chemical
foundation
argued
decided
october
attorney
general
henry
anderson
richmond
herman
galloway
asst
atty
john
davis
new
york
city
william
mahaffy
wilmington
moorfield
storey
boston
appellee
justice
butler
delivered
opinion
suit
brought
district
delaware
set
aside
sales
made
chemical
foundation
number
patents
copyrights
trademarks
similar
brevity
referred
pursuant
trading
enemy
act
october
stat
amended
act
march
stat
act
november
stat
acts
comp
et
complaint
alleges
number
domestic
manufacturers
result
war
conditions
able
combine
monopolize
certain
chemical
industries
country
fearing
end
war
german
competition
destroy
monopoly
conspired
bring
transfers
sales
patents
nominal
prices
corporation
controlled
patents
obtained
control
industries
question
perpetuate
monopoly
sales
procured
fraudulent
deception
president
alien
property
custodian
cials
answer
denies
conspiracy
fraud
asserts
transfers
made
good
faith
pursuant
law
valid
trial
much
evidence
taken
district
dismissed
complaint
decree
affirmed
circuit
appeals
courts
found
unlawful
scheme
combination
conspiracy
shown
deception
fraud
took
appeal
section
judicial
code
comp
applied
writ
certiorari
section
comp
decree
circuit
appeals
entered
march
prior
taking
effect
act
february
amending
judicial
code
chapter
stat
comp
st
since
case
decree
made
final
section
right
appeal
application
certiorari
therefore
denied
chemical
industries
question
closely
related
production
explosives
gasses
things
directly
used
waging
war
well
production
dyestuffs
medicines
essential
welfare
people
outbreak
war
many
necessary
medicines
substances
well
dyestuffs
used
country
imported
germany
manufactured
patents
owned
enemy
germans
amount
things
produced
small
importations
hindered
blockade
ceased
country
entered
war
meet
demand
numerous
plants
developed
chemicals
dyestuffs
medicines
like
produced
large
quantities
number
associations
manufacturers
formed
advancement
industries
included
membership
producers
nearly
dyestuffs
like
chemicals
made
country
mitchell
palmer
alien
property
custodian
appointed
attorney
general
march
order
protect
enemy
foreign
control
chemical
industries
stimulate
production
favored
seizure
sale
patents
question
end
number
conferences
held
representatives
industries
plan
carried
effect
formulated
direction
february
chemical
foundation
incorporated
laws
delaware
certificate
incorporation
discloses
created
empowered
purchase
patents
seized
custodian
hold
rights
acquired
fiduciary
capacity
americanization
industries
may
affected
thereby
exclusion
elimination
alien
interest
hostile
detrimental
said
industries
advancement
chemical
allied
science
industry
grant
nonexclusive
licenses
make
use
sell
inventions
covered
patents
also
grant
like
licenses
equal
terms
without
advantage
licensees
american
citizens
corporations
control
american
citizens
board
directors
authorized
prescribe
terms
conditions
licenses
may
refuse
issue
license
may
revoke
license
granted
corporation
required
enforce
rights
protect
rights
licensees
authorized
capital
stock
consisting
shares
par
value
shares
constitute
nonvoting
preferred
stock
holders
entitled
cumulative
dividend
per
centum
per
annum
shares
constitute
common
stock
holders
entitled
dividends
exceeding
per
centum
per
annum
dividends
preferred
stock
provided
preferred
stock
subject
redemption
par
plus
accumulated
dividends
redemption
net
earnings
needed
working
capital
used
devoted
development
advancement
chemistry
allied
sciences
useful
arts
manufactures
manner
board
directors
may
determine
holders
common
stock
voting
power
certificate
provides
without
approval
board
directors
stockholders
may
sell
stock
board
directors
consists
three
members
executive
officers
president
vice
president
secretary
treasurer
president
vice
president
required
serve
without
pay
shares
foundation
subscribed
interested
chemical
dye
industries
voting
trust
agreement
made
pursuant
common
stock
deposited
voting
power
vested
five
trustees
directors
officers
chosen
march
francis
garvan
douglas
mckay
george
corbett
made
