pennsylvania
public
welfare
dept
davenport
argued
february
decided
may
respondents
pleaded
guilty
welfare
fraud
ordered
pennsylvania
condition
probation
make
monthly
restitution
payments
petitioner
county
probation
department
petitioner
state
welfare
department
subsequently
respondents
filed
petition
chapter
bankruptcy
code
bankruptcy
listing
restitution
obligation
unsecured
debt
probation
department
commenced
probation
violation
proceeding
state
alleging
respondents
failed
comply
restitution
order
respondents
filed
adversary
action
bankruptcy
seeking
declaration
restitution
obligation
dischargeable
debt
injunction
preventing
probation
department
undertaking
efforts
collect
obligation
bankruptcy
held
obligation
unsecured
debt
dischargeable
chapter
district
reversed
relying
kelly
robinson
held
restitution
obligations
nondischargeable
chapter
proceedings
fall
within
code
exception
discharge
debt
government
fine
penalty
forfeiture
compensation
actual
pecuniary
loss
district
emphasized
dicta
kelly
congress
intend
make
criminal
penalties
debts
code
also
emphasized
federalism
concerns
implicated
federal
courts
intrude
state
criminal
proceedings
appeals
reversed
held
code
language
structure
demonstrate
restitution
obligations
constitute
debts
within
meaning
therefore
dischargeable
chapter
pp
section
definition
debt
liability
claim
reveals
congress
intent
meanings
debt
claim
coextensive
furthermore
definition
claim
right
payment
broadly
contemplates
enforceable
obligation
debtor
including
restitution
order
petitioners
reliance
kelly
discussion
emphasizing
special
purposes
punishment
rehabilitation
underlie
imposition
restitution
obligations
misplaced
unlike
explicitly
ties
application
purpose
compensation
makes
reference
objectives
state
seeks
serve
imposing
obligation
probation
department
enforcement
mechanism
criminal
rather
civil
also
alter
restitution
order
character
right
payment
indeed
may
make
right
greater
conferred
ordinary
civil
obligation
since
secured
debtor
freedom
rather
property
pp
code
provisions
reflect
congressional
intent
exempt
restitution
orders
chapter
discharge
section
removes
criminal
prosecutions
debtor
operation
code
automatic
stay
provision
inconsistent
granting
sanctuary
restitution
orders
chapter
congress
well
concluded
maintaining
criminal
prosecutions
bankruptcy
proceedings
essential
functioning
government
debtor
interest
full
complete
release
obligations
outweighs
society
interest
collecting
enforcing
restitution
obligation
outside
agreement
reached
chapter
plan
must
effect
establishes
order
settlement
claims
plans
assigning
low
priority
claim
fine
penalty
forfeiture
construed
apply
civil
fines
criminal
restitution
orders
order
assure
governments
receive
disfavored
treatment
relative
creditors
construction
conflicts
kelly
holding
quoted
phrase
used
applies
criminal
restitution
obligations
also
highlights
tension
kelly
interpretation
dictum
suggesting
restitution
obligations
debts
congress
believed
obligations
debts
giving
rise
claims
reason
except
obligations
discharge
mere
surplusage
moreover
kelly
faithful
language
structure
code
congress
defined
debt
broadly
carefully
excepted
particular
debts
discharge
policy
considerations
warranted
thus
securing
broader
discharge
debtors
chapter
chapter
congress
chose
extend
exception
chapter
thus
override
balance
congress
struck
crafting
appropriate
discharge
exceptions
construe
debt
narrowly
context
pp
holding
signal
retreat
principles
applied
kelly
code
read
erode
past
bankruptcy
practice
absent
clear
indication
congress
intended
departure
however
congressional
intent
clear
function
enforce
statute
according
terms
even
means
concluding
congress
intended
interfere
administration
criminal
justice
systems
pp
marshall
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
brennan
white
stevens
scalia
kennedy
joined
blackmun
