dept
air
force
rose
argued
october
decided
april
air
force
academy
honor
code
administered
cadet
committee
cadets
pledge
lie
steal
cheat
tolerate
among
number
anyone
cadet
investigatory
team
finds
hearing
honor
board
concerning
suspected
violation
warranted
accused
may
call
witnesses
cadet
observers
attend
board
consisting
eight
members
may
adjudge
guilt
unanimous
vote
may
least
six
members
concur
grant
guilty
cadet
discretion
returns
squadron
good
standing
cadet
found
guilty
without
discretion
may
resign
request
hearing
board
officers
trial
honor
board
hearing
confidential
committee
prepares
summary
posted
squadron
bulletin
boards
distributed
among
academy
faculty
officials
discretion
cases
names
deleted
guilty
cases
names
deleted
posting
deferred
cadet
left
academy
ethics
code
violations
less
serious
breaches
handled
informally
though
similarly
confidential
basis
respondents
present
former
student
law
review
editors
researching
article
denied
access
case
summaries
honors
ethics
hearings
identifying
data
deleted
brought
suit
compel
disclosure
freedom
information
act
foia
department
air
force
certain
academy
officers
hereinafter
collectively
agency
district
without
camera
inspection
granted
agency
motion
summary
judgment
ground
summaries
matters
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
thus
exempted
mandatory
disclosure
exemption
foia
appeals
reversed
holding
exemption
inapplicable
agency
made
contention
district
rejected
case
summaries
fell
within
exemption
constituting
personnel
medical
files
similar
files
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
appeals
disagreeing
district
approach
hold
agency
without
prior
inspection
turn
summaries
respondents
proper
names
removed
exemption
covered
part
summaries
held
agency
maintained
statutory
burden
district
sustaining
action
means
affidavits
testimony
inquiry
required
agency
produce
summaries
camera
inspection
cooperating
district
redacting
records
delete
personal
references
identifying
information
held
limited
statutory
exemptions
obscure
basic
policy
disclosure
secrecy
dominant
legislative
objective
foia
pp
exemption
generally
apply
matters
summaries
involved
genuine
important
public
interest
pp
phrasing
exemption
reflected
congressional
dissatisfaction
internal
management
exemption
former
administrative
procedure
act
generally
designed
senate
report
made
clear
delineate
one
hand
trivial
matters
substantial
matters
public
might
legitimate
interest
pp
public
substantial
concern
academy
administration
discipline
procedures
affect
training
air
force
officers
military
careers
pp
exemption
create
blanket
exemption
personnel
files
respect
files
similar
files
congress
enunciated
policy
judicially
enforced
involving
balancing
public
private
interests
regardless
whether
documents
whose
disclosure
sought
personnel
similar
files
nondisclosure
sanctioned
unless
showing
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
redaction
documents
permit
disclosure
nonexempt
portions
appropriate
exemption
pp
even
personnel
files
considered
wholly
exempt
disclosure
exemption
without
regard
whether
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
case
summaries
category
although
constituted
similar
files
relating
discipline
cadets
disclosure
implicating
similar
privacy
values
pp
appeals
err
ordering
agency
produce
case
summaries
district
camera
examination
procedure
represents
workable
compromise
individual
rights
preservation
public
rights
overnment
information
statutory
goal
exemption
pp
limitation
exemption
cases
clearly
unwarranted
invasions
privacy
indicates
congress
intend
matter
exempted
disclosure
merely
guaranteed
disclosure
trigger
recollection
identity
person
whatever
congress
vested
courts
responsibility
determining
de
novo
whether
exemption
properly
invoked
pp
respondents
request
access
summaries
personal
references
identifying
information
deleted
respected
confidentiality
interests
embodied
exemption
comported
academy
tradition
confidentiality
pp
brennan
delivered
opinion
stewart
white
marshall
powell
joined
burger
post
blackmun
post
rehnquist
post
filed
dissenting
opinions
stevens
took
part
consideration
decision
case
deputy
solicitor
general
friedman
argued
cause
petitioners
briefs
solicitor
general
bork
assistant
attorney
general
lee
acting
assistant
attorney
general
jaffe
allan
abbot
tuttle
leonard
schaitman
donald
etra
barrington
parker
argued
cause
respondents
brief
melvin
wulf
john
shattuck
justice
brennan
delivered
opinion
respondents
student
editors
former
student
editors
new
york
university
law
review
researching
disciplinary
systems
procedures
military
service
academies
article
law
review
denied
access
petitioners
case
summaries
honor
ethics
hearings
personal
references
identifying
information
deleted
maintained
air
force
academy
honor
ethics
code
reading
files
although
academy
practice
post
copies
summaries
squadron
bulletin
boards
throughout
academy
distribute
copies
academy
faculty
administration
officials
thereupon
respondents
brought
action
freedom
information
act
amended
ed
supp
district
southern
district
new
york
petitioners
department
air
force
air
force
officers
supervise
cadets
air
force
academy
hereinafter
collectively
agency
district
granted
petitioner
agency
motion
summary
judgment
without
first
requiring
production
case
summaries
inspection
holding
unreported
opinion
case
summaries
even
deletions
personal
references
identifying
information
matters
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
exempted
mandatory
