bifulco
argued
february
decided
june
section
comprehensive
drug
abuse
prevention
control
act
act
provides
ny
person
attempts
conspires
commit
offense
defined
title
punishable
imprisonment
fine
may
exceed
maximum
punishment
prescribed
offense
commission
object
attempt
conspiracy
target
offense
petitioner
others
convicted
violating
conspiring
violate
act
knowingly
manufacturing
distributing
possessing
controlled
substance
accordance
provisions
prescribing
penalties
violations
petitioner
sentenced
term
imprisonment
fine
special
parole
term
served
upon
completion
term
imprisonment
appeals
affirmed
petitioner
conviction
thereafter
filed
action
vacate
sentence
claiming
sentence
unlawful
authorize
imposition
special
parole
term
district
held
petitioner
properly
sentenced
appeals
affirmed
held
section
act
authorize
imposition
special
parole
term
even
though
sanction
included
within
penalty
provision
target
offense
pp
plain
meaning
interpretation
term
imprisonment
support
position
term
means
term
incarceration
plus
special
parole
made
applicable
target
offense
penalty
provisions
moreover
structure
act
read
whole
supports
conclusion
defines
types
punishment
authorized
conspirators
imprisonment
fine
sets
maximum
limits
sanctions
reference
penalty
provisions
target
offense
incorporate
reference
provisions
special
parole
pp
act
legislative
history
demonstrate
congress
intended
penalties
authorized
substantive
offenses
conspiracies
commit
identical
thus
authorizing
special
parole
terms
conspiracy
convictions
instead
history
supports
view
authorizes
two
types
sanctions
fines
imprisonment
fixes
maximum
amount
may
imposed
reference
target
offense
penalty
provisions
pp
reading
include
special
parole
provisions
target
offenses
supported
ground
congress
principal
objective
enacting
act
penalty
provisions
deter
professional
criminals
engaging
drug
trafficking
profit
renders
unreasonable
ascribe
congress
intent
authorize
special
parole
isolated
substantive
offenses
withholding
sentencing
tool
conspiracies
comparison
drug
offenses
congress
clearly
authorized
special
parole
terms
clearly
reveal
coherent
pattern
based
asserted
justification
escalated
sanctions
moreover
since
deals
conspiracies
attempts
prescribes
identical
range
punishment
surprising
congress
provide
less
stringent
sanctions
imposed
violations
completed
substantive
offense
pp
blackmun
delivered
opinion
burger
brennan
stewart
marshall
powell
joined
burger
filed
concurring
opinion
post
stevens
filed
dissenting
opinion
white
rehnquist
joined
post
steven
lloyd
barrett
appointment
argued
cause
petitioner
briefs
william
hellerstein
phylis
skloot
bamberger
harlon
dalton
argued
cause
brief
solicitor
general
mccree
assistant
attorney
general
heymann
deputy
solicitor
general
frey
john
de
pue
justice
blackmun
delivered
opinion
issue
presented
case
whether
comprehensive
drug
abuse
prevention
control
act
act
stat
authorizes
sentencing
impose
term
special
parole
upon
defendant
convicted
conspiracy
manufacture
distribute
controlled
substance
section
provides
person
attempts
conspires
commit
offense
defined
title
punishable
imprisonment
fine
may
exceed
maximum
punishment
prescribed
offense
commission
object
attempt
conspiracy
except
authorized
title
shall
unlawful
person
knowingly
intentionally
manufacture
distribute
dispense
possess
intent
manufacture
distribute
dispense
controlled
substance
create
distribute
dispense
possess
intent
distribute
dispense
counterfeit
substance
except
otherwise
provided
section
deals
distribution
minors
person
violates
subsection
section
shall
sentenced
follows
case
controlled
substance
schedule
ii
narcotic
drug
case
controlled
substance
schedule
iii
person
shall
sentenced
term
imprisonment
years
fine
person
commits
violation
one
prior
convictions
offense
punishable
paragraph
felony
provision
title
title
iii
law
relating
narcotic
drugs
marihuana
depressant
stimulant
substances
become
final
person
shall
sentenced
term
imprisonment
years
fine
sentence
imposing
term
imprisonment
paragraph
shall
absence
prior
conviction
impose
special
parole
term
least
years
addition
term
imprisonment
shall
prior
conviction
impose
special
parole
term
least
years
addition
term
imprisonment
special
parole
term