filed
dissenting
opinion
joined
post
walter
cohen
first
deputy
attorney
general
pennsylvania
argued
cause
petitioners
briefs
ernest
preate
attorney
general
john
knorr
iii
chief
deputy
attorney
general
calvin
koons
senior
deputy
attorney
general
mary
benefield
seiverling
deputy
attorney
general
david
searles
argued
cause
respondents
briefs
eric
frank
henry
sommer
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
solicitor
general
starr
assistant
attorneys
general
dennis
gerson
deputy
solicitor
general
roberts
stephen
nightingale
state
alabama
et
al
mary
sue
terry
attorney
general
virginia
lane
kneedler
chief
deputy
attorney
general
walter
mcfarlane
deputy
attorney
general
jeffrey
spencer
assistant
attorney
general
siegelman
attorney
general
alabama
robert
corbin
attorney
general
arizona
john
van
de
kamp
attorney
general
california
clarine
nardi
riddle
acting
attorney
general
connecticut
john
kelly
chief
attorney
charles
oberly
iii
attorney
general
delaware
robert
butterworth
attorney
general
florida
james
jones
attorney
general
idaho
neil
hartigan
attorney
general
illinois
linley
pearson
attorney
general
indiana
thomas
miller
attorney
general
iowa
robert
stephan
attorney
general
kansas
frederic
cowan
attorney
general
kentucky
william
guste
attorney
general
louisiana
james
tierney
attorney
general
maine
james
shannon
attorney
general
massachusetts
joseph
curran
attorney
general
maryland
frank
kelley
attorney
general
michigan
hubert
humphrey
iii
attorney
general
minnesota
william
webster
attorney
general
missouri
mare
racicot
attorney
general
montana
john
arnold
attorney
general
new
hampshire
peter
perretti
attorney
general
new
jersey
hal
stratton
attorney
general
new
mexico
lacy
thornburg
attorney
general
north
carolina
nicholas
spaeth
attorney
general
north
dakota
anthony
celebrezze
attorney
general
ohio
dave
frohnmayer
attorney
general
oregon
jorge
solicitor
general
puerto
rico
travis
medlock
attorney
general
south
carolina
roger
tellinghuisen
attorney
general
south
dakota
charles
burson
attorney
general
tennessee
paul
van
dam
attorney
general
utah
jeffrey
amestoy
attorney
general
vermont
godfrey
de
castro
attorney
general
virgin
islands
joseph
meyer
attorney
general
wyoming
council
state
governments
et
al
benna
ruth
solomon
thomas
goldberg
washington
legal
foundation
et
al
daniel
popeo
paul
kamenar
richard
samp
justice
marshall
delivered
opinion
kelly
robinson
held
restitution
obligations
imposed
conditions
probation
state
criminal
actions
nondischargeable
proceedings
chapter
bankruptcy
code
et
seq
rested
holding
interpretation
code
provision
protects
discharge
debt
fine
penalty
forfeiture
payable
benefit
governmental
unit
compensation
actual
pecuniary
loss
determined
restitution
orders
fall
within
exception
discharge
declined
reach
question
whether
restitution
orders
debt
defined
code
case
must
decide
whether
restitution
obligations
dischargeable
debts
proceedings
chapter
et
seq
exception
discharge
relied
kelly
extend
chapter
conclude
based
language
structure
code
restitution
obligations
debt
defined
therefore
hold
payments
dischargeable
chapter
september
respondents
edward
debora
davenport
pleaded
guilty
pennsylvania
welfare
fraud
sentenced
one
year
probation
condition
probation
state
ordered
davenports
make
monthly
restitution
payments
county
probation
department
turn
forward
payments
pennsylvania
department
public
welfare
victim
davenports
fraud
pennsylvania
law
mandates
restitution
welfare
payments
obtained
fraud
stat
tit
purdon
supp
directs
probation
section
forward
victim
property
payments
made
pursuant
restitution
order
cons
stat
may
davenports
filed
petition
chapter
bankruptcy
eastern
district
pennsylvania
chapter
statement
listed
restitution
obligation
unsecured
debt
payable
department
public
welfare
soon
thereafter
adult
probation
parole
department
bucks
county