disclosure
statute
appeals
second
circuit
reversed
holding
exempt
case
summaries
mandatory
disclosure
agency
argued
alternatively
however
case
summaries
constituted
personnel
medical
files
similar
files
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
exempted
mandatory
disclosure
district
held
exemption
inapplicable
case
summaries
concluded
disclosure
summaries
without
names
identifying
information
subject
former
cadet
public
identification
stigma
possibility
identification
another
former
cadet
context
academy
practice
distribution
official
posting
summaries
constitute
invasion
personal
privacy
proscribed
pet
cert
appeals
disagreed
approach
stating
ignores
certain
practical
realities
militated
conclusion
agency
internal
dissemination
summaries
lessens
concerned
cadets
right
privacy
embodied
exemption
six
refused
hold
one
hand
either
agency
must
without
prior
inspection
turn
summaries
respondents
proper
names
removed
hand
exemption
six
covers
part
summaries
issue
rather
appeals
held
agency
carried
burden
district
imposed
act
sustain
ing
action
means
affidavits
testimony
inquiry
required
agency
must
produce
summaries
camera
inspection
cooperate
judge
redacting
records
delete
personal
references
identifying
information
think
highly
likely
combined
skills
agency
applied
summaries
yield
edited
documents
sufficient
purpose
sought
sufficient
well
safeguard
affected
persons
legitimate
claims
privacy
ibid
footnotes
omitted
district
made
factual
findings
respecting
administration
honor
ethics
codes
academy
see
pet
cert
nn
honor
code
enrolled
cadets
pledge
lie
steal
cheat
tolerate
among
us
anyone
honor
code
administered
honor
committee
composed
academy
cadets
suspected
violations
code
referred
chairman
honor
committee
appoints
investigatory
team
advice
legal
adviser
evaluates
facts
determines
whether
hearing
honor
board
eight
cadets
warranted
team
finds
hearing
warranted
case
closed
finds
hearing
accused
cadet
may
call
witnesses
testify
behalf
cadet
squadron
may
ordinarily
send
two
cadets
observe
board
may
return
guilty
finding
upon
unanimous
vote
verdict
guilty
certain
circumstances
board
may
grant
guilty
cadet
discretion
vote
six
eight
members
required
verdict
guilty
discretion
equivalent
finding
cadet
returned
cadet
squadron
good
standing
verdict
guilty
without
discretion
results
one
three
alternative
dispositions
cadet
may
resign
academy
request
hearing
board
officers
request
trial
announcement
verdict
honor
committee
chairman
reminds
cadets
present
hearing
matters
discussed
hearing
confidential
discussed
outside
room
anyone
honor
representative
case
summary
consisting
brief
statement
usually
one
page
significant
facts
prepared
committee
said
copies
summaries
posted
squadron
bulletin
boards
throughout
academy
distributed
among
academy
faculty
administration
officials
cadets
instructed
read
summaries
unless
need
beyond
mere
curiosity
know
contents
reading
files
covered
notice
official
use
case
summaries
discretion
cases
circulated
names
deleted
guilty
cases
guilty
cadet
name
deleted
summary
posting
bulletin
boards
deferred
guilty
cadet
left
academy
ethics
code
violations
breaches
conduct
less
serious
honor
code
violations
administration
ethics
code
cases
generally
less
structured
though
similar
many
instances
ethics
cases
handled
informally
cadet
squadron
commander
squadron
ethics
representative
individual
concerned
cases
necessarily
written
complete
file
maintained
case
written
summary
placed
back
honor
code
reading
files
determined
value
cadet
population
distribution
ethics
code
summaries
substantially
honor
code
summaries
confidentiality
maintained
academy
custom
practice
ii
discussion
may
conveniently
begin
emphasizing
basic
thrust
freedom
information
act
ed
supp
canvassed
subject
length
three
years
ago
epa
mink
need
briefly
review
history
act
revises
public
disclosure
section
administrative
procedure
act
revision
deemed
necessary
section
generally
recognized
falling
far
short
disclosure
goals
came
looked
upon
withholding
statute
disclosure
statute
mink
supra
congress
therefore
structured
revision
whose
basic
purpose
reflected
general
philosophy
full
agency
disclosure
unless
information
exempted
clearly
delineated
statutory
language
hereinafter
make
crystal
clear
congressional
objective
words
appeals
pierce
veil
administrative
secrecy
open
agency
action
light
public
scrutiny
congress
provided
nothing
act
read
authorize
withholding
information
limit
availability
records
public
except
specifically
stated
consistently
objective
act
repeatedly
official
information
shall
made
available
public
public
inspection
mink
supra
however
exemptions
compelled
disclosure
nine
number
set
forth
limited
exemptions
obscure
basic
policy
disclosure
secrecy
dominant
objective
act
exemptions
explicitly
made
exclusive
mink
supra
must
narrowly
construed
vaughn
rosen
app
app
soucie
david
app
sum
said
mink
supra
without
question
act
broadly
conceived
seeks
permit
access
official
information
long
shielded
unnecessarily
public
view
attempts
create
judicially
enforceable
public
right
secure
information
possibly
unwilling
official
hands
subsection
part
scheme
represents
congressional
determination
types
information
executive
branch
must
option
keep
confidential
chooses
senate
committee
explained
easy
task
balance
opposing
interests
impossible
one
either
success
lies
providing
workable
formula
encompasses
balances
protects
interests
yet
places
emphasis
fullest
responsible
disclosure
iii
phrasing
exemption
traceable
congressional
dissatisfaction
exemption
