
tribunals
different
procedures
time
limitations
remedial
powers
must
participate
see
donnelly
fruit
report
committee
improvement
administration
agreements
individual
grievances
nw
rev
murphy
duty
fair
representation
mo
rev
summers
individual
rights
collective
agreements
arbitration
rev
see
sheremet
chrysler
wyle
labor
arbitration
concept
exclusive
representation
ind
com
rev
current
grievance
practices
attempt
usually
made
keep
number
arbitrated
grievances
minimum
officer
national
union
testified
case
one
grievances
filed
swift
plants
september
october
taken
arbitration
amicus
brief
reveals
similar
performances
general
motors
corporation
steel
corporation
two
nation
largest
unionized
employers
less
written
grievances
filed
recent
period
general
motors
required
arbitration
grievances
processed
beyond
first
step
steel
decided
arbitrator
owens
allege
testify
petitioner
vaca
president
kansas
city
local
demanded
expenses
union
take
grievance
arbitration
charge
petitioners
vigorously
denied
trial
collective
bargaining
agreement
local
union
power
invoke
arbitration
see
supra
moreover
union
decision
send
owens
another
doctor
union
expense
occurred
vaca
alleged
demand
ultimate
decision
invoke
arbitration
came
later
still
thus
even
jury
believed
owens
controverted
testimony
think
incident
establish
breach
duty
union
obviously
arbitration
appropriate
remedy
parties
created
procedure
collective
bargaining
agreement
dealing
situations
union
affirmatively
caused
employer
commit
alleged
breach
contract
cases
sort
union
conduct
found
unfair
labor
practice
nlrb
found
unfair
labor
practice
employer
held
union
employer
jointly
severally
liable
back
pay
found
owing
particular
employee
subject
joint
discrimination
imparato
stevedoring
squirt
distrib
newman
even
approach
appropriate
analogous
suits
applicable
since
union
played
part
swift
alleged
breach
contract
since
swift
took
part
union
alleged
breach
duty
joint
liability
either
wrong
unwarranted
justice
fortas
chief
justice
justice
harlan
join
concurring
result
view
complaint
employee
union
breached
duty
fair
representation
subject
exclusive
jurisdiction
nlrb
charge
unfair
labor
practice
see
miranda
fuel
local
rubber
workers
enforced
cir
case
unfair
labor
practices
board
jurisdiction
preemptive
garner
teamsters
union
guss
utah
labor
board
san
diego
building
trades
council
garmon
local
constr
laborers
curry
plumbers
union
borden
iron
workers
perko
liner
jafco
cf
woody
sterling
alum
cir
pet
cert
pending
basis
failure
apply
preemption
principle
present
case
shall
discuss
strong
reason
application
relationship
union
individual
employee
respect
processing
claims
employment
rights
collective
bargaining
agreement
fundamental
design
operation
federal
labor
law
merely
peripheral
opinion
presents
difficult
problems
definition
status
problems
held
precisely
kind
wisely
entrusted
initially
agency
charged
administration
act
whole
iron
workers
perko
supra
accordingly
judgment
missouri
reversed
complaint
dismissed
reason
basis
agree
however
assumed
jurisdiction
subject
matter
exists
judgment
still
reversed
use
missouri
improper
standard
measuring
union
duty
absence
evidence
establish
union
refused
process
owens
grievance
bad
faith
arbitrarily
regret
elaborate
discussion
opinion
problems
irrelevant
action
employee
employer
discussion
requisites
action
judgment
unnecessary
argues
employee
sue
employer
maintain
action
employee
show
exhausted
remedies
collective
bargaining
agreement
alternatively
prevented
union
breached
duty
failure
completely
process
claim
may
maybe
show
maintain
action
employer
wrongful
discharge
demanded
union
process
claim
exhaustion
available
remedies
refused
see
need
pass
upon
question
presented
respect
lends
support
argument
seems
use
discussion
litigation
somehow
analogous
supportive
conclusion
employee
may
maintain
action
union
believe
follows
agree
nlrb
unfair
labor
practice
jurisdiction
preclude
action
employer
wrongful
discharge
employment
smith
evening
news
therefore
owens
might
maintained
action
employer
present
case
action
enforce
collective
bargaining
agreement
congress
authorized
courts
entertain
actions
type
claim
union
quite
different
character
recognizes
holds
think
correctly
issue
reached
union
required