probation
department
commenced
probation
violation
proceeding
alleging
davenports
failed
comply
restitution
order
davenports
informed
probation
department
pending
bankruptcy
proceedings
requested
department
withdraw
probation
violation
charges
bankruptcy
issues
settled
probation
department
refused
davenports
filed
adversary
action
bankruptcy
seeking
declaration
restitution
obligation
dischargeable
debt
injunction
preventing
probation
department
undertaking
efforts
collect
obligation
adversary
action
pending
bankruptcy
confirmed
davenports
chapter
plan
without
objection
creditor
although
notified
proceedings
neither
probation
department
department
public
welfare
filed
proof
claim
bankruptcy
action
meanwhile
probation
department
proceeded
state
motion
revoke
probation
although
declined
revoke
davenports
probation
extended
payment
period
nonetheless
ruled
restitution
order
remained
effect
bankruptcy
subsequently
held
davenports
restitution
obligation
unsecured
debt
dischargeable
ed
appeal
district
reversed
holding
criminal
restitution
obligations
discharged
chapter
bankruptcy
ed
district
emphasized
federalism
concerns
implicated
federal
courts
intrude
state
criminal
processes
relied
substantially
dicta
kelly
supra
expressed
serious
doubts
whether
congress
intended
make
criminal
penalties
debts
code
appeals
third
circuit
reversed
concluding
plain
language
chapter
demonstrated
restitution
orders
debts
within
meaning
code
hence
dischargeable
proceedings
chapter
address
conflict
among
bankruptcy
courts
issue
granted
certiorari
ii
construction
term
debt
guided
fundamental
canon
statutory
interpretation
begins
language
statute
landreth
timber
landreth
section
bankruptcy
code
defines
debt
liability
claim
definition
reveals
congress
intent
meanings
debt
claim
coextensive
see
also
thus
meaning
claim
crucial
analysis
claim
right
payment
whether
right
reduced
judgment
liquidated
unliquidated
fixed
contingent
matured
unmatured
disputed
undisputed
legal
equitable
secured
unsecured
emphasis
added
apparent
congress
chose
expansive
language
definitions
relevant
case
example
extent
phrase
right
payment
modified
statute
modifying
language
whether
right
reflects
congress
broad
rather
restrictive
view
class
obligations
qualify
claim
giving
rise
debt
see
also
supra
describing
definition
claim
broadest
possible
noting
code
contemplates
legal
obligations
debtor
able
dealt
bankruptcy
case
accord
supra
petitioners
maintain
restitution
order
right
payment
neither
probation
department
victim
stands
traditional
relationship
criminal
offender
support
position
petitioners
refer
kelly
discussion
special
purposes
punishment
rehabilitation
underlying
imposition
restitution
obligations
petitioners
also
emphasize
restitution
orders
enforced
differently
obligations
considered
rights
payment
kelly
decided
restitution
orders
fall
within
exception
discharge
provision
protects
discharge
debt
extent
debt
fine
penalty
forfeiture
payable
benefit
governmental
unit
compensation
actual
pecuniary
loss
reaching
conclusion
necessarily
found
orders
compensation
actual
pecuniary
loss
rather
ecause
criminal
proceedings
focus
state
interests
rehabilitation
punishment
held
restitution
orders
imposed
proceedings
operate
benefit
state
compensation
victim
contrary
petitioners
argument
however
prior
characterization
purposes
underlying
restitution
orders
bear
construction
phrase
right
payment
kelly
analyzed
purposes
restitution
construing
qualifying
clauses
explicitly
tie
application
provision
purpose
compensation
required
language
employed
define
claim
makes
reference
purpose
plain
meaning
right
payment
nothing
less
enforceable
obligation
regardless
objectives
state
seeks
serve
imposing
obligation
state
method
enforcing
restitution
obligations
suggest
obligations
claims
although
neither
probation
department
victim
enforce
restitution