disclosure
former
administrative
procedure
act
matter
relating
solely
internal
management
agency
sweep
wording
led
withholding
agencies
disclosure
matter
rang
ing
important
insignificant
hereinafter
earlier
effort
minimizing
sweep
introduced
congress
applied
internal
management
exemption
matters
required
published
federal
register
agency
orders
records
exempted
public
disclosure
information
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
distinction
highlighted
senate
report
reference
latter
tightly
drawn
exempting
language
final
action
taken
congress
senate
passed
bill
reached
house
late
action
renegotiation
board
bannercraft
clothing
bill
introduced
senate
became
law
dropped
internal
management
exemption
matters
required
published
federal
register
consolidated
exemptions
single
subsection
thus
legislative
history
plainly
evidences
congressional
conclusion
wording
exemption
internal
personnel
rules
practices
narrower
reach
administrative
procedure
act
exemption
internal
management
matters
end
inquiry
house
senate
reports
bill
finally
enacted
differ
upon
scope
narrowed
exemption
senate
report
stated
exemption
relates
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
examples
may
rules
personnel
use
parking
facilities
regulations
lunch
hours
statements
policy
sick
leave
like
matters
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
operating
rules
guidelines
manuals
procedure
government
investigators
examiners
exempt
disclosure
exemption
cover
matters
internal
management
employee
relations
working
conditions
routine
administrative
procedures
withheld
present
law
might
appear
nonetheless
house
report
reference
perating
rules
guidelines
manuals
procedure
supports
much
broader
interpretation
exemption
senate
report
circumscribed
examples
argument
recently
considered
rejected
judge
wilkey
speaking
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
vaughn
rosen
app
congress
intended
exemption
interpreted
narrowly
specifically
view
house
report
carries
potential
exempting
wide
swath
information
category
operating
rules
guidelines
manuals
procedure
house
report
exemption
cover
matters
internal
management
employee
relations
working
conditions
routine
administrative
procedures
yet
gives
precious
little
guidance
matters
covered
exemption
although
equally
terse
senate
report
indicates
line
sought
drawn
one
minor
trivial
matters
substantial
matters
might
subject
legitimate
public
interest
standard
guide
agency
need
apply
certainty
consistency
clarity
reinforcing
interpretation
clear
legislative
intent
foia
assure
public
access
governmental
records
whose
disclosure
significantly
harm
specific
governmental
interests
soucie
david
app
result
repeatedly
stated
policy
act
requires
disclosure
requirements
construed
broadly
exemptions
narrowly
ibid
vaughn
rosen
app
thus
faced
conflict
legislative
history
recognized
principal
purpose
foia
requires
us
choose
interpretation
favoring
disclosure
second
major
consideration
favoring
reliance
upon
senate
report
fact
committee
report
houses
congress
house
unanimously
passed
senate
bill
without
amendment
therefore
conference
committee
necessary
reconcile
conflicting
provisions
viewing
legislative
history
must
wary
relying
upon
house
report
even
statements
house
sponsors
views
differ
expressed
senate
professor
davis
said
basic
principle
quite
elementary
content
law
must
depend
upon
intent
houses
one
see
generally
davis
administrative
law
treatise
unanimously
passing
senate
bill
without
amendment
house
denied
senate
committee
entire
senate
opportunity
object
concur
interpretation
written
house
report
voiced
floor
colloquy
case
choose
rely
upon
senate
report
district
also
concluded
case
senate
report
surer
indication
congressional
intent
pet
cert
appeals
found
unnecessary
take
firm
stand
issue
concluding
difference
approach
house
senate
reports
affect
result
different
conclusions
two
courts
applying
senate
report
interpretation
centered
upon
disagreement
materiality
public
significance
operation
honor
ethics
codes
district
based
conclusion
determination
honor
ethics
codes
definition
meant
control
people
agency
operation
honor
code
possibly
affect
anyone
outside
sphere
voluntary
participation
limited
function
publication
academy
pet
cert
appeals
hand
concluded
senate
construction
exemption
two
case
summaries
clearly
fall
outside
ambit
uch
summaries
substantial
potential
public
interest
outside
government
agree
approach
conclusion
appeals
implication
general
public
academy
administration
discipline
obvious
particularly
light
unique
role
military
said
military
contexts
equal
application
constitutes
specialized
community
governed
separate
discipline
civilian
orloff
willoughby
internal
law
command
obedience
invests
military
officer
particular
position
responsibility
parker
levy
within
discipline
accuracy
effect
superior
command
depends
critically
upon
specific
customary
reliability
subordinates
instinctive
obedience
subordinates
depends
upon
unquestioned
specific
customary
reliability
superior
importance
considerations
maintenance
force
able
ready
fight
effectively
renders
undeniably
significant
public
role
military
moreover
essential
integrity
critical
military
relationship
civilian
direction
since
purpose
honor
ethics
codes
administered
enforced
air
force
academy
ingrain
ethical
reflexes
basic
responsibilities
future
air
force
officers
select
candidates
apparently
unlikely
serve
standards
follows
nature
instruction
adequacy
inadequacy
significantly
related
substantive
public
role
air
