strauder
west
virginia
argued
decided
october
error
appeals
state
west
virginia
facts
stated
opinion
charles
devens
george
davenport
plaintiff
error
robert
white
west
virginia
james
green
contra
justice
strong
delivered
opinion
plaintiff
error
colored
man
indicated
murder
circuit
ohio
county
west
virginia
october
upon
trial
convicted
sentenced
record
removed
state
judgment
circuit
affirmed
present
case
writ
error
substance
averred
trial
state
defendant
plaintiff
error
denied
rights
entitled
constitution
laws
circuit
state
trial
indictment
commenced
defendant
presented
petition
verified
oath
praying
removal
cause
circuit
assigning
ground
removal
virtue
laws
state
west
virginia
colored
man
eligible
member
grand
jury
serve
petit
jury
state
white
men
eligible
reason
colored
man
slave
reason
believe
believe
full
equal
benefit
laws
proceedings
state
west
virginia
security
person
enjoyed
white
citizens
less
chance
enforcing
courts
state
rights
prosecution
citizen
probabilities
denial
citizen
every
trial
might
take
place
indictment
courts
state
much
enhanced
white
man
petition
denied
state
cause
forced
trial
motions
quash
venire
law
issued
unconstitutional
null
void
successive
motions
challenge
array
panel
new
trial
arrest
judgment
made
overruled
made
exceptions
parts
record
law
state
reference
made
petition
removal
several
motions
enacted
march
acts
follows
white
male
persons
years
age
citizens
state
shall
liable
serve
jurors
except
herein
provided
persons
excepted
state
officials
several
errors
assigned
controlling
questions
underlying
first
whether
constitution
laws
every
citizen
right
trial
indictment
jury
selected
impanelled
without
discrimination
race
color
race
color
second
right
denied
enjoyment
state
indicted
may
cause
case
removed
circuit
observed
first
questions
whether
colored
man
indictment
preferred
right
grand
petit
jury
composed
whole
part
persons
race
color
whether
composition
selection
jurors
indicted
tried
persons
race
color
may
excluded
law
solely
race
color
possibility
colored
man
sit
upon
jury
questions
important
demand
construction
recent
amendments
constitution
defendant
right
jury
selected
trial
case
without
discrimination
persons
race
color
race
color
right
created
protected
amendments
legislation
congress
fourteenth
amendment
ordains
persons
born
naturalized
subject
jurisdiction
thereof
citizens
state
wherein
reside
state
shall
make
enforce
laws
shall
abridge
privileges
immunities
citizens
shall
state
deprive
person
life
liberty
property
without
due
process
law
deny
person
within
jurisdiction
equal
protection
laws
one
series
constitutional
provisions
common
purpose
namely
securing
race
recently
emancipated
race
many
generations
held
slavery
civil
rights
superior
race
enjoy
true
spirit
meaning
amendments
said
cases
wall
understood
without
keeping
view
history
times
adopted
general
objects
plainly
sought
accomplish
time
incorporated
constitution
required
little
knowledge
human
nature
anticipate
long
regarded
inferior
subject
race
suddenly
raised
rank
citizenship
looked
upon
jealousy
positive
dislike
state
laws
might
enacted
enforced
perpetuate
distinctions
existed
discriminations
habitual
well
known
laws
making
discriminations
existed
others
might
well
expected
colored
race
race
abject
ignorant
condition
unfitted
command
respect
superior
intelligence
training
left
mere
children
needed
protection
wise
government
extends
unable
protect
especially
needed
protection
unfriendly
action
resident
view
considerations
fourteenth
amendment
framed
adopted
designed
assure
colored
race
enjoyment
civil
rights
law
enjoyed
white
persons
give
race
protection
general
government
enjoyment
whenever
denied
gave
citizenship
privileges
citizenship
persons
color
denied
state
power
withhold
equal
protection
laws
authorized
congress
enforce
provisions
appropriate
legislation
quote
language
used
us
cases
one
fail
impressed
one
pervaiding
purpose
found
amendments
lying
foundation
without
none
suggested
mean
freedom
slave
