ward
board
county
love
county
argued
decided
april
john
emerson
bennett
worth
george
glaze
oklahoma
city
petitioners
justice
van
devanter
delivered
opinion
proceeding
behalf
coleman
ward
six
indians
recover
moneys
alleged
coercively
collected
love
county
oklahoma
taxes
allotments
laws
constitution
nontaxable
county
commissioners
disallowed
claim
claimants
appealed
district
county
claimants
petition
challenged
demurrer
overruled
county
elected
plead
judgment
claimants
followed
reversed
board
comr
love
county
ward
pac
case
writ
certiorari
sup
claimants
members
choctaw
tribe
wards
received
al
otments
tribal
domain
congressional
enactment
subjected
right
alienation
certain
restrictions
provided
lands
allotted
shall
nontaxable
title
remains
original
allottee
exceed
years
date
patent
chapter
stat
act
enabling
oklahoma
become
state
congress
made
plain
impairment
rights
property
pertaining
indians
intended
chapter
stat
state
included
constitution
provision
exempting
taxation
property
may
exempt
reason
treaty
stipulations
existing
indians
government
federal
laws
force
effect
treaties
federal
laws
article
afterwards
congress
act
removed
restrictions
alienation
certain
classes
allottees
including
present
claimants
declared
land
restrictions
removed
subject
taxation
though
property
persons
allottees
chapter
stat
following
last
enactment
officers
love
counties
began
tax
allotted
lands
restrictions
alienation
removed
met
pronounced
opposition
part
indian
allottees
insisted
advised
tax
exemption
vested
property
right
abrogated
destroyed
consistently
constitution
suits
begun
state
courts
maintain
exemption
enjoin
threatened
taxation
one
suits
prosecuted
allottees
officers
love
counties
suits
resisted
state
courts
opinion
exemption
repealed
congress
sustained
power
tax
english
richardson
okl
pac
gleason
wood
okl
pac
choate
trapp
okl
pac
cases
brought
held
exemption
vested
property
right
congress
repeal
consistently
fifth
amendment
binding
taxing
authorities
oklahoma
state
courts
erred
refusing
enjoin
taxing
lands
choate
trapp
sup
gleason
wood
sup
english
richardson
sup
suits
pending
officers
love
county
full
knowledge
suits
defendants
one
proceeded
taxation
allotments
demanded
claimants
taxes
lands
paid
county
threatened
advertise
sell
lands
unless
taxes
paid
advertise
sell
lands
similarly
situated
caused
claimants
believe
lands
sold
taxes
paid
prevent
sale
avoid
imposition
penalty
eighteen
per
local
statute
provided
claimants
paid
taxes
protested
objected
time
taxes
invalid
county
officers
knew
allottees
pressing
objection
pending
suits
conclusion
facts
claimants
asserted
taxes
collected
love
county
coercive
means
collection
violation
right
arising
law
congress
protected
constitution
county
accordingly
bound
repay
moneys
thus
collected
total
amount
claimed
aside
interest
substance
case
presented
petition
also
described
tract
taxed
named
allottee
taxes
collected
stated
amount
date
eachp
ayment
reversing
judgment
district
given
claimants
held
first
taxes
collected
coercive
means
paid
voluntarily
recovered
back
statutory
authority
therefor
secondly
statute
making
county
liable
taxes
collected
paid
state
municipal
bodies
assumed
true
portion
petition
show
much
taxes
retained
county
much
paid
state
municipal
bodies
therefore
basis
judgment
county
county
challenges
jurisdiction
motion
dismiss
writ
certiorari
way
supporting
motion
insists
put
judgment
entirely
independent
nonfederal
grounds
broad
enough
sustain
judgment
claimants
disposed
allotments
one
years
elapsed
since
date
patents
certain
lands
nontaxable
settled
choate
trapp
supra
cases
decided
also
settled
cases
exemption
vested
property
right
arising
law
congress
protected
constitution
state
agencies
political
subdivisions
bound
give
effect
exemption
operated
direct
restraint
love
county
matter
said
local
statutes
county
respect
contrary
assessed
lands
allotted
claimants