force
academy
indeed
public
stake
operation
codes
affect
training
future
air
force
officers
military
careers
underscored
agency
proclamations
importance
codes
academy
educational
training
program
thus
appeals
said
agree
respondents
drawn
attention
various
items
newspaper
excerpts
press
conference
academy
officer
white
house
press
release
illustrate
extent
general
concern
working
cadet
honor
code
press
conference
press
release
show
interest
generated
least
enhanced
acts
government
course
even
without
official
encouragement
interest
treatment
cadets
whose
education
publicly
financed
furnish
good
portion
country
future
military
leadership
indeed
sectors
society
including
cadets
stake
fairness
system
leads
many
instances
forced
resignation
cadets
study
involved
case
bears
additional
witness
degree
professional
academic
interest
academy
system
discipline
factor
differentiate
summaries
matters
daily
routine
like
working
hours
words
exemption
two
relate
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
emphasis
appeals
opinion
iv
additional
questions
involved
determination
whether
exemption
exempts
case
summaries
mandatory
disclosure
personnel
medical
files
similar
files
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
first
question
whether
clause
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
modifies
personnel
medical
files
similar
files
agency
argues
exemption
distinguishes
personnel
similar
files
exempting
personnel
files
similar
files
whose
disclosure
constitutes
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
case
summaries
sought
personnel
files
reading
determined
case
summaries
personnel
files
agency
argues
judicial
inquiry
end
appeals
therefore
erred
remanding
determination
whether
disclosure
redaction
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
agency
argue
suggested
distinction
personnel
similar
files
either
district
appeals
opinions
courts
treat
exemption
making
distinction
personnel
similar
files
application
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
requirement
district
held
identifying
connection
individual
casts
personnel
medical
similar
files
within
protection
sixth
exemption
pet
cert
appeals
stated
dealing
personnel
similar
files
key
words
course
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
agree
views
find
nothing
wording
exemption
legislative
history
support
agency
claim
congress
created
blanket
exemption
personnel
files
judicial
interpretation
uniformly
reflected
view
reason
exist
nondisclosure
absence
showing
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
privacy
whether
documents
filed
personnel
similar
files
see
wine
hobby
usa
irs
rural
housing
alliance
dept
agriculture
app
vaughn
rosen
app
getman
nlrb
app
congressional
concern
protection
kind
confidential
personal
data
usually
included
personnel
file
abundantly
clear
congress
also
made
clear
nonconfidential
matter
insulated
disclosure
merely
stored
agency
personnel
files
rather
congress
sought
construct
exemption
require
balancing
individual
right
privacy
preservation
basic
purpose
freedom
information
act
open
agency
action
light
public
scrutiny
device
adopted
achieve
balance
limited
exemption
privacy
threatened
clearly
unwarranted
invasions
personal
privacy
house
senate
reports
read
disclosing
congressional
purpose
eschew
blanket
exemption
personnel
similar
files
require
balancing
interests
either
case
thus
house
report
limitation
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
provides
proper
balance
protection
individual
right
privacy
preservation
public
right
government
information
excluding
kinds
files
disclosure
might
harm
individual
similarly
senate
report
phrase
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
enunciates
policy
involve
balancing
interests
protection
individual
private
affairs
unnecessary
public
scrutiny
preservation
public
right
governmental
information
plainly
congress
strike
balance
personnel
files
confine
courts
striking
balance
similar
files
contrary
congress
enunciated
single
policy
enforced
cases
courts
involve
balancing
private
public
interests
conclusion
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
medical
files
conclusion
equally
applicable
personnel
files
exemption
act
covers
medical
files
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
purely
medical
file
withheld
authority
exemption
district
ultimately
determine
dispute
whether
exemption
properly
invoked
ackerly
ley
app
ellipses
original
congress
recent
action
amending
freedom
information
act
make
explicit
agreement
judicial
decisions
requiring
disclosure
nonexempt
portions
otherwise
exempt
files
consistent
conclusion
thus
supp
provides
ny
reasonably
segregable
portion
record
shall
provided
person
requesting
record
deletion
portions
exempt
subsection
supp
added
explicitly
authorize
camera
inspection
matter
claimed
exempt
determine
whether
records
part
thereof
shall
withheld
emphasis
supplied
senate
report
accompanying
legislation
explains
without
distinguishing
personnel
medical
files
similar
files
effect
require
courts
look
beneath
label
file
record
withholding
information
challenged
files
involved
courts
examine
records
require
disclosure
portions
purposes
exemption
withheld
apply
example
deletion
names
identifying
characteristics
individuals
cases
serve
underlying
purpose
exemption
exempts
personnel
medical
files
similar
files
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
privacy
cong
rec
moreover
even
agree
personnel
files
wholly
exempt
disclosure
exemption
clear
case
