tateo
argued
april
decided
june
respondent
informed
trial
trial
judge
expressed
intention
jury
found
guilty
impose
life
sentence
kidnaping
charge
consecutive
sentences
felony
charges
pleaded
guilty
whereupon
jury
discharged
kidnaping
count
dismissed
sentence
imposed
remaining
counts
subsequent
proceeding
another
district
judge
doubting
respondent
guilty
plea
voluntary
set
aside
conviction
granted
new
trial
third
trial
judge
dismissed
charges
holding
reprosecution
barred
double
jeopardy
clause
fifth
amendment
held
retrial
defendant
whose
conviction
set
aside
collateral
attack
error
proceedings
leading
conviction
barred
double
jeopardy
ball
followed
downum
distinguished
pp
supp
reversed
remanded
beatrice
rosenberg
argued
cause
brief
solicitor
general
cox
assistant
attorney
general
miller
philip
heymann
jerome
nelson
robert
kasanof
argued
cause
appellee
brief
john
rogge
justice
harlan
delivered
opinion
case
presents
question
whether
federal
criminal
defendant
conviction
overturned
collateral
proceedings
ground
guilty
plea
entered
trial
voluntary
induced
part
comments
trial
judge
may
tried
crimes
protected
prosecution
double
jeopardy
clause
fifth
amendment
hold
circumstances
retrial
infringe
constitutional
protection
double
jeopardy
may
appellee
tateo
another
brought
trial
jury
indictment
charging
bank
robbery
kidnaping
connection
robbery
taking
carrying
away
bank
money
receiving
possessing
stolen
bank
money
conspiracy
commit
substantive
offenses
fourth
day
trial
judge
informed
tateo
counsel
tateo
found
guilty
jury
impose
life
sentence
kidnaping
charge
consecutive
sentences
charges
upon
told
judge
position
advised
counsel
likelihood
conviction
great
tateo
pleaded
guilty
codefendant
thereupon
jury
discharged
kidnaping
count
dismissed
prosecution
consent
tateo
sentenced
total
years
months
imprisonment
counts
later
proceeding
another
district
judge
judge
weinfeld
granted
tateo
motion
set
aside
judgment
conviction
new
trial
determining
cumulative
impact
trial
testimony
trial
judge
expressed
views
punishment
strong
advice
given
counsel
rendered
doubtful
tateo
possessed
freedom
necessary
voluntary
plea
guilty
supp
reindicted
kidnaping
charge
tateo
brought
third
district
judge
judge
tyler
trial
charge
four
bank
robbery
charges
earlier
pleaded
guilty
upon
motions
defense
judge
tyler
dismissed
kidnaping
count
abandoned
government
four
counts
reasoned
since
neither
genuine
consent
exceptional
circumstance
underlay
termination
first
trial
waiver
double
jeopardy
claim
made
tateo
government
precluded
retrying
supp
government
appealed
accord
permits
direct
appeal
decision
district
sustaining
motion
bar
defendant
put
jeopardy
noted
probable
jurisdiction
reasons
given
reverse
judgment
district
fifth
amendment
provides
person
shall
subject
offence
twice
put
jeopardy
life
limb
principle
provision
preclude
government
retrying
defendant
whose
conviction
set
aside
error
proceedings
leading
conviction
part
constitutional
jurisprudence
respect
differ
practice
obtaining
england
rule
country
explicitly
stated
ball
case
defendants
reindicted
found
original
indictment
defective
followed
variety
circumstances
see
stroud
conviction
reversed
confession
error
bryan
conviction
reversed
insufficient
evidence
forman
original
conviction
reversed
error
instructions
jury
defendant
conviction
overturned
collateral
rather
direct
attack
irrelevant
purposes
see
robinson
aff
another
ground
courts
empowered
grant
new
trials
incongruous
compel
greater
relief
one
proceeds
collaterally
one
whose
rights
vindicated
direct
review
different
theories
advanced
support
permissibility
retrial
greater
importance
conceptual
abstractions
employed
explain
ball
principle
implications
principle
sound
administration
justice
corresponding
right
accused
given
fair
trial
societal
interest
punishing
one
whose
guilt
clear
obtained
trial
high
price
indeed
society
pay
every
accused
granted
immunity
punishment
defect
sufficient
constitute
reversible
error
proceedings
leading
conviction
standpoint
defendant
least
doubtful
appellate
courts
zealous
protecting
effects
improprieties
trial
pretrial
stage
knew
reversal
conviction
put
accused
irrevocably
beyond
reach
prosecution
reality
therefore
practice
retrial
serves
defendants
rights
well
society
interest
underlying
purpose
permitting
retrial
much
furthered
application
rule
case
cases
previously
decided
tateo
contends
situation
must
distinguished
one
accused
found
guilty
jury
since
involuntary
plea
guilty
deprived
opportunity
obtain
jury
verdict
acquittal
find
argument
unconvincing
case
reversed
coerced
confession
improperly
admitted
deficiency
indictment
improper
instruction
presumed
accused
case
fairly
put
jury
defendant
less
wronged
jury
finding
guilt
unfair
trial
