smiley
citibank
south
dakota
argued
april
decided
june
petitioner
resident
california
held
credit
cards
issued
respondent
national
bank
located
south
dakota
filed
suit
state
alleging
fees
charged
respondent
although
legal
south
dakota
law
violated
california
law
respondent
moved
judgment
pleadings
contending
petitioner
state
law
claims
provision
national
bank
act
permits
national
bank
charge
loan
customers
interest
rate
allowed
laws
state
bank
located
section
see
marquette
nat
bank
minneapolis
first
omaha
service
california
superior
accepting
respondent
argument
credit
card
fees
constitute
interest
purposes
section
granted
respondent
motion
state
appeal
state
affirmed
held
comptroller
currency
reasonably
interpreted
term
interest
section
include
fees
see
cfr
section
petitioner
failed
establish
accord
customary
deference
comptroller
interpretation
ambiguous
provision
national
bank
act
pp
provision
national
bank
act
ambiguous
pursuant
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
defers
reasonable
judgments
comptroller
official
charged
administering
act
nationsbank
variable
annuity
life
ins
petitioner
argument
deference
owing
recently
adopted
cfr
section
unpersuasive
validity
comptroller
interpretation
affected
fact
regulation
issued
years
section
enacted
litigation
including
suit
disclosed
need
regulation
distinction
regulation
makes
charges
designated
interest
classified
arbitrary
capricious
see
chevron
supra
petitioner
errs
contending
agency
interpretation
contradicts
prior
agency
position
necessarily
invalid
event
fails
show
change
official
agency
position
occurred
finally
issue
meaning
section
bring
play
considerations
petitioner
raises
pp
comptroller
interpretation
statutory
term
interest
reasonable
indication
time
passage
national
bank
act
common
usage
word
interest
phrase
rate
allowed
required
interest
charges
expressed
functions
time
amount
owing
support
petitioner
contention
late
fees
penalties
rather
interest
see
citizens
national
bank
donnell
pp
cal
affirmed
scalia
delivered
opinion
unanimous
notice
opinion
subject
formal
revision
publication
preliminary
print
reports
readers
requested
notify
reporter
decisions
washington
typographical
formal
errors
order
corrections
may
made
preliminary
print
goes
press
end
syllabus
barbara
smiley
petitioner
citibank
south
dakota
late
fees
permitted
south
dakota
law
see
codified
laws
section
supp
petitioner
however
view
exacting
unconscionable
late
charges
california
residents
violates
california
law
brought
class
action
respondent
behalf
california
holders
respondent
credit
cards
asserting
various
statutory
claims
respondent
moved
judgment
pleadings
contending
petitioner
claims
section
superior
los
angeles
county
initially
denied
respondent
motion
california
appeal
second
appellate
district
issued
writ
mandate
directing
superior
either
grant
motion
show
cause
required
superior
chose
former
course
appeal
affirmed
dismissal
complaint
cal
app
cal
rptr
california
granted
review
affirmed
two
justices
dissenting
cal
granted
certiorari
ii
march
california
superior
dismissal
petitioner
complaint
comptroller
currency
noticed
public
comment
proposed
regulation
dealing
subject
us
see
fed
reg
february
california
decision
adopted
following
provision
term
interest
used
section
includes
payment
compensating
creditor
prospective
creditor
extension
credit
making
available
line
credit
default
breach
borrower
condition
upon
credit
extended
includes
among
things
following
fees
connected
credit
extension
availability
numerical
periodic
rates
late
fees
sufficient
funds
nsf
fees
overlimit
fees
annual
fees
cash
advance
fees
membership
fees
ordinarily
include
appraisal
fees
premiums
commissions
attributable
insurance
guaranteeing
repayment
extension
credit
finders
fees
fees
document
preparation
notarization
fees
incurred
obtain
credit
reports
fed
reg
codified
cfr
section
second
petitioner
contends
comptroller
regulation
deserving
deference
rational
basis
distinguishing
various
