smith
kansas
city
title
trust
argued
decided
february
wm
marshall
bullitt
louisville
frank
hagerman
kansas
city
appellant
charles
hughes
george
wickersham
new
york
city
appellees
justice
day
delivered
opinion
bill
filed
district
western
division
western
district
missouri
shareholder
kansas
city
title
trust
company
enjoin
company
officers
agents
employees
investing
funds
company
farm
loan
bonds
issued
federal
land
banks
land
banks
authority
federal
farm
loan
act
july
stat
comp
amended
act
stat
comp
comp
ann
supp
relief
sought
ground
acts
beyond
constitutional
power
congress
bill
avers
board
directors
company
invest
funds
bonds
amount
classes
described
unless
enjoined
action
bill
avers
formation
federal
land
banks
land
banks
provisions
act
federal
land
banks
averred
loaned
upon
farm
lands
large
amounts
secured
mortgage
depositing
farm
loan
registrar
executed
issued
collateral
trust
obligations
called
loan
bonds
secured
depositing
equivalent
amount
farm
mortgages
notes
said
federal
land
banks
sold
continuing
offer
sale
large
amounts
said
farm
loan
bonds
bill
also
avers
various
persons
different
parts
organized
land
banks
capital
stock
subscribed
owned
private
persons
land
banks
deposited
notes
mortgages
farm
loan
registrar
issued
equivalent
amount
collateral
trust
obligations
called
loan
bonds
sold
continued
offered
sale
investors
large
amounts
markets
country
statement
given
amount
deposits
secretary
treasury
federal
land
banks
banks
issued
certificates
indebtedness
bearing
interest
per
cent
per
annum
averred
september
federal
land
banks
owned
bouds
par
value
land
banks
owned
like
bonds
par
value
august
pursuant
provisions
act
secretary
treasury
invested
public
funds
capital
stock
federal
land
banks
july
secretary
treasury
behalf
held
capital
stock
federal
land
banks
pursuant
provisions
section
act
amended
secretary
treasury
purchased
farm
loan
bonds
issued
federal
land
banks
par
value
september
bonds
issued
act
federal
land
banks
amount
held
treasury
purchased
authority
amendment
january
september
stock
land
banks
incorporated
act
aggregate
capital
subscribed
paid
bonds
issued
land
banks
amount
hands
public
secretary
treasury
time
filing
bill
designated
federal
land
banks
land
banks
depositaries
public
money
except
stated
later
bill
employed
financial
agents
government
performed
duties
depositaries
public
money
accepted
deposits
engaged
banking
business
bill
avers
summer
federal
land
banks
wichita
paul
spokane
designated
financial
agents
government
making
seed
grain
loans
farmers
sections
president
request
secretary
agriculture
set
aside
purpose
war
funds
three
banks
mentioned
made
upwards
loans
character
aggregating
sum
upwards
engaged
collecting
loans
secured
crop
liens
banks
act
capacity
without
compensation
receiving
actual
expenses
incurred
section
act
provides
farm
loan
bonds
issued
provisions
act
federal
land
banks
stock
land
banks
shall
lawful
investment
fiduciary
trust
funds
may
accepted
security
public
deposits
bill
avers
defendant
trust
company
authorized
buy
invest
sell
government
state
municipal
bonds
buy
invest
sell
bonds
papers
stocks
securities
authorized
issued
valid
law
investment
securities
nevertheless
invest
farm
loan
bonds
trust
company
induced
direct
officers
make
investment
reason
reliance
upon
provisions
farm
loan
acts
especially
sections
farm
loan
bonds
declared
instrumentalities
government
income
derived
therefrom
declared
exempt
federal
state
municipal
local
taxation
declared
lawful
investments
fiduciary
trust
funds
bill
avers
acts
attempted
authorize
bonds
wholly
illegal
void
unconstitutional
effect
unauthorized
constitution
bill
prays
acts
congress
authorizing
creation
banks
especially
sections
thereof
shall
adjudged
decreed
unconstitutional
void
effect
issuance
farm
loan
bonds
taxation
exemption
feature
thereof
shall
adjudged
decreed
invalid
first
land
bank
chicago
federal
land
bank
wichita
allowed
intervene
became
parties
defendant
suit
kansas
city
title
trust
company
filed
motion
dismiss
nature
general
demurrer
upon
hearing
district
entered
decree
dismissing
bill
decree
appeal
taken
objection
made
federal