summaries
sought
lack
attributes
personnel
files
commonly
understood
two
attributes
case
summaries
require
characterized
similar
files
first
relate
discipline
cadet
personnel
even
air
force
regulations
show
single
factor
insufficient
characterize
summaries
personnel
files
supports
conclusion
similar
second
significantly
disclosure
summaries
implicates
similar
privacy
values
said
appeals
identification
disciplined
cadets
possible
consequence
even
anonymous
disclosure
expose
formerly
accused
men
lifelong
embarrassment
perhaps
disgrace
well
practical
disabilities
loss
employment
friends
see
generally
wine
hobby
usa
irs
rural
housing
alliance
dept
agriculture
app
robles
epa
summaries
collected
honor
ethics
code
reading
files
academy
honor
records
contain
vast
amounts
personal
data
constitute
kind
profile
individual
ordinarily
found
personnel
file
showing
example
born
names
parents
lived
time
time
high
school
school
records
results
examinations
evaluations
work
performance
moreover
access
files
drastically
limited
customarily
true
personnel
files
supervisory
personnel
directly
involved
individual
apart
personnel
department
frequently
thus
excluding
even
individual
contrary
case
summaries
name
names
except
guilty
cases
widely
disseminated
examination
fellow
cadets
contain
facts
except
pertain
alleged
violation
honor
ethics
codes
justified
academy
solely
value
educational
instructional
tool
better
train
military
officers
discharge
important
exacting
functions
documents
treated
agency
manner
reasonably
claimed
within
common
congressional
meaning
constitutes
personnel
file
exemption
agency
argues
secondly
even
taking
case
summaries
files
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
qualification
applies
appeals
nevertheless
improperly
ordered
agency
produce
case
summaries
district
camera
examination
eliminate
information
result
identifying
cadets
involved
honor
ethics
code
violations
argument
substance
recognition
appeals
harm
might
result
cadets
disclosure
demonstrates
ineffectiveness
excision
names
identifying
facts
means
maintaining
confidentiality
persons
named
government
reports
brief
petitioners
contention
merit
first
argument
implies
congress
barred
disclosure
case
conclusion
guaranteed
disclosure
trigger
recollection
identity
person
whatever
ignores
congress
limitation
exemption
cases
clearly
unwarranted
invasions
personal
privacy
second
congress
vested
courts
responsibility
ultimately
determine
de
novo
dispute
whether
exemption
properly
invoked
order
constrain
agencies
withholding
nonexempt
matters
yet
seen
case
histories
appeals
therefore
correct
holding
function
examination
must
discharged
first
instance
district
ackerly
ley
app
rural
housing
alliance
dept
agriculture
supra
striking
balance
whether
order
disclosure
part
case
summaries
district
determining
whether
disclosure
entail
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
may
properly
discount
probability
light
academy
tradition
keep
identities
confidential
within
academy
respondents
sought
disclosure
consistent
tradition
request
access
summaries
personal
references
identifying
information
deleted
respected
confidentiality
interests
embodied
exemption
appeals
recognized
however
constitutes
identifying
information
regarding
subject
cadet
must
weighed
viewpoint
public
also
vantage
familiar
fellow
cadets
academy
staff
aspects
career
academy
despite
summaries
distribution
within
academy
many
group
earlier
access
summaries
may
never
identified
particular
cadet
may
wholly
forgotten
encounter
academy
discipline
risk
privacy
interests
former
cadet
particularly
one
remained
military
posed
identification
otherwise
unknowing
former
colleagues
instructors
rejected
trivial
nevertheless
conclude
consideration
policies
underlying
freedom
information
act
open
public
business
public
view
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
privacy
result
requires
affirmance
holding
appeals
although
one
guarantee
know
hold
tongues
particularly
years
later
time
may
eroded
fabric
cadet
loyalty
sufficed
protect
privacy
stage
proceedings
enjoining
district
opinion
deletion
personal
references
identifying
information
sufficient
safeguard
privacy
summaries
disclosed
respondents
hold
therefore
agreement
appeals
camera
procedure
ordered
statutory
goal
exemption
six
workable
compromise
individual
rights
preservation
public
rights
government
information
sure
redaction
eliminate
risks
identifiability
human
approximation
risks
degree
imperfection
consequences
exposure
identity
admittedly
severe
redaction
familiar
technique
contexts
exemptions
disclosure
act
intended
practical
workable
concepts
epa
mink
moreover
repeat
exemption
protect
disclosure
every
incidental
invasion
privacy
disclosures
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasions
personal
privacy
affirmed
footnotes
upon
respondent
rose
request
documents
academy
officials
gave
copies
honor
code
honor
reference
manual
lesson
plans
honor
hearing
procedures
various
materials
explaining
honor
ethics
codes
denied
access
case
summaries
however
grounds
even
names
deleted
ome
cases
may
recognized
reader
circumstances
alone
without
identity
cadet
given
way
determining
facts
used
app
appeal
secretary
air
force
secretary
letter
administrative
assistant
refused
disclosure
case
summaries
ground
exempted
disclosure
exemption
freedom
information
act
air
force
regulations
cfr
ii
app
freedom
information
act
ed
supp
provides
pertinent
part
agency
shall
make
available
public
information
follows
except
respect
records
made
