santobello
new
york
argued
november
decided
december
negotiations
prosecutor
petitioner
withdrew
previous
plea
two
felony
counts
pleaded
guilty
offense
prosecutor
agreed
make
recommendation
sentence
petitioner
appearance
sentencing
many
months
later
new
prosecutor
recommended
maximum
sentence
judge
stated
uninfluenced
recommendation
imposed
petitioner
attempted
unsuccessfully
withdraw
guilty
plea
conviction
affirmed
appeal
held
interests
justice
proper
recognition
prosecution
duties
relation
promises
made
connection
plea
bargaining
require
judgment
vacated
case
remanded
state
courts
consideration
whether
circumstances
require
specific
performance
agreement
plea
case
petitioner
resentenced
different
judge
petitioner
afforded
relief
seeks
withdrawing
guilty
plea
pp
app
div
vacated
remanded
burger
delivered
opinion
douglas
white
blackmun
joined
douglas
filed
concurring
opinion
post
marshall
filed
opinion
concurring
part
dissenting
part
brennan
stewart
joined
post
irving
anolik
argued
cause
filed
brief
petitioner
daniel
sullivan
argued
cause
respondent
brief
burton
roberts
chief
justice
burger
delivered
opinion
granted
certiorari
case
determine
whether
state
failure
keep
commitment
concerning
sentence
recommendation
guilty
plea
required
new
trial
facts
dispute
state
new
york
indicted
petitioner
two
felony
counts
promoting
gambling
first
degree
possession
gambling
records
first
degree
penal
law
petitioner
first
entered
plea
guilty
counts
negotiations
assistant
district
attorney
charge
case
agreed
permit
petitioner
plead
guilty
offense
possession
gambling
records
second
degree
penal
law
conviction
carry
maximum
prison
sentence
one
year
prosecutor
agreed
make
recommendation
sentence
june
petitioner
accordingly
withdrew
plea
guilty
entered
plea
guilty
lesser
charge
petitioner
represented
sentencing
judge
plea
voluntary
facts
case
described
assistant
district
attorney
true
accepted
plea
set
date
sentencing
series
delays
followed
owing
primarily
absence
report
september
petitioner
still
sentenced
date
petitioner
acquired
new
defense
counsel
petitioner
new
counsel
moved
immediately
withdraw
guilty
plea
accompanying
affidavit
petitioner
alleged
know
time
plea
crucial
evidence
obtained
result
illegal
search
accuracy
affidavit
subject
challenge
since
petitioner
filed
withdrawn
motion
suppress
pleading
guilty
addition
motion
withdraw
guilty
plea
petitioner
renewed
motion
suppress
filed
motion
inspect
grand
jury
minutes
three
motions
turn
caused
delay
november
denied
three
set
january
date
sentencing
january
petitioner
appeared
different
judge
judge
presided
case
juncture
retired
petitioner
renewed
motions
rejected
turned
consideration
sentence
appearance
another
prosecutor
replaced
prosecutor
negotiated
plea
new
prosecutor
recommended
maximum
sentence
making
recommendation
cited
petitioner
criminal
record
alleged
links
organized
crime
defense
counsel
immediately
objected
ground
state
promised
petitioner
plea
entered
sentence
recommendation
prosecution
sought
adjourn
sentence
hearing
order
time
prepare
proof
first
prosecutor
promise
second
prosecutor
apparently
ignorant
colleague
commitment
argued
nothing
record
support
petitioner
claim
promise
state
subsequent
proceedings
contested
promise
made
sentencing
judge
ended
discussion
following
statement
quoting
extensively
presentence
report
aronstein
defense
counsel
influenced
district
attorney
says
need
adjourn
sentence
need
testimony
make
particle
difference
district
attorney
says
aronstein
probation
report
history
long
long
serious
criminal
record
picture
life
history
man
unamenable
supervision
community
professional
criminal
quotes
recidivist
institutionalization
means
plain
language
putting
away
means
halting
activities
protecting
family
family
protecting
society
institutionalization
plain
language
put
behind
bars
plea
send
new
york
city
correctional
institution
men
one
year
hereby
petitioner
sought
obtained
certificate
reasonable
doubt
admitted
bail
pending
appeal
state
new
york
appellate
division
first
department
unanimously
affirmed
petitioner
conviction
app
div
petitioner
denied
leave
appeal
new
york
appeals
petitioner
sought
certiorari
justice
harlan
granted
bail
pending
disposition
case
record
represents
another
example
unfortunate
lapse
orderly
prosecutorial
procedures
part
doubt
enormous
increase
workload
often
understaffed
prosecutor
offices
heavy
workload
may
well
explain
