baumgartner
argued
april
decided
june
harold
evans
philadelphia
petitioner
charles
fahy
sol
washington
respondent
justice
frankfurter
delivered
opinion
september
district
western
district
missouri
entered
order
admitting
baumgartner
citizenship
issued
certificate
naturalization
almost
ten
years
later
august
brought
suit
nationality
act
stat
set
aside
naturalization
decree
cancel
certificate
district
entered
decree
government
circuit
appeals
eighth
circuit
one
judge
dissenting
affirmed
brought
case
raises
important
issues
proper
administration
law
affecting
naturalized
citizens
condition
receiving
american
citizenship
baumgartner
like
every
alien
applying
great
gift
required
declare
oath
renounced
former
allegiance
case
german
reich
defend
constitution
laws
america
enemies
foreign
domestic
true
faith
allegiance
truly
fully
renounce
allegiance
germany
fact
intend
support
constitution
laws
give
true
faith
allegiance
charges
fraud
illegality
citizenship
claimed
forfeit
true
determination
issues
falsity
fraud
case
depends
particular
facts
division
opinion
among
judges
makes
manifest
facts
assess
decisive
element
attitude
appropriate
judgment
facts
case
like
two
lower
courts
sustained
government
claim
expressions
baumgartner
conversations
others
soliloquies
diary
showed
consciously
withheld
complete
renunciation
allegiance
germany
entertained
reservations
oath
allegiance
country
constitution
laws
follows
fair
summary
evidence
finding
rests
putting
government
case
favorable
light
baumgartner
born
kiel
germany
january
brought
modestly
comfortable
circumstances
received
classical
education
completed
time
enter
german
army
commissioned
second
lieutenant
shortly
thereafter
captured
british
confined
england
november
upon
return
germany
baumgartner
studied
university
darmstadt
graduated
electrical
engineer
thereupon
employed
public
utility
company
january
left
shortly
baumgartner
married
wife
followed
country
later
year
three
months
baumgartner
stayed
friends
illinois
came
kansas
city
missouri
employed
kansas
city
power
light
company
continued
employ
time
suit
man
reported
work
testified
two
days
job
baumgartner
began
discuss
political
scene
germany
express
lack
enthusiasm
german
government
extol
virtues
hitler
movement
baumgartner
spoke
persistently
superiority
german
people
german
schools
engineering
work
germans
aroused
antagonism
among
transferred
different
section
plant
testimony
baumgartner
mother
visited
country
visit
baumgartner
beginning
work
hitler
bringing
germany
back
repeated
occasions
evidence
statements
made
baumgartner
period
seven
years
beginning
indicated
oftrepeated
admiration
nazi
government
comparisons
president
roosevelt
adolf
hitler
led
conclusions
country
better
run
hitler
ran
germany
regimentation
nazis
formed
sic
superior
democracy
democracy
practical
farce
one
witness
german
extraction
testified
baumgartner
told
traitor
country
witness
condemnation
hitler
baumgartner
made
public
speeches
least
three
occasions
businessmen
groups
clubs
like
told
accomplishments
nazi
government
indicated
glad
live
regime
hitler
baumgartner
conducted
sunday
school
class
former
students
testified
discussion
class
turned
germany
frequently
baumgartner
indicated
students
get
fairer
picture
conditions
germany
german
radio
germany
justified
much
school
superintendent
also
testified
received
complaints
baumgartner
preaching
nazism
baumgartner
resigned
country
club
congregational
church
kansas
city
objected
injection
politics
sermons
may
next
year
wife
three
children
born
kansas
city
went
germany
visit
baumgartner
parents
one
witness
testified
baumgartner
explained
trip
part
saying
wanted
children
brought
german
schools
war
broke
september
baumgartner
cabled
money
return
baumgartner
raise
necessary
funds
felt
family
safe
germany
baumgartner
remarked
wanted
wife
come
back
germany
german
boat
one
baumgartner
neighbors
testified
conversation
december
baumgartner
asked
daughter
germany
said
sarcastically
done
thing
joined
nazi
youth
movement
testimony
baumgartner
justified
german
invasions
late
announced
dunkerque
fell
rejoicing
one
witness
testified
baumgartner
told
order
called
diary
baumgartner
kept
december
summer
reveals
attended
meeting
german
vocational
league
german
national
anthem
sung
naturally
arose
assumed
usual
german
stance
arm
extended
give
national
socialist
greeting
diary
entries
reflect
violent
impatience
lack
militancy
approval
