crandon
argued
november
decided
february
individual
petitioners
terminated
employment
petitioner
boeing
company
accept
important
positions
executive
branch
federal
government
boeing
made
became
government
employee
unconditional
payment
mitigate
substantial
loss
expected
suffer
reason
change
employment
subsequently
filed
civil
complaint
district
seeking
damages
boeing
imposition
constructive
trust
moneys
received
individual
petitioners
complaint
alleged
payments
made
supplement
individual
petitioners
compensation
federal
employees
created
conflict
interest
situation
induced
breach
fiduciary
duty
undivided
loyalty
owed
individual
petitioners
government
measured
inter
alia
makes
crime
private
party
pay
government
employee
receive
supplemental
compensation
employee
government
service
held
among
things
violated
payments
made
recipients
become
government
employees
intended
compensate
government
service
appeals
reversed
holding
inter
alia
employment
status
time
payment
element
violation
finding
payments
intended
supplemental
compensation
government
service
clearly
erroneous
held
section
apply
severance
payment
made
encourage
payee
accept
government
employment
made
payee
becomes
government
employee
pp
section
text
indicates
employment
status
element
offense
neither
two
prohibitions
one
directed
every
person
receives
salary
supplement
compensation
services
officer
employee
directed
every
person
pays
makes
contribution
salary
officer
employee
directly
specifies
payment
must
made
received
however
literal
reading
second
prohibition
supports
conclusion
payee
must
government
employee
time
payment
made
prohibitions
appear
coextensive
coverage
sides
single
transaction
pp
legislative
history
language
obviously
focus
certain
payments
made
recipient
government
employee
unambiguous
language
covering
preemployment
payments
congress
used
contemporaneous
revision
bribery
conflicts
provisions
indicate
congress
intend
change
substance
predecessor
statute
eliminated
language
unquestionably
required
recipient
payment
government
employee
time
payment
made
pp
literal
reading
serves
one
conflicting
policies
motivated
enactment
statute
public
interest
recruiting
personnel
highest
quality
capacity
since
allows
corporations
encourage
qualified
employees
make
special
skills
available
government
policy
justifications
concerns
private
paymaster
economic
hold
employee
payment
engender
bitterness
among
fellow
employees
employee
might
tend
favor
former
employer
wholly
inapplicable
unconditional
preemployment
severance
payments
means
directly
implicated
cases
ongoing
salary
supplements
pp
extent
ambiguity
temporal
scope
remains
rule
lenity
requires
resolved
petitioners
favor
unless
congress
plainly
intent
misconstrued
stevens
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
brennan
white
marshall
blackmun
joined
scalia
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
kennedy
joined
post
together
boeing
also
certiorari
philip
lacovara
argued
cause
petitioners
briefs
william
stein
gerard
treanor
robert
plotkin
lawrence
barcella
benjamin
sharp
argued
cause
petitioner
briefs
hilary
harp
robert
bennett
alan
kriegel
edwin
kneedler
argued
cause
brief
solicitor
general
starr
acting
assistant
attorney
general
schiffer
deputy
solicitor
general
wallace
michael
hertz
douglas
letter
justice
stevens
delivered
opinion
five
executives
boeing
company
boeing
resigned
took
early
retirement
accept
important
positions
executive
branch
federal
government
upon
termination
employment
boeing
shortly
formation
employment
relationship
government
boeing
made
payment
amount
intended
mitigate
substantial
financial
loss
employee
expected
suffer
reason
change
employment
question
must
decide
whether
payments
violated
provision
criminal
code
prohibits
private
parties
paying
government
employees
receiving
supplemental
compensation
employee
government
service
essential
facts
disputed
employee
resigned
planned
accept
specific
federal
position
shifts
required
forgoing
higher
salaries
employee
earned
boeing
also
severing
financial
connection
company
thus
petitioner
paisley
took
early
retirement
become
assistant
secretary
navy
research
engineering
systems
office
requires
confirmation
senate
estimated
financial
cost
separating
boeing
approximately
including
approximately
lost
stock
options
lost
retirement
benefits
boeing
severance
payment
paisley
amounted
comparable
estimate
petitioner
crandon
resigned
become
computer
scientist
north
atlantic
treaty
organization
severance
payment
three
individual
petitioners
payments
higher
crandon
lower
paisley
boeing
paid
five
departing
employees
total
none
five
individual
petitioners
government
employee
time
received
severance
payment
moreover
payment
made
unconditionally
none
employees
promised
return
boeing
later
date
boeing
make
