video
argued
october
decided
november
respondents
convicted
protection
children
sexual
exploitation
act
prohibits
knowingly
transporting
shipping
receiving
distributing
reproducing
visual
depiction
depiction
involves
use
minor
engaging
sexually
explicit
conduct
reversing
ninth
circuit
held
inter
alia
facially
unconstitutional
first
amendment
require
showing
defendant
knew
one
performers
minor
held
term
knowingly
modifies
phrase
use
minor
subsections
act
properly
read
include
scienter
requirement
age
minority
rejects
natural
grammatical
reading
adopted
ninth
circuit
knowingly
modifies
relevant
verbs
subsections
extend
elements
minority
performers
sexually
explicit
nature
material
set
forth
independent
clauses
separated
interruptive
punctuation
applications
reading
sweep
within
statute
ambit
actors
idea
even
dealing
sexually
explicit
material
anomalous
result
assume
congress
intended
moreover
morissette
reinforced
staples
instructs
standard
presumption
favor
scienter
requirement
apply
statutory
elements
criminalize
otherwise
innocent
conduct
minority
status
performers
crucial
element
separating
page
ii
legal
innocence
wrongful
conduct
legislative
history
although
unclear
whether
congress
intended
knowingly
extend
performer
age
persuasively
indicates
word
applies
sexually
explicit
conduct
depicted
thereby
demonstrates
knowingly
emancipated
merely
modifying
verbs
subsections
matter
grammar
difficult
conclude
word
modifies
one
elements
interpretation
supported
canon
statute
construed
fairly
possible
avoid
substantial
constitutional
questions
pp
reversed
rehnquist
delivered
opinion
stevens
kennedy
souter
ginsburg
breyer
joined
stevens
filed
concurring
opinion
scalia
filed
dissenting
opinion
thomas
joined
video
chief
justice
rehnquist
delivered
opinion
protection
children
sexual
exploitation
act
amended
prohibits
interstate
transportation
shipping
receipt
distribution
reproduction
visual
depictions
minors
engaged
sexually
explicit
conduct
appeals
ninth
circuit
reversed
conviction
respondents
violation
act
held
act
require
defendant
know
one
performers
minor
therefore
facially
unconstitutional
conclude
act
properly
read
include
requirement
rubin
gottesman
owned
operated
video
undercover
police
posed
pornography
retailers
targeted
video
investigation
course
sting
operation
media
exposed
traci
lords
roles
pornographic
films
age
police
officer
steven
takeshita
expressed
interest
obtaining
traci
lords
tapes
gottesman
complied
selling
takeshita
videotapes
featuring
lords
birthday
two
months
later
gottesman
shipped
eight
tapes
underage
traci
lords
takeshita
hawaii
video
two
transactions
formed
basis
federal
indictment
child
pornography
statute
indictment
charged
respondents
one
count
violating
along
one
count
conspiracy
evidence
trial
suggested
gottesman
full
awareness
lords
underage
performances
gottesman
cr
findings
fact
cd
app
pet
cert
defendants
knew
traci
lords
underage
made
films
defendant
sic
transported
shipped
interstate
commerce
district
convicted
respondents
three
counts
appeal
gottesman
argued
inter
alia
act
facially
unconstitutional
lacked
necessary
scienter
requirement
unconstitutional
applied
tapes
issue
child
pornography
ninth
circuit
remanded
district
reconsideration
light
thomas
cert
denied
case
ninth
circuit
held
contain
scienter
requirement
reached
constitutional
questions
remand
district
refused
set
aside
judgment
conviction
appeal
second
time
gottesman
reiterated
constitutional
arguments
time
reached
merits
claims
divided
vote
found
facially
unconstitutional
first
held
met
constitutional
standards
setting
age
minority
age
substituting
lascivious
lewd
prohibiting
actual
simulated
bestiality
sadistic
masochistic
abuse
video
discussed
noting
bound
conclusion
thomas
construe
act
lacking
scienter
requirement
age
minority
concluded
case
law
