morgan
argued
april
decided
may
robert
jackson
sol
appellants
frederick
wood
new
york
city
john
gage
kansas
city
appellees
justice
stone
delivered
opinion
appeal
asked
determine
proper
disposition
made
fund
paid
pending
suit
instituted
set
aside
order
secretary
agriculture
reducing
scheduled
rates
services
rendered
kansas
city
stockyards
fund
made
difference
scheduled
rates
prescribed
secretary
order
ultimately
set
aside
morgan
without
consideration
merits
failure
secretary
follow
procedure
prescribed
statute
june
secretary
agriculture
promulgated
order
packers
stockyards
act
stat
setting
aside
schedule
maximum
rates
charged
stockyard
services
filed
market
agencies
kansas
city
stockyards
prescribing
new
lower
rate
schedule
future
suit
brought
district
western
missouri
appellees
conducting
market
agencies
kansas
city
stockyards
set
aside
order
confiscatory
rendered
without
procedural
due
process
july
entered
temporary
restraining
order
enjoining
enforcement
secretary
order
upon
condition
appellees
clerk
monday
every
week
thereafter
order
extension
thereof
may
remain
force
effect
pending
final
disposition
cause
full
amount
charges
collected
schedule
rates
effect
exceeds
amount
collected
rates
prescribed
order
secretary
together
verified
statement
names
addresses
persons
upon
whose
behalf
amounts
collected
petitioner
two
appeals
reversed
final
decree
district
sustained
order
secretary
held
accorded
appellees
hearing
act
requires
without
considering
merits
remanded
cause
proceedings
morgan
petition
rehearing
part
ground
mandate
made
provision
distribution
fund
paid
district
pursuant
restraining
order
denied
memorandum
opinion
stating
questions
raised
appropriately
district
cause
remanded
proceedings
opinion
added
remand
case
district
proceedings
conformity
opinion
proceedings
secretary
may
see
fit
take
light
decision
determinations
may
made
district
relation
ceedings
matters
attempt
forecast
hypothetically
decide
pages
page
remand
secretary
left
free
take
proceedings
statute
permits
texas
pacific
ry
interstate
commerce
commission
southern
railway
louis
hay
grain
state
florida
secretary
thereupon
order
june
reopened
original
proceedings
resulted
challenged
order
june
directed
findings
fact
conclusion
order
june
served
upon
appellee
market
agencies
tentative
findings
order
opportunity
appellees
file
exceptions
make
oral
argument
upon
exceptions
action
followed
june
present
proceeding
begun
motion
appellants
district
stay
proceedings
direct
clerk
retain
impounded
funds
time
secretary
proceeding
due
expedition
entered
final
order
proceedings
reopened
motion
denied
order
district
granting
motion
appellees
distribute
fund
among
case
comes
appeal
packers
stock
yards
act
stat
stat
judicial
code
stayed
superseded
order
district
pending
appeal
october
district
held
fund
presently
distributed
appellees
secretary
without
authority
act
make
order
prescribing
rates
charges
effective
june
date
original
order
construed
terms
restraining
order
requiring
distribution
fund
appellees
final
determination
secretary
order
june
invalid
thus
result
litigation
district
twice
sustained
determination
secretary
rates
prescribed
basis
voluminous
evidence
reasonable
decision
secretary
failed
observe
statutory
requirement
full
hearing
never
reviewed
determination
question
arises
whether
upon
redetermination
issue
secretary
district
exercise
power
order
distribution
impounded
fund
conformity
determination
directing
much
amounts
paid
exceeds
rates
ultimately
determined
upon
appropriate
review
secretary
findings
reasonable
returned
paid
issue
must
decided
unless
power
occasion
retain
fund
pending
proceedings
secretary
distribution
must
made
district
directed
decision
turns
meaning
application
provisions
packers
stockyards
act
construed
light
dominant
purpose
secure
patrons
stockyards
prescribed
stockyard
services
reasonable
rates
upon
authority
duty
district
effectuate
purpose
making
disposition
fund
section
act
requires
every
stockyard
owner
market
agency
furnish
discriminatory
reasonable
stockyard
services
declares
rates
charges
made
stockyard
services
furnished
stockyard
stockyard
owner
market
agency
shall
reasonable
unjust
unreasonable
discriminatory
rate
charge
prohibited
declared
unlawful
section
makes
like
requirement
regulations
practices
respect
furnishing
stockyard
services
section
makes
duty
stockyard