commitment
rehire
entering
government
service
none
individual
petitioners
provided
boeing
favored
treatment
indeed
participated
source
selection
procurement
decision
affected
boeing
stipulated
five
competent
faithful
government
servants
apart
fact
payments
charge
case
misconduct
petitioners
filed
civil
complaint
alleging
payments
made
supplement
individual
defendant
compensation
federal
employee
created
conflict
interest
situation
induced
breach
fiduciary
duty
undivided
loyalty
individual
defendant
owed
measured
common
law
app
complaint
sought
relief
boeing
aggregate
amount
payments
made
imposition
constructive
trust
moneys
received
individual
petitioners
full
trial
district
ruled
government
several
alternative
grounds
supp
ed
first
held
violated
payments
made
recipients
become
government
employees
intended
compensate
government
service
second
held
violation
fiduciary
standard
conduct
established
principles
agency
payments
disclosed
responsible
government
officials
tend
subvert
loyalty
individual
defendants
government
finally
district
concluded
payments
created
neither
appearance
actual
conflict
interest
government
injured
payments
therefore
event
entitled
recover
damages
ibid
divided
panel
appeals
reversed
held
employment
status
time
payment
element
violation
district
finding
payments
intended
supplemental
compensation
services
employees
clearly
erroneous
held
prophylactic
character
conflict
interest
laws
made
unnecessary
government
prove
actual
injury
defendants
disclosure
payments
constitute
defense
action
recovery
therefore
concluded
individual
defendants
boeing
liable
although
double
recovery
government
permitted
granted
certiorari
review
appeals
construction
important
statute
outset
note
congress
created
express
civil
remedy
violations
government
many
words
argue
enactment
statute
implicitly
created
damages
remedy
rather
government
begins
rule
agent
secretly
profits
breach
fiduciary
obligation
principal
must
disgorge
gains
replaces
definition
fiduciary
obligation
stricter
standard
arguing
concealment
payment
element
statutory
offense
disclosure
payments
defense
regardless
whether
government
amalgamation
statutory
concepts
describes
tenable
theory
recovery
least
clear
government
must
prove
violation
prevail
cases
proceed
therefore
consider
whether
applies
severance
payment
made
encourage
payee
accept
government
employment
made
payee
becomes
government
employee
determining
meaning
statute
look
particular
statutory
language
design
statute
whole
object
policy
mart
cartier
pilot
life
ins
dedeaux
moreover
governing
standard
set
forth
criminal
statute
appropriate
apply
rule
lenity
resolving
ambiguity
ambit
statute
coverage
extent
language
history
uncertain
interpretive
guideline
serves
ensure
fair
warning
boundaries
criminal
conduct
legislatures
courts
define
criminal
liability
liparota
see
also
bass
ii
section
one
almost
two
dozen
statutory
provisions
addressing
bribery
graft
conflicts
interest
revised
compiled
chapter
criminal
code
sections
focus
bribes
compensation
offered
quid
pro
quo
government
acts
apply
persons
commencing
government
service
prophylactic
rule
aims
source
government
employees
compensation
section
contains
two
prohibitions
neither
directly
specifies
payment
must
made
received
first
paragraph
directed
every
person
receives
salary
supplement
compensation
services
officer
employee
executive
agency
government
second
paragraph
directed
every
person
pays
makes
contribution
supplement
salary
officer
employee
circumstances
make
receipt
contribution
violation
subsection
literal
reading
second
paragraph
particularly
use
term
officer
employee
supports
conclusion
payee
must
government
employee
time
payment
made
similarly
paragraph
additional
prohibitions
one
makes
contribution
way
supplements
salary
also
refer
officer
employee
indeed
since
prohibited
conduct
merely
receipt
payment
salary
supplement
follows
violation
either
committed
time
payment
made
despite
awkward
drafting
paragraphs
appear
coextensive
coverage
sides
single
transaction
text
thus
indicates
employment
status
element
offense
appeals
rejected
reading
statute
two
reasons
first
noted
prior
codification
criminal
code
plain
language
predecessor
statute
ed
unambiguously
limited
whoever
government
official
employee
received
salary
appeals
inferred
deletion
phrase
meant
payment
longer
need
occur
federal
employment
thus
preemployment
payments
violate
second
felt
public
policy
underlying
conflict
interest
laws
general
also
support
broad
interpretation
coverage
ibid
construction
criminal
statute
must
guided
need
fair
warning
rare
legislative
history
statutory
policies
support
construction
statute
broader
clearly
warranted
text
case
sources
indicates
reading
statutory
language
consistent
congressional
intent
iii
predecessor
enacted