jurisdiction
either
original
appellate
parties
suit
question
first
examined
company
authorized
invest
funds
legal
securities
attack
upon
proposed
investment
bonds
described
alleged
unconstitutionality
acts
congress
undertaking
organize
banks
authorize
issue
bonds
reason
set
forth
bill
ground
objection
proposed
investment
board
directors
acting
company
behalf
diversity
citizenship
lacking
jurisdiction
district
depends
upon
whether
cause
action
set
forth
arises
constitution
laws
judicial
code
comp
general
rule
appears
bill
statement
plaintiff
right
relief
depends
upon
construction
application
constitution
laws
federal
claim
merely
colorable
rests
upon
reasonable
foundation
district
jurisdiction
provision
early
date
considering
grant
constitutional
power
confer
jurisdiction
upon
federal
courts
chief
justice
marshall
said
case
law
equity
consists
right
one
party
well
may
truly
said
arise
constitution
law
whenever
correct
decision
depends
upon
construction
either
cohens
virginia
wheat
ed
title
right
set
party
may
defeated
one
construction
constitution
law
sustained
opposite
construction
osborn
bank
wheat
ed
definitions
quoted
approved
patton
brady
sup
citing
gold
washing
keyes
tennessee
davis
white
greenhow
sup
railroad
mississippi
characterization
suit
arising
constitution
laws
followed
many
decisions
federal
courts
see
macon
grocery
atlantic
coast
line
sup
shulthis
mcdougal
sup
principle
applied
brushaber
union
pacific
sup
ann
cas
shareholder
filed
bill
enjoin
defendant
corporation
complying
income
tax
provisions
tariff
act
october
case
diversity
citizenship
direct
appeal
sustained
constitutional
questions
raised
bill
dismissed
repugnancy
statute
constitution
well
grounds
equitable
jurisdiction
set
forth
bill
right
come
direct
appeal
sustained
averments
based
upon
constitutional
objections
act
reference
made
pollock
farmers
loan
trust
sup
similar
shareholder
right
sue
maintained
direct
appeal
decree
circuit
held
authorized
brushaber
case
chief
justice
speaking
said
right
prevent
corporation
returning
paying
tax
based
upon
many
averments
repugnancy
statute
constitution
peculiar
relation
corporation
stockholders
particualr
interests
resulting
many
administrative
provisions
assailed
act
confusion
wrong
multiplicity
suits
absence
means
redress
result
corporation
paid
tax
complied
act
respects
without
protest
alleged
intention
put
way
question
jurisdiction
say
view
averments
ruling
pollock
farmers
loan
trust
company
sustaining
right
stockholder
sue
restrain
corporation
proper
averments
voluntarily
paying
tax
charged
unconstitutional
ground
permit
suit
violate
prohibitions
section
rev
enjoining
enforcement
taxes
opinion
contention
made
jurisdiction
cause
since
entertain
violate
provisions
revised
statutes
referred
without
merit
averments
citizenship
residence
recitals
provisions
statute
statements
business
corporation
contained
first
paragraphs
bill
advanced
sustain
jurisdiction
bill
alleged
constitutional
objections
specified
number
paragraphs
subdivisions
grounds
assert
violation
constitution
follows
wide
sense
charge
repugnancy
statute
sixteenth
amendment
immediate
sanction
statute
adopted
jurisdiction
determined
upon
principles
laid
cases
referred
instant
case
averments
bill
show
directors
proceeding
make
investments
view
act
authorizing
bonds
purchased
maintaining
act
authorizing
constitutional
bonds
valid
desirable
investments
objecting
shareholder
avers
bill
securities
issued
unconstitutional
law
hence
validity
therefore
apparent
controversy
concerns
constitutional
validity
act
congress
directly
drawn
question
decision
depends
upon
determination
issue
general
allegations
interest
shareholder
right
injunction
prevent
purchase
alleged
unconstitutional
securities
mis
application
funds
corporation
gives
jurisdiction
principles
settled
pollock
trust
company
brushaber
union
pacific
company
supra
therefore
opinion
district
jurisdiction
averments
bill
direct
appeal
upon
constitutional
grounds
authorized
come
examine
questions
presented
attack
upon
constitutionality
legislation
question
federal
farm
loan
act
lengthy
set
full
entitled
act
provide