required
defendant
must
knowledge
least
nature
character
materials
citing
smith
california
new
york
ferber
hamling
extended
cases
hold
first
amendment
requires
defendant
possess
knowledge
particular
fact
one
performer
reached
age
majority
time
visual
depiction
produced
found
statute
require
showing
reversed
respondents
convictions
granted
certiorari
reverse
title
ed
supp
provides
relevant
part
person
knowingly
transports
ships
interstate
foreign
commerce
means
including
computer
mails
visual
depiction
producing
visual
depiction
involves
use
minor
engaging
sexually
explicit
conduct
visual
depiction
conduct
knowingly
receives
distributes
visual
depiction
mailed
shipped
transported
interstate
foreign
commerce
contains
materials
mailed
shipped
transported
means
including
computer
knowingly
reproduces
visual
depiction
distribution
video
interstate
foreign
commerce
mails
producing
visual
depiction
involves
use
minor
engaging
sexually
explicit
conduct
visual
depiction
conduct
shall
punished
provided
subsection
section
term
knowingly
applies
relevant
verbs
transporting
shipping
receiving
distributing
reproducing
conclude
congress
wished
distinguish
someone
knowingly
transported
particular
package
film
whose
contents
unknown
someone
unknowingly
transported
package
video
seem
odd
say
least
congress
distinguished
someone
inadvertently
dropped
item
mail
without
realizing
someone
consciously
placed
item
mail
nonetheless
unconcerned
whether
person
knowledge
prohibited
contents
package
applications
respondents
position
produce
results
merely
odd
positively
absurd
conclude
knowingly
modifies
relevant
verbs
sweep
within
ambit
statute
actors
idea
even
dealing
sexually
explicit
material
instance
retail
druggist
returns
uninspected
roll
developed
film
customer
knowingly
distributes
visual
depiction
criminally
liable
later
discovered
visual
depiction
contained
images
children
engaged
sexually
explicit
conduct
new
resident
apartment
might
receive
mail
prior
resident
store
mail
unopened
prior
tenant
requested
delivery
materials
covered
residential
successor
prosecuted
knowing
receipt
materials
similarly
federal
express
courier
delivers
box
shipper
declared
contents
film
knowingly
transports
film
assume
congress
passing
laws
intended
results
public
citizen
department
justice
turkette
reluctance
simply
follow
grammatical
reading
statute
heightened
cases
interpreting
criminal
statutes
include
broadly
applicable
scienter
requirements
even
statute
terms
contain
landmark
opinion
morissette
discussed
common
law
history
mens
rea
applied
elements
federal
embezzlement
statute
video
statute
read
whoever
embezzles
steals
purloins
knowingly
converts
use
use
another
without
authority
sells
conveys
disposes
record
voucher
money
thing
value
hall
fined
cited
morissette
perhaps
even
obviously
statute
presently
us
word
knowingly
isolated
position
suggested
attached
verb
converts
required
defendant
intentionally
assume
dominion
property
used
background
presumption
evil
intent
conclude
term
knowingly
also
required
defendant
knowledge
facts
made
taking
conversion
property
belonged
see
also
gypsum
ar
simple
omission
appropriate
phrase
statutory
definition
necessary
justify
dispensing
intent
requirement
liparota
posed
challenge
federal
statute
prohibiting
certain
actions
respect
food
stamps
statute
use
knowingly
read
modify
uses
transfers
acquires
alters
possesses
read
also
modify
manner
authorized
statute
noting
neither
interpretation
posed
constitutional
problems
held
scienter
requirement
applied
elements
invoking
background
principle
set
forth
morissette
addition
concerned
broader
reading
criminalize
broad
range
apparently
innocent
conduct
imposing
criminal
liability
unwitting
food
stamp
recipient
purchased
groceries
store
inflated
prices
purchasers
struck
beyond
intended
reach
statute