amendment
bureau
education
legislative
appropriation
provided
government
official
employee
shall
receive
salary
connection
services
source
phrase
government
official
employee
appear
provision
transferred
reorganization
title
appeals
recognized
wording
unquestionably
required
recipient
payment
government
employee
time
payment
made
reading
neither
changed
original
scope
statute
engendered
controversy
entire
period
criticism
focused
instead
vagueness
reference
payments
made
connection
employee
service
fact
legislative
history
explains
narrowing
consequence
elimination
words
silent
reason
eliminating
government
official
employee
inconsistent
view
congress
intended
latter
change
broaden
coverage
section
senate
house
judiciary
committees
attorney
general
maintained
made
substantive
change
law
rather
deletion
government
official
employee
use
phrase
officer
employee
executive
branch
seemed
enhance
clarity
consistency
new
conflicts
statutes
attach
greater
significance
two
changes
congress
made
revised
bribery
conflict
laws
added
language
extending
prohibition
bribery
public
official
person
selected
public
official
defined
person
nominated
appointed
public
official
officially
informed
nominated
appointed
prohibits
outside
compensation
performance
public
service
congress
expressly
covered
advance
requests
offers
compensation
services
rendered
time
recipient
officer
employee
provisions
congress
used
unambiguous
language
cover
preemployment
payments
absence
comparable
language
indicates
congress
intend
broaden
coverage
provision
evidence
confirming
requires
employment
status
time
payment
found
subsections
former
expressly
authorizes
federal
employees
continue
receive
payments
bona
fide
pension
health
benefit
plan
maintained
former
employer
latter
makes
inapplicable
certain
types
government
employees
provisions
obviously
focus
payments
made
recipient
government
employee
addition
two
exemptions
like
careful
draftsmanship
consistent
attorney
general
kennedy
contemporaneous
opinion
change
substance
former
see
supra
iv
congress
appropriately
enacts
prophylactic
rules
intended
prevent
even
appearance
wrongdoing
may
apply
conduct
caused
actual
injury
section
rule
legislation
designed
prohibit
avoid
potential
conflicts
interest
performance
governmental
service
supported
legitimate
interest
maintaining
public
confidence
integrity
federal
service
neither
good
faith
full
disclosure
exemplary
performance
public
office
excuse
making
receipt
prohibited
payment
nevertheless
appropriate
case
raises
questions
scope
prohibition
identify
specific
policies
provision
serves
well
counsel
reading
broadly
see
offshore
logistics
tallentire
special
committee
federal
conflict
interest
laws
association
bar
city
new
york
prepared
scholarly
report
government
petitioners
agree
accurately
describes
policies
implemented
report
stated
rule
really
special
case
general
injunction
serving
two
masters
three
basic
concerns
underlie
rule
prohibiting
two
payrolls
two
paymasters
employee
job
first
outside
payor
hold
employee
deriving
ability
cut
one
employee
economic
lifelines
second
employee
may
tend
favor
outside
payor
even
though
direct
pressure
put
third
real
risks
arrangement
generally
unwholesome
appearance
breeds
suspicion
bitterness
among
fellow
employees
observers
public
interpretation
apt
outside
party
paying
government
employee
paying
past
services
must
paying
current
services
payor
time
services
supposed
devoted
government
association
bar
city
new
york
conflict
interest
federal
service
important
countervailing
consideration
also
ignored
president
kennedy
recognized
sent
message
congress
calling
wholesale
revision
conflict
interest
laws
regulation
setting
highest
moral
standards
must
impair
ability
government
recruit
personnel
highest
quality
capacity
today
government
needs
men
women
broad
range
experience
knowledge
ability
needs
increasing
numbers
people
topflight
executive
talent
needs
hundreds
occasional
intermittent
consultants
experts
help
deal
problems
increasing
complexity
technical
difficulty
short
need
draw
upon
america
entire
reservoir
talent
skill
help
conduct
generation
important
business
public
business
message
president
relative
ethical
conduct
government
doc
attorney
general
kennedy
commented
concern
memorandum
legislation
explaining
one
main
purposes
new
legislation
help
government
obtain
temporary
intermittent
services
persons
special
knowledge
skills
whose
principal
employment
outside
government
predicted
new
legislation
lead
significant
expansion
pool
talent
departments
agencies
draw
special
needs
substantive
additions
allow
continuing
participation
pension
benefits
plans
exempt
certain
employees
prohibitions
wholly
consistent
attorney
general
outlook
contrast
expansion
encompass
preemployment
payments
run
counter
interest