owners
market
agencies
file
secretary
schedule
rates
stockyard
services
charge
collect
rates
unless
set
aside
appropriate
action
secretary
changed
filing
new
rates
authorized
section
section
provides
stockyard
owner
market
agency
violating
previously
mentioned
sections
shall
liable
persons
injured
full
extent
damage
sustained
section
provides
enforcement
liability
either
complaint
secretary
suit
district
concludes
declaration
section
shall
way
abridge
alter
remedies
existing
common
law
statute
provisions
chapter
act
addition
remedies
section
authorizes
secretary
full
hearing
complaint
initiative
prescribe
reasonable
rates
future
appellees
insist
notwithstanding
command
rates
shall
reasonable
mandate
effective
far
implemented
sections
act
except
reparation
case
statute
forbids
secretary
make
orders
affecting
completed
transactions
acting
initiative
fix
rates
future
point
person
aggrieved
may
petition
secretary
seek
damages
exaction
unreasonable
rate
past
naming
new
rate
future
secretary
institutes
proceedings
motion
precluded
making
order
payment
money
original
proceeding
action
secretary
reopening
taken
motion
conclusion
drawn
legal
warrant
restitution
impounded
moneys
patrons
market
agencies
even
though
secretary
shall
determine
evidence
proper
procedure
scheduled
rates
exceeded
reasonable
rate
prescribed
even
though
premises
accepted
respects
sound
conclusion
follow
question
secretary
making
order
payment
money
fund
taken
custody
consequence
order
restraining
operation
rate
schedule
prescribed
secretary
questions
decision
whether
district
discharge
duty
thus
assumed
equity
rightly
dispose
fund
without
regard
command
secretary
shall
determine
rates
exacted
aid
paid
registry
excessive
whether
exercise
discretion
retain
fund
time
secretary
proceeding
due
expedition
shall
make
final
determination
order
answering
questions
two
cardinal
principles
must
guide
us
conclusion
one
construing
statute
setting
administrative
agency
providing
judicial
review
action
agency
regarded
wholly
independent
unrelated
instrumentalities
justice
acting
performance
prescribed
statutory
duty
without
regard
appropriate
function
securing
plainly
indicated
objects
statute
agency
means
adopted
attain
prescribed
end
far
duties
defined
words
statute
words
construed
attain
end
action
neither
body
repeat
day
mistake
made
courts
law
equity
struggling
recognition
ameliorating
system
justice
neither
rightly
regarded
alien
intruder
tolerated
must
never
encouraged
aided
attainment
common
aim
guiding
principle
reviewing
action
secretary
similarly
reviewing
action
interstate
commerce
commission
conformity
provisions
urgent
deficiencies
act
district
sits
equity
see
ford
motor
national
labor
relations
board
inland
steel
exerting
extraordinary
powers
stay
execution
rate
order
directing
payment
much
rate
found
administratively
excessive
assumes
duty
making
disposition
fund
conformity
equitable
principles
assuming
appellees
contend
secretary
order
june
set
aside
reopened
proceeding
neither
promulgate
rate
order
date
make
order
payment
money
still
without
authority
premises
statute
mandate
free
make
order
fixing
rates
future
purpose
within
purview
act
free
determine
reasonable
rate
period
antedating
order
may
make
see
atlantic
coast
line
florida
prior
decision
secretary
stands
way
making
determination
cf
arizona
grocery
atchison
topeka
santa
fe
railway
sole
limitation
upon
power
prescribed
upon
inquiry
instituted
may
order
payment
money
respects
power
investigate
decide
unaffected
may
make
inquiry
matter
thing
concerning
complaint
authorized
made
concerning
question
may
arise
provisions
act
relating
enforcement
provision
given
power
authority
proceed
inquiry
instituted
upon
motion
though
appealed
petition
including
power
make
enforce
order
orders
case
relating
matter
thing
concerning
inquiry
except
orders
payment
money
secretary
acting
entertain
complaint
patrons
appellees
contributed
fund
charging
rates
exacted
violation
seems
conceded
think
plain
section
specifically
provides
appears
reasonable
ground
investigating
complaint
shall
duty
secretary
investigate
matters
complained
manner
means
deems
proper
seems
equally
plain
secretary
exercise
discretion
may
conduct
investigation
motion
ordinarily
true
occasion
investigation
result
secretary
make
reparation
order
shall
presently
point
alleged
excessive
rates
custodia
legis
