phosphate
export
argued
october
decided
november
government
filed
civil
antitrust
action
appellee
association
member
firms
charging
violations
sherman
act
regard
sales
association
concentrated
phosphate
republic
korea
foreign
aid
program
two
cases
government
let
contracts
remaining
nine
let
agency
korean
government
agency
international
development
aid
retained
effective
control
transactions
approving
procurement
financing
thereof
shipping
trial
upheld
appellees
contention
exempt
antitrust
liability
act
acts
done
course
export
trade
appellee
association
since
dissolved
alleging
recent
aid
regulation
made
continued
operation
uneconomical
held
case
moot
pp
government
sought
relief
association
also
members
pp
aid
regulation
apply
contracts
former
members
association
might
bid
appellees
statement
uneconomical
engage
joint
operations
standing
alone
satisfy
stringent
test
mootness
appellees
may
show
remand
likelihood
violations
sufficiently
remote
make
injunctive
relief
unnecessary
pp
antitrust
exemption
act
enacted
extend
foreign
trade
without
significantly
injuring
american
consumers
insulate
transactions
initiated
controlled
financed
government
merely
foreign
government
nominal
purchaser
pp
economic
reality
transactions
shows
american
participation
overwhelmingly
dominant
foreign
elements
comparatively
insignificant
burden
noncompetitive
pricing
fell
foreign
purchaser
american
taxpayer
stretches
neither
language
purpose
act
determine
sales
exports
pp
contracts
involved
world
major
trading
nations
ineligible
compete
procurement
limited
essentially
underdeveloped
countries
major
impact
permitting
combination
appellees
desire
encourage
exports
deprive
americans
main
benefits
competition
among
american
firms
deputy
attorney
general
christopher
argued
cause
brief
solicitor
general
griswold
acting
assistant
attorney
general
zimmerman
lawrence
wallace
howard
shapiro
samuel
murphy
argued
cause
appellees
brief
marcus
hollabaugh
alan
ward
concentrated
phosphate
export
murphy
andrew
kilcarr
american
cyanamid
lawrence
mckay
jerrold
van
cise
grace
edgar
barton
international
minerals
chemical
edward
howrey
john
bodner
mobil
oil
alfred
berman
randolph
guggenheimer
tennessee
appellees
justice
marshall
delivered
opinion
involved
case
sales
concentrated
phosphate
made
appellee
association
phosphate
supplied
association
members
producers
fertilizer
shipped
republic
korea
foreign
aid
program
government
civil
antitrust
complaint
filed
december
contended
concerted
activities
association
members
regard
sales
violated
sherman
act
stat
amended
appellees
defended
ground
inter
alia
activities
exempted
antitrust
liability
act
stat
act
done
course
export
trade
trial
held
act
immunize
appellees
conduct
supp
dismissed
complaint
government
perfected
direct
appeal
expediting
act
stat
amended
probable
jurisdiction
noted
two
factors
make
argument
untenable
first
dissolved
association
defendant
case
government
sought
injunctive
relief
association
members
well
prohibited
forming
new
export
associations
without
approval
continuing
effect
prices
jointly
agreed
upon
therefore
even
dissolution
made
impossible
frame
effective
relief
association
party
difficulty
secondly
new
aid
regulation
apply
contracts
former
members
association
might
bid
whenever
foreign
bidders
eligible
aid
still
permits
american
associations
compete
fact
foreign
bidders
eligible
transactions
gave
rise
suit
therefore
however
much
new
regulation
may
reduce
practical
importance
case
completely
remove
controversy
absent
relief
prayed
appellees
free
act
concert
certain
situations
government
contends
must
compete
test
mootness
cases
stringent
one
mere
voluntary
cessation
allegedly
illegal
conduct
moot
case
courts
compelled
leave
defendant
free
return
old
ways
grant
see
freight
case
might
become
moot
subsequent
events
made
absolutely
clear
allegedly
wrongful
behavior
reasonably
expected
recur
appellees
statement
uneconomical
engage
joint
operations
statement
standing
alone
suffice
satisfy
heavy
burden
persuasion
held
rests
upon
appellees
shoes