pay
damages
measured
breach
employment
contract
union
employer
breached
contract
agree
suggest
reveals
point
contend
employee
claim
union
claim
collective
bargaining
agreement
claim
union
breached
statutory
duty
fair
representation
claim
submit
claim
unfair
labor
practice
within
exclusive
jurisdiction
nlrb
agrees
one
available
remedies
obtainable
says
action
breach
union
duty
proved
order
compelling
arbitration
precisely
uniquely
kind
order
within
province
board
beyond
exceedingly
vague
remedy
appropriate
damages
equitable
relief
suggested
possible
remedies
apparently
arbitration
available
damages
union
admonishes
gauged
according
damage
caused
fault
failure
exhaust
remedies
grievance
difficulty
seems
reflects
basic
awkwardness
position
attempting
force
posture
contract
violation
alleged
default
union
violation
collective
bargaining
agreement
breach
separate
basic
duty
fairly
represent
employees
unit
unfair
labor
practice
treated
look
beyond
logic
precedent
policy
labor
relations
design
congress
provided
jurisdiction
type
action
seems
anomalous
dealing
interpretation
contract
alleged
breach
employment
agreement
effect
acknowledges
concerned
subtleties
union
statutory
duty
faithfully
represent
employees
unit
including
may
members
union
regrettably
opinion
ventures
state
judgments
metes
bounds
reciprocal
duties
involved
relationship
union
employee
opinion
precisely
especially
kind
judgment
congress
intended
entrust
board
well
within
doctrine
prudently
stated
see
cases
cited
supra
especially
perko
borden
cases
facts
strongly
parallel
situation
case
see
also
linn
plant
guard
workers
dissenting
opinion
nuances
relationships
infinite
consequential
particularly
issue
amorphous
whether
union
proved
guilty
arbitrary
conduct
standard
applicable
reason
good
judgment
jurisdiction
left
board
placed
courts
especially
complex
necessarily
confusing
guidebook
publishes
accordingly
join
judgment
reversal
basis
stated
decision
nlrb
denied
enforcement
appeals
second
circuit
basis
decide
point
relevant
nlrb
miranda
fuel
cir
one
judge
judge
medina
took
position
nlrb
incorrectly
held
violation
duty
fair
representation
unfair
labor
practice
alternative
ground
decision
held
nlrb
sufficient
evidence
support
finding
breach
duty
judge
lumbard
agreed
latter
holding
explicitly
reach
question
whether
breach
duty
unfair
labor
practice
judge
friendly
dissented
affirmed
nlrb
sufficiency
evidence
holding
breach
duty
fair
representation
unfair
labor
practice
nlrb
give
relief
opinion
judge
thornberry
fifth
circuit
supports
views
expressed
herein
see
also
cox
duty
fair
representation
vill
rev
wellington
union
democracy
fair
representation
federal
responsibility
federal
system
yale
cf
brother
black
dissenting
opinion
case
cf
also
brown
sterling
alum
prods
cir
cert
denied
post
republic
steel
maddox
pass
upon
issue
leave
employee
remediless
union
wrongfully
refuses
process
grievance
great
injustice
believe
relieves
injustice
great
extent
requiring
employee
prove
unfair
labor
practice
prerequisite
judicial
relief
employer
breach
contract
understand
giving
employee
cause
action
union
appropriate
way
remedy
injustice
exist
union
allowed
foreclose
relief
employer
argues
since
employee
suing
employer
breach
employment
contract
show
exhaustion
remedies
contract
since
purpose
show
demand
union
according
wrongful
failure
prosecute
grievance
union
joined
party
defendant
since
union
joined
suit
may
sued
independently
employer
non
sequitur
insists
suit
union
breach
employment
contract
violation
duty
fairly
represent
employee
entirely
different
matter
breach
statutory
duty
unfair
labor
practice
breach
employment
contract
variety
contexts
nlrb
concerns
substantive
bargaining
behavior
parties
example
duty
bargain
good
faith
see
fibreboard
labor
board
jurisdictional
disputes
see
labor
board
radio
engineers
secondary
boycotts
hot
cargo
clauses
see
orange
belt
district
council
painters
nlrb
app
justice
black
dissenting
today
opens
slightly
courthouse
door
employee
incidental
claim
union
breach
duty
fair
representation
shut
face
seeks
direct
judicial
relief
underlying
valuable
claim
employer
result
follows
announcement
case
involving
employee
suit
union
new
rule
govern
employee
suit
employer
rule
employee
sue
employer