video
analysis
drove
recent
conclusion
staples
criminally
liable
defendant
must
know
weapon
possessed
automatic
firing
capability
make
machine
gun
defined
national
firearms
act
congress
expressly
imposed
mens
rea
requirement
provision
criminalizing
possession
firearm
absence
proper
registration
first
rejected
argument
statute
described
public
welfare
offense
traditionally
excepted
background
principle
favoring
scienter
morissette
supra
expressed
concern
statutory
reading
criminalize
behavior
defendant
believed
fell
within
long
tradition
widespread
lawful
gun
ownership
private
individuals
staples
slip
also
emphasized
harsh
penalties
attaching
violations
statute
significant
consideration
determining
whether
statute
construed
dispensing
mens
rea
slip
applying
principles
think
ninth
circuit
plain
language
reading
plain
first
public
welfare
offense
persons
harbor
settled
expectations
contents
magazines
film
generally
subject
stringent
public
regulation
fact
first
amendment
constraints
presuppose
opposite
view
rather
statute
akin
common
law
offenses
state
person
property
public
morals
morissette
supra
presume
scienter
requirement
absence
express
contrary
intent
second
video
staples
concern
harsh
penalties
looms
equally
large
respecting
violations
punishable
years
prison
well
substantial
fines
forfeiture
see
also
morissette
supra
morissette
reinforced
staples
instructs
presumption
favor
scienter
requirement
apply
statutory
elements
criminalize
otherwise
innocent
conduct
staples
held
features
gun
technically
described
firearm
registration
act
element
holding
rested
upon
nature
particular
device
substance
congress
subjected
regulation
expectations
individuals
may
legitimately
dealing
regulated
items
staples
supra
slip
age
minority
indisputably
possesses
status
elemental
fact
sexually
explicit
materials
involving
persons
age
protected
first
amendment
alexander
slip
sable
communications
california
federal
communications
commission
dallas
smith
california
light
decisions
one
reasonably
video
expect
free
regulation
trafficking
sexually
explicit
though
obscene
materials
involving
adults
therefore
age
performers
crucial
element
separating
legal
innocence
wrongful
conduct
legislative
history
statute
evolved
period
years
perhaps
reason
speaks
somewhat
indistinctly
question
whether
knowingly
statute
modifies
elements
visual
depiction
involves
use
minor
engaging
sexually
explicit
conduct
merely
verbs
transport
ship
receive
distribute
reproduce
held
smith
california
supra
california
statute
dispensed
mens
rea
requirement
contents
obscene
book
violate
first
amendment
congress
began
dealing
child
pornography
content
legislative
debates
suggest
aware
decision
see
cong
rec
intended
knowledge
type
material
proscribed
bill
legislative
history
clear
remove
chance
lead
constitutional
problems
even
case
impute
congress
intent
pass
legislation
inconsistent
constitution
construed
yates
construing
video
statute
assume
congress
chose
disregard
constitutional
danger
zone
clearly
marked
first
passed
punished
one
knowingly
transports
ships
interstate
foreign
commerce
mails
purpose
sale
distribution
sale
obscene
visual
print
medium
involved
use
minor
engaged
sexually
explicit
conduct
pub
stat
emphasis
added
assuming
awareness
smith
minimum
knowingly
intended
modify
obscene
version
congress
amended
statute
current
form
broadening
application
sexually
explicit
materials
obscene
defined
miller
california
restricted
without
violating
first
amendment
explained
new
york
ferber
congress
eliminated
adjective
obscene
elements
defining
character
content
materials
issue
relegated
subsections
effort
expand
child
pornography
statute
full
constitutional
limits
congress
nowhere
expressed
intent
eliminate
mens
rea
requirement
previously
attached
character
content
material
word
obscene
committee