available
paragraphs
subsection
agency
upon
request
records
reasonably
describes
records
made
accordance
published
rules
stating
time
place
fees
procedures
followed
shall
make
records
promptly
available
person
complaint
district
district
complainant
resides
principal
place
business
agency
records
situated
district
columbia
jurisdiction
enjoin
agency
withholding
agency
records
order
production
agency
records
improperly
withheld
complainant
case
shall
determine
matter
de
novo
may
examine
contents
agency
records
camera
determine
whether
records
part
thereof
shall
withheld
exemptions
set
forth
subsection
section
burden
agency
sustain
action
section
apply
matters
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
personnel
medical
files
similar
files
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
reasonably
segregable
portion
record
shall
provided
person
requesting
record
deletion
portions
exempt
subsection
section
authorize
withholding
information
limit
availability
records
public
except
specifically
stated
section
respondents
also
sought
access
complete
study
resignations
academy
graduates
air
force
agency
claimed
study
exempted
disclosure
concerning
memorandums
letters
available
law
party
agency
litigation
agency
district
held
since
study
already
offered
dissemination
public
agency
waived
rights
exemption
accordingly
granted
respondents
partial
summary
judgment
requiring
agency
disclose
complete
study
respondents
pet
cert
agency
complied
order
stokes
brennan
hawkes
irs
stern
richardson
supp
dc
consumers
union
veterans
administration
supp
sdny
appeal
dismissed
moot
benson
gsa
supp
wd
aff
exemption
apparently
raised
appeal
honor
reference
handbook
air
force
cadet
wing
recites
former
secretary
war
newton
baker
said
inexact
untruthful
soldier
trifles
lives
fellow
men
honor
government
young
officer
needs
able
trust
men
commander
times
expensive
increasingly
complex
weapons
systems
officer
must
rely
fellow
officers
airmen
safety
safety
men
app
see
note
freedom
information
act
assessment
rev
note
comments
proposed
amendments
section
administrative
procedure
act
freedom
information
bill
notre
dame
law
see
also
vaughn
rosen
app
leventhal
concurring
agency
suggests
disclosure
identities
disciplined
cadets
release
case
summaries
weaken
honor
ethics
codes
principally
cadets
less
likely
report
misconduct
assured
absolute
confidentiality
reports
even
assuming
speculation
raises
argument
exemption
rather
exemption
alone
unpersuasive
light
deletion
process
ordered
appeals
conducted
remand
report
time
broad
philosophy
freedom
information
enacted
law
necessary
protect
certain
equally
important
rights
privacy
respect
certain
information
government
files
medical
personnel
records
easy
task
balance
opposing
interests
impossible
one
either
necessary
conclude
protect
one
interests
must
necessity
either
abrogated
substantially
subordinated
success
lies
providing
workable
formula
encompasses
balances
protects
interests
yet
places
emphasis
fullest
responsible
disclosure
see
generally
general
exemption
category
information
much
practical
separate
statutes
protecting
type
personal
record
limitation
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
provides
proper
balance
emphasis
supplied
senate
report
well
speaks
general
exemption
held
within
bounds
use
limitation
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
vaughn
rosen
app
soucie
david
app
ftc
app
accord
rural
housing
alliance
dept
agriculture
app
cf
supp
providing
extent
required
prevent
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
agency
may
delete
identifying
details
makes
available
publishes
opinion
statement
policy
interpretation
staff
manual
instruction
senate
report
amendment
cited
evident
approval
decision
appeals
case
remanding
district
redaction
case
summaries
accommodate
dual
interests
pp
brief
petitioners
sparse
legislative
history
precise
scope
intended
term
personnel
files
detail
suggests
congress
intended
particular
characterization
critical
application
exemption
quite
clear
committee
reports
primary
concern
congress
drafting
exemption
provide
confidentiality
personal
matters
files
maintained
department
health
education
welfare
selective
service
veterans
administration
moreover
senate
report
principal
source
bill
ultimately
enacted
freedom
information
act
exemption
particular
specifically
refers
files
personnel
files
see
also
hearings
house
committee
government
operations
analysis
agency
comments
air
force
regulations
force
time
decisions
drew
distinction
personnel
medical
files
cfr
files
similar
medical
personnel
files
cfr
clearly
categorized
case
summaries
among
latter
examples
similar
files
containing
reports
records
material
pertaining
personnel
matters
administrative
action
including
disciplinary
action
may
taken
taken
cfr
ii
fed
reg
emphasis
supplied
appeals
decision
regulations
amended
inter
alia
deleting
last
four
words
cfr
ii
fed
reg
alteration
event
insignificant
point
addition
qualification
considered
significant
determination
robles
epa
getman
nlrb
app
national
labor
relations
board
treasury
department
urged
hearings
act
clearly
clearly
unwarranted
qualification
exemption
deleted
see
hearings
subcommittee
administrative
practice
procedure
senate
committee
judiciary
treasury
nlrb
hearings
subcommittee
house
committee
government
operations
treasury
nlrb
see
also
hearings
supra
department
defense
objecting
heavy
burden
showing
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
see
also
hearings
supra
testimony
clark
mollenhoff
vice
