nixon
argued
july
decided
july
together
nixon
president
also
certiorari
judgment
following
indictment
alleging
violation
federal
statutes
certain
staff
members
white
house
political
supporters
president
special
prosecutor
filed
motion
fed
rule
crim
proc
subpoena
duces
tecum
production
trial
certain
tapes
documents
relating
precisely
identified
conversations
meetings
president
others
president
claiming
executive
privilege
filed
motion
quash
subpoena
district
treating
subpoenaed
material
presumptively
privileged
concluded
special
prosecutor
made
sufficient
showing
rebut
presumption
requirements
rule
satisfied
thereafter
issued
order
camera
examination
subpoenaed
material
rejected
president
contentions
dispute
special
prosecutor
nonjusticiable
conflict
judiciary
lacked
authority
review
president
assertion
executive
privilege
stayed
order
pending
appellate
review
president
sought
appeals
special
prosecutor
filed
petition
writ
certiorari
judgment
president
filed
writ
challenging
action
granted
petitions
held
district
order
appealable
final
order
therefore
properly
appeals
petition
certiorari
judgment
filed
properly
review
although
order
normally
final
subject
appeal
exception
made
limited
class
cases
denial
immediate
review
render
impossible
review
whatsoever
individual
claims
ryan
exception
proper
unique
circumstances
case
inappropriate
subject
president
procedure
securing
review
resisting
order
inappropriate
require
district
proceed
traditional
contempt
citation
order
provide
appellate
review
pp
dispute
special
prosecutor
president
presents
justiciable
controversy
pp
mere
assertion
dispute
without
defeat
federal
jurisdiction
icc
attorney
general
regulation
conferred
upon
special
prosecutor
unique
tenure
authority
represent
given
special
prosecutor
explicit
power
contest
invocation
executive
privilege
seeking
evidence
deemed
relevant
performance
specially
delegated
duties
regulation
remains
effect
executive
branch
bound
ex
rel
accardi
shaughnessy
pp
action
special
prosecutor
within
scope
express
authority
seeking
specified
evidence
preliminarily
determined
relevant
admissible
pending
criminal
case
president
assertion
privilege
opposition
thereto
present
issues
type
traditionally
justiciable
icc
supra
fact
litigants
officers
executive
branch
bar
justiciability
pp
examination
material
submitted
special
prosecutor
support
motion
subpoena
much
seal
clear
district
denial
motion
quash
comported
rule
special
prosecutor
made
sufficient
showing
justify
subpoena
production
trial
pp
neither
doctrine
separation
powers
generalized
need
confidentiality
communications
without
sustain
absolute
unqualified
presidential
privilege
immunity
judicial
process
circumstances
see
marbury
madison
cranch
baker
carr
absent
claim
need
protect
military
diplomatic
sensitive
national
security
secrets
confidentiality
presidential
communications
significantly
diminished
producing
material
criminal
trial
protected
conditions
camera
inspection
absolute
executive
privilege
art
ii
constitution
plainly
conflict
function
courts
constitution
pp
although
courts
afford
utmost
deference
presidential
acts
performance
art
ii
function
burr
cas
claim
presidential
privilege
materials
subpoenaed
use
criminal
trial
based
ground
military
diplomatic
secrets
implicated
merely
ground
generalized
interest
confidentiality
president
generalized
assertion
privilege
must
yield
demonstrated
specific
need
evidence
pending
criminal
trial
fundamental
demands
due
process
law
fair
administration
criminal
justice
pp
basis
examination
record
concluded
district
erred
ordering
camera
examination
subpoenaed
material
shall
forthwith
transmitted
district
pp
since
president
communications
encompass
vastly
wider
range
sensitive
material
true
ordinary
individual
public
interest
requires
presidential
confidentiality
afforded
greatest
protection
consistent
fair
administration
justice
district
heavy
responsibility
ensure
material
involving
presidential
conversations
irrelevant
inadmissible
criminal
prosecution
accorded
high
degree
respect
due
president
material
returned
seal
lawful
custodian
released
special
prosecutor
camera
material
released
anyone
pp
burger
delivered
opinion
members
joined
except
rehnquist
took
part
consideration
decision
cases
leon
jaworski
philip
lacovara
argued
cause
filed
briefs
cases
james
clair
argued