severance
payments
made
petitioners
case
somewhat
nebulous
character
one
hand
government
correctly
argues
give
rise
possible
appearance
impropriety
certainly
one
concerns
hand
allowing
corporations
encourage
qualified
employees
make
special
skills
available
government
serves
public
interest
identified
president
attorney
general
enacted
function
express
either
approval
disapproval
kind
unconditional
severance
payment
note
literal
reading
statute
places
service
severance
payment
outside
coverage
consistent
one
policies
motivated
enactment
statute
language
congress
used
thus
harmony
thought
spirit
purpose
act
case
presents
none
rare
exceptional
circumstances
may
justify
departure
statutory
language
crooks
harrelson
accord
rubin
finally
already
observed
construing
criminal
statute
therefore
bound
consider
application
rule
lenity
extent
ambiguity
temporal
scope
remains
resolved
petitioners
favor
unless
congress
plainly
misconstrued
intent
judgment
appeals
accordingly
reversed
ordered
footnotes
whoever
receives
salary
contribution
supplementation
salary
compensation
services
officer
employee
executive
branch
government
independent
agency
district
columbia
source
government
except
may
contributed
treasury
state
county
municipality
whoever
whether
individual
partnership
association
corporation
organization
pays
makes
contribution
way
supplements
salary
officer
employee
circumstances
make
receipt
violation
subsection
shall
fined
imprisoned
one
year
enacted
act
pub
stat
joint
stipulations
uncontested
facts
app
joint
stipulations
uncontested
facts
app
petitioner
jones
resigned
become
deputy
secretary
defense
strategic
theater
nuclear
forces
requested
cost
severance
received
petitioner
reynolds
resigned
become
consultant
deputy
director
space
intelligence
policy
requested
received
petitioner
kitson
took
early
retirement
become
deputy
assistant
secretary
navy
command
control
communications
intelligence
requested
received
joint
stipulations
uncontested
facts
app
app
app
employees
submitted
estimates
boeing
included
expected
reduction
salary
benefits
value
accumulated
unvested
company
benefits
separate
payment
standard
departing
boeing
employees
cashed
employees
interests
vested
benefits
ibid
boeing
internal
accounting
procedure
calculating
severance
pay
employees
departing
government
positions
used
four
factors
loss
salary
duration
anticipated
government
employment
assumed
remainder
presidential
term
period
prior
employee
birthday
whichever
shorter
loss
boeing
contributions
employee
retirement
plan
relocation
costs
supplement
cover
difference
living
costs
seattle
washington
alternative
procedure
considered
employee
salary
years
service
boeing
duration
anticipated
government
employment
app
boeing
staff
estimated
payments
petitioners
kitson
crandon
using
procedures
petitioners
jones
paisley
reynolds
using
solely
first
procedure
petitioner
anticipated
length
government
service
thus
component
calculation
final
payment
final
amounts
approved
boeing
chief
executive
ibid
appeals
also
held
statute
limitations
barred
government
tort
claims
boeing
except
boeing
payment
kitson
see
bribery
public
officials
witnesses
compensation
members
congress
officers
others
matters
affecting
government
preemployment
payments
mere
offering
seeking
thereof
thus
criminal
provisions
justice
scalia
grammatical
analysis
post
misses
point
matter
whether
payment
made
officer
supplement
salary
officer
either
event
recipient
payment
must
officer
first
paragraph
whoever
government
official
employee
receives
salary
connection
services
official
employee
source
government
except
may
contributed
treasury
state
county
municipality
legislation
arose
desire
halt
bureau
education
practice
allowing
private
organizations
rockefeller
foundation
universities
pay
real
salaries
employees
bureau
pay
nominal
salary
one
dollar
year
decrying
activities
indulged
bureau
education
agencies
seem
inimical
education
youth
country
senator
chamberlain
oregon
proposed
following
addition
fiscal
year
appropriations
bill
part
appropriations
made
bureau
education
whether
salaries
expenses
purpose
connected
therewith
shall
used
connection
money
contributed
tendered
general
education
board
corporate
organization
individual
way
associated
either
directly
indirectly
contributed
tendered
corporation
individual
may
contributed
state
county
municipal
agencies
shall
bureau
education
receive
moneys
salaries
cong
rec
government
official
employee
shall
receive
salary
connection
services
official
employee
source
government
except
may
contributed
treasury
state
county
municipality
person
association
corporation
shall
make
contribution
way
supplement
salary
government
official
employee
services
performed
government
act
mar
ch
stat
act
june
ch
stat
reviser
note
official
code
explains
three