imposed
section
section
may
revoked
terms
conditions
violated
circumstances
original
term
imprisonment
shall
increased
period
special
parole
term
resulting
new
term
imprisonment
shall
diminished
time
spent
special
parole
person
whose
special
parole
term
revoked
may
required
serve
part
remainder
new
term
imprisonment
special
parole
term
provided
section
section
shall
addition
lieu
parole
provided
law
ii
indictment
filed
december
district
eastern
district
new
york
petitioner
alphonse
bifulco
others
charged
single
count
conspiring
violate
knowingly
intentionally
manufacturing
distributing
possessing
substantial
quantities
phencyclidine
schedule
iii
controlled
substance
conspiracy
charged
violation
jury
found
petitioner
several
codefendants
guilty
offense
charged
petitioner
sentenced
term
imprisonment
fine
special
parole
term
appeals
second
circuit
subsequently
affirmed
petitioner
conviction
unpublished
order
january
petitioner
pursuant
filed
pro
se
motion
vacate
sentence
claimed
sentence
unlawful
authorize
imposition
special
parole
term
served
upon
completion
term
imprisonment
district
held
petitioner
properly
sentenced
dismissed
complaint
app
appeal
second
circuit
affirmed
per
curiam
opinion
followed
two
courts
appeals
held
authorizes
imposition
special
parole
term
see
burman
cert
denied
jacobson
cert
denied
also
relied
decision
dankert
reached
similar
result
respect
closely
analogous
sentencing
provisions
act
proscribing
conspiracy
import
controlled
substance
shortly
second
circuit
decision
case
appeals
third
circuit
reached
opposite
conclusion
issue
held
special
parole
term
may
imposed
mearns
supp
del
cert
pending
granted
certiorari
resolve
conflict
among
courts
appeals
iii
government
recognizes
brief
examination
meaning
must
informed
policy
expressed
rule
lenity
past
cases
made
clear
principle
statutory
construction
applies
interpretations
substantive
ambit
criminal
prohibitions
also
penalties
impose
see
batchelder
simpson
opinion
ladner
rule
policy
lenity
means
interpret
federal
criminal
statute
increase
penalty
places
individual
interpretation
based
guess
congress
intended
see
whalen
simpson
emphasized
touchstone
rule
lenity
statutory
ambiguity
see
lewis
congress
manifested
intention
may
manufacture
ambiguity
order
defeat
intent
government
argues
uncertainty
congress
intent
authorize
special
parole
term
penalty
conspiracy
offense
whenever
penalty
authorized
offense
target
conspiracy
advancing
argument
focuses
language
structure
legislative
history
motivating
policies
act
examine
three
factors
turn
language
structure
act
several
reviewing
courts
adopted
view
special
parole
term
specified
necessarily
included
within
term
imprisonment
appended
see
jacobson
thus
congress
stated
person
guilty
attempt
conspiracy
punishable
imprisonment
meant
include
within
term
imprisonment
special
parole
term
made
applicable
penalty
provisions
substantive
offense
argument
persuasive
however
special
parole
authorized
substantive
offenses
refers
therefore
imprisonment
within
meaning
always
include
special
parole
period
supervision
served
upon
completion
prison
term
special
parole
also
functionally
distinct
incarceration
finally
penalty
provisions
substantive
offenses
authorize
special
parole
terms
reflect
functional
dichotomy
section
example
twice
provides
special
parole
term
years
imposed
addition
term
imprisonment
emphasis
added
agree
therefore
conclusion
courts
rejected
argument
imprisonment
plainly
means
term
incarceration
plus
special
parole
see
jacquinto
supp
ed
faced
obstacles
government
rely
solely
plain
meaning
interpretation
term
imprisonment
thus
principal
argument
government
asks
take
broader
view
relationship
penalty
provisions
substantive
offenses
conclude
structure
act
viewed
whole
creates
inference
incorporates
reference
substantive
penalty
provisions
government
contends
language
statute
supports
reading
authorizes
penalties
may
exceed
maximum
punishment
prescribed
offense
commission
object
attempt
conspiracy
argument
wholly
without
force
ignores
immediately
preceding
words
state
ny
person
attempts
conspires
commit
offense
defined
title
punishable
imprisonment
fine
emphasis
added
petitioner
argues
defines
types
punishment
authorized
conspirators
imprisonment