germans
americanized
ruined
finally
baumgartner
replied
affirmative
trial
judge
question
attitude
towards
principles
american
government
took
oath
ever
since
concurrent
findings
two
lower
courts
persuasive
proof
support
judgments
rule
wisdom
judicial
administration
reaffirming
importance
mean
pay
lip
service
rule
relieve
us
task
examining
foundation
findings
particular
case
measure
proof
requisite
denaturalize
citizen
schneiderman
held
proof
bring
loss
citizenship
must
clear
unequivocal
escape
conviction
case
made
government
lacks
solidity
proof
leaves
troubling
doubt
deciding
question
gravity
implied
attempt
reduce
person
status
alien
citizen
phrase
fact
may
summary
characterization
complicated
factors
varying
significance
judgment
fact
may
ultimate
judgment
mass
details
involving
merely
assessment
trustworthiness
witnesses
appropriate
inferences
may
drawn
living
testimony
elude
print
conclusiveness
fact
depends
nature
materials
finding
based
finding
even
fact
may
less
difficult
process
varying
according
simplicity
subtlety
type
controversy
finding
ultimate
clearly
implics
application
standards
law
fact
even
made
two
courts
may
go
beyond
determination
set
aside
though
labeled
fact
may
involve
basis
judgment
fallible
evidence
made
thus
conclusion
may
appropriately
drawn
whole
mass
evidence
always
ascertainment
kind
precludes
consideration
see
beyer
lefevre
particularly
decision
review
escape
broadly
social
lying
close
opinion
regarding
whole
nature
government
duties
immunities
citizenship
deference
properly
due
findings
lower
preclude
review
judgments
recognized
scope
appellate
review
usually
differentiated
review
ordinary
questions
fact
called
review
question
law
often
illuminating
test
never
suffice
say
emphasis
importance
unequivocal
convincing
proof
see
schneiderman
supra
page
page
rest
cancellation
certificate
naturalization
lost
ascertainment
lower
courts
whether
exacting
standard
proof
satisfied
whole
record
deemed
order
open
review
gravamen
government
complaint
findings
opinions
baumgartner
sciously
withheld
allegiance
constitution
laws
short
baumgartner
guilty
fraud
prove
intentional
misrepresentation
evidence
calculated
establish
objective
falsity
baumgartner
oath
adduced
nothing
else
offered
show
baumgartner
aware
conflict
views
new
political
allegiance
assumed
even
objective
falsity
perjurious
falsity
oath
deemed
sufficient
nationality
act
revoke
admission
citizenship
view
evidence
measure
standard
proof
must
applied
case
come
consideration
evidence
context
thatevidence
judged
congress
alone
entrusted
constitution
power
give
withhold
naturalization
end
establish
uniform
rule
naturalization
art
clause
exercising
power
congress
authorized
courts
grant
american
citizenship
alien
satisfied
conditions
imposed
congress
naturalization
naturalization
unless
statutory
requirements
complied
ginsberg
certificate
procured
prescribed
qualifications
existence
fact
may
canceled
suit
tutun
earliest
days
republic
congress
required
condition
citizenship
alien
renounce
foreign
allegiance
swear
allegiance
country
constitution
act
january
stat
requirement
congress
used
meaningless
words
hand
thereby
expressed
narrow
test
formula
susceptible
almost
mechanical
proof
true
prerequisites
residence
documentation
arrival
requisite
number
sponsoring
witnesses
like
allegiance
government
laws
compendious
phrase
describe
political
legal
institutions
enduring
features
american
political
society
dealing
test
expressing
broad
breadth
appropriate
nature
subject
matter
nothing
less
bonds
tie
americans
together
devotion
common
fealty
spacious
scope
conception
expressed
stating
constitution
made
undefined
expanding
future
people
gathered
gathered
many
nations
many
tongues
hurtado
california
dealing
words
also
constituent
act
like
constitution
must
realize
called
life
development
foreseen
completely
gifted
begetters
enough
realize
hope
created
organism
taken
century
cost
successors
much
sweat
blood
prove
created
nation
case
us
must
considered
light
whole
experience
merely
said
hundred
years
ago
state
missouri
holland
ascertain
fulfilment
test
implying
expansive
reach
presents
difficult
doubtful
problems
even
judges
presumably
trained
meaning
country
institutions
demands
citizens
constitution
naturalized
citizen
stands
equal
footing
native
citizen
respects
save
eligibility
presidency
luria
one
prerogatives
american
citizenship
right
criticize
public
men
means
