monia
argued
december
decided
january
appeal
district
northern
district
illinois
edward
miller
washington
appellant
hodson
chicago
appellees
justice
roberts
delivered
opinion
direct
appeal
district
northern
illinois
prosecuted
pursuant
criminal
appeals
act
presents
question
upon
lower
federal
courts
sharply
divided
question
whether
one
obedience
subpoena
appears
grand
jury
inquiring
alleged
violation
sherman
act
gives
testimony
oath
substantially
touching
alleged
offense
obtains
immunity
prosecution
offense
pursuant
terms
sherman
act
although
claim
privilege
incrimination
sherman
provides
part
person
shall
prosecuted
subjected
penalty
forfeiture
account
transaction
matter
thing
concerning
may
testify
produce
evidence
documentary
otherwise
proceeding
suit
prosecution
said
acts
interstate
commerce
act
sherman
act
acts
provided
person
testifying
shall
exempt
prosecution
punishment
perjury
committed
testifying
statute
supplemented
act
june
far
material
immunity
provisions
act
others
immunity
shall
extend
natural
person
obedience
subpoena
gives
testimony
oath
produces
evidence
documentary
otherwise
oath
indictment
returned
charging
corporations
individuals
including
two
appellees
conspiracy
fix
prices
violation
sherman
act
appellees
filed
special
pleas
bar
alleging
obedience
subpoena
duly
served
appeared
witness
grand
jury
inquiring
respecting
matters
charged
indictment
gave
testimony
substantially
connected
transactions
covered
indictment
question
made
testimony
given
substantially
relate
transactions
subject
indictment
demurred
pleas
insufficient
since
neither
alleged
witness
asserted
claim
privilege
therefore
neither
fifth
amendment
constitution
immunity
statute
avail
district
overruled
demurrers
ground
plain
mandate
statute
precluded
prosecution
appellees
whether
claimed
privilege
hold
decision
right
beyond
dispute
appellees
entitled
immunity
prosecution
statute
given
effect
written
asked
however
read
qualification
effect
immunity
obtained
unless
privilege
claimed
much
statute
addressed
privilege
privilege
accorded
fifth
amendment
said
immunity
offered
substitute
privilege
immunity
like
privilege
claimed
thus
statute
fifth
amendment
pari
materia
given
consistent
construction
second
place
urged
qualification
right
terms
statute
necessary
order
avoid
unreasonable
unfair
unintended
result
argument
runs
statute
construed
automatically
grant
immunity
without
claim
privilege
prosecutor
disadvantage
since
know
whether
extent
witness
may
participated
crime
runs
risk
unintentionally
affording
immunity
hand
said
witness
full
knowledge
nature
conduct
possible
incrimination
testimony
unfair
require
claim
privilege
put
prosecutor
notice
insists
upon
testimony
witness
obtain
immunity
well
understood
course
legislation
adoption
statute
involved
legislative
history
compel
rejection
contentions
fifth
amendment
declares
person
shall
compelled
criminal
case
witness
investigation
grand
jury
criminal
case
amendment
speaks
compulsion
preclude
witness
testifying
voluntarily
matters
may
incriminate
therefore
desires
protection
privilege
must
claim
considered
within
meaning
amendment
seventy
years
ago
congress
advised
suits
prosecuted
evidence
sought
certain
persons
used
government
interposed
claim
privilege
sustained
courts
order
forestall
obstruction
delay
incident
judicial
determination
validity
witness
claim
order
obtain
necessary
evidence
even
though
claim
well
founded
congress
adopted
act
february
became
act
applied
judicial
proceedings
provided
effect
evidence
obtained
witness
used
criminal
proceeding
counselman
hitchcock
held
act
unconstitutional
prevented
use
evidence
witness
preclude
prosecution
result
information
gained
testimony
indicated
clearly
nothing
short
absolute
immunity
justify
compelling
witness
testify
claimed
privilege
original
interstate
commerce
contained
immunity
provision
form
held
invalid
counselman
case
meet
decision
case
congress
passed
act
february
applied
proceedings
interstate
commerce
act
et
seq
statute
however
became
model
immunity
provisions
enacted
various
times
including
act
february
supra
concerned
sustained
constitutionality
acts
district
northern
district
illinois
held
armour
voluntary
appearance
furnishing
testimony
information
without
subpoena
operated
confer
immunity
prosecution
sherman
act
held
immunity
conferred
broader
privilege
given
fifth
amendment
decision
attracted
public
interest