chairman
sigma
delta
chi
committee
advancement
freedom
information
advocating
retention
clearly
exemption
terms
objected
nevertheless
retained
proper
balance
keep
scope
exemption
within
bounds
legislative
history
amendment
exemption
applies
investigatory
files
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
stands
marked
contrast
sess
originally
amended
passed
senate
cong
rec
although
originally
passed
house
cong
rec
exemption
amended
exempt
investigatory
files
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
extent
production
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
meet
one
several
conditions
response
presidential
request
delete
clearly
unwarranted
amendment
interests
personal
privacy
conference
committee
dropped
clearly
cong
rec
letters
president
ford
kennedy
letters
president
ford
cong
moorhead
bill
enacted
reported
conference
committee
stat
appeals
held
argument
raised
agency
courts
broad
equitable
power
decline
order
release
disclosure
damage
public
interest
substantial
one
context
exemption
since
exemption
requires
exercise
large
measure
discretion
agency
renewed
argument
supp
one
prime
shortcomings
administrative
procedure
act
view
congress
passed
freedom
information
act
precisely
provided
judicial
remedy
unauthorized
withholding
agency
records
epa
mink
legislative
history
clear
exemption
directed
threats
privacy
interests
palpable
mere
possibilities
house
report
explains
exemption
intended
exclude
files
disclosure
might
harm
individual
detailed
government
records
individual
identified
applying
individual
emphasis
supplied
senate
report
balance
drawn
exemption
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
clause
one
protection
individual
private
affairs
unnecessary
public
scrutiny
preservation
public
right
governmental
information
emphasis
supplied
appeals
cited
examples
revenue
rulings
collected
cumulative
bulletin
internal
revenue
service
american
bar
association
opinions
professional
ethics
chief
justice
burger
dissenting
hard
cases
make
bad
law
unusual
cases
surely
potential
make
even
worse
law
today
basis
highly
unusual
request
information
unique
governmental
process
military
academy
honor
system
interprets
definitively
substantial
significant
part
major
federal
statute
governing
balance
public
right
know
privacy
individual
citizen
view
makes
case
carry
much
jurisprudential
baggage
consequently
basic
congressional
intent
protect
reasonable
balance
availability
information
custody
government
particular
individual
right
privacy
undermined
addition
district
courts
burdened
task
congress
intended
case
compel
us
decide
whether
summaries
issue
personnel
files
whether
files
categorized
beyond
proviso
exemption
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
even
assuming
arguendo
government
must
show
summaries
subject
foregoing
standard
quite
clear
view
disclosure
material
issue
constitutes
invasion
matter
excision
process
attempted
federal
judge
correctly
notes
congress
enacting
exemption
intended
strike
proper
balance
protection
individual
right
privacy
preservation
public
right
government
information
excluding
kinds
files
disclosure
might
harm
individual
acknowledged
necessity
balance
however
view
blandly
ignores
thereby
frustrates
congressional
intent
refusing
weigh
realistically
grave
consequences
implicit
release
particular
information
form
relatively
inconsequential
claim
need
material
alleged
complaint
opinions
long
recognized
opprobrium
civilian
military
segments
society
attribute
allegations
dishonor
among
commissioned
officers
armed
forces
see
parker
levy
quoting
orloff
willoughby
stigma
society
imposes
individual
accepted
position
trust
abused
erasable
realistic
sense
passage
time
even
subsequent
exemplary
conduct
absence
broken
sword
torn
epaulets
rogue
march
military
ritual
lessen
indelibility
stigma
significantly
cadets
midshipmen
inchoate
officers
traditionally
held
high
standards
subjected
stigma
commissioned
officers
involved
matters
overtones
dishonor
indeed
mode
punitive
separation
result
officers
cadets
dismissal
ellman
moreover
appeals
noted
unrealistic
conclude
cases
finding
guilty
discretion
exonerates
cadet
anything
purely
technical
legal
sense
term
admittedly
requires
release
documents
subject
camera
inspection
power
excising
parts
admits
attempt
sanitize
summaries
still
leave
distinct
possibility
individual
still
identifiable
thereby
injured
light
congress
recent
manifest
concern
privacy
act
supp
governmental
respect
privacy
citizens
indeed
difficult
attribute
congress
willingness
subject
individual
citizen
risk
possible
severe
damage
reputation
simply
permit
law
students
invade
individual
privacy
prepare
law
journal
article
definition
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
equated
protect
ing
individual
private
affairs
unnecessary
public
scrutiny
emphasis
supplied
otherwise
rendered
meaningless
moreover
excision
ineffectual
accomplishing
legislative
intent
protecting
individual
affairs
unnecessary
public
scrutiny
place
intolerable
burden
upon
district
view
congress
never
intended
inflict
although
amendments
freedom
information
act
require
ny
reasonably
segregable
portion
record
supp
otherwise
exempt
provided
nothing
legislative
history
original
act
amendments
require
district
construct
effect
new
document
yet
excision
process
mandated
require
sweeping
reconstruction
material
end
product
constitute
entirely
new
document
provision
freedom
information
act
contemplates
federal
district
judge
acting
rewrite
editor
original
material
holding