informed
responsible
criticism
freedom
speak
foolishly
without
moderation
trust
good
sense
people
deliberate
reflection
goes
deep
contradictoriness
human
mind
expression
views
may
collide
cherished
american
ideals
necessarily
prove
want
devotion
nation
foolish
deny
even
blatant
intolerance
toward
presuppositions
democratic
faith
may
imply
rooted
disbelief
system
government
forswearing
past
political
allegiance
without
reservation
full
assumption
obligations
american
citizenship
inconsistent
cultural
feelings
imbedded
childhood
youth
period
new
strength
land
one
nativity
flamboyantly
exploited
full
sinister
meaning
adequately
revealed
even
americans
oldest
lineage
old
cultural
loyalty
well
known
stimulated
confusion
mind
sometimes
expressions
offensive
exuberance
denial
application
citizenship
judicial
mind
satisfied
test
allegiance
met
presents
problem
different
revocation
naturalization
certificate
admission
community
american
citizenship
decreed
doubt
statutory
procedure
naturalization
nationality
act
concerned
designed
afford
cumulative
protection
fraudulent
illegal
naturalization
ness
relaxation
vigor
appropriate
scrutinizing
intensity
allegiance
country
embraced
applicant
admitting
citizenship
corrected
meagre
standards
disproving
allegiance
retrospectively
new
relations
new
interests
flow
citizenship
granted
undone
unless
proof
compelling
granted
obtained
defiance
congressional
authority
specific
conditions
like
time
residence
required
number
supporting
witnesses
easily
established
established
leave
room
discretion
congress
left
area
discretion
claim
really
involves
issues
belief
fraud
proof
treacherous
objective
judgment
even
disciplined
minds
precarious
denaturalization
score
calls
weighty
proof
especially
proof
false
fraudulent
oath
rests
predominantly
upon
contemporaneous
evidence
established
later
expressions
opinion
argumentatively
projected
often
distorting
medium
memory
earlier
year
qualifications
citizenship
claimed
tested
adjudicated
idle
try
capture
confine
spirit
requirement
proof
within
fixed
form
words
exercise
judgment
course
large
fully
mindful
due
observance
law
governing
grant
citizenship
aliens
touches
nation
nothing
deciding
intended
weaken
slightest
alertness
admission
american
citizenship
safeguarded
must
equally
watchful
citizenship
bestowed
jeopardy
fear
exercising
american
freedom
easy
finding
citizenship
disloyally
acquired
sufficiently
indicated
considerations
policy
derived
traditions
people
require
solid
proof
citizenship
falsely
fraudulently
procured
considerations
must
guide
judicial
judgment
duty
exercising
judgment
evaded
illusory
definiteness
formula
insufficiency
evidence
show
baumgartner
renounce
allegiance
germany
need
labored
whatever
german
political
leanings
baumgartner
hitler
hitlerism
certainly
weimar
republic
hitler
come
power
baumgartner
forswore
allegiance
german
nation
views
attributed
baumgartner
superiority
german
people
schools
engineering
techniques
virtues
hitler
expressed
began
work
kansas
city
direct
evidence
introduced
show
naturalized
attitude
precluded
truly
honestly
taking
oath
allegiance
constitution
laws
statement
trial
attitude
toward
principles
american
government
time
trial
hardly
significant
baumgartner
professed
loyalty
trial
denied
explained
disturbing
statements
attributed
others
reconciled
suspicious
diary
entries
ways
preclude
validity
oath
allegiance
short
weakness
proof
baumgartner
state
mind
time
took
oath
allegiance
removed
presumption
disqualifying
views
expressed
naturalization
accurate
representations
views
took
oath
logical
validity
presumption
best
dubious
even
supporting
evidence
less
rhetorical
conclusive
baumgartner
certainly
shown
party
nazi
statement
one
witness
baumgartner
told
member
bund
hint
even
remotely
baumgartner
associated
group
systematic
agitation
nazi
views
views
hostile
government
contrary
baumgartner
diary
government
mainly
relies
reveals
attended
meeting
german
vocational
league
nazi
salute
given
apparently
experience
group
went
wanted
see
sort
organization
vocational
league
conclude
evidence
baumgartner
attitude
affords
insufficient
proof
knowing
reservations
forswearing
allegiance
weimar
republic
embracing
allegiance
country
warrant
infliction
grave
consequences
involved
making
alien
man
ten
years
admitted
citizenship
evidence
record
us
sufficiently
compelling
require
penalize
naturalized
citizen
expression
silly
even
views
citizens