failure
get
jury
verdict
distinction
two
kinds
wrongs
affords
sensible
basis
differentiation
regard
retrial
appellee
argument
considerably
less
strong
similar
one
rejected
bryan
supra
case
held
despite
appeals
determination
defendant
entitled
insufficiency
evidence
directed
verdict
acquittal
reversal
conviction
direction
new
trial
permissible
disposition
downum
way
inconsistent
permitting
retrial
held
jury
discharged
prosecution
ready
go
forward
case
accused
may
tried
another
jury
opinion
recognized
however
circumstances
mistrial
preclude
second
trial
see
perez
wheat
jury
unable
agree
simmons
likelihood
juror
subject
bias
gori
sustained
second
conviction
original
trial
judge
declared
mistrial
ground
possible
prejudice
defendant
although
judge
acted
without
defendant
consent
wisdom
granting
mistrial
doubtful
tateo
requested
mistrial
basis
judge
comments
doubt
successful
government
barred
retrying
see
gori
page
see
also
dissenting
opinion
douglas
although
may
good
reasons
tateo
counsel
chose
make
motion
trial
judge
strange
tateo
benefit
delay
challenging
judge
conduct
conclude
case
falls
squarely
within
reasoning
ball
subsequent
cases
allowing
government
retry
persons
whose
convictions
overturned
judgment
therefore
reversed
case
remanded
district
instructions
reinstate
four
bank
robbery
counts
ordered
footnotes
also
difficult
understand
tateo
treated
differently
one
coerced
pleading
guilty
jury
impaneled
intimation
case
prosecutorial
judicial
impropriety
justifying
mistrial
resulted
fear
jury
likely
acquit
accused
different
considerations
course
obtain
dissent
post
entirely
misconceives
thrust
argument
point
whether
one
expected
tateo
ask
mistrial
rather
whether
request
made
either
granted
underlain
reversal
direct
review
tateo
tried
tried
decision
proscribing
retrial
attack
collateral
mean
lawyer
worth
salt
forbear
requesting
mistrial
similar
circumstances
even
certain
position
sustained
trial
judge
review
judicial
system
encourage
litigants
raise
objections
earliest
rather
latest
possible
time
seems
words
simple
logic
compels
conclusion
precluded
retrial
also
preclude
retrial
similar
case
mistrial
granted
result
contradict
language
prevailing
dissenting
opinions
gori
justice
goldberg
justice
black
justice
douglas
join
dissenting
affirm
district
holding
supp
decision
last
term
downum
double
jeopardy
clause
fifth
amendment
protects
tateo
reprosecution
today
departs
downum
substantially
weakens
constitutional
guarantee
downum
correctly
decided
deserves
life
longer
accorded
decision
today
rather
making
real
effort
distinguish
downum
limits
particular
facts
reaffirms
indeed
extends
doubtful
holding
narrow
majority
gori
holding
view
departs
downum
hospitable
attitude
toward
policy
bill
rights
make
rare
indeed
occasions
citizen
offense
required
run
gantlet
twice
gori
supra
douglas
dissenting
comparison
facts
rationale
downum
reveals
case
calls
loudly
downum
protection
double
jeopardy
downum
morning
case
called
trial
sides
announced
ready
jury
selected
sworn
instructed
return
returned
prosecution
asked
jury
discharged
key
witness
two
counts
indictment
present
fact
discovered
prosecutor
noon
recess
contended
failure
secure
attendance
witness
way
deliberate
based
upon
prosecutor
conclusion
impaneled
jury
likely
acquit
instead
jury
first
selected
try
petitioner
sworn
discharged
prosecution
witness
served
summons
arrangements
made
assure
presence
downum
supra
sustaining
claim
double
jeopardy
retrial
commenced
two
days
later
said
times
valued
right
defendant
trial
completed
particular
tribunal
summoned
sit
judgment
may
subordinated
public
interest
imperious
necessity
wade
hunter
supra
differences
arisen
application
principle
see
brock
north
carolina
green
harassment
accused
successive
prosecutions
declaration
mistrial
afford
prosecution
favorable
opportunity
convict
examples
jeopardy
attaches
gori
supra
extreme
cases
mark
limits
guarantee
discretion
discharge
jury
reached
verdict
exercised
extraordinary
striking
circumstances
use
words
justice
story
coolidge
fed
cas
prohibition
double
jeopardy
clause
twice
punished
twice
put
jeopardy
ball
resolve
doubt
favor
liberty
citizen
rather
exercise
unlimited
uncertain
arbitrary
judicial
discretion
present
case
four
days
trial
trial
judge
put
time
sentencing
told
defendant
counsel
convicted
jury
intend
give
absolute
maximum
sentence
life
sentence
plus
years
follow
life
sentence
anybody
wonders
one
serve
sentence
served
life
sentence
simple
life
sentence
eligible
parole
fifteen
years
sentence
follow
life
sentence
eligible
parole
life
sentence
stay
jail
rest
life
tateo
served
almost
seven
years
prison
district
judge
weinfeld
granted
motion
vacate
conviction
judge
weinfeld
found
choice
open
defendant
apprised
trial