indeed
fair
reflection
congressional
intent
confronted
legislative
reaction
conflict
seeming
passion
privacy
comparable
passion
needless
invasions
privacy
accordingly
reverse
judgment
appeals
noted
orloff
willoughby
president
commission
uses
words
reposing
special
trust
confidence
patriotism
valor
fidelity
abilities
appointee
officer
may
punitively
dismissed
equivalent
dishonorable
discharge
found
guilty
offense
general
regardless
limitations
placed
punishment
offense
committed
enlisted
personnel
manual
see
generally
goodwin
op
atty
article
uniform
code
military
justice
example
commissioned
officer
cadet
midshipman
convicted
conduct
unbecoming
officer
gentleman
shall
punished
may
direct
emphasis
supplied
concerned
freedom
information
act
ed
supp
two
exemptions
provided
recent
past
hesitated
consistently
provide
force
congressionally
mandated
exemptions
see
faa
administrator
robertson
renegotiation
board
grumman
aircraft
nlrb
sears
roebuck
epa
mink
see
also
renegotiation
board
bannercraft
clothing
today
fear
opposite
act
second
exemption
extends
matters
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
doubt
department
air
force
including
faculty
staff
supervise
cadets
air
force
academy
qualifies
agency
within
meaning
recognizes
ante
thought
however
matters
concern
established
honor
codes
military
academies
codes
long
existence
part
military
society
tradition
see
parker
levy
disciplining
cadets
move
along
education
clearly
qualify
internal
personnel
practices
agency
nature
smacks
personnel
personnel
problems
practices
agency
internal
business
public
exemption
afforded
thus
although
find
great
support
language
second
exemption
petitioners
position
makes
obvious
common
sense
hold
district
act
second
exemption
applies
case
summaries
respondent
rose
ardently
desired
removes
eager
grasp
accept
rationale
appeals
majority
existence
substantial
potential
public
interest
outside
government
makes
case
summaries
less
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
surely
public
interest
secondary
byproduct
measure
sole
relationship
primary
concept
summaries
involve
discipline
fitness
training
cadets
administered
enforced
basis
cadets
exist
wholly
apart
formal
system
uniform
code
military
justice
act
sixth
exemption
equally
supportive
petitioners
result
opposite
reaches
today
exemption
applies
matters
personnel
medical
files
similar
files
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
specific
reference
personnel
files
said
applies
equally
addition
sixth
exemption
covers
similar
files
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
added
restrictive
phrase
applies
personnel
surely
medical
files
similar
files
see
robles
epa
emphasis
personnel
files
medical
files
similar
files
extent
privacy
invasion
latter
unwarranted
exemption
personnel
files
medical
files
clear
unembellished
almost
inconceivable
willing
today
attach
qualification
phrase
medical
files
thereby
open
public
recognized
almost
essence
ultimate
privacy
law
long
established
privilege
establishes
anyone
even
minimal
contact
practice
medicine
surely
agree
extension
judicial
construction
reasoning
another
appeals
ackerly
ley
app
referred
seemingly
approved
ante
case
summaries
something
less
personnel
files
proposition
accept
surely
similar
personnel
files
invaded
afford
instance
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
hard
imagine
something
personal
seems
blinding
realities
concludes
rose
demands
result
invasions
personal
privacy
cadets
concerned
regard
less
unwarranted
redaction
impractical
solution
judicial
rationalization
case
summaries
posted
squadron
bulletin
boards
throughout
academy
ante
copies
distributed
faculty
administration
officials
invasion
invasion
publication
restricted
academy
grounds
private
public
portions
facilities
disseminated
corps
alone
faculty
administration
part
academy
general
pedagogical
disciplinary
purpose
program
sure
may
appear
large
number
academy
family
area
confinement
important
reasoning
must
apply
awkwardly
seems
five
two
posting
places
indeed
one
add
see
little
assistance
legislative
history
often
case
history
cuts
ways
particularly
confusing
struggle
ante
demonstrates
finally
note
candid
recognition
personal
risks
involved
ante
today
decision
course
makes
risks
reality
cadet
particularly
one
remained
military
risks
imposed
upon
individual
return
questionable
benefit
public
personal
benefit
respondent
rose
often
pendulum
swings
far
fear
today
strikes
severe
blow
honor
codes
system
operate
former
cadets
concerned
sad
see
old
institutions
mortally
wounded
passing
away
individuals
placed
jeopardy
embarrassment
lesser
incidents
long
past
reverse
judgment
appeals
justice
rehnquist
dissenting
although
case
requires
consideration
claim
right
privacy
arises
quite
different
context
recent
decisions
paul
davis
case
custodians
public
records
chose
disseminate
one
subjects
record
claimed
fourteenth
amendment
constitution
prohibited
custodian
custodian
records
petitioner
department
air
force
chosen
disseminate
records
decision
effect
challenged
citizen
freedom
information
act
act
opinion
dissenting
opinion
chief
justice
point
requires
federal
courts
balance
claim
right
access
information
consequent
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
reasons
stated
part
dissenting
opinion
chief
justice
agree
act
contemplate
virtual
reconstruction
records
guise
excision
segregable
part
record
therefore
agree
chief
justice
justice
blackmun
absence
redaction
sixth
exemption
act
applicable
judgment
appeals
reversed