trop
dulles
argued
may
decided
march
least
applied
case
citizen
voluntarily
relinquish
abandon
citizenship
become
involved
way
foreign
nation
nationality
act
amended
provides
citizen
shall
lose
nationality
deserting
military
naval
forces
time
war
provided
convicted
thereof
martial
result
conviction
dismissed
dishonorably
discharged
service
unconstitutional
pp
reversed
chief
justice
opinion
joined
justice
black
justice
douglas
justice
whittaker
concluded
citizenship
subject
general
powers
national
government
therefore
divested
exercise
powers
pp
even
citizenship
divested
exercise
governmental
power
violates
eighth
amendment
penal
nature
prescribes
cruel
unusual
punishment
pp
justice
brennan
agreeing
perez
brownell
ante
constitutional
infirmity
expatriates
citizen
votes
foreign
political
election
concluded
case
lies
beyond
power
congress
enact
pp
dissenting
opinion
justice
frankfurter
joined
justice
burton
justice
clark
justice
harlan
see
post
osmond
fraenkel
argued
cause
filed
briefs
petitioner
oscar
davis
argued
cause
respondents
original
argument
solicitor
general
rankin
reargument
briefs
warren
olney
iii
assistant
attorney
general
bishop
beatrice
rosenberg
also
brief
reargument
chief
justice
warren
announced
judgment
delivered
opinion
justice
black
justice
douglas
justice
whittaker
join
petitioner
case
american
declared
lost
citizenship
become
stateless
reason
conviction
wartime
desertion
perez
brownell
ante
issue
us
whether
forfeiture
citizenship
comports
constitution
facts
dispute
petitioner
private
army
serving
french
morocco
may
escaped
stockade
casablanca
confined
following
previous
breach
discipline
next
day
petitioner
companion
walking
along
road
towards
rabat
general
direction
back
casablanca
army
truck
approached
stopped
witness
testified
petitioner
boarded
truck
willingly
words
spoken
rabat
petitioner
turned
military
police
thus
ended
petitioner
desertion
gone
less
day
willingly
surrendered
officer
army
vehicle
walking
back
towards
base
testified
time
companion
picked
army
truck
decided
return
stockade
going
tough
money
speak
time
foot
getting
cold
hungry
general
convicted
petitioner
desertion
sentenced
three
years
hard
labor
forfeiture
pay
allowances
dishonorable
discharge
petitioner
applied
passport
application
denied
ground
provisions
section
nationality
act
amended
lost
citizenship
reason
conviction
dishonorable
discharge
wartime
desertion
petitioner
commenced
action
district
seeking
declaratory
judgment
citizen
government
motion
summary
judgment
granted
appeals
second
circuit
affirmed
chief
judge
clark
dissenting
granted
certiorari
section
statute
decrees
forfeiture
petitioner
citizenship
based
directly
civil
war
statute
provided
deserter
lose
rights
citizenship
meaning
phrase
clear
codification
revision
nationality
laws
prepared
civil
war
statute
amended
make
certain
convicted
deserter
lose
nationality
statute
amended
provide
convicted
deserter
lose
citizenship
dismissed
service
dishonorably
discharged
time
provided
citizenship
regained
deserter
restored
active
duty
wartime
permission
military
authorities
though
amendments
added
ameliorate
harshness
statute
combined
effect
produces
result
poses
far
graver
problems
ones
sought
solved
section
amended
gives
military
authorities
complete
discretion
decide
among
convicted
deserters
shall
continue
americans
shall
stateless
deciding
whether
issue
execute
dishonorable
discharge
whether
allow
deserter
armed
forces
military
becomes
arbiter
citizenship
domain
given
congress
narrow
might
supposed
though
crime
desertion
one
serious
military
law
means
rare
event
soldier
convicted
crime
elements
desertion
simply
absence
duty
plus
intention
return
category
falls
great
range
conduct
may
prompted
variety
motives
fear
laziness
hysteria
emotional
imbalance
offense
may
occur
combat
also
training
camps
draftees
country
solicitor
general
informed
world
war
ii
according
army
estimates
approximately
soldiers
airmen
convicted
desertion
given
dishonorable
discharges
sentencing
actually
separated
service
thus
rendered
stateless
reviewing
authorities
refused
remit
dishonorable
discharges
group
men
enlarged
whatever
corresponding
figures
may
navy
marines
military
given
power
grant
withhold
citizenship
number
youths
subject
power
easily
enlarged
simply
expanding
statute
cover
crimes
desertion
instance
dishonorable
discharge
might
future
declared
sufficient
justify
forfeiture
citizenship
three
times
past
three
years
confronted
cases
presenting
important
questions
bearing
proper
relationship
civilian
military
authority
country
statute
section
raises
serious
issues
area
view
case
unnecessary
deal
problems
conclude
judgment
case
must
reversed
following
reasons
perez
brownell
supra
expressed
principles
believe
govern
constitutional
status
citizenship
conviction
citizenship
subject
general
powers
national
government
therefore
divested
exercise
powers
right
may
voluntarily
relinquished
abandoned
either
express
language
language
conduct
show
renunciation
citizenship
principles
petitioner
lost
citizenship
desertion
wartime
though
may
merit
ultimate
penalty
necessarily
signify
allegiance
foreign
state
section
limited
cases
desertion
enemy
element
case
soldier
committed
crime
punished
involve
way
foreign
state
dilution
allegiance
country
fact
desertion
occurred
foreign
soil
consequence
solicitor
general
acknowledged
forfeiture
citizenship
occurred
entire
incident
transpired
country
citizenship
license
expires
upon
misbehavior
duties
citizenship
numerous
discharge
many
obligations
essential
security
nation
citizen
fails
pay
taxes
abide
laws
safeguarding
integrity
elections
deals
dangerous
blow
country
citizen
deprived
nationality
evading
basic
responsibilities
citizenship
time
war
citizen
duties
include
military
defense
nation
also
full
participation
manifold
activities
civilian
ranks
failure
perform
obligations
may
cause
nation
serious
injury
appropriate
circumstances
punishing
power
available
deal
derelictions
duty
citizenship
lost
every
time
duty
citizenship
shirked
deprivation
citizenship
weapon
government
may
use
express
displeasure
citizen
conduct
however
reprehensible
conduct
may
long
person
voluntarily
renounce
abandon
citizenship
petitioner
done
neither
believe
fundamental
right
citizenship
secure
ground
alone
judgment
case
reversed
ii
since
majority
concluded
perez
brownell
citizenship
may
divested
exercise
governmental
power
deem
appropriate
state
additionally
action
taken
case
exceeds
constitutional
limits
even