cause
president
cases
briefs
charles
alan
wright
leonard
garment
michael
sterlacci
jerome
murphy
loren
smith
james
prochnow
theodore
garrish
james
tansey
larry
gutterridge
william
snow
frates
andrew
hall
spencer
boyer
henry
jones
filed
brief
respondent
ehrlichman
john
bray
filed
brief
respondent
strachan
fn
norman
dorsen
melvin
wulf
filed
brief
american
civil
liberties
union
amicus
curiae
urging
affirmance
district
judgment
chief
justice
burger
delivered
opinion
litigation
presents
review
denial
motion
filed
district
behalf
president
case
mitchell
crim
quash
subpoena
duces
tecum
issued
district
district
columbia
pursuant
fed
rule
crim
proc
subpoena
directed
president
produce
certain
tape
recordings
documents
relating
conversations
aides
advisers
rejected
president
claims
absolute
executive
privilege
lack
jurisdiction
failure
satisfy
requirements
rule
president
appealed
appeals
granted
petition
certiorari
judgment
also
president
certiorari
judgment
public
importance
issues
presented
need
prompt
resolution
march
grand
jury
district
district
columbia
returned
indictment
charging
seven
named
individuals
various
offenses
including
conspiracy
defraud
obstruct
justice
although
designated
indictment
grand
jury
named
president
among
others
unindicted
coconspirator
april
upon
motion
special
prosecutor
see
infra
subpoena
duces
tecum
issued
pursuant
rule
president
district
made
returnable
may
subpoena
required
production
advance
september
trial
date
certain
tapes
memoranda
papers
transcripts
writings
relating
certain
precisely
identified
meetings
president
others
special
prosecutor
able
fix
time
place
persons
present
discussions
white
house
daily
logs
appointment
records
delivered
april
president
publicly
released
edited
transcripts
conversations
portions
conversations
subject
subpoena
present
case
included
may
president
counsel
filed
special
appearance
motion
quash
subpoena
rule
motion
accompanied
formal
claim
privilege
subsequent
hearing
motions
expunge
grand
jury
action
naming
president
unindicted
coconspirator
protective
orders
disclosure
information
filed
raised
orally
counsel
president
may
district
denied
motion
quash
motions
expunge
protective
orders
supp
ordered
president
subordinate
officer
official
employee
custody
control
documents
objects
subpoenaed
deliver
district
may
originals
subpoenaed
items
well
index
analysis
items
together
tape
copies
portions
subpoenaed
recordings
transcripts
released
public
president
april
district
rejected
jurisdictional
challenges
based
contention
dispute
nonjusticiable
special
prosecutor
chief
executive
hence
character
also
rejected
contention
judiciary
without
authority
review
assertion
executive
privilege
president
rejection
first
challenge
based
authority
powers
vested
special
prosecutor
regulation
promulgated
attorney
general
concluded
justiciable
controversy
presented
second
challenge
held
foreclosed
decision
nixon
sirica
app
district
held
judiciary
president
final
arbiter
claim
executive
privilege
concluded
circumstances
case
presumptive
privilege
overcome
special
prosecutor
prima
facie
demonstration
need
sufficiently
compelling
warrant
judicial
examination
chambers
held
finally
special
prosecutor
satisfied
requirements
rule
district
stayed
order
pending
appellate
review
condition
review
sought
may
provided
matters
filed
seal
remain
seal
transmitted
part
record
may
president
filed
timely
notice
appeal
district
order
certified
record
district
docketed
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
day
president
also
filed
petition
writ
mandamus
appeals
seeking
review
district
order
later
may
special
prosecutor
also
filed
petition
writ
certiorari
judgment
may
petition
granted
expedited
briefing
schedule
june
president
filed
seal
writ
certiorari
judgment
granted
june
case
set
argument
july
jurisdiction
finality
requirements
embodies
strong
congressional
policy
piecemeal
reviews
obstructing
impeding
ongoing
judicial
proceeding
interlocutory
appeals
see
cobbledick
requirement
ordinarily
promotes
judicial
efficiency
hastens
ultimate
termination
litigation
applying
principle
order
denying
motion
quash
requiring
production
evidence
pursuant
subpoena
duces
tecum
repeatedly
held
order
final
hence
appealable
ryan
cobbledick
supra
alexander
consistently
held
necessity
expedition
administration
criminal
law
