moore
illinois
argued
october
decided
december
petitioner
arrested
rape
related
offenses
identified
complaining
witness
assailant
ensuing
preliminary
hearing
petitioner
represented
counsel
offered
appointed
counsel
victim
asked
make
identification
told
going
view
suspect
told
name
heard
called
led
bench
heard
prosecutor
recite
evidence
believed
implicate
petitioner
subsequently
petitioner
indicted
counsel
appointed
moved
suppress
victim
identification
petitioner
illinois
trial
denied
motion
ground
prosecution
shown
independent
basis
victim
identification
trial
victim
testified
direct
examination
prosecution
identified
petitioner
assailant
preliminary
hearing
certain
evidence
linking
petitioner
crimes
convicted
illinois
affirmed
sought
habeas
corpus
relief
federal
district
ground
admission
identification
testimony
trial
violated
sixth
fourteenth
amendment
rights
denied
relief
ground
prosecution
shown
independent
basis
identification
appeals
affirmed
held
petitioner
sixth
amendment
right
counsel
violated
corporeal
identification
conducted
initiation
adversary
judicial
criminal
proceedings
absence
counsel
wade
gilbert
california
difficult
imagine
suggestive
manner
present
suspect
witness
critical
first
confrontation
employed
case
preliminary
hearing
petitioner
represented
counsel
suggestiveness
avoided
prosecution
properly
buttress
introducing
evidence
pretrial
identification
made
violation
petitioner
sixth
amendment
rights
even
prove
pretrial
identification
independent
source
pp
case
remanded
however
determination
whether
failure
exclude
evidence
derived
directly
violation
petitioner
sixth
amendment
right
counsel
harmless
constitutional
error
chapman
california
powell
delivered
opinion
burger
brennan
stewart
white
marshall
rehnquist
joined
rehnquist
filed
concurring
opinion
post
blackmun
filed
opinion
concurring
result
post
stevens
took
part
consideration
decision
case
patrick
hughes
argued
cause
filed
briefs
petitioner
charles
levad
assistant
attorney
general
illinois
argued
cause
respondent
briefs
william
scott
attorney
general
justice
powell
delivered
opinion
petitioner
convicted
rape
related
offenses
trial
complaining
witness
testified
direct
examination
prosecution
identified
petitioner
preliminary
hearing
represented
counsel
state
affirmed
petitioner
convictions
federal
district
appeals
denied
habeas
corpus
relief
granted
certiorari
apparent
conflict
decisions
holdings
respect
right
counsel
corporeal
identifications
wade
gilbert
california
kirby
illinois
reverse
victim
offenses
question
lived
apartment
south
side
chicago
shortly
noon
december
awakened
nap
find
man
standing
doorway
bedroom
holding
knife
man
entered
bedroom
threw
face
bed
choked
quiet
covering
face
bandana
intruder
partially
undressed
victim
forced
commit
oral
sodomy
raped
left
taking
guitar
flute
apartment
police
arrived
victim
gave
description
assailant
although
know
seen
face
seconds
attack
thought
man
made
offensive
remarks
neighborhood
bar
night
also
gave
police
notebook
found
next
bed
attack
week
followed
police
showed
victim
two
groups
photographs
men
first
group
picked
resembled
assailant
height
weight
build
second
group
picked
two
three
one
petitioner
police
also
found
letter
notebook
victim
given
investigation
revealed
written
woman
petitioner
staying
letter
taken
woman
home
absence
petitioner
appeared
person
access
home
evening
december
police
arrested
petitioner
apartment
held
overnight
pending
preliminary
hearing
determine
whether
bound
grand
jury
set
bail
next
morning
policeman
accompanied
victim
circuit
cook
county
first
municipal
district
hearing
policeman
told
going
view
suspect
identify
also
sign
complaint
named
petitioner
assailant
hearing
petitioner
name
called
led
bench
judge
told
petitioner
charged
rape
deviate
sexual
behavior
judge
called
victim
courtroom
waiting
case
called
come
bench
state
attorney
stated
police
found
evidence
linking
petitioner
offenses
charged
asked
victim
whether
saw
assailant
courtroom
pointed
petitioner
state
attorney
requested
continuance
hearing
time
needed
check
fingerprints
judge
granted
continuance
fixed
bail
petitioner
represented
counsel
hearing
offer
appoint
counsel
subsequent
hearing
petitioner
bound
grand
jury
indicted
rape
deviate
sexual
behavior
burglary
robbery
counsel
appointed
moved
suppress
victim
identification
petitioner
elicited
preliminary
hearing
unnecessarily
suggestive
procedure
petitioner
represented
counsel
evidentiary
hearing
trial
denied
motion
ground
prosecution
shown
independent
basis
victim
identification
trial
victim
testified
direct