obligations
civil
proceedings
commonwealth
mourar
super
vacated
remanded
grounds
obligation
enforceable
substantial
threat
revocation
probation
incarceration
probation
department
enforcement
mechanism
criminal
rather
civil
alter
restitution
order
character
right
payment
indeed
right
created
order
made
condition
probation
sense
greater
right
conferred
ordinary
civil
obligation
secured
debtor
freedom
rather
property
accordingly
regard
purpose
enforcement
mechanism
restitution
orders
placing
orders
outside
scope
iii
moving
beyond
language
appearing
amicus
support
petitioners
contends
provisions
code
particularly
exemption
automatic
stay
provision
chapter
distribution
claims
provision
reflect
congress
intent
exempt
restitution
orders
discharge
chapter
persuaded
however
language
structure
code
whole
supports
conclusion
section
automatically
stays
wide
array
collection
enforcement
proceedings
debtor
property
section
exempts
stay
commencement
continuation
criminal
action
proceeding
debtor
according
senate
report
exception
automatic
stay
ensures
bankruptcy
laws
criminal
offenders
supra
section
however
explicitly
exempt
governmental
efforts
collect
restitution
obligations
debtor
cf
collection
alimony
maintenance
support
barred
stay
nonetheless
argues
anomalous
construe
code
eliminating
criminal
offenders
automatic
stay
provision
granting
sanctuary
restitution
obligations
chapter
find
inconsistency
provisions
section
ensures
automatic
stay
provision
construed
bar
federal
state
prosecution
alleged
criminal
offenses
irrational
inconsistent
policy
choice
permit
prosecution
criminal
offenses
pendency
bankruptcy
action
time
preclude
probation
officials
enforcing
restitution
orders
debtor
seeks
relief
chapter
congress
well
concluded
maintaining
criminal
prosecutions
bankruptcy
proceedings
essential
functioning
government
context
chapter
debtor
interest
full
complete
release
obligations
outweighs
society
interest
collecting
enforcing
restitution
obligation
outside
agreement
reached
chapter
plan
reliance
likewise
unavailing
section
establishes
order
claims
settled
chapter
section
assigns
low
priority
allowed
claim
whether
secured
unsecured
fine
penalty
forfeiture
extent
fine
penalty
forfeiture
damages
compensation
actual
pecuniary
loss
suffered
holder
claim
argues
phrase
fine
penalty
forfeiture
construed
apply
civil
fines
penalties
forfeitures
criminal
restitution
obligations
otherwise
state
federal
governments
receive
disfavored
treatment
relative
creditors
chapter
chapter
proceedings
see
chapter
plan
must
ensure
unsecured
creditors
receive
worse
treatment
chapter
result
regards
anomalous
given
strength
governmental
interest
collecting
restitution
payments
central
difficulty
construction
conflicts
kelly
holding
exception
discharge
provision
applies
criminal
restitution
obligations
creates
broad
exception
penal
sanctions
acknowledges
phrase
fine
penalty
forfeiture
appears
must
meaning
unwilling
revisit
kelly
determination
protects
traditional
criminal
fines
codif
ying
judicially
created
exception
discharge
fines
ibid
emphasis
added
thus
reject
view
implicitly
refer
civil
fines
penalties
position
highlights
tension
kelly
interpretation
dictum
suggesting
restitution
obligations
debts
see
supra
stated
kelly
found
explicitly
codifies
judicially
created
exception
discharge
civil
criminal
fines
congress
believed
restitution
obligations
debts
giving
rise
claims
reason
except
obligations
discharge
given
kelly
interpretation
anomalous
construe
debt
narrowly
exclude
criminal
restitution
orders
narrow
construction
debt
necessarily
renders
codification
judicial
exception
criminal
restitution
orders
mere
surplusage
cases
express
deep
reluctance
interpret
statutory
provision
render
superfluous
provisions
enactment
see
mackey
lanier
collection
agency
service
moreover
locating
congress
policy
choice
regarding
dischargeability