justifies
putting
one
seeks
resist
production
desired
information
choice
compliance
trial
order
produce
prior
review
order
resistance
order
concomitant
possibility
adjudication
contempt
claims
rejected
appeal
ryan
supra
traditional
contempt
avenue
immediate
appeal
peculiarly
inappropriate
due
unique
setting
question
arises
require
president
place
posture
disobeying
order
merely
trigger
procedural
mechanism
review
ruling
unseemly
present
unnecessary
occasion
constitutional
confrontation
two
branches
government
similarly
federal
judge
placed
posture
issuing
citation
president
simply
order
invoke
review
issue
whether
president
cited
contempt
engender
protracted
litigation
delay
review
merits
claim
privilege
ultimate
termination
underlying
criminal
action
evidence
sought
considerations
lead
us
conclude
order
district
appealable
order
appeal
order
therefore
properly
appeals
case
properly
writ
certiorari
judgment
gay
ruff
ii
justiciability
mere
assertion
claim
dispute
without
never
operated
defeat
federal
jurisdiction
justiciability
depend
surface
inquiry
icc
observed
courts
must
look
behind
names
symbolize
parties
determine
whether
justiciable
case
controversy
presented
see
also
powell
mccormack
icc
jersey
city
ex
rel
chapman
fpc
secretary
agriculture
fmb
isbrandtsen
marine
bancorporation
ante
connecticut
national
bank
ante
starting
point
nature
proceeding
evidence
sought
pending
criminal
prosecution
judicial
proceeding
federal
alleging
violation
federal
laws
brought
name
sovereign
berger
authority
art
ii
congress
vested
attorney
general
power
conduct
criminal
litigation
government
also
vested
power
appoint
subordinate
officers
assist
discharge
duties
acting
pursuant
statutes
attorney
general
delegated
authority
represent
particular
matters
special
prosecutor
unique
authority
tenure
regulation
gives
special
prosecutor
explicit
power
contest
invocation
executive
privilege
process
seeking
evidence
deemed
relevant
performance
specially
delegated
duties
fed
reg
amended
fed
reg
long
regulation
extant
force
law
ex
rel
accardi
shaughnessy
regulations
attorney
general
delegated
certain
discretionary
powers
board
immigration
appeals
required
board
exercise
discretion
appeals
deportation
cases
held
long
attorney
general
regulations
remained
operative
denied
authority
exercise
discretion
delegated
board
even
though
original
authority
reassert
amending
regulations
service
dulles
vitarelli
seaton
reaffirmed
basic
holding
accardi
accardi
theoretically
possible
attorney
general
amend
revoke
regulation
defining
special
prosecutor
authority
done
long
regulation
remains
force
executive
branch
bound
indeed
sovereign
composed
three
branches
bound
respect
enforce
moreover
delegation
authority
special
prosecutor
case
ordinary
delegation
attorney
general
subordinate
officer
authorization
president
acting
attorney
general
provided
regulation
special
prosecutor
removed
without
consensus
eight
designated
leaders
congress
supra
demands
resistance
subpoena
present
obvious
controversy
ordinary
sense
alone
sufficient
meet
constitutional
standards
constitutional
sense
controversy
means
disagreement
conflict
rather
means
kind
controversy
courts
traditionally
resolve
issue
production
nonproduction
specified
evidence
deemed
special
prosecutor
relevant
admissible
pending
criminal
case
sought
one
official
executive
branch
within
scope
express
authority
resisted
chief
executive
ground
duty
preserve
confidentiality
communications
president
whatever
correct
answer
merits
issues
type
traditionally
justiciable
icc
independent
special
prosecutor
asserted
need
subpoenaed
material
underlying
criminal
prosecution
opposed
president
steadfast
assertion
privilege
disclosure
material
setting
assures
concrete
adverseness
sharpens
presentation
issues
upon
largely
depends
illumination
difficult
constitutional
questions
baker
carr
moreover
since
matter
one
arising
regular
course
federal
criminal
prosecution
within
traditional
scope
art
iii
power
light
uniqueness
setting
conflict
arises
fact
parties
officers
executive
branch
viewed
barrier
justiciability
inconsistent
applicable
law
regulation
unique
facts
case
conclude
special
prosecutor
standing
bring
action
justiciable
controversy
presented
decision
iii
rule
rule
provides
subpoena
may
also
command
person
directed
produce
books
papers
documents
objects