since
stood
one
immunize
prosecution
volunteering
information
investigatory
bodies
congress
promptly
adopted
act
june
supra
providing
immunity
extend
natural
person
obedience
subpoena
testified
produced
evidence
oath
congressional
record
shows
sole
purpose
bill
exactly
language
senator
knox
sponsored
bill
stated
president
purpose
bill
clear
range
broad
intended
cover
disputed
provisions
rights
witnesses
circumstances
except
enumerated
bill
evident
congress
earlier
legislation
opened
door
practice
whereby
government
might
trapped
conferring
unintended
immunity
witnesses
volunteering
testify
amendment
thought
congressional
record
demonstrates
sufficient
protect
government
interests
preventing
immunity
unless
prosecuting
officer
government
official
concerned
compel
witness
attendance
subpoena
sworn
congress
evidence
intent
witness
desired
immunity
must
addition
assert
constitutional
privilege
series
acts
adopted
additional
provision
inserted
adding
requirement
acts
indicate
simple
add
similar
provision
applicable
interstate
commerce
act
sherman
act
others
allowed
stand
originally
enacted
save
amending
act
legislation
involved
instant
case
plain
terms
face
means
layman
subpoenaed
sworn
testifies
immunity
instead
trap
government
original
act
statutes
question
interpreted
government
desires
may
well
trap
witness
congress
evidently
intended
afford
government
officials
choice
subpoenaing
witness
putting
oath
knowledge
complete
immunity
prosecution
respecting
matter
substantially
connected
transactions
respect
testified
retaining
right
prosecute
foregoing
opportunity
examine
congress
intend
statutes
issue
provide
addition
witness
must
claim
privilege
seems
clear
us
add
legislation
congress
pretermitted
referred
diversity
views
amongst
lower
courts
government
insists
settled
question
favor
view
reliance
upon
heike
case
however
decided
immunity
conferred
legislation
question
intended
protect
witness
extent
fifth
amendment
protects
question
whether
immunity
extended
prosecution
crimes
matters
testified
remotely
connected
held
amendment
justify
claim
privilege
remote
contingencies
immunity
likewise
construed
reach
question
necessity
witness
investigatory
body
claiming
privilege
order
earn
immunity
decided
judgment
affirmed
affirmed
justice
frankfurter
dissenting
beyond
dispute
constitution
compel
congress
afford
immunity
prosecution
testify
without
invoking
constitutional
privilege
question
decision
whether
act
june
stat
amending
immunity
provision
act
february
stat
congress
granted
constitution
requires
offered
crime
heike
conferring
immunity
persons
testify
without
claiming
protection
privilege
way
indicate
testimony
given
return
statutory
immunity
words
congress
amendment
seek
facilitate
enforcement
law
making
available
compulsory
otherwise
got
passing
act
amnesty
question
answered
closing
eyes
everything
except
naked
words
act
june
notion
words
statute
plain
meaning
also
plain
merely
pernicious
oversimplification
wooden
english
doctrine
rather
recent
vintage
see
plucknett
concise
history
common
law
amos
interpretation
statutes
davies
interpretation
statutes
lip
service
occasion
given
since
days
marshall
rejected
especially
practice
fisher
cranch
boston
sand
american
trucking
statute
like
living
organisms
derives
significance
sustenance
environment
severed
without
mutilated
especially
true
statute
like
one
us
part
legislative
process
history
purpose
meaning
statute
gained
confining
inquiry
within
four
corners
historic
process
legislation
incomplete
gave
rise
well
gave
rise
yield
true
meaning
must
turn
history
federal
immunity
provisions
earliest
federal
statute
dealing
immunity
act
january
stat
amended
act
january
stat
legislation
relating
testimony
either
house
congress
furnished
model
later
immunity
provisions
congress
careful
state
precisely
immunity
given
witness
shall
hereafter
allowed
refuse
testify
fact
produce
paper
stat
italics
added
refusal
testify
refusal
appear
witness
congress
took
away
gave
immunity
duty
privilege
lies
core
duty
testify
privilege
relieves
duty
classic
phrase
lord
chancellor
hardwicke
public
right
every
man
evidence
duty
give
testimony
qualified
common
law
privilege
fifth
amendment
embodied
privilege
fundamental
law
privilege
privilege
withhold
answers
privilege
limit
range
public
inquiry
constitution
forbid
asking
criminative
questions
provides
witness
compelled
answer
questions
