american
ry
exp
argued
decided
june
attorney
general
blackburn
esterline
washington
robert
alston
atlanta
cunningham
savannah
marx
new
york
city
appellees
farrell
washington
appellant
interstate
commerce
commission
mrssrs
sanders
mcdaniel
atlanta
charles
rixey
washington
appellant
southeastern
express
challen
ellis
washington
appellant
southern
traffic
league
justice
brandeis
delivered
opinion
transportation
act
stat
amending
interstate
commerce
act
par
comp
ann
supp
directs
commission
whenever
deemed
necessary
desirable
public
interest
establish
routes
paragraph
section
provides
establishing
route
commission
shall
require
carrier
railroad
without
consent
embrace
route
substantially
less
entire
length
railroad
intermediate
railroad
operated
conjunction
common
management
control
therewith
lies
termini
proposed
route
unless
inclusion
lines
make
route
unreasonably
long
compared
another
practicable
route
otherwise
established
commission
shall
compel
carrier
short
haul
traffic
main
question
decision
whether
american
railway
express
company
uses
railroads
transportation
service
described
wells
fargo
taylor
sup
railroad
within
meaning
paragraph
american
organized
june
war
measure
take
express
business
done
railroads
come
federal
control
government
relinquished
control
consolidation
transportation
business
property
express
companies
approved
commission
paragraph
section
interstate
commerce
act
amended
transportation
act
comp
ann
supp
consolidation
express
interst
com
uniform
contracts
entered
american
substantially
railroads
express
contract
interst
com
enjoyed
practical
monopoly
railroad
express
business
may
day
southeastern
express
company
entered
field
utilizing
purpose
southern
railway
system
affiliated
lines
miles
railroad
many
cities
towns
southeastern
served
american
southeastern
called
common
points
larger
number
served
one
companies
called
exclusive
points
except
southeastern
practically
railroad
express
offices
exclusive
points
american
southeastern
sought
american
agree
establish
routes
joint
rates
points
served
respectively
whether
common
points
exclusive
permit
shipper
give
routing
instruction
american
declined
limiting
concurrence
routes
exclusive
points
one
company
exclusive
points
way
attempted
secure
either
entire
haul
longest
possible
haul
thereupon
southeastern
instituted
commission
proceedings
american
praying
commission
establish
routes
joint
rates
sought
another
proceeding
seeking
part
like
relief
brought
two
express
companies
shippers
associations
cases
consolidated
commission
ordered
establishment
routes
prayed
finding
order
secure
adequate
service
necessary
desirable
public
interest
competitive
joint
routes
established
although
american
reasonable
routes
origin
destination
origin
point
nearer
destination
joint
routes
established
southeastern
express
american
railway
express
interst
com
interst
com
effective
date
order
suit
enjoin
enforcement
brought
american
federal
northern
georgia
seaboard
air
line
railway
one
many
railroads
american
contract
intervened
plaintiff
commission
southeastern
southern
traffic
league
shippers
associations
intervened
defendants
case
heard
application
temporary
injunction
three
judges
pursuant
act
october
stat
order
held
void
ground
american
railroad
within
meaning
paragraph
therefore
commission
facts
found
without
power
make
order
temporary
granted
circuit
judge
bryan
dissenting
fed
case
separate
appeals
decision
several
respondents
three
appeals
present
questions
law
first
power
establish
routes
conferred
broadly
carriers
paragraph
section
limitation
upon
power
respect
railroad
imposed
paragraph
language
embodies
limitation
appropriate
describe
situation
express
company
commission
may
compel
carrier
embrace
route
less
entire
length
railroad
intermediate
railroad
operated
conjunction
common
management
control
therewith
lies
termini
proposed
route
unless
express
company
railroad
served
many
railroads
served
water
lines
motor
trucks
horses
wagons
moreover
language
paragraph
describes
aptly
single
railroad
system
system
express
routes
extending
many
separate
railroad
systems
practically
every
express
company
american
routes
many
separate
railroad
system
however
numerous
railroads
used
routes
parts
single
express
system
express
company
railroad
length
railroad
must
american
argues
construed
mean
entire
length
lines
railroads
within
routes
construction
adopted
tend
give
permanency
existing
monopoly
although
failed
give
adequate
service
deprive
commission
power
foster
competition
found
necessary
secure
service
nothing
transportation
act
evinces
intention
part
congress
accomplish
purpose
natural
meaning
term
railroad
one
operates
railroad
one
whose
shipments
carried
railroad
term
found
original
act
regulate
commerce
applicable
carriers
transportation
passengers
property
wholly
railroad
partly
railroad
partly
water
amendment
extended
commission
jurisdiction
express
companies
sleeping
car
companies
pipe
lines
extended
jurisdiction
telegraph
telephone
cable
companies
occasion
differentiating