capital
agricultural
development
create
standard
forms
investment
based
upon
farm
mortgage
equalize
rates
interest
upon
farm
loans
furnish
market
bonds
create
government
depositaries
financial
agents
purposes
administration
act
placed
direction
control
federal
farm
loan
bureau
established
seat
government
treasury
department
general
supervision
federal
loan
board
consisting
secretary
treasury
four
members
appointed
president
advice
consent
senate
divided
districts
purpose
establishing
federal
land
banks
banks
must
subscribed
capital
less
divided
shares
may
subscribed
individual
firm
corporation
government
state
dividends
shall
paid
stock
owned
stock
shall
share
dividend
distributions
without
preference
federal
farm
loan
board
designate
five
directors
shall
temporarily
manage
affairs
federal
land
bank
shall
prepare
organization
certificate
approved
federal
farm
loan
board
filed
farm
loan
commissioner
shall
operate
create
bank
body
corporate
federal
farm
loan
board
required
open
books
subscription
capital
stock
federal
land
bank
within
days
thereafter
part
minimum
capitalization
bank
shall
remain
unsubscribed
made
duty
secretary
treasury
subscribe
balance
behalf
amendment
january
authorizes
secretary
treasury
purchase
bonds
issued
federal
land
banks
provides
temporary
organization
bank
shall
continued
long
farm
loan
bonds
shall
held
treasury
subscription
stock
bank
national
farm
loan
associations
shall
equal
amount
stock
held
government
conditions
complied
permanent
organization
take
management
bank
consisting
board
directors
composed
nine
members
three
shall
known
district
directors
shall
appointed
farm
loan
board
shall
represent
public
interest
six
known
local
directors
shall
chosen
representative
national
farm
loan
associations
federal
land
banks
empowered
invest
funds
purchase
qualified
first
mortgages
farm
lands
situated
within
federal
land
bank
district
within
organized
acting
loans
farm
mortgages
made
borrowers
organization
corporations
known
national
farm
loan
associations
persons
desiring
borrow
money
farm
mortgage
security
terms
act
ten
natural
persons
owners
become
owners
farm
land
qualified
security
mortgage
loans
desire
borrow
money
farm
mortgage
security
may
unite
form
national
farm
loan
association
manner
forming
associations
qualifications
membership
set
act
loan
desired
person
must
less
aggregate
desired
loans
less
application
loan
must
accompanied
subscriptions
stock
federal
land
bank
equal
aggregate
sum
desired
mortgage
loan
provision
made
appraisal
land
report
federal
farm
loan
board
persons
borrowers
farm
loan
mortgages
shall
members
shareholders
national
farm
loan
associations
shareholders
farm
loan
associations
made
individually
responsible
debts
association
extent
amount
stock
owned
respectively
addition
amount
paid
represented
shares
national
farm
loan
association
shall
desire
secure
member
loan
first
mortgage
federal
land
bank
district
must
subscribe
capital
stock
federal
land
bank
amount
per
cent
loan
capital
stock
shall
held
federal
land
bank
collateral
security
payment
loan
association
shall
paid
dividends
accruing
payable
capital
stock
outstanding
stock
may
discretion
directors
approval
federal
farm
loan
board
paid
par
retired
shall
retired
upon
full
payment
mortgage
loan
event
national
farm
loan
association
must
pay
par
retire
corresponding
shares
stock
issued
land
bank
stock
retired
issued
provided
capital
stock
land
bank
shall
reduced
less
per
cent
principal
outstanding
farm
loan
bonds
issued
shares
national
farm
loan
associations
shall
par
value
least
per
cent
part
capital
federal
land
bank
stock
outstanding
name
national
farm
loan
associations
must
held
quick
assets
less
per
cent
capital
must
invested
government
bonds
loans
federal
land
banks
may
make
upon
first
mortgages
farm
lands
provided
section
act
section
banks
empowered
subject
provisions
act
issue
sell
farm
loan
bonds
kind
described
act
invest
funds
possession
qualified
first
mortgages
farm
lands
receive
deposit
trust
farm
loan
registrar
held
collateral
security
farm
loan
bonds
first
mortgages
upon
farm
lands
approval
farm
loan
board
issue
