security
industrial
bank
argued
october
decided
november
provision
bankruptcy
reform
act
supp
permits
individual
debtors
bankruptcy
proceedings
avoid
nonpossessory
liens
certain
property
including
household
furnishings
appliances
appellees
loaned
individual
debtors
money
obtained
perfected
liens
debtors
household
furnishings
appliances
act
enacted
subsequently
debtors
instituted
separate
bankruptcy
proceedings
act
sections
exempt
household
items
property
included
within
debtors
estates
debtors
claimed
exemptions
relying
avoid
liens
bankruptcy
courts
refused
apply
retroactively
abrogate
liens
appeals
consolidated
appeals
affirmed
holding
although
act
intended
apply
retrospectively
thus
designed
invalidate
liens
acquired
enactment
date
application
violates
takings
clause
fifth
amendment
held
section
intended
applied
retrospectively
destroy
property
rights
pp
substantial
doubt
whether
retroactive
destruction
appellee
liens
comport
fifth
amendment
cardinal
principle
first
determine
whether
construction
statute
fairly
possible
constitutional
question
may
avoided
warrants
consideration
whether
matter
statutory
construction
must
necessarily
applied
retroactively
pp
bankruptcy
law
shall
construed
eliminate
property
rights
existed
law
enacted
absence
explicit
command
congress
light
principle
absence
clear
expression
congress
intent
apply
property
rights
established
enactment
date
statute
construed
manner
call
upon
resolve
difficult
sensitive
questions
arising
guarantees
takings
clause
pp
rehnquist
delivered
opinion
burger
white
powell
stevens
joined
blackmun
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
brennan
marshall
joined
post
alan
horowitz
argued
cause
briefs
solicitor
general
lee
assistant
attorney
general
mcgrath
deputy
solicitor
general
geller
henry
field
argued
cause
appellees
briefs
appellee
beneficial
finance
kansas
abe
fortas
phil
neal
joseph
berl
michael
katch
filed
brief
appellees
security
industrial
bank
et
al
justice
rehnquist
delivered
opinion
case
concerns
effect
supp
permits
individual
debtors
bankruptcy
proceedings
avoid
liens
certain
property
appeals
consolidated
seven
appeals
bankruptcy
courts
districts
kansas
colorado
case
debtor
individual
instituted
bankruptcy
proceedings
bankruptcy
reform
act
pub
stat
act
became
effective
october
case
one
appellees
loaned
debtor
money
obtained
perfected
lien
debtor
household
furnishings
appliances
act
enacted
november
none
liens
possessory
none
secured
obligations
included
within
personal
property
subject
appellees
liens
household
items
exempt
property
included
within
debtors
estates
virtue
subsections
debtors
claimed
exemptions
respective
bankruptcy
proceedings
relying
avoid
liens
section
provides
notwithstanding
waiver
exemptions
debtor
may
avoid
fixing
lien
interest
debtor
property
extent
lien
impairs
exemption
debtor
entitled
subsection
section
lien
nonpossessory
security
interest
household
furnishings
household
goods
wearing
apparel
appliances
books
animals
crops
musical
instruments
jewelry
held
primarily
personal
family
household
use
debtor
dependent
debtor
implements
professional
books
tools
trade
debtor
trade
dependent
debtor
professionally
prescribed
health
aids
debtor
dependent
debtor
appeals
consolidated
cases
affirmed
judgments
bankruptcy
courts
held
act
intended
apply
retrospectively
thus
designed
invalidate
liens
acquired
enactment
date
also
held
however
application
violates
fifth
amendment
stated
effects
complete
taking
secured
creditors
property
interests
thus
invalid
louisville
joint
stock
land
bank
radford
appealed
noted
probable
jurisdiction
appellees
course
defend
judgment
appeals
government
argues
length
retrospective
application
liens
violate
fifth
amendment
contends
enactment
rational
exercise
congress
bankruptcy
power
bankruptcy
purposes
property
interests
indistinguishable
contractual
interests
particular
interests
insubstantial