directors
constituted
board
garvan
alien
property
custodian
elected
president
mckay
elected
vice
president
corbett
secretary
treasurer
otto
bannard
four
others
made
voting
trustees
directors
officers
voting
trustees
chosen
accordance
direction
palmer
given
custodian
president
executive
order
december
declared
hereby
vest
frank
polk
power
authority
conferred
upon
president
provisions
section
trading
enemy
act
amended
comp
ff
polk
counselor
department
state
described
order
made
two
orders
dated
respectively
february
april
authorize
custodian
sell
private
sale
foundation
without
advertisement
places
upon
terms
conditions
custodian
might
seem
proper
patents
found
relate
objects
purposes
foundation
expressed
charter
orders
contained
statement
reasons
therefor
public
interest
briefly
patents
sold
best
advantage
public
sale
advertisement
foundation
incorporated
hold
patents
trustee
american
industries
affected
patents
eliminate
hostile
alien
interests
advance
chemical
allied
industry
obligated
grant
nonexclusive
licenses
upon
equal
terms
qualified
american
manufacturers
empowered
grant
free
licenses
public
interest
best
served
wide
use
inventions
readily
promoted
licenses
foundation
obligated
grant
private
sale
prevent
patents
falling
hands
purchasers
unwilling
unable
use
inventions
use
speculative
purposes
impossible
make
public
sale
secure
benefits
private
sale
avoid
unnecessary
expense
delay
inconvenience
prior
contemporaneously
organization
foundation
representatives
chemical
industries
custodian
making
lists
patents
seized
sold
custodian
foundation
garvan
custodian
time
time
commencing
april
executed
delivered
foundation
various
assignments
patents
considerations
paid
foundation
custodian
amounted
president
february
made
executive
order
held
courts
constitute
ratification
transactions
pursuant
order
custodian
confirmed
assignments
theretofore
made
come
question
whether
held
act
amended
march
empowered
president
authorize
custodian
supervision
consummate
sales
pertinent
provisions
act
section
amended
alien
property
custodian
shall
vested
powers
trustee
respect
property
money
shall
shall
required
conveyed
transferred
assigned
delivered
paid
pursuance
provisions
act
addition
thereto
acting
supervision
direction
president
rules
regulations
president
shall
prescribe
shall
power
manage
property
act
things
respect
thereof
make
disposition
thereof
part
thereof
sale
otherwise
exercise
rights
powers
may
become
appurtenant
thereto
ownership
thereof
like
manner
though
absolute
owner
thereof
provided
property
sold
act
except
sold
shall
sold
american
citizens
public
sale
highest
bidder
public
advertisement
time
place
sale
shall
property
major
portion
thereof
situated
unless
president
stating
reasons
therefor
public
interest
shall
otherwise
determine
stat
end
war
claim
enemy
ally
enemy
money
property
received
held
alien
property
custodian
deposited
treasury
shall
settled
congress
shall
direct
stat
conceded
seized
patents
belonged
enemy
germans
lawfully
taken
custodian
purpose
trading
enemy
act
weaken
enemy
countries
depriving
supporters
properties
miller
robertson
also
promote
production
things
useful
effective
prosecution
war
section
authorized
president
deemed
public
welfare
grant
licenses
american
citizens
corporations
use
inventions
covered
patents
subsection
section
act
amended
november
comp
authorized
seizure
patents
provided
property
acquired
held
disposed
provided
act
ground
contending
seizure
transfers
tend
lessen
enemy
strength
encourage
safeguard
domestic
production
things
essential
useful
prosecution
war
nothing
support
strict
construction
act
respect
seizure
disposition
enemy
property
hand
contemporaneous
conditions
war
legislation
indicate
purpose
employ
legitimate
means
effectively
prosecute
war
law
liberally
construed
give
effect
purposes
enacted
subserve
originally
enacted
section
gave
custodian
respect
properties
possession
powers
trustee
authorized
acting
supervision
direction
president
rules
regulations
prescribed
president
manage
property
act
things
respect
