harrison
ppg
industries
argued
january
decided
may
authorized
clean
air
act
act
environmental
protection
agency
epa
decided
basis
correspondence
respondents
certain
equipment
power
generating
facility
respondent
ppg
industries
ppg
subject
certain
new
source
performance
standards
regarding
air
pollution
promulgated
epa
administrator
ppg
filed
petition
appeals
review
epa
decision
act
provides
direct
review
federal
appeals
certain
locally
regionally
applicable
actions
taken
administrator
specifically
enumerated
provisions
act
final
action
administrator
act
locally
regionally
applicable
uncertainty
proper
forum
judicial
review
ppg
also
filed
suit
injunctive
relief
administrator
federal
district
suit
stayed
pending
disposition
present
case
appeals
dismissed
ppg
petition
lack
jurisdiction
held
phrase
final
action
construed
accordance
literal
meaning
reach
action
administrator
final
final
actions
administrator
similar
actions
specifically
enumerated
provisions
precede
catchall
phrase
statute
pp
rule
ejusdem
generis
apply
limit
final
action
actions
similar
specifically
enumerated
provisions
theory
latter
actions
unlike
administrator
informal
decision
must
based
administrative
proceedings
reflecting
least
notice
opportunity
hearing
least
one
specifically
enumerated
provisions
require
administrator
act
notice
opportunity
hearing
thus
even
rule
ejusdem
generis
applied
significantly
narrow
ambit
final
action
moreover
rule
ejusdem
generis
instrumentality
ascertaining
correct
meaning
words
uncertainty
phrase
final
action
offers
indication
whatever
congress
intended
limiting
construction
pp
nothing
legislative
history
supports
conclusion
phrase
final
action
means
anything
says
congress
intend
phrase
enlarge
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
include
review
cases
based
administrative
record
reflecting
less
notice
opportunity
hearing
pp
argument
matter
policy
basic
purpose
provide
prompt
review
epa
action
better
served
providing
cases
review
district
rather
appeals
argument
addressed
congress
pp
stewart
delivered
opinion
burger
brennan
white
marshall
powell
joined
powell
filed
concurring
opinion
post
blackmun
filed
opinion
concurring
result
post
rehnquist
post
stevens
post
filed
dissenting
opinions
maryann
walsh
argued
cause
petitioners
briefs
solicitor
general
mccree
assistant
attorney
general
moorman
william
alsup
jacques
gelin
michele
corash
charles
lettow
argued
cause
respondents
brief
peter
wynne
oliver
stockwell
gene
lafitte
justice
stewart
delivered
opinion
section
clean
air
act
act
provides
direct
review
federal
appeals
certain
locally
regionally
applicable
actions
taken
administrator
environmental
protection
agency
epa
specifically
enumerated
provisions
act
final
action
administrator
act
locally
regionally
applicable
emphasis
added
issue
case
whether
appeals
fifth
circuit
correct
concluding
without
jurisdiction
entertain
petition
review
ppg
industries
ppg
conoco
conoco
respondents
challenged
decision
administrator
concerning
applicability
epa
new
source
performance
standards
power
generating
facility
operated
ppg
specifically
must
decide
whether
administrator
decision
falls
within
ambit
final
action
reviewable
appeals
dispute
underlying
jurisdictional
question
involves
decision
administrator
act
supp
ii
provision
requires
administrator
publish
time
time
revise
list
categories
stationary
source
determines
causes
contributes
significantly
air
pollution
may
reasonably
anticipated
endanger
public
health
welfare
promulgate
regulations
establishing
standards
performance
new
sources
within
list
categories
act
defines
new
source
stationary
source
construction
modification
commenced
publication
regulations
earlier
proposed
regulations
prescribing
standard
performance
section
applicable
source
administrator
included
fossil
steam
generators
list
stationary
sources
fed
reg
later
year
pursuant
mandate
promulgate
new
source
performance
standards
administrator
established
certain
emission
limits
fossil
steam
generating
unit
million
btu
per
hour
heat
input
construction
modification
commenced
august
date
standards
proposed
cfr
new
source
regulations
define
term
fossil
steam
generating
unit
also
create
procedure
administrator
upon
request
determine
whether
action
taken
planned
owner
operator
facility
constitutes
constitute
construction
modification
facility
purposes
triggering
applicability
performance
standards
sometime
respondent
ppg
chemical
manufacturing
corporation
began
planning
preliminary
construction
new
power
generating
facility
plant
lake
charles
la
facility
designed
take
advantage
cogeneration
technology
consist
two
gas
turbine
generators
two
boilers
turbogenerator
dispute
epa
ppg
concerns
applicability
new
source
performance
standards
boilers
facility
controversy
first
arose
respondent
conoco
ppg
fuel
supplier
informed
epa
conoco
switching
supply
fuel
lake
charles
facility
natural
gas
fuel
oil
exchange
correspondence
ensued
initiated
epa
request
ppg
submit
additional
information
bearing
whether
boilers
covered
new