reports
legislative
debate
speak
opaquely
desire
congress
scienter
requirement
respect
age
minority
early
form
proposed
legislation
rejected
principally
failed
distinguish
video
obscene
materials
evaluating
proposal
justice
department
offered
thoughts
word
knowingly
second
line
section
unnecessary
stricken
unless
knowingly
deleted
bill
might
subject
interpretation
requiring
government
prove
defendant
knowledge
everything
follows
knowingly
including
age
child
assume
intention
drafters
require
government
prove
defendant
knew
child
age
sixteen
merely
prove
child
fact
less
age
sixteen
hand
use
word
knowingly
subsection
appropriate
make
clear
bill
apply
common
carriers
innocent
transporters
knowledge
nature
character
material
transporting
clarify
situation
legislative
history
might
reflect
defendant
knowledge
age
child
element
offense
bill
intended
apply
innocent
transportation
knowledge
nature
character
material
involved
emphasis
added
video
mean
distributor
seller
must
either
first
actual
knowledge
materials
contain
child
pornographic
depictions
second
circumstances
must
actual
knowledge
mere
inadvertence
negligence
alone
enough
render
actions
unlawful
absolutely
correct
amendment
limited
phrase
knowingly
insures
sellers
distributors
consciously
deliberately
engaged
marketing
child
pornography
subject
prosecution
ibid
video
video
legislative
history
summarized
saying
persuasively
indicates
congress
intended
term
knowingly
apply
requirement
depiction
sexually
explicit
conduct
good
deal
less
clear
committee
reports
floor
debates
congress
intended
requirement
extend
also
age
performers
turning
statute
term
knowingly
applies
sexually
explicit
conduct
depicted
emancipated
merely
modifying
verbs
subsections
matter
grammar
difficult
conclude
word
knowingly
modifies
one
elements
final
canon
statutory
construction
supports
reading
term
knowingly
applies
elements
cases
ferber
obscenity
laws
criminal
responsibility
may
imposed
without
element
scienter
part
defendant
smith
california
hamling
osborne
ohio
suggest
statute
completely
bereft
scienter
requirement
age
performers
raise
serious
constitutional
doubts
therefore
incumbent
upon
us
read
statute
eliminate
doubts
long
reading
plainly
contrary
intent
congress
edward
debartolo
florida
gulf
video
coast
building
construction
trades
council
foregoing
reasons
conclude
term
knowingly
extends
sexually
explicit
nature
material
age
performers
alternative
grounds
upholding
reversal
convictions
respondents
reiterate
constitutional
challenge
claims
encompassed
question
granted
certiorari
prevailing
party
without
entitled
precedents
urge
grounds
lend
support
judgment
dayton
bd
ed
brinkman
respondents
argue
section
unconstitutionally
vague
overbroad
makes
age
majority
rather
new
york
statute
upheld
new
york
ferber
supra
congress
replaced
term
lewd
term
lascivious
defining
illegal
exhibition
genitals
children
regard
claims
insubstantial
reject
reasons
stated
appeals
opinion
case
respondents
also
argued
indictment
fatally
defective
contain
scienter
requirement
age
minority
appeals
reach
issue
determination
unconstitutional
face
decline
decide
judgment
appeals
reversed
footnotes
morissette
treatment
common
law
presumption
mens
rea
recognized
presumption
expressly
excepted
sex
offenses
rape
victim
actual
age
determinative
despite
defendant
reasonable
belief
girl
video
reached
age
consent
criminalization
pornography
production
see
infra
perpetrator
confronts
underage
victim
personally
may
reasonably
required
ascertain
victim
age
opportunity
reasonable
mistake
age
increases
significantly
victim
reduced
visual
depiction
unavailable
questioning
distributor
receiver
thus
think
common
law
treatment
sex
offenses
militates
construction
present
statute
regard
age
minority
jurisdictional
fact
enhances
offense
otherwise
committed
evil