specific
changes
wording
mention
addition
change
appears
encompassed
reviser
conclusion
inor
changes
made
phraseology
supp
iv
see
association
bar
city
new
york
conflict
interest
federal
service
see
supra
attorney
general
kennedy
summary
memorandum
regarding
conflict
interest
provisions
public
law
fed
reg
reported
subsection
uses
much
language
former
vary
statute
substance
deletion
phrase
government
official
employee
suggested
least
proposed
amendment
house
antitrust
subcommittee
considered
pass
subcommittee
staff
found
phrase
clearly
cover
members
congress
judiciary
recommended
section
revised
address
hoever
receives
salary
contribution
supplementation
salary
connection
services
member
delegate
congress
resident
commissioner
officer
agent
employee
executive
legislative
judicial
branch
house
committee
judiciary
federal
conflict
interest
legislation
comm
print
like
proposed
amendment
dropped
government
official
clause
left
unqualified
hoever
receives
subject
yet
drafters
contemplate
effect
persons
yet
employed
government
one
purpose
bill
eliminate
inconsistency
overlap
conflicts
provisions
section
predecessor
statute
containing
phrase
government
official
employee
new
bill
replaced
phrase
different
terms
previously
used
uniform
phrase
officer
employee
executive
branch
government
independent
agency
district
columbia
supra
act
pub
stat
phrase
included
order
set
forth
point
prospective
public
official
comes
within
statutory
coverage
supra
stat
present
statute
even
specific
covering
services
rendered
rendered
either
personally
another
time
person
member
congress
member
congress
elect
delegate
delegate
elect
resident
commissioner
resident
commissioner
elect
time
person
officer
employee
executive
legislative
judicial
branch
government
agency
including
district
columbia
subsections
provide
nothing
herein
prevents
officer
employee
executive
branch
government
independent
agency
district
columbia
continuing
participate
bona
fide
pension
retirement
group
life
health
accident
insurance
stock
bonus
employee
welfare
benefit
plan
maintained
former
employer
section
apply
special
government
employee
officer
employee
government
serving
without
compensation
whether
special
government
employee
person
paying
contributing
supplementing
salary
conflict
interest
legislation
directed
evil
endangers
fabric
democratic
society
democracy
effective
people
faith
govern
faith
bound
shattered
high
officials
appointees
engage
activities
arouse
suspicions
malfeasance
corruption
mississippi
valley
generating
office
attorney
general
memorandum
regarding
conflict
interest
provisions
public
law
fed
reg
reach
long
recognized
serious
obstacle
recruitment
men
government
office
age
apt
vigorous
productive
association
bar
city
new
york
conflict
interest
federal
service
see
also
hearings
et
supra
memorandum
attorney
general
conflict
interest
statutes
appears
significant
problem
respecting
section
whether
discourages
recruitment
executives
private
industry
justice
scalia
justice
justice
kennedy
join
concurring
judgment
agree
government
failed
prove
petitioners
violated
claim
remedy
premised
upon
violation
accordingly
must
fail
reasons
however
somewhat
different
think
payments
made
term
federal
employment
necessarily
excluded
think
payments
neither
made
periodically
term
federal
service
calculated
reference
periodic
compensation
excluded
subsection
makes
criminally
liable
whoever
receives
salary
contribution
supplementation
salary
compensation
services
officer
employee
executive
branch
government
source
government
whoever
pays
makes
contribution
way
supplements
salary
officer
employee
circumstances
make
receipt
violation
subsection
apparently
concedes
first
clause
subsection
refers
someone
receives
salary
contribution
supplementation
salary
compensation
services
officer
employee
executive
branch
imply
recipient
must
officer
employee
time
receipt
reason
think
second
clause
imports
requirement
refers
someone
pays
makes
contribution
way
supplements
salary
officer
employee
perhaps
possible
pay
officer
officer
surely
possible
pay
contribute
supplement
salary
officer
possible
receive
payment
contribution
supplementation
salary
either
service
salary
pertains
completed
different
reason
unaddressed
agree
payment
present
case
covered
ii
ancient
sound
rule
construction
word
statute
possible
given
effect
interpretation
needlessly
renders
words
superfluous
suspect
seeking
hold
present
petitioners
liable
government
treats
though
read
hoever
receives
compensation
services
officer
employee
executive
branch
government
source
government
read
way
another
ethics
statutes
read
way
covering
receipt
payment
compensation
services
government
employee
relating
particular
matter
subsection
however
refer
whoever
receives
compensation
whoever
receives
salary
contribution
