morton
salt
argued
december
decided
february
federal
trade
commission
act
commission
ordered
respondent
corporations
others
cease
desist
certain
trade
practices
appeals
affirmed
order
modifications
commanded
compliance
decree
directed
reports
compliance
filed
commission
within
days
reserved
jurisdiction
enter
orders
enforce
compliance
provided
without
prejudice
right
government
prosecute
suits
recover
civil
penalties
violations
order
initiate
contempt
proceedings
violations
decree
reports
compliance
filed
accepted
act
rule
practice
xxvi
commission
subsequently
ordered
respondents
file
special
reports
show
continuing
compliance
decree
held
order
invade
jurisdiction
appeals
pp
commission
continuing
duty
prevent
unfair
methods
competition
unfair
deceptive
acts
practices
commerce
suspended
exhausted
violator
whose
guilt
established
pp
although
commission
cease
desist
order
merged
decree
neither
assumed
denied
commission
agency
duty
inform
protect
commerce
continued
renewed
unlawful
practice
investigative
accusatory
duties
delegated
statute
administrative
body
like
commission
may
take
steps
inform
whether
probable
violation
law
without
first
making
charges
violations
pp
commission
order
special
reports
made
name
reliance
upon
judicial
powers
reliance
upon
powers
order
violate
administrative
procedure
act
respondents
put
notice
possibility
issuance
orders
commission
rule
xxvi
together
statement
organization
procedures
functions
meet
requirements
section
pp
commission
authority
act
require
special
reports
corporations
includes
special
reports
manner
complying
decrees
enforcing
cease
desist
orders
pp
use
commission
power
novel
unprecedented
commission
practice
require
different
result
since
power
granted
governmental
agencies
forfeited
nonuser
pp
language
clearly
broad
enough
authorize
issuance
order
question
pp
use
information
obtained
special
reports
limited
support
general
economic
surveys
president
congress
attorney
general
may
also
used
determining
whether
proper
compliance
decree
pp
special
reports
required
order
kind
commission
authorized
require
fact
applies
individuals
partnerships
corporations
apply
corporations
require
different
result
pp
commission
order
contravene
fourth
amendment
proscription
unreasonable
searches
seizures
due
process
clause
fifth
amendment
pp
agencies
legitimate
right
satisfy
corporate
behavior
consistent
law
public
interest
inquiry
within
authority
agency
demand
indefinite
information
sought
reasonably
relevant
exceed
investigatory
power
commission
face
commission
order
transgress
bounds
pp
courts
hold
order
commission
seeking
information
reports
arbitrarily
excessive
may
expect
supplicant
made
reasonable
efforts
commission
obtain
reasonable
conditions
petitioners
made
efforts
case
pp
decision
understood
holding
orders
exempt
judicial
examination
extending
license
exact
reports
reasonably
comprehended
within
term
used
congress
context
act
together
international
salt
also
certiorari
district
dismissed
suits
federal
trade
commission
act
compel
respondents
comply
order
federal
trade
commission
requiring
file
special
reports
recover
penalties
noncompliance
supp
appeals
affirmed
granted
certiorari
reversed
philip
elman
argued
cause
brief
solicitor
general
perlman
assistant
attorney
general
bergson
curtis
shears
roger
wollenberg
kelley
joseph
wright
mcbride
argued
cause
filed
brief
respondent
frederic
sanborn
argued
cause
filed
brief
respondent
justice
jackson
delivered
opinion
controversy
power
federal
trade
commission
require
corporations
file
reports
showing
complied
decree
appeals
enforcing
commission
cease
desist
order
addition
reports
required
decree
proceedings
federal
trade
commission
act
culminated
commission
order
requiring
respondents
morton
salt
company
international
salt
company
together
eighteen
salt
producers
trade
association
cease
desist
stated
practices
connection
pricing
producing
marketing
salt
appeals
seventh
circuit
affirmed
order
modifications
commanded
compliance
decree
directed
reports
manner
compliance
filed
commission
within
ninety
days
reserved
jurisdiction
enter
orders
herein
time
time
may
become
necessary
effectively
enforce
compliance
every
respect
decree
prevent
evasion
thereof
decree
expressly
without
prejudice
right
provided
section
federal
trade
commission
act
prosecute
suits
recover
civil
penalties
violations
said
modified
order
cease
desist
hereby
affirmed
without