intent
see
feola
video
require
knowledge
jurisdictional
facts
target
assault
federal
officer
criminal
intent
serves
separate
understand
wrongful
nature
act
require
knowledge
precise
consequences
may
flow
act
aware
act
wrongful
cf
hamling
knowledge
materials
issue
legally
obscene
required
miller
test
obscenity
asks
whether
work
taken
whole
appeals
prurient
interest
depicts
describes
sexual
conduct
patently
offensive
way
lacks
serious
literary
artistic
political
scientific
value
miller
difference
congressional
intent
respect
versus
reflects
reality
producers
conveniently
able
ascertain
age
performers
thus
makes
sense
impose
risk
error
producers
district
central
district
california
although
producers
may
convicted
without
proof
knowledge
age
congress
independently
required
primary
secondary
producers
record
ages
performers
independent
penalties
failure
comply
ed
supp
american
library
assn
reno
cadc
congress
amended
insert
subsection
pub
stat
provision
created
new
offenses
relating
advertising
availability
child
pornography
soliciting
children
participate
depictions
legislative
history
address
scienter
requirement
government
must
prove
defendant
knew
character
visual
depictions
depicting
minor
engaging
sexually
explicit
conduct
need
prove
defendant
actually
knew
person
depicted
fact
years
age
depictions
violated
federal
law
may
argued
since
house
committee
report
rejects
requirement
scienter
age
minority
video
house
committee
thought
requirement
views
one
congress
meaning
act
passed
earlier
congress
ordinarily
great
weight
clark
citing
southwestern
cable
views
committee
one
house
another
congress
even
less
weight
pierce
underwood
video
justice
stevens
concurring
opinion
normal
commonsense
reading
subsection
criminal
statute
introduced
word
knowingly
treat
adverb
modifying
elements
offense
identified
remainder
subsection
reads
follows
person
knowingly
transports
ships
interstate
foreign
commerce
means
including
computer
mails
visual
depiction
producing
visual
depiction
involves
use
minor
engaging
sexually
explicit
conduct
visual
depiction
conduct
emphasis
added
video
video
justice
scalia
justice
thomas
joins
dissenting
today
opinion
without
antecedent
none
decisions
cited
authority
support
interpreting
explicit
statutory
scienter
requirement
manner
language
simply
bear
staples
discussed
ante
gypsum
discussed
ante
applied
background
rule
scienter
statute
said
nothing
matter
morissette
discussed
ante
applied
background
rule
statute
contain
word
knowingly
order
conclude
knowingly
converts
requires
knowledge
merely
fact
one
assertion
dominion
property
also
knowledge
fact
assertion
conversion
wrongful
liparota
video
discussed
ante
involved
statute
contain
word
knowingly
used
fashion
reasonably
grammatically
thought
apply
phrase
uses
transfers
acquires
alters
possesses
cause
defendant
liable
without
wrongful
intent
also
later
phrase
manner
authorized
statute
applying
background
rule
scienter
latter
reasonable
permissible
reading
preferred
way
cases
combination
read
stand
sweeping
proposition
presumption
favor
scienter
requirement
apply
statutory
elements
criminalize
otherwise
innocent
conduct
ante
even
plain
text
statute
says
otherwise
earlier
cases
employ
presumption
rule
interpretation
applies
congress
addressed
question
criminal
intent
staples
gypsum
import
said
subject
ambiguous
morissette
liparota
today
opinion
converts
rule
interpretation
rule
law
contradicting
plain
import
congress
specifically
prescribed
regarding
criminal
intent
thomas
cert
denied
ninth
circuit
interpreted
require
knowledge
neither
fact
visual
depiction
portrays
sexually
explicit
conduct
fact
participant
conduct
minor
panel
present
case
accepted
interpretation
see
say
interpretation
grammatical
reading
ante
natural
grammatical
reading
ante
understatement
point
distortion
rather
