mci
telecommunications
argued
march
decided
june
page
together
et
al
american
telephone
telegraph
et
also
certiorari
title
requires
communications
common
carriers
file
tariffs
federal
communications
commission
authorizes
commission
modify
requirement
made
section
relying
latter
provision
commission
issued
order
determining
earlier
decision
make
tariff
filing
optional
nondominant
long
distance
carriers
within
authority
modify
american
telephone
telegraph
dominant
long
distance
carrier
filed
motion
appeals
seeking
summary
reversal
commission
order
motion
granted
basis
prior
decision
determining
commission
authorization
permissive
detariffing
violated
held
commission
permissive
detariffing
policy
valid
exercise
authority
modify
requirement
virtually
every
dictionary
use
time
statute
enacted
defines
modify
meaning
change
moderately
minor
fashion
word
modify
must
seen
connotation
increment
limitation
contemplate
basic
fundamental
changes
also
demonstrated
fact
exception
deals
minor
matter
commission
may
require
period
giving
notice
tariff
changes
exceed
days
commission
page
ii
permissive
detariffing
policy
justified
nonfundamental
modification
tariff
filing
requirement
heart
common
carrier
subchapter
communications
act
policy
eliminates
requirement
entirely
except
one
firm
long
distance
sector
consumers
sector
moreover
hard
imagine
condition
shared
many
affected
parties
qualifies
special
requirement
commission
proceeds
general
order
make
modification
order
apply
special
circumstances
conditions
commission
interpretation
statute
therefore
entitled
deference
since
goes
beyond
meaning
statute
bear
congress
seemed
manifest
agreement
parties
respective
interpretations
later
legislation
irrelevant
consistent
history
legislation
one
interpretation
essential
finally
petitioners
argument
interpretation
better
serves
act
broad
purpose
promoting
efficient
telephone
service
addressed
congress
pp
affirmed
scalia
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
kennedy
thomas
ginsburg
joined
stevens
filed
dissenting
opinion
blackmun
souter
joined
took
part
consideration
decision
cases
mci
telecommunications
justice
scalia
delivered
opinion
section
title
code
requires
communications
common
carriers
file
tariffs
federal
communications
commission
authorizes
commission
modify
requirement
cases
present
question
whether
commission
decision
make
tariff
filing
optional
nondominant
long
distance
carriers
valid
exercise
modification
authority
like
cases
involving
role
american
telephone
telegraph
company
national
telecommunication
system
long
history
understanding
cases
requires
brief
mci
telecommunications
review
commission
efforts
regulate
deregulate
telecommunications
industry
congress
created
commission
vertically
integrated
bell
system
held
virtual
monopoly
nation
telephone
service
communications
act
stat
amended
authorized
commission
regulate
rates
charged
communication
services
ensure
reasonable
nondiscriminatory
requirements
common
carriers
file
rates
commission
charge
filed
rate
centerpiece
act
regulatory
scheme
technological
advances
reduced
entry
costs
competitors
market
long
distance
telephone
service
commission
recognizing
feasibility
greater
competition
passed
regulations
facilitate
competitive
entry
competition
provision
long
distance
service
well
established
urged
continuation
extensive
tariff
filing
requirements
served
impose
unnecessary
costs
new
entrants
facilitate
collusive
pricing
commission
held
hearings
matter
see
competitive
carrier
notice
inquiry
proposed
rulemaking
following
issued
series
rules
produced
litigation
first
report
order
distinguished
dominant
carriers
market
power
nondominant
carriers
long
distance
market
amounted
distinction
everyone
else
relaxed
filing
procedures
nondominant
carriers
second
report
order
commission
entirely
eliminated
filing
requirement
resellers
terrestrial
common
carrier
services
policy
optional
filing
permissive
detariffing
extended
resellers
mci
telecommunications
specialized
common
carriers
including
petitioner
mci
telecommunications
fourth
report
order
virtually
remaining
categories
nondominant
carriers
fifth
report
order
commission
shifted
mandatory
detariffing
policy
prohibited
nondominant
carriers
filing
tariffs
see
sixth
report
order
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
however
struck
sixth
report
mandatory
detariffing
policy
challenge
brought
somewhat
ironically
appears
mci
see
mci
telecommunications
fcc
ginsburg
appeals
reasoned
command
common
carrier
shall