episodes
excuse
disposition
criminal
charges
agreement
prosecutor
accused
sometimes
loosely
called
plea
bargaining
essential
component
administration
justice
properly
administered
encouraged
every
criminal
charge
subjected
trial
federal
government
need
multiply
many
times
number
judges
facilities
disposition
charges
plea
discussions
essential
part
process
highly
desirable
part
many
reasons
leads
prompt
largely
final
disposition
criminal
cases
avoids
much
corrosive
impact
enforced
idleness
pretrial
confinement
denied
release
pending
trial
protects
public
accused
persons
prone
continue
criminal
conduct
even
pretrial
release
shortening
time
charge
disposition
enhances
whatever
may
rehabilitative
prospects
guilty
ultimately
imprisoned
see
brady
however
considerations
presuppose
fairness
securing
agreement
accused
prosecutor
clear
example
accused
pleading
guilty
must
counseled
absent
waiver
moore
michigan
fed
rule
crim
proc
governing
pleas
federal
courts
makes
clear
sentencing
judge
must
develop
record
factual
basis
plea
example
accused
describe
conduct
gave
rise
charge
plea
must
course
voluntary
knowing
induced
promises
essence
promises
must
way
made
known
course
absolute
right
guilty
plea
accepted
lynch
overholser
fed
rule
crim
proc
may
reject
plea
exercise
sound
judicial
discretion
phase
process
criminal
justice
adjudicative
element
inherent
accepting
plea
guilty
must
attended
safeguards
insure
defendant
reasonably
due
circumstances
circumstances
vary
constant
factor
plea
rests
significant
degree
promise
agreement
prosecutor
said
part
inducement
consideration
promise
must
fulfilled
record
petitioner
bargained
negotiated
particular
plea
order
secure
dismissal
serious
charges
also
condition
sentence
recommendation
made
prosecutor
conceded
promise
abstain
recommendation
made
stage
prosecution
good
position
argue
inadvertent
breach
agreement
immaterial
staff
lawyers
prosecutor
office
burden
letting
left
hand
know
right
hand
done
breach
agreement
inadvertent
lessen
impact
need
reach
question
whether
sentencing
judge
influenced
known
details
negotiations
plea
stated
prosecutor
recommendation
influence
reason
doubt
nevertheless
conclude
interests
justice
appropriate
recognition
duties
prosecution
relation
promises
made
negotiation
pleas
guilty
best
served
remanding
case
state
courts
consideration
ultimate
relief
petitioner
entitled
leave
discretion
state
better
position
decide
whether
circumstances
case
require
specific
performance
agreement
plea
case
petitioner
resentenced
different
judge
whether
view
state
circumstances
require
granting
relief
sought
petitioner
opportunity
withdraw
plea
guilty
emphasize
sense
question
fairness
sentencing
judge
fault
rests
prosecutor
sentencing
judge
judgment
vacated
case
remanded
reconsideration
inconsistent
opinion
footnotes
state
decides
allow
withdrawal
plea
petitioner
course
plead
anew
original
charge
two
felony
counts
justice
douglas
concurring
join
opinion
add
word
agree
chief
justice
justice
marshall
new
york
keep
plea
bargain
petitioner
excuse
default
merely
member
prosecutor
staff
party
plea
bargain
charge
case
came
new
york
staff
prosecution
unit
member
must
presumed
know
commitments
made
member
responsibility
evaded
way
prosecution
designed
another
deceptive
contrivance
akin
condemned
mooney
holohan
napue
illinois
plea
bargains
important
administration
justice
state
federal
levels
chief
justice
says
serve
important
role
disposition
today
heavy
calendars
however
important
plea
bargaining
may
administration
criminal
justice
opinions
established
guilty
plea
serious
sobering
occasion
inasmuch
constitutes
waiver
fundamental
rights
jury
trial
duncan
louisiana
confront
one
accusers
pointer
texas
present
witnesses
one
defense
washington
texas
remain
silent
malloy
hogan
convicted
proof
beyond
reasonable
doubt
winship
since
kercheval
recognized
unfairly
obtained
guilty
pleas
federal
courts
vacated
course
holding
withdrawn
guilty
pleas
admissible
subsequent
federal
prosecutions
opined
timely
application
vacate
plea
guilty
shown
unfairly
obtained
given
ignorance
fear
inadvertence
application
involve
question
guilt
innocence
state
convictions
founded
upon
coerced
unfairly
induced
guilty
pleas
also
received
increased
scrutiny
fundamental
rights
applied
powell
alabama
held
state
defendant
entitled
lawyer
assistance
choosing
whether
plead
guilty
williams
kaiser
herman
claudy
federal
habeas
corpus
held