source
standards
ppg
submissions
revealed
although
assembly
boilers
begun
new
power
facility
boilers
integral
component
originally
designed
partially
ordered
year
proposed
date
new
source
performance
standards
basis
ppg
submissions
regional
director
enforcement
epa
notified
ppg
conclusion
boilers
subject
new
source
standards
since
construction
boilers
begun
long
january
date
standards
proposed
response
ppg
took
position
boilers
part
integrated
unit
construction
begun
proposed
date
standards
regional
director
nevertheless
reaffirmed
initial
decision
pursuant
procedure
outlined
new
source
regulations
cfr
ppg
submitted
formal
request
epa
determination
new
source
standards
fossil
steam
generators
apply
type
boilers
question
event
since
construction
facility
boilers
part
began
date
standards
proposed
boilers
new
sources
thus
subject
performance
standards
event
epa
determined
ppg
boilers
subject
standards
ppg
also
requested
clarification
standards
apply
responding
ppg
request
regional
administrator
notified
ppg
letter
concluded
boilers
indeed
subject
new
source
standards
fossil
steam
generators
rejected
ppg
argument
construction
boilers
begun
construction
facets
lake
charles
facility
thus
regional
administrator
affirmed
previous
epa
determination
boilers
subject
new
source
performance
standards
regard
manner
standards
apply
boilers
regional
administrator
indicated
since
ppg
gas
turbine
generators
subject
new
source
standards
ppg
held
accountable
emissions
boilers
attributable
combustion
fossil
fuel
emissions
attributable
waste
heat
gas
turbine
generators
ppg
filed
petition
appeals
fifth
circuit
seeking
review
epa
decision
concerning
applicability
new
source
standards
boilers
uncertainty
regarding
proper
forum
judicial
review
ppg
also
filed
complaint
injunctive
relief
administrator
district
western
district
louisiana
suit
stayed
pending
disposition
present
case
ppg
uncertainty
issue
case
stem
conflicting
views
proper
interpretation
act
supp
ii
provided
exclusive
review
appropriate
appeals
certain
locally
regionally
applicable
actions
administrator
several
specifically
enumerated
provisions
act
actions
administrator
provisions
specifically
enumerated
reviewable
district
jurisdiction
congress
expanded
ambit
clean
air
act
amendments
pub
stat
added
list
locally
regionally
applicable
actions
reviewable
exclusively
appropriate
appeals
actions
administrator
another
specifically
enumerated
provision
act
final
action
administrator
act
locally
regionally
applicable
emphasis
added
later
enacting
clean
air
act
technical
conforming
amendments
pub
stat
congress
added
several
provisions
listed
locally
regionally
applicable
action
administrator
reviewable
appropriate
appeals
amended
ppg
filed
petition
review
appeals
fifth
circuit
despite
filed
petition
ppg
conoco
intervenor
argued
without
jurisdiction
since
administrator
decision
action
taken
one
provisions
specifically
enumerated
properly
characterized
final
action
administrator
latter
phrase
argued
referred
locally
regionally
applicable
final
actions
provisions
act
specifically
enumerated
response
epa
argued
phrase
final
action
read
literally
mean
final
action
administrator
appeals
concluded
administrator
decision
fall
within
meaning
final
action
view
congress
intended
cast
entire
responsibility
reviewing
epa
action
act
courts
appeals
numeration
specific
sections
appear
redundant
revealing
aspect
legislative
history
thought
complete
absence
discussion
massive
shift
jurisdiction
moreover
found
unlikely
congress
intended
shift
jurisdiction
require
courts
appeals
review
decisions
administrator
simply
applied
interpreted
regulations
case
decision
noted
often
based
skeletal
record
may
leave
reviewing
unable
perform
meaningful
judicial
review
since
appellate
augment
record
especially
compared
trial
tools
discovery
available
concluded
hatever
addition
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
congress
may
contemplated
adding
final
action
language
assume
section
drafted
mechanical
limitations
courts
appeals
mind
accordingly
appeals
dismissed
ppg
petition
lack
jurisdiction
granted
certiorari
importance
determining
locus
judicial
review
actions
epa
ii
undisputed
administrator
decision
concerning
applicability
new
source
performance
standards
ppg
boilers
locally
applicable
action
provision
act
specifically
enumerated
question
issue
whether
administrator
decision
falls
within
scope
phrase
final
action
administrator
make
decision
reviewable
federal
appeals
outset
note
parties
agreement
administrator
decision
final
action
term
understood
context
administrative
procedure
act
provisions
federal
law
undisputed
administrator
ruling
represented
epa
final
determination
concerning
applicability
new
source
standards
ppg
power
facility
short
enforcement
action
epa
rendered
last
word
matter
controversy
thus
whether
administrator
decision
final
rather
whether
final
action
within
meaning
amended
petitioners
argue
phrase
final
action
construed
accordance
literal
meaning
reach
action
administrator
act
final
taken