race
security
firm
establishment
freedom
protection
newly
made
freeman
citizen
oppressions
formerly
exercised
unlimited
dominion
existence
laws
newly
emancipated
negroes
resided
discriminated
gross
injustice
hardship
class
evil
remedied
fourteenth
amendment
laws
forbidden
however
conform
laws
requirements
fifth
section
article
amendment
congress
authorized
enforce
suitable
legislation
added
doubt
much
whether
action
state
directed
way
discrimination
negroes
class
ever
held
come
within
purview
provision
spirit
meaning
amendment
whether
means
construed
liberally
carry
purposes
framers
ordains
state
shall
make
enforce
laws
shall
abridge
privileges
immunities
citizens
evidently
referring
newly
made
citizens
citizens
declared
also
citizens
state
reside
ordains
state
shall
deprive
person
life
liberty
property
without
due
process
law
deny
person
within
jurisdiction
equal
protection
laws
declaring
law
shall
black
white
persons
whether
colored
white
shall
stand
equal
laws
regard
colored
race
whose
protection
amendment
primarily
designed
discrimination
shall
made
law
color
words
amendment
true
prohibitory
contain
necessary
implication
positive
immunity
right
valuable
colored
race
right
exemption
unfriendly
legislation
distinctively
colored
legal
discriminations
implying
inferiority
civil
society
lessening
security
enjoyment
rights
others
enjoy
discriminations
steps
towards
reducing
condition
subject
race
west
virginia
statute
respecting
statute
controlled
selection
grand
petit
jury
case
plaintiff
discrimination
doubted
persons
excluded
white
men
colored
people
constitute
majority
entire
population
law
enacted
excluding
white
men
jury
service
thus
denying
privilege
participating
equally
blacks
administration
justice
apprehend
one
heard
claim
denial
white
men
equal
protection
laws
law
passed
excluding
naturalized
celtic
irishmen
doubt
inconsistency
spirit
amendment
fact
colored
people
singled
expressly
denied
statute
right
participate
administration
law
jurors
color
though
citizens
may
respects
fully
qualified
practically
brand
upon
affixed
law
assertion
inferiority
stimulant
race
prejudice
impediment
securing
individuals
race
equal
justice
law
aims
secure
others
right
trial
jury
guaranteed
every
citizen
west
virginia
constitution
state
constitution
juries
essential
part
protection
mode
trial
intended
secure
idea
jury
body
men
composed
peers
equals
person
whose
rights
selected
summoned
determine
neighbors
fellows
associates
persons
legal
status
society
holds
blackstone
commentaries
says
right
trial
jury
country
trial
peers
every
englishman
grand
bulwark
liberties
secured
great
charter
also
guarded
statutory
enactments
intended
make
impossible
bentham
called
juries
well
known
prejudices
often
exist
particular
classes
community
sway
judgment
jurors
therefore
operate
cases
deny
persons
classes
full
enjoyment
protection
others
enjoy
prejudice
local
community
held
reason
change
venue
framers
constitutional
amendment
must
known
full
well
existence
prejudice
likelihood
continue
manumitted
slaves
race
knowledge
doubtless
motive
led
amendment
manumission
citizenship
colored
race
became
entitled
equal
protection
laws
resided
apprehension
prejudice
might
denied
equal
protection
might
discrimination
inducement
bestow
upon
national
government
power
enforce
provision
state
shall
deny
equal
protection
laws
without
apprehended
existence
prejudice
portion
amendment
unnecessary
might
left
extend
equality
protection
view
considerations
hard
see
statute
west
virginia
regarded
discriminating
colored
man
put
upon
trial
alleged
criminal
offence
state
easy
comprehend
said
every
white
man
entitled
trial
jury
selected
persons
race
color
rather
selected
without
discrimination
color
negro
latter
equally
protected
law
former
protection
life
liberty
race
color
prejudice
right
legal
right
constitutional
amendment
maintained
compelling
colored
man
submit
trial
life
jury
drawn
panel
state
expressly
excluded
every
man
race
color
alone
however
well
qualified