charges
denominated
interest
charges
denominated
reply
brief
petitioner
disagree
analytical
matter
seems
us
perfectly
possible
draw
line
regulation
payment
compensating
creditor
prospective
creditor
extension
credit
making
available
line
credit
default
breach
borrower
condition
upon
credit
extended
payments
sure
broadest
sense
payments
connected
way
reimbursement
lender
costs
processing
application
insuring
loan
appraising
regarded
compensating
creditor
extension
credit
seems
us
quite
possible
rational
distinguish
regulation
charges
specifically
assigned
expenses
assessed
simply
making
loan
borrower
default
logic
least
line
arbitrary
capricious
thereby
disentitled
deference
chevron
see
whether
arbitrary
capricious
interpretation
statute
perhaps
even
chevron
also
excludes
deference
manifestly
contrary
statute
discuss
next
part
opinion
finally
petitioner
argues
regulation
entitled
deference
inconsistent
positions
taken
comptroller
past
course
mere
fact
agency
interpretation
contradicts
prior
agency
position
fatal
sudden
unexplained
change
see
motor
vehicle
mfrs
assn
state
farm
mut
automobile
ins
change
take
account
legitimate
reliance
prior
interpretation
see
pennsylvania
industrial
chemical
nlrb
bell
aerospace
may
arbitrary
capricious
abuse
discretion
section
pitfalls
avoided
change
invalidating
since
whole
point
chevron
leave
discretion
provided
ambiguities
statute
implementing
agency
case
think
anything
accurately
described
change
official
agency
position
occurred
agency
notice
proposed
rulemaking
asserted
new
regulation
reflect
current
law
office
comptroller
currency
occ
interpretive
letters
fed
reg
statement
basis
purpose
accompanying
final
adoption
stated
final
ruling
consistent
occ
interpretive
letters
area
reflects
position
occ
taken
amicus
curiae
briefs
litigation
pending
many
state
federal
courts
fed
reg
citing
occ
interpretive
letters
petitioner
points
june
letter
comptroller
president
committee
consumer
interests
harges
late
payments
credit
life
insurance
recording
fees
documentary
stamp
illustrations
charges
made
banks
properly
characterized
interest
see
app
brief
petitioner
opinion
letter
deputy
chief
counsel
occ
stating
position
section
laws
banks
located
determine
whether
banks
impose
foregoing
fees
charges
including
late
fees
iowa
residents
occ
interpretive
letter
reprinted
transfer
binder
cch
fed
banking
para
doubt
whether
either
statements
sufficient
establish
binding
agency
former
informal
latter
purported
represent
position
deputy
chief
counsel
response
inquiry
concerning
particular
banks
even
argued
two
statements
reflect
prior
agency
policy
since
addition
contradicting
regulation
us
also
contradict
one
former
asserting
interest
nationally
uniform
concept
latter
determined
reference
state
law
statements
show
anything
good
reason
comptroller
promulgate
new
regulation
order
eliminate
uncertainty
confusion
addition
offering
reasons
cfr
section
particular
entitled
deference
petitioner
contends
comptroller
interpretation
section
entitled
deference
section
provision
state
law
argues
presumption
announced
cipollone
liggett
group
effect
trumps
chevron
requires
make
interpretation
section
avoid
extent
possible
state
law
argument
confuses
question
substantive
opposed
meaning
statute
question
whether
statute
may
assume
without
deciding
latter
question
must
always
decided
de
novo
courts
question
issue
doubt
section
state
law
marquette
nat
bank
minneapolis
first
omaha
service
dismissed
petitioners
argument
exportation
interest
rates
bank
home
state
significantly
impair
ability
enact
effective
usury
laws
observation
impairment
always
implicit
structure
national
bank
act
protection
state
usury
laws
issue
legislative
policy
plea
alter
section
end
better
addressed
wisdom
congress
judgment
issue
simply
meaning
provision
like
provision
cipollone
deal
hence
bring
play
considerations
petitioner
raises
iii
petitioner
argues
late
fees
charged
respondent
constitute
interest
vary
based
payment
owed
time
period