specifically
enumerated
provision
respondents
argue
statutory
language
construed
narrowly
relying
familiar
doctrine
ejusdem
generis
assert
phrase
final
action
read
reach
final
actions
administrator
rather
similar
actions
specifically
enumerated
provisions
precede
catchall
phrase
statute
similarity
respondents
discern
among
actions
specifically
enumerated
provisions
actions
must
based
respondents
refer
contemporaneously
compiled
administrative
record
mean
record
based
administrative
proceedings
reflecting
least
notice
opportunity
hearing
since
administrator
informal
decision
case
based
record
respondents
argue
decision
final
action
within
meaning
thus
within
jurisdiction
appeals
respondents
reliance
rule
ejusdem
generis
think
misplaced
two
respects
rule
ejusdem
generis
general
words
follow
enumeration
specific
items
general
words
read
applying
items
akin
specifically
enumerated
applying
rule
respondents
argue
final
action
must
refer
final
actions
based
administrative
record
reflecting
least
notice
opportunity
hearing
flaw
argument
least
one
specifically
enumerated
provisions
namely
act
supp
ii
require
administrator
act
notice
opportunity
hearing
fact
respondents
recognize
action
administrator
based
administrative
record
unlike
involved
case
thus
even
rule
ejusdem
generis
applied
significantly
narrow
ambit
final
action
second
problem
respondents
reliance
rule
ejusdem
generis
fundamental
often
noted
rule
ejusdem
generis
firmly
established
instrumentality
ascertaining
correct
meaning
words
uncertainty
powell
quoting
gooch
regard
discern
uncertainty
meaning
phrase
final
action
congress
amended
provision
expanded
ambit
include
simply
final
action
rather
final
action
expansive
language
offers
indication
whatever
congress
intended
limiting
construction
respondents
urge
accordingly
think
inappropriate
apply
rule
ejusdem
generis
construing
rather
agree
petitioners
phrase
final
action
absence
legislative
history
contrary
must
construed
mean
exactly
says
namely
final
action
found
nothing
legislative
history
support
conclusion
phrase
final
action
means
anything
says
congress
added
language
final
action
clean
air
act
amendments
phrase
first
appeared
sess
bill
reported
house
committee
interstate
foreign
commerce
expanded
jurisdiction
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
include
review
certain
epa
actions
nationwide
consequences
specifically
enumerated
provisions
act
also
nationally
applicable
regulations
promulgated
final
action
taken
administrator
act
parallel
fashion
bill
expanded
jurisdiction
regional
courts
appeals
include
review
certain
local
regional
actions
specifically
enumerated
provisions
also
final
action
administrator
act
locally
regionally
applicable
emphasis
added
extended
discussion
proposed
amendment
contained
committee
report
accompanying
pp
discussion
however
focused
jurisdictional
question
issue
rather
proper
venue
district
columbia
circuit
federal
circuits
committee
report
described
proposed
amendments
intended
clarify
questions
relating
venue
review
rules
orders
regard
committee
report
explained
proposed
addition
first
sentence
makes
clear
nationally
applicable
regulations
promulgated
administrator
clean
air
act
reviewed
appeals
district
columbia
proposed
addition
second
sentence
provides
essentially
locally
statewide
regionally
applicable
rules
orders
reviewed
appeals
circuit
locality
state
region
located
ibid
respondents
infer
scant
legislative
history
congress
never
intended
addition
phrase
final
action
enlarge
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
include
review
cases
based
administrative
record
reflecting
less
notice
opportunity
hearing
insofar
respondents
rely
committee
said
report
fail
see
committee
observations
venue
bearing
jurisdictional
issue
moreover
since
administrative
conference
proposed
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
expanded
include
final
action
fact
committee
expressly
disclaimed
endorsement
recommendations
administrative
conference
matters
venue
appear
wholly
irrelevant
respondents
also
rely
committee
congress
say
amendments
unlikely
respondents
assert
congress
expanded
radically
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
divested
district
courts
jurisdiction
without
consideration
discussion
matter
accept
argument
first
although
number
actions
comprehended
literal
interpretation
final
action
doubt
substantial
number
appear
large
ineluctably
provoked
comment
congress
secondly
strange
canon
statutory
construction
require
congress
state
committee
reports
elsewhere
deliberations
obvious
face
statute
ascertaining
meaning
statute
manner
sherlock
holmes
pursue
theory
dog
bark
respondents
finally
argue
matter
policy
basic
purpose
provide
prompt
review
epa
action
better
served
providing
judicial
review
cases
district
rather
appeals
respondents
view
since
agency
action
predicated
neither
formal
adjudication
informal
rulemaking
apt
based
record
scant
permit
informed
judicial
review
district
preferable
forum
since
tools
discovery
available
augment