lie
lawyerless
uneducated
state
prisoner
pleaded
guilty
numerous
complex
robbery
charges
guilty
plea
obtained
without
advice
counsel
may
admitted
subsequent
state
prosecution
white
maryland
thus
plea
bargaining
per
se
unconstitutional
north
carolina
alford
shelton
aff
en
banc
guilty
plea
rendered
voidable
threatening
physical
harm
waley
johnston
supra
threatening
use
false
testimony
threatening
bring
additional
prosecutions
machibroda
supra
failing
inform
defendant
right
counsel
walker
johnston
supra
circumstances
clear
guilty
plea
must
vacated
also
clear
prosecutor
promise
may
deprive
guilty
plea
character
voluntary
act
machibroda
supra
cf
bram
decisions
spelled
sorts
promises
prosecutors
tend
coercive
order
assist
appellate
review
weighing
promises
light
circumstances
trial
courts
required
interrogate
defendants
enter
guilty
pleas
waiver
fundamental
rights
affirmatively
appear
record
mccarthy
boykin
alabama
lower
courts
however
uniformly
held
prisoner
entitled
form
relief
shows
prosecutor
reneged
sentencing
agreement
made
connection
plea
bargain
jurisdictions
preferring
vacation
plea
ground
involuntariness
permit
specific
enforcement
note
guilty
plea
bargaining
compromises
prosecutors
secure
guilty
pleas
rev
one
author
stated
basis
outright
vacation
outraged
sense
fairness
prosecutor
breaches
promise
connection
sentencing
newman
conviction
determination
guilt
innocence
without
trial
state
case
supervisory
jurisdiction
rule
federal
rules
criminal
procedure
obviously
relevancy
problem
join
opinion
favor
constitutional
rule
well
pending
oncoming
cases
plea
bargain
kept
prosecutor
sentence
must
vacated
state
decide
light
circumstances
case
whether
due
process
requires
specific
performance
plea
bargain
defendant
given
option
go
trial
original
charges
one
alternative
may
justice
one
case
different
case
choosing
remedy
however
accord
defendant
preference
considerable
controlling
weight
inasmuch
fundamental
rights
flouted
prosecutor
breach
plea
bargain
defendant
state
guilty
pleas
accounted
criminal
convictions
trial
courts
general
jurisdiction
new
york
figure
california
president
commission
law
enforcement
administration
justice
task
force
report
courts
guilty
pleas
accounted
criminal
convictions
district
courts
ibid
fiscal
convictions
district
courts
pleas
guilty
nolo
contendere
report
director
administrative
office
courts
period
july
table
justice
marshall
justice
brennan
justice
stewart
join
concurring
part
dissenting
part
agree
much
majority
opinion
conclude
petitioner
must
permitted
withdraw
guilty
plea
relief
petitioner
requested
facts
set
majority
form
relief
entitled
need
belabor
fact
constitution
guarantees
criminal
defendants
right
trial
judge
jury
put
another
way
right
plead
guilty
jackson
federal
rights
may
waived
guilty
plea
waivers
lightly
presumed
fact
viewed
utmost
solicitude
boykin
alabama
given
believe
defendant
present
reason
vacating
plea
government
relied
plea
disadvantage
plea
may
vacated
right
trial
regained
least
motion
vacate
made
prior
sentence
judgment
words
circumstances
deem
earlier
plea
irrevocably
waived
defendant
federal
constitutional
right
trial
petitioner
never
claimed
automatic
right
withdraw
guilty
plea
sentencing
rather
tendered
specific
reason
case
plea
vacated
reason
prosecutor
broken
promise
made
return
agreement
plead
guilty
prosecutor
breaks
bargain
undercuts
basis
waiver
constitutional
rights
implicit
plea
seems
provides
defendant
ample
justification
rescinding
plea
promise
unfulfilled
brady
specifically
denies
plea
must
stand
course
prosecutor
broken
plea
agreement
may
appropriate
permit
defendant
enforce
plea
bargain
remedy
sought
rather
seems
breach
plea
bargain
provides
ample
reason
permit
plea
vacated
worth
noting
ordinary
case
motion
vacate
made
prior
sentencing
government
taken
action
reliance
previously
entered
guilty
plea
suffer
harm
plea
withdrawal
pointedly
state
claims
harm
beyond
disappointed
expectations
plea
least
government
broken
plea
bargain
disappointment
bar
petitioner
withdrawing
guilty
plea
reclaiming
right
trial
remand
case
instructions
plea
vacated
petitioner
given
opportunity
replead
original
charges
indictment
justice
douglas
although
joining
opinion
apparently
thinks
remedy
chosen
state
concludes
state
accord
defendant
preference
considerable
controlling
weight
thus
majority
appears
believe
cases
like
defendant
seeks
vacate
plea
relief
generally
granted