supplementation
salary
compensation
second
clause
seen
likewise
entirely
tied
salary
bad
construction
ignore
language
given
reasonable
meaning
interpretation
statute
particularly
bad
construction
ignore
criminal
statute
rule
lenity
applies
see
adamo
wrecking
salary
compensation
one
species
genus
recompense
consideration
paid
stipulated
paid
person
regular
intervals
services
fixed
compensation
regularly
paid
year
quarter
month
week
webster
second
new
international
dictionary
emphasis
added
see
also
benedict
word
salary
may
defined
generally
fixed
annual
periodical
payment
services
depending
upon
time
upon
amount
services
rendered
receive
salary
compensation
receive
periodic
payments
compensation
context
present
statute
must
reasonably
thought
receive
contribution
supplementation
salary
compensation
receive
contribution
supplementation
periodic
payments
sense
contribution
supplementation
must
periodic
read
differently
regard
single
payment
nongovernment
source
contribution
supplementation
salary
render
references
salary
superfluous
statute
might
well
prohibited
like
compensation
significant
office
personnel
management
sought
embody
substance
ethics
regulations
fashion
understood
mean
government
thinks
means
revised
references
contribution
supplementation
salary
follows
employee
shall
receive
salary
anything
monetary
value
private
source
compensation
services
government
cfr
government
official
employee
shall
receive
salary
connection
services
official
employee
source
government
person
association
corporation
shall
make
contribution
way
supplement
salary
government
official
employee
services
performed
government
act
mar
stat
whoever
government
official
employee
receives
salary
connection
services
official
employee
source
government
whoever
whether
person
association
corporation
makes
contribution
way
supplements
salary
government
official
employee
services
performed
government
stat
must
acknowledge
subsections
exclude
coverage
subsection
payments
periodic
payments
interpretation
described
successful
government
giving
effect
language
section
superfluous
exceptions
make
assurance
doubly
sure
common
phenomenon
insertion
utterly
pointless
language
center
substantive
restriction
moreover
since
shall
discuss
part
iii
government
foolish
apply
literally
interpretation
payments
compensation
covered
subsections
turn
largely
superfluous
view
statute
well
see
may
memorandum
office
legal
counsel
olc
advising
proposed
subsection
clarification
existing
law
rather
exemption
ed
op
atty
op
atty
case
granting
reasonable
implication
subsections
subsection
applies
payments
addition
periodic
payments
remains
true
reasonable
meaning
subsection
applies
exclusively
periodic
payments
even
one
think
meaning
trumps
implication
ambiguity
since
criminal
statute
rule
lenity
demands
resolved
favor
narrow
criminal
liability
may
seem
strange
nowadays
congress
think
categorically
criminalizing
periodic
payments
salary
supplementation
salary
rather
payments
government
employees
seemed
strange
substance
subsection
originally
enacted
existed
time
apparently
one
government
agency
regular
practice
hiring
nominal
salary
individuals
whose
real
compensation
paid
private
organizations
cong
rec
manning
federal
conflict
interest
law
cf
op
atty
comp
apart
fact
congress
often
acts
one
step
time
eliminate
one
abuse
become
focus
attention
allied
abuses
good
practical
reasons
payment
supplementation
salary
singled
surely
receipt
regular
salary
private
source
poses
greatest
risk
corruption
one
commonly
characterizes
corrupt
official
saying
someone
payroll
moreover
payment
supplementation
salary
categorically
eliminated
payments
without
criminalizing
large
number
harmless
perfectly
innocent
often
desirable
arrangements
example
rare
think
parents
make
periodic
payments
child
might
continue
government
job
proud
performing
wish
continue
suspect
rare
however
parents
make
occasional
gifts
child
leave
particularly
generous
bequest
precisely
end
mind
interpretation
adopted
government
act
generosity
rendered
accepted
objective
seemingly
violate
law
alone
think
reason
enough
criminalize
supplementation
salary
sense
government
us
understand
term
iii
must
address
length
seems
strongest
argument
interpreting
mean
says
fact
long
interpreted
differently
analysis
proves
weaker
consideration
one
might
suppose
indeed
long
unsatisfactory
experience
countertextual
interpretation
one
prime
reasons
adhering
congress
enacted
two
points
must
made
clear
outset
first
substantial
history
interpretation
exists
history
judicial
interpretation
years
predecessors
existence
discussed
passing
three
times
see
muschany
myers
international
davidson
prior
present
litigation
courts
appeals
discussed
three
times
see
oberhardt
raborn
muntain
app
district
courts
four
times
see
pezzello
supp
nd