utter
impunity
judgment
must
accordingly
reversed
case
manded
district
proceedings
inconsistent
opinion
ordered
reversed
remanded
directions
justice
murphy
issue
case
clear
government
sought
set
aside
petitioner
naturalization
certificate
alleged
fraudulent
illegal
procurement
thus
incumbent
government
meet
standard
proof
laid
schneiderman
presenting
evidence
unequivocal
convincing
character
leave
issue
doubt
whether
petitioner
fraudulently
illegally
procured
certificate
true
schneiderman
case
met
issue
whether
petitioner
case
illegally
procured
naturalization
certificate
time
naturalization
five
years
prior
thereto
behaved
person
attached
principles
constitution
well
disposed
good
order
happiness
expressly
pass
upon
charge
fraud
obtaining
certificate
primary
charge
present
proceeding
requirement
government
prove
case
unequivocal
convincing
evidence
transcends
particular
ground
upon
government
seeks
set
aside
naturalization
certificate
decision
schneiderman
case
merely
decision
isolated
case
formulation
majority
rule
law
governing
denaturalization
proceedings
rule
law
equally
applicable
whether
citizen
proceeding
brought
communist
nazi
follower
political
faith
requirement
proof
recognized
government
petitioner
us
instant
case
failure
government
present
evidence
unequivocal
convincing
nature
petitioner
fraudulently
illegally
procured
naturalization
certificate
patent
one
unimportant
exception
government
proved
petitioner
displayed
certain
nazi
sympathies
critical
several
years
competent
evidence
entertained
strong
beliefs
mental
reservations
forswearing
allegiance
veimar
republic
american
citizenship
right
granted
condition
subsequent
naturalized
citizen
refrain
future
uttering
remark
adopting
attitude
favorable
original
homeland
power
matter
distasteful
conduct
may
us
required
imprison
intellectual
spiritual
straightjacket
obliged
retain
static
mental
attitude
moreover
lose
precious
right
citizenship
subsequently
dares
critize
adopted
government
vituperative
defamatory
terms
obviously
difficult
conform
standard
set
forth
schneiderman
case
mere
proof
state
mind
subsequent
naturalization
proof
facts
existing
prior
time
naturalization
excuse
failure
meet
standard
naturalized
citizen
much
right
natural
born
citizen
exercise
cherished
freedoms
speech
press
religion
without
unequivocal
convincing
proof
bear
swear
true
allegiance
time
naturalization
denaturalized
proper
realization
principle
makes
clear
error
setting
aside
petitioner
naturalization
certificate
basis
facts
adduced
proceeding
justice
black
justice
douglas
justice
rutledge
join
opinion
footnotes
section
provides
shall
duty
district
attorneys
respective
districts
upon
affidavit
showing
good
cause
therefor
institute
proceedings
purpose
revoking
setting
aside
order
admitting
person
citizenship
canceling
certificate
naturalization
ground
fraud
ground
order
certificate
naturalization
illegally
procured
following
excerpts
baumgartner
diary
ones
ideas
jews
ideas
vile
mean
malicious
today
president
delivered
message
new
congress
speech
horrible
mixture
war
agitation
laughable
talk
freedom
press
speech
country
allegedly
protected
guns
drank
bottle
pschorr
brew
together
welfare
future
germany
fortress
heart
central
europe
fallen
terrible
defeat
named
powers
probably
difficult
time
recovering
listened
hitler
speech
krolls
opera
house
wonderful
usual
whole
country
influence
insane
actions
government
washington
character
wild
unbridled
despotism
retention
cultural
ties
despite
change
political
status
thus
put
distinguished
historian
gaetano
salvemini
speaking
naturalization
country
wider
area
generosity
least
europe
feeling
one
home
conquers
little
little
one
fine
day
feel
longer
exile
citizen
country
took
oath
felt
really
performing
grand
function
throwing
away
intellectual
moral
juristic
past
threw
away
without
regret
ethiopian
war
rape
albania
spanish
crime
last
idiotic
crime
really
broken
connection
sovereigns
potentates
ugly
things
enumerated
formula
oath
wonderful
formula
pledges
juridical
political
asked
sever
connections
government
former
country
people
civilization
former
country
asked
give
allegiance
constitution
adopted
country
ideal
life
radcliffe
quarterly
august
pp
denaturalization
proceeding
schneiderman
case
brought
provisions
act
june
stat
practically
identical
provisions
contained
nationality
act
stat
proceeding
instant
case
instituted
see
schneiderman
page
page
note