majority
decision
perez
concluded
perez
citizenship
divested
exercise
foreign
affairs
power
case
urged
war
power
adequate
support
divestment
citizenship
vital
difference
two
statutes
purport
implement
powers
decreeing
loss
citizenship
statute
perez
decreed
loss
citizenship
majority
concluded
eliminate
international
problems
thought
arise
reason
citizen
voted
foreign
election
statute
case
however
entirely
different
section
decrees
loss
citizenship
found
guilty
crime
desertion
essentially
like
section
nationality
act
decreeing
loss
citizenship
evading
draft
remaining
outside
provision
also
perez
majority
declined
consider
validity
section
decrees
loss
citizenship
without
providing
semblance
procedural
due
process
whereby
guilt
draft
evader
may
determined
sanction
imposed
section
provision
case
accords
accused
deserter
least
safeguards
adjudication
guilt
constitutional
question
posed
section
appear
whether
denationalization
may
inflicted
punishment
even
assuming
citizenship
may
divested
pursuant
governmental
power
government
contends
statute
impose
penalty
constitutional
limitations
power
congress
punish
therefore
inapplicable
told
committee
cabinet
members
recommending
legislation
congress
said
technically
penal
law
simple
tasks
constitutional
adjudication
law
generally
specific
problems
solved
inspection
labels
pasted
manifestly
issue
whether
section
penal
law
thus
determined
course
relevant
know
classification
employed
cabinet
committee
played
important
role
preparation
nationality
act
equally
relevant
know
committee
acknowledged
section
based
provisions
civil
war
statute
committee
termed
distinctly
penal
character
furthermore
statute
terms
deprivation
rights
citizenship
addition
lawful
penalties
crime
desertion
certainly
relevant
know
reason
given
senate
committee
immigration
loss
nationality
section
follow
desertion
conviction
penalty
drastic
doubtless
even
clear
legislative
classification
statute
alter
fundamental
nature
plainly
penal
statute
regard
section
fact
views
cabinet
committee
congress
nature
statute
equivocal
possibly
provide
answer
inquiry
determination
whether
statute
penal
law
requires
careful
consideration
form
section
appears
regulation
nationality
statute
deals
initially
status
nationality
specifies
conduct
result
loss
status
surely
form
provide
answer
inquiry
statute
providing
person
shall
lose
liberty
committing
bank
robbery
though
form
regulation
liberty
nonetheless
penal
penal
effect
altered
labeling
regulation
banks
arguing
rational
connection
safeguarding
banks
imprisoning
bank
robbers
inquiry
must
directed
substance
called
upon
decide
whether
various
statutes
penal
ever
since
calder
bull
dall
time
statute
challenged
conflict
constitutional
prohibitions
bills
attainder
ex
post
facto
laws
necessary
determine
whether
penal
law
involved
provisions
apply
statutes
imposing
penalties
deciding
whether
law
penal
generally
based
determination
upon
purpose
statute
statute
imposes
disability
purposes
punishment
reprimand
wrongdoer
deter
others
etc
considered
penal
statute
considered
nonpenal
imposes
disability
punish
accomplish
legitimate
governmental
purpose
recognized
statute
decreeing
adversity
consequence
certain
conduct
may
penal
nonpenal
effect
controlling
nature
statutes
normally
depends
evident
purpose
legislature
point
may
illustrated
situation
ordinary
felon
person
commits
bank
robbery
instance
loses
right
liberty
often
right
vote
exercise
power
protect
banks
sanctions
imposed
purpose
punishing
bank
robbers
statutes
authorizing
disabilities
penal
purpose
latter
statute
designate
reasonable
ground
eligibility
voting
law
sustained
nonpenal
exercise
power
regulate
franchise
reasoning
applies
section
purpose
taking
away
citizenship
convicted
deserter
simply
punish
legitimate
purpose
statute
serve
denationalization
case
even
claimed
means
solving
international
problems
argued
perez
purpose
punishment
therefore
statute
penal
law
urged
statute
penal
law
regulatory
provision
authorized
war
power
denied
congress
power
prescribe
rules
governing
proper
performance
military
obligations
perhaps
significant
performance
one
duty
hazardous
important
service
required
statute
prescribes
consequence
befall
one
fails
abide
regulatory
provisions
penal
law
plainly
legislation
prescribing
imprisonment
crime
desertion
penal
nature
loss
citizenship
substituted
imprisonment
fairly
said
use
particular
sanction
transforms
fundamental
nature
statute
fact
dishonorable
discharge
consequent
loss
citizenship
might
punishment
meted
world
war
ii
threat
punishment
explicitly
communicated
army
soldiers
field
statute
taking
away
citizenship
congressional
exercise
war
power
rationally
treated
penal
law
imposes
sanction
denationalization
purpose
punishing
transgression
standard
conduct
prescribed
exercise
power
government
argues
sanction
denationalization
imposed
section
penalty
deportation
considered
deportation
undoubtedly
harsh
sanction
severe
penal
effect
past
sustained
deportation
exercise
sovereign
power
determine
conditions
upon
alien
may
reside
country
example
statute
authorizing
deportation
alien
convicted
espionage
act
viewed
designed
punish
crime
espionage
implementation
sovereign
power
exclude
deporting
power
derived
mahler
eby
view
deportation
may
highly
fictional
even
validity
conceded
wholly
inapplicable
case
one
contends
government
addition
power
exclude
aliens
sweeping
power
denationalize
citizens
comparison
denaturalization
eliminate
penal
effect
denationalization
case
denaturalization
imposed
penalize
alien
falsified
application
citizenship
punishment
rather
imposed
exercise
power
make
rules
naturalization
aliens
short
fact
deportation
denaturalization
fraudulent
procurement
citizenship
may
imposed
purposes
punishment
affords
basis
saying
case
denationalization
punishment
section
penal
law
must
face
question
whether
constitution
permits
congress
take
away
citizenship
punishment
crime
assumed
power
congress
extends
divestment
citizenship
problem
still
remains
statute
whether
denationalization
cruel
unusual
punishment
within
meaning
eighth
amendment
since
wartime
desertion
punishable
death
argument
penalty
denationalization
excessive
relation
gravity
crime
question
whether
penalty
subjects
individual
fate
forbidden
principle
civilized
treatment
guaranteed
eighth
amendment
outset
let
us
put
one
side
death
penalty
index
constitutional
limit
punishment
whatever
arguments
may
capital
punishment
moral
grounds
terms
accomplishing
purposes
punishment
forceful