grant
course
still
open
appellees
show
remand
likelihood
violations
sufficiently
remote
make
injunctive
relief
unnecessary
matter
trial
judge
case
technically
moot
appeal
properly
taken
choice
decide
ii
transactions
involved
controlled
impressive
network
international
treaties
agreements
well
american
statutes
regulations
administrative
procedures
procurement
process
revealed
stipulated
record
rather
involved
began
funds
appropriated
congress
funds
allocated
various
development
programs
aid
accordance
provisions
applicable
statutes
aid
assessments
priorities
money
allocated
korea
process
simply
shipped
seoul
used
korea
wished
fact
never
left
country
accordance
series
agreements
korea
authorized
request
finance
purchases
certain
eligible
commodities
rather
complicated
procurement
authorization
application
prepared
aid
form
korean
signature
application
sets
forth
goods
purchased
also
rather
detailed
specifications
quality
delivery
plans
bidding
procedures
statement
explaining
korea
need
goods
even
though
aid
officials
obviously
must
participated
drafting
requests
aid
way
obligated
approve
agreement
korea
specifically
aid
may
decline
finance
specific
commodity
service
judgment
financing
inconsistent
purposes
grant
foreign
assistance
act
amended
transaction
approved
procurement
authorization
issued
aid
specifically
made
subject
detailed
regulations
specify
procedures
followed
awarding
contracts
also
contained
authorization
specified
american
bank
pay
goods
procured
aid
way
chosen
goods
purchased
either
two
methods
procurement
used
two
cases
government
let
contracts
general
services
administration
nine
cases
formal
act
letting
contracts
performed
office
supply
republic
korea
osrok
performing
task
koreans
subject
detailed
regulation
aid
invitation
bids
even
submitted
aid
circulated
country
documents
english
criteria
selecting
winning
contractors
carefully
defined
advance
abstract
bids
received
notice
naming
contractor
selected
sent
washington
finally
letter
credit
issued
supplier
paid
payor
bank
reimbursed
treasury
goods
shipped
consigned
osrok
aid
last
precaution
reserved
right
vest
title
action
necessary
assure
compliance
provisions
purposes
act
congress
cfr
asked
decide
whether
transactions
sort
constitute
act
done
course
export
trade
within
meaning
exemption
sherman
act
although
act
statute
books
half
century
first
time
called
upon
interpret
meaning
words
export
trade
upon
full
consideration
language
purpose
legislative
history
statute
reverse
judgment
iii
reading
act
confirmed
structure
legislative
history
act
contains
number
provisos
obviously
designed
protect
domestic
interests
combinations
congress
authorizing
act
done
export
association
restraint
trade
within
words
export
trade
exclude
among
things
selling
consumption
within
association
forbidden
enter
agreement
artificially
intentionally
enhances
depresses
prices
within
substantially
lessens
competition
within
otherwise
restrains
trade
therein
legislative
history
even
explicit
hearings
bill
one
congressman
charles
carlin
virginia
stated
clearly
later
one
dominant
themes
floor
debate
question
addressed
chairman
federal
trade
commission
testifying
support
bill
said
frank
say
personally
sympathy
foreigner
pays
products
like
see
american
manufacturers
get
largest
price
possible
indirection
going
set
system
going
fix
higher
price
eventually
home
combination
suggested
bill
think
well
see
system
dangerous
one
hearings
house
committee
judiciary
atmosphere
act
passed
clear
congress
thought
increase
american
exports
depriving
foreigners
benefits
competition
among
american
firms
without
significant
way
injuring
american
consumers
cf
alkali
export
assn
validity
economic
judgment
us
question
quite
relevant
interpreting
language
congress
chose
question
us
whether
congress
meant
exemption
insulate
transactions
initiated
controlled
financed
american
government
foreign
government
nominal
purchaser
think
interpreting
antitrust
laws
bound
formal
conceptions
contract
law
simpson
union
oil
must
look
economic
reality
relevant