sell
bonds
secured
deposit
first
mortgages
qualified
farm
lands
collateral
conformity
provisions
section
act
amendment
january
secretary
treasury
empowered
years
purchase
farm
loan
bonds
issued
federal
land
banks
amount
exceeding
year
federal
land
bank
authorized
time
repurchase
par
accrued
interest
purpose
redemption
resale
bonds
purchased
held
treasury
also
provided
bonds
federal
land
bank
purchased
held
treasury
one
year
termination
pending
war
shall
upon
days
notice
secretary
treasury
redeemed
repurchased
bank
par
accrued
interest
section
provided
whenever
act
shall
effect
one
year
shall
appear
federal
farm
loan
board
national
farm
loan
associations
formed
likely
formed
locality
peculiar
local
conditions
board
may
discretion
authorize
federal
land
banks
make
loans
farm
lands
agents
approved
board
terms
conditions
subject
restrictions
prescribed
section
act
also
authorizes
incorporation
land
banks
capital
provided
private
subscription
organized
less
natural
persons
subject
requirements
provisions
section
act
far
applicable
board
directors
shall
consist
less
five
members
shareholder
shall
voting
privileges
holders
shares
national
banking
associations
shall
held
individually
responsible
equally
ratably
one
another
contracts
debts
engagements
bank
extent
amount
stock
owned
par
value
thereof
addition
amount
paid
represented
shares
land
bank
authorized
business
capital
stock
amount
subscribed
paid
cash
balance
remaining
subject
call
board
directors
charter
issued
federal
farm
loan
board
bonds
shall
issued
capital
stock
entirely
paid
except
otherwise
provided
land
banks
shall
powers
subject
restrictions
conditions
imposed
federal
land
banks
act
far
conditions
restrictions
applicable
federal
land
banks
may
issue
farm
loan
bonds
times
capital
surplus
land
banks
limited
issue
farm
loan
bonds
excess
times
amount
capital
surplus
land
banks
loan
first
mortgages
upon
land
state
located
state
contiguous
thereto
loan
mortgage
may
made
bank
rate
exceeding
per
cent
per
annum
exclusive
amortization
payments
stock
land
banks
shall
case
charge
rate
interest
farm
loans
shall
exceed
per
cent
rate
extablished
last
series
farm
loan
bonds
issued
rate
shall
exceed
per
cent
per
annum
provisions
issue
farm
loan
bonds
secured
first
mortgages
farm
lands
bonds
collateral
made
federal
land
banks
land
banks
case
issue
made
subject
approval
federal
farm
loan
board
farm
loan
mortgages
bonds
constitute
collateral
security
bonds
must
deposited
farm
loan
registrar
section
act
provides
follows
every
federal
land
bank
every
national
farm
loan
association
including
capital
reserve
surplus
therein
income
derived
therefrom
shall
exempt
federal
state
municipal
local
taxation
except
taxes
upon
real
estate
held
purchased
taken
said
bank
association
provisions
section
eleven
section
thirteen
act
first
mortgages
executed
federal
land
banks
land
banks
farm
loan
bonds
issued
provisions
act
shall
deemed
held
instrumentalities
government
income
derived
therefrom
shall
exempt
federal
state
municipal
local
taxation
herein
shall
prevent
shares
land
bank
included
valuation
personal
property
owner
holder
shares
assessing
taxes
imposed
authority
state
within
bank
located
assessment
taxation
shall
manner
subject
conditions
limitations
contained
section
hundred
nineteen
revised
statutes
reference
shares
national
banking
associations
herein
shall
construed
exempt
real
property
federal
land
banks
national
farm
loan
associations
either
state
county
municipal
taxes
extent
according
value
real
property
taxed
since
decision
great
cases
mcculloch
maryland
wheat
osborn
bank
wheat
longer
open
question
congress
may
establish
banks
national
purposes
small
part
capital
held
government
majority
ownership
represented
shares
capital
stock
privately
owned
held
principal
business
banks
private
banking
conducted
usual
methods
business
express
power
create
bank
incorporate
one
found
constitution
speaking
chief
justice
marshall
mcculloch
maryland
found
authority
broad
general
powers
conferred
constitution
upon
congress
levy
collect
taxes
borrow
money
regulate
commerce
pay
public
debts
declare
conduct
war
raise
