fdic
meyer
argued
october
decided
february
federal
savings
loan
insurance
corporation
fslic
receiver
failing
thrift
institution
terminated
respondent
meyer
job
senior
officer
institution
filed
suit
district
claiming
summary
discharge
deprived
property
without
due
process
law
violation
fifth
amendment
making
claim
relied
bivens
six
unknown
fed
narcotics
agents
implied
cause
action
damages
federal
agents
allegedly
violated
fourth
amendment
jury
returned
verdict
fslic
whose
statutory
successor
petitioner
federal
deposit
insurance
corporation
fdic
appealed
appeals
affirmed
holding
although
federal
tort
claims
act
ftca
provides
exclusive
remedy
claims
cognizable
meyer
claim
cognizable
clause
contained
fslic
organic
statute
constituted
waiver
sovereign
immunity
meyer
claim
entitled
maintain
action
fslic
deprived
due
process
summarily
discharged
without
notice
hearing
held
fslic
sovereign
immunity
waived
pp
meyer
constitutional
tort
claim
cognizable
section
provide
cause
action
claim
claim
actionable
section
alleges
inter
alia
liable
private
person
accordance
law
place
act
page
ii
omission
occurred
claim
meyer
contain
allegation
reference
law
place
means
law
state
see
miree
dekalb
county
definition
federal
law
state
law
provides
source
liability
claim
alleging
deprivation
federal
constitutional
right
thus
ftca
constitute
meyer
exclusive
remedy
claim
properly
brought
fslic
simply
basis
statutory
language
interpretation
suggested
fdic
deem
claims
sounding
tort
including
constitutional
torts
cognizable
pp
fslic
clause
waives
sovereign
immunity
meyer
constitutional
tort
claim
clause
terms
simple
broad
fslic
shall
power
sue
sued
complain
defend
competent
jurisdiction
fdic
attempt
make
clear
showing
congressional
intent
necessary
overcome
presumption
clause
fully
waives
immunity
see
federal
housing
admin
burr
international
primate
protection
league
administrators
tulane
ed
fund
instead
fdic
argues
statutory
waiver
scope
limited
cases
fslic
subjected
liability
private
entity
category
include
instances
constitutional
tort
cases
fdic
relies
burr
supra
loeffler
frank
franchise
tax
bd
california
postal
service
support
limitation
suggested
fdic
pp
bivens
cause
action
implied
directly
fslic
logic
bivens
support
extension
bivens
federal
agents
federal
agencies
bivens
petitioner
sued
agents
federal
bureau
narcotics
allegedly
violated
rights
bureau
implied
cause
action
agents
part
direct
action
government
available
harlan
concurring
judgment
essence
meyer
asks
imply
damages
action
based
decision
presumed
absence
action
moreover
imply
action
directly
federal
agencies
thereby
permitting
claimants
bypass
qualified
immunity
protection
invoked
many
bivens
defendants
longer
reason
aggrieved
parties
bring
damages
actions
individual
officers
deterrent
effects
bivens
remedy
lost
finally
special
factors
counseling
hesitation
creation
damages
page
iii
remedy
federal
agencies
remedy
create
potentially
enormous
financial
burden
federal
government
matter
affecting
fiscal
policy
better
left
congress
pp
thomas
delivered
opinion
unanimous
fdic
meyer
justice
thomas
delivered
opinion
bivens
six
unknown
fed
narcotics
agents
implied
cause
action
damages
federal
agents
allegedly
violated
constitution
today
asked
imply
similar
cause
action
directly
agency
federal
government
logic
bivens
support
extension
decline
take
step
april
california
savings
loan
commissioner
seized
fidelity
savings
loan
association
fidelity
thrift
institution
appointed
federal
savings
loan
insurance
corporation
fslic
serve
fidelity
receiver
state
law
day
federal
home
loan
bank
board
appointed
fslic
serve
fidelity
receiver
federal
law
capacity
receiver
fslic
broad
authority
take
action
may
necessary
put
thrift
sound
solvent
condition
stat
amended
ii
repealed
pursuant
general
policy
terminating