designated
therein
motion
made
promptly
may
quash
modify
subpoena
compliance
unreasonable
oppressive
may
direct
books
papers
documents
objects
designated
subpoena
produced
time
prior
trial
prior
time
offered
evidence
may
upon
production
permit
books
papers
documents
objects
portions
thereof
inspected
parties
attorneys
background
special
prosecutor
order
carry
burden
must
clear
three
hurdles
relevancy
admissibility
specificity
review
record
necessarily
affords
less
comprehensive
view
total
situation
available
trial
judge
unwilling
conclude
district
erred
evaluation
special
prosecutor
showing
rule
conclusion
based
record
us
much
seal
course
contents
subpoenaed
tapes
stage
described
fully
special
prosecutor
sufficient
likelihood
tapes
contains
conversations
relevant
offenses
charged
indictment
gross
sdny
respect
many
tapes
special
prosecutor
offered
sworn
testimony
statements
one
participants
conversations
said
time
remainder
tapes
identity
participants
time
place
conversations
taken
total
context
permit
rational
inference
least
part
conversations
relate
offenses
charged
indictment
also
conclude
sufficient
preliminary
showing
subpoenaed
tapes
contains
evidence
admissible
respect
offenses
charged
indictment
cogent
objection
admissibility
taped
conversations
issue
collection
statements
declarants
subject
statements
therefore
inadmissible
hearsay
however
tapes
apparently
contain
conversations
one
defendants
named
indictment
party
hearsay
rule
automatically
bar
statements
defendant
criminal
case
declarations
one
defendant
may
also
admissible
defendants
upon
sufficient
showing
independent
evidence
conspiracy
among
one
defendants
declarant
declarations
issue
furtherance
conspiracy
true
declarations
coconspirators
defendants
case
trial
dutton
evans
recorded
conversations
may
also
admissible
limited
purpose
impeaching
credibility
defendant
testifies
coconspirator
testifies
generally
need
evidence
impeach
witnesses
insufficient
require
production
advance
trial
see
carter
dc
however
valid
potential
evidentiary
uses
material
analysis
possible
transcription
tapes
may
take
significant
period
time
accordingly
conclude
district
erred
authorizing
issuance
subpoena
duces
tecum
enforcement
pretrial
subpoena
duces
tecum
must
necessarily
committed
sound
discretion
trial
since
necessity
subpoena
often
turns
upon
determination
factual
issues
without
determination
arbitrariness
trial
finding
without
record
support
appellate
ordinarily
disturb
finding
applicant
subpoena
complied
rule
see
sue
chicago
transit
authority
shotkin
nelson
case
however
subpoena
directed
president
appellate
review
deference
coordinate
branch
government
particularly
meticulous
ensure
standards
rule
correctly
applied
burr
cas
cc
examination
materials
submitted
special
prosecutor
district
support
motion
subpoena
persuaded
district
denial
president
motion
quash
subpoena
consistent
rule
also
conclude
special
prosecutor
made
sufficient
showing
justify
subpoena
production
trial
subpoenaed
materials
available
source
examination
processing
await
trial
circumstances
shown
bowman
dairy
iozia
sdny
iv
claim
privilege
determined
requirements
rule
satisfied
turn
claim
subpoena
quashed
demands
confidential
conversations
president
close
advisors
inconsistent
public
interest
produce
app
first
contention
broad
claim
separation
powers
doctrine
precludes
judicial
review
president
claim
privilege
second
contention
prevail
claim
absolute
privilege
hold
matter
constitutional
law
privilege
prevails
subpoena
duces
tecum
performance
assigned
constitutional
duties
branch
government
must
initially
interpret
constitution
interpretation
powers
branch
due
great
respect
others
president
counsel
noted
reads
constitution
providing
absolute
privilege
confidentiality
presidential
communications
many
decisions
however
unequivocally
reaffirmed
holding
marbury
madison
cranch
emphatically
province
duty
judicial
department
say
law
holding
defined
scope
judicial
power
specifically
relating
enforcement
subpoena
confidential
presidential
communications
use
criminal
prosecution
exercises
power
executive
branch
legislative
branch
found
invalid
conflict
constitution
powell
mccormack
youngstown
sheet
tube
sawyer
series
cases
interpreted
explicit
immunity
conferred
express
provisions
constitution
members
house
senate
speech
debate
clause
const
