mazer
stein
argued
december
decided
march
respondents
engaged
manufacture
sale
electric
lamps
one
respondents
created
original
works
sculpture
models
china
statuettes
made
statuettes
used
bases
fully
equipped
electric
lamps
respondents
sold
respondents
submitted
statuettes
without
lamp
components
added
registration
copyright
law
works
art
reproductions
thereof
held
statuettes
copyrightable
pp
successive
copyright
acts
legislative
history
act
practice
copyright
office
show
works
art
reproductions
works
art
intended
congress
include
authority
copyright
statuettes
pp
statuettes
fitted
lamps
unfitted
may
patentable
bar
copyright
works
art
pp
intended
actual
use
industry
article
eligible
copyright
bar
invalidate
registration
subsequent
registration
work
art
published
element
manufactured
article
misuse
copyright
pp
respondents
sued
petitioners
copyright
infringement
district
dismissed
complaint
supp
appeals
reversed
granted
certiorari
affirmed
max
kraus
robert
kahn
argued
cause
filed
brief
petitioners
george
frost
argued
cause
respondents
brief
freeman
charles
barber
special
leave
benjamin
forman
argued
cause
register
copyrights
amicus
curiae
urging
affirmance
brief
acting
solicitor
general
stern
assistant
attorney
general
burger
paul
sweeney
justice
reed
delivered
opinion
case
involves
validity
copyrights
obtained
respondents
statuettes
male
female
dancing
figures
made
semivitreous
china
controversy
centers
around
fact
although
copyrighted
works
art
statuettes
intended
use
used
bases
table
lamps
electric
wiring
sockets
lamp
shades
attached
respondents
partners
manufacture
sale
electric
lamps
one
respondents
created
original
works
sculpture
form
human
figures
traditional
technique
model
production
mold
casting
copies
made
resulting
statuettes
without
lamp
components
added
submitted
respondents
copyright
office
registration
works
art
reproductions
thereof
copyright
law
certificates
registration
issued
sales
publication
accordance
statute
fully
equipped
lamps
preceded
applications
copyright
registration
statuettes
supp
rules
regulations
cfr
thereafter
statuettes
sold
quantity
throughout
country
lamp
bases
statuettes
sales
lamp
form
accounted
insignificant
portion
respondents
sales
petitioners
partners
like
respondents
make
sell
lamps
without
authorization
copied
statuettes
embodied
lamps
sold
instant
case
one
series
reported
suits
brought
respondents
various
alleged
infringers
copyrights
presenting
similar
question
conflicting
decisions
granted
certiorari
present
case
respondents
sued
petitioners
infringement
maryland
stein
mazer
supp
following
expert
decision
rejecting
reasoning
district
rosenthal
opinion
referred
preceding
note
district
dismissed
complaint
appeals
reversed
held
copyrights
valid
stein
mazer
said
subsequent
utilization
work
art
article
manufacture
way
affects
right
copyright
owner
protected
infringement
work
art
petitioners
charged
present
complaint
infringement
respondents
copyrights
reproductions
works
art
seek
reversal
appeals
decree
upholding
copyrights
petitioners
petition
certiorari
present
single
question
statuettes
protected
copyright
copyright
applicant
intended
primarily
use
statuettes
form
lamp
bases
made
sold
quantity
carried
intentions
effect
stripped
essentials
question
presented
lamp
manufacturer
copyright
lamp
bases
artist
becomes
manufacturer
designer
manufacturer
subject
limitations
design
patents
deserves
consideration
manufacturer
designer
however
cellini
designed
manufactured
item
quantity
general
public
salt
cellars
entirely
different
conclusion
reached
case
salt
cellar
becomes
article
manufacture
utility
addition
ornamental
value
therefore
protected
design
patent
unfair
competition
question
presented
constitutional
power
congress
confer
copyright
protection
works
art
reproductions
questioned
petitioners
assume
congress
enactments
constitutional
clause
empowering
legislation
promote
progress
science
useful
arts
securing
limited
times
authors
inventors
exclusive
right
respective
writings
discoveries
art
cl
includes
within
term
authors
creator
picture
statue
consideration
limited
question
presented
petition
writ
certiorari
recent
years
question
utilitarian
use
copyrighted
articles
much
discussed
answering
issue
review
development
copyright
coverage
make
clear
purpose
congress
copyright
legislation
first
congress
conferred
copyright
authors
map
chart
book
books
already
printed
later
designing