support
armies
provide
maintain
navy
etc
congress
held
authority
use
means
deemed
appropriate
exercise
great
powers
government
virtue
article
section
clause
constitution
granting
congress
right
make
laws
necessary
proper
make
grant
effectual
first
national
bank
union
trust
sup
ann
cas
chief
justice
speaking
reviewing
mcculloch
maryland
osborn
bank
considering
power
given
congress
pass
laws
make
specific
powers
granted
effectual
said
terms
pointed
broad
authority
stereotyped
particular
time
endured
thus
furnishing
perpetual
living
sanction
legislative
authority
within
limits
discretion
enabling
take
consideration
changing
wants
demands
society
adopt
provisions
appropriate
meet
every
situation
deemed
required
provided
formation
bank
required
judgment
congress
fiscal
operations
government
principal
consideration
upon
chief
justice
marshall
rested
authority
create
bank
purpose
appropriate
measure
judgment
congress
held
within
authority
question
conclusion
reached
legislative
branch
government
upon
authority
mcculloch
maryland
osborn
bank
national
banking
system
established
upon
rested
constitutionality
legislation
establishing
banks
farmers
mechanics
national
bank
dearing
congress
seen
fit
section
act
make
classes
banks
designated
purpose
secretary
treasury
depositaries
public
money
except
receipts
customs
regulations
prescribed
secretary
treasury
authorized
employment
financial
agents
government
banks
required
perform
reasonable
duties
depositaries
public
moneys
financial
agents
may
required
secretary
treasury
shall
require
federal
land
banks
land
banks
thus
designated
satisfactory
security
deposit
bonds
otherwise
prompt
payment
public
money
deposited
faithful
performance
duties
financial
agents
government
section
also
provides
government
funds
deposited
provisions
section
shall
invested
mortgage
loans
farm
loan
bonds
said
power
designate
banks
depositaries
exercised
government
federal
land
banks
acted
federal
agents
case
loans
money
seed
purposes
made
summer
already
referred
existence
power
constitution
determined
extent
exercise
authority
conferred
congress
declared
necessary
create
fiscal
agencies
make
authorized
depositaries
public
money
power
longer
open
question
urged
attempt
create
federal
agencies
make
banks
fiscal
agents
public
depositaries
government
pretext
nothing
better
settled
decisions
congress
acts
within
limits
constitutional
authority
province
judicial
branch
government
question
motives
veazie
bank
fenno
wall
mccray
sup
ann
cas
flint
sup
ann
cas
cases
cited
congress
seen
fit
making
banks
fiscal
agencies
depositaries
public
moneys
grant
banking
powers
limited
character
wise
detracts
authority
congress
use
governmental
purposes
named
sees
fit
bank
may
organized
without
authority
issue
currency
may
authorized
receive
deposits
limited
way
speaking
generally
bank
moneyed
institution
facilitate
borrowing
lending
caring
money
whether
technically
banks
organizations
may
serve
governmental
purposes
declared
congress
creation
furthermore
institutions
organized
serve
market
bonds
less
per
cent
capital
federal
land
banks
stock
outstanding
farm
loan
associations
required
invested
bonds
kinds
banks
empowered
buy
sell
bonds
first
national
bank
trust
sup
ann
cas
supra
sustained
power
congress
enable
national
bank
transact
business
considered
might
beyond
power
congress
authorize
case
held
within
authority
congress
permit
national
banks
exercise
permission
federal
reserve
board
contravention
local
law
office
trustee
executor
administrator
registrar
stocks
bonds
therefore
conclude
creation
banks
grant
authority
act
government
depositaries
public
moneys
purchasers
government
bonds
brings
within
creative
power
congress
although
may
intended
connection
privileges
duties
facilitate
making
loans
upon
farm
security
low
rates
interest
destroy
validity
enactments
general
banking
powers
destroyed
authority
congress
create
bank
authority
given
national
banks
carry
additional
activities
destroyed
authority
congress
create
institutions
brief
filed
upon
reargument
counsel
appellant
seem
admit
power
congress
appropriate
money
direct
purposes
named
brief