thereof
make
disposition
sale
otherwise
exercise
rights
appurtenant
ownership
necessary
prevent
waste
protect
property
end
interests
property
rights
person
may
ultimately
become
entitled
thereto
proceeds
thereof
may
preserved
safeguarded
custodian
mere
conservator
authorized
sell
prevent
waste
brief
experience
made
clear
restriction
power
dispose
enemy
property
sometimes
operated
defeat
purpose
act
brought
profit
advantage
enemy
amendment
march
eliminated
restriction
upon
power
sale
stated
powers
given
addition
trustee
authorized
custodian
president
dispose
properties
sale
otherwise
like
manner
though
absolute
owner
thereof
support
construction
restrain
force
broad
language
used
congress
untrammeled
free
authorize
seizure
use
appropriation
properties
without
compensation
owners
constitutional
prohibition
confiscation
enemy
properties
brown
cranch
miller
wall
et
seq
kirk
lynd
stoehr
wallace
white
mechanics
securities
act
makes
provision
compensation
former
enemy
owners
claim
patents
proceeds
derived
sales
makes
difference
whether
consideration
paid
foundation
adequate
inadequate
provision
war
enemy
claims
shall
settled
congress
shall
direct
conferred
rights
upon
owners
moreover
treaty
berlin
prevents
enforcement
claim
germany
nationals
nationals
account
seizures
sales
question
denying
power
confiscate
enemy
properties
argues
construed
provision
question
unconstitutional
attempts
delegate
legislative
power
executive
act
gave
custodian
acting
president
full
power
disposition
restriction
put
upon
dispositions
sales
sales
regulated
general
rule
laid
dispositions
sale
otherwise
made
accordance
determinations
president
proviso
made
exception
including
class
sales
upon
failure
president
otherwise
determine
stating
reasons
therefore
public
interest
required
sales
made
specified
necessary
congress
ascertain
facts
deal
case
act
went
far
reasonably
practicable
circumstances
existing
peculiarly
within
province
know
facts
determine
disposition
made
enemy
properties
order
effectively
carry
war
determination
terms
sales
enemy
properties
light
facts
conditions
time
time
arising
progress
war
making
law
application
general
rule
laid
act
plenary
power
congress
general
rule
established
regarded
manifest
limitation
upon
excepted
class
delegation
legislative
power
field
clark
buttfield
stranahan
union
bridge
grimaud
language
statute
plain
misunderstood
except
affected
proviso
custodian
dominion
property
power
dispose
president
unlimited
powers
absolute
owner
power
president
determine
terms
conditions
sales
disposition
restricted
authorized
stating
reasons
therefor
public
interest
dispense
requirements
specified
proviso
substitute
others
cf
levinson
amended
section
read
comparison
original
enactment
regard
chemical
warfare
conditions
existing
time
amendment
march
inevitable
conclusion
empowered
president
authorize
custodian
acting
consummate
sales
question
argues
executive
order
december
void
one
february
authorize
ratify
transactions
section
act
provides
president
may
exercise
power
authority
conferred
act
officer
officers
shall
direct
comp
language
executive
order
hereby
vest
frank
polk
power
authority
conferred
upon
president
provisions
section
obviously
functions
great
office
exercised
president
person
contention
power
determine
enemy
property
sold
delegated
another
sustained
occasion
consider
like
question
certral
trust
garvan
stoehr
wallace
supra
commercial
trust
miller
decisions
sustain
delegation
involved
argued
order
made
conformity
statute
power
another
order
show
polk
officer
two
constructions
possible
one
render
order
useless
give
validity
latter
adopted
cf
panama
johnson
coombs
pet
intention
exert
power
conferred
section
plain
meticulous
precision
language
necessary
russell
use
word
accurate
must
deemed
sufficient
context
circumstances
considered
polk
officer
president
authorized
act
counselor
department
state
appointed
president
confirmed
senate
germaine
particular
form
designation
required
unreasonable
read
order
otherwise
meaning
respect
matters
covered
section
president