simple
breach
employment
contract
employee
must
prove
attempted
exhaust
contractual
remedies
attempt
exhaust
frustrated
arbitrary
discriminatory
bad
faith
conduct
part
union
new
rule
result
agree
recognizes
must
jury
case
found
least
benjamin
owens
fit
work
grievance
swift
meritorious
swift
breached
collective
bargaining
agreement
wrongfully
discharged
also
notes
passing
owens
separate
action
breach
contract
pending
swift
state
courts
part
iv
opinion
vigorously
insists
reason
exempt
employer
contractual
damages
otherwise
pay
employee
difficulty
recovering
damages
employer
unrelated
breach
contract
employee
assured
direct
recovery
employer
reassurance
part
iv
gives
comfort
owens
part
iv
based
assumption
union
breached
duty
owens
assumption
part
iii
opinion
finds
unsupported
facts
case
means
though
expressly
say
owens
successful
pending
action
swift
suit
union
makes
clear
question
whether
union
breached
duty
fair
representation
critical
issue
suit
wrongfully
discharged
employee
may
bring
action
employer
prove
union
breached
duty
fair
representation
handling
employee
grievance
employee
part
parcel
action
finds
necessary
prove
unfair
labor
practice
union
thus
owens
attempts
proceed
pending
action
swift
swift
undoubtedly
secure
prompt
dismissal
pointing
conclusion
union
breached
duty
fair
representation
thus
owens
obtained
judicial
determination
wrongfully
discharged
left
remediless
swift
breached
contract
allowed
hide
behind
shielded
union
conduct
simply
fail
see
make
one
iota
difference
far
unrelated
breach
contract
swift
concerned
whether
union
conduct
wrongful
rightful
neither
precedent
logic
supports
new
announcement
certainly
nothing
republic
steel
maddox
supports
new
rule
case
aggrieved
employee
attempted
completely
sidestep
available
grievance
procedures
favor
lawsuit
nothing
said
contract
grievance
procedures
inadequate
protect
interests
aggrieved
employee
employee
attempted
implement
procedures
found
held
employee
must
attempt
use
contract
grievance
procedure
must
afford
union
opportunity
act
behalf
dissented
firm
belief
employee
free
litigate
lawsuit
lawyer
jury
rather
forced
entrust
claim
union
even
agree
press
required
submit
arbitration
even
implied
worker
allowed
sue
presented
claim
union
suffered
inevitable
discouragement
delay
necessarily
accompanies
union
refusal
press
claim
find
threat
peaceful
labor
relations
union
prestige
allowing
employee
completely
contractual
remedies
favor
traditional
lawsuit
back
pay
wage
substitutes
course
benjamin
owens
completely
sidestep
available
grievance
procedures
favor
lawsuit
complete
respect
union
authority
deference
contract
grievance
procedures
gave
union
chance
act
behalf
every
way
possible
tried
convince
claim
meritorious
carried
fifth
step
arbitration
short
everything
opinion
maddox
said
yet
says
much
enough
maddox
noted
cases
really
point
involved
agreements
governed
railway
labor
act
expressly
refused
hold
discharged
worker
must
pursue
collective
bargaining
grievance
procedures
suing
wrongful
discharge
transcontinental
western
air
koppal
moore
illinois
central
also
observed
decision
maddox
raised
overruling
axe
high
cases
falling
certain
changing
seasons
latter
observation
mistaken
term
walker
southern
refused
overrule
light
maddox
cases
moore
koppal
noting
long
delays
attendant
upon
exhausting
administrative
remedies
railway
labor
act
based
refusal
contrast
administrative
remedy
available
maddox
available
walker
suggested
availability
administrative
remedy
determines
whether
employee
sue
without
first
exhausting
doubt
owens
administrative
remedy
free
sue
walker
slow
one
unlike
maddox
owens
attempted
implement
contract
grievance
procedures
found
inadequate
today
decision
following
wake
walker
southern
merely
perpetuates
unfortunate
anomaly
created
maddox
law
labor
relations
rule
announced
maddox
thought
brainchild
recent
preference
arbitration
unable
ascribe
genesis
today
rule
arbitration
precisely
owens
sought
preferred
today
holds
employee
meritorious
claim
absolute
right
either
litigated
arbitrated
fearing
arbitrators
overworked
allows
unions
unilaterally
determine
take
grievance
arbitration
first
step
contract
grievance
procedure
claim
presented
impartial
third
party
long
union
decisions
neither