therefore
destruction
amount
taking
property
requiring
compensation
decide
constitutional
question
reached
appeals
address
determine
whether
attack
retrospective
application
statute
raises
substantial
enough
constitutional
doubts
warrant
employment
canon
statutory
construction
referred
infra
may
readily
agreed
rational
exercise
congress
authority
art
cl
authority
regularly
construed
authorize
retrospective
impairment
contractual
obligations
hanover
national
bank
moyses
agreement
however
obviate
additional
difficulty
arises
power
sought
used
defeat
traditional
property
interests
bankruptcy
power
subject
fifth
amendment
prohibition
taking
private
property
without
compensation
louisville
joint
stock
land
bank
radford
supra
thus
however
rational
exercise
bankruptcy
power
may
inquiry
quite
separate
question
whether
enactment
takes
property
within
prohibition
fifth
amendment
government
apparently
contends
brief
cases
arnett
kennedy
goldberg
kelly
defined
property
purposes
due
process
clause
sufficiently
broadly
include
rights
common
law
deemed
contractual
traditional
property
rights
entitled
greater
protection
takings
clause
traditional
contract
rights
argues
bankruptcy
principles
support
sharp
distinction
rights
secured
unsecured
creditors
brief
however
bankruptcy
principles
may
speak
question
cases
recognize
common
law
contractual
right
secured
creditor
obtain
repayment
debt
may
quite
different
legal
contemplation
property
right
creditor
collateral
compare
hanover
national
bank
moyses
supra
louisville
joint
stock
land
bank
radford
supra
kaiser
aetna
since
governmental
action
result
complete
destruction
property
right
secured
party
case
fits
awkwardly
analytic
framework
employed
penn
central
transportation
new
york
city
pruneyard
shopping
center
robins
governmental
action
affected
bundle
rights
constitute
property
question
government
argues
interest
secured
party
involved
insubstantial
apparently
part
nonpossessory
interest
personal
property
bundle
rights
accrues
secured
party
obviously
smaller
accrues
owner
fee
simple
government
cites
cases
supporting
proposition
differences
relegate
secured
party
interest
something
less
property
decisions
radford
supra
armstrong
militate
proposition
radford
held
act
stat
violated
takings
clause
bank
held
mortgage
radford
farm
radford
defaulted
instituted
bankruptcy
proceedings
act
terms
applied
retrospectively
permitted
debtor
purchase
property
less
fair
market
value
held
statute
void
effected
taking
substantive
rights
specific
property
acquired
bank
prior
enactment
opinion
justice
brandeis
stated
fifth
amendment
commands
however
great
nation
need
private
property
shall
thus
taken
even
wholly
public
use
without
compensation
public
interest
requires
permits
taking
property
individual
mortgagees
order
relieve
necessities
individual
mortgagors
resort
must
proceedings
eminent
domain
taxation
burden
relief
afforded
public
interest
may
borne
public
total
destruction
government
value
liens
constitute
compensable
property
every
possible
element
fifth
amendment
taking
mere
consequential
incidence
valid
regulatory
measure
government
finally
contends
resale
value
household
goods
generally
low
creditors
therefore
view
principal
value
security
lever
negotiate
reaffirmation
debt
rather
vehicle
foreclosure
property
interests
involved
merit
protection
takings
clause
contention
dismissed
hand
seems
run
counter
state
characterization
interest
property
see
supra
reliance
takings
cases
characterizations
see
kaiser
aetna
also
least
implications
radford
supra
armstrong
supra
foregoing
discussion
satisfies
us
substantial
doubt
whether
retroactive
destruction
appellees
liens
case
comports
fifth
amendment
consider
whether
matter
statutory
construction
must
necessarily
applied
manner
consider
statutory
question
cardinal
principle
first
ascertain
whether
construction
statute
fairly
possible
constitutional