record
whereas
appeals
remand
epa
might
required
argument
addressed
congress
task
determine
ideal
forum
judicial
review
administrator
decision
case
see
currie
goodman
judicial
review
federal
administrative
action
quest
optimum
forum
colum
rev
rather
must
determine
congress
intended
vested
courts
appeals
jurisdiction
review
final
action
language
statute
clearly
provides
decision
sort
issue
reviewable
appeals
nothing
legislative
history
points
different
conclusion
add
matter
policy
conferral
jurisdiction
upon
courts
appeals
wholly
irrational
obvious
advantage
direct
review
appeals
time
saved
compared
review
district
followed
second
review
appeal
may
seriously
questioned
whether
overall
time
lost
appeals
remands
epa
cases
records
inadequate
exceed
time
saved
forgoing
every
case
initial
review
district
whatever
answer
empirical
question
appellate
without
recourse
event
finds
unable
exercise
informed
judicial
review
inadequate
administrative
record
situation
appellate
may
always
remand
case
agency
consideration
reasons
stated
hold
appeals
erred
dismissing
petition
want
jurisdiction
accordingly
judgment
reversed
case
remanded
appeals
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
footnotes
petition
review
action
administrator
promulgating
national
primary
secondary
ambient
air
quality
standard
emission
standard
requirement
section
standard
performance
requirement
section
standard
section
standard
required
prescribed
section
determination
section
control
prohibition
section
standard
section
rule
issued
section
section
nationally
applicable
regulations
promulgated
final
action
taken
administrator
act
may
filed
appeals
district
columbia
petition
review
administrator
action
approving
promulgating
implementation
plan
section
section
order
section
section
section
section
section
action
section
effect
date
enactment
clean
air
act
amendments
regulations
thereunder
final
action
administrator
act
including
denial
disapproval
administrator
title
locally
regionally
applicable
may
filed
appeals
appropriate
circuit
notwithstanding
preceding
sentence
petition
review
action
referred
sentence
may
filed
appeals
district
columbia
action
based
determination
nationwide
scope
effect
taking
action
administrator
finds
publishes
action
based
determination
petition
review
subsection
shall
filed
within
sixty
days
date
notice
promulgation
approval
action
appears
federal
register
except
petition
based
solely
grounds
arising
sixtieth
day
petition
review
subsection
shall
filed
within
sixty
days
grounds
arise
emphasis
added
act
added
stat
amended
clean
air
act
amendments
pub
stat
clean
air
act
technical
conforming
amendments
pub
stat
supp
ii
request
clarification
ppg
expressed
understanding
new
source
standards
applicable
normal
course
operation
boilers
performance
tests
periods
boilers
operating
fossil
fuel
epa
letter
confirmed
ppg
understanding
position
however
inconsistent
regional
administrator
earlier
ruling
epa
position
similar
cases
accordingly
epa
representative
notified
ppg
telephone
letter
incorrect
subsequent
letter
director
division
stationary
source
enforcement
epa
reiterated
new
source
standards
applicable
normal
operation
boilers
extent
boilers
operating
fossil
fuel
rather
waste
heat
director
also
indicated
pursuant
standards
ppg
required
operate
boilers
times
fuel
containing
less
certain
specified
content
sulfur
noted
ppg
required
install
operate
opacity
monitors
stacks
boilers
perform
alternative
monitoring
tests
respondents
abandoned
construction
statute
advanced
appeals
namely
phrase
final
action
refers
final
actions
provisions
specifically
enumerated
construction
appeals
correctly
noted
inconsistent
fact
phrase
final
action
modified
sections
rather
act
appear
respondents
construction
statute
adopted
appeals
although
matter
free
doubt
doubt
arises
fact
appeals
opinion
also
read
establishing
jurisdictional
test
turns
inquiry
adequacy
administrative
record
respondents
acknowledge
reading
opinion
create
excessive
uncertainty
proper
forum
judicial
review
respondents
argue
exception
ignored
applying
rule
ejusdem
generis
since
governs
regulation
hazardous
air
pollutants
congress
may
wanted
special
review
courts
appeals
even
absence
procedures
requiring
notice
opportunity
hearing
view
however
rule
ejusdem
generis
applicable
must
applied
actions
specifically
enumerated
provisions
simply
fit
respondents
theory
respondents
raise
several
objections
literal
reading
none
find
persuasive
first
respondents
assert
construction
internally
inconsistent
inconsistent
another
provision
act
internal
inconsistency
said
arise
fact
phrase
final
action
construed
include
final
action
administrator
nullify
express
exception
review
standard
required
prescribed
section
inconsistency
another
provision
act
said
arise
fact
literal
reading
final
action
effectively
repeal
another
judicial
review
provision
act
supp
ii
objections
fall
far
short
mark
however
general
language
catchall
phrase
final
action
must
obviously
give
way
specific
express
provisions
act
respondents