death
penalty
employed
throughout
history
day
still
widely
accepted
said
violate
constitutional
concept
cruelty
equally
plain
existence
death
penalty
license
government
devise
punishment
short
death
within
limit
imagination
exact
scope
constitutional
phrase
cruel
unusual
detailed
basic
policy
reflected
words
firmly
established
tradition
criminal
justice
phrase
constitution
taken
directly
english
declaration
rights
principle
represents
traced
back
magna
carta
basic
concept
underlying
eighth
amendment
nothing
less
dignity
man
state
power
punish
amendment
stands
assure
power
exercised
within
limits
civilized
standards
fines
imprisonment
even
execution
may
imposed
depending
upon
enormity
crime
technique
outside
bounds
traditional
penalties
constitutionally
suspect
little
occasion
give
precise
content
eighth
amendment
enlightened
democracy
surprising
confronted
punishment
years
irons
hard
painful
labor
imposed
crime
falsifying
public
records
hesitate
declare
penalty
cruel
excessiveness
unusual
character
weems
recognized
case
words
amendment
precise
scope
static
amendment
must
draw
meaning
evolving
standards
decency
mark
progress
maturing
society
believe
chief
judge
clark
use
denationalization
punishment
barred
eighth
amendment
may
involved
physical
mistreatment
primitive
torture
instead
total
destruction
individual
status
organized
society
form
punishment
primitive
torture
destroys
individual
political
existence
centuries
development
punishment
strips
citizen
status
national
international
political
community
existence
sufferance
country
happens
find
one
country
may
accord
rights
presumably
long
remained
country
enjoy
limited
rights
alien
country
need
stateless
furthermore
enjoyment
even
limited
rights
alien
might
subject
termination
time
reason
deportation
short
expatriate
lost
right
rights
punishment
offensive
cardinal
principles
constitution
stands
subjects
individual
fate
fear
distress
knows
discriminations
may
established
proscriptions
may
directed
cause
existence
native
land
may
terminated
may
subject
banishment
fate
universally
decried
civilized
people
stateless
condition
deplored
international
community
democracies
answer
suggest
disastrous
consequences
fate
may
brought
bear
stateless
person
threat
makes
punishment
obnoxious
civilized
nations
world
virtual
unanimity
statelessness
imposed
punishment
crime
true
several
countries
prescribe
expatriation
event
nationals
engage
conduct
derogation
native
allegiance
even
statutes
sort
generally
applicable
primarily
naturalized
citizens
use
denationalization
punishment
crime
entirely
different
matter
nations
survey
nationality
laws
nations
world
reveals
two
countries
philippines
turkey
impose
denationalization
penalty
desertion
country
eighth
amendment
forbids
done
concluding
eighth
amendment
forbids
congress
punish
taking
away
citizenship
mindful
gravity
issue
inevitably
raised
whenever
constitutionality
act
national
legislature
challenged
member
believes
case
statute
us
construed
avoid
issue
constitutionality
issue
confronts
us
task
resolving
inescapably
task
requires
exercise
judgment
reliance
upon
personal
preferences
courts
must
consider
wisdom
statutes
neither
sanction
merely
unwise
constitution
forbids
defend
constitution
obligation
requires
congressional
enactments
judged
standards
constitution
judiciary
duty
implementing
constitutional
safeguards
protect
individual
rights
government
acts
take
away
fundamental
right
citizenship
safeguards
constitution
examined
special
diligence
provisions
constitution
adages
hollow
shibboleths
vital
living
principles
authorize
limit
governmental
powers
nation
rules
government
constitutionality
act
congress
challenged
must
apply
rules
words
constitution
become
little
good
advice
appears
act
congress
conflicts
one
provisions
choice
enforce
paramount
commands
constitution
sworn
less
push
back
limits
constitution
merely
accommodate
challenged
legislation
must
apply
limits
constitution
prescribes
bearing
mind
broad
scope
legislative
discretion
ultimate
responsibility
constitutional
adjudication
well
approach
task
cautiously
predecessors
counseled
ordeal
judgment
shirked
instances
since
established
determined
congressional
action
exceeded
bounds
constitution
case
judgment
appeals
second
circuit
reversed
cause
remanded
district
appropriate
proceedings
reversed
remanded
footnotes
act
march
stat
see
roche
loss
american
nationality
development
statutory
expatriation
rev
administratively
phrase
rights
citizenship
apparently
taken
mean
citizenship
see
foreign
relations
exec
doc
pt
vol
ii
view
secretary
state
fish
doc
sess
state
department
board
hearings
house
committee
immigration
naturalization
sess
testimony
richard
flournoy
state
department
representative
hearings
entirely
clear
however
congress
fully
appreciated
fact
section
rendered
convicted
deserter
stateless
regard
following
colloquy
occurred
hearings
house
committee
immigration
naturalization
congressmen
allen
kearney
members
committee
edward
shaughnessy
deputy
commissioner
immigration
illuminating
allen
convicted
desertion
martial
time
war
loses
citizenship
shaughnessy
correct
allen
words
thing
civil
courts
one
convicted
felony
sent
penitentiary
one
loses
citizenship
shaughnessy
loses
rights
citizenship
kearney
difference
losing
citizenship
losing
civil
rights
shaughnessy
loses
civil
rights
citizenship
loses
citizenship
allen
loses
rights
derived
citizenship
shaughnessy
yes
almost
amounts
thing
technical
difference
allen
still
american
citizen
rights
shaughnessy
rights
citizenship
hearings
house
committee
immigration
naturalization
sess
see
also
elmer
true
loss
citizenship
desertion
state
matter
government
nothing
act
january
stat
see
sess
sess
cong
rec
articles
war
stat
article
uniform
code
military
justice
supp
winthrop
military
law
precedents
reprint
solicitor
general
stated
argument
apply
desertion
camps
ex
rel
toth
quarles
reid
covert
harmon
brucker
stat
amended
stat
person
national
whether
birth
naturalization
shall
lose
nationality
departing
remaining
outside
jurisdiction
time
war
period
declared
president
period
national
emergency
purpose
evading
avoiding
training
service
land
naval
forces
codification
nationality
laws
comm
print
pt
sess
ibid
act
march
stat
sess
constantine
la
franca
art
cl
cl
lovett
calder
bull
dall
course
severity
disability
imposed
well
circumstances
surrounding
legislative
enactment
relevant
decision
see
generally
wormuth
legislative
disqualifications
bills
attainder
vand
rev
yale