art
doe
mcmillan
gravel
brewster
johnson
since
consistently
exercised
power
construe
delineate
claims
arising
express
powers
must
follow
authority
interpret
claims
respect
powers
alleged
derive
enumerated
powers
system
government
requires
federal
courts
occasion
interpret
constitution
manner
variance
construction
given
document
another
branch
powell
mccormack
supra
baker
carr
stated
deciding
whether
matter
measure
committed
constitution
another
branch
government
whether
action
branch
exceeds
whatever
authority
committed
delicate
exercise
constitutional
interpretation
responsibility
ultimate
interpreter
constitution
support
claim
absolute
privilege
president
counsel
urges
two
grounds
one
common
governments
one
peculiar
system
separation
powers
first
ground
valid
need
protection
communications
high
government
officials
advise
assist
performance
manifold
duties
importance
confidentiality
plain
require
discussion
human
experience
teaches
expect
public
dissemination
remarks
may
well
temper
candor
concern
appearances
interests
detriment
decisionmaking
process
whatever
nature
privilege
confidentiality
presidential
communications
exercise
art
ii
powers
privilege
said
derive
supremacy
branch
within
assigned
area
constitutional
duties
certain
powers
privileges
flow
nature
enumerated
powers
protection
confidentiality
presidential
communications
similar
constitutional
underpinnings
second
ground
asserted
president
counsel
support
claim
absolute
privilege
rests
doctrine
separation
powers
argued
independence
executive
branch
within
sphere
humphrey
executor
kilbourn
thompson
insulates
president
judicial
subpoena
ongoing
criminal
prosecution
thereby
protects
confidential
presidential
communications
however
neither
doctrine
separation
powers
need
confidentiality
communications
without
sustain
absolute
unqualified
presidential
privilege
immunity
judicial
process
circumstances
president
need
complete
candor
objectivity
advisers
calls
great
deference
courts
however
privilege
depends
solely
broad
undifferentiated
claim
public
interest
confidentiality
conversations
confrontation
values
arises
absent
claim
need
protect
military
diplomatic
sensitive
national
security
secrets
find
difficult
accept
argument
even
important
interest
confidentiality
presidential
communications
significantly
diminished
production
material
camera
inspection
protection
district
obliged
provide
impediment
absolute
unqualified
privilege
place
way
primary
constitutional
duty
judicial
branch
justice
criminal
prosecutions
plainly
conflict
function
courts
art
iii
designing
structure
government
dividing
allocating
sovereign
power
among
three
branches
framers
constitution
sought
provide
comprehensive
system
separate
powers
intended
operate
absolute
independence
constitution
diffuses
power
better
secure
liberty
also
contemplates
practice
integrate
dispersed
powers
workable
government
enjoins
upon
branches
separateness
interdependence
autonomy
reciprocity
youngstown
sheet
tube
sawyer
jackson
concurring
since
conclude
legitimate
needs
judicial
process
may
outweigh
presidential
privilege
necessary
resolve
competing
interests
manner
preserves
essential
functions
branch
right
indeed
duty
resolve
question
free
judiciary
according
high
respect
representations
made
behalf
president
burr
cas
cc
expectation
president
confidentiality
conversations
correspondence
like
claim
confidentiality
judicial
deliberations
example
values
accord
deference
privacy
citizens
added
values
necessity
protection
public
interest
candid
objective
even
blunt
harsh
opinions
presidential
president
assist
must
free
explore
alternatives
process
shaping
policies
making
decisions
way
many
unwilling
express
except
privately
considerations
justifying
presumptive
privilege
presidential
communications
privilege
fundamental
operation
government
inextricably
rooted
separation
powers
constitution
nixon
sirica
app
appeals
held
presidential
communications
presumptively
privileged
position
accepted
parties
present
litigation
agree
chief
justice
marshall
observation
therefore
case
kind
required
proceed
president
ordinary
individual
burr
presumptive
privilege
must
considered
light
historic
commitment
rule
law
nowhere
profoundly
manifest
view
twofold
aim
criminal
justice
guilt
shall
escape
innocence
suffer
berger
elected
employ
adversary
system
criminal