transactions
although
fertilizer
shipments
consigned
korea
although
cases
korea
formally
let
contracts
american
participation
overwhelmingly
dominant
feature
burden
noncompetitive
pricing
fell
foreign
purchaser
american
taxpayer
essence
furnishing
fertilizer
korea
aid
selected
commodity
determined
amount
purchased
controlled
contracting
process
paid
bill
foreign
elements
transactions
comparison
insignificant
stretches
neither
language
purpose
act
determine
sales
exports
appellees
contend
contrary
result
reached
competing
contracts
foreign
suppliers
evidently
contention
therefore
fall
within
class
congress
intended
allow
form
export
associations
aid
already
given
american
suppliers
great
competitive
advantages
battle
foreign
firms
governing
statute
requires
preference
american
procurement
foreign
assistance
act
stat
none
contracts
involved
major
trading
nations
world
eligible
compete
procurement
limited
essentially
underdeveloped
countries
say
american
producers
need
additional
stimulus
able
compete
strains
credulity
major
impact
allowing
combination
appellees
desire
encourage
american
exports
place
burden
noncompetitive
pricing
shoulders
american
taxpayer
whatever
impact
exports
might
clear
framers
act
intend
americans
deprived
main
benefits
competition
among
american
firms
since
relevant
aspects
transactions
involved
american
korean
hold
export
trade
within
meaning
act
remand
district
may
decide
issues
relevant
resolution
controversy
reversed
footnotes
nothing
contained
sections
title
shall
construed
declaring
illegal
association
entered
sole
purpose
engaging
export
trade
actually
engaged
solely
export
trade
agreement
made
act
done
course
export
trade
association
provided
association
agreement
act
restraint
trade
within
restraint
export
trade
domestic
competitor
association
provided
association
either
elsewhere
enter
agreement
understanding
conspiracy
act
artificially
intentionally
enhances
depresses
prices
within
commodities
class
exported
association
substantially
lessens
competition
within
otherwise
restrains
trade
therein
section
act
stat
defines
export
trade
solely
trade
commerce
goods
wares
merchandise
exported
course
exported
territory
thereof
foreign
nation
words
export
trade
shall
deemed
include
production
manufacture
selling
consumption
resale
within
territory
thereof
goods
wares
merchandise
act
course
production
manufacture
selling
consumption
resale
fed
reg
codified
cfr
appendix
amended
regulation
applies
certain
specified
commodities
motion
affirm
dismiss
see
aid
operations
report
fiscal
year
large
percentage
foreign
aid
procurement
actually
coming
american
sources
exceeds
required
regulation
appellees
contend
economic
factors
dictated
dissolution
supra
government
argue
dissolution
related
fact
notice
appeal
case
filed
november
government
evidently
contest
export
status
two
fertilizer
sales
korea
made
one
paid
korea
foreign
exchange
funds
financed
special
stabilization
fund
granted
use
latter
fund
fully
controlled
grants
financed
purchases
involved
particular
limitation
specific
list
commodities
contained
record
program
assistance
grant
agreement
dated
november
appendix
although
agreement
applied
earlier
transactions
involved
stipulated
record
contains
examples
complete
compilation
documents
involved
case
earlier
agreements
included
record
contain
limitations
give
government
equivalent
powers
see
appendix
regulations
collected
cfr
government
raises
questions
various
provisos
included
act
accordingly
intimate
opinion
scope
brief
mention
congressional
debates
existence
american
loans
european
nations
whose
purchasing
power
might
reduced
higher
american
export
prices
see
cong
rec
isolated
statement
determine
meaning
statute
case
clear
america
world
war
loans
bear
little
resemblance
modern
foreign
aid
program
expected
repaid
also
loans
made
subject
detailed
american
administrative
control
typical
today
foreign
aid
program
justice
white
justice
stewart
joins
dissenting
majority
holds
today
concentrated
phosphate
shipped
american
firm
florida
republic
korea