say
exemption
real
issue
sought
settled
deciding
institutions
created
congress
within
exercise
legitimate
authority
think
power
make
securities
involved
tax
exempt
necessarily
follows
principle
settled
mcculloch
maryland
osborn
bank
supra
federal
government
sees
fit
exempt
securities
taxation
seems
obvious
upon
clearest
principles
said
invasion
state
authority
extend
tax
exemption
restrain
power
state
similar
contention
made
mcculloch
maryland
chief
justice
marshall
uttered
often
quoted
statement
power
tax
involves
power
destroy
power
destroy
may
defeat
render
useless
power
create
plain
repugnance
conferring
one
government
power
control
constitutional
measures
another
respect
measures
declared
exerts
control
propositions
denied
wheat
principle
recognized
national
bank
cases
declaring
power
tax
property
franchises
national
banks
extent
authorized
laws
congress
owensboro
nat
bank
owensboro
sup
involved
validity
franchise
tax
kentucky
national
banks
case
declared
sup
ed
wholly
without
power
levy
tax
directly
indirectly
upon
national
banks
property
assets
franchises
except
far
permissive
legislation
congress
allowed
taxation
declared
right
granted
tax
real
estate
banks
shares
names
shareholders
constituted
extent
permission
given
congress
tax
beyond
declared
void
farmers
bank
minnesota
sup
held
state
may
tax
bonds
issued
municipality
territory
tax
bonds
property
hands
holder
last
analysis
imposition
upon
right
municipality
issue
exercise
taxing
power
might
used
hamper
destroy
exercise
authority
conferred
congress
justifies
exemption
tax
bonds
may
destroy
means
provided
obtaining
necessary
funds
future
operation
banks
wisdom
policy
legislation
nothing
function
ascertaining
whether
congress
creation
banks
exempting
securities
taxation
federal
state
acted
within
limits
constitutional
authority
reasons
stated
think
contention
government
appellees
banks
constitutionally
organized
securities
involved
legally
exempted
taxation
must
sustained
follows
decree
district
affirmed
justice
brandeis
took
part
consideration
decision
case
justice
holmes
dissenting
doubt
desirable
question
raised
case
set
rest
done
courts
within
limits
jurisdiction
conferred
upon
constitution
laws
suit
brought
citizen
missouri
missouri
corporation
single
ground
upon
jurisdiction
district
maintained
suit
constitution
laws
within
meaning
section
judicial
code
opinion
case
arise
way
therefore
bill
dismissed
evident
cause
action
arises
law
wholly
missouri
law
defendant
missouri
corporation
right
claimed
stockholder
prevent
directors
act
making
investment
alleged
contrary
duty
scope
duty
depends
upon
charter
corporation
laws
missouri
laws
authorized
investment
terms
plaintiff
case
seems
make
manifest
unable
deem
even
debatable
said
cause
action
arises
wholly
missouri
law
missouri
law
authorizes
forbids
investment
according
determination
upon
point
constitution
acts
congress
still
point
material
missouri
law
saw
fit
make
whole
foundation
duty
missouri
law
sole
incorporated
law
might
incorporate
document
law
document
depends
relevance
effect
force
upon
law
took
repeat
cause
action
arises
wholly
law
state
seems
suit
said
arise
law
creates
cause
action
may
enough
law
relied
upon
creates
part
cause
action
although
whole
held
osborn
bank
wheat
perhaps
meant
less
guarded
expressions
cohens
virginia
wheat
content
assume
although
osborn
case
criticized
regretted
law
must
create
least
part
cause
action
force
suit
question
suit
must
arise
law
mere
adoption
state
law
law
criterion
test
law
force
proprio
vigore
cause
case
state
law
also
case
law
decided
miller
swann
sup
louisville
nashville
western
union
telegraph
sup
see
also
shoshone
mining
rutter
sup
find
nothing
contrary
views
brushaber
union
pacific
sup
ann
cas
seems
plain
objection
considering
mind
subject
observations
open
confirmed
view
case
fact
next
volume
reports
decision
reached
without
discussion
single
dissent
suit
arises
law
creates
cause
action
ratio
decidendi
american
wells
works
layne
bowler
sup
know
decisions
contrary
see
reason
overruling
justice
mcreynolds
concurs
dissent
view
opinion
jurisdiction
express
judgment
merits