determined
act
frank
polk
counselor
department
state
validity
orders
made
polk
attacked
ground
broad
constituted
attempt
give
custodian
power
granted
president
act
power
determine
enemy
properties
disposed
otherwise
specified
proviso
contention
prevail
orders
sufficiently
described
patents
seized
authorized
private
sale
foundation
without
advertisement
enough
indicate
determination
take
sales
class
covered
proviso
insisted
orders
induced
misrepresentation
made
without
knowledge
material
facts
courts
found
failed
establish
conspiracy
fraud
deception
alleged
findings
fact
concurred
two
lower
courts
disturbed
unless
clearly
erroneous
washington
sec
rule
findings
must
accepted
presumption
regularity
supports
official
acts
public
officers
absence
clear
evidence
contrary
courts
presume
properly
discharged
official
duties
confiscation
cases
wall
page
nix
presumption
taken
polk
acted
upon
knowledge
material
facts
validity
reasons
stated
orders
basis
fact
rest
reviewed
courts
dakota
cent
tel
south
dakota
monongahela
bridge
martin
mott
wheat
cf
levinson
supra
agree
lower
courts
sales
transfers
patents
ratified
confirmed
president
order
february
urged
ratification
shown
president
knowledge
material
facts
intend
ratify
sales
patents
language
used
order
broad
enough
include
patents
copyrights
question
polk
order
february
described
property
covered
letters
patent
rights
letters
patent
including
profits
damages
past
infringement
thereof
alien
property
custodian
may
seize
may
seized
time
time
shall
determine
relate
objects
purposes
chemical
foundation
president
order
confirmation
recites
polk
orders
authorized
custodian
sell
choses
action
rights
interests
benefits
heretofore
determined
belong
held
account
benefit
persons
heretofore
determined
enemies
language
last
quoted
used
define
properties
covered
polk
orders
action
rights
used
include
patent
etc
president
order
also
intention
polk
orders
authorize
custodian
sell
choses
action
rights
interests
benefits
agreements
rights
claims
every
character
description
including
rights
receive
moneys
way
royalties
otherwise
compensation
use
patents
alien
property
custodian
may
seized
determined
relate
objects
purposes
foundation
recites
doubt
arisen
authority
custodian
sell
convey
foundation
said
choses
action
rights
receive
moneys
way
royalties
otherwise
president
expressly
authorized
custodian
sell
private
sale
without
public
advertisement
foundation
upon
terms
conditions
custodian
might
seem
proper
choses
action
rights
interests
benefits
agreements
rights
claims
every
character
description
alien
property
custodian
may
seize
may
seized
act
president
authorized
custodian
suitable
instrument
conform
ratify
sales
theretofore
made
property
authority
polk
orders
might
deemed
doubtful
stated
reasons
determination
order
given
polk
orders
addition
specified
reasons
need
quoted
order
authorizes
sales
patents
made
ratifies
confirms
theretofore
made
custodian
president
presumed
known
material
facts
acted
light
intention
ratify
sales
plain
comprehensive
language
used
broad
enough
include
patents
moreover
statement
reasons
determination
given
polk
orders
shows
intention
cover
properties
referred
transactions
question
ratified
unnecessary
consider
objections
made
procedure
custodian
polk
orders
contends
sales
void
made
violation
section
criminal
code
stat
comp
rule
law
forbidding
sales
public
officer
fiduciary
trust
property
custody
corporation
head
section
provides
officer
agent
corporation
person
directly
indirectly
interested
pecuniary
profits
contracts
corporation
shall
employed
shall
act
officer
agent
transaction
business
corporation
violators
made
punishable
fine
imprisonment
lays
much
stress
facts
garvan
director
bureau
investigation
joseph
choate
chief
chemical
division
bureau
ramsey
hoguet
patent
attorney
custodian
conferred
representatives
chemical
industries
arrange
make
seizures
sales
patents
later
garvan
custodian
acted
making
transfers
chemical
foundation
president
mckay
corbett
directors
officers
appointed
custodian
various
corporations