restitution
orders
kelly
faithful
language
structure
code
congress
defined
debt
broadly
took
care
except
particular
debts
discharge
policy
considerations
warranted
accordingly
congress
secured
broader
discharge
debtors
chapter
chapter
extending
chapter
proceedings
exceptions
discharge
see
collier
bankruptcy
ed
dischargeability
debts
chapter
dischargeable
chapter
represents
policy
judgment
preferable
debtors
attempt
pay
debts
best
abilities
three
years
rather
debtors
debts
hanging
heads
indefinitely
perhaps
rest
lives
omitted
among
exceptions
congress
chose
extend
chapter
proceedings
exception
debts
arising
fine
penalty
forfeiture
thus
construe
debt
narrowly
context
override
balance
congress
struck
crafting
appropriate
discharge
exceptions
chapter
chapter
debtors
iv
refusal
carve
broad
judicial
exception
discharge
restitution
orders
signal
retreat
principles
applied
kelly
read
bankruptcy
code
erode
past
bankruptcy
practice
absent
clear
indication
congress
intended
departure
kelly
supra
citing
midlantic
national
bank
new
jersey
dept
environmental
protection
kelly
examined
practice
identified
general
reluctance
interpret
federal
bankruptcy
statutes
remit
state
criminal
judgments
practice
informed
conclusion
broadly
applies
penal
sanctions
including
criminal
fines
hand
statutory
language
plainly
reveals
congress
intent
except
restitution
orders
discharge
certain
chapter
proceedings
intent
clear
congress
decision
limit
exceptions
discharge
applicable
chapter
well
adoption
broadest
possible
definition
debt
see
supra
conclude
lightly
congress
intended
interfere
administration
criminal
justice
systems
younger
harris
stated
kelly
permitting
discharge
criminal
restitution
obligations
may
hamper
flexibility
state
criminal
judges
fashioning
appropriate
sentences
require
state
prosecutors
participate
federal
bankruptcy
proceedings
safeguard
state
interests
certainly
legitimate
state
interest
avoiding
intrusions
lessened
simply
offender
files
chapter
rather
chapter
nonetheless
concerns
animating
younger
justify
rewriting
code
avoid
federal
intrusion
congressional
intent
clear
sole
function
enforce
statute
according
terms
restitution
obligations
constitute
debts
within
meaning
bankruptcy
code
therefore
dischargeable
chapter
decision
appeals
affirmed
ordered
footnotes
compare
kohr
md
restitution
obligations
debts
within
meaning
code
cullens
restitution
orders
debts
although
automatic
stay
protects
debtor
various
collection
efforts
specified
period
extinguish
discharge
debt
see
generally
norton
bankruptcy
law
practice
supp
event
government
contention
congress
must
intended
favor
criminal
opposed
civil
claims
held
government
unsubstantiated
view
wisdom
policy
choice
unsupported
textual
authority
congress
fact
adopted
policy
inadequate
basis
rejecting
statute
broad
definition
debt
see
supra
justice
blackmun
justice
joins
dissenting
today
concludes
congress
intended
obligation
pay
restitution
imposed
part
state
criminal
sentence
debt
within
meaning
bankruptcy
code
congress
given
clear
indication
intended
abrogate
long
history
bankruptcy
deference
criminal
judgments
kelly
robinson
suggestion
bankruptcy
code
may
used
shield
protect
criminal
punishment
crime
must
disagree
carefully
set
forth
method
statutory
analysis
bankruptcy
code
see
kelly
supra
see
also
midlantic
national
bank
new
jersey
dept
environmental
protection
analyzing
bankruptcy
statute
course
looks
plain
language
warned
overly
literal
interpretation
bankruptcy
code
must
guided
single
sentence
member
sentence
look
provisions
whole
law
object
policy
kelly
quoting
opinions
heirs
boisdore
strict
language
bankruptcy
code
control
even
statutory
language
plain
meaning
application
language
produce
result
demonstrably
odds
intention
drafters
ron
pair
enterprises
determine
drafters
intent
presumes
congress
intended
keep
continuity
judicial