lovett
supra
pierce
carskadon
wall
ex
parte
garland
wall
cummings
missouri
wall
mahler
eby
hawker
new
york
davis
beason
murphy
ramsey
see
gathings
loss
citizenship
civil
rights
conviction
crime
pol
sci
rev
cf
davis
beason
supra
murphy
ramsey
supra
see
war
department
circular
compilation
war
department
general
orders
bulletins
circulars
government
printing
office
mahler
eby
supra
bugajewitz
adams
fong
yue
ting
act
may
stat
act
june
stat
see
baumgartner
schneiderman
amend
viii
excessive
bail
shall
required
excessive
fines
imposed
cruel
unusual
punishments
inflicted
see
louisiana
ex
rel
francis
resweber
weems
howard
fleming
vermont
kemmler
wilkerson
utah
wm
mary
sess
see
rev
vand
rev
whether
word
unusual
qualitative
meaning
different
cruel
clear
occasions
consider
meaning
phrase
precise
distinctions
cruelty
unusualness
seem
drawn
see
weems
supra
vermont
supra
wilkerson
utah
supra
cases
indicate
simply
examines
particular
punishment
involved
light
basic
prohibition
inhuman
treatment
without
regard
subtleties
meaning
might
latent
word
unusual
cf
kemmler
supra
ex
rel
milwaukee
social
democratic
publishing
burleson
brandeis
dissenting
word
unusual
meaning
apart
word
cruel
however
meaning
ordinary
one
signifying
something
different
generally
done
denationalization
punishment
certainly
meets
test
never
explicitly
sanctioned
government
never
tested
constitution
day
cited
us
obviously
relied
masterful
analysis
expatriation
legislation
set
forth
comment
expatriation
act
yale
agree
author
documented
conclusions
therein
punitive
expatriation
persons
nationality
constitutes
cruel
unusual
punishment
invalid
since
doubt
add
persuasive
arguments
made
shall
merely
incorporate
reference
faith
american
concept
man
dignity
comport
making
even
punish
completely
stateless
fair
game
despoiler
home
oppressor
abroad
indeed
place
tolerate
see
discussion
perez
brownell
ante
see
study
statelessness
doc
statelessness
special
reference
borchard
diplomatic
protection
citizens
abroad
suggestion
judicial
relief
available
alleviate
potential
rigors
statelessness
assumes
much
undermining
assumption
still
fresh
memory
shaughnessy
ex
rel
mezei
alien
resident
country
years
returned
visit
abroad
find
barred
country
others
turned
summary
imprisonment
ellis
island
fate
without
judicial
examination
grounds
confinement
denied
relief
intolerable
situation
remedied
four
years
imprisonment
executive
action
matter
grace
see
times
see
laws
concerning
nationality
doc
cf
nationality
law
august
art
haiti
justice
black
justice
douglas
joins
concurring
concur
opinion
chief
justice
one
additional
thing
needs
said
even
citizenship
involuntarily
divested
believe
power
denationalize
may
placed
hands
military
authorities
desertion
misconduct
basis
forfeiting
citizenship
guilt
determined
civilian
justice
protections
bill
rights
guard
fairness
outcome
forfeiture
rest
findings
military
tribunal
military
courts
may
try
soldiers
punish
military
offenses
last
word
soldier
right
citizenship
statute
held
invalid
makes
military
finding
desertion
final
gives
military
authorities
discretion
choose
soldiers
convicted
desertion
shall
allowed
keep
citizenship
ones
shall
thereafter
stateless
nothing
constitution
history
lends
slightest
support
military
control
right
american
citizen
justice
brennan
concurring
perez
brownell
ante
also
decided
today
agreed
constitutional
infirmity
expatriates
citizen
votes
foreign
political
election
reach
different
conclusion
case
however
believe
expatriates
wartime
deserter
dishonorably
discharged
conviction
lies
beyond
congress
power
enact
concededly
paradoxical
justify
constitutional
expatriation
citizen
committed
crime
voting
mexican
political
election
yet
find
unconstitutional
statute
provides
expatriation
soldier
guilty
serious
crime
desertion
time
war
loss
citizenship
may
ominous
significance
individual
one
case
constitution
prevent
expatriation
voter
well
deserter
perez
brownell
must
inquire
whether
exists
relevant
connection
particular
legislative
enactment
power
granted
congress
constitution
held
relevant
connection
exists
power
maintain
relations
sovereign
nations
power
expatriate
american
votes
foreign
election
within
power
granted
congress
regulate
conduct
foreign
affairs
lies
power
deal
evils
might
obstruct
embarrass
diplomatic
interests
among
evils
congress
might
believe
voting
american
citizens
political
elections
nations
whatever
realities
situation
many
foreign
nations
may
well
view
political
activity
part
americans
even
lawful
either
expressions
official
american
positions
else
improper
meddling
affairs
either
event
reaction
liable
detrimental
interests
finding
evil
congress
empowered
prevent
concluded
expatriation
means
reasonably
calculated
achieve
end
expatriation
noted
advantage
acting
automatically
act
casting
ballot
act
denationalization
effect
cutting
american
responsibility
consequences
foreign
government
objects
answer
conclusive
voter
longer
one
harsh
consequences
may
individual
concerned
congress
ordained
loss
citizenship
simultaneously
act
voting
congress
might
reasonably
believe
circumstances
acceptable
alternative
expatriation
means
avoiding
possible
embarrassments
relations
foreign
nations
congress
determined
considerations
highest
national
importance
indicate
course
action
adequate
substitute
might
rationally
appear
lacking
say
means
lies
beyond
congress
power
choose
cf
korematsu
contrast
section
concerned
draws
upon
power
congress
raise
maintain
military
forces
wage
war
pretense
made
expatriation
deserter
way
relates
conduct
foreign
affairs
statute
limited
effects
desert
foreign
country
flee
another
land
statute
limited
application
deserter
whose
conduct
imports
elements
allegiance
another
country
measure
least
inconsistent
american
citizenship
perez
brownell
supra
history
provision
indeed
shows
essential
congressional
purpose
response
needs
military
maintaining
discipline
armed
forces
especially
wartime
serious
question
included
congress
power
maintain
armies
power
deal
problem
desertion
act
plainly
destructive
military
establishment
importantly
nation
ability
wage
war
effectively
granting
congress
authorized
deal
evil
desertion
must
yet
inquire
whether
expatriation
means
reasonably
calculated
achieve
legitimate
end
thereby
designed
ultimate
congressional
objective
successful
waging
war
expatriation
deserter
originated
act
stat
wholesale
desertion
draftlaw
violations
seriously
threatened
effectiveness
union
armies
act
expressly
provided
expatriation
addition