examination
prosecution
identified
petitioner
assailant
preliminary
hearing
also
testified
defendant
trial
man
raped
prosecution
evidence
linking
petitioner
crimes
letter
found
victim
apartment
defense
counsel
stipulated
petitioner
taken
letter
woman
friend
home
presented
evidence
petitioner
might
lost
notebook
containing
letter
neighborhood
bar
night
attack
defense
theory
victim
also
bar
night
picked
notebook
mistake
taken
home
defense
also
called
witnesses
testified
petitioner
college
lunchroom
another
part
chicago
time
attack
committed
jury
found
petitioner
guilty
four
counts
thus
rejecting
theory
alibi
trial
sentenced
years
prison
illinois
affirmed
people
moore
rejected
petitioner
argument
victim
identification
testimony
excluded
ground
prosecution
shown
independent
basis
identification
denied
certiorari
petitioner
sought
writ
habeas
corpus
federal
district
contended
admission
identification
testimony
trial
violated
sixth
fourteenth
amendment
rights
relying
transcript
state
proceedings
district
denied
writ
unpublished
opinion
ground
prosecution
shown
independent
basis
identification
app
appeals
seventh
circuit
affirmed
unpublished
opinion
ex
rel
moore
illinois
granted
certiorari
ii
wade
held
pretrial
corporeal
identification
conducted
suspect
indicated
critical
stage
criminal
prosecution
sixth
amendment
entitles
accused
presence
counsel
emphasized
dangers
inherent
pretrial
identification
conducted
absence
counsel
persons
conduct
identification
procedure
may
suggest
intentionally
unintentionally
expect
witness
identify
accused
suggestion
coming
police
officer
prosecutor
lead
witness
make
mistaken
identification
witness
predisposed
adhere
identification
subsequent
testimony
trial
accused
counsel
present
pretrial
identification
serve
client
prosecution
interests
objecting
suggestive
features
procedure
influence
witness
identification
view
variables
pitfalls
exist
uncounseled
pretrial
identification
wade
reasoned
first
line
defense
must
prevention
unfairness
lessening
hazards
eyewitness
identification
lineup
trial
might
determine
accused
fate
may
well
courtroom
pretrial
confrontation
state
aligned
accused
witness
sole
jury
accused
unprotected
overreaching
intentional
unintentional
little
effective
appeal
judgment
rendered
witness
man
gilbert
differed
wade
one
critical
respect
gilbert
prosecution
elicit
testimony
witnesses
identified
accused
uncounselled
pretrial
lineup
recognized
testimony
enhance
impact
witness
identification
jury
seriously
aggravate
whatever
derogation
exists
accused
right
fair
trial
hat
testimony
direct
result
illegal
lineup
come
exploitation
primary
illegality
wong
sun
prosecution
entitled
opportunity
show
testimony
independent
source
see
also
wade
supra
announced
exclusionary
rule
belief
sanction
necessary
assure
law
enforcement
authorities
respect
accused
constitutional
right
presence
counsel
critical
lineup
gilbert
supra
therefore
reversed
conviction
remanded
state
determination
whether
admission
evidence
harmless
constitutional
error
chapman
california
kirby
illinois
plurality
opinion
made
clear
right
counsel
announced
wade
gilbert
attaches
corporeal
identifications
conducted
initiation
adversary
judicial
criminal
proceedings
whether
way
formal
charge
preliminary
hearing
indictment
information
arraignment
initiation
proceedings
marks
commencement
criminal
prosecutions
alone
explicit
guarantees
sixth
amendment
applicable
thus
kirby
plurality
held
prosecution
evidence
robbery
victim
stationhouse
identification
uncounseled
suspect
shortly
suspect
arrest
admissible
adversary
judicial
criminal
proceedings
yet
initiated
cases
however
due
process
protects
accused
introduction
evidence
tainted
unreliable
pretrial
identifications
obtained
unnecessarily
suggestive
procedures
neil
biggers
stovall
denno
see
generally
manson
brathwaite
iii
instant
case
petitioner
argues
preliminary
hearing
victim
identified
marked
initiation
adversary
judicial
criminal
proceedings
hence
wade
gilbert
kirby
entitled
presence
counsel
confrontation
moreover
prosecution
introduced
evidence
uncounseled
corporeal
identification
trial
petitioner
contends
gilbert
evidence
excluded
without
regard
whether
independent
source
appeals
took
different
view
case
read
kirby
holding
evidence
corporeal
identification
conducted
absence
defense
counsel
must
excluded
identification
made
defendant
indicted
app
reading
squared
kirby
held
accused
rights
wade
gilbert
attach
identifications
conducted
initiation
adversary
judicial
criminal
proceedings
including
proceedings
instituted
way
formal
charge
preliminary
hearing