unless
full
substitute
constitutional
privilege
given
counselman
hitchcock
compulsion
privilege
entitles
witness
resist
compulsion
answer
questions
justifiably
claims
tend
incriminate
constitution
protect
refusal
obey
process
subpoena
course
process
merely
summons
appear
wigmore
evidence
ed
never
privilege
disregard
duty
subpoena
calls
congress
turned
device
immunity
legislation
therefore
provide
performance
universal
duty
appear
undertake
give
something
nothing
refusal
give
incriminating
testimony
congress
bargained
refusal
give
testimony
exchange
testimony
got
heike
witness
invocation
constitutional
rights
congress
conferred
immunity
use
testimony
instead
giving
constitutional
equivalent
privilege
congress
long
time
give
enough
see
counselman
hitchcock
invalidating
act
february
stat
first
immunity
statute
relating
judicial
proceedings
order
remove
gap
act
gave
constitution
construed
require
congress
promptly
passed
act
february
stat
order
interrupt
effective
enforcement
interstate
commerce
act
debates
reveal
congress
acted
understanding
counselman
decision
indicated
adequate
legislative
alternative
see
remarks
senator
cullom
july
act
followed
language
act
january
providing
person
shall
excused
attending
testifying
producing
books
stat
italics
added
brown
walker
found
act
satisfies
constitutional
guaranty
protection
indication
belief
congress
given
anything
indeed
bare
majority
thought
statute
given
much
constitution
required
certainly
beginning
century
therefore
congress
displayed
magnanimity
criminals
affording
amnesty
crimes
indeed
sensitive
congress
immunizing
crime
entrusted
prosecutors
generally
power
relieve
witnesses
prosecution
exchange
incriminating
evidence
others
part
legislative
program
correction
corporate
abuses
congress
february
included
provisions
immunity
three
additional
measures
act
february
stat
establishing
department
commerce
labor
conferring
upon
commissioner
corporations
investigatory
powers
possessed
interstate
commerce
commission
elkins
amendment
february
stat
interstate
commerce
act
act
february
stat
making
large
appropriations
enforcement
interstate
commerce
act
sherman
law
enactments
latter
provision
amended
act
immediately
us
startling
decision
district
judge
humphrey
armour
suggestion
seriously
made
congress
studiously
fashioning
constitutional
equivalent
privilege
playing
lady
bountiful
criminals
particular
concerns
armour
opinion
stirred
must
heeded
provoked
act
meaning
legislation
lost
unless
derived
circumstances
gave
rise
case
arose
proceeding
begun
act
february
stat
creating
department
commerce
labor
section
act
provided
secretary
commerce
labor
shall
time
time
make
special
investigations
reports
may
required
either
house
congress
obedience
resolution
house
representatives
secretary
directed
commissioner
corporations
investigate
causes
low
prices
beef
cattle
accordingly
commissioner
instituted
inquiry
conference
officers
packing
corporations
counsel
commissioner
explained
purposes
scope
investigation
informed
acting
independently
cooperation
department
justice
contemporaneous
proceeding
trust
alleged
violations
sherman
law
note
evidence
obtained
packers
given
department
reported
president
appropriate
use
doc
thereupon
commissioner
agents
afforded
opportunity
examine
packers
books
papers
subsequently
indictment
sherman
law
found
packing
corporations
officers
pleas
bar
filed
alleging
substance
result
investigation
made
commissioner
corporations
defendants
obtained
immunity
prosecution
offenses
charged
indictment
judge
humphrey
sustained
pleas
individual
defendants
ground
information
furnished
defendants
brought
operation
immunity
provision
act
february
incorporated
reference
act
february
stat
relating
testimony
interstate
commerce
commission
judge
humphrey
reached
conclusion
attributing
congress
passing
act
february
purpose
later
unanimously
rejected
heike
judge
humphrey
correctly
held
privilege
amendment
permits
refusal
answer
also
stated
quite
incorrectly
without
warrant
language
legislative
history
policy
act
statute
offense
witness
might
refused
answer
page
words
district
judge
treated
immunity
act
though
act
amnesty
precisely
heike
case
said
course
clear
distinction
amnesty
constitutional
protection
party
compelled
criminal
case
witness
amendment
obvious
purpose
statute
act
february
make
evidence
available
compulsory
otherwise
got
see
reason
supposing
act
offered