carriers
arose
provisions
act
regulate
commerce
obviously
applicable
classes
carriers
made
subject
regulation
extent
provisions
applied
class
left
amendments
largely
construction
transportation
act
phrase
railroad
seems
systematically
employed
designate
sections
interstate
commerce
act
apply
carriers
operating
railroads
term
introduced
paragraph
place
word
used
amendment
purpose
substitution
make
clearer
prohibition
compelling
carrier
traffic
limited
railroads
phrase
adopted
federal
employers
liability
act
april
stat
comp
used
act
held
wells
fargo
taylor
sup
include
independent
express
companies
business
railroads
section
transportation
act
given
meaning
compare
ex
rel
cnicago
new
york
boston
refrigerator
interstate
commerce
commission
decided
may
sup
ed
second
american
claims
order
void
even
limitation
contained
paragraph
applicable
express
companies
one
contention
order
exceeds
power
conferred
upon
commission
matter
law
unreasonable
establish
second
route
merely
sake
securing
competition
service
another
contention
order
exceeds
power
conferred
upon
commission
purports
authorize
shipper
give
routing
instructions
claim
made
american
matter
law
right
carry
lines
traffic
originates
long
done
without
unreasonably
delaying
delivery
destination
right
haul
traffic
destination
property
protected
fifth
amendment
authorize
shipper
give
routing
instructions
takes
property
provision
making
equitable
division
joint
rate
afford
legal
compensation
taking
entitled
southeastern
insists
claims
although
adequately
presented
bill
complaint
availed
overruled
district
american
take
objection
unsound
true
party
appeal
final
decree
trial
heard
opposition
thereto
case
brought
appeal
adverse
party
words
appellee
may
attack
decree
view
either
enlarging
rights
thereunder
lessening
rights
adversary
whether
seeks
correct
error
supplement
decree
respect
matter
dealt
likewise
settled
appellee
may
without
taking
appeal
urge
support
decree
matter
appearing
record
although
argument
may
involve
attack
upon
reasoning
lower
insistence
upon
matter
overlooked
ignored
claims
question
american
attack
respect
decree
entered
merely
asserts
additional
grounds
decree
affirmed
grounds
examined
competitive
route
ordered
must
course
reasonable
character
standpoint
transportation
must
reasonable
cause
establishing
case
objection
made
character
routest
ordered
objection
matter
law
competitive
routes
justified
time
required
delivery
existing
routes
american
short
competitive
joint
routes
objection
action
taken
congress
supplies
answer
act
commission
act
satisfactory
route
exists
interstate
commerce
commission
northern
pacific
ry
sup
set
aside
order
establish
second
route
deemed
existing
one
adequate
thereupon
congress
amendment
struck
proviso
empowered
commission
establish
routes
deemed
necessary
desirable
public
interest
transportation
quality
service
furnished
may
important
shipper
rate
commission
found
proceeding
review
service
american
instances
inadequate
competition
time
important
element
conpetition
tends
make
company
improve
general
treatment
public
practices
rules
regulations
regard
methods
business
found
also
common
points
improved
since
formation
southeastern
conclusion
establishment
competitive
routes
necessary
desirable
public
interest
shown
unreasonable
existence
competitive
route
ordinarily
implies
option
shipper
give
privilege
directing
routing
corollary
establishment
competitive
routes
upon
shippers
railroad
freight
right
expressly
conferred
congress
paragraph
section
subject
reasonable
exceptions
regulations
commission
may
prescribe
rights
respect
shippers
express
dealt
terms
matter
therefore
left
subject
regulation
commission
general
provisions
act
paragraph
empowers
commission
establish
routes
authorizes
also
fix
terms
conditions
routes
shall
operated
order
shipper
express
may
direct
routing
unreasonable
american
absolute
right
retain
traffic
originates
provision
authorizing
shipper
direct
routing
reasonable
order
violate
late
constitutional
rights
occasion
consider
grounds
urged
support
reversed
footnotes
commission
found
necessary
desirable
public
interest
additional
reasonable
direct
routes
joint
rates
shall
maintained
points
lines
american
railway
express
company
points
lines
southeastern
express
company
regardless
fact
one
company
may
reasonable
direct
route
join
reasonable
direct
joint
route
via
another
junction
allows
longer
haul
rates
two
points
shall
regardless
route
shipment
may
move
number
lines
may
travel
joint
routes
shall
established
instances
result
reasonable
direct
routes
least
two
reasonable
direct
routes
points
one
shall
via
transfer
point
selected
southeastern
express
company
via
transfer
point
selected
american
railway
express
company
tariffs
shall
provide
right
shipper
designate
routing
express
shipments
routes
established
see
interst
com
order
interst
com
required
companies
establish
october
routes
points
maine
new
hampshire
vermont
massachusetts
rhode
island
connecticut
new
york
points
direct
routes
american
railway