question
may
avoided
lorillard
pons
quoting
crowell
benson
appeals
thought
must
apply
retroactively
liens
attached
enactment
date
bankruptcy
law
applicable
cases
involving
liens
apparently
thought
apply
liens
came
existence
enactment
date
part
act
apply
cases
involving
liens
necessarily
case
liens
course
exist
state
law
independently
act
although
act
general
effective
cases
commenced
effective
date
congress
might
intended
provisions
destroy
previously
vested
property
rights
apply
interests
came
effect
enactment
date
provision
remainder
act
affect
enforceability
liens
still
apply
liens
cases
think
analysis
appeals
adequately
dispose
question
retrospective
effect
therefore
pursue
inquiry
principle
statutes
operate
prospectively
judicial
decisions
operate
retrospectively
familiar
every
law
student
compare
sands
sutherland
statutory
construction
ed
linkletter
walker
often
pointed
first
rule
construction
legislation
must
considered
addressed
future
past
rule
expressed
varying
degrees
strength
always
one
import
retrospective
operation
given
statute
interferes
antecedent
rights
unless
unequivocal
inflexible
import
terms
manifest
intention
legislature
union
pacific
laramie
stock
yards
citations
omitted
principle
repeatedly
applied
bankruptcy
statutes
affecting
property
rights
holt
henley
new
statute
granting
bankruptcy
trustees
position
lienholder
priority
sellers
conditional
sales
contracts
act
june
ch
stat
provision
like
read
literally
divest
property
interests
created
enacted
statute
like
act
applied
bankruptcy
cases
instituted
became
effective
nonetheless
followed
lead
lower
courts
refusing
infer
retroactivity
absent
explicitly
expressed
intent
congress
arctic
ice
machine
armstrong
county
trust
see
also
schneider
ed
opinion
unanimous
justice
holmes
stated
reasonable
usual
interpretation
bankruptcy
statutes
confine
effect
far
may
property
rights
established
passed
see
rasin
government
nonetheless
contends
bankruptcy
statutes
usually
construed
apply
rights
statement
unobjectionable
context
traditional
contract
rights
hanover
national
bank
moyses
none
cases
cited
government
extend
property
rights
involved
neither
cases
come
attention
casts
doubt
principle
statutory
construction
deducible
holt
bankruptcy
law
shall
construed
eliminate
property
rights
existed
law
enacted
absence
explicit
command
congress
light
principle
legislative
history
act
suggests
congress
may
intended
operate
destroy
property
rights
early
version
act
contained
explicit
requirement
provisions
shall
apply
cases
proceedings
instituted
effective
date
regardless
date
occurrence
operative
facts
determining
legal
rights
duties
liabilities
hereunder
sess
reprinted
bankruptcy
act
revision
hearings
subcommittee
civil
constitutional
rights
house
committee
judiciary
appendix
provision
may
may
deleted
directly
response
comments
witness
william
plumb
effect
retroactive
invalidation
liens
may
unconstitutional
taking
nonetheless
congress
elimination
explicit
command
evidence
intend
depart
usual
principle
construction
see
bradley
richmond
school
board
reluctant
read
statute
limitation
congress
eliminated
accordingly
absence
clear
expression
congress
intent
apply
property
rights
established
enactment
date
decline
construe
act
manner
turn
call
upon
resolve
difficult
sensitive
questions
arising
guarantees
takings
clause
nlrb
catholic
bishop
chicago
judgment
appeals
must
therefore
affirmed
footnotes
subsections
provide
pertinent
part
individual
debtor
may
exempt
property
estate
property
specified
subsection
section
following
property
may
exempted
subsection
section
debtor
interest
exceed
value
particular
item
household
furnishings
household
goods
wearing
apparel
appliances
books
animals
crops
musical
instruments
held
primarily
personal
family
household
use
debtor
dependent
debtor
debtor
aggregate
interest
exceed
value
jewelry
held
primarily
personal
family
household