delay
brief
petitioner
think
limitation
must
read
statutory
term
legal
dictionaries
era
national
bank
act
place
limitation
upon
interest
see
bouvier
law
dictionary
ed
compensation
paid
borrower
lender
debtor
creditor
use
money
burrill
law
dictionary
glossary
ed
american
english
encyclopedia
law
merrill
ed
see
wharton
law
lexicon
dictionary
jurisprudence
amer
ed
definition
interest
set
brown
hiatts
wall
decided
shortly
enactment
national
bank
act
likewise
contained
indication
limited
charges
expressed
function
time
amount
owing
interest
compensation
allowed
law
fixed
parties
use
forbearance
money
damages
detention
see
also
hollowell
southern
building
loan
ny
charges
made
borrower
excess
lawful
rate
interest
whether
called
fines
charges
dues
interest
fact
interest
usurious
petitioner
suggests
another
source
asserted
requirement
charges
timeand
authorized
section
notes
charging
interest
rate
allowed
laws
bank
home
state
requires
view
interest
charges
expressed
functions
time
amount
owing
surprising
find
requirement
act
pointless
flat
charge
may
course
readily
converted
percentage
indeed
basis
decisions
holding
flat
charges
violated
state
usury
laws
establishing
maximum
rates
see
craig
pleiss
hollowell
supra
apparent
reason
percentage
charges
permissible
flat
charges
unlawful
event
common
usage
time
national
bank
act
prevents
conclusion
comptroller
refusal
give
word
rate
narrow
meaning
petitioner
demands
unreasonable
edition
webster
gives
one
definitions
rate
rice
amount
stated
fixed
thing
webster
american
dictionary
english
language
illustrate
sense
word
provides
following
examples
king
may
purchase
territory
dear
rate
rate
interest
prescribed
law
ibid
cf
bouvier
supra
defining
rate
exchange
price
bill
drawn
one
country
upon
another
may
sold
former
finally
petitioner
contends
late
fees
interest
penalties
support
dichotomy
points
opinion
meilink
unemployment
reserves
meilink
involved
provision
bankruptcy
act
disallowed
debts
owing
governmental
entities
penalty
except
amount
pecuniary
loss
sustained
act
penalty
arose
interest
may
accrued
thereon
according
law
obviously
provision
uses
interest
mean
interest
exacted
commercial
compensation
interest
exacted
penalty
word
often
takes
narrow
connotation
expressly
opposed
another
word
car
example
broader
meaning
passage
speaking
cars
taxis
section
term
interest
used
contradistinction
penalty
reason
include
interest
charges
imposed
purpose
relevant
meilink
opinion
citizens
nat
bank
kansas
city
donnell
involve
section
precisely
predecessor
rev
stat
section
bank
argued
charge
overdrafts
violate
state
law
setting
ceiling
interest
rates
inter
alia
overdraft
charge
penalty
failure
pay
debt
due
dismissed
argument
hand
suggestions
twelve
per
cent
charge
overdrafts
seem
us
need
answer
petitioner
devotes
much
brief
question
whether
meaning
interest
section
constitutionally
left
defined
law
bank
home
question
implicated
comptroller
regulation
regulation
entitled
deference
comptroller
interpretation
section
unreasonable
one
decision
california
must
affirmed
ordered
footnotes
way
claims
petitioner
complaint
alleged
breach
duty
good
faith
fair
dealing
unjust
enrichment
fraud
deceit
negligent
misrepresentation
breach
contract
also
alleged
violation
cal
bus
code
ann
section
west
supp
prohibiting
unlawful
business
practices
cal
civ
code
ann
section
west
invalidating
unreasonable
liquidated
damages
sherman
citibank
south
dakota
colorado
appeals
first
circuit
adopted
interpretation
california
see
copeland
mbna
america
bank
greenwood
trust
massachusetts
dictum
cert
denied
last
page
reply
brief
unpursued
oral
argument
petitioner
raised
point
deferring
regulation
case
involving
antecedent
transactions
make
regulation
retroactive
violation
bowen
georgetown
univ
hospital
reply
brief
petitioner
might
substance
point
regulation
replaced
prior
agency
discussed
however
addressing
transactions
occurred
time
clear
agency
guidance
absurd
ignore
agency
current
authoritative
pronouncement
statute
means