solicited
bids
world
market
exports
within
meaning
act
stat
supplied
funds
korea
used
pay
purchases
retained
limited
power
control
expenditure
korea
obliged
repay
funds
directly
required
set
aside
proceeds
resale
phosphate
counterpart
funds
spent
ways
prescribed
decision
conforms
neither
plain
meaning
word
exports
underlying
purposes
act
statute
defines
export
trade
trade
goods
exported
course
exported
case
tons
concentrated
phosphate
shipped
directly
association
florida
korea
ordinary
sense
goods
exported
even
aid
regulations
refer
receiving
countries
importers
transactions
exports
cfr
district
found
aid
encouraged
least
tolerated
bidding
associations
transactions
exclusion
definition
exports
goods
sold
consumption
within
discussed
majority
application
case
parties
stipulated
since
phosphate
obviously
consumed
korea
contention
purely
domestic
trade
restrained
way
prices
enhanced
depressed
given
clarity
statute
need
resort
legislative
history
unexcelled
chemical
even
legislative
history
lends
support
majority
indeed
leads
contrary
conclusion
majority
asserts
congress
thought
increase
american
exports
ending
competition
foreign
shipments
among
american
firms
without
impairing
domestic
competition
correct
congress
recognized
trade
foreign
nations
ringed
antitrust
restrictions
keep
domestic
industry
competitive
congress
found
foreign
trusts
substantial
advantages
american
competitors
offer
extend
credit
fill
large
orders
single
american
firm
fill
maintain
staffs
keep
touch
foreign
demand
cheaply
single
american
seller
advertising
distribution
costs
generally
lower
separate
american
firms
made
findings
congress
concluded
american
firms
allowed
combine
achieve
lower
costs
lower
prices
comprehensive
effective
service
order
able
compete
equal
footing
foreign
shipments
transaction
american
goods
compete
foreign
goods
foreign
consumption
congress
objection
formation
american
associations
achieve
lower
prices
compete
foreign
suppliers
competition
involved
graphically
illustrated
fact
korean
purchases
involved
case
foreign
bidders
successful
capturing
least
part
market
government
admits
foreign
competition
never
absent
precisely
enable
american
firms
meet
competition
act
passed
moreover
kindness
american
taxpayer
carve
exception
forbidding
formation
associations
case
given
assumptions
act
passed
congress
specifically
discussed
phosphate
commodity
american
associations
necessary
order
achieve
savings
organization
enable
compete
foreign
cartels
price
service
without
associations
congress
concluded
american
firms
underbid
foreign
competitors
even
case
association
bidding
foreign
cartels
captured
business
majority
opinion
american
taxpayers
paying
american
dollars
buy
foreign
cartels
goods
obtained
cheaply
american
associations
employing
american
workers
congress
explicitly
found
associations
lead
lower
higher
prices
competition
foreign
suppliers
basis
joint
efforts
american
companies
export
trade
exempted
antitrust
laws
charged
duty
faithfully
execute
laws
honor
exemption
challenge
facile
assertions
act
chauvinistic
certainly
equipped
empowered
challenge
either
exemption
assumptions
rests
carve
exception
word
export
based
notions
sound
economic
policy
contradict
plain
words
statute
congressional
judgment
american
associations
necessary
lower
prices
combat
foreign
competition
exception
ever
justified
case
americans
paying
bill
also
foreign
competition
absent
case
two
transactions
challenged
general
services
administration
solicited
bids
korea
neither
government
finds
distinction
significant
funds
used
support
korean
american
military
establishments
korea
finance
public
works
generally
available
requested
indeed
even
government
statistics
relating
balance
payments
refer
shipments
exports
department
commerce
bureau
census
statistical
abstract
cfr
et
seq
see
sess
sess
hearings
senate
committee
interstate
commerce
thirteen
phosphate
purchases
made
korea
government
challenges
aid
regulations
apply
transactions
alone
foreign
bidders
captured
business
cong
rec
remarks
senator
kellogg