engraving
etching
included
musical
compositions
dramatic
compositions
photographs
negatives
thereof
act
defined
copyrightable
subject
matter
book
map
chart
dramatic
musical
composition
engraving
cut
print
photograph
negative
thereof
painting
drawing
chromo
statue
statuary
models
designs
intended
perfected
works
fine
arts
emphasis
supplied
works
copyright
may
secured
act
shall
include
writings
author
practice
copyright
office
acts
act
allow
registration
works
fine
arts
articles
character
respondents
challenge
seven
examples
appear
government
brief
amicus
curiae
interpreting
act
pertinent
copyright
regulations
read
shown
margin
explained
government
regulation
made
reference
articles
might
fairly
considered
works
art
although
might
also
serve
useful
purpose
reworded
shown
amicus
brief
gives
sixty
examples
selected
intervals
said
typical
registrations
works
art
possessing
utilitarian
aspects
current
pertinent
regulation
published
cfr
reads
thus
works
art
class
general
class
includes
works
artistic
craftsmanship
far
form
mechanical
utilitarian
aspects
concerned
artistic
jewelry
enamels
glassware
tapestries
well
works
belonging
fine
arts
paintings
drawings
sculpture
essayed
fix
limits
fine
arts
effort
need
appraised
relation
copyright
issue
clear
congress
intended
scope
copyright
statute
include
traditional
fine
arts
herbert
putnam
librarian
congress
active
movement
amend
copyright
laws
told
joint
meeting
house
senate
committees
term
works
art
deliberately
intended
broader
specification
works
fine
arts
present
statute
idea
instance
applied
design
yet
within
province
design
patents
may
properly
entitled
protection
copyright
law
conclusion
statues
issue
may
copyrighted
goes
far
solve
question
whether
intended
reproduction
lamp
stands
bars
invalidates
registration
depends
solely
statutory
interpretation
congress
may
publication
protect
copyright
writing
author
statute
creates
copyright
exist
common
law
even
though
property
right
unpublished
work
petitioners
assert
congressional
enactment
design
patent
laws
interpreted
denying
protection
artistic
articles
embodied
reproduced
manufactured
articles
say
fundamentally
historically
copyright
office
repository
claimant
considers
cultural
treasure
whereas
patent
office
repository
applicant
considers
evidence
advance
industrial
technological
fields
industrial
designer
satisfy
novelty
requirements
design
patent
laws
design
used
articles
manufacture
copied
anyone
held
statuettes
involved
copyrightable
need
decide
question
patentability
though
courts
passed
upon
issue
whether
allowance
election
author
patentee
one
bars
grant
hold
patentability
statuettes
fitted
lamps
unfitted
bar
copyright
works
art
neither
copyright
statute
says
thing
patentable
may
copyrighted
hold
unlike
patent
copyright
gives
exclusive
right
art
disclosed
protection
given
expression
idea
idea
thus
baker
selden
held
copyrighted
book
peculiar
system
bookkeeping
infringed
similar
book
using
similar
plan
achieved
similar
results
alleged
infringer
made
different
arrangement
columns
used
different
headings
distinction
illustrated
fred
fisher
dillingham
speaks
two
men
perfectionist
independently
making
maps
territory
though
maps
identical
may
obtain
exclusive
right
make
copies
particular
map
yet
neither
infringe
copyright
likewise
copyrighted
directory
infringed
similar
directory
product
independent
work
copyright
protects
originality
rather
novelty
invention
conferring
sole
right
multiplying
copies
absent
copying
infringement
copyright
thus
respondents
may
exclude
others
using
statuettes
human
figures
table
lamps
may
prevent
use
copies
statuettes
incorporated
article
regulation
supra
makes
clear
artistic
articles
protected
form
mechanical
utilitarian
aspects
see
stein
rosenthal
supp
dichotomy
protection
aesthetic
beauty
utility
art
copyright
invention
original
ornamental
design
design
patents
find
nothing
copyright
statute
support
argument
intended
use
use
industry
article
eligible
copyright
bars
invalidates
registration
read
limitation
copyright
law
think
subsequent
registration
work
art
published
element
manufactured
article
misuse
copyright
different
registration
statuette
later
embodiment
industrial
article
copyright
law
like
patent
statutes
makes
reward
owner
secondary
consideration
paramount
pictures
however
intended
definitely
grant
valuable
enforceable
rights
authors
publishers
without
requirements
afford
greater
encouragement