file
tariffs
mandatory
although
authorizes
commission
modify
requirement
section
appeals
concluded
phrase
suggest
ed
circumscribed
alterations
fcc
wholesale
abandonment
elimination
requirement
wake
invalidation
mandatory
detariffing
appeals
mci
continued
practice
filing
tariffs
certain
services
pursuant
permissive
detariffing
policy
fourth
report
order
august
filed
complaint
pursuant
third
party
complaint
provision
communications
act
alleged
mci
collection
unfiled
rates
violated
mci
responded
fourth
report
substantive
rule
mci
legal
obligation
mci
telecommunications
file
rates
rejoined
fourth
report
order
simply
statement
commission
nonenforcement
policy
immunize
mci
private
enforcement
actions
fourth
report
order
established
substantive
rule
excess
statutory
authority
commission
take
final
action
complaint
almost
two
years
filing
see
communications
mci
telecommunications
fcc
rcd
characterized
fourth
report
order
substantive
rule
dismissed
complaint
ground
mci
compliance
rule
refused
address
however
contention
rule
ultra
vires
announcing
instead
proposed
rulemaking
consider
question
see
tariff
filing
requirements
interstate
common
carriers
notice
proposed
rulemaking
fcc
rcd
petitioned
review
arguing
inter
alia
commission
lacked
authority
defer
later
rulemaking
consideration
issue
dispositive
adjudicatory
complaint
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
granted
petition
review
see
fcc
silberman
appeals
characterized
commission
failure
address
authority
promulgate
permissive
detariffing
policy
sort
administrative
law
shell
game
addressing
question
appeals
concluded
permissive
detariffing
policy
fourth
report
order
rendered
indefensible
mci
decision
whether
detariffing
made
mandatory
sixth
report
simply
permissive
fourth
report
carriers
either
event
relieved
obligation
file
tariffs
section
step
exceeds
limited
authority
granted
commission
section
mci
telecommunications
modify
requirements
act
appeals
remanded
case
commission
award
appropriate
relief
see
denied
certiorari
moving
admirable
dispatch
less
two
weeks
decision
appeals
concerning
adjudicatory
proceeding
commission
released
report
order
rulemaking
proceeding
commenced
response
complaint
see
tariff
filing
requirements
interstate
common
carriers
fcc
rcd
stayed
pending
notice
fcc
rcd
report
order
issue
case
commission
relying
upon
authority
modify
twice
rejected
circuit
determined
permissive
detariffing
policy
within
authority
communications
act
filed
motion
circuit
seeking
summary
reversal
commission
order
motion
granted
unpublished
per
curiam
order
stating
decision
fcc
conclusively
determined
fcc
authorization
permissive
detariffing
violates
section
communications
act
app
pet
cert
mci
together
commission
petitioned
certiorari
granted
petitions
consolidated
ii
section
communications
act
contains
filed
rate
provisions
act
commission
disputed
modification
authority
provides
relevant
part
filing
public
display
mci
telecommunications
every
common
carrier
except
connecting
carriers
shall
within
reasonable
time
commission
shall
designate
file
commission
print
keep
open
public
inspection
schedules
showing
charges
whether
charges
joint
separate
showing
classifications
practices
regulations
affecting
charges
changes
schedule
discretion
commission
modify
requirements
change
shall
made
charges
classifications
regulations
practices
filed
published
except
one
hundred
twenty
days
notice
commission
public
shall
published
form
contain
information
commission
may
regulations
prescribe
commission
may
discretion
good
cause
shown
modify
requirement
made
authority
section
either
particular
instances
general
order
applicable
special
circumstances
conditions
except
commission
may
require
notice
period
specified
paragraph
one
hundred
twenty
days
overcharges
rebates
carrier
unless
otherwise
provided
authority
chapter
shall
engage
participate
communication
unless
schedules
filed
published
accordance
provisions
chapter
regulations
made
thereunder
carrier
shall
charge
demand
collect
receive
greater
less
different
compensation
communication
charges
specified
schedule
effect
refund
remit
means
device
portion
charges
specified
extend
mci
telecommunications
person
privileges
facilities
communication
employ
enforce
classifications
regulations
practices
affecting
charges
except
specified
schedule
ed
supp
iv
support
position
petitioners
cite
dictionary
definitions
contained
derived
single
source
webster
third
new
international
dictionary
webster
third
includes
among
meanings
modify
make