tex
exchange
national
bank
chicago
abramson
supp
gerdel
supp
ed
mo
morse
sdny
one
scarce
judicial
references
district
opinion
explicitly
discusses
issue
salary
versus
payment
agreeing
government
position
discussion
moreover
admission
gratuitous
since
statute
way
issue
see
gerdel
supra
two
cases
one
district
one
appeals
relatively
recent
unchallenged
assumption
payments
covered
apparently
necessary
holding
see
oberhardt
supra
pezzello
supra
sum
government
position
supported
long
even
appreciable
body
judicial
interpretation
second
vast
body
administrative
interpretation
exists
innumerable
advisory
opinions
attorney
general
olc
office
government
ethics
also
comptroller
general
general
counsels
various
agencies
administrative
interpretation
entitled
deference
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
law
question
criminal
statute
administered
agency
courts
entirely
reasonable
understandable
federal
officials
make
available
employees
legal
advice
regarding
interpretation
general
way
agencies
government
must
interpret
order
assure
behavior
employees
lawful
must
interpret
innumerable
civil
criminal
provisions
order
operate
lawfully
sort
specific
responsibility
administering
law
triggers
chevron
justice
department
course
specific
responsibility
determine
statute
means
order
decide
prosecute
never
thought
interpretation
charged
prosecuting
criminal
statutes
entitled
deference
besides
unentitled
might
called
ex
officio
deference
chevron
expansive
administrative
interpretation
even
deserving
persuasive
effect
responsible
lawyer
advising
whether
particular
conduct
violates
criminal
statute
obviously
err
direction
inclusion
rather
exclusion
assuming
safe
side
statute
may
cover
entirely
apparent
tendency
reinforced
justice
department
knows
takes
erroneously
narrow
view
prosecute
error
likely
never
corrected
whereas
erroneously
broad
view
corrected
courts
prosecutions
brought
thus
give
persuasive
effect
government
expansive
interpretation
turn
normal
construction
criminal
statutes
replacing
doctrine
lenity
doctrine
severity
body
administrative
interpretation
nonetheless
useful
present
case
one
purpose
demonstrates
beyond
question
unmanageable
problems
arise
interpreted
written
limited
payment
supplementation
salary
administrative
history
record
poignant
attempts
attorney
general
olc
derive
reasonable
results
rigid
undiscriminating
criminal
statute
invented
follow
logic
glimpse
behind
looking
glass
example
employee
receipt
cash
awards
nonprofit
organizations
meritorious
public
service
unless
one
believes
statutory
term
compensation
predecessor
term
connection
imports
commonlaw
requirement
consideration
one
contends
difficult
imagine
payments
clearly
covered
cash
grants
conferred
specifically
reward
work
government
officials
justice
department
approved
first
olc
opinion
rendered
june
exemplifies
benign
unpredictable
discretion
guided
administrative
interpretation
criminal
statute
opinion
quotes
attorney
general
opinion
make
obvious
point
object
provision
government
official
employee
shall
serve
two
masters
prejudice
unbiased
devotion
interests
june
memorandum
olc
quoting
op
atty
continues
conflict
present
statute
liberally
construed
apply
situations
strictly
construed
might
held
applicable
appeared
violation
spirit
statute
june
memorandum
course
absurd
interpret
criminal
statute
basis
one
perception
whether
spirit
violated
doubly
absurd
interpret
prophylactic
measure
basis
whether
evil
prophylaxis
directed
fact
exists
olc
opinion
also
finds
award
subject
case
based
upon
relationship
payor
payee
usually
attends
may
expected
attend
application
statute
principle
far
tell
basis
law
government
assuredly
apply
statute
contexts
basis
reasoning
short
conflict
interest
legislative
history
statute
indicates
designed
prevent
created
opinion
approves
receipt
rockefeller
public
service
awards
established
grant
john
rockefeller
iii
later
olc
opinions
memoranda
continue
essentially
approach
awards
unified
mostly
extraordinary
principle
criminal
statute
violated
purposes
seem
offended
award
kind
far
removed
purposes
statutory
prohibition
covered
july
memorandum
olc
title
prohibits
payments
made
received
intent
reward
past
government
services
compensate
future
ones
intent
inferred
circumstances
particularly
past
prospective
connection
employee
payor
ability
employee
benefit
payor
performance
official
duties
office
advised
rockefeller
public
service
awards
prohibited
statute
intended
fact
give
rise
sort
dual
loyalty
designed
prevent
appear
true
payor
educational
institution
prize
payment
based
achievements
entered
government
one
factor
determinative
opinion
based
understanding
situation
receipt
award
prohibited
april
memorandum
olc
many
areas
besides
meritorious
awards
unworkability
government
interpretation
led
charitably