also
argue
congress
intended
phrase
final
action
refer
final
actions
administrator
unnecessary
add
list
specifically
enumerated
provisions
actions
administrator
reviewable
courts
appeals
may
true
fact
remains
even
congress
intended
phrase
final
action
read
respondents
urge
accordance
rule
ejusdem
generis
still
necessity
add
list
specifically
enumerated
provisions
committee
intended
phrase
final
action
result
least
expansion
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
evident
fact
committee
report
expressly
indicated
several
types
nationwide
actions
provisions
specifically
enumerated
reviewable
district
columbia
circuit
see
pp
regulations
carry
nonattainment
policy
set
act
thus
even
respondents
concede
issue
whether
congress
intended
expansion
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
rather
extent
congress
intended
expand
jurisdiction
issue
legislative
history
silent
arthur
conan
doyle
silver
blaze
complete
sherlock
holmes
respondents
also
argue
literal
construction
violate
due
process
law
argument
turns
interrelationship
companion
provision
provides
ction
administrator
respect
review
obtained
shall
subject
judicial
review
civil
criminal
proceedings
enforcement
supp
ii
preclude
defendant
civil
criminal
enforcement
proceeding
attacking
validity
informal
action
part
administrator
respondents
view
violate
defendant
due
process
right
reasonable
opportunity
heard
present
evidence
yakus
short
answer
respondents
argument
validity
issue
constitutional
question
raised
respondents
must
therefore
await
another
day
dissenting
opinions
modify
language
read
either
final
action
similar
specifically
enumerated
provisions
added
clean
air
act
technical
conforming
amendments
post
final
action
expressly
impliedly
authorized
sections
act
specifically
enumerated
post
neither
language
statute
legislative
history
supports
either
proposed
readings
whether
present
administrative
record
case
adequate
permit
informed
judicial
review
question
appeals
must
determine
justice
powell
concurring
continue
reservations
constitutionality
notice
review
preclusion
provisions
adamo
wrecking
powell
concurring
see
ante
congress
extended
days
period
within
petition
review
may
filed
publication
federal
register
still
unlikely
provide
constitutionally
adequate
notice
failure
seek
immediate
review
bar
affected
parties
challenging
noticed
action
subsequent
criminal
prosecution
informal
exchange
letters
like
involved
case
often
provide
greater
protection
although
constitutional
difficulties
well
may
counsel
narrow
construction
cf
chrysler
epa
app
parallel
provisions
noise
control
act
construction
possible
case
demonstrates
intention
congress
clear
accordingly
join
opinion
justice
blackmun
concurring
result
reasons
stated
brother
stevens
dissent
accept
conclusion
agency
determination
case
constituted
final
action
opaque
language
scant
attention
received
congress
however
leave
doubt
concerning
congress
true
intention
respect
scope
direct
appellate
review
like
dissenting
brethren
find
difficult
believe
congress
undertake
massive
expansion
number
agency
actions
directly
reviewable
courts
appeals
without
palpable
indication
given
thought
consequences
nonetheless
agree
dearth
evidence
contrary
makes
broad
interpretation
statute
inescapable
legislative
record
must
leave
congress
inclined
task
introducing
clear
limitation
appellate
jurisdiction
review
informal
agency
determinations
like
one
us
justice
rehnquist
dissenting
effort
determine
congressional
intent
might
better
entrusted
detective
judge
rejects
application
traditional
canon
ejusdem
generis
phrase
final
action
grounds
uncertainty
meaning
phrase
ante
least
one
provisions
included
supp
ii
supp
ii
require
administrator
act
notice
opportunity
comment
hearing
ante
agree
phrase
final
action
may
ambiguous
think
know
matter
makes
congress
additions
clean
air
act
technical
conforming
amendments
less
curious
incident
silver
blaze
dog
nothing
nighttime
correct
must
look
beyond
language
phrase
final
action
ascertaining
congressional
intention
chemehuevi
tribe
indians
fpc
granted
exclusive
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
review
limited
class
actions
taken
administrator
district
columbia
train
app
utah
power
light
epa
app
epa
required
provide
notice
opportunity
hearing
comment
respect
actions
procedural
requirements
generally
result
creation
administrative
record
susceptible
judicial
review
courts
appeals
actions
one
case
notice
opportunity
comment
required
indeed
stated
requirements
interested
persons
opportunity
least
written
comment
agency
provide
general
statement
reasons
virtually
assure
appellate
meaningful
record
review
true
many
instances
informal
adjudication
also
produces
administrative
record
nature
scope
records
vary
widely
one
type
action
another
provide
assurance
appellate
review
feasible
currie
goodman
judicial
review
federal
administrative
action
quest
optimum
forum
colum
rev
thus
grant
exclusive
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
actions
fully
comports