basic
important
mci
telecommunications
change
petitioners
contend
establishes
sufficient
ambiguity
entitle
commission
deference
acceptance
broader
meaning
turn
requires
approval
permissive
detariffing
policy
see
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
short
contend
courts
must
defer
agency
choice
among
available
dictionary
definitions
citing
national
railroad
passenger
boston
maine
boston
maine
stand
proposition
case
involved
question
whether
statutory
term
required
mean
demanded
essential
also
mean
demanded
appropriate
holding
latter
permissible
interpretation
chevron
deference
owed
opinion
rely
exclusively
upon
dictionary
definitions
also
upon
contextual
indications
see
ibid
present
case
shall
see
contradict
petitioners
position
moreover
boston
maine
opinion
spoke
alternative
dictionary
definitions
ibid
refer
one
dictionary
whose
mci
telecommunications
suggested
meaning
contradicts
virtually
others
referred
alternative
definitions
within
dictionary
cited
webster
third
happens
represented
dictionary
giving
alternatives
contrary
said
alternative
interpretations
old
jurisprudence
citing
mcculloch
maryland
wheat
see
also
webster
new
international
dictionary
ed
new
shorter
oxford
english
dictionary
giving
alternatives
cases
verbal
ambiguity
statutes
involve
boston
maine
selection
accepted
alternative
meanings
shown
many
dictionaries
one
envision
though
case
immediately
come
mind
choose
accepted
alternative
meanings
one
newly
accepted
recorded
single
lexicographer
dictionary
must
first
record
widespread
use
projection
example
mean
forecast
petitioners
demand
accept
creating
ambiguity
rarity
even
rarer
meaning
set
forth
single
dictionary
say
progeny
supplements
meaning
contained
dictionaries
contradicts
one
meanings
contained
virtually
dictionaries
indeed
contradicts
one
alternative
meanings
contained
dictionary
observed
webster
third
defines
modify
connote
specifically
major
change
specifically
minor
change
hard
see
word
modify
come
mean
change
respects
change
fundamentally
fact
mean
neither
things
simply
mean
change
adverb
called
mci
telecommunications
service
indicate
great
small
degree
change
peculiar
webster
third
definition
means
suggest
happened
petitioners
suggest
appealing
webster
third
simply
disagree
modify
view
connotes
moderate
change
might
good
english
say
french
revolution
modified
status
french
nobility
figure
speech
called
understatement
literary
device
known
sarcasm
might
unsurprising
discover
white
house
press
release
saying
administration
modifying
position
regard
prosecution
war
vietnam
press
agents
tend
impart
nowadays
called
spin
intentional
distortions
simply
careless
ignorant
misuse
must
formed
basis
usage
webster
third
webster
third
alone
reported
perhaps
gilding
lily
add
communications
act
became
law
relevant
time
determining
statutory
term
meaning
see
perrin
webster
third
yet
even
contemplated
knowledge
english
dictionaries
provided
narrow
definition
modify
including
mci
telecommunications
published
merriam
company
see
webster
new
international
dictionary
ed
webster
collegiate
dictionary
ed
slightest
doubt
meaning
statute
intended
beyond
word
indication
authority
modify
contemplate
fundamental
changes
sole
exception
authority
section
provides
one
requirements
changes
filed
tariffs
made
days
notice
commission
public
exception
commission
modification
authority
follows
except
commission
may
require
notice
period
specified
paragraph
one
hundred
twenty
days
conceivable
statute
indifferent
commission
power
eliminate
tariff
filing
requirement
entirely
except
one
firm
long
distance
sector
yet
strains
gnat
extending
waiting
period
tariff
revision
beyond
days
think
exception
ridiculous
lilliputian
london
found
lilliput
world
modifications
big
deal
since
agency
interpretation
statute
entitled
deference
goes
beyond
meaning
statute
bear
see
pittston
coal
group
sebben
chevron
commission
permissive
detariffing
policy
justified
makes
less
radical
fundamental
change
act
tariff
filing
requirement
commission
attempt
establish
involved
greatly
understates
extent
policy
deviates
filing
requirement
greatly
undervalues
importance
filing
requirement
mci
telecommunications
consider
latter
point
first
body
law
body
person
whether
change
minor
major
depends
extent
upon
importance
item
changed
whole
loss
entire
toenail
insignificant
loss
entire
arm
tragic
tariff
filing
requirement
pursue
analogy
heart
common
carrier
section
communications
act
context
interstate
commerce
act
served
model
see
mci
telecommunications