gratuity
crime
construed
far
words
fairly
allow
construction
coterminous
otherwise
privilege
person
concerned
believe
policy
earlier
act
february
chap
stat
read
person
shall
excused
attending
testifying
etc
person
shall
prosecuted
thus
showing
correlation
constitutional
right
immunity
form
page
page
judge
humphrey
doubtless
fell
error
treated
immunity
provision
subsidiary
main
purpose
conceived
act
establishing
department
commerce
labor
believed
primary
purpose
act
information
use
legislative
body
page
plain
view
immunity
provisions
true
light
means
facilitate
administration
criminal
law
whatever
justification
judge
humphrey
may
entertaining
notion
regard
act
creating
department
commerce
labor
certainly
application
immunity
provisions
touching
interstate
commerce
act
et
sherman
law
note
provisions
enacted
aids
enforcement
criminal
justice
acts
amnesty
designed
wipe
criminal
offenses
acting
swiftly
correct
error
armour
decision
president
recommended
congress
pass
declaratory
act
set
aside
judge
humphrey
misconception
congressional
purpose
message
president
april
doc
president
theodore
roosevelt
acting
upon
advice
attorney
general
soon
become
justice
moody
naturally
enough
declaratory
legislation
directed
correction
two
evils
judge
humphrey
opinion
projected
namely
make
clear
immunity
afforded
producing
corporate
documents
event
privilege
available
porations
wilson
person
give
evidence
ordinary
formalities
incident
witness
entitled
immunity
legislation
responsive
government
position
stated
attorney
general
moody
facts
armour
case
government
contended
statutory
immunity
conferred
upon
persons
subpoenaed
commissioner
corporations
might
subsequently
give
testimony
evidence
legal
sense
terms
relating
matter
indictment
doc
limited
purpose
amendment
president
proposed
congress
enacted
restrictive
declaration
regarding
scope
immunity
provision
order
prevent
courts
following
latitudinarian
misconception
judge
humphrey
president
congress
acting
upon
advice
one
ablest
attorneys
general
unwittingly
betrayed
introducing
new
gratuity
witnesses
duty
respond
subpoena
giving
amnesty
exchange
mere
response
seventeen
years
thereafter
unquestioned
congress
given
constitution
prosecution
evidence
otherwise
obtained
evidence
withheld
upon
claim
constitutional
privilege
evidence
given
congress
provided
immunity
ruling
federal
courts
considered
question
courts
sat
ablest
judges
martin
heike
judge
grubb
skinner
judge
hunt
elton
judge
rose
johnson
narrow
purpose
amendment
light
events
gave
rise
succinctly
set
forth
judge
rose
clearly
act
two
things
intended
made
clear
immunity
granted
inure
benefit
corporations
natural
person
claim
unless
testified
obedience
subpoena
passed
meet
serious
situation
president
congress
thought
created
rulings
judge
humphrey
clearly
intended
change
previously
existing
law
respect
construction
given
result
grand
jury
prosecuting
officer
unwittingly
conferring
immunity
upon
serious
offender
best
good
faith
reason
suppose
criminally
involved
transaction
subpoenaed
produce
documents
give
testimony
perhaps
well
obtained
sources
unquestionably
witness
constitutional
right
object
testifying
open
government
elect
whether
proceed
examination
statute
rights
remain
called
stand
johnson
observations
judge
grubb
skinner
equally
pertinent
witness
many
cases
alone
informed
whether
evidence
tend
incriminate
supposed
incrimination
may
relate
offenses
investigation
examining
tribunal
existence
relation
desired
evidence
examining
tribunal
government
law
officer
may
knowledge
heike
case
apt
illustration
possibility
witness
likely
exclusive
knowledge
facts
answers
may
tend
incrimination
reference
offenses
witness
alone
knows
whether
willingly
gives
evidence
purpose
exonerating
expectation
receiving
immunity
therefor
therefore
better
position
called
upon
assert
constitutional
privilege
examining
tribunal
law
officer
government
call
upon
elect
hardship
attends
imposition
burden
witness
never
considered
weighty
enough
relieve
therefrom
exercising
constitutional
privilege
prior
immunity
statutes
immunity
granted
statute
mere
substitute
constitutional
safeguard
held
coterminous
seem
therefore
reason
different
practice
assertion
privilege
immunity
desired
constitutional
privilege
insisted
upon
decisions
thus
reflected
weighty
considerations
policy
finding
congress
afforded
immunity
prosecution
extent
constitution
required