traditional
role
appellate
courts
reviewing
agency
decisions
based
development
factual
issues
means
administrative
record
revision
clean
air
act
amendments
congress
added
phrase
final
action
view
support
construction
phrase
major
expansion
congress
original
limited
grant
exclusive
jurisdiction
federal
courts
appeals
amendment
added
supp
ii
list
specifically
enumerated
also
included
final
action
phrase
pub
stat
section
depart
requirement
notice
opportunity
comment
hearing
existed
prior
respect
sections
specifically
enumerated
directs
epa
give
notice
opportunity
public
hearing
adopting
authorized
regulations
adding
phrase
final
action
congress
gave
indication
whatsoever
intended
make
reviewable
courts
appeals
actions
differed
substantially
character
authorized
sections
listed
instead
limited
legislative
history
subject
suggests
amendment
aimed
resolving
problems
venue
section
effecting
major
jurisdictional
shift
district
courts
courts
appeals
congress
done
nothing
enact
amendment
doubt
find
application
rule
ejusdem
generis
problematic
see
infra
difficulty
ascertaining
congress
intention
arises
technical
amendments
enacted
three
months
congress
adopted
clean
air
act
amendments
clean
air
act
technical
conforming
amendments
pub
stat
amendments
purportedly
made
substantive
changes
earlier
amendments
nonetheless
altered
specifying
four
additional
sections
trigger
original
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
supp
ii
supp
ii
supp
ii
supp
ii
epa
maintains
additions
make
substantive
changes
final
action
phrase
already
included
actions
sections
interpretation
phrase
clearly
case
view
however
also
leads
conclusion
technical
amendments
largely
meaningless
exercise
congress
legislative
authority
previously
noted
presenting
technical
amendments
senator
muskie
said
necessary
correct
technical
errors
unclear
phrases
cong
rec
emphasis
added
supra
thus
technical
amendments
coupled
senator
muskie
statement
introducing
present
paradox
attempting
ascertain
congress
intention
interpretation
phrase
final
action
technical
amendments
contrary
advance
billing
entirely
unnecessary
phrase
clearly
includes
sections
final
action
means
anything
less
interpretation
technical
amendments
contrary
stated
purpose
made
important
substantive
changes
attempts
partially
unsuccessfully
address
difficulty
acknowledges
interpretation
technical
amendments
unnecessary
response
however
answer
question
merely
restates
adds
additional
observation
may
true
fact
remains
even
congress
intended
phrase
final
action
read
accordance
rule
ejusdem
generis
still
necessity
add
list
specifically
enumerated
provisions
ante
view
absent
clear
indication
contrary
statute
construed
creating
broad
expansion
jurisdiction
federal
courts
appeals
approach
quite
appropriate
case
jurisdictional
expansion
wrought
thoroughly
inconsistent
traditional
role
appellate
courts
indeed
think
difficult
believe
congress
adopt
massive
shift
jurisdiction
district
courts
courts
appeals
without
comment
whatsoever
sketchy
legislative
history
indicates
congress
considered
administrative
conference
recommendations
principal
purpose
amendment
effect
change
venue
recommended
administrative
conference
change
far
less
substantial
jurisdictional
shift
according
congress
adopted
sub
silentio
remarks
made
time
technical
amendments
adopted
coupled
nature
actions
reviewable
prior
time
sufficiently
perplexing
view
technical
amendments
shed
meaningful
light
congress
intention
adding
phrase
final
action
accordingly
even
though
labeled
technical
amendments
think
accurately
viewed
subsequent
legislative
history
controlling
interpreting
prior
enactment
see
air
lines
mcmann
indeed
one
acquainted
significance
expansion
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
urged
epa
adopted
technical
amendments
likely
looked
like
minor
additions
thus
think
sensible
way
interpret
phrase
final
action
reference
time
phrase
enacted
rather
subsequent
time
technical
amendments
added
phrase
final
action
interpreted
reference
time
phrase
added
case
clearly
proper
one
apply
rule
ejusdem
generis
rule
ejusdem
generis
ordinarily
limits
general
terms
follow
specific
ones
matters
similar
specified
gooch
rests
notion
statutes
construed
sense
words
best
harmonizes
context
end
view
ibid
time
general
language
final
action
adopted
notice
opportunity
comments
hearing
required
actions
listed
sections
preceded
requirement
distinguished
sections
administrator
action
issue
thus
principle
ejusdem
generis
general
phrase
refers
similar
types
actions
interpretation
offers
satisfactory
explanation
congress
curious
failure
provide
indication
intended
effect
major
jurisdictional
change
manner
reviewing
epa
actions
one
us
change
inconsistent
traditional
role
appellate
courts
case
construction
legislative
language
makes
sweeping
relatively
unorthodox
change
made
think
judges
well
detectives
may
take
consideration
fact
watchdog
bark
night
section
originally
provided
petition
review
action
administrator
promulgating
national
primary
secondary
ambient