fcc
cadc
repeatedly
stressed
rate
filing
congress
chosen
means
preventing
unreasonableness
discrimination
charges
relation
indissoluble
unity
provision
establishment
maintenance
rates
corrected
accordance
statute
prohibitions
preferences
discrimination
texas
pacific
abilene
cotton
oil
see
also
robinson
baltimore
ohio
duty
file
rates
commission
analog
obligation
charge
rates
analog
always
considered
essential
preventing
price
discrimination
stabilizing
rates
maislin
industries
primary
steel
see
also
arizona
grocery
atchison
filing
requirements
render
rates
definite
certain
prevent
discrimination
abuses
armour
packing
elimination
filing
requirement
opens
door
possibility
abuses
unequal
rates
design
statute
prohibit
punish
maislin
concluded
compliance
provisions
utterly
central
administration
act
quoting
regular
common
mci
telecommunications
carrier
conference
cadc
much
rest
communications
act
subchapter
applicable
common
carriers
see
act
procedural
administrative
provisions
premised
upon
tariff
filing
requirement
example
defines
overcharges
customers
entitled
recover
reference
filed
rate
see
provisions
allowing
customers
competitors
challenge
rates
unreasonable
discriminatory
see
susceptible
effective
enforcement
rates
publicly
filed
see
maislin
rate
filings
fact
essential
characteristic
industry
highly
unlikely
congress
leave
determination
whether
industry
entirely
even
substantially
agency
discretion
even
unlikely
achieve
subtle
device
permission
modify
rate
filing
requirements
bearing
mind
enormous
importance
statutory
scheme
tariff
filing
provision
turn
whether
occurred
considered
mere
modification
commission
stresses
detariffing
policy
applies
nondominant
carriers
rates
charged
half
mci
telecommunications
consumers
market
file
commission
clear
us
proportion
customers
affected
rather
proportion
carriers
affected
proper
measure
extent
exemption
course
carriers
long
distance
market
exempted
except
even
assuming
think
elimination
crucial
provision
statute
major
sector
industry
much
extensive
considered
modification
reality
fundamental
revision
statute
changing
scheme
rate
regulation
long
distance
common
carrier
communications
scheme
rate
regulation
effective
competition
exist
may
good
idea
idea
congress
enacted
law
apart
failure
qualify
modification
independent
reason
commission
detariffing
policy
come
within
authority
modify
provision
requires
commission
proceeds
general
order
opposed
acts
particular
instances
make
modification
order
apply
special
circumstances
conditions
although
somewhat
elastic
phrase
infinitely
hard
imagine
condition
shared
long
distance
customers
long
distance
carriers
except
one
qualifies
special
within
intent
limitation
mci
telecommunications
sides
dispute
contend
congress
manifested
later
legislation
agreement
respective
interpretations
communications
act
petitioners
point
amendment
act
require
operator
service
providers
osps
file
informational
tariffs
phased
four
years
see
telephone
operator
consumer
services
improvement
act
tocsia
stat
supp
iv
petitioners
reason
must
envision
background
permissive
filing
since
otherwise
permitted
informational
tariffs
even
rigorous
requirements
hand
claims
congress
manifested
agreement
position
recent
amendment
supp
gives
commission
authority
limit
tariff
filing
requirement
commercial
mobile
carriers
authority
unnecessary
commission
view
correct
conflicting
arguments
indicate
congress
aware
tug
war
commission
circuit
authority
relax
filing
requirements
different
times
proceeded
different
assumptions
win
consistent
history
legislation
one
interpretation
act
essential
rather
two
pieces
legislation
first
one
interpretation
act
congenial
enough
change
anything
mci
telecommunications
finally
petitioners
earnestly
urge
interpretation
furthers
communications
act
broad
purpose
promoting
efficient
telephone
service
claim
although
filing
requirement
prevented
price
discrimination
unfair
practices
maintained
monopoly
long
distances
service
frustrates
goals
greater
competition
market
specifically
contend
filing
costs
raise
artificial
barriers
entry
publication
rates
facilitates
parallel
pricing
stifles
price
competition
considerable
sympathy
arguments
though
doubt
makes
sense
one
concerned
use
filed
tariffs
communicate
pricing
information
require
filing
dominant
carrier
firm
likely
price
leader
policed
trade
associations
rate
bureaus
antitrust
laws
precisely
sharing
pricing
information
facilitate
price
fixing
see
sugar
institute
american
column
lumber
protected