placed
county
tax
roll
charged
taxes
like
property
portion
taxes
go
state
municipal
bodies
assume
still
county
charged
taxes
lands
proceeded
collect
payment
taxes
demanded
county
paid
circumstances
already
narrated
accept
much
decision
held
payment
voluntary
moneys
recovered
back
absence
permissive
statute
statute
unable
accept
decision
respects
right
exemption
federal
right
specially
set
claimed
petition
whether
right
denied
given
due
recognition
question
claimants
entitled
invoke
judgment
done
appropriate
way
therefore
within
province
inquire
whether
right
denied
express
terms
also
whether
denied
substance
effect
putting
forward
nonfederal
grounds
decision
without
fair
substantial
support
union
pacific
public
service
commission
sup
leathe
thomas
sup
vandalia
south
bend
sup
gaar
scott
shannon
sup
creswill
knights
pythias
sup
enterprise
irrigation
district
farmers
mutual
canal
sup
see
jefferson
branch
bank
skelly
black
huntington
attrill
sup
boyd
thayer
sup
carter
texas
sup
course
nonfederal
grounds
plainly
untenable
may
thus
put
forward
successfully
power
review
easily
may
avoided
terre
haute
indiana
sup
witht
qualification
true
judgment
state
put
independent
nonfederal
grounds
broad
enough
sustain
reviewed
us
qualification
material
one
disregarded
without
neglecting
renouncing
jurisdiction
conferred
law
designed
protect
maintain
supremacy
constitution
laws
made
pursuance
thereof
facts
set
forth
petition
admitted
demurrer
whereon
county
elected
stand
make
plain
think
finding
decision
taxes
paid
voluntarily
without
fair
substantial
support
claimants
indians
emerging
state
dependency
wardship
pending
suits
otherwise
objecting
protesting
taxation
lands
forbidden
law
congress
notwithstanding
county
demanded
taxes
paid
threatening
sell
lands
claimants
actually
selling
lands
similarly
situated
made
appear
claimants
must
choose
paying
taxes
losing
lands
prevent
sale
avoid
imposition
penalty
eighteen
per
cent
yielded
county
demand
paid
taxes
protesting
objecting
time
illegal
moneys
thus
collected
obtained
coercive
compulsion
county
officers
reasonably
regarded
otherwise
much
less
indian
claimants
atchison
topeka
santa
fe
ry
sup
ann
cas
gaar
scott
shannon
supra
sup
union
pacific
public
service
commission
supra
swift
sup
robertson
frank
sup
oceanic
steam
navigation
stranahan
sup
county
places
reliance
lamborn
county
commissioners
railroad
commissioners
cases
quite
distinguishable
facts
general
observations
therein
county
invites
attention
must
taken
modified
later
cases
cited
payment
voluntary
made
compulsion
statutory
authority
essential
enable
require
county
refund
money
rule
got
imposition
may
recovered
back
said
several
occasions
obligation
justice
rests
upon
persons
natural
artificial
county
obtains
money
property
others
without
authority
law
independent
statute
compel
restitution
compensation
marsh
fulton
county
wall
ed
city
louisiana
wood
chapman
county
douglas
sup
say
county
collect
unlawful
taxes
coercive
means
incur
obligation
pay
back
nothing
short
saying
take
appropriate
property
indian
allottees
arbitrarily
without
due
process
law
course
contravention
fourteenth
amendment
binds
county
agency
state
true
assumed
portion
taxes
paid
collection
state
municipal
bodies
regard
certain
alter
county
liability
claimants
county
right
collect
money
took
notice
rights
share
taxes
disputed
claimants
contested
pending
suits
circumstances
uld
lessen
liability
paying
portion
money
others
whose
rights
knew
disputed
better
atchison
topeka
santa
fe
ry
supra
sup
ann
cas
legal
contemplation
received
money
use
benefit
claimants
respond
accordingly
county
calls
attention
fact
demurrer
petition
statute
limitation
probably
meaning
section
rev
laws
relied
point
discussed
concerned
beyond
observing
case
remanded
open
deal
point
whole
claim
item
valid
local
law
force
claim
filed
may
require
motion
dismiss
denied
judgment
reversed