respects
denial
equal
legal
protection
say
within
limits
excluded
amendment
state
may
prescribe
qualifications
jurors
make
discriminations
may
confine
selection
males
freeholders
citizens
persons
within
certain
ages
persons
educational
qualifications
believe
fourteenth
amendment
ever
intended
prohibit
looking
history
clear
purpose
aim
discrimination
race
color
said
design
protect
emancipated
race
strike
possible
legal
discriminations
belong
quote
supra
giving
construction
articles
amendments
necessary
keep
main
purpose
steadily
view
clearly
provision
race
emergency
strong
case
necessary
application
called
upon
affirm
deny
purposes
fourteenth
amendment
makes
attempt
enumerate
rights
designed
protect
speaks
general
terms
comprehensive
possible
language
prohibitory
every
prohibition
implies
existence
rights
immunities
prominent
among
immunity
inequality
legal
protection
either
life
liberty
property
state
action
denies
immunity
colored
man
conflict
constitution
concluding
therefore
statute
west
virginia
discriminating
selection
jurors
negroes
color
amounts
denial
equal
protection
laws
colored
man
put
upon
trial
alleged
offence
state
remains
considered
whether
power
congress
enforce
provisions
fourteenth
amendment
appropriate
legislation
sufficient
justify
enactment
sect
revised
statutes
right
immunity
whether
created
constitution
guaranteed
even
without
express
delegation
power
may
protected
congress
prigg
commonwealth
pennsylvania
pet
reese
said
chief
justice
immunities
created
dependent
upon
constitution
protected
congress
form
manner
protection
may
congress
legitimate
exercise
legislative
discretion
shall
provide
may
varied
meet
necessities
particular
right
protected
express
authority
protect
rights
immunities
referred
fourteenth
amendment
enforce
observance
appropriate
congressional
legislation
one
efficient
appropriate
mode
extending
protection
securing
party
enjoyment
right
immunity
law
providing
removal
case
state
right
denied
state
law
federal
upheld
ordinary
mode
protecting
rights
immunities
conferred
federal
constitution
laws
sect
provision
enacts
civil
suit
criminal
prosecution
commenced
state
cause
whatsoever
person
denied
enforce
judicial
tribunals
state
part
state
prosecution
pending
right
secured
law
providing
equal
civil
rights
citizens
persons
within
jurisdiction
suit
prosecution
may
upon
petition
defendant
filed
said
state
time
trial
final
hearing
case
stating
facts
verified
oath
removed
trial
next
circuit
held
district
pending
act
plainly
reference
sects
statutes
partially
enumerate
rights
immunities
intended
guaranteed
constitution
first
declares
persons
within
jurisdiction
shall
right
every
state
territory
make
enforce
contracts
sue
parties
give
evidence
full
equal
benefit
laws
proceedings
security
persons
property
enjoyed
white
citizens
shall
subject
like
punishment
pains
penalties
taxes
licenses
exactions
every
kind
act
puts
form
statute
substantially
ordained
constitutional
amendment
step
towards
enforcing
constitutional
provisions
sect
advanced
step
fully
warranted
think
fifth
section
fourteenth
amendment
heretofore
considered
affirmed
constitutional
power
congress
authorize
removal
state
courts
circuit
courts
trial
criminal
prosecutions
alleged
offences
laws
state
defence
presents
federal
question
right
federal
constitution
laws
involved
tennessee
davis
supra
unnecessary
repeat
said
petition
plaintiff
error
filed
state
trial
case
made
case
removal
federal
circuit
sect
plain
constitutional
amendment
sect
revised
statutes
entitled
immunity
discrimination
selection
jurors
color
endeavored
show
set
forth
sufficient
facts
exhibit
denial
immunity
denial
statute
law
state
error
therefore
proceeding
trial
indictment
petition
filed
also
overruling
challenge
array
jury
refusing
quash
panel
judgment
west
virginia
reversed
case
remitted
instructions
reverse
judgment
circuit
ohio
county
ordered
justice
field
dissent
judgment
case
grounds
stated
opinion
ex
parte
virginia
infra
justice
clifford
concurs