regulated
firms
types
antitrust
suits
brought
basis
filed
rates
see
square
niagara
frontier
tariff
bureau
noted
earlier
term
considerable
debate
forums
wisdom
filed
rate
doctrine
securities
services
kmart
slip
broadly
value
continued
regulation
telecommunications
industry
estimations
commission
estimations
desirable
policy
alter
meaning
federal
communications
act
better
worse
act
establishes
rate
regulation
filed
tariff
system
common
carrier
communications
commission
desire
increase
competition
provide
authority
alter
mci
telecommunications
statutory
filed
rate
requirements
maislin
observed
context
dispute
filed
rate
doctrine
years
ago
considerations
address
congress
courts
armour
packing
mean
suggest
requirement
inviolate
commission
existing
modification
authority
reach
certainly
commission
modify
form
contents
location
required
filings
defer
filing
perhaps
even
waive
altogether
limited
circumstances
goes
well
beyond
effectively
introduction
whole
new
regime
regulation
competition
may
well
better
regime
one
congress
established
judgment
appeals
affirmed
justice
took
part
consideration
decision
cases
footnotes
petitioners
also
cite
webster
ninth
new
collegiate
dictionary
includes
among
definitions
modify
make
basic
fundamental
changes
often
give
new
orientation
serve
new
end
might
also
cited
webster
eighth
new
collegiate
dictionary
contains
definition
webster
seventh
new
collegiate
dictionary
contains
definition
webster
third
new
international
dictionary
quoted
text
webster
new
collegiate
dictionaries
published
merriam
company
springfield
massachusetts
essentially
abridgments
company
webster
new
international
dictionaries
recite
based
upon
lengthier
works
last
new
collegiate
based
upon
webster
second
new
international
rather
webster
third
include
basic
fundamental
change
among
accepted
meanings
modify
see
webster
new
collegiate
dictionary
ed
unlikely
hypothesis
upon
appearance
webster
third
widely
criticized
portrayal
common
error
proper
usage
see
follett
sabotage
springfield
atlantic
barzun
dictionary
american
scholar
spring
dwight
macdonald
string
unwound
new
yorker
mar
example
approval
without
qualification
use
infer
mean
imply
infer
give
reason
draw
inference
concerning
hint
take
part
debate
except
ask
question
inferring
constitution
must
changed
manchester
guardian
weekly
webster
third
new
international
dictionary
dissent
misrepresents
say
sentence
see
post
addresses
two
paragraphs
argument
made
simply
say
maislin
eliminating
tariff
filing
requirement
frustrate
complaint
proceedings
eliminating
requirements
indeed
even
eliminating
complaint
proceedings
frustrate
ultimate
purposes
act
perhaps
dissent
asserts
perhaps
even
eliminating
fcc
fcc
bound
ultimate
purposes
congress
selected
means
deemed
appropriate
prescribed
pursuit
purposes
dissent
suggests
ignore
subsection
act
prohibits
carriers
providing
service
absence
filed
rate
unless
provided
authority
chapter
dissent
asserts
phrase
must
refer
modification
authority
see
post
perhaps
though
contradict
interpretation
acknowledged
see
infra
might
limited
circumstances
mci
telecommunications
permit
commission
waive
filing
requirement
fact
easily
read
referring
express
exemption
connecting
carriers
authorization
services
carriers
pursuant
contractual
rates
exemptions
mobile
carriers
express
statutory
exemptions
filing
requirements
mci
telecommunications
justice
stevens
justice
blackmun
justice
souter
join
dissenting
communications
industry
unusually
dynamic
character
congress
authorized
federal
communications
commission
fcc
regulate
field
enterprise
dominant
characteristic
rapid
pace
unfolding
national
broadcasting
communications
act
act
gives
fcc
unusually
broad
discretion
meet
new
unanticipated
problems
order
fulfill
sweeping
mandate
make
available
far
possible
people
rapid
efficient
nationwide
worldwide
wire
radio
communication
service
adequate
facilities
reasonable
charges
consistent
interpretation
act
afforded
commission
mci
telecommunications
ample
leeway
interpret
apply
statutory
powers
responsibilities
see
southwestern
cable
fcc
pottsville
broadcasting
today
abandons
approach
favor
rigid
literalism
deprives
fcc
flexibility
congress
meant
order
implement
core
policies
act
rapidly
changing
conditions
time
communications
act
passed
telephone
industry
dominated
american
telephone
telegraph
company
affiliates
title
ii
act
establishes
framework
fcc
regulation
common
carriers
wire
clearly
response
dominance
senate
report
explained
nder
existing
provisions
interstate
commerce