authority
equitable
duty
dispose
according
law
justice
thus
secretary
best
reasons
exercise
power
determine
whether
rates
reasonable
may
rightly
determination
afford
proper
basis
action
district
making
disposition
fund
district
staying
secretary
order
time
arresting
excess
payments
appellees
scheduled
rates
assumed
duty
making
proper
disposition
fund
upon
termination
litigation
duty
imperative
injunction
order
deprived
public
benefit
lower
rates
obstructed
effective
reparation
order
secretary
action
presupposed
ownership
excess
payments
doubt
finally
determined
adjudication
merits
reasonableness
filed
rates
taking
payments
custody
acted
equity
charged
responsibility
protecting
fund
disposing
according
law
free
discharge
duty
use
broad
discretion
exercise
powers
manner
avoid
unjust
unlawful
result
entered
contract
understanding
litigants
entered
undertaking
manner
disposing
fund
duty
respect
prescribed
applicable
principles
law
equity
protection
litigants
public
whose
interests
injunction
final
disposition
fund
affect
inland
steel
supra
familiar
doctrine
extent
equity
may
grant
withhold
aid
manner
moulding
remedies
may
affected
public
interest
involved
central
kentucky
gas
railroad
commission
pennsylvania
williams
virginia
railway
federation
et
congress
packers
stockyards
act
established
public
policy
maintaining
reasonable
rates
stockyard
services
prohibited
declared
unlawful
unjust
unreasonable
rate
equity
astute
avoid
use
process
effectuate
collection
unlawful
rates
equally
direct
restitution
rates
taken
custody
shown
unlawful
determination
already
made
secretary
proceeding
full
hearing
found
district
supported
evidence
duty
make
restitution
forthwith
seem
evident
notwithstanding
absence
order
secretary
directing
payment
inland
steel
supra
secretary
seen
authorized
make
determination
section
denounces
unreasonable
rates
unlawful
statute
declared
saves
authority
give
remedy
present
circumstances
might
otherwise
afford
went
much
atlantic
coast
line
florida
supra
denying
equitable
grounds
restitution
shippers
excess
intrastate
rate
prescribed
order
interstate
commerce
commission
avoid
discrimination
interstate
commerce
prescribed
state
commission
order
former
later
set
aside
want
proper
findings
commission
upon
proceedings
commission
made
second
order
upon
proper
findings
discrimination
establishing
rate
final
result
litigation
railroads
permitted
collect
retain
higher
rates
period
lawful
order
commission
superseding
state
commission
rates
administrative
agency
prescribe
rates
future
higher
rates
exacted
date
first
order
second
without
sanction
valid
order
first
administrative
order
nullity
ewell
daggs
weeks
bridgman
toy
toy
hopkins
though
voidable
ignored
without
incurring
penalties
disobedience
inflicted
applicable
provisions
statute
rates
lose
unjust
unreasonable
quality
one
case
cease
unjustly
discriminatory
merely
administrative
orders
voidable
procedural
defects
second
order
operate
future
case
administrative
agency
without
power
inquire
whether
injustice
done
earlier
rate
called
ascertain
according
equitable
principles
rights
parties
respect
payments
made
voidable
order
take
account
subsequent
determination
administrative
agency
basis
action
atlantic
coast
line
florida
supra
pages
pages
new
york
edison
maltbie
brooklyn
union
gas
maltbie
said
distinction
atlantic
coast
line
case
distinction
judicial
inaction
judicial
action
upon
settled
equitable
principles
free
refrain
compelling
restitution
satisfied
injustice
done
see
tiffany
boatman
institution
wall
mississippi
cromwell
deweese
reinhard
called
appellants
act
withholding
pellees
rates
still
lawfully
force
filed
schedule
set
aside
valid
order
secretary
moment
appellants
content
inaction
appellees
demanding
payment
rates
whose
lawfulness
challenged
yet
actual
posture
case
duty
act
virtue
taken
fund
possession
acting
dispose
fund
must
conform
controlling
legal
principles
reasonableness
rates
established
filed
schedules
rates
collected
paid
appellees
instead
clerk
secretary
ordered
reparation
upon
proper
findings
unreasonable
question
whether
must
face
proceeding
secretary
determine
reasonableness
challenged
rates
use
power
complete
collection
risk
obstructing
reparation
whether
remain
inactive
lawfulness
determined
act
accordingly
power
every
justice
long
retains
control
parties
correct
wrongfully
done
virtue
process
arkadelphia