practice
enactment
bankruptcy
code
midlantic
statutory
language
consistent
authority
treating
criminal
sanctions
nondischargeable
bankruptcy
act
absence
legislative
history
suggesting
code
intended
change
established
principle
strong
policy
deference
state
criminal
judgments
compel
conclusion
restitution
order
dischargeable
debt
majority
appropriately
begins
analysis
language
statute
majority
points
bankruptcy
code
defines
debt
liability
claim
term
claim
turn
defined
right
payment
question
becomes
whether
clear
statutory
language
alone
restitution
order
right
payment
whether
statutory
language
least
degree
open
interpretation
ron
pair
emphasis
added
majority
simply
asserts
plain
meaning
right
payment
enforceable
obligation
gives
restitution
order
character
right
payment
ante
accept
easy
conclusion
time
ago
justice
frankfurter
pointed
notion
words
statute
plain
meaning
also
plain
merely
pernicious
oversimplification
monia
dissenting
opinion
observation
rings
especially
true
case
clear
words
right
payment
plainly
include
obligation
resulting
criminal
restitution
order
words
may
common
usage
meaning
plain
context
notably
absent
code
definition
legislative
history
debt
claim
indication
congress
intended
discharge
provisions
extend
criminal
sphere
indeed
persuasive
reasons
excluding
criminal
restitution
category
debts
petitioners
argue
without
force
criminal
restitution
order
right
payment
neither
victim
crime
probation
department
possesses
right
payment
restitution
order
brief
petitioners
petitioners
also
argue
victim
right
enforcement
victim
right
payment
see
also
commonwealth
mourar
super
criminal
defendant
fails
make
restitution
ordered
victim
right
enforcement
vacated
remanded
grounds
cf
bearden
georgia
state
constitutionally
revoke
probation
failure
pay
fine
make
restitution
without
first
determining
probationer
ability
pay
several
bankruptcy
courts
agreed
petitioners
decided
definition
debt
bankruptcy
code
include
criminal
restitution
order
see
norman
criminal
penalties
fines
debt
defined
code
crime
victim
right
payment
restitution
debt
pellegrino
since
crime
victim
right
payment
restitution
debt
bankruptcy
code
magnifico
criminal
restitution
debt
contemplated
bankruptcy
code
button
wdny
definitions
debt
laim
reditor
appear
restitution
considered
debt
accord
kohr
md
oslager
md
mead
bankruptcy
courts
sure
determined
definition
debt
include
restitution
obligations
see
vandrovec
least
varied
interpretations
code
bankruptcy
judges
evidence
phrase
right
payment
applied
restitution
orders
subject
interpretation
kelly
statute
face
surely
compel
result
criminal
restitution
orders
constitute
debts
conclusion
majority
errs
concluding
words
right
payment
include
restitution
orders
supported
fact
interpretation
produce
result
demonstrably
odds
intention
drafters
ron
pair
quoting
griffin
oceanic
contractors
declared
effectuate
congress
intent
enacting
code
must
consider
language
light
history
bankruptcy
deference
criminal
judgments
light
interests
unfettered
administration
criminal
justice
systems
kelly
deference
reflected
judicial
interpretation
discharge
provisions
bankruptcy
act
ch
stat
kelly
discussed
length
customary
practice
holding
criminal
monetary
sanctions
dischargeable
bankruptcy
see
explained
new
code
enacted
replace
act
noted
treatment
criminal
judgments
act
informs
understanding
language
code
congress
presumed
intent
preserve
practice
unless
specifically
indicates
otherwise
must
first
consider
treatment
criminal
restitution
orders
act
act
established
two
categories
debts
allowable
provable
debt
allowable
creditor
receive
share
bankrupt
assets
citing
provable
debts
dischargeable
see
kelly
explained
penalties
forfeitures
owed
governmental
entities
generally
allowable
act
failed
state
debts
provable
see
given
statutory
scheme
natural
construction
act
therefore
allowed
criminal
penalties