act
regulation
telephone
monopoly
practically
nil
vast
monopoly
immediately
serves
needs
people
daily
social
life
must
effectively
regulated
wire
communications
provisions
act
address
problems
distinctly
associated
monopoly
section
requires
telephone
carriers
furnish
communication
service
upon
reasonable
request
therefor
mandates
charges
practices
classifications
regulations
reasonable
section
forbids
carriers
make
unjust
unreasonable
discrimination
charges
practices
mci
telecommunications
classifications
regulations
facilities
services
give
undue
unreasonable
preference
advantage
particular
person
class
persons
locality
commission
upon
complaint
motion
may
hold
hearings
upon
declare
lawfulness
proposed
rate
increases
may
prescribe
reasonable
charges
upon
finding
carriers
actual
proposed
charges
illegal
persons
damaged
carrier
violation
statute
right
damages
person
may
file
commission
complaint
violation
act
section
modeled
upon
filed
rate
provisions
interstate
commerce
act
see
supra
requires
common
carriers
connecting
carriers
file
commission
print
keep
open
public
inspection
schedules
showing
charges
connecting
carriers
telephone
carrier
must
allow
period
lead
time
tariff
goes
effect
unless
otherwise
provided
authority
act
may
provide
communication
services
except
according
filed
schedule
tariff
filing
section
communications
act
however
contains
proviso
changes
schedule
discretion
commission
modify
requirements
commission
may
discretion
good
cause
shown
modify
requirement
made
authority
section
either
particular
instances
general
order
applicable
special
circumstances
conditions
except
commission
may
require
notice
period
specified
paragraph
one
hundred
twenty
days
mci
telecommunications
supp
iv
ii
response
new
conditions
communications
industry
including
stirrings
competition
long
distance
telephone
market
fcc
began
reexamining
regulatory
scheme
commission
tentatively
concluded
costly
tariff
filing
requirements
unnecessary
actually
counterproductive
applied
nondominant
carriers
whose
lack
market
power
leaves
unable
extract
supracompetitive
discriminatory
rates
customers
see
competitive
carrier
rulemaking
relaxing
regulatory
burdens
upon
new
entrants
foster
competition
telecommunications
markets
time
forces
competition
ensure
firms
without
monopoly
power
comply
act
prohibitions
unreasonable
rates
price
discrimination
see
commission
explained
tariff
filing
obligations
nondominant
firms
simultaneously
superfluous
consumer
protection
device
since
competition
circumscribes
prices
practices
companies
inimical
price
competition
service
marketing
innovation
deregulation
telecommunications
services
accordingly
series
rulings
early
commission
issued
orders
progressively
exempting
specified
classes
nondominant
mci
telecommunications
carriers
obligation
file
tariff
schedules
see
second
report
order
third
report
order
commission
fourth
report
order
extended
reaffirmed
permissive
detariffing
policy
dominant
long
distance
carriers
must
file
tariff
schedules
whereas
nondominant
carriers
although
subject
act
prohibitions
unreasonable
rates
price
discrimination
may
need
file
instant
november
report
order
rcd
fcc
adhered
policy
excusing
nondominant
providers
long
distance
telephone
service
filing
requirement
codified
longstanding
forbearance
policy
commission
reaffirmed
commitment
adapt
regulation
telecommunications
common
carriers
changed
circumstances
competition
develop
regulatory
approach
furthers
purposes
act
fostering
innovation
efficient
development
telecommunications
industry
explained
view
permissive
detariffing
furthered
goals
since
initial
stages
detariffing
see
commission
found
principal
statutory
authority
detariffing
modify
requirement
language
rcd
ctual
experience
permissive
detariffing
including
increase
number
long
distance
carriers
decade
later
confirm
ed
success
fcc
approach
furthering
statutory
goals
communications
act
iii
although
majority
observes
relaxation
requirements
might
effectively
mci
telecommunications
enhance
competition
ante
take
issue
commission
conclusions
mandatory
filing
tariff
schedules
serves
useful
purpose
actually
counterproductive
case
carriers
lack
market
power
prior
detariffing
orders
see
nondominant
carrier
sought
charge
inflated
rates
customers
simply
move
carriers
rcd
moreover
absence
market
power
ordinarily
preclude
firms
kind
engaging
price
discrimination
see
sullivan
law
antitrust
firm
discriminate
unless
market
power
areeda
antitrust
law
pp
commission
plausibly
concluded
slight