statement
rather
severely
limited
constitutional
right
continued
trial
found
guilty
faced
light
announced
attitude
imposition
life
sentence
upon
kidnapping
charge
plus
additional
time
upon
counts
sentence
lawyer
informed
believed
without
reason
meant
life
imprisonment
matter
heinous
offense
charged
overwhelming
proof
guilt
may
appear
hopeless
defense
defendant
right
continue
trial
may
violated
constitutional
right
require
government
proceed
conclusion
trial
establish
guilt
independent
evidence
exercised
shadow
penalty
persists
assertion
right
found
guilty
faces
view
trial
announced
intention
maximum
sentence
pleads
guilty
prospect
substantially
reduced
term
realities
human
nature
common
experience
compel
conclusion
defendant
enveloped
coercive
force
resulting
knowledge
conveyed
attitude
sentence
circumstances
foreclosed
reasoned
choice
time
entered
plea
guilty
judge
tyler
found
tateo
coerced
availing
fifth
amendment
right
go
original
jury
verdict
guilt
innocence
applying
downum
judge
tyler
held
ince
neither
constitutionally
sound
consent
exceptional
circumstance
underpinned
termination
second
trial
constitutionally
impermissible
government
indeed
challenge
judge
weinfeld
judge
tyler
conclusion
tateo
guilty
plea
coerced
trial
judge
contended
injury
tateo
less
substantial
injury
downum
deprived
valued
right
trial
completed
particular
tribunal
wade
hunter
downum
reason
prosecutorial
oversight
neglect
tateo
reason
trial
judge
threat
impose
sentence
make
stay
jail
rest
life
anything
tateo
deprivation
serious
purpose
judicial
coercion
case
deny
right
impaneled
jury
decide
fate
whereas
merely
effect
prosecutorial
negligence
downum
moreover
downum
subjected
taking
evidence
whereas
tateo
trial
progress
four
days
abortive
ending
reasons
advanced
support
holding
similar
arguments
presented
government
effect
rejected
downum
suggests
government
unsuccessfully
argued
downum
double
jeopardy
pleas
sustained
logically
reprosecution
barred
case
error
committed
trial
decisions
however
non
sequitur
country
contrary
english
practice
defendant
may
retried
reversal
errors
trial
including
errors
instructions
rulings
evidence
admitting
confessions
permitting
prejudicial
comments
conduct
prosecutor
instances
realities
notwithstanding
errors
defendant
jury
trial
albeit
jury
trial
law
entitled
tateo
however
deprived
valued
right
original
jury
consider
case
wade
hunter
supra
experienced
trial
lawyer
aware
realities
jury
trials
recognize
difference
two
cases
many
juries
acquit
defendants
trials
reversible
error
committed
many
experienced
trial
lawyers
forego
motion
mistrial
favor
case
decided
jury
says
tateo
requested
mistrial
basis
judge
comments
doubt
successful
government
barred
retrying
ante
completely
overlooks
judge
weinfeld
unchallenged
finding
tateo
enveloped
coercive
force
trial
judge
threat
choice
plead
guilty
hypothesize
results
defense
request
mistrial
circumstances
obscures
issue
trial
judge
defendant
took
case
away
jury
coercing
guilty
plea
also
intimates
tateo
plea
double
jeopardy
accepted
logically
necessary
bar
reprosecutions
double
jeopardy
clause
persons
whose
guilty
pleas
made
jury
sworn
ultimately
found
coerced
decisions
follow
settled
interpretation
protection
double
jeopardy
clause
attach
jury
impaneled
sworn
nonjury
trial
begun
hear
evidence
thus
application
double
jeopardy
guarantee
tateo
case
plea
coerced
four
days
trial
way
impair
settled
interpretation
also
suggested
tateo
proceeded
verdict
appealed
sentence
reply
counsel
seems
unanswerable
audacious
trial
lawyer
indeed
advise
client
federal
risk
life
prison
without
hope
parole
basis
appellate
review
sentence
power
review
sentence
within
statutory
maximum
either
gore
appeals
pependrea
final
point
decision
necessary
protect
societal
interest
punishing
one
whose
guilt
clear
interest
prefers
right
accused
subjected
double
jeopardy
ante
deference
suggest
constitution
resolved
question
competing
interests
government
individual
favor
protecting
individual
harassment
danger
reprosecution
agree
brother
douglas
dissenting
gori
question
whether
defendant
receive
absolution
crime
policy
bill
rights
make
rare
indeed
occasions
citizen
offense
required
run
gantlet
twice
risk
judicial
arbitrariness
rests
view
constitution
puts
government
downum
resolve
doubt
favor
liberty
citizen
reasons
dissent
gori
expressly
refused
decide
whether
reprosecution
permitted
situations
discretion
trial
judge
may
abused
judge
exercises
authority
help
prosecution
holds
effect
reprosecution
permissible
situations
see
note
double
jeopardy
reprosecution
problem
harv
rev
ball
note
harv
downum
cornero
compare
bassing
cady
dickerson
app
whether
counsel
correct
conclusion
compare
wiley
note
rev
beside
point
dilemma
real
authorities