air
quality
standard
emission
standard
section
standard
performance
section
standard
section
standard
required
prescribed
section
determination
section
control
prohibition
section
standard
section
may
filed
appeals
district
columbia
petition
review
administrator
action
approving
promulgating
implementation
plan
section
section
may
filed
appeals
appropriate
circuit
petition
shall
filed
within
days
date
promulgation
approval
pub
stat
senate
debates
senator
cooper
stated
decisions
epa
made
development
technical
relevant
information
necessary
achieve
sound
judgment
reviewable
appeals
interests
parties
fully
protected
record
developed
epa
secretary
unbiased
independent
institution
appropriate
forum
reviewing
decision
making
judgment
quality
cong
rec
direct
appellate
review
formal
administrative
adjudications
long
standard
practice
agency
action
judged
administrative
record
need
trial
thus
need
prior
resort
district
currie
judicial
review
federal
pollution
laws
iowa
rev
emphasis
added
see
also
currie
goodman
judicial
review
federal
administrative
action
quest
optimum
forum
colum
rev
discussion
addition
clean
air
act
amendment
intended
clarify
questions
relating
venue
review
rules
orders
act
emphasis
added
house
report
noted
adopting
subsection
committee
large
measure
approving
portion
administrative
conference
recommendation
section
fed
reg
deals
venue
proposed
amendment
also
incorporates
recommendation
administrative
conference
extending
period
petitioning
judicial
review
appeals
stated
endorse
remainder
administrative
conference
recommendations
include
recommendation
proposed
expanding
jurisdiction
courts
appeals
eliminating
exception
review
courts
regulations
adopted
supp
ii
statement
explaining
amendments
senator
muskie
stated
purpose
amendments
substantive
issues
clean
air
act
cong
rec
rather
continued
nly
amendments
necessary
correct
technical
errors
unclear
phrases
retained
package
amendments
senate
ibid
section
make
provision
notice
comment
hearing
generally
provide
notice
hearing
every
case
order
denying
waiver
apparently
may
made
administrator
without
formal
proceedings
administrator
apparently
may
deny
application
primary
nonferrous
smelter
order
without
providing
notice
hearing
justice
stevens
dissenting
may
june
respondent
ppg
industries
ppg
exchanged
series
letters
various
officials
environmental
protection
agency
concerning
applicability
certain
federal
performance
standards
ppg
boilers
lake
charles
plant
ppg
took
position
boilers
required
meet
standards
first
construction
begun
prior
effective
date
standards
second
boilers
within
category
sources
standards
question
apply
april
ppg
submitted
formal
request
pursuant
cfr
definitive
determination
issues
although
provides
determinations
respect
first
issue
raised
ppg
epa
regional
administrator
apparently
rejected
arguments
june
response
unequivocally
stating
ppg
boilers
subject
standards
question
clarifying
letters
exchanged
ppg
brought
two
separate
petitions
review
epa
determination
filing
district
western
district
louisiana
appeals
fifth
circuit
fifth
circuit
dismissed
petition
ground
review
properly
district
two
issues
us
today
first
whether
epa
determination
constitutes
final
agency
action
review
appropriate
second
whether
review
must
appeals
determination
constituted
final
action
within
meaning
clean
air
act
supp
ii
accept
holding
agency
determination
constituted
final
action
term
ordinarily
used
administrative
procedure
act
persuaded
congress
intended
exclusive
review
type
action
courts
appeals
abbott
laboratories
gardner
set
three
tests
informal
agency
action
must
meet
order
considered
final
agency
action
ripe
judicial
review
first
action
must
involve
issue
appropriate
judicial
review
purely
legal
question
second
must
definitive
statement
agency
position
merely
tentative
view
opinion
subordinate
official
finally
party
seeking
review
action
must
faced
serious
hardship
allowed
obtain
review
abbott
laboratories
third
requirement
satisfied
fact
affected
companies
either
expend
substantial
amounts
money
comply
regulation
comply
risk
serious
criminal
civil
penalties
although
informal
advice
agency
personnel
agency
likely
react
particular
set
circumstances
ordinarily
subject
judicial
review
abbott
laboratories
tests
case
seem
exception
epa
argues
issue
decided
whether
certain
regulations
apply
facts
submitted
agency
ppg
second
regional
administrator
epa
signed
letter
rejecting
ppg
position
thus
appears
suggests
agency
last
word
issue
ante
finally
although
parties
informed
us
magnitude
ppg
estimated
compliance
costs
appears
ppg
risk
sizeable
penalties
supp
ii
order
challenge
epa
determination
enforcement
proceedings
assuming
epa
letter
case
constitute
final
agency
action
apa
second
question
whether
compelled
language
hold
appeals
exclusive
jurisdiction
review
action
justice
rehnquist
points
dissent
construction
statute
greatly
increase
burdens
currently
borne
courts
appeals
terms
numbers
cases
difficulty
issues
presented
ante
view
also
distort
concept
final
agency
action