prejudice
right
federal
trade
commission
initiate
contempt
proceedings
violations
decree
reports
compliance
subsequently
filed
accepted
matter
appears
rested
little
upwards
four
years
september
commission
ordered
additional
highly
particularized
reports
show
continuing
compliance
decree
done
without
application
authorized
provision
decree
provided
statute
commission
original
cease
desist
order
issued
new
order
recited
issued
commission
motion
pursuant
published
rule
practice
xxvi
authority
granted
subsections
trade
commission
act
ordered
parties
restrained
earlier
decree
file
within
thirty
days
additional
reports
showing
detail
manner
form
complying
said
modified
order
cease
desist
said
decree
demanded
producer
complete
statement
prices
terms
conditions
sale
salt
together
books
compilations
freight
rates
used
calculating
delivered
prices
price
lists
price
announcements
distributed
published
employed
marketing
salt
january
salt
producers
association
required
information
activities
services
association
producers
reported
satisfactorily
two
respondents
instead
informed
commission
general
terms
complied
decree
manner
previously
reported
doubted
commission
jurisdiction
require
reports
declined
supply
particulars
demanded
neither
asked
hearing
made
objection
scope
order
commission
next
gave
respondents
notices
asserting
default
calling
attention
penalties
provided
act
neither
respondent
asked
hearing
notice
default
suits
commenced
name
district
trade
commission
act
asking
mandatory
injunctions
commanding
respondents
report
directed
together
judgment
per
day
default
continued
respondents
answered
sides
moved
summary
judgments
found
dispute
material
facts
dismissed
complaints
want
jurisdiction
supp
appeals
divided
vote
affirmed
granted
certiorari
case
involved
issues
importance
enforcement
act
decrees
acts
provide
similar
methods
enforce
orders
administrative
bodies
government
suits
commission
order
challenged
upon
variety
grounds
considered
appeals
include
contentions
order
constitutes
interference
decree
invasion
powers
appeals
commission
rule
xxvi
ultra
vires
violates
federal
administrative
procedure
act
stat
et
seq
procedure
unauthorized
sections
act
based
novel
arbitrary
violates
fourth
fifth
amendments
constitution
reasons
given
reject
contentions
invasion
appeals
jurisdiction
seems
conceded
however
power
duty
independently
decree
must
still
resided
commission
certainly
entry
decree
wholly
relieve
commission
responsibility
enforcement
decree
recognized
left
commission
right
hence
responsibility
initiate
contempt
proceedings
violation
decree
must
contemplated
commission
obtain
accurate
information
time
time
base
responsible
conclusion
cause
proceeding
decree
also
required
original
report
showing
manner
form
respondent
compliance
filed
commission
presumably
commission
expected
scrutinize
insufficient
face
reject
move
take
notice
default
duty
likewise
left
upon
commission
move
respondent
made
false
report
duty
appear
temporary
compliance
truly
reported
conduct
resumed
violate
decree
addition
trade
commission
continuing
duty
prevent
unfair
methods
competition
unfair
deceptive
acts
practices
commerce
responsibility
within
coverage
act
suspended
exhausted
violator
whose
guilt
established
commission
petitioned
order
additional
reports
compliance
properly
required
present
evidence
probable
violation
overcome
presumption
legality
innocence
obedience
law
respondents
urge
courts
hesitate
alter
supplement
decrees
except
need
proved
well
asserted
evidence
commission
suspicion
let
us
say
curiosity
whether
respondents
reported
reformation
business
methods
abiding
one
must
decree
single
report
compliance
rest
upon
respondents
honor
unless
evidence
violation
fortuitously
comes
commission
may
commission
view
residual
duty
enforcement
affirmatively
satisfy
decree
observed
whether
usurps
courts
function
think
answered
consideration
fundamental
relationship
courts
administrative
bodies
trade
commission
act
one
several
congress
make
policy
effective
relied
upon
initiative
administrative
officials
flexibility
administrative
process
agencies
provided
staffs
institute
proceedings
follow
decrees
police
obedience
process
times
adversary
also
times
inquisitorial
agencies
expected
ascertain
proceedings
set
motion
take
lead
following
effective
results
expected
combination
duty
power
always
result
earnest
eager
action
feared
may
sometimes
result
harsh