lawful
penalties
crime
desertion
emphasized
leading
case
act
huber
reily
decided
pennsylvania
little
year
passage
act
said
avowed
purpose
add
penalties
law
previously
affixed
offence
desertion
military
naval
service
denominates
additional
sanctions
provided
penalties
although
imposed
expatriation
entirely
added
punishment
crime
act
expressly
make
conviction
prerequisite
punishment
case
conventional
penalties
pennsylvania
felt
huber
right
contending
serious
constitutional
objection
act
proposes
inflict
pains
penalties
upon
offenders
without
trial
conviction
due
process
law
therefore
prohibited
bill
rights
however
construed
statute
avoid
constitutional
difficulties
holding
loss
citizenship
like
penalties
desertion
followed
upon
conviction
view
act
approved
kurtz
moffitt
noted
view
uniformly
held
civil
courts
well
military
authorities
see
mccafferty
guyer
state
symonds
gotcheus
matheson
barb
winthrop
military
law
precedents
ed
particular
significance
moreover
fact
congress
confirmed
correctness
view
purposed
expatriation
deserter
solely
additional
punishment
present
merely
incorporates
provision
codification
became
nationality
act
expressly
stated
omitted
act
namely
deserter
shall
expatriated
convicted
thereof
martial
stat
amended
difficult
indeed
see
expatriation
deserter
helps
wage
war
except
performs
function
imposed
punishment
obvious
expatriation
wise
avoid
harm
apprehended
congress
act
desertion
punishment
follow
harm
done
deserter
moreover
cease
american
citizen
moment
deserts
indeed
even
conviction
necessarily
effect
expatriation
dishonorable
discharge
condition
precedent
loss
citizenship
therefore
expatriation
made
consequence
desertion
must
stand
together
death
imprisonment
form
punishment
characterize
expatriation
punishment
course
beginning
critical
inquiry
punishment
may
extremely
harsh
crime
desertion
may
grave
indeed
however
harshness
punishment
may
important
consideration
asserted
power
expatriate
slight
tenuous
relation
granted
power
material
forms
one
today
judge
precise
consequences
expatriation
happily
american
law
little
experience
status
said
hypothetically
extent
severity
status
may
increased
consistently
demands
due
process
supposed
consequences
greatest
weight
terms
ultimate
impact
petitioner
unknown
unknowable
indeed
truth
may
live
life
minor
inconvenience
may
perhaps
live
work
marry
raise
family
generally
experience
satisfactorily
happy
life
nevertheless
denied
impact
expatriation
especially
statelessness
upshot
may
severe
expatriation
respect
constitutes
especially
demoralizing
sanction
uncertainty
consequent
psychological
hurt
must
accompany
one
becomes
outcast
land
must
reckoned
substantial
factor
ultimate
judgment
view
manifest
severity
sanction
feel
look
closely
probable
effect
determine
whether
congress
imposition
expatriation
penal
device
justified
reason
clearly
severity
penalty
case
serious
offense
enough
invalidate
nature
penalty
rationally
directed
achieve
legitimate
ends
punishment
novelty
expatriation
punishment
alone
demonstrate
inefficiency
recent
years
seen
devices
indeterminate
sentences
parole
added
traditional
term
imprisonment
penal
methods
seek
achieve
end
humane
effective
society
make
every
effort
rehabilitate
offender
restore
useful
member
society
society
best
protection
course
rehabilitation
one
several
purposes
penal
law
among
purposes
deterrents
wrongful
act
threat
punishment
insulation
society
dangerous
individuals
imprisonment
execution
relationship
punishment
expatriation
ends
penal
law
perfectly
obvious
constitutes
antithesis
rehabilitation
instead
guiding
offender
back
useful
paths
society
excommunicates
makes
literally
outcast
think
certain
way
make
man
perhaps
rest
seeds
serious
antisocial
behavior
likely
pursue
career
unlawful
activity
place
stigma
derelict
uncertain
many
basic
rights
similarly
must
questioned
whether
expatriation
really
achieve
effects
sought
society
punitive
devices
certainly
insulate
society
deserter
unless
coupled
banishment
sanction
leaves
offender
large
deterrent
device
sanction
appear
little
effect
offender
deterred
thought
specific
penalties
long
imprisonment
even
death
likely
swayed
course
prospect
expatriation
however
insidious
demoralizing
may
actual
experience
statelessness
contemplation
advance
seems
unlikely
invoke
serious
misgiving
none
us
yet
knows
ramifications
light
considerations
understandable
government
pressed
case
basis
expatriation
deserter
punishment
crime
rather
government
argues
necessary
nexus
granted
power
found
idea
legislative
withdrawal
citizenship
justified
case
trop
desertion
constituted
refusal
perform
one
highest
duties
american
citizenship
bearing
arms
time
desperate
national
peril
denied
implicit
certain
rough
justice
refuses
act
american
longer
american
fairer
see
anything
forcing
retribution
offender
naked
vengeance
many
acts
desertion
certainly
fall
far
short
refusal
perform
ultimate
duty
american
citizenship
desertion
defined
absence
without
leave
accompanied
intention
return
army
manual
offense
may
quite
technical
officer
tendered
resignation
prior
due
notice
acceptance
quits
post
proper
duties
without
leave
intent
absent
permanently
therefrom
article
war
stat
desertion
also
committed
soldier
without
received
regular
discharge
another
service
youngster
example
restive
assignment
supply
depot
runs
front
fight
subjects
possibility
sanction
yet
statute
imposes
penalty
coextensive
substantive
crime
since
many
acts
desertion
thus
certainly
fall
far
short
refusal
perform
ultimate
duty
american
citizenship
stretches
imagination
excessively
establish
rational
relation
mere
retribution
ends
purported
served
expatriation
deserter
simply
accept
judgment
congress
free
adopt
measure
demonstrate
displeasure
exact
penalty
offender
laws
seems
nothing
solved
uncritical
reference
service
armed
forces
ultimate
duty
american
citizenship
indeed
difficult
imagine
theory
power
congress
impose
expatriation
punishment
crime
tax
evasion
bank
robbery
narcotics
offenses
citizens
also
called
upon
pay
taxes
obey
laws
duties
appear
fully
related
nature
citizenship
military
obligations
congress
asserted
power
expatriate
deserter
bears
war
powers
precisely
relation
power
expatriate
tax
evader
bear
taxing
power
therefore
must
conclude
beyond
power
congress
enact
admittedly
congress
belief
expatriation
deserter
might
war
effort
may
find
though
necessarily
slender
support
reason
substantial
achievement
device
congress
legitimate
purposes
war
power
seems
fairly
remote