giving
epa
virtually
unlimited
discretion
transform
informal
advice
final
agency
action
subject
appeals
review
clean
air
act
agency
action
reviewable
courts
appeals
challenged
enforcement
proceeding
whether
review
actually
sought
petition
review
must
filed
within
days
publication
agency
action
federal
register
although
epa
apparently
publish
letters
like
letter
ppg
federal
register
prior
clean
air
act
amendments
embarking
program
publication
may
give
agency
benefit
preclusive
effect
every
incentive
notice
wide
range
actions
federal
register
notice
action
published
federal
register
difficult
argue
final
agency
action
determinations
like
one
concern
applications
particular
regulations
undisputed
fact
situations
second
fact
agency
published
position
indicate
definitive
statement
agency
policy
finally
requirement
aggrieved
person
show
hardship
entitling
review
also
seem
satisfied
mere
publication
since
failure
raise
issue
might
well
foreclose
future
review
entirely
find
difficult
believe
congress
intended
highly
undesirable
result
although
share
justice
rehnquist
interpretation
statute
construe
drawing
line
short
allowing
epa
complete
discretion
turn
anything
chooses
final
action
reviewable
courts
appeals
section
mandates
exclusive
review
courts
appeals
administrator
actions
certain
specific
subsections
act
subsections
contain
specific
grants
authority
administrator
make
certain
determinations
thus
supp
ii
empower
administrator
approve
state
implementation
plans
supp
ii
empower
administrator
grant
necessary
implication
deny
waivers
companies
unable
comply
applicable
standards
supp
ii
sets
procedure
administrator
assess
noncompliance
penalties
notice
hearing
record
types
agency
action
immediate
impact
legal
rights
affected
party
contrast
agency
advice
whether
particular
sources
subject
previously
promulgated
regulations
change
party
legal
status
anything
statute
specifically
requires
permits
administrator
give
advice
mean
beyond
administrator
power
set
procedures
done
cfr
giving
advice
formalized
manner
believe
congress
intended
review
provisions
statute
cover
type
agency
action
well
types
specifically
contemplated
statute
making
reviewable
final
action
administrator
chapter
congress
must
thinking
actions
specifically
directed
authorized
administrator
take
sections
act
specifically
enumerated
interpretation
consistent
ejusdem
generis
construction
statute
plain
language
also
supported
congress
apparent
belief
extending
appeals
review
types
actions
epa
accustomed
publishing
federal
register
see
supra
accordingly
respectfully
dissent
ppg
also
questions
compliance
event
standards
found
apply
title
cfr
provides
requested
owner
operator
administrator
make
determination
whether
action
taken
intended
taken
owner
operator
constitutes
construction
including
reconstruction
modification
commencement
thereof
within
meaning
part
relies
exclusively
factor
along
fact
parties
agree
action
final
place
much
reliance
parties
agreement
however
since
share
common
interest
threshold
jurisdictional
question
resolved
affirmative
thus
serves
ppg
interests
treat
epa
letter
final
action
ppg
wants
judicial
review
soon
possible
also
serves
epa
interests
broadening
category
agency
actions
final
reviewable
courts
appeals
increases
number
agency
actions
challenged
enforcement
proceedings
act
see
infra
see
national
automatic
laundry
cleaning
council
shultz
app
held
letter
signed
administrator
concerning
particular
application
fair
labor
standards
act
final
action
light
fact
noncompliance
agency
policy
led
criminal
liability
actions
double
damages
affected
employees
see
west
penn
power
train
cert
denied
adams
dissenting
refused
consider
notice
violation
issued
pursuant
clean
air
act
final
agency
action
despite
severe
penalties
attached
future
noncompliance
whether
record
case
sufficiently
developed
purposes
appeals
review
issue
parties
differ
clear
many
cases
involving
informal
epa
action
record
agency
relied
making
determination
minimal
section
clean
air
act
provides
action
administrator
respect
review
obtained
paragraph
shall
subject
judicial
review
civil
criminal
proceedings
enforcement
epa
brief
appeals
took
position
adding
final
action
congress
intended
require
agency
give
notice
federal
register
every
final
action
takes
contrary
prior
practice
although
agency
noted
yet
begun
complying
obligation
stated
intended
begin
publication
near
future
final
agency
actions
taken
since
amendments
brief
respondents
pp
epa
interpretation
federal
register
clause
requirement
notice
final
determinations
given
seems
backwards
think
plausible
interpretation
statute
congress
intended
term
final
agency
action
refer
types
actions
epa
accustomed
publishing
federal
register
prior
amendments
hardship
determination
course
becomes
circular
since
preclusion
unless
final
agency
action
finality
unless
hardship
according
review
circumstances
courts
likely
emulate
approach
case
ignoring
hardship
component
entirely
making
reviewable
action
constitutes
definitive
statement
agency
position