fine
sets
maximum
limits
sanctions
reference
penalty
provisions
target
offense
petitioner
reading
language
sentencing
scheme
proposes
less
plausible
government
moreover
petitioner
reading
finds
support
structure
act
read
whole
section
provision
act
defines
sentences
reference
penalty
provisions
offenses
section
act
enhances
punishment
one
convicted
distributing
controlled
substance
minor
provides
person
least
eighteen
years
age
violates
section
distributing
controlled
substance
person
years
age
punishable
term
imprisonment
fine
twice
authorized
section
least
twice
special
parole
term
authorized
section
first
offense
involving
controlled
substance
schedule
emphasis
supplied
proof
congress
intended
special
parole
imposed
certain
substantive
offenses
defined
offenses
act
found
defines
workings
special
parole
subsection
special
parole
term
imposed
section
section
may
revoked
terms
conditions
violated
emphasis
supplied
one
convicted
sentenced
conspiracy
said
sentence
imposed
legislative
history
conceding
congress
draftsmanship
enacted
may
less
explicit
brief
government
asks
look
beyond
ambiguous
language
statute
give
words
fair
meaning
accord
manifest
intent
lawmakers
brown
government
argues
legislative
history
act
demonstrates
congress
intended
penalties
authorized
substantive
offenses
conspiracies
commit
identical
true
prior
act
federal
narcotics
legislation
provided
congruence
sentences
authorized
substantive
violations
sentences
authorized
conspiracies
similar
congruence
feature
several
bills
introduced
congress
forerunners
act
special
parole
term
sanction
previously
unknown
administration
system
criminal
justice
authorized
penalty
offense
initial
proposals
special
parole
concept
first
presented
congress
john
ingersoll
director
bureau
narcotics
dangerous
drugs
testimony
senate
subcommittee
october
see
narcotics
legislation
hearings
et
al
subcommittee
investigate
juvenile
delinquency
senate
committee
judiciary
attorney
general
earlier
sought
subcommittee
approval
input
justice
department
penalty
structures
pending
legislation
ingersoll
presented
several
alternative
penalty
schemes
subcommittee
consideration
comments
subcommittee
concerning
special
parole
provisions
entirety
follows
another
requirement
included
alternative
penalty
schemes
special
parole
term
part
illicit
trafficking
sentence
structure
incarceration
always
meaningful
answer
effective
rehabilitation
certainly
incarceration
without
adequate
supervisory
followup
release
best
interest
society
therefore
required
special
parole
term
persons
sentenced
trafficking
violations
placed
supervision
period
time
regardless
whether
incarcerated
sentence
probated
suspended
intent
give
judges
another
tool
sentencing
another
means
protecting
society
dealing
drug
violator
judiciary
committee
analysis
noted
special
parole
terms
imposed
certain
substantive
offenses
respect
endeavor
conspiracy
provision
stated
section
provides
person
endeavors
conspires
commit
offense
defined
title
may
punished
imprisonment
fine
may
exceed
maximum
punishment
prescribed
offense
government
argues
subcommittee
meant
include
specific
reference
special
parole
amended
substantive
offense
sections
response
ingersoll
testimony
unexplained
reasons
however
subcommittee
neglected
make
conforming
change
conspiracy
section
brief
wording
judiciary
committee
analysis
however
seem
indicate
awareness
unlike
subsections
amended
incorporate
concept
special
parole
authorized
punishments
consisting
imprisonment
fine
support
view
judiciary
committee
knew
approved
may
found
provisions
bill
dealt
second
subsequent
offense
act
doubly
enhanced
penalties
second
offenders
included
within
provisions
defining
sentences
individual
substantive
offenses
see
quoted
supra
however
contained
separate
provision
set
penalties
repeat
offenders
stated
person
convicted
offense
act
offense
second
subsequent
offense
punishable
term
imprisonment
twice
authorized
twice
fine
otherwise
authorized
conviction
offense
punishable
subsection
subsection
act
offender
second
subsequent
offense
shall
impose
addition
terms
imprisonment
fine
twice
special
parole
term
otherwise
authorized
reference
made
special
parole
provisions
senate
debates
tends
confirm
conclusion
senator
dodd