like
saying
ordinarily
preferred
video
total
plus
ninth
circuit
interpretation
fact
quite
obviously
grammatical
reading
one
rack
brains
way
express
thought
knowledge
requirement
subsection
applied
transportation
shipment
visual
depiction
interstate
foreign
commerce
fact
depiction
produced
use
minor
engaging
sexually
explicit
conduct
depiction
conduct
impossible
construct
sentence
structure
clearly
conveys
thought
thought
alone
word
knowingly
contained
merely
distant
phrase
entirely
separate
clause
one
today
opinion
inserts
equivalent
expressing
simpler
thought
following
anyone
knowingly
subject
fine
conduct
occurs
rush
hour
clearer
scienter
requirement
applies
time
day
also
clearer
applies
transportation
shipment
visual
depiction
interstate
foreign
commerce
doubt
ambiguity
possible
less
natural
nonetheless
permissible
reading
willing
case
civil
statutes
acknowledge
doctrine
scrivener
error
permits
give
unusual
though
meaning
word
given
normal
meaning
produce
absurd
arguably
unconstitutional
result
see
green
bock
laundry
machine
scalia
concurring
even
willing
stretch
doctrine
give
problematic
text
meaning
possibly
bear
even
willing
extend
doctrine
criminal
cases
application
produce
conviction
rather
video
acquittal
still
proper
bearing
sine
qua
non
scrivener
error
doctrine
seems
meaning
genuinely
intended
inadequately
expressed
must
absolutely
clear
otherwise
might
rewriting
statute
rather
correcting
technical
mistake
condition
met
acknowledges
good
deal
less
clear
committee
reports
floor
debates
congress
intended
requirement
scienter
extend
age
performers
ante
surely
fact
seems
dominant
entirely
uncontradicted
view
expressed
legislative
history
set
forth
statement
carter
administration
justice
department
introduced
original
bill
defendant
knowledge
age
child
element
offense
bill
intended
apply
innocent
transportation
knowledge
nature
character
material
involved
applied
final
bill
mean
scienter
requirement
applies
element
crime
depiction
sexually
explicit
conduct
element
depiction
involv
use
minor
engaging
conduct
see
interpretation
argued
ninth
circuit
see
rejects
construction
statute
two
reasons
first
matter
grammar
difficult
conclude
word
knowingly
modifies
one
elements
ante
described
matter
grammar
also
difficult
nay
impossible
conclude
word
knowingly
modifies
elements
really
quite
extraordinary
fresh
says
emancipated
video
adverb
grammatical
restriction
renders
inapplicable
entire
conditional
clause
suddenly
insist
demands
syntax
must
prevail
legislative
intent
thus
producing
end
result
accords
neither
syntax
supposed
intent
statute
says
must
ignored
one
think
might
settle
least
statute
meant
say
alas
told
statute
says
prevents
second
reason
even
worse
statute
completely
bereft
scienter
requirement
age
performers
raise
serious
constitutional
doubts
ante
view
apparent
view
government
appeals
true
derives
serious
constitutional
doubts
fact
sexually
explicit
materials
involving
persons
age
protected
first
amendment
ante
made
entirely
clear
however
first
amendment
protection
accorded
materials
extensive
accorded
speech
surely
less
vital
interest
uninhibited
exhibition
material
borderline
pornography
artistic
expression
free
dissemination
ideas
social
political
significance
young
american
mini
theatres
see
also
ven
though
recognize
first
amendment
tolerate
total
suppression
erotic
materials
arguably
artistic
value
manifest
society
interest
protecting
type
expression
wholly
different
lesser
magnitude
interest
untrammeled
political
debate
opinion
stevens
joined
burger
white
rehnquist
cf
fcc
pacifica
foundation
broadcasts
patently
offensive
references
excretory
sexual
organs
video
activities
may
protected
surely
lie
periphery
first
amendment
concern
let
us
clear
sort
pictures
issue
sort
likely
found
catalog
national
gallery
metropolitan
museum
art