prosecution
case
commenced
illinois
law
victim
complaint
filed
see
rev
ch
purpose
preliminary
hearing
determine
whether
probable
cause
bind
petitioner
grand
jury
set
bail
petitioner
right
oppose
prosecution
hearing
moving
dismiss
charges
suppress
evidence
faced
counsel
state
elicited
victim
identification
summarized
state
evidence
petitioner
urged
state
given
time
marshal
evidence
plain
government
ha
committed
prosecute
petitioner
found
faced
prosecutorial
forces
organized
society
immersed
intricacies
substantive
procedural
criminal
law
kirby
supra
state
candidly
concedes
preliminary
hearing
marked
initiation
adversary
judicial
criminal
proceedings
petitioner
brief
respondent
tr
oral
arg
hardly
contend
otherwise
appeals
therefore
erred
holding
petitioner
rights
wade
gilbert
yet
attached
time
preliminary
hearing
appeals
also
suggested
wade
gilbert
apply
identification
hardly
considered
app
meaning
statement
entirely
clear
meant
identification
procedure
distinguished
lineup
subject
counsel
requirement
mistaken
although
wade
gilbert
involved
lineups
wade
clearly
contemplated
counsel
required
situations
pretrial
confrontation
purpose
identification
may
take
form
lineup
presentation
suspect
alone
witness
obvious
risks
suggestion
attend
either
form
confrontation
see
also
white
dissenting
part
concurring
part
cf
stovall
denno
supra
kirby
illinois
indeed
confrontation
generally
thought
present
greater
risks
mistaken
identification
lineup
wall
identification
criminal
cases
williams
hammelmann
identification
parades
crim
rev
reason
hold
identification
procedure
subject
requirements
lineup
believed
petitioner
right
counsel
identification
procedure
conducted
course
judicial
proceeding
agree
reasons
supporting
wade
holding
corporeal
identification
critical
stage
criminal
prosecution
sixth
amendment
purposes
apply
equal
force
identification
difficult
imagine
suggestive
manner
present
suspect
witness
critical
first
confrontation
employed
case
victim
seen
assailant
seconds
asked
make
identification
told
going
view
suspect
told
name
heard
called
led
bench
heard
prosecutor
recite
evidence
believed
implicate
petitioner
petitioner
represented
counsel
suggestiveness
avoided
sum
unpersuaded
reasons
advanced
appeals
distinguishing
identification
procedure
case
considered
wade
gilbert
cases
petitioner
sixth
amendment
rights
violated
corporeal
identification
conducted
initiation
adversary
judicial
criminal
proceedings
absence
counsel
courts
thought
victim
testimony
trial
identified
petitioner
uncounseled
pretrial
confrontation
admissible
even
petitioner
rights
violated
independent
source
victim
identification
uncounseled
confrontation
app
district
appeals
gilbert
held
prosecution
buttress
introducing
evidence
pretrial
identification
made
violation
accused
sixth
amendment
rights
even
prove
pretrial
identification
independent
source
testimony
direct
result
illegal
lineup
come
exploitation
primary
illegality
gilbert
prosecution
therefore
entitled
opportunity
show
testimony
independent
source
prosecution
made
use
testimony
case
petitioner
entitled
benefit
strict
rule
gilbert
iv
view
violation
petitioner
sixth
fourteenth
amendment
right
counsel
pretrial
corporeal
identification
prosecution
exploitation
trial
evidence
derived
directly
violation
reverse
judgment
appeals
remand
determination
whether
failure
exclude
evidence
harmless
constitutional
error
chapman
california
see
gilbert
supra
also
free
remand
issues
presented
petition
upon
pass
reversed
remanded
footnotes
among
factors
considered
making
determination
prior
opportunity
observe
alleged
criminal
act
existence
discrepancy
description
defendant
actual
description
identification
prior
lineup
another
person
identification
picture
defendant
prior
lineup
failure
identify
defendant
prior
occasion
lapse
time
alleged
act
lineup
identification
ash
held
sixth
amendment
require
defense
counsel
present
witness
views
police
prosecution
photographic
arrays
photographic
showing
unlike
corporeal
identification
adversary
confrontation
accused
agents
government
hence
possibility
arises
accused
might
misled
lack
familiarity
law
overpowered
professional
adversary
moreover
even
without
attending
prosecution
photographic
showing
defense
counsel
equal
chance
prepare
trial
presenting
photographic
displays
witnesses
trial
uplication
defense
counsel
safeguard
normally
available
formal
confrontation
occurs
accused
nevertheless
entitled
due
process
protection
introduction
evidence
tainted
unreliable
identifications
elicited
unnecessarily
suggestive
photographic
displays
manson