express
company
new
york
washington
one
hand
points
main
line
southern
railway
company
washington
including
birmingham
transfer
companies
washington
rates
points
shall
exceed
rates
contemporaneously
effect
points
routes
used
tariffs
provide
right
shipper
designate
writing
routing
shipments
routes
prescribed
order
made
fixing
divisions
joint
rates
opinion
stated
injunction
prejudice
right
commission
inquire
whether
existing
routes
unreasonably
long
cause
particularly
appearing
proposed
new
routes
established
consistently
paragraph
section
interstate
commerce
act
order
establishment
american
ry
express
fed
act
regulate
commerce
february
stat
comp
et
seq
confer
upon
commission
power
establish
routes
compare
southern
pacific
interstate
commerce
commission
sup
amendment
act
june
state
comp
conferred
power
may
necessary
give
effect
provision
act
carriers
complained
refused
neglected
voluntarily
establish
routes
joint
rates
provided
reasonable
satisfactory
route
exists
amendment
byact
june
stat
struck
proviso
substituted
therefor
limitation
reenacted
paragraph
section
interstate
commerce
act
amended
transportation
act
latter
act
struck
also
clause
act
commission
power
establish
routes
dependent
upon
failure
carriers
establish
voluntarily
section
par
provides
term
carrier
used
act
shall
include
companies
telegraph
telephone
cable
companies
operating
wire
wireless
express
companies
sleeping
car
companies
etc
section
par
imposes
upon
every
carrier
property
duty
establish
routes
section
par
deals
among
things
joint
rates
confers
regulatory
powers
respect
common
carrier
carriers
subject
provisions
act
transportation
persons
property
transmission
messages
defined
first
section
act
paragraph
section
deals
time
orders
paragraph
takes
effect
paragraph
contains
words
limiting
scope
commission
power
establish
routes
railroad
limitation
imposed
applied
railroad
appears
first
paragraph
prior
transportation
act
existence
unrestricted
power
establish
routes
joint
rates
appears
assumed
without
question
commission
express
rates
interst
com
interst
com
compare
american
express
sup
express
companies
important
ones
conducted
service
miles
railway
miles
steamship
stage
lines
miles
electric
lines
express
rates
practices
interst
com
interst
com
interst
com
proposed
increase
express
rates
interst
com
january
express
companies
consolidation
express
interst
com
compare
express
rates
interst
com
american
express
company
business
railroads
transportation
act
enacted
conducted
service
nearly
miles
railroad
first
class
operated
separate
railroad
companies
railways
interstate
commerce
commission
consolidation
express
interst
com
see
section
phrase
used
later
sections
original
act
common
carrier
subject
provisions
act
see
sections
compare
section
commission
held
express
interst
com
express
business
conducted
department
business
railroad
subject
original
act
business
conducted
independent
company
acquired
rights
contract
railroad
subject
act
term
railroad
found
amendments
march
stat
february
stat
february
stat
amendment
appears
section
stat
amendment
appears
sections
stat
connection
establishment
routes
use
term
railroad
appears
first
time
amendment
made
act
see
following
provisions
interstate
commerce
act
amended
transportation
act
title
comp
ann
supp
et
seq
section
pars
compared
paragraphs
section
par
compared
paragraphs
section
par
compared
paragraph
section
par
compared
paragraph
also
section
par
compared
paragraphs
section
section
section
pars
section
see
also
section
comp
ann
supp
section
amended
act
june
stat
comp
read
commission
shall
require
carrier
without
consent
embrace
route
substantially
less
entire
length
railroad
etc
phrase
introduced
safety
appliance
act
march
stat
comp
found
original
safety
appliance
act
march
stat
comp
amendment
thereof
april
stat
comp
term
used
hours
service
act
march
stat
comp
act
may
comp
boiler
inspection
act
february
stat
comp
et
hand
law
act
june
stat
comp
enumerates
express
company
car
company
common
jcarrier
water
railway
mail
service
pay
provision
act
july
stat
comp
employs
phrase
common
carriers
merchant
marine
act
stat
comp
ann
supp
phrase
rail
william
bagaley
wall
stephen
morgan
landram
jordan
sup
compare
union
tool
wilson
sup
decision
peoria
pekin
union
ry
sup
ed
upon
appellants
rely
rests
upon
peculiar
character
question
raised
objection
upon
appellee
relied
one
venue
district
overruled
dismissed
bill
merits
objection
venue
waived
stage
proceeding
held
waived
failure
take
rule
express
classification
approved
commission
provided
shippers
designation
writing
may
route
shipments
way
established
routes
transfer
points
may
desire
see
express
rates
interst
com
interst
com
commission
found
american
refuses
obey
shipper
routing
instructions
disregards
rule
express
classification
see
southeastern
express
american
ry
express
interst
com
statements
practice
commission
cases
relied
upon
american
entirely
consistent
rule
see
annual
report
also
cincinnati
columbus
traction
baltimore
ohio
interst
com
express
rates
interst
com