justice
parties
contest
issues
law
need
develop
relevant
facts
adversary
system
fundamental
comprehensive
ends
criminal
justice
defeated
judgments
founded
partial
speculative
presentation
facts
integrity
judicial
system
public
confidence
system
depend
full
disclosure
facts
within
framework
rules
evidence
ensure
justice
done
imperative
function
courts
compulsory
process
available
production
evidence
needed
either
prosecution
defense
recently
restated
ancient
proposition
law
albeit
context
grand
jury
inquiry
rather
trial
public
right
every
man
evidence
except
persons
protected
constitutional
statutory
privilege
bryan
blackmer
branzburg
hayes
case
president
challenges
subpoena
served
third
party
requiring
production
materials
use
criminal
prosecution
claim
privilege
disclosure
confidential
communications
place
claim
privilege
ground
military
diplomatic
secrets
areas
art
ii
duties
courts
traditionally
shown
utmost
deference
presidential
responsibilities
air
lines
waterman
dealing
presidential
authority
involving
foreign
policy
considerations
said
president
nation
organ
foreign
affairs
available
intelligence
services
whose
reports
published
world
intolerable
courts
without
relevant
information
review
perhaps
nullify
actions
executive
taken
information
properly
held
secret
may
possible
satisfy
circumstances
case
reasonable
danger
compulsion
evidence
expose
military
matters
interest
national
security
divulged
case
occasion
privilege
appropriate
jeopardize
security
privilege
meant
protect
insisting
upon
examination
evidence
even
judge
alone
chambers
right
production
evidence
criminal
trial
similarly
constitutional
dimensions
sixth
amendment
explicitly
confers
upon
every
defendant
criminal
trial
right
confronted
witnesses
compulsory
process
obtaining
witnesses
favor
moreover
fifth
amendment
also
guarantees
person
shall
deprived
liberty
without
due
process
law
manifest
duty
courts
vindicate
guarantees
accomplish
essential
relevant
admissible
evidence
produced
case
must
weigh
importance
general
privilege
confidentiality
presidential
communications
performance
president
responsibilities
inroads
privilege
fair
administration
criminal
justice
interest
preserving
confidentiality
weighty
indeed
entitled
great
respect
however
conclude
advisers
moved
temper
candor
remarks
infrequent
occasions
disclosure
possibility
conversations
called
context
criminal
prosecution
hand
allowance
privilege
withhold
evidence
demonstrably
relevant
criminal
trial
cut
deeply
guarantee
due
process
law
gravely
impair
basic
function
courts
president
acknowledged
need
confidentiality
communications
office
general
nature
whereas
constitutional
need
production
relevant
evidence
criminal
proceeding
specific
central
fair
adjudication
particular
criminal
case
administration
justice
without
access
specific
facts
criminal
prosecution
may
totally
frustrated
president
broad
interest
confidentiality
communications
vitiated
disclosure
limited
number
conversations
preliminarily
shown
bearing
pending
criminal
cases
conclude
ground
asserting
privilege
subpoenaed
materials
sought
use
criminal
trial
based
generalized
interest
confidentiality
prevail
fundamental
demands
due
process
law
fair
administration
criminal
justice
generalized
assertion
privilege
must
yield
demonstrated
specific
need
evidence
pending
criminal
trial
earlier
determined
district
err
authorizing
issuance
subpoena
president
concludes
compliance
subpoena
injurious
public
interest
may
properly
done
invoke
claim
privilege
return
subpoena
upon
receiving
claim
privilege
chief
executive
became
duty
district
treat
subpoenaed
material
presumptively
privileged
require
special
prosecutor
demonstrate
presidential
material
essential
justice
pending
criminal
case
burr
district
treated
material
presumptively
privileged
proceeded
find
special
prosecutor
made
sufficient
showing
rebut
presumption
ordered
camera
examination
subpoenaed
material
basis
examination
record
unable
conclude
district
erred
ordering
inspection
accordingly
affirm
order
district
subpoenaed
materials
transmitted
turn
important
question
district
responsibilities
conducting
camera
examination
presidential
materials
communications
delivered
compulsion
subpoena
duces
tecum
enforcement
subpoena
duces
tecum
stayed
pending
resolution
issues
raised
petitions
certiorari
issues
disposed