taken
control
transfers
made
choate
became
general
counsel
hoguet
patent
attorney
foundation
bannard
voting
trustees
members
advisory
sales
president
see
sales
enemy
properties
fairly
made
qualified
buyers
without
reference
facts
relied
port
contention
assume
favor
acted
transactions
complained
time
directors
officers
corporation
members
advisory
sales
committee
voting
trustees
participated
fixing
prices
paid
patents
foundation
prices
much
less
value
properties
inadequate
constitute
compensation
patents
belonged
nonenemy
owners
taken
public
use
power
eminent
domain
section
enacted
war
long
trading
enemy
act
lays
general
rule
protection
transactions
corporations
prevent
action
influenced
one
interested
adversely
penal
statute
extended
cases
clearly
within
terms
exceptional
spirit
purpose
noveck
baender
barnett
hawaii
mankichi
kirby
wall
bishop
statutory
crimes
ed
time
enactment
enemy
properties
dealt
save
generality
language
used
nothing
indicate
legislative
purpose
deal
subject
trading
enemy
act
war
measure
covering
specifically
fully
exclusively
seizure
disposition
enemy
properties
authority
president
authorize
sales
determine
terms
conditions
lieu
specified
proviso
undoubtedly
included
power
cause
chemical
foundation
incorporated
purchase
hold
patents
specified
direct
selection
directors
officers
voting
trustees
president
custodian
acting
seller
patents
caused
foundation
created
buy
hold
caused
controlled
officers
representatives
acting
exclusively
interest
neither
garvan
others
acted
financial
interest
foundation
profits
contracts
corporate
shares
subscribed
paid
interested
chemical
industries
furnished
money
carry
plan
formulated
direction
palmer
custodian
voting
trust
agreement
shareholders
divested
voice
control
business
affairs
corporation
shares
held
voting
trustee
years
within
patents
expire
charter
provisions
dividends
limited
per
centum
per
annum
transferable
certificates
beneficial
interest
issued
trustees
shareholders
used
control
corporation
arrangement
intended
amount
public
trust
patents
benefit
promotion
american
industries
give
right
equal
reasonable
terms
licenses
make
use
sell
inventions
covered
patents
foundation
properly
considered
instrumentality
created
direction
president
effect
disposition
subsequent
control
patents
determined
public
interest
transactions
complained
involve
evils
aimed
section
act
construed
applied
qualified
affected
provision
criminal
code
utah
power
light
kepner
ann
cas
townsend
little
rouse
hazard
power
dispose
properties
sales
terms
conditions
specified
included
grant
made
statute
follows
rule
respect
sales
trust
properties
fiduciaries
apply
commencement
trial
district
found
necessary
testimony
taken
shorthand
transcribed
appointed
official
stenographer
purpose
ordered
fees
ultimately
taxed
part
costs
another
order
counsel
consenting
directed
expense
printing
copies
transcript
available
use
appeal
advanced
time
time
borne
equal
amounts
parties
form
part
taxable
costs
decree
directs
chemical
foundation
recover
money
advanced
foundation
account
fees
expenses
orders
amount
taxed
costs
case
government
insists
erroneous
general
rule
absence
statute
directly
authorizing
courts
give
judgment
costs
expenses
hooe
cranch
shewan
sons
davis
et
foundation
insists
equity
rule
taken
consent
counsel
orders
authorized
direct
items
taxed
costs
give
judgment
therefor
equity
rule
general
terms
provides
stenographers
fees
shall
fixed
taxed
costs
specify
costs
judgment
money
rule
mention
affect
sovereign
prerogative
pay
costs
congress
alone
power
waive
qualify
immunity
statute
izes
giving
judgment
items
authorizes
attorney
general
counsel
case
consent
judgment
authority
necessary
proper
conduct
litigation
behalf
ground
implying
authority
follows
direction
judgment
costs
sustained
part
decree
eliminated
decree
modified
affirmed
decree
modified
affirmed
modified
justice
sutherland
justice
stone
took
part
consideration
decision
case
footnotes
part
section
iv
article
annex
paragraphs
treaty
versailles
adopted
article
ii
treaty
berlin
stat