employment
failed
thrift
senior
management
fslic
special
fdic
meyer
representative
robert
pattullo
terminated
respondent
john
meyer
senior
fidelity
officer
approximately
one
year
later
meyer
filed
lawsuit
number
defendants
including
fslic
pattullo
district
northern
district
california
time
trial
meyer
sole
claim
fslic
pattullo
summary
discharge
deprived
property
right
right
continued
employment
california
law
without
due
process
law
violation
fifth
amendment
making
claim
meyer
relied
upon
bivens
six
unknown
fed
narcotics
agents
supra
implied
cause
action
damages
federal
agents
allegedly
violated
fourth
amendment
jury
returned
verdict
fslic
found
favor
pattullo
qualified
immunity
grounds
petitioner
federal
deposit
insurance
corporation
fdic
fslic
statutory
successor
appealed
appeals
ninth
circuit
affirmed
first
appeals
determined
federal
tort
claims
act
ftca
act
provide
meyer
exclusive
remedy
although
ftca
remedy
exclusive
claims
cognizable
section
act
appeals
decided
meyer
claim
cognizable
concluded
clause
contained
fslic
organic
statute
repealed
constituted
waiver
sovereign
immunity
meyer
claim
fdic
meyer
entitled
maintain
action
agency
finally
merits
affirmed
jury
conclusion
meyer
deprived
due
process
summarily
discharged
without
notice
hearing
granted
certiorari
consider
validity
damages
award
fslic
ii
absent
waiver
sovereign
immunity
shields
federal
government
agencies
suit
loeffler
frank
federal
housing
admin
burr
sovereign
immunity
jurisdictional
nature
indeed
terms
consent
sued
define
jurisdiction
entertain
suit
sherwood
see
also
mitchell
axiomatic
may
sued
without
consent
existence
consent
prerequisite
jurisdiction
therefore
must
first
decide
whether
fslic
immunity
waived
congress
created
fslic
empowered
agency
sue
sued
complain
defend
competent
jurisdiction
repealed
permitting
fslic
fdic
meyer
sue
sued
congress
effected
broad
waiver
fslic
immunity
suit
nordic
village
slip
congress
passed
ftca
waived
sovereign
immunity
certain
torts
committed
federal
employees
order
place
torts
suable
agencies
upon
precisely
footing
torts
nonsuable
agencies
loeffler
supra
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
congress
ftca
limited
scope
waivers
contained
fslic
organic
statute
ftca
limitation
provides
authority
federal
agency
sue
sued
name
shall
construed
authorize
suits
federal
agency
claims
cognizable
section
title
remedies
provided
title
cases
shall
exclusive
fdic
meyer
first
question
whether
meyer
claim
cognizable
term
cognizable
defined
act
absence
definition
construe
statutory
term
accordance
ordinary
natural
meaning
smith
slip
cognizable
ordinarily
means
apable
tried
examined
designated
tribunal
within
jurisdiction
power
given
adjudicate
controversy
black
law
dictionary
ed
definition
inquiry
focuses
jurisdictional
grant
provided
section
grants
federal
district
courts
jurisdiction
certain
category
claims
waived
sovereign
immunity
render
ed
liable
richards
category
includes
claims
money
damages
injury
loss
property
personal
injury
death
caused
negligent
wrongful
act
omission
employee
government
acting
within
scope
office
employment
circumstances
private
person
liable
claimant
accordance
law
place
act
omission
occurred
fdic
meyer
applying
principles
case
conclude
meyer
constitutional
tort
claim
cognizable
actionable
provide
cause
action
claim
noted
actionable
claim
must
allege
inter
alia
liable
claimant
private
person
accordance
law
place
act
omission
occurred
constitutional
tort
claim
meyer
contain
allegation
indeed
consistently
held
reference
law
place
means
law
state
source
substantive
liability
ftca
see
miree
dekalb
county
muniz
richards
supra
rayonier
definition
federal
law
state
law
provides
source
liability
claim
alleging
deprivation
federal
constitutional
right
use
terminology
richards
simply