subcommittee
chairman
summarized
sentencing
provisions
follows
selling
schedule
ii
narcotics
heroin
opium
draw
sentence
years
possible
fine
schedules
ii
iii
sales
marihuana
pep
pills
like
sentence
years
possible
fine
exceeding
minimum
special
parole
term
years
required
offenses
cong
rec
given
scant
support
legislative
history
senate
bill
government
position
surprising
government
must
place
greater
reliance
events
transpired
house
consideration
proposed
narcotics
legislation
similar
subject
hearings
house
committee
ways
means
july
contained
penalty
provisions
substantially
identical
see
reprinted
ways
means
hearings
ingersoll
appeared
committee
ways
means
testified
department
justice
firm
support
submitted
analysis
bill
highlighted
differences
provisions
existing
federal
narcotics
legislation
ways
means
hearings
analysis
described
operation
special
parole
terms
applicable
noted
special
parole
term
new
program
comparable
laws
force
narcotic
drug
law
convictions
respect
bill
conspiracy
provision
ingersoll
analysis
stated
section
provides
person
may
punished
endeavoring
conspiring
commit
offense
act
upon
conviction
sentence
may
exceed
punishment
prescribed
offense
object
attempt
conspiracy
hearings
committee
ways
means
followed
earlier
hearings
conducted
house
committee
interstate
foreign
commerce
latter
committee
issued
house
report
sess
contained
additions
revisions
pertinent
sentencing
provisions
issue
pt
like
senate
report
house
report
appears
plainly
recognize
distinction
penalties
specific
substantive
offenses
authorizing
special
parole
terms
conspiracy
offense
authorizing
terms
imprisonment
fines
thus
respect
direct
ancestor
present
house
report
analysis
section
provides
person
attempts
conspires
commit
offense
defined
title
may
punished
imprisonment
fine
may
exceed
maximum
amount
set
offense
commission
object
attempt
conspiracy
emphasis
supplied
conclusion
believe
rather
supporting
government
argument
congress
manifested
intention
authorize
special
parole
terms
conspiracy
convictions
act
legislative
history
supports
opposite
view
hearings
debates
legislative
reports
extent
congress
attention
drawn
matter
members
houses
explicitly
recognized
penalty
provisions
substantive
offenses
attached
mandatory
minimum
term
special
parole
term
imprisonment
hand
every
reference
one
forerunners
stated
authorized
penalties
consisting
imprisonment
fine
failed
mention
special
parole
motivating
policy
government
strongly
argues
finally
congress
principal
objective
enacting
penalty
provisions
act
deter
professional
criminals
engaging
drug
trafficking
profit
render
unreasonable
ascribe
congress
intent
authorize
special
parole
isolated
substantive
offenses
withholding
major
sentencing
tool
conspiracy
offenses
brief
contention
unpersuasive
two
reasons
first
petitioner
points
brief
petitioner
reply
brief
petitioner
comparison
drug
offenses
congress
clearly
authorized
imposition
special
parole
terms
clearly
reveal
coherent
pattern
based
asserted
justification
escalated
sanctions
serious
offenses
measured
length
term
imprisonment
severity
fine
authorize
special
parole
included
among
available
sanctions
act
continuing
criminal
enterprise
act
registrants
new
act
supp
ii
piperidine
offenses
thus
government
argument
based
congress
sentencing
objectives
prove
much
second
thrust
government
argument
conspiracy
engage
drug
trafficking
presents
least
great
threat
greater
one
community
isolated
act
distribution
contexts
recognized
logic
view
see
iannelli
premise
government
contends
congress
must
desired
harsh
sanctions
incorporated
within
concept
special
parole
unlimited
maximum
length
term
grave
consequences
attending
revocation
see
available
judge
sentencing
drug
conspirator
government
mention
however
sets
identical
penalties
conspiracies
attempts
congress
dealt
forms
inchoate
crime
single
provision
prescribed
identical
range
punishment
person
convicted
participation
major
trafficking
conspiracy
another
person
convicted
unsuccessful
attempt
manufacture
distribute
small
amount
controlled
substance
one
focuses
fact
penalizes
attempts
well
conspiracies
surprising
congress
provide
less
stringent
sanctions
imposed
violations
provision
completed
substantive
offense
indeed
ingersoll