production
literary
artistic
works
lasting
benefit
world
washingtonian
pearson
affirmed
footnotes
unreported
action
stein
zuckerman
dubeshter
pending
eastern
district
new
york
note
harv
rev
advised
dismissed
consent
february
stein
expert
lamp
stein
expert
lamp
supp
first
action
brought
accident
presentation
trial
determined
case
though
copyright
statuette
lamp
attachments
held
statuettes
copyrightable
evidence
practical
use
intended
petition
reconsideration
held
presence
absence
attachments
immaterial
stein
mazer
supp
rosenthal
stein
appeals
seventh
circuit
affirmed
ground
copyright
act
refer
articles
manufacture
utilitarian
purpose
provide
previous
examination
proper
tribunal
originality
matter
offered
copyright
stein
expert
lamp
stein
rosenthal
supp
second
infringement
case
held
protection
dissipated
taking
unadulterated
object
art
copyrighted
integrating
commercially
valuable
merchandise
appeal
appeals
ninth
circuit
affirmed
saying
theory
use
copyrighted
work
art
loses
status
work
art
put
functional
use
basis
wording
copyright
laws
nothing
laws
excludes
work
art
operation
copyright
laws
rosenthal
stein
stein
benaderet
supp
district
michigan
held
intent
purpose
designer
determines
whether
object
copyrightable
work
art
said
plaintiffs
applied
design
patent
held
defendants
appeal
pending
appeals
sixth
circuit
opinions
cases
district
appeals
present
litigation
deserve
careful
reading
case
register
copyrights
participated
amicus
curiae
supported
respondents
solicitor
general
also
filed
brief
participated
oral
argument
reach
constitutional
questions
raised
parties
chicago
wellman
new
york
ex
rel
rosevale
realty
kleinert
mcadory
fact
issue
mentioned
argument
bring
question
properly
us
herbring
lee
question
jurisdiction
emerges
chicot
county
dist
bank
compare
kalb
feuerstein
continental
illinois
nat
bank
trust
chicago
compare
constitutional
question
following
lithographic
sarony
upheld
copyright
photograph
unanimously
said
writings
clause
meant
literary
productions
authors
congress
properly
declared
include
forms
writing
printing
engraving
etching
ideas
mind
author
given
visible
expression
findings
think
show
photograph
original
work
art
product
plaintiff
intellectual
invention
plaintiff
author
class
inventions
constitution
intended
congress
secure
exclusive
right
use
publish
sell
done
section
revised
statutes
bleistein
donaldson
lithographing
upheld
copyright
circus
posters
said
shall
mention
suggestion
painting
engraving
unless
mechanical
end
among
useful
arts
progress
congress
empowered
constitution
promote
constitution
limit
useful
satisfies
immediate
bodily
needs
personality
always
contains
something
unique
expresses
singularity
even
handwriting
modest
grade
art
something
irreducible
one
man
alone
something
may
copyright
unless
restriction
words
act
kalem
harper
involved
pirating
motion
pictures
copyrighted
dramatic
rights
book
said
argued
law
construed
construed
goes
beyond
power
conferred
upon
congress
constitution
secure
authors
limited
time
exclusive
right
writings
art
cl
suggested
extend
copyright
case
like
extend
ideas
distinguished
words
ideas
clothed
attempt
make
monopoly
ideas
expressed
law
confines
particular
cognate
well
known
form
reproduction
extent
grant
monopoly
thought
proper
way
secure
right
writings
say
congress
wrong
see
also
schreiber
thornton
reversed
grounds
thornton
schreiber
see
fenning
origin
patent
copyright
clause
constitution
geo
story
constitution
ed
xix
cases
congress
passed
act
patent
copyright
clause
unanimous
held
effort
protect
unconstitutional
ordinary
necessary
relation
invention
discovery
endeavor
classify
head
writings
authors
objections
equally
strong
regard
inventions
originality
required
word
writings
may
liberally
construed
include
original
designs
engravings
prints
original
founded
creative
powers
mind
writings
protected
fruits
intellectual
labor
embodied
form
books
prints
engravings
like
depend
upon
novelty
invention
discovery
work
brain
requires
fancy
imagination
genius
laborious
thought
simply
founded
priority
appropriation
see
commerce
robert
commentary
lanham
act
national
licorice
labor
board
general
talking
pictures
western
electric
crown
ferdinand
gutmann
cases
cited
gunning
cooley
policy
incorporated
rule
revised
rules
practice
bringing
additional
questions
case
condemned
recently
irvine
california
ball
law
copyright
literary
property
howell
copyright
law
ladas