discharged
bankruptcy
even
though
government
entitled
share
bankrupt
estate
nonetheless
courts
consistently
refused
allow
discharge
bankruptcy
affect
judgment
state
criminal
see
abramson
udgments
penalties
debts
proved
allowed
fixed
liability
cf
alderson
decision
found
kelly
allowed
discharge
affect
sentence
imposed
state
criminal
fact
judicially
created
exception
discharge
widely
accepted
time
congress
enacted
new
code
leading
commentator
state
flatly
fines
penalties
affected
discharge
kelly
quoting
collier
bankruptcy
pp
ed
courts
addressing
criminal
restitution
orders
applied
reasoning
prevent
discharge
bankruptcy
affecting
condition
criminal
sentence
result
congress
enacted
bankruptcy
code
existed
established
judicial
exception
discharge
criminal
sentences
including
restitution
orders
ibid
see
also
zwick
freeman
overnmental
sanctions
regarded
debts
even
require
monetary
payments
criminal
sanctions
dischargeable
also
provable
two
terms
tended
merge
practice
see
collier
supra
practice
held
ines
violation
law
forfeitures
provable
purposes
therefore
dischargeable
footnotes
omitted
thus
act
criminal
monetary
sanctions
allowable
provable
dischargeable
bankruptcy
functional
terms
criminal
monetary
sanctions
debts
purpose
bankruptcy
proceedings
judicially
created
practice
reflected
policy
considerations
great
longevity
importance
deep
conviction
federal
bankruptcy
courts
invalidate
results
state
criminal
proceedings
ron
pair
quoting
kelly
face
longstanding
principle
must
determine
whether
congress
expressed
intent
change
interpretation
judicially
created
concept
enacting
code
ibid
stated
midlantic
normal
rule
statutory
construction
congress
intends
legislation
change
interpretation
judicially
created
concept
makes
intent
specific
indication
congress
intent
drastically
change
established
practice
regarding
criminal
sanctions
although
bankruptcy
code
definition
debt
broad
one
nothing
legislative
history
bankruptcy
code
provisions
compels
conclusion
congress
intended
change
state
law
respect
criminal
judgments
kelly
see
also
midlantic
despite
code
language
dissent
labeled
absolute
terms
refused
find
congress
implicitly
abrogated
judicially
created
limitation
abandonment
powers
indeed
light
established
state
law
bankruptcy
courts
discharge
criminal
judgments
kelly
expressed
serious
doubts
whether
congress
intended
make
criminal
penalties
debts
within
meaning
congress
intended
radical
change
surely
spoken
clearly
view
congress
attitude
towards
criminal
sanctions
clearly
indicated
statement
bankruptcy
laws
criminal
offenders
discussing
automatic
stay
provisions
majority
today
brushes
aside
rule
statutory
construction
outlined
rule
stressed
must
used
particular
care
construing
scope
bankruptcy
codifications
midlantic
emphasis
added
majority
insists
holding
signal
retreat
principles
applied
kelly
clear
indication
congress
intended
depart
past
bankruptcy
practice
ante
emphasis
added
majority
contends
congress
made
intent
clear
adoption
broadest
possible
definition
debt
ante
disagree
puzzled
majority
position
previously
rejected
expressly
see
kelly
although
definition
debt
broadened
nothing
legislative
history
sections
compels
conclusion
congress
intended
change
state
law
respect
criminal
judgments
moreover
seems
likely
broader
definition
enacted
simply
redress
problems
created
restrictive
definitions
allowable
provable
claims
act
made
impossible
debtors
resolve
civil
liabilities
bankruptcy
particular
concern
contingent
unliquidated
claims
nonprovable
act
nder
liquidation
chapters
bankruptcy
act
certain
creditors
permitted
share
estate
nature
claims
debtor
discharged
claims
thus
relief
debtor
incomplete
creditors
given
opportunity
collect
case
claims
proposed
law
permit
complete
settlement
affairs
bankrupt
debtor
complete
discharge
fresh
start
supra
omitted
majority
assertion
congress
enactment