matter
implementation
rest
district
guard
furnished
president
protect
harassed
vexatious
unnecessary
subpoenas
looked
conduct
district
subpoenas
issued
circumstance
precede
issued
burr
statements
meet
test
admissibility
relevance
must
isolated
material
must
excised
stage
district
limited
representations
special
prosecutor
evidence
sought
subpoena
material
available
district
elementary
camera
inspection
evidence
always
procedure
calling
scrupulous
protection
release
publication
material
found
stage
probably
admissible
evidence
relevant
issues
trial
sought
true
ordinary
situation
obvious
district
heavy
responsibility
see
presidential
conversations
either
relevant
admissible
accorded
high
degree
respect
due
president
chief
justice
marshall
sitting
trial
judge
burr
case
supra
extraordinarily
careful
point
case
kind
required
proceed
president
ordinary
individual
since
matter
came
pendency
criminal
prosecution
representations
time
essence
mandate
shall
issue
forthwith
affirmed
footnotes
raised
issue
whether
grand
jury
acted
within
authority
naming
president
unindicted
coconspirator
since
find
resolution
issue
unnecessary
resolution
question
whether
claim
privilege
prevail
certiorari
dismissed
improvidently
granted
remainder
opinion
concerned
issues
raised
june
president
counsel
moved
disclosure
transmittal
evidence
presented
grand
jury
relating
action
naming
president
unindicted
coconspirator
action
motion
deferred
pending
oral
argument
case
denied
seven
defendants
john
mitchell
haldeman
john
ehrlichman
charles
colson
robert
mardian
kenneth
parkinson
gordon
strachan
occupied
either
position
responsibility
white
house
staff
position
committee
president
colson
entered
guilty
plea
another
charge
longer
defendant
president
entered
special
appearance
district
june
requested
lift
protective
order
regarding
naming
certain
individuals
coconspirators
additional
extent
deemed
appropriate
motion
president
based
ground
disclosures
news
media
made
reasons
continuance
protective
order
longer
meaningful
june
district
removed
protective
order
june
counsel
parties
jointly
moved
unseal
parts
record
related
action
grand
jury
regarding
president
receiving
statement
opposition
defendants
denied
motion
june
except
grand
jury
immediate
finding
relating
status
president
unindicted
coconspirator
specific
meetings
conversations
enumerated
schedule
attached
subpoena
app
joint
suggestion
special
prosecutor
counsel
president
approval
counsel
defendants
proceedings
district
held
camera
parties
suggested
jurisdiction
grounds
view
conclusion
jurisdiction
district
order
appealable
need
decide
whether
jurisdictional
vehicles
available
regulation
issued
attorney
general
pursuant
statutory
authority
vests
special
prosecutor
plenary
authority
control
course
investigations
litigation
related
offenses
arising
presidential
election
special
prosecutor
deems
necessary
appropriate
assume
responsibility
allegations
involving
president
members
white
house
staff
presidential
appointees
matters
consents
assigned
attorney
general
fed
reg
amended
fed
reg
particular
special
prosecutor
given
full
authority
inter
alia
contest
assertion
executive
privilege
handl
aspects
cases
within
jurisdiction
regulation
goes
provide
exercising
authority
special
prosecutor
greatest
degree
independence
consistent
attorney
general
statutory
accountability
matters
falling
within
jurisdiction
department
justice
attorney
general
countermand
interfere
special
prosecutor
decisions
actions
special
prosecutor
determine
whether
extent
inform
consult
attorney
general
conduct
duties
responsibilities
accordance
assurances
given
president
attorney
general
president
exercise
constitutional
powers
effect
discharge
special
prosecutor
limit
independence
hereby
given
special
prosecutor
removed
duties
except
extraordinary
improprieties
part
without
president
first
consulting
majority
minority
leaders
chairmen
ranking
minority
members
judiciary
committees
senate
house
representatives
ascertaining
consensus
accord
proposed
action
understanding
acting
attorney
general
robert
bork
author
regulation
establishing
independence
special
prosecutor
shown
testimony
senate
judiciary
committee
although
anticipated
jaworski
receive
cooperation
white
house
getting
evidence
feels
needs
conduct
investigations
prosecutions
clear
understood
sides
power