exually
explicit
conduct
defined
statute
include
mere
nudity
conduct
consists
sexual
intercourse
persons
opposite
sex
bestiality
masturbation
sadistic
masochistic
abuse
lascivious
exhibition
genitals
pubic
area
see
involved
words
clinical
artistic
even
risque
pornography
indeed
think
entirely
clear
involved
constitutes
merely
pornography
fully
proscribable
obscenity
except
extent
joined
material
perhaps
manner
presentation
artistic
social
value
see
miller
california
requirement
imposed
course
upon
fully
protected
speech
one
shout
republic
hooray
mozart
even
skidoo
whether
expression
joined
something
else
social
value
whereas
one
side
balance
present
case
material
minimal
first
amendment
concern
described
side
prevention
sexual
exploitation
abuse
children
government
objective
surpassing
importance
new
york
ferber
concerned
holding
purveyors
receivers
material
absolutely
liable
supporting
exploitation
minors
deter
activity
constitution
designed
protect
concerned
suggestion
unconstitutionality
absolute
liability
cause
video
congress
leave
world
children
inadequately
protected
depredations
pornography
trade
recognized
ferber
supra
producers
materials
always
readily
found
often
located
abroad
knowledge
performers
age
dealers
specialize
child
pornography
purchasers
sustain
market
obviously
hard
prove
first
amendment
lose
none
value
free
society
knowingly
place
stream
pornographic
commerce
obliged
make
sure
subsidizing
child
abuse
unconstitutional
make
persons
knowingly
deal
pornography
criminally
liable
underage
character
entertainers
make
men
engage
consensual
fornication
criminally
liable
statutory
rape
underage
character
partners
dispose
present
case
ninth
circuit
reading
statute
written
provide
criminal
penalties
knowing
transportation
shipment
visual
depiction
interstate
foreign
commerce
knowing
receipt
distribution
visual
depiction
transported
shipped
depiction
whether
defendant
knew
portrayal
minor
engaging
sexually
explicit
conduct
find
statute
interpreted
unconstitutional
since
imposing
criminal
liability
upon
knowingly
dealing
pornography
establishes
severe
deterrent
narrowly
tailored
purposes
upon
fully
protected
first
amendment
activities
see
smith
california
conclusion
unconstitutionality
course
ground
going
back
reinterpret
statute
making
say
something
say
constitutional
every
construction
every
reasonable
construction
must
resorted
video
order
save
statute
unconstitutionality
edward
debartolo
florida
gulf
coast
building
construction
trades
council
quoting
hooper
california
emphasis
added
although
often
strain
construe
legislation
save
constitutional
attack
must
carry
point
perverting
purpose
statute
judicially
rewriting
commodity
futures
trading
schor
quoting
aptheker
secretary
state
otherwise
thing
unconstitutional
statute
earlier
discussed
present
case
reasonable
alternative
construction
exists
neither
coaxed
text
substituted
text
scrivener
error
grounds
therefore
agree
ninth
circuit
respondent
conviction
stand
understand
though
approve
disposition
order
uphold
statute
departed
text
little
possible
order
sustain
constitutionality
disposition
applying
scienter
requirement
pornographic
nature
materials
age
performers
neither
understand
approve
disposition
urged
adopted
today
rewrites
statute
rewrites
radically
constitutional
survival
demands
raises
baseless
constitutional
doubts
impede
congressional
enactment
law
providing
greater
protection
pornography
industry
today
saves
single
conviction
putting
place
relatively
toothless
law
congress
enact
rendering
congressional
strengthening
new
law
difficult
respectfully
dissent
case
involve
claims
situation
even
obviously
statute
presently
us
word
knowingly
isolated
position
suggested
attached
verb
converts
ante
nonetheless
applied
well
another
word
issue
simply
meaning
knowingly
converts
video