milling
louis
railway
see
northwestern
fuel
brock
given
paid
compulsion
judgment
restore
judgment
set
aside
justice
requires
restitution
northwestern
fuel
brock
supra
ex
parte
lincoln
gas
electric
light
baltimore
ohio
railway
injunction
compelled
payment
registry
amounts
may
pending
proceedings
found
due
paid
think
justice
equally
requires
await
outcome
proceedings
order
may
discharge
duty
owes
litigants
public
avoiding
unlawful
disposition
fund
meantime
ultimately
distributing
found
entitled
see
new
york
edison
maltbie
supra
brooklyn
union
gas
maltbie
supra
cf
klein
proceeding
pending
secretary
seen
free
determine
reasonableness
rates
determination
supported
evidence
made
proceeding
conducted
conformity
statute
due
process
afford
appropriate
basis
action
district
making
distribution
fund
custody
atlantic
coast
line
florida
supra
pages
pages
due
regard
discharge
responsibility
litigants
public
appropriate
exercise
discretion
manner
effectuate
policy
act
facilitate
administration
system
set
require
retention
fund
district
time
secretary
proceeding
due
expedition
shall
entered
final
order
proceedings
pending
cf
mahler
eby
tod
waldman
district
thus
avoid
risk
using
process
instrument
injustice
full
record
secretary
proceedings
including
findings
supported
evidence
appropriate
basis
action
able
make
order
distribution
accordingly
reversed
justice
reed
took
part
consideration
decision
case
justice
butler
dissenting
proceedings
instituted
complaint
shippers
secretary
july
approved
per
cent
reduction
market
agencies
charges
may
agencies
filed
tariffs
challenged
shippers
suspended
secretary
making
additional
reductions
per
cent
rates
remained
force
november
became
effective
new
schedule
established
agreement
agencies
secretary
question
reasonableness
charges
made
since
date
appellees
required
continue
making
deposits
secure
compliance
secretary
order
june
challenged
suit
impounding
ceased
money
deposit
district
made
amounts
taken
charges
low
lower
put
kept
force
applied
november
proceedings
pending
secretary
may
order
reparation
see
also
arizona
grocery
atchison
without
jurisdiction
prescribe
charges
applied
effective
date
order
one
shall
made
challenged
order
adjudged
invalid
made
violation
act
morgan
appellees
immediately
became
entitled
money
pursuance
restraining
order
deposited
secure
compliance
secretary
order
found
valid
record
contains
nothing
support
idea
pledge
purpose
justify
excuse
withholding
another
use
reasons
stated
opinion
district
rightly
held
appellees
entitled
money
returned
decree
affirmed
justice
mcreynolds
justice
roberts
join
opinion
footnotes
date
district
entered
decree
mandate
setting
aside
secretary
order
june
permanently
enjoining
enforcement
decree
district
retained
jurisdiction
decreed
proceedings
herein
conformity
opinion
said
reference
distribution
restitution
funds
deposited
plaintiffs
registry
clerk
thereof
pursuant
provisions
temporary
restraining
order
entered
day
july
law
justice
may
appertain
see
ed
iv
pl
heath
rydley
holdsworth
history
english
law
secretary
may
time
institute
inquiry
motion
case
matter
thing
concerning
complaint
authorized
made
secretary
provision
sections
inclusive
chapter
title
concerning
question
may
arise
provisions
sections
inclusive
chapter
title
relating
enforcement
provisions
sections
inclusive
chapter
title
secretary
shall
power
authority
proceed
inquiry
instituted
upon
motion
though
appealed
petition
including
power
make
enforce
order
orders
case
relating
matter
thing
concerning
inquiry
except
orders
payment
money
inland
steel
interstate
commerce
commission
ordered
certain
railroads
cease
payment
shippers
conformity
filed
tariff
switching
charges
commission
found
unlawful
review
action
commission
district
stayed
commission
order
directed
railroads
pending
final
disposition
cause
place
payments
due
tariff
special
fund
held
subject
order
commission
order
ultimately
sustained
meanwhile
commission
pending
review
courts
postponed
effective
date
order
litigation
operative
commission
order
forbidding
unlawful
payments
rejected
contention
shippers
fund
must
paid
accumulated
absence
controlling
order
commission
held
duty
district
resulting
injunction
control
fund
make
equitable
disposition
sustained
district
order
fund
turned
railroads
conformity
commission
determination
confirmed
judicial
review
switching
allowances
unlawful