pointed
analysis
prior
passage
act
attempt
commit
substantive
drug
offense
punishable
federal
narcotics
laws
ways
means
hearings
iv
investigation
meaning
informed
examination
language
structure
history
relevant
policy
considerations
yields
likely
conclusion
congress
failure
specifically
authorize
imposition
special
parole
terms
punishment
convicted
conspiracy
slip
legislative
pen
result
inartful
draftsmanship
conscious
irrational
legislative
choice
analysis
reveals
least
complete
absence
unambiguous
legislative
decision
authorize
special
parole
terms
punishment
convicted
drug
conspiracies
course
extent
doubts
remain
must
resolved
accord
rule
lenity
construction
congress
intent
evidenced
scant
record
left
behind
clashes
present
legislative
expectations
simple
remedy
insertion
brief
appropriate
phrase
amendment
present
language
congress
enact
words
produce
result
government
seeks
case
judgment
appeals
reversed
case
remanded
instructions
vacate
special
parole
term
imposed
upon
petitioner
ordered
footnotes
provision
amended
amendment
pertinent
issue
presented
see
pub
stat
supp
ii
appeals
stated
petitioner
charged
two
substantive
violations
addition
conspiracy
count
acquitted
substantive
charges
parties
agree
however
error
petitioner
charged
convicted
single
conspiracy
count
brief
petitioner
brief
two
courts
appeals
addition
followed
second
circuit
case
joined
conclusion
authorizes
imposition
special
parole
term
term
included
penalty
provisions
target
offense
see
sellers
cantu
addition
number
cases
appellate
courts
affirmed
convictions
defendants
sentenced
special
parole
terms
without
considering
question
whether
special
parole
authorized
example
question
presented
may
lingered
beneath
surface
timmreck
mearns
third
circuit
followed
lead
two
district
opinions
addition
opinion
review
holding
special
parole
penalty
authorized
see
jacquinto
supp
ed
fassette
supp
cd
cal
cf
wells
supp
sd
iowa
adopting
mearns
rationale
sentencing
pursuant
accessories
fact
drug
conspiracy
dissent
ordinary
reading
post
appears
based
incomplete
reading
words
conspiracy
provision
section
likewise
provides
treble
enhancement
fine
term
imprisonment
minimum
length
special
parole
term
one
convicted
second
subsequent
time
distributing
controlled
substance
minor
government
argues
express
reference
special
parole
detract
view
incorporates
special
parole
implication
contends
necessary
congress
deal
special
parole
explicitly
chose
mandate
minimum
special
parole
term
least
twice
length
term
authorized
whereas
imposes
fine
imprisonment
twice
otherwise
authorized
government
argument
dispel
fact
however
congress
specifically
accommodated
concept
special
parole
one
general
provision
imposing
sentence
reference
offenses
respect
adjacent
provision
government
explain
specificity
instance
drafters
provision
simply
looked
see
sections
proposed
bill
used
term
special
parole
inserted
section
numbers
forerunner
brief
argues
course
although
refer
special
parole
many
words
incorporate
sentencing
provisions
reject
government
argument
reasons
stated
text
moreover
explanation
assumes
carelessness
draftsmanship
probably
unwarranted
see
following
subparts
see
ed
see
reprinted
narcotics
legislation
hearings
et
al
subcommittee
investigate
juvenile
delinquency
senate
committee
judiciary
see
also
reprinted
part
drug
abuse
control
amendments
hearings
subcommittee
public
health
welfare
house
committee
interstate
foreign
commerce
chart
setting
alternative
penalty
schemes
proposed
justice
department
included
record
hearings
held
subcommittee
public
health
welfare
house
committee
interstate
foreign
commerce
chart
describes
penalty
provisions
favored
department
attempt
conspiracy
providing
person
attempts
conspires
commit
offense
act
may
punished
imprisonment
fine
may
exceed
maximum
punishment
proscribed
committing
offense
mention
made
special
parole
terms
conspiracy
context
seems
therefore
inexact
draftsmanship
government
find
legislative
history
attributed
solely
congress
forerunner
provided
identical
penalty
scheme
first
offenders
current
substantive
offense
term
imprisonment
five
years
fine
minimum
special
parole
term
addition
term
imprisonment
see
section
differed
use
term
endeavor
rather
attempt
provided
person