arbitrary
bad
faith
derives
standard
conduct
long
line
cases
holding
breach
statutory
duty
fair
representation
occurs
union
conduct
toward
member
collective
bargaining
unit
arbitrary
discriminatory
bad
faith
overlooks
cases
laid
standard
context
situations
employee
sole
fundamental
complaint
union
slightest
hint
cases
standard
apply
employee
primary
complaint
employer
breach
contract
incidentally
contended
union
conduct
prevented
adjudication
either
arbitrator
underlying
grievance
satisfied
merely
holding
situation
employee
recover
damages
union
unless
union
breached
duty
fair
representation
one
thing
say
union
making
decision
take
employee
grievance
arbitration
goes
hold
employee
sue
employer
breach
contract
unless
failure
exhaust
contractual
remedies
due
union
breach
duty
fair
representation
quite
unwilling
say
union
refusal
exhaust
remedies
however
nonarbitrary
amount
breach
duty
either
employee
able
sue
employer
breach
contract
attempted
exhaust
contractual
remedies
union
absolute
duty
exhaust
contractual
remedies
behalf
merits
employee
grievance
thus
determined
either
jury
arbitrator
today
decision
never
determined
either
clear
opinion
goes
much
simply
holding
employee
absolute
right
union
take
grievance
arbitration
course
union
supervised
grievance
fourth
step
contract
machinery
dropped
prior
arbitration
belief
outcome
arbitration
unfavorable
limited
standard
arbitrariness
clearly
need
union
go
far
suppose
instance
union
rule
prosecute
grievance
even
first
step
unless
grievance
filed
employee
within
hours
arose
pursuant
rule
union
might
completely
refuse
prosecute
grievance
filed
several
days
late
thus
employee
matter
meritorious
grievance
get
absolutely
nowhere
unless
prove
union
rule
arbitrary
standard
one
define
employee
get
absolutely
consideration
merits
grievance
either
jury
arbitrator
employer
union
suggests
three
reasons
giving
union
almost
unlimited
discretion
deprive
injured
employees
remedies
breach
contract
first
frivolous
grievances
ended
prior
costly
arbitration
one
even
union
suggests
benjamin
owens
grievance
frivolous
union
decided
take
arbitration
simply
union
doubted
chance
success
even
doubt
think
union
duty
present
contested
serious
claim
arbitrator
whose
function
decide
claims
basis
believes
right
second
says
allowing
union
settle
grievances
prior
arbitration
assure
consistent
treatment
major
problem
areas
interpretation
collective
bargaining
contract
argued
whether
owens
fit
work
presents
major
problem
interpretation
collective
bargaining
agreement
problem
one
interpreting
medical
reports
collective
bargaining
agreement
evaluating
evidence
owens
physical
condition
doubt
whether
consistency
either
possible
desirable
determining
whether
particular
employee
able
perform
particular
job
finally
suggests
decision
furthers
interest
union
statutory
agent
think
real
reason
today
decision
entirely
overlooks
interests
injured
employee
one
anything
lose
course
anything
gives
union
life
death
power
supposed
represent
furthers
interest
simply
fail
see
union
legitimate
role
statutory
agent
undermined
requiring
prosecute
serious
grievances
conclusion
allowing
injured
employee
sue
employer
given
union
chance
act
behalf
henceforth
almost
every
suit
employee
employer
employee
additional
burden
proving
union
acted
arbitrarily
bad
faith
never
explains
meant
vague
phrase
trial
judges
intelligently
translate
jury
must
employee
prove
union
fact
acted
arbitrarily
sufficient
show
employee
grievance
meritorious
reasonable
union
refused
carry
arbitration
must
employee
join
union
suit
employer
must
join
employer
unfair
representation
suit
union
however
questions
answered
today
decision
requiring
individual
employee
take
employer
union
every
suit
employer
prove
employer
breached
contract
union
acted
arbitrarily
converts
otherwise
simple
action
donnybrook
puts
intolerable
burden
employees
meritorious
grievances
means
frequently
left
remedy
today
decision
giving
worker
ephemeral
right
sue
union
breach
duty
fair
representation
creates
insurmountable
obstacles
block
far
valuable
right
sue
employer
breach
collective
bargaining
agreement
owens
died
appeal
case
trial
pending
administrator
estate
substituted
respondent
herein
though
simplicity
referred
herein
owens