overzealous
action
protect
mistaken
arbitrary
orders
judicial
review
provided
function
dispassionate
disinterested
adjudication
unmixed
concern
success
either
prosecution
defense
courts
expected
start
wheels
moving
follow
judgments
courts
neither
need
sleuths
dig
evidence
staffs
analyze
reports
personnel
prepare
prosecutions
contempts
indeed
situations
force
judge
pass
contempt
issues
raises
regretted
whenever
sense
must
become
prosecutor
occasions
needlessly
multiplied
denying
investigative
prosecutive
powers
lawful
agencies
case
advisedly
left
commission
receive
report
compliance
institute
contempt
proceedings
harmony
system
process
adjudication
complete
judgments
handed
litigant
executive
officers
sheriff
marshal
execute
steps
litigant
executive
department
lawfully
takes
enforcement
vindication
rather
usurpation
power
case
us
true
commission
cease
desist
order
merged
decree
neither
assumed
denied
commission
agency
duty
inform
protect
commerce
continued
renewed
unlawful
practice
case
illustrates
difference
judicial
function
function
commission
attempting
perform
respondents
argue
since
commission
made
charge
violation
either
decree
statute
engaged
mere
fishing
expedition
see
turn
evidence
guilt
assume
argument
courts
often
disapproved
employment
judicial
process
enterprise
federal
judicial
power
extends
adjudication
cases
controversies
natural
investigative
powers
jealously
confined
ends
judicial
subpoena
power
subject
specific
constitutional
limitations
also
apply
administrative
orders
unreasonable
search
seizure
due
process
law
also
subject
limitations
inherent
body
issues
provisions
judiciary
article
constitution
must
disguise
fact
sometimes
especially
early
history
federal
administrative
tribunal
courts
persuaded
engraft
judicial
limitations
upon
administrative
process
courts
go
fishing
followed
neither
anyone
else
administrative
investigations
fell
colorful
nostalgic
slogan
fishing
expeditions
must
forgotten
administrative
process
agencies
relative
newcomers
field
law
taken
continue
take
experience
trial
error
fit
process
system
judicature
recent
views
tolerant
underlay
many
older
decisions
compare
jones
securities
exchange
morgan
power
involved
power
get
information
best
give
interested
judicial
power
reluctant
unable
summon
evidence
shown
relevant
issues
litigation
follow
administrative
agency
charged
seeing
laws
enforced
may
exercise
powers
original
inquiry
power
inquisition
one
chooses
call
derived
judicial
function
analogous
grand
jury
depend
case
controversy
power
get
evidence
investigate
merely
suspicion
law
violated
even
wants
assurance
investigative
accusatory
duties
delegated
statute
administrative
body
may
take
steps
inform
whether
probable
violation
law
course
commission
intrude
upon
usurp
function
adjudication
decree
always
makes
jurisdiction
review
remains
exclusive
judgment
final
commission
done
however
modify
follow
decree
asked
report
name
reliance
upon
judicial
powers
reliance
upon
powers
congress
regard
judicial
function
investigate
compliance
decrees
least
initially
shown
action
antitrust
decrees
section
act
consideration
specifically
authorizes
commission
initiative
without
leave
investigate
compliance
final
decrees
cases
prosecuted
attorney
general
involving
commission
party
congress
obviously
deemed
function
commission
rather
courts
probe
compliance
decrees
even
part
obtaining
surely
fear
involve
collision
judicial
function
congress
omitted
express
authorization
commission
follow
decrees
cases
express
grant
power
seem
necessary
decrees
commission
interest
whether
commission
invaded
private
right
respondents
consider
later
rubrics
concern
present
heading
whether
commission
order
infringes
prerogatives
hold
ii
violation
administrative
procedure
act
thus
act
requires
every
agency
applies
includes
federal
trade
commission
publish
federal
register
certain
statements
rules
organization
procedure
including
nature
requirements
formal
informal
procedures
available
adds
person
shall
manner
required
resort
organization
procedure
published
addition
proscribes
requirement
report
investigative
demand
manner
purpose
except
authorized
law
principally
basis
two
sections
respondents
contend
current
order
enforced
except
violation
administrative
procedure
act
respondents
ordered
comply
procedure
put
notice
publication
federal
register
extent
procedure
defined
published
authorized
law
pertinent
provisions