exchange
privilege
congress
giving
away
indulgences
considerations
policy
certainly
answered
opinion
texas
district
made
first
departure
uniform
construction
statute
held
immunity
came
merely
one
testified
obedience
subpoena
without
claim
either
explicit
implied
circumstances
constitutional
right
refuse
answer
ground
might
thereby
incriminated
testimony
given
compulsion
immunity
statute
pardue
stated
position
supported
weight
authority
citing
decision
judge
humphrey
armour
case
swift
opinion
far
relevant
question
seems
point
clearly
way
see
especially
pages
state
murphy
much
questioned
originally
repudiated
rendered
carchidi
state
state
grosnickle
decision
new
york
appeals
people
sharp
considering
reasons
control
district
unconscionableness
claim
government
statute
grants
general
amnesty
persons
appear
testify
obedience
subpoena
compel
testify
thereafter
break
faith
denying
protection
statute
testify
exact
accordance
terms
page
starting
misconception
immunity
provision
act
amnesty
quid
pro
quo
constitutional
privilege
district
readily
glided
finding
breach
faith
contesting
claim
amnesty
confusion
avoided
act
amnesty
act
gives
immunity
order
make
evidence
available
compulsory
otherwise
got
withheld
upon
claim
constitutional
privilege
becomes
clear
witness
requiring
claim
constitutional
privilege
affording
substitute
witness
entrapped
requirement
must
stand
upon
constitutional
rights
desires
protection
immunity
statute
none
one
thing
find
incriminating
answers
given
witness
given
setting
particular
circumstances
allowed
withhold
quite
another
suggest
one
appears
witness
merely
appearance
obedience
subpoena
thereby
obtain
immunity
account
transaction
matter
thing
concerning
may
testify
even
though
incrimination
may
relate
transaction
wholly
foreign
inquiry
testimony
given
even
though
alert
conscientious
prosecutor
slightest
inkling
testimony
led
trail
construction
makes
immunity
statute
history
clearly
reveals
namely
carefully
devised
instrument
achievement
criminal
justice
measure
gratuitous
relief
criminals
statute
reflects
judgment
congress
public
right
every
man
evidence
us
relax
demands
society
upon
citizens
appear
proceedings
enforce
laws
enacted
public
good
beginning
securities
act
stat
congress
enacted
less
seventeen
regulatory
measures
contain
provisions
immunity
prosecution
exchange
incriminating
testimony
fourteen
including
inter
alia
securities
exchange
act
stat
national
labor
relations
act
stat
et
communications
act
stat
public
utility
holding
company
act
stat
federal
power
act
stat
civil
aeronautics
act
stat
confer
immunity
person
testifies
compulsion
claimed
privilege
nation
three
statutes
however
motor
carrier
act
stat
industrial
alcohol
act
stat
fair
labor
standards
act
stat
contain
additional
merely
follow
old
form
customarily
used
congress
prior
securities
act
course
difference
language
statutory
provisions
process
construing
statute
end
noting
literary
differences
task
one
finding
meaning
difference
words
necessarily
difference
meaning
carry
question
whether
provisions
different
whether
significance
difference
difference
language
reflected
difference
scope
immunity
given
nature
considerations
moved
congress
make
differentiation
surely
indication
however
faint
somewhere
legislative
history
enactments
legislator
aware
difference
language
significance
none
congress
saw
fit
gratuitously
confer
immunity
citizens
appear
witnesses
proceedings
enforce
motor
carrier
act
august
hard
understand
give
immunity
asserting
privilege
pressed
give
evidence
proceedings
enforce
federal
power
act
august
proceedings
enforce
public
utility
holding
company
act
became
law
day
given
privilege
gratuitiously
industrial
alcohol
act
became
law
following
day
railroad
unemployment
insurance
act
stat
fair
labor
standards
act
stat
et
became
law
day
june
yet
immunity
provision
former
contains
claimed
etc
clause
latter
fair
congress
assume
purpose
make
difference
demands
upon
citizens
appear
witnesses
one
statute
rather
purpose
stated
somewhere
course
legislative
history
total
absence
indication
anywhere
congressman
notion
enforcement
motor
carrier
act
industrial
alcohol
act
fair
labor
standards
act
called
different
treatment
witnesses
proceedings
acts
enforcement
proceedings
fourteen
acts
explanation
seems
obvious
expressions
legislative
materials
indicate
legislative
purpose
varied
respect
acts
difference
purpose
variations