evidences
clear
indication
abrogate
rulings
criminal
sanctions
neither
provable
dischargeable
bankruptcy
similarly
unconvincing
debt
dischargeable
extent
debt
fine
penalty
forfeiture
payable
benefit
governmental
unit
compensation
actual
pecuniary
loss
tax
penalty
majority
reasons
restitution
obligations
debts
need
except
discharge
therefore
says
congress
clearly
intended
criminal
restitution
orders
considered
debts
apply
chapter
proceedings
majority
contends
criminal
restitution
obligations
considered
dischargeable
debts
chapter
ante
disagree
enactment
single
provision
bankruptcy
code
little
demonstrate
clear
congressional
intent
change
traditional
practice
even
interpreted
making
criminal
restitution
orders
dischargeable
mean
congress
intended
make
criminal
restitution
orders
debts
practice
nondischargeability
criminal
restitution
order
evidence
debt
congress
gave
indication
intended
break
conception
dischargeability
enacted
addition
chapter
xiii
essentially
adopted
chapter
vii
discharge
policy
excepting
discharge
debts
dischargeable
chapter
vii
debts
held
creditors
accepted
bankruptcy
plan
see
act
congress
failure
include
parallel
provision
chapter
far
demonstrating
clear
intent
make
fines
dischargeable
chapter
likely
carryover
practice
chapter
xiii
relied
chapter
vii
discharge
provisions
congress
intended
provision
change
practice
holding
monetary
sanctions
allowable
provable
dischargeable
bankruptcy
certain
hearings
testimony
debate
concerning
consequences
wasteful
inimical
purposes
previously
deemed
important
likely
arouse
public
outrage
kelly
quoting
powell
dissenting
tva
hill
believe
congress
cavalierly
disregarded
overwhelmingly
important
interest
administering
criminal
justice
systems
free
interference
federal
bankruptcy
judge
every
state
district
columbia
presently
authorize
use
restitution
orders
see
note
criminal
restitution
limited
opportunity
new
eng
crim
civ
confinement
bankruptcy
discharge
criminal
restitution
order
deep
intrusion
federal
courts
state
sovereign
power
vacates
criminal
sentence
presumably
entered
full
accord
substantive
procedural
mandates
constitution
seriously
doubt
congress
lightly
limit
rehabilitative
deterrent
options
available
state
criminal
judges
kelly
majority
decision
today
adverse
effect
sentencing
process
judgment
sentencing
courts
legislators
rehabilitation
effective
form
punishment
tempered
knowledge
convicted
criminals
easily
may
avoid
sentence
requiring
restitution
merely
obtaining
chapter
discharge
sentencing
courts
faced
dilemma
sentencing
judge
must
either
risk
federal
bankruptcy
judge
undermine
restitution
order
thus
absolving
convicted
criminal
punishment
impose
harsher
less
appropriate
term
imprisonment
sentence
federal
bankruptcy
unable
undermine
congress
surely
enacted
legislation
extraordinary
result
without
least
discussion
consequences
majority
holding
turns
kelly
around
kelly
stressed
compelling
federalism
concern
terming
one
powerful
considerations
influence
considering
equitable
types
relief
recognized
must
influence
interpretation
bankruptcy
code
concerned
federal
remission
judgments
imposed
state
criminal
judges
hamper
flexibility
state
criminal
judges
choosing
combination
imprisonment
fines
restitution
likely
rehabilitative
deterrent
goals
state
criminal
justice
systems
ibid
concerns
kelly
less
applicable
case
congress
intent
invalidate
results
state
criminal
proceedings
far
clear
simply
suggestion
congress
intended
depart
practice
encroach
deeply
upon
administration
criminal
justice
systems
absence
evidence
congressional
intent
contrary
statutory
construction
rule
set
forth
kelly
midlantic
requires
determination
bankruptcy
code
permit
convicted
criminals
discharge
restitution
obligations
chapter
proceedings
therefore
refuse
allow
bankruptcy
code
become
sanctuary
criminal
trying
avoid
punishment
meted
judge
dissent