brathwaite
simmons
immediately
state
attorney
asked
victim
identify
petitioner
stated
allegation
rape
deviate
sexual
assault
home
invasion
apartment
hyde
park
victim
raped
forced
commit
oral
copulation
taken
guitar
instruments
defendant
arrested
upon
arrest
warrant
signed
judge
articles
guitar
instruments
found
apartment
clothes
described
man
attacked
day
app
example
counsel
requested
hearing
postponed
lineup
arranged
victim
view
petitioner
less
suggestive
setting
see
ravich
cert
denied
mason
app
short
counsel
asked
victim
excused
courtroom
charges
read
evidence
petitioner
recited
petitioner
seated
people
audience
victim
attempted
identification
see
allen
rhay
cert
denied
counsel
might
sought
victim
test
identification
hardened
cf
haberstroh
montanye
ex
rel
riffert
rundle
cert
denied
sub
nom
riffert
johnson
prosecution
interest
well
accused
witnesses
identifications
remain
untainted
see
wade
assume
requests
vain
requests
ordinarily
addressed
sound
discretion
see
ravich
supra
express
opinion
whether
preliminary
hearing
required
grant
requests
existence
independent
source
thought
demonstrated
victim
selection
picture
petitioner
second
photographic
array
courts
parties
certain
many
pictures
victim
actually
selected
array
although
ambiguity
record
compare
trial
transcript
think
fair
reading
indicates
victim
selected
one
photograph
make
positive
identification
petitioner
resolution
factual
issue
necessary
decision
case
addition
gilbert
argument
petitioner
urges
victim
identification
tainted
prior
uncounseled
identification
see
wade
identification
unreliable
product
unnecessarily
suggestive
identification
procedure
excluded
due
process
clause
fourteenth
amendment
see
manson
brathwaite
trial
denial
transcript
preliminary
hearing
prejudicial
constitutional
error
see
roberts
lavallee
justice
rehnquist
concurring
held
certain
limited
circumstances
statement
given
police
persistent
questioning
suppressed
trial
suspect
repeatedly
requested
denied
opportunity
consult
attorney
escobedo
illinois
time
intimations
ruling
rested
largely
sixth
amendment
guarantee
right
counsel
critical
stages
criminal
proceeding
shortly
thereafter
however
perceived
prime
purpose
escobedo
vindicate
constitutional
right
counsel
like
miranda
guarantee
full
effectuation
privilege
johnson
new
jersey
kirby
illinois
stewart
cf
darwin
connecticut
accordingly
escobedo
largely
limited
facts
see
johnson
new
jersey
kirby
illinois
supra
frazier
cupp
michigan
tucker
course
left
open
possibility
examining
voluntariness
confession
appropriate
standard
totality
circumstances
cf
clewis
texas
believe
time
come
reconsider
rule
many
reasons
rule
established
ensure
accuracy
reliability
pretrial
identifications
decide
whether
per
se
exclusionary
rule
still
apply
whether
violations
like
questions
involving
reliability
pretrial
identification
judged
totality
circumstances
cf
manson
brathwaite
cf
kirby
illinois
supra
simmons
stovall
denno
however
since
state
chosen
press
point
believe
opinion
correct
reading
wade
gilbert
concur
opinion
judgment
wade
gilbert
california
justice
blackmun
concurring
result
concur
result
join
remanding
case
determination
whether
adjudged
error
harmless
record
case
conclusion
harmless
seems
almost
inevitable
however
courts
decide
first
instance
feel
furthermore
opinion
made
case
facts
warrant
points
ante
state
illinois
conceded
brief
respondent
tr
oral
arg
preliminary
hearing
december
victim
testified
initiation
adversary
judicial
criminal
proceedings
petitioner
trial
victim
testified
hearing
identified
petitioner
assailant
ban
gilbert
california
applies
full
force
require
remand
orders
state
concession
see
need
wrestle
issue
whether
took
place
december
marked
initiation
formal
proceedings
petitioner
sense
kirby
illinois
thereby
possibly
become
entangled
ghost
unmentioned
holding
coleman
alabama
determined
retroactive
adams
illinois
one
last
word
disassociate
implication
twice
appearing
opinion
ante
something
insignificant
unreliable
rape
victim
observation
crime
facial
features
assailant
observation
lasts
seconds
time
course
always
comparative
matter
fifteen
seconds
perhaps
mean
little
identification
scores
separate
individuals
participating
illegal
riot
seconds
observation
face
rapist
midday
female
victim
commission
crime
means
insufficient
leave
accurate
indelible
impression
victim
one
need
observe
another
person
face
seconds
clock
know
resisting
woman
seconds
seem
endless
female
victim
rape
given
period
daylight
observation
ever
believe
otherwise
therefore
party
degradation
almost
literal
dismissal
vital
observation