administrative
procedure
act
became
effective
september
december
federal
trade
commission
published
federal
register
rules
practice
fed
reg
commission
rule
xxvi
republished
without
change
fed
reg
sets
time
limit
filing
initial
reports
compliance
commission
orders
asserts
commission
right
require
within
sound
discretion
filing
compliance
reports
thereafter
statement
organization
procedures
functions
fed
reg
commission
restated
right
require
order
supplemental
reports
compliance
considers
warranted
defined
contents
report
conclude
commission
published
rule
xxvi
announced
right
claims
case
demand
party
enforcement
decree
entered
file
commission
time
time
thereafter
reports
writing
setting
forth
detail
manner
form
complying
said
order
taken
together
commission
statement
organization
procedures
functions
supra
indeed
rule
xxvi
amply
met
requirements
administrative
procedure
act
respondents
hardly
challenge
conclusion
subtle
argument
requirement
supplemental
reports
following
enforcement
commission
order
unauthorized
statute
ultra
vires
valid
notice
rule
xxvi
given
required
administrative
procedure
act
also
said
direct
violation
act
leads
question
statutory
authority
order
report
question
must
determine
even
apart
consideration
administrative
procedure
act
accordingly
turn
federal
trade
commission
act
see
whether
contains
statutory
authority
commission
rule
xxvi
well
order
sought
enforced
issued
pursuant
procedures
proclaimed
rule
find
statutory
authority
must
conclude
objections
administrative
procedure
act
taken
vain
iii
statutory
authority
require
reports
root
position
lies
elaborate
plausible
argument
respondents
act
set
independent
exclusive
procedures
dealing
different
matters
therefore
neither
section
supported
aided
respondents
also
say
present
use
asserted
power
novel
unprecedented
commission
practice
introduces
new
method
investigating
compliance
respondents
without
statements
commission
officials
dicta
judicial
opinions
views
text
writers
facts
legislative
history
give
support
theory
never
called
upon
deal
consciously
squarely
subject
fact
powers
long
unexercised
well
may
call
close
scrutiny
whether
exist
granted
lost
allowed
lie
dormant
nonexistent
powers
prescripted
unchallenged
exercise
know
unquestioned
powers
sometimes
unexercised
lack
funds
motives
expediency
competition
immediately
important
concerns
find
basis
holding
power
ever
granted
trade
commission
forfeited
nonuser
commission
organic
act
comprehensively
provides
substantive
procedural
rules
checking
unfair
methods
competition
procedure
complete
complaint
service
process
final
order
review
enforcement
proceedings
recover
penalties
sued
entire
subject
unfair
competition
true
came
bill
late
legislative
history
dealt
commercial
evil
quite
different
target
prior
antitrust
laws
noted
however
although
complete
otherwise
section
confers
power
investigate
matter
power
without
others
vain
must
found
sections
act
commission
power
investigate
compliance
order
turned
authorizes
require
certain
reports
expressly
applicable
case
respondents
say
might
better
turned
authorizes
send
investigators
examine
books
copy
documents
issue
subpoenas
expressly
applicable
proceedings
section
commission
relies
adds
among
things
exceptions
material
power
investigate
time
time
organization
business
conduct
practices
management
corporation
engaged
commerce
relation
corporations
individuals
associations
partnerships
also
authorizes
commission
require
general
special
orders
corporations
engaged
commerce
file
commission
form
commission
may
prescribe
annual
special
annual
special
reports
answers
writing
specific
questions
furnishing
commission
information
may
require
organization
business
conduct
practices
management
relation
corporations
partnerships
individuals
respective
corporations
filing
reports
answers
writing
one
informed
fact
apart
text
appear
grant
ample
power
order
reports
question
respondents
class
subject
inquiry
call
appears
special
report
matter
reported
seem
business
conduct
practices
commission
authorized
inquire
respondents
advance
several
arguments
persuade
us
seemingly
comprehensive
power
subject
limitations
evident
text
respondents
derive
legislative
history
contention
congress
divided
duties
powers
commission
two
separate
categories
one
merely
old
powers
investigation
publicity
antitrust
matters
essentially
mere
continuance
former
powers
old
bureau
corporations
new
power