enforcement
benefits
tariff
filing
requirement
might
offer
outweighed
burdens
put
new
entrants
consumers
thus
sole
question
us
whether
fcc
policy
however
sensible
nonetheless
inconsistent
act
view
commission
detariffing
orders
squarely
within
power
modify
requirement
subsection
plainly
confers
least
discretion
modify
general
rule
carriers
file
tariffs
speaks
requirement
subsection
act
ignored
squarely
supports
fcc
position
prohibits
carriers
providing
service
without
tariff
unless
otherwise
provided
authority
act
subsection
plainly
one
provision
otherwise
provides
thereby
authorizes
service
without
filed
schedule
fcc
authority
modify
requirements
particular
instances
mci
telecommunications
general
order
applicable
special
circumstances
conditions
emphasizes
expansive
character
commission
authority
modifications
may
narrow
broad
depending
upon
commission
appraisal
current
conditions
vantage
congress
seeking
regulate
almost
completely
monopolized
industry
advent
competition
surely
special
circumstance
condition
might
legitimately
call
different
regulatory
treatment
statutory
exception
commission
modification
authority
provides
may
extend
notice
period
set
see
act
thus
imposes
specific
limit
commission
authority
stiffen
regulatory
imposition
carriers
confine
commission
authority
relax
stretch
fcc
draw
single
unidirectional
statutory
limitation
modification
authority
inference
authority
otherwise
unlimited
see
rcd
according
term
modify
explicated
unreliable
dictionaries
ante
rules
commission
claimed
authority
relieve
nondominant
carriers
basic
obligation
file
tariffs
dictionaries
useful
aides
statutory
interpretation
substitute
close
analysis
words
mean
used
particular
statutory
context
cf
cabell
markham
hand
even
sole
possible
meaning
modify
make
minor
changes
ante
elaboration
needed
mci
telecommunications
show
detariffing
policy
fail
commission
came
present
policy
series
rulings
gradually
relaxed
filing
requirements
nondominant
carriers
whether
current
policy
count
cataclysmic
merely
incremental
departure
baseline
depends
whether
one
focuses
particular
carriers
obligations
file
case
commission
policy
arguably
works
major
shift
statutory
policies
behind
tariff
filing
requirement
remain
satisfied
market
constraints
nondominant
carriers
obviate
need
rate
filing
viewed
part
statute
whose
aim
constrain
monopoly
power
commission
decision
exempt
nondominant
carriers
rational
measured
adjustment
novel
circumstances
one
remains
faithful
core
purpose
tariff
filing
section
see
black
law
dictionary
ed
defining
modification
change
alteration
introduces
new
elements
details
cancels
leaves
general
purpose
effect
intact
seizes
upon
particular
sense
word
modify
expense
another
meaning
fully
supports
commission
position
word
first
defined
webster
collegiate
dictionary
ed
meaning
limit
reduce
extent
degree
commission
permissive
mci
telecommunications
detariffing
policy
fits
comfortably
within
common
understanding
term
effect
adopted
general
rule
stating
dominant
must
file
nondominant
need
commission
partial
detariffing
policy
excuses
nondominant
carriers
filing
condition
remain
nondominant
simply
relaxation
costly
regulatory
requirement
recent
developments
rendered
pointless
counterproductive
certain
class
cases
modification
pursuant
like
order
issued
act
must
course
consistent
purposes
statute
point
asserts
act
prohibition
unreasonable
discriminatory
rates
susceptible
effective
enforcement
rates
publicly
filed
ante
determination
course
commission
make
first
instance
commission
repeatedly
explained
carrier
lacks
market
power
entirely
unlikely
charge
unreasonable
discriminatory
rates
ii
statutory
bans
unreasonable
charges
price
discrimination
mci
telecommunications
apply
full
force
regardless
whether
carriers
file
tariffs
iii
suspected
violations
nondominant
carriers
addressed
commission
motion
damages
complaint
filed
pursuant
iv
fcc
reimpose
tariff
requirement
violations
occur
see
rcd
adequately
respond
fcc
explanations
gives
reason
whatsoever
doubt
commission
considered
judgment
tariff
filing
altogether
unnecessary
case
competitive
carriers
see
rcd
majority
ineffective
enforcement
argument
lacks
evidentiary
historical
support
argument
also
demonstrably
incorrect
contemporary
cousin
communications
act
price
discrimination
act
enacted
contains
much
broader
prohibition
price
discrimination
communications
act
statute
performed
mission
almost
years
without
counterpart
filed
rate
doctrine
indeed
substantive
requirements
title
ii
communications
act
