rooker
fidelity
trust
argued
decided
december
wm
rooker
indianapolis
appellants
opposition
motion
charles
cox
indianapolis
appellees
support
motion
justice
van
devanter
delivered
opinion
bill
equity
judgment
circuit
indiana
affirmed
state
declared
null
void
obtain
relief
dependent
outcome
effort
judgment
reviewed
writ
error
failed
record
disclose
presence
question
constituting
basis
review
rooker
fidelity
trust
sup
parties
bill
litigation
state
addition
two
defendants
whose
presence
need
special
notice
citizens
state
grounds
advanced
resorting
district
judgment
rendered
affirmed
contravention
contract
clause
constitution
article
cl
due
process
law
equal
protection
clauses
fourteenth
amendment
section
gave
effect
state
statute
alleged
conflict
clauses
give
effect
prior
decision
cause
state
alleged
become
case
district
opinion
suit
within
jurisdiction
defined
congress
ground
dismissed
bill
plaintiffs
appealed
directly
section
judicial
code
comp
appellees
move
appeal
dismissed
alternative
decree
affirmed
appeal
within
first
clause
section
motion
dismiss
must
overruled
suit
plainly
within
district
juridiction
defined
congress
motion
affirm
must
sustained
affirmatively
appears
bill
judgment
rendered
cause
wherein
circuit
jurisdiction
matter
parties
full
hearing
therein
judgment
responsive
issues
affirmed
state
appeal
plaintiffs
constitutional
questions
stated
bill
actually
arose
cause
province
duty
state
courts
decide
decision
whether
right
wrong
exercise
jurisdiction
decision
wrong
make
judgment
void
merely
left
open
reversal
modification
appropriate
timely
appellate
proceeding
unless
reversed
modified
effective
conclusive
adjudication
elliott
peirsol
pet
thompson
tolmie
pet
voorhees
bank
pet
cornett
williams
wall
ex
parte
harding
sup
legislation
congress
entertain
proceeding
reverse
modify
judgment
errors
character
judicial
code
amended
act
stat
comp
exercise
appellate
jurisdiction
jurisdiction
possessed
district
courts
strictly
original
judicial
code
comp
besides
period
within
proceeding
might
begun
correction
errors
charged
bill
expired
filed
act
stat
comp
pointed
voorhees
bank
supra
period
elapses
aggrieved
litigant
permitted
indirectly
longer
directly
parts
bill
speak
judgment
given
without
jurisdiction
absolutely
void
merely
mistaken
characterization
reading
entire
bill
shows
indubitably
full
jurisdiction
state
courts
bill
best
merely
attempt
get
rid
judgment
alleged
errors
law
committed
exercise
jurisdiction
said
proceeded
assumption
constitutional
questions
alleged
arisen
state
courts
respecting
validity
state
statute
acts
effect
given
prior
decision
cause
state
ind
questions
substance
hold
assumption
indulged
merely
purpose
testing
nature
bill
power
district
entertain
matter
calls
brief
notice
bill
charges
judgment
affirmance
state
void
one
judges
participating
therein
interest
case
worked
disqualification
case
related
duties
obligations
corporation
holding
property
conventional
trust
facts
set
forth
show
disqualification
follows
three
four
years
theretofore
citizen
state
executed
wherein
designated
judge
one
executors
trustees
testator
died
time
case
submitted
admitted
probate
day
two
judgment
affirmance
judge
became
executor
trustee
designation
executed
time
death
testator
owned
many
shares
stock
corporations
holding
property
trusts
like
question
stock
pass
pass
executors
trustees
administration
disposal
judge
relation
prospective
relation
estate
stocks
belonging
sole
basis
charge
disqualifying
interest
case
think
facts
set
forth
relied
upon
neither
support
tend
support
charge
experience
difficulty
reconciling
presence
bill
care
good
faith
attend
preparation
pleading
certainly
charge
change
nature
bill
require
given
effect
otherwise
decree
affirmed