use
debtor
dependent
debtor
debtor
aggregate
interest
exceed
value
implements
professional
books
tools
trade
debtor
trade
dependent
debtor
professionally
prescribed
health
aids
debtor
dependent
debtor
see
schulte
beneficial
finance
kansas
hunter
beneficial
finance
kansas
bankruptcy
district
kansas
noted
retrospective
application
creates
constitutional
problems
held
applied
prospectively
jackson
security
industrial
bank
stevens
liberty
loan
rodrock
security
industrial
bank
knezel
security
industrial
bank
bankruptcy
district
colorado
concluded
applied
retrospectively
violates
due
process
clause
fifth
amendment
hoops
freedom
finance
bankruptcy
district
colorado
concluded
applied
retrospectively
violates
substantive
due
process
gifford
en
banc
holds
constitutionally
applies
liens
created
enactment
date
webber
holds
constitutionally
applies
liens
created
act
became
effective
enactment
date
ashe
holds
permits
avoidance
certain
judicial
liens
constitutionally
applies
cognovit
note
created
enactment
date
appellee
beneficial
finance
kansas
asserts
judgments
affirmed
act
violates
art
iii
constitution
granting
judicial
power
iii
bankruptcy
judges
see
northern
pipeline
construction
marathon
pipe
line
plurality
opinion
brennan
rehnquist
concurring
judgment
decision
northern
pipeline
prospective
stayed
issuance
mandate
case
december
post
decision
affect
judgment
case
oral
argument
government
conceded
liens
issue
case
treated
property
state
law
tr
oral
arg
kansas
colorado
adopted
uniform
commercial
code
although
code
priority
among
secured
parties
often
affected
possessory
character
security
interests
see
characterizations
affect
nature
security
interest
see
defining
purchase
money
security
interest
providing
perfection
security
interests
possession
section
act
defines
lien
charge
interest
property
secure
payment
debt
performance
obligation
make
distinctions
based
possessory
nature
lien
act
permitted
farmer
mortgagee
assented
purchase
property
value
deferred
payment
plan
mortgagee
refused
assent
required
stay
proceedings
five
years
time
farmer
retain
possession
paying
reasonable
rent
five
years
property
reappraised
farmer
still
right
purchase
free
clear
appraised
value
regardless
amount
lien
see
radford
given
interest
rate
present
value
deferred
payments
much
less
value
property
uniform
commercial
code
definition
statutory
liens
nonpossessory
liens
personal
property
see
supra
transition
provisions
statute
stat
substance
act
pub
title
iv
stat
claridge
apartments
commissioner
involved
rights
certain
tax
benefits
property
rights
dickinson
industrial
site
cowan
dealt
application
new
procedural
rules
bankruptcy
proceeding
pending
new
statute
enacted
allowing
appeal
circuit
appeals
rather
district
case
eliminate
property
rights
carpenter
wabash
involved
provision
giving
personal
injury
judgments
status
operating
expenses
thus
priority
mortgages
ongoing
railroad
reorganizations
although
statute
may
disadvantaged
mortgages
reducing
amount
cash
available
pay
notes
affect
property
right
collateral
securing
mortgages
mcfaddin
considered
curative
statute
providing
methods
valid
mortgages
created
indian
territory
legal
tender
cases
wall
decided
debts
paid
legal
tender
defined
congress
time
payment
without
impairing
obligation
contracts
liens
issue
case
established
enactment
date
occasion
consider
whether
applied
liens
established
congress
passed
act
became
effective
aid
construction
meaning
words
used
statute
available
certainly
rule
law
forbids
use
however
clear
words
may
appear
superficial
examination
obviously
danger
courts
conclusion
legislative
purpose
unconsciously
influenced
judges
views
factors
considered
enacting
body
lively
appreciation
danger
best
assurance
escape
threat
hardly
justifies
acceptance
literal
interpretation
dogma
withholds
courts
available
information
reaching
correct
conclusion
words
general
connotation
appearing