sealed
argued
reports
set
forth
required
support
general
economic
surveys
aid
enforcement
proceedings
section
find
good
deal
warrant
concluding
framed
antitrust
laws
mind
expectation
information
procured
chiefly
useful
reports
president
congress
attorney
general
find
nothing
deny
use
purpose
within
duties
commission
including
proceeding
construction
act
allow
information
obtained
part
commission
functions
require
commission
pursue
rest
duties
information
exist
unusual
say
least
information
commission
authorized
obtain
think
required
use
determining
whether
proper
compliance
decree
case
argued
however
agreed
special
report
authorized
statute
embrace
one
asked
method
compliance
decree
find
nothing
legislative
history
justify
limiting
meaning
special
reports
holding
report
asked
one
house
committee
report
sess
thought
sustained
respondents
contention
read
context
support
commission
speaking
became
section
report
said
commission
section
may
also
require
special
reports
may
deem
advisable
means
ordinary
data
furnished
corporation
annual
reports
adequately
disclose
organization
financial
condition
business
practices
relation
corporations
obtained
special
report
additional
information
commission
may
deem
necessary
annual
report
corporation
recurrent
relatively
standardized
affair
special
report
used
enable
commission
elicit
information
beyond
ordinary
date
routine
annual
report
report
asked
special
report
hard
put
define
one
fact
applies
individuals
partnerships
corporations
apply
corporations
lead
us
conclude
act
must
read
integrated
whole
argument
reporting
penalty
provisions
latter
extend
corporations
must
invoked
implement
corporations
proceeding
contemplates
action
persons
partnerships
well
force
sound
reason
drastic
powers
compel
disclosure
corporations
natural
persons
former
may
compelled
disclose
without
objection
latter
may
withhold
reveal
exacting
price
immunity
prosecution
corporations
constitutional
immunity
disparity
artificial
natural
persons
significant
differing
treatment
rarely
urged
objection
particular
construction
statute
moreover
congress
may
considered
volume
proportion
unincorporated
business
relatively
small
size
individually
owned
enterprises
even
lesser
capacity
disposition
resist
made
possible
omit
persons
duties
penalties
imposed
artificial
combinations
capital
conclude
authority
commission
require
special
reports
corporations
includes
special
reports
manner
complying
decrees
enforcing
cease
desist
orders
iv
rights
fourth
fifth
amendments
unnecessary
examine
question
whether
corporation
entitled
protection
fourth
amendment
cf
oklahoma
press
publishing
walling
although
right
let
alone
comprehensive
rights
right
valued
civilized
men
brandeis
dissenting
olmstead
confined
literally
searches
seizures
extends
well
orderly
taking
compulsion
process
boyd
hale
henkel
neither
incorporated
unincorporated
associations
plead
unqualified
right
conduct
affairs
secret
hale
henkel
supra
white
may
protection
unlawful
demands
made
name
public
investigation
cf
federal
trade
american
tobacco
corporations
claim
equality
individuals
enjoyment
right
privacy
cf
white
supra
endowed
public
attributes
collective
impact
upon
society
derive
privilege
acting
artificial
entities
federal
government
allows
privilege
engaging
interstate
commerce
favors
government
often
carry
enhanced
measure
regulation
cf
graham
brotherhood
locomotive
firemen
steele
louisville
nashville
tunstall
brotherhood
locomotive
firemen
enginemen
wickard
filburn
even
one
regard
request
information
case
caused
nothing
official
curiosity
nevertheless
agencies
legitimate
right
satisfy
corporate
behavior
consistent
law
public
interest
course
governmental
investigation
corporate
matters
may
sweeping
nature
unrelated
matter
properly
inquiry
exceed
investigatory
power
federal
trade
american
tobacco
supra
sufficient
inquiry
within
authority
agency
demand
indefinite
information
sought
reasonably
relevant
gist
protection
requirement
expressed
terms
disclosure
sought
shall
unreasonable
oklahoma
press
publishing
walling
nothing
face
commission
order
transgressed
bounds
consider
whether
reasons
peculiar
cases
apparent
face
orders
limits
transgressed
questions
presented
procedure
followed
respondents
courts
hold
order
seeking
information
reports
arbitrarily
excessive
may
expect
supplicant
made
reasonable
efforts
commission
obtain
reasonable
conditions
neither
respondent
raised