use
judicial
processes
pursue
evidence
disagreement
develop
confirmation
hearings
attorney
general
william
saxbe
testified
agreed
regulation
adopted
acting
attorney
general
bork
remove
special
prosecutor
except
gross
impropriety
contention
special
prosecutor
guilty
impropriety
quoted
statement
member
advisory
committee
purpose
rule
bring
documents
advance
time
offered
evidence
may
inspected
advance
purpose
enabling
party
see
whether
use
whether
wants
use
manual
complex
multidistrict
litigation
published
federal
judicial
center
recommends
use
rule
encouraged
complex
criminal
cases
order
party
may
compelled
produce
documentary
evidence
well
advance
trial
advance
time
offered
district
found
faced
unusual
situation
subpoena
rather
directed
government
defendants
issues
practical
matter
third
party
mitchell
supp
dc
special
prosecutor
suggests
evidentiary
requirement
bowman
dairy
iozia
apply
full
vigor
subpoena
duces
tecum
issued
third
parties
rather
government
prosecutors
brief
need
decide
whether
lower
standard
exists
satisfied
relevance
evidentiary
nature
subpoenaed
tapes
sufficiently
shown
preliminary
matter
warrant
district
refusal
quash
subpoena
statements
declarations
party
defendant
surmount
objections
based
hearsay
rule
least
declarant
admissible
whatever
inferences
might
reasonably
drawn
matlock
lee
see
also
mccormick
evidence
pp
ed
preliminary
matter
must
substantial
independent
evidence
conspiracy
least
enough
take
question
jury
vaught
hoffa
aff
grounds
santos
cert
denied
morton
spanos
carbo
cert
denied
whether
standard
satisfied
question
admissibility
evidence
decided
trial
judge
nothing
novel
governmental
confidentiality
meetings
constitutional
convention
conducted
complete
privacy
farrand
records
federal
convention
pp
moreover
records
meetings
sealed
years
convention
see
stat
res
framers
acknowledged
without
secrecy
constitution
kind
developed
written
warren
making
constitution
special
prosecutor
argues
provision
constitution
presidential
privilege
president
communications
corresponding
privilege
members
congress
speech
debate
clause
silence
constitution
score
dispositive
rule
constitutional
interpretation
announced
mcculloch
maryland
wheat
reasonably
appropriate
relevant
exercise
granted
power
considered
accompanying
grant
universally
applied
suffices
merely
state
marshall
gordon
freedom
communication
vital
fulfillment
aims
wholesome
relationships
obtained
removing
specter
compelled
disclosure
overnment
needs
open
protected
channels
kind
plain
talk
essential
quality
functioning
carl
zeiss
stiftung
carl
zeiss
jena
dc
see
nixon
sirica
app
kaiser
aluminum
chem
cl
supp
reed
federalist
mittell
ed
key
role
testimony
witnesses
judicial
process
courts
historically
cautious
privileges
justice
frankfurter
dissenting
elkins
said
limitations
properly
placed
upon
operation
general
principle
limited
extent
permitting
refusal
testify
excluding
relevant
evidence
public
good
transcending
normally
predominant
principle
utilizing
rational
means
ascertaining
truth
concerned
balance
president
generalized
interest
confidentiality
need
relevant
evidence
civil
litigation
confidentiality
interest
congressional
demands
information
president
interest
preserving
state
secrets
address
conflict
president
assertion
generalized
privilege
confidentiality
constitutional
need
relevant
evidence
criminal
trials
justice
cardozo
made
point
analogous
context
speaking
unanimous
clark
emphasized
importance
maintaining
secrecy
deliberations
petit
jury
criminal
case
freedom
debate
might
stifled
independence
thought
checked
jurors
made
feel
arguments
ballots
freely
published
world
nonetheless
also
recognized
isolated
inroads
confidentiality
designed
serve
paramount
need
criminal
law
vitiate
interests
served
secrecy
juror
integrity
reasonable
firmness
fear
speak
mind
confidences
debate
barred
ears
mere
impertinence
malice
expect
shielded
disclosure
conduct
event
evidence
reflecting
upon
honor
chance
may
found
timid
soul
take
counsel
fears
give
way
repressive
power
remote
shadowy
shape
course
justice
subpoenaed
material
delivered
district
judge
camera
questions
may
arise
excising
parts
lies
within
discretion
seek
aid
special
prosecutor
president
counsel
camera
consideration
validity
particular
excisions
whether
basis
excision
relevancy
admissibility
cases
reynolds
air
lines
waterman