called
convoluted
reasoning
mention
two
attorney
general
opined
violate
predecessor
employee
department
commerce
dispatched
official
business
speech
business
organization
accept
organization
reimbursement
travel
expenses
hotel
bills
otherwise
bear
personally
extent
reasoning
follows
arrangement
proposed
officer
employee
concerned
personally
benefit
payments
outside
sources
paid
traveling
expenses
statute
violated
literally
may
said
contribution
officer
employee
services
performed
government
reality
contribution
government
furtherance
prejudice
interests
op
atty
finally
may
mention
opinion
attorney
general
robert
jackson
president
roosevelt
advising
predecessor
prohibit
universities
granting
leave
pay
faculty
members
serving
consultants
government
part
regular
sabbatical
program
enable
rendering
consulting
services
wartime
emergency
opinion
genuinely
devoid
analysis
unless
one
gives
name
ipse
dixit
payments
circumstances
made
respect
former
employment
incidental
leave
granted
made
connection
services
individual
official
employee
within
contemplation
statute
op
atty
mention
opinion
demonstrates
approach
necessitated
interpretation
expands
beyond
language
ultimately
quite
predictably
affect
even
proper
applications
statute
consultants
salaries
paid
universities
almost
precise
equivalent
employees
salaries
paid
foundations
last
example
shows
liberties
government
taken
interpretation
extent
appeal
anything
concrete
spirit
statute
rely
upon
phrase
compensation
predecessor
connection
proper
interpretation
eliminate
troublesome
phrase
eliminate
temptation
give
something
clear
constant
meaning
covers
payment
salary
little
difficulty
following
principle
statute
violated
reason
paying
salary
whole
part
recipient
status
work
recipient
performed
perform
federal
officer
employee
one
balks
applying
clear
principle
example
reimbursement
transportation
lodging
federal
employee
gives
speech
see
op
atty
meritorious
awards
see
memorandum
june
registration
fees
federal
employees
american
bar
association
meetings
entertainment
tickets
members
armed
services
many
situations
one
envision
criminal
statute
reasonable
enough
accorded
clear
interpretation
enacted
payments
consist
bribes
already
covered
compensation
services
particular
matter
already
covered
better
handled
administrative
prohibition
executive
order
president
authority
pursuant
see
exec
order
cfr
comp
agency
regulations
adopted
delegation
authority
operating
manner
executive
make
experiment
sorts
reasonable
distinctions
interpreted
cover
payments
honestly
said
permit
according
special
treatment
example
privately
paid
compensation
consists
cash
reimbursement
travel
subsistence
expenses
see
cfr
compensation
consists
awards
conferred
nonprofit
organization
see
cfr
cfr
iv
come
finally
applying
think
must
interpreted
facts
present
case
payments
recipients
lump
sums
perhaps
room
argument
nonetheless
fall
within
statute
existence
amounts
strictly
tied
period
federal
service
computed
basis
much
per
month
much
per
year
recipient
promised
serve
even
argument
eliminated
district
finding
severance
payments
contingent
upon
individuals
sic
entering
federal
government
service
remaining
government
service
stated
period
time
supp
ed
short
basis
holding
transpired
receipt
salary
contribution
supplementation
salary
within
meaning
therefore
agree
judgment
appeals
must
reversed
interpretation
one
possible
effect
salary
language
allow
unsalaried
government
officer
employee
receive
payment
services
private
source
result
payment
salary
contribution
supplementation
salary
since
salary
exists
supplemented
contributed
even
effect
strangely
contrived
largely
completely
eliminated
subsection
entirely
excludes
section
coverage
special
government
employees
defined
uncompensated
government
officers
employees
class
remains
possible
recipient
payments
obscurely
validated
otherwise
pointless
salary
language
consists
government
officers
employees
special
employees
compensated
manner
payment
salary
aware
class
exists
olc
opinion
notes
apparently
misses
delicious
irony
fact
sponsor
original
version
objected
particularly
employment
persons
whose
actual
salary
paid
rockefeller
carnegie
foundations
june
memorandum
olc
interesting
note
three
years
olc
opinion
comptroller
general
given
advice
receipt
rockefeller
public
service
awards
violate
comp
time
grants
cash
gifts
continuing
grants
tuition
travel
living
expenses
educational
facilities
hard
see
government
theory
made
difference
limited
discussion
text
justice
department
opinions
comptroller
general
rational
consider
example
following
donations
cash
employees
private
sources
therefore
prohibited
even
though
money
used
purchase
transportation
tickets
hotel
accommodations
however
services
furnished
kind
believe
different
conclusion
justifiable
comp