international
protection
literary
artistic
property
weil
copyright
law
derenberg
copyright
land
fringe
rights
literary
artistic
property
copyright
problems
analyzed
cch
pogue
borderland
copyright
design
patent
meet
rev
notes
geo
rev
harv
rev
ind
see
report
copyright
committee
board
trade
london
october
artistic
copyright
industrial
designs
et
seq
stat
stat
stat
stat
stat
laws
dealing
copyrights
solberg
copyright
congress
stat
act
also
vested
control
records
relating
copyrights
librarian
congress
provided
administer
law
connection
phrase
act
intended
perfected
works
fine
arts
see
amendatory
act
stat
bleistein
donaldson
lithographing
section
contained
following
provision
construction
act
words
engraving
cut
print
shall
applied
pictorial
illustrations
works
connected
fine
arts
prints
labels
designed
used
articles
manufacture
shall
entered
copyright
law
may
registered
patent
office
repealed
following
enacted
sec
section
act
entitled
act
amend
consolidate
acts
respecting
copyright
approved
march
hereby
amended
read
prints
pictorial
illustrations
including
prints
labels
used
articles
merchandise
stat
amendment
act
stat
noted
however
act
conform
language
present
act
supp
contain
amendatory
language
act
sess
existing
statutes
attempt
specifications
unfortunate
necessarily
imperfect
requiring
frequent
additions
cover
new
forms
new
processes
bill
general
definition
substitutes
general
term
works
author
term
used
constitution
writings
congress
always
construed
term
broadly
uniformly
supported
judicial
decision
instance
interpreted
authorizing
remote
popular
significance
photographs
paintings
statuary
dramas
even
unwritten
thus
interpreted
word
writings
popular
parlance
nearly
represented
word
works
bill
adopts
referring
back
however
word
writings
way
safe
anchorage
regarding
including
forms
record
thought
author
may
recorded
may
read
reproduced
lithographic
sarony
held
photographs
copyrightable
spite
argument
constitution
specified
protection
writings
author
decision
made
clear
writings
limited
chirography
typography
stat
weil
copyright
law
howell
copyright
law
ed
sess
report
clear
point
however
application
registration
shall
specify
following
classes
work
copyright
claimed
belongs
books
including
composite
cyclopaedic
works
directories
gazetteers
compilations
periodicals
including
newspapers
lectures
sermons
addresses
prepared
oral
delivery
dramatic
compositions
musical
compositions
maps
works
art
models
designs
works
art
reproductions
work
art
drawings
plastic
works
scientific
technical
character
photographs
prints
pictorial
illustrations
provided
nevertheless
specifications
shall
held
limit
copyright
defined
section
four
act
shall
error
classification
invalidate
impair
copyright
protection
secured
act
stat
subsection
amended
addition
words
including
prints
labels
used
articles
merchandise
stat
see
note
supra
two
classes
photoplays
motion
pictures
photoplays
added
stat
see
note
supra
repeal
clause
defining
engraving
cuts
prints
terms
fine
art
title
code
entitled
copyrights
codified
positive
law
without
change
pertinent
provisions
stat
supp
female
figure
bearing
urn
front
partly
supported
drapery
around
head
figure
nude
waist
form
concealed
conventionalized
skirt
draperies
flow
forward
forming
tray
base
sides
back
skirt
fluted
form
whole
designed
match
tray
figure
standing
bent
forward
hips
waist
works
art
term
includes
works
belonging
fairly
fine
arts
paintings
drawings
sculpture
productions
industrial
arts
utilitarian
purpose
character
subject
copyright
registration
even
artistically
made
ornamented
rules
regulations
registration
claims
copyright
bulletin
works
art
models
designs
works
art
term
includes
works
belonging
fairly
fine
arts
paintings
drawings
sculpture
protection
productions
industrial
arts
utilitarian
purpose
character
even
artistically
made
ornamented
depends
upon
action
patent
law
registration
copyright
office
made
protect
artistic
drawings
notwithstanding
may
afterwards
utilized
articles
manufacture
cfr
lighting
fixture
design
guitini
bowlshaped
bracket
embellished
figure
woman
standing
bunch
flowers
copyright
december
registration
number
copyright
claimant
kathodion
bronze
works
new
york
great
northern
perry
arguments
committees
patents
senate
house
representatives
conjointly
amend
consolidate
acts
respecting
copyright
june
statement
applicable
act
since
act
identical
sections
although
hearings
reports
see
house