time
abundantly
clear
ends
fully
achieved
alternative
methods
open
objections
light
factors
conceding
possibly
favor
enactment
conclude
requisite
rational
relation
statute
war
power
appear
relation
statute
really
calculated
effect
objects
entrusted
government
maryland
wheat
therefore
falls
beyond
domain
congress
indication
problem
seen
joint
resolutions
introduced
houses
congress
exempt
two
three
thousand
americans
allegedly
lost
citizenship
voting
certain
italian
elections
see
res
res
sess
proposed
suspend
operation
section
nationality
act
certain
cases
see
also
sess
perez
brownell
raise
questions
first
amendment
course
effect
appropriate
cases
limiting
congressional
power
otherwise
possessed
good
description
extent
problem
raised
desertions
union
armies
extreme
measures
taken
combat
problem
found
pullen
twentieth
maine
volunteer
regiment
civil
war
opinion
huber
reily
written
justice
strong
later
member
suggested
hold
statutes
considerations
due
process
required
expatriation
accomplished
specifically
included
part
sentence
see
military
law
adjudges
guilt
extent
initial
sentence
jackson
taylor
see
article
war
stat
however
practice
specifically
include
expatriation
part
sentence
winthrop
military
law
precedents
ed
provision
limited
desertion
time
war
stat
otherwise
revised
carried
nationality
act
stat
however
first
codified
part
laws
concerning
citizenship
revised
statutes
reason
addition
proviso
stated
report
codification
nationality
laws
comm
print
pt
prepared
request
president
secretary
state
attorney
general
secretary
labor
proposing
revision
codification
nationality
laws
provisions
sections
revised
statutes
distinctly
penal
character
must
therefore
construed
strictly
penalties
take
effect
upon
conviction
martial
huber
reilly
penn
kurtz
moffitt
reference
later
report
technically
penal
law
section
whole
subdivision
adjudication
hypothetical
contingent
consequences
beyond
function
incidents
expatriation
altogether
indefinite
nonetheless
uncertainty
consequences
makes
expatriation
punishment
severe
also
unnecessary
consider
whether
consequences
different
citizen
expatriated
another
section
deterrent
effect
certainly
conjectural
told
world
war
ii
many
soldiers
convicted
desertion
sentenced
dishonorably
discharged
fact
reviewing
authorities
ultimately
remitted
dishonorable
discharges
cases
possible
infer
military
firm
belief
deterrent
effects
expatriation
justice
frankfurter
justice
burton
justice
clark
justice
harlan
join
dissenting
petitioner
born
ohio
army
serving
french
morocco
tried
general
found
guilty
twice
escaped
confinement
absent
without
leave
deserted
remained
desertion
one
day
sentenced
dishonorable
discharge
forfeiture
pay
allowances
confinement
hard
labor
three
years
subsequently
returned
applied
passport
application
denied
state
department
ground
petitioner
lost
citizenship
result
conviction
dishonorable
discharge
desertion
army
time
war
department
relied
upon
nationality
act
stat
amended
act
january
stat
provided
pertinent
part
person
national
whether
birth
naturalization
shall
lose
nationality
deserting
military
naval
forces
time
war
provided
convicted
thereof
martial
result
conviction
dismissed
dishonorably
discharged
service
military
naval
forces
provided
notwithstanding
loss
nationality
citizenship
civil
political
rights
terms
previous
acts
reason
desertion
committed
time
war
restoration
active
duty
military
naval
forces
time
war
reenlistment
induction
person
time
war
permission
competent
military
naval
authority
prior
subsequent
effective
date
act
shall
deemed
immediate
effect
restoring
nationality
citizenship
civil
political
rights
heretofore
hereafter
lost
removing
civil
political
disabilities
resulting
therefrom
threshold
petitioner
suggests
constructions
statute
avoid
consideration
constitutional
issues
construction
precluded
petitioner
contends
congress
without
power
attach
loss
citizenship
consequence
conviction
desertion
also
argues
exercise
power
violate
due
process
clause
fifth
amendment
constitution
prohibition
cruel
unusual
punishments
eighth
amendment
subsection
nationality
act
amended
making
loss
nationality
result
conviction
desertion
wartime
direct
descendant
provision
enacted
civil
war
one
section
act
amend
several
acts
heretofore
passed
provide
enrolling
calling
national
forces
purposes
stat
approved
march
provided
addition
lawful
penalties
crime
desertion
military
naval
service
persons
desert
service
shall
deemed
taken
voluntarily
relinquished
forfeited
rights
citizenship
rights
become
citizens
except
limited
desertion
time
war
stat
provision
remained
effect
absorbed
nationality
act
stat
shortly
enactment
provision
received
important
interpretation
huber
reily
pennsylvania
opinion
justice
strong
later
held
disabilities
act
attach
individual
convicted
desertion
requirement
drawn
due
process
clause
fifth
amendment
constitution
interpretation
followed
courts
state
symonds
referred
approvingly
kurtz
moffitt
without
discussion
rationale
nationality
laws
revised
codified
nationality
act
stat
added
list
acts
result
loss
american
nationality
deserting
military
naval
service
time
war
provided
deserter
convicted
thereof
martial
stat
consideration
act
substantially
debate
provision
seems
clear
however
report
cabinet
committee
recommended
adoption
nothing
intended
enactment
incorporate
provision
codification
time
making
clear
nationality
ambiguous
rights
citizenship
lost
provision
applied
nationals
codification
nationality
laws
comm
print
pt
sess
request
war
department
congress
amended
act
form
applied
petitioner
amendment
required
dismissal
dishonorable
discharge
result
conviction
desertion
expatriation
follow
provided
restoration
deserter
active
duty
wartime
effect
restoring
citizenship
stat
abundantly
clear
debate
reports
sole
purpose
change
permit
persons
convicted
desertion
regain
citizenship
continue
serving
armed
forces
sess
sess
cong
rec
thought
unreasonable
require
persons
still
service
fight
perhaps
die
country
longer
citizens
requirement
dismissal
dishonorable
discharge
prior
denationalization
included
amendment
see
supra
cong
rec
petitioner
advances
two
possible
constructions
exclude
operation
avoid
constitutional
determinations
suggested
provision
applies
desertion
enemy
sentence
dishonorable
discharge
without
imposition
conviction
desertion
expatriating
effect
must
resulted
conviction
solely
desertion
support
first
constructions
fair
reading
congressional
history
rigorously
admonished
avoid
consideration