endeavors
conspires
commit
offense
defined
title
punishable
imprisonment
fine
may
exceed
maximum
punishment
prescribed
offense
commission
object
endeavor
conspiracy
identical
provision
contained
forerunner
act
approved
one
two
house
committees
conduct
hearings
proposed
narcotics
legislation
see
controlled
dangerous
substances
narcotics
drug
control
laws
hearings
house
committee
ways
means
hereinafter
ways
means
hearings
bill
eventually
passed
house
sess
incorporated
enhanced
penalties
repeat
offenders
within
individual
substantive
offenses
see
cong
rec
house
bills
discussed
government
makes
argument
respect
repeat
offender
provisions
makes
respect
see
supra
argument
persuasive
dissent
takes
us
task
failing
recognize
unlikely
congress
intend
directors
narcotics
distribution
business
punished
less
severely
subordinates
merely
peddle
poison
post
even
cursory
reading
act
make
clear
opinion
today
result
sentencing
disparity
dissent
fears
section
punishment
provisions
sole
sanctions
congress
enacted
apprehended
directors
organized
drug
trafficking
operations
first
nothing
prevents
government
prosecuting
operators
distribution
network
either
principals
aiders
abettors
substantive
manufacturing
distribution
possession
offenses
pursuant
act
second
significantly
congress
enacted
two
special
provisions
directors
large
trafficking
operations
particularly
mind
sanctions
available
provisions
especially
severe
see
act
continuing
criminal
enterprise
act
defining
special
drug
offender
one
might
quarrel
conclusion
congress
aware
distinction
penalty
provisions
chose
include
special
parole
terms
among
sanctions
authorized
attempts
conspiracies
extremely
difficult
accept
government
argument
congress
unambiguously
intended
contrary
result
however
perhaps
best
evidenced
fact
rule
lenity
mentioned
let
alone
applied
lower
opinions
accepted
government
position
see
cases
cited
supra
accompanying
text
dissenting
opinion
appear
fare
little
better
score
chief
justice
burger
concurring
question
presented
case
simple
easy
dissent
formulates
whether
directors
narcotics
distribution
business
punished
less
severely
subordinates
merely
peddle
poison
none
us
difficulty
decision
really
issue
rather
question
substantially
limited
words
statute
mean
course
must
try
discern
intent
congress
perform
task
beginning
ordinary
meaning
language
statute
compass
read
statute
reach
perceive
even
think
reasonable
person
perceive
sensible
result
congress
must
taken
word
unless
assume
role
statute
revisers
aaron
sec
tva
hill
particularly
administration
criminal
justice
badly
drawn
statute
places
strains
judges
see
busic
larocca
decided
busic
temptation
exceed
limited
judicial
role
regard
sensible
thing
great
takes
us
slippery
slope
duty
paraphrase
justice
holmes
conversation
judge
learned
hand
justice
apply
law
hope
justice
done
spirit
liberty
papers
addresses
learned
hand
dilliard
ed
without
reluctance
view
underlies
opinion
join
opinion
justice
stevens
justice
white
justice
rehnquist
join
dissenting
directors
narcotics
distribution
business
punished
less
severely
subordinates
merely
peddle
poison
unlikely
congress
intended
see
callanan
since
ordinary
reading
comprehensive
drug
abuse
prevention
control
act
implies
conspirator
may
punished
severely
substantive
offender
construe
statute
construction
fortified
total
absence
statement
legislator
suggesting
purpose
treat
conspirators
drug
trade
greater
lenity
substantive
offenders
particularly
important
view
fact
prior
act
congress
authorized
identical
penalties
conspiracies
completed
offenses
see
ante
statutory
language
conveys
quite
different
meaning
paused
consider
narrow
issue
presented
case
context
larger
objectives
congress
seeking
respectfully
dissent
person
attempts
conspires
commit
offense
defined
title
punishable
imprisonment
fine
may
exceed
maximum
punishment
prescribed
offense
commission
object
attempt
conspiracy
stat
surely
reference
ante
offense
attempt
cuts
way
common
legislation
authorize
range
punishments
attempts
substantive
offenses
see
american
law
institute
model
penal
code
prop
draft
provides
part
except
otherwise
provided
section
attempt
solicitation
conspiracy
crimes
grade
degree
serious
offense
attempted
solicited
object
conspiracy