rendered
liable
constitutional
tort
claims
thus
meyer
constitutional
tort
claim
cognizable
ftca
constitute
exclusive
remedy
claim
therefore
properly
brought
fslic
name
fdic
argues
exposing
agency
constitutional
tort
claims
interpretation
fdic
meyer
cognizability
runs
afoul
congress
understanding
place
torts
suable
nonsuable
agencies
footing
see
loeffler
supra
fdic
deem
claims
sounding
tort
including
constitutional
torts
cognizable
fdic
reading
statute
portion
describes
tort
claims
money
damages
injury
loss
property
personal
injury
death
caused
negligent
wrongful
act
omission
employee
government
govern
cognizability
remaining
portion
simply
describe
limitation
waiver
sovereign
immunity
reject
reading
statute
already
noted
describes
scope
jurisdiction
reference
claims
waived
immunity
rendered
liable
fdic
seeks
uncouple
scope
jurisdiction
scope
waiver
sovereign
immunity
interpretation
jurisdictional
grant
broad
covering
claims
fdic
meyer
sounding
tort
waiver
sovereign
immunity
narrow
covering
claims
private
person
held
liable
state
law
simply
basis
statutory
language
parsing
fdic
suggests
section
reference
claims
cognizable
means
cognizable
whole
simply
portion
meyer
claim
cognizable
must
determine
whether
fslic
clause
waives
sovereign
immunity
claim
fdic
argues
scope
waiver
limited
cases
fslic
subjected
liability
private
entity
constitutional
tort
claim
meyer
fdic
argues
fall
outside
waiver
constitution
generally
restrict
conduct
private
entities
essence
fdic
asks
us
engraft
fdic
meyer
portion
sixth
element
liability
circumstances
private
person
liable
claimant
onto
clause
face
clause
contains
limitation
contrary
terms
simple
broad
fslic
shall
power
sue
sued
complain
defend
competent
jurisdiction
repealed
past
recognized
waivers
liberally
construed
federal
housing
admin
burr
notwithstanding
general
rule
waivers
sovereign
immunity
read
narrowly
favor
sovereign
see
nordic
village
slip
burr
makes
clear
clauses
limited
implication
unless
clea
show
ing
certain
types
suits
consistent
statutory
constitutional
scheme
implied
restriction
general
authority
necessary
avoid
grave
interference
performance
governmental
function
reasons
plainly
purpose
congress
use
sue
sued
clause
narrow
sense
omitted
fdic
attempt
make
clear
showing
congressional
purpose
necessary
overcome
presumption
fdic
meyer
immunity
waived
instead
bases
argument
solely
language
cases
suggesting
federal
agencies
bear
burdens
suit
borne
private
entities
typical
cases
burr
stated
congress
launche
governmental
agency
commercial
world
endow
authority
sue
sued
agency
less
amenable
judicial
process
private
enterprise
like
circumstances
emphasis
added
see
also
franchise
tax
supra
nder
burr
must
liberally
construe
clause
also
must
presume
postal
service
liability
business
emphasis
added
loeffler
supra
clause
congress
waived
postal
service
immunity
interest
awards
authorizing
recovery
interest
postal
service
extent
interest
recoverable
private
party
normal
incident
suit
emphasis
added
read
context
however
clear
burr
franchise
tax
board
loeffler
support
limitation
fdic
proposes
cases
claimants
sought
subject
agencies
particular
suit
incident
suit
private
businesses
amenable
matter
course
burr
example
claimant
obtained
judgment
employee
federal
housing
administration
fha
served
fha
writ
garnish
employee
wages
similarly
franchise
tax
board
claimant
directed
postal
service
withhold
amounts
delinquent
state
income
taxes
wages
four
postal
fdic
meyer
service
employees
loeffler
claimant
discharged
employment
rural
letter
carrier
sought
prejudgment
interest
incident
successful
suit
postal
service
title
vii
civil
rights
act
et
seq
claimant
cases
seeking
hold
agency
liable
like
business
franchise
tax
board
supra
natural
look
liability
private
businesses
guidance
stood
reason
agency