constitutional
issues
statutory
disposition
available
violence
statute
compellingly
conveys
draw
meaning
spontaneously
reveals
section
imposes
expatriation
individual
desertion
provided
convicted
thereof
martial
result
conviction
dismissed
dishonorably
discharged
service
military
naval
forces
petitioner
argument
dishonorable
discharge
must
solely
result
conviction
therefore
applicable
convicted
escape
confinement
absence
without
leave
addition
desertion
since
invariable
practice
military
trials
related
offenses
tried
together
single
sentence
cover
convictions
see
jackson
taylor
effect
suggested
construction
force
break
historic
process
military
law
congress
remotest
way
given
warrant
obvious
purpose
amendment
requiring
dishonorable
discharge
condition
precedent
expatriation
correct
situation
individual
convicted
desertion
thus
lost
citizenship
kept
duty
fight
sometimes
die
country
disowns
letter
secretary
war
chairman
senate
military
affairs
committee
sess
hint
congressional
history
requirement
discharge
intended
make
expatriation
depend
seriousness
desertion
measured
sentence
imposed
give
effect
purpose
congress
making
conviction
wartime
desertion
result
loss
citizenship
must
hold
dishonorable
discharge
order
expatriation
follow
need
result
conviction
one
offenses
among
one
must
wartime
desertion
since
none
petitioner
nonconstitutional
grounds
reversal
sustained
claim
unconstitutionality
must
faced
always
basic
power
congress
enact
legislation
challenged
appropriate
approach
judicial
review
congressional
legislation
power
madison
phrase
encroaching
nature
federalist
earle
ed
judicial
power
immune
human
weakness
also
must
guard
encroaching
beyond
proper
bounds
less
since
restraint
upon
power
congress
pass
statute
challenged
function
determine
whether
legislative
action
lies
clearly
outside
constitutional
grant
power
may
fairly
referred
making
determination
sits
judgment
action
branch
government
keeping
unto
must
constitutional
system
final
determination
power
act
wonder
function
deemed
gravest
delicate
duty
called
perform
holmes
blodgett
holden
separate
opinion
platitude
rigorous
observance
difference
limits
power
wise
exercise
power
questions
authority
questions
prudence
requires
alert
appreciation
decisive
subtle
relationship
two
concepts
easily
coalesce
less
require
disciplined
adhere
difference
easy
stand
aloof
allow
want
wisdom
prevail
disregard
one
strongly
held
view
wise
conduct
affairs
business
pronounce
policy
must
observe
fastidious
regard
limitations
power
precludes
giving
effect
notions
wise
politic
essence
observance
judicial
oath
constitution
authorized
judges
sit
judgment
wisdom
congress
executive
branch
one
principal
purposes
establishing
constitution
provide
common
defence
end
granted
congress
several
powers
article
section
clauses
compendiously
described
war
power
although
specific
grants
power
specifically
enumerate
every
factor
relevant
power
conduct
war
limitation
upon
due
process
clause
commands
scope
war
power
defined
chief
justice
hughes
home
bldg
loan
assn
blaisdell
war
power
federal
government
created
emergency
war
power
given
meet
emergency
power
wage
war
successfully
thus
permits
harnessing
entire
energies
people
cooperative
effort
preserve
nation
see
also
chief
justice
stone
opinion
hirabayashi
probably
important
governmental
action
contemplated
war
power
building
maintenance
armed
force
common
defense
congress
may
convinced
necessity
conscription
effective
conduct
war
selective
draft
law
cases
congress
may
justifiably
view
stern
measures
may
seem
overly
stern
needed
order
control
may
evasions
military
duty
armed
forces
committed
nation
defense
deleterious
effects
evasions
may
kept
minimum
clearly
congress
may
deal
severely
problem
desertion
armed
forces
wartime
equally
clear
face
legislation
circumstances
passed
congress
calling
upon
war
powers
made
desertion
act
expatriation
cf
winthrop
military
law
precedents
reprint
possession
american
citizen
rights
privileges
constitute
citizenship
imposes
correlative
obligations
indispensable
may
well
take
place
ranks
army
country
risk
chance
shot
defense
jacobson
massachusetts
harsh
may
sound
actualities
responds
said
rational
nexus
refusal
perform
ultimate
duty
american
citizenship
legislative
withdrawal
citizenship
congress
may
well
thought
making
loss
citizenship
consequence
wartime
desertion
affect
ability
military
authorities
control
forces
expected
fight
win
major
world
conflict
us
deny
congress
might
reasonably
believed
morale
fighting
efficiency
troops
impaired
soldiers
knew
fellows
abandoned
time
greatest
need
remain
communion
citizens
petitioner
urges
imposing
loss
citizenship
punishment
wartime
desertion
violation
due
process
clause
fifth
amendment
eighth
amendment
objections
notice
expatriation
consequence
desertion
provision
defining
offense
loss
citizenship
punishment
unconstitutionally
disproportionate
offense
desertion
loss
citizenship
constitutes
cruel
unusual
punishment
provision
articles
war
petitioner
convicted
desertion
art
articles
war
stat
mention
fact
one
convicted
offense
wartime
suffer
loss
citizenship
may
stating
consequences
conduct
statutory
provision
making
offense
desideratum
administration
criminal
justice
scarcely
said
petitioner
contend
ever
said
constitutional
requirement
us
require
congress
list
one
statutory
section
ordinary
penal
consequences
engaging
activities
therein
prohibited
also
collateral
disabilities
follow
operation
law
conviction
thereof
duly
resulting
proceeding
conducted
accordance
relevant
constitutional
safeguards
course
individual
apprised
consequences
actions
articles
war
put
petitioner
notice
desertion
offense
committed
wartime
punishable
death
art
supra
expatriation
automatically
followed
command
nationality
act
duly
promulgated
act
congress
war
department
appears
made
every
effort
inform
individual
soldiers
gravity
consequences
desertion
circular
pointed
convictions
desertion
punishable
death
result
forfeiture
rights
citizenship
instructed
unit
commanders
explain
carefully
personnel
commands
certain
articles
war
including
art
emphasize
serious
consequences
may
result
violation
compilation
war
department
general
orders
bulletins
circulars
government
printing
office
congress
must
define
rubric
substantive
crime
consequences
conduct
made
grave
offense
provide
collateral
consequence
stern
may
explicit
pronouncement
another
place
statute
books
claim
hardly
rises
dignity
constitutional
requirement
petitioner
contends
loss
citizenship