committee
hearings
committee
patents
consolidating
revising
copyright
laws
sess
statement
putnam
explanation
change
statutory
language
though
refers
works
art
new
designation
mentioned
deletion
fine
category
cf
white
morton
converse
son
lithographic
sarony
bleistein
donaldson
lithographing
louis
de
jonge
breuker
kessler
woolworth
contemporary
arts
see
case
yuengling
schile
schumacher
schwencke
pellegrini
allegrini
wheaton
donaldson
peters
grigg
pet
fox
film
doyal
lord
brougham
lord
leonards
jefferys
boosey
iv
eng
two
cases
relied
upon
support
position
petitioners
taylor
instrument
companies
brown
instrument
warner
app
cases
hold
mechanical
patent
law
copyright
laws
mutually
exclusive
overlapping
design
patent
copyright
laws
however
different
answer
given
courts
louis
de
jonge
breuker
kessler
affirmed
grounds
see
also
cases
cited
note
infra
said
new
original
design
manufacture
whether
metal
material
either
worked
article
manufacture
new
original
shape
configuration
article
manufacture
one
law
view
thing
invented
produced
patent
given
gives
peculiar
distinctive
appearance
manufacture
article
may
applied
gives
form
therefore
proposes
secure
limited
time
ingenious
producer
appearances
advantages
flowing
appearance
therefore
matter
agency
caused
constitutes
mainly
entirely
contribution
public
law
deems
worthy
recompense
design
patent
base
table
lamps
fanciful
statuette
girl
standing
front
high
rock
bathing
costume
english
copyright
act
halsbury
statutes
england
ed
protect
designs
registrable
patents
designs
act
registered
designs
act
halsbury
statutes
england
ed
unless
designs
used
intended
used
models
patterns
multiplied
industrial
process
board
trade
ruled
design
shall
deemed
used
model
pattern
multiplied
industrial
process
within
meaning
design
reproduced
intended
reproduced
fifty
single
articles
copyright
industrial
designs
rules
statutory
instruments
see
rosenthal
stein
note
supra
blood
app
korzybski
underwood
underwood
william
meier
glass
anchor
hocking
glass
supp
jones
underkoffler
supp
louis
de
jonge
breuker
kessler
harv
rev
rev
cf
taylor
instrument
companies
see
pogue
borderland
copyright
design
patent
meet
rev
woolworth
contemporary
arts
ansehl
puritan
pharmaceutical
fulmer
cl
supp
muller
triborough
bridge
authority
supp
sampson
murdock
see
anno
jeweler
circular
pub
keystone
publishing
music
pub
apollo
bleistein
donaldson
lithographing
arustein
porter
alfred
bell
catalda
fine
arts
ansehl
puritan
pharmaceutical
supra
christic
cohan
opinion
justice
douglas
justice
black
concurs
important
constitutional
question
underlies
case
question
stirred
oral
argument
treated
briefs
whether
statuettes
dancing
figures
may
copyrighted
congress
provided
works
art
models
designs
works
art
reproductions
work
art
may
copyrighted
holds
statuettes
included
words
works
art
may
statuettes
granted
monopoly
copyright
article
constitution
grants
congress
power
promote
progress
science
useful
arts
securing
limited
times
authors
exclusive
right
respective
writings
power
thus
circumscribed
allows
monopoly
granted
authors
writings
sculptor
author
statue
writing
within
meaning
constitution
never
decided
question
lithographic
sarony
held
photograph
copyrighted
bleistein
donaldson
lithographing
held
chromolithographs
used
advertisements
circus
pictorial
illustrations
within
meaning
copyright
laws
broad
language
used
latter
case
modest
grade
art
something
irreducible
one
man
alone
something
may
copyright
unless
restriction
words
act
constitutional
range
meaning
writings
field
art
issue
either
bleistein
case
woolworth
contemporary
arts
recently
writ
certiorari
limited
question
damages
times
initiative
considered
decided
constitutional
issues
raised
argued
briefed
parties
example
case
continental
bank
rock
island
decided
constitutionality
bankruptcy
act
though
question
noticed
party
decide
question
case
however
pressing
one
urgency
decision
moreover
constitutional
materials
quite
meager
see
fenning
origin
patent
copyright
clause
constitution
geo
much
research
needed
interests
involved
category
works
art
used
copyright
law
considerable
copyright
office
supplied
us
long
list
articles
copyrighted
statuettes
book
ends
clocks
lamps
door
knockers
candlesticks
inkstands
chandeliers
piggy
banks
sundials
salt
pepper
shakers
fish
bowls
casseroles
ash
trays
perhaps
writings
constitutional
sense
least
obviously
time
came
problem
full
face
accordingly
put
case
reargument