escape
liability
private
enterprise
face
similar
circumstances
contrast
meyer
seek
hold
fslic
liable
like
business
indeed
seeks
impose
fslic
form
tort
liability
tort
liability
arising
constitution
generally
apply
private
entities
burr
franchise
tax
board
loeffler
simply
speak
issue
sovereign
immunity
context
constitutional
tort
claim
moreover
nothing
decisions
suggests
liability
private
enterprise
serve
outer
boundary
waiver
rather
cases
merely
involve
determination
whether
particular
suit
incident
suit
came
within
scope
waiver
burr
supra
determined
particular
suit
incident
suit
fell
within
waiver
looked
liability
private
enterprise
floor
agency
liability
fall
present
case
contrast
fdic
argues
agency
liability
never
greater
private
entity
attempts
use
liability
private
entity
ceiling
nothing
burr
franchise
tax
board
loeffler
supports
result
finally
hesitate
engraft
language
fdic
meyer
onto
clause
congress
expressly
set
former
provision
limit
latter
provided
limits
waivers
claims
cognizable
thus
contemplates
waiver
encompass
claims
cognizable
render
agency
subject
suit
unconstrained
express
limitations
ftca
fdic
construction
taken
logical
permit
result
render
coextensive
scope
waivers
contained
clauses
generally
congress
wished
achieve
outcome
surely
employed
language
see
connecticut
nat
bank
germain
slip
ourts
must
presume
legislature
says
statute
means
means
statute
says
showing
made
overcome
presumption
clause
fully
waived
fslic
immunity
instance
franchise
tax
board
supra
international
primate
protection
league
hold
fslic
clause
waives
agency
sovereign
immunity
meyer
constitutional
tort
claim
iii
although
determined
meyer
claim
falls
within
waiver
inquiry
end
point
part
ways
ninth
circuit
determined
meyer
cause
action
damages
fslic
waiver
sovereign
immunity
ninth
circuit
reasoning
conflates
two
analytically
distinct
inquiries
mitchell
first
inquiry
whether
waiver
sovereign
immunity
fdic
meyer
waiver
case
second
inquiry
comes
play
whether
source
substantive
law
upon
claimant
relies
provides
avenue
relief
second
inquiry
turn
meyer
bases
due
process
claim
decision
bivens
held
individual
injured
federal
agent
alleged
violation
fourth
amendment
may
bring
action
damages
agent
recent
decisions
responded
cautiously
suggestions
bivens
remedies
extended
new
contexts
schweiker
chilicky
case
meyer
seeks
significant
extension
bivens
asks
us
expand
category
defendants
actions
may
brought
include
federal
agents
federal
agencies
well
know
appeals
decision
ninth
circuit
implied
cause
action
directly
federal
agency
meyer
recognizes
absence
authority
supporting
position
argues
logic
bivens
support
remedy
disagree
bivens
petitioner
sued
agents
federal
bureau
narcotics
allegedly
violated
rights
bureau
meyer
brought
precisely
claim
logic
fdic
meyer
bivens
supports
bivens
claim
damages
pattullo
fslic
employee
terminated
additional
problem
meyer
logic
argument
fact
implied
cause
action
federal
officials
bivens
part
direct
action
government
available
harlan
concurring
judgment
essence
meyer
asks
us
imply
damages
action
based
decision
presumed
absence
action
meyer
real
complaint
pattullo
like
many
bivens
defendants
invoked
protection
qualified
immunity
bivens
clearly
contemplated
official
immunity
raised
noting
district
ruled
respondents
immune
liability
virtue
official
position
importantly
meyer
proposed
solution
essentially
circumvention
qualified
immunity
mean
evisceration
bivens
remedy
rather
extension
must
remembered
purpose
bivens
deter
officer
see
carlson
green
bivens
remedy
recoverable
individuals
effective
deterrent
ftca
remedy
imply
damages
action
directly
federal
agencies
thereby
permitting
claimants
bypass
qualified
immunity
reason
aggrieved
parties
bring
damages
actions
individual
officers
fdic
meyer
meyer
regime
deterrent