unconstitutionally
disproportionate
punishment
desertion
constitutes
cruel
unusual
punishment
within
scope
eighth
amendment
loss
citizenship
entails
undoubtedly
severe
particular
situations
even
tragic
consequences
divestment
citizenship
government
characterized
context
denaturalization
serious
taking
one
property
imposition
fine
penalty
schneiderman
however
like
denaturalization
see
klapprott
expatriation
nationality
act
punishment
valid
constitutional
sense
cf
fong
yue
ting
simply
denationalization
attached
congress
consequence
conduct
elsewhere
made
unlawful
follow
denationalization
punishment
said
loss
civil
rights
result
conviction
felony
see
gathings
loss
citizenship
civil
rights
conviction
crime
pol
sci
rev
punishment
legally
significant
purposes
process
denationalization
devised
expert
cabinet
committee
congress
quite
properly
responsibly
relied
established
congress
legislation
related
authority
congress
pursuant
constitutional
powers
regulate
conduct
free
restrictions
pertain
legislation
field
technically
described
criminal
justice
since
legislative
ends
within
scope
congress
war
power
wholly
consistent
purpose
regulate
military
forces
since
nothing
face
legislation
history
indicate
congress
contrary
purpose
warrant
labeling
disability
imposed
punishment
even
assuming
arguendo
said
impose
punishment
insist
denationalization
cruel
unusual
punishment
stretch
concept
beyond
breaking
point
seems
scarcely
arguable
loss
citizenship
within
eighth
amendment
prohibition
disproportionate
offense
capital
first
year
independence
art
supra
art
articles
war
cont
cong
ford
ed
constitutional
dialectic
empty
reason
seriously
urged
loss
citizenship
fate
worse
death
seriousness
abandoning
one
country
grip
mortal
conflict
precludes
denial
congress
power
terminate
citizenship
unless
power
denied
congress
circumstance
many
civilized
nations
impose
loss
citizenship
indulgence
designated
prohibited
activities
see
generally
laws
concerning
nationality
doc
although
provisions
often
always
applicable
naturalized
citizens
nearly
comparable
expatriation
law
denaturalization
law
countries
made
wartime
desertion
result
loss
citizenship
naturalized
philippine
commonwealth
act
amended
republic
act
june
supra
see
borchard
diplomatic
protection
citizens
abroad
country
desertion
punishable
loss
least
rights
citizenship
since
today
reaffirms
decisions
mackenzie
hare
savorgnan
sustaining
power
congress
denationalize
citizens
desire
intention
give
citizenship
loss
citizenship
may
constitutionally
made
consequence
conduct
marrying
foreigner
thus
certainly
cruel
unusual
seems
incongruous
loss
thought
cruel
unusual
consequence
conduct
also
crime
short
denationalization
attached
offense
wartime
desertion
justifiably
deemed
variance
enlightened
concepts
humane
justice
see
weems
beyond
power
congress
constituting
cruel
unusual
punishment
within
meaning
eighth
amendment
congress
fallen
afoul
prohibition
person
status
elements
unpredictability
presumably
denationalized
person
becomes
alien
substantial
rights
privileges
alien
country
enjoys
federal
state
constitutions
puts
different
condition
outlaw
england
need
constant
fear
lest
dire
unforeseen
fate
imposed
arbitrary
governmental
action
certainly
sits
holmes
dissenting
panhandle
oil
mississippi
ex
rel
knox
multitudinous
decisions
protective
rights
aliens
bear
weighty
testimony
assumption
brutal
treatment
inevitable
lot
denationalized
persons
found
countries
slender
basis
strike
act
congress
otherwise
amply
sustainable
misguides
popular
understanding
judicial
function
limited
power
democracy
suggest
invalidating
act
congress
endanger
necessary
subordination
military
civil
authority
case
doubt
derives
consequence
sitting
judgment
military
congress
military
merely
carried
responsibility
charged
congress
armed
forces
ceased
discharging
wartime
deserters
congress
attached
consequence
performance
responsibility
legislation
result
exercise
congress
legislative
power
vested
constitution
exercise
president
constitutional
power
approving
bill
thereby
making
law
sustain
respect
actions
two
branches
government
directly
responsive
people
empowered
constitution
determine
wisdom
legislation
awesome
power
invalidate
legislation
practice
bounded
prudence
discerning
limits
constitutional
function
must
exercised
utmost
restraint
justice
holmes
one
profoundest
thinkers
ever
sat
expressed
conviction
think
come
end
lost
power
declare
act
congress
void
think
union
imperiled
make
declaration
laws
several
holmes
speeches
course
deny
power
existed
strike
congressional
legislation
shrink
exercise
whole
work
thirty
years
service
constant
reminder
power
invalidate
legislation
must
exercised
either
constitutional
theory
art
government
stood
sole
bulwark
unwisdom
excesses
moment
substance
provision
appears
immigration
nationality
act
stat
precise
meaning
phrase
never
clear
see
roche
loss
american
nationality
development
statutory
expatriation
rev
appears
however
state
department
regarded
mean
loss
citizenship
see
hearings
house
committee
immigration
naturalization
sess
noted
person
deprived
citizenship
merely
basis
administrative
finding
deserted
wartime
even
finality
sole
basis
dishonorably
discharged
result
conviction
wartime
desertion
section
nationality
act
provides
person
claims
right
privilege
national
denied
right
privilege
department
agency
executive
official
thereof
upon
ground
national
person
regardless
whether
within
abroad
may
institute
action
head
department
agency
district
district
columbia
district
district
person
claims
permanent
residence
judgment
declaring
national
stat
immigration
nationality
act
stat
proceeding
open
person
like
petitioner
alleged
expatriated
act
show
example
without
jurisdiction
including
observance
requirements
due
process
individual
restoration
active
duty
conviction
discharge
regained
citizenship
terms
proviso
supra
report
committee
stated
provision
question
technically
penal
law
codification
nationality
laws
supra
letter
president
covering
report
committee
stated
none
loss
nationality
provisions
designed
punitive
vii
basis
finding
congress
enacted
provision
regarded
otherwise
part
clearly
nonpenal
scheme
acts
expatriation
represented
nationality
act
supra
denaturalization
based
exclusively
theory
individual
obtained
citizenship
fraud
see
luria
laws
many
countries
making
naturalized
citizens
subject
expatriation
grounds
applicable
citizens
relate
grounds
actual
naturalization
process
british
nationality
act
geo
vi
see
note
supra