text
statutes
given
wide
meaning
contrary
settled
policy
excepting
different
purpose
plainly
shown
american
trucking
footnotes
omitted
justice
blackmun
justice
brennan
justice
marshall
join
concurring
judgment
case
concerns
bankruptcy
act
et
seq
supp
particular
exemption
provisions
act
specifically
issue
effect
certain
exemption
provisions
upon
nonpossessory
obligations
given
debtors
small
loan
companies
enactment
act
purported
liens
apply
generally
specifically
property
kind
described
practicable
matter
nothing
prevent
debtor
selling
property
replacing
replacing
chooses
section
first
time
established
set
federal
exemptions
individual
debtors
concededly
section
similar
statutes
enacted
protect
debtor
essential
needs
enable
fresh
start
economically
section
permits
debtor
avoid
fixing
nonpossessory
security
interest
certain
property
subsection
extend
property
otherwise
exempt
limited
certain
personal
items
household
furnishings
wearing
apparel
jewelry
tools
debtor
trade
professionally
prescribed
health
aids
naturally
struggles
question
application
new
exemption
provisions
obligations
created
new
act
notes
concern
constitutional
problems
also
greets
obvious
relief
possibility
construing
act
prospective
operation
quickly
pursues
latter
route
order
avoid
constitutional
issue
understand
sympathize
desire
thus
resolve
case
usually
much
easier
construe
statute
avoid
constitutional
issue
resolve
constitutional
issue
course
cases
announced
feasible
preferred
method
see
lorillard
pons
writing
clean
slate
however
pursue
case
principle
think
case
deserve
consideration
greater
depth
see
nothing
statute
concerned
speaks
hints
prospective
applicability
compels
find
necessary
reach
constitutional
issue
resolve
issue
favor
debtor
creditor
exemptions
question
limited
kinds
property
values
amount
loaned
little
relationship
value
property
asserted
lien
interests
come
close
contracts
adhesion
repossessions
small
loan
companies
kind
situation
rare
purpose
statute
salutary
give
debtor
fresh
start
minimum
necessities
creditor
abuse
congress
merely
adjusted
priorities
taken
government
use
public
use
exemption
provisions
question
affect
remedy
debt
security
interest
seems
little
direct
value
weight
right
appears
useful
mainly
convenient
tool
threaten
debtor
reaffirm
underlying
obligation
statute
essentially
economic
regulation
insubstantial
element
precedent
favorable
debtor
found
cases
penn
central
transp
new
york
city
pruneyard
shopping
center
robins
writing
clean
slate
seems
case
holt
henley
precisely
point
unless
chooses
overrule
must
control
present
case
holt
eventual
bankrupt
signed
agreement
installation
automatic
sprinkler
system
property
eventual
bankrupt
agreement
specified
system
remain
holt
property
paid
right
enter
remove
upon
failure
pay
agreed
thereafter
also
mortgage
deed
executed
covering
plant
acquired
placed
upon
said
premises
continuance
trust
section
act
june
ch
stat
amended
bankruptcy
act
give
trustee
bankruptcy
property
coming
custody
bankruptcy
rights
creditor
holding
lien
upon
holt
debtor
bankruptcy
mortgagees
claimed
sprinkler
system
justice
holmes
writing
unanimous
observed
amendment
holt
better
title
trustees
got
opinion
act
construed
impair
went
need
consider
whether
far
event
constitutional
power
congress
limited
enough
reasonable
usual
interpretation
statutes
confine
effect
far
may
property
rights
established
passed
familiar
natural
mode
interpretation
opinion
holt
title
affected
enactment
later
date
conditional
sale
opposite
construction
simply
extend
remedy
impute
act
congress
intent
take
away
rights
lawfully
retained
unimpeachable
moment
took
start
holt
henley
thus
also
involved
agreement
subsequent
change
bankruptcy
act
preservation
right
see
way
distinguish
case
one
affirm
judgment
appeals
simply
compelling
authority
holt
henley
see
also
rasin
much
prefer
avoid
way
dicta
enunciates
respect
takings