effects
bivens
remedy
lost
finally
damages
remedy
federal
agencies
inappropriate
even
remedy
consistent
bivens
unlike
bivens
special
factors
counseling
hesitation
creation
damages
remedy
bivens
recognize
direct
action
damages
federal
agencies
creating
potentially
enormous
financial
burden
federal
government
meyer
disputes
reasoning
argues
federal
government
already
expends
significant
resources
indemnifying
employees
sued
bivens
meyer
argument
implicitly
suggests
funds
used
indemnification
shifted
cover
direct
liability
federal
agencies
may
may
true
decisions
involving
federal
fiscal
policy
make
ibid
quoting
standard
oil
leave
congress
weigh
implications
significant
expansion
government
liability
iv
extension
bivens
agencies
federal
government
supported
logic
bivens
therefore
hold
meyer
bivens
cause
action
damages
fslic
accordingly
judgment
reversed
ordered
footnotes
meyer
filed
challenging
jury
finding
pattullo
protected
qualified
immunity
ninth
circuit
affirmed
finding
declined
review
aspect
case
meyer
pattullo
statute
governing
fdic
contains
nearly
identical
fdic
meyer
clause
see
fourth
supp
iv
fdic
shall
power
sue
sued
complain
defend
law
equity
state
federal
section
provides
district
courts
shall
exclusive
jurisdiction
civil
actions
claims
money
damages
injury
loss
property
personal
injury
death
caused
negligent
wrongful
act
omission
employee
government
acting
within
scope
office
employment
circumstances
private
person
liable
claimant
accordance
law
place
act
omission
occurred
asked
define
cognizability
loeffler
language
bit
imprecise
question
whether
claim
cognizable
ftca
generally
loeffler
suggests
rather
whether
cognizable
section
emphasis
added
fdic
relies
upon
smith
interpretation
term
cognizable
smith
foreign
country
exception
barred
plaintiffs
recovery
federal
government
injuries
allegedly
caused
negligence
government
employee
working
abroad
held
ftca
provided
plaintiffs
exclusive
remedy
even
though
ftca
provide
means
recovery
smith
involve
provision
issue
case
rather
provides
ftca
remedy
exclusive
civil
action
proceeding
money
damages
employee
whose
act
omission
gave
rise
claim
occasion
smith
address
meaning
term
cognizable
contain
term
therefore
find
smith
unhelpful
regard
nothing
decision
hubsch
per
curiam
contrary
hubsch
parties
submitted
approval
settlement
agreement
supp
iv
time
provided
attorney
general
approval
settle
claim
cognizable
section
emphasis
added
construed
imposing
district
authority
responsibility
passing
proposed
compromises
notwithstanding
fact
found
claimant
failed
prove
government
employee
acted
within
scope
authority
fifth
element
mentioned
see
also
hubsch
holding
case
recognized
claim
lose
cognizability
simply
failure
proof
element
claim
case
failure
proof
rather
meyer
claim
fall
within
terms
first
instance
brief
discussion
clause
fdic
mention
let
alone
attempt
overcome
presumption
waiver
see
brief
petitioner
example
bivens
action
alleging
violation
due
process
clause
fifth
amendment
may
appropriate
contexts
others
compare
davis
passman
implying
bivens
action
equal
protection
component
due
process
clause
context
alleged
gender
discrimination
employment
schweiker
chilicky
refusing
imply
bivens
action
alleged
due
process
violations
denial
social
security
disability
benefits
ground
damages
remedy
included
elaborate
remedial
scheme
devised
congress
although
critical
analysis
note
addition
bivens
claim
pattullo
meyer
initially
brought
contractual
claim
fslic
later
dropped
meyer
also
filed
claim
fslic
receiver
value
contractual
rights
believed
violated
see
repealed
cfr
coit
independence
joint
venture
fslic
regard
note
congress
considered
several
proposals
created
remedy
directly
federal
government
see
sess
sess
sess
sess
find
meyer
bivens
action
fslic
reach
merits
due
process
claim
page