objection
order
sweep
asked
modification
clarification
interpretation
challenged
instead
power
issue
position
commission
authority
issue
reasonable
order
unreasonable
one
defense
action
course
limits
name
reports
commission
may
demand
limits
attempt
define
abstract
safe
say
stop
commission
considerably
short
extravagant
example
used
one
respondents
fears
sustain
order
commission
may
require
reports
automobile
companies
include
filing
automobiles
case
doubt
read
order
respondents
ask
require
shipment
extensive
files
gifts
expensive
books
necessary
reading
certainly
parties
decree
seem
able
satisfy
requirements
respondents
objected
terms
order
presented
least
offered
present
evidence
concerning
records
required
cost
books
matters
rest
mere
assertions
briefs
commission
opportunity
disclaim
inadvertent
excesses
justify
demands
record
think
respondents
obtained
reasonable
modifications
necessary
least
made
record
convince
us
measure
grievance
rather
ask
us
assume
argued
sustain
use
power
unconfined
arbitrary
exercise
subject
judicial
review
control
unless
government
brings
suit
penalties
government
said
may
delay
action
ruinous
penalties
accumulate
defendant
runs
risk
defenses
sustained
however
prepared
say
courts
powerless
effort
clarify
modify
order
still
considered
arbitrary
unlawful
government
pursues
policy
accumulating
penalties
avoiding
judicial
test
refusing
bring
action
recover
since
think
record
presents
question
undertake
determine
whether
declaratory
judgment
act
administrative
procedure
act
general
equitable
powers
courts
afford
remedy
shown
wrong
consequences
chance
given
test
reasonable
objections
order
cf
oklahoma
operating
love
enough
say
upholding
order
upon
record
understood
holding
orders
exempt
judicial
examination
extending
license
exact
reports
reasonably
comprehended
within
term
used
congress
context
act
judgment
accordingly
reversed
footnotes
see
note
infra
example
one
respondents
frankly
time
respondent
attempted
argue
immune
investigation
federal
trade
commission
simply
virtue
original
case
come
within
jurisdiction
appeals
respondent
assumes
manner
commission
chooses
continue
police
compliance
respondent
appropriate
investigatory
procedures
whether
appropriate
procedure
petitioning
appeals
permission
investigate
respondent
view
possible
contempt
section
proceedings
assertion
right
investigation
section
even
though
investigation
supplemental
appeals
decree
assertion
alleged
inherent
right
investigation
section
matter
law
issue
case
represents
issue
respondent
moment
completely
indifferent
reports
showing
compliance
orders
stipulations
every
case
order
cease
desist
issued
commission
purpose
preventing
violations
law
every
instance
commission
approves
accepts
stipulation
party
agrees
cease
desist
unlawful
methods
acts
practices
involved
respondents
named
orders
parties
stipulating
shall
file
commission
within
sixty
days
service
order
within
sixty
days
approval
stipulation
report
writing
setting
forth
detail
manner
form
complied
said
order
said
stipulation
provided
however
within
said
sixty
day
period
respondent
shall
file
petition
review
circuit
appeals
time
filing
report
compliance
begin
run
de
novo
final
judicial
determination
within
sound
discretion
commission
may
require
respondent
upon
order
served
party
entering
stipulation
file
commission
time
time
thereafter
reports
writing
setting
forth
detail
manner
form
complying
said
order
said
stipulation
compliance
enforcement
reports
compliance
orders
cease
desist
required
accordance
provisions
rules
practice
commission
may
order
require
supplemental
reports
compliance
considers
warranted
reports
compliance
must
consist
full
statement
showing
manner
form
order
complied
mere
statements
respondent
violating
order
acceptable
factual
showing
required
sufficient
enable
commission
appraise
manner
form
compliance
order
cease
desist
issued
commission
pursuant
federal
trade
commission
act
become
final
provided
section
act
commission
reason
believe
respondent
violated
order
shall
certify
facts
concerning
violation
attorney
general
may
institute
suit
one
district
courts
recovery
civil
penalties
provided
act
proceedings
federal
trade
commission
act
circuit
appeals
decree
commanded
obedience
commission
order
enforcement
may
accomplished
way
contempt
proceedings
circuit
respect
orders
various
provisions
clayton
act
enforcement
must
accomplished
way
contempt
proceedings