phraseology
employed
acts
explained
away
caprices
single
draftsman
explanation
likely
found
manner
congress
usually
acts
adopting
regulatory
legislation
single
draftsman
drafted
provisions
seventeen
statutes
might
reason
believing
difference
language
reflected
difference
meaning
common
knowledge
measures
frequently
drawn
least
first
instance
specialists
perhaps
connected
interested
government
departments
various
fields
provisions
different
measures
dealing
procedural
problem
unnaturally
therefore
lack
uniformity
phrasing
look
far
order
see
congress
happened
use
one
form
immunity
provision
statutes
another
form
others
consider
evolution
three
statutes
followed
old
form
motor
carrier
act
enacted
amendment
interstate
commerce
act
natural
enforcement
provisions
old
act
incorporated
reference
providing
new
powers
commission
stat
industrial
alcohol
act
far
enforcement
provisions
concerned
patterned
upon
predecessor
national
prohibition
act
stat
et
draftsman
naturally
took
immunity
provision
statute
fair
labor
standards
act
complicated
even
revealing
history
introduced
first
senate
may
carried
explicit
provision
person
gains
immunity
claimed
privilege
remained
form
throughout
course
legislation
house
senate
nearly
year
whole
conception
bill
changed
everything
struck
enacting
clause
new
measure
submitted
house
april
part
new
bill
provision
attendance
witnesses
enforcement
act
simply
incorporated
reference
provision
federal
trade
commission
act
et
obviously
draftsmen
new
bill
drew
heavily
upon
scheme
act
utter
want
evidence
support
suggestion
year
proponents
legislation
committees
grappled
problems
changed
minds
extent
immunity
afforded
witnesses
summoned
proceedings
act
evidence
debates
congress
finally
passed
measure
present
form
meant
give
greater
immunity
provided
various
bills
senate
house
year
course
taken
securities
act
finally
enacted
revealing
significance
immunity
provision
first
depart
old
form
time
bills
eventually
became
act
emerged
conference
immunity
provision
followed
old
form
new
formula
appears
first
time
bill
reported
conference
neither
conference
report
elsewhere
suggestion
introduction
phrase
imported
new
legislative
purpose
anything
careful
rephrasing
conventional
statutory
provision
case
fair
labor
standards
act
seen
meticulous
phrase
claimed
privilege
successive
bills
house
senate
disappeared
final
stage
enactment
measure
one
ever
suggested
far
available
materials
show
change
formula
implied
change
intended
scope
immunity
provision
style
substance
obviously
explanation
case
one
statute
congress
began
new
form
ended
old
one
case
began
old
one
ended
new
upon
rational
basis
attribute
congress
intention
make
scope
immunity
provision
one
statute
vitally
different
attribute
caprice
congress
respect
rational
purpose
find
uniform
policy
deeply
rooted
history
even
though
variously
phrased
always
directed
end
meeting
constitutional
requirement
therefore
opinion
appearance
response
subpoena
confer
immunity
prosecution
anything
witness
responding
may
testify
must
conscious
surrender
privilege
silence
course
testimonial
inquiry
course
form
words
necessary
claim
one
privilege
circumstances
may
establish
claim
must
manifestation
surrender
privilege
prosecutor
insistence
upon
disclosure
immunity
prosecution
withheld
alone
immunity
given
history
reason
alike
reject
notion
immunity
prosecution
squandered
giving
gratuitously
responding
duty
owed
everyone
appear
summoned
witness
since
demurrers
pleas
sustained
case
remanded
district
appropriate
disposition
accordance
views
herein
expressed
justice
douglas
joins
dissent
footnotes
act
march
stat
amended
act
may
stat
compare
armour
skinner
elton
lee
johnson
lay
fish
greater
new
york
live
poultry
pardue
ward
moore
goldman
act
february
stat
stat
counselman
hitchcock
ex
rel
vajtauer
commissioner
cong
globe
pp
stat
stat
stat
brown
walker
see
securities
exchange
act
stat
investment
advisers
act
stat
may
due
thoroughness
preliminary
investigation
classes
cases
question
congress
believed
government
representatives
needed
warning
result
subpoenaing
witness
examining
oath
debate
house
lords
bill
indemnify
evidence
hansard
parliamentary
history
england
may
quoted
wigmore
evidence
ed
significant
heike
case
held
reason
supposing
immunity
act
offered
gratuity
crime
page
page
cited
neither
case
judge
hutcheson
pardue
case
cases
following
pardue
ruling
ward
moore
goldman