apply
connecting
carriers
even
though
exempts
carriers
tariff
filing
provisions
see
national
assn
regulatory
utility
commr
cadc
cert
denied
small
fraction
competitive
carriers
mci
telecommunications
existed
represents
market
growth
occurred
detariffing
policy
effect
without
indication
absence
filed
schedules
produced
discriminatory
unreasonable
pricing
nondominant
carriers
extolling
enormous
importance
filed
rates
ante
resorting
dictionary
definitions
colorful
metaphors
unsatisfactory
substitutes
reasoned
explanation
statute
requires
rate
filing
even
practice
serves
useful
purpose
actually
harms
consumers
filed
tariff
provisions
communications
act
ends
merely
one
several
procedural
means
commission
ensure
carriers
charge
unreasonable
discriminatory
rates
see
commission
reasonably
concluded
particular
means
enforcing
statute
substantive
mandates
prove
counterproductive
case
nondominant
long
distance
carriers
even
congress
define
scope
commission
modification
authority
perfect
scholarly
precision
surely
paradigm
case
judicial
deference
agency
interpretation
particularly
statutory
regime
obviously
meant
maximize
administrative
flexibility
mci
telecommunications
whatever
best
reading
commission
reading
view
termed
unreasonable
informed
practical
understanding
role
lack
thereof
filed
tariffs
play
modern
regulatory
climate
telecommunications
industry
since
fcc
sought
adapt
measures
originally
designed
control
monopoly
power
new
market
conditions
carefully
consistently
explained
mandatory
tariff
filing
rules
frustrate
core
statutory
interest
rate
reasonableness
commission
use
discretion
expressly
conferred
reflects
reasonable
accommodation
manifestly
competing
interests
entitled
deference
regulatory
scheme
technical
complex
agency
considered
matter
detailed
reasoned
fashion
decision
involves
reconciling
conflicting
policies
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
footnotes
omitted
fcc
permissibly
interpreted
authority
service
goals
congress
set
forth
communications
act
sustain
eminently
sound
uncommonly
well
explained
judgment
respectfully
dissent
see
investigation
telephone
industry
sess
chronicling
bell
system
development
nationwide
unified
system
monopolize
telephone
part
national
communication
field
prevention
elimination
effective
competition
see
also
xxxi
telephone
business
monopoly
supposed
regulated
subsection
must
merely
allow
commission
dictate
form
contents
tariff
filings
separately
grants
authority
petitioner
mci
points
revolutionary
consent
decree
providing
breakup
bell
system
per
proposal
entitled
modification
final
judgment
see
american
tel
tel
aff
statute
imposes
limit
commission
authority
shorten
interval
filing
tariff
bringing
effect
sign
anyone
actually
pays
attention
tariffs
filed
nondominant
carriers
additional
step
eliminating
filing
requirement
less
important
even
appears
recognize
commission
sometimes
excuse
carriers
filing
tariffs
see
ante
see
also
oxford
english
dictionary
ed
alter
direction
moderation
lenity
make
less
severe
mci
telecommunications
rigorous
decided
qualify
tone
donne
mariana
modefies
doctrine
prince
execute
clergy
man
though
hee
deser
random
house
dictionary
english
language
ed
reduce
lessen
degree
extent
moderate
soften
modify
one
demands
webster
third
new
international
dictionary
make
temperate
less
extreme
lessen
severity
traffic
rules
modified
let
pass
webster
new
collegiate
dictionary
make
less
extreme
moderate
webster
seventh
new
collegiate
dictionary
webster
new
international
dictionary
ed
reduce
extent
degree
moderate
qualify
lower
modify
heat
pain
punishment
webster
american
dictionary
english
language
moderate
qualify
reduce
extent
degree
grace
modifies
first
severe
decree
dryden
suggests
commission
detariffing
policy
disrupts
statutory
scheme
defines
recoverable
overcharges
reference
filed
tariffs
see
ante
overcharge
suits
definition
depend
presence
tariffs
means
aggrieved
telephone
customers
recover
section
allows
recover
damages
carriers
violated
act
turn
existence
tariff
see
also
majority
considers
unlikely
congress
conferred
power
commission
exempt
carriers
supposedly
pivotal
rate
filing
obligation
see
ante
surely
delegation
place
statute
also
empowers
fcc
example
decide
public
convenience
interest
necessity
requires
see
prescribe
rules
regulations
may
necessary
public
interest
see
also
rigid
reading
step
prior
recognition
act
meant
supple
instrument
exercise
discretion
expert
body
congress
charged
carry
legislative
policy
fcc
pottsville
broadcasting
page