lehman
nakshian
argued
march
decided
june
age
discrimination
employment
act
adea
act
amended
extend
federal
employees
act
protection
older
workers
discrimination
workplace
based
age
section
act
provides
aggrieved
federal
employee
may
bring
civil
action
federal
district
competent
jurisdiction
legal
equitable
relief
effectuate
purposes
act
respondent
federal
employee
brought
suit
federal
district
secretary
navy
alleging
violations
act
demanding
jury
trial
district
ruled
secretary
objection
respondent
entitled
jury
trial
interlocutory
appeal
appeals
affirmed
held
respondent
entitled
jury
trial
pp
congress
waives
government
immunity
suit
adea
plaintiff
right
trial
jury
congress
affirmatively
unambiguously
granted
right
statute
pp
congress
done
neither
provision
federal
employer
cases
brought
federal
district
courts
rather
claims
use
word
legal
section
evinces
congressional
intent
adea
plaintiffs
proceed
trial
federal
government
may
jury
lorillard
pons
distinguished
section
contrasts
act
expressly
provides
jury
trials
actions
private
employers
state
local
governments
moreover
extending
act
cover
federal
employees
congress
based
provision
fair
labor
standards
act
title
vii
civil
rights
act
unlike
flsa
right
trial
jury
pp
legislative
history
supports
holding
respondent
right
jury
trial
statutory
language
pp
stewart
delivered
opinion
burger
white
powell
rehnquist
joined
brennan
filed
dissenting
opinion
marshall
blackmun
stevens
joined
post
edwin
kneedler
argued
cause
petitioner
briefs
solicitor
general
mccree
acting
assistant
attorney
general
martin
deputy
solicitor
general
geller
robert
kopp
michael
jay
singer
patricia
barry
argued
cause
filed
brief
respondent
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
affirmance
filed
mary
jacksteit
american
federation
government
employees
congressman
claude
pepper
pro
se
edward
howard
pepper
et
al
justice
stewart
delivered
opinion
question
presented
case
whether
plaintiff
action
age
discrimination
employment
act
entitled
trial
jury
amendments
age
discrimination
employment
act
added
new
brought
federal
government
within
scope
act
first
time
section
prohibits
federal
government
discrimination
based
age
civilian
employment
decisions
concerning
persons
years
age
section
provides
enforcement
agencies
including
military
departments
responsibility
equal
employment
opportunity
commission
commission
directed
issue
rules
regulations
orders
instructions
commission
deems
necessary
appropriate
carry
responsibility
section
provides
person
aggrieved
may
bring
civil
action
federal
district
competent
jurisdiction
legal
equitable
relief
effectuate
purposes
act
stat
interlocutory
appeal
divided
panel
appeals
affirmed
nakshian
claytor
app
appellate
rejected
secretary
argument
plaintiff
entitled
trial
jury
suit
trial
expressly
authorized
instead
viewed
question
ordinary
question
statutory
interpretation
found
sufficient
evidence
legislative
intent
provide
trial
jury
cases
noting
congress
conferred
jurisdiction
adea
suits
upon
federal
district
courts
rather
claims
appeals
concluded
absent
provision
method
trial
grant
jurisdiction
district
law
carries
right
jury
trial
quoting
moore
lucas
wicker
moore
federal
practice
footnotes
omitted
appeals
also
adopted
district
view
legal
relief
language
view
existence
explicit
statutory
right
jury
trial
suits
private
employers
negate
existence
right
jury
trial
suits
government
since
provision
jury
trials
private
suits
added
resolve
conflict
courts
appeals
issue
confirm
correctness
decision
lorillard
case
granted
certiorari
consider
issue
presented
sub
nom
hildalgo
nakshian
ii
long
settled
seventh
amendment
right
trial
jury
apply
actions
federal
government
galloway
observed
footnotes
omitted
suit
one
enforce
monetary
claim
hardly
maintained
common
law
jury
trial
matter
right
persons
asserting
claims
sovereign
whatever
force
amendment
therefore
derived
congress
legislation
cited
made
applicable
congress
waived
sovereign
immunity
almost
always
conditioned
waiver
upon
plaintiff
relinquishing
claim
jury
trial
jury
trials
example
made
available
claims
broad
range
cases
within
jurisdiction
claims
founded
either
upon
constitution
act
congress
upon
express
implied
contract
liquidated
unliquidated
damages
cases
sounding
tort
see
glidden
supra
jury
trial
right
range
cases
federal
district
courts
concurrent
jurisdiction
see
finally
tort
actions
see
congress
similarly
provided
trials
shall
without
jury
appropriate
inquiry
therefore
whether
congress
clearly
unequivocally
departed
usual
practice
area
granted
right
trial
jury
amended
adea
section
adea
ed
supp
iii
prohibits
age
discrimination
federal
employment
section
provides
means
judicial
enforcement
guarantee
person
aggrieved
may
bring
civil
action
federal
district
competent
jurisdiction
legal
equitable
relief
effectuate
purposes
act
section
contrasts
act
supp
iii
authorizes
civil
actions
private
employers
state
local
governments
expressly
provides
jury
trials
congress
accordingly
demonstrated
knew
provide
statutory
right
jury
trial
wished
elsewhere
legislation
cited
galloway
supra
failed
explicitly
see
fedorenko
cf
monroe
standard
oil
respondent
infers
statutory
intent
language
providing
award
legal
equitable
relief
relying
lorillard
pons
proposition
authorization
legal
relief
supports
statutory
jury
trial
right
lorillard
application
context
first
place
word
legal
deemed
lorillard
described
term
art
respect
availability
jury
trials
cases
defendant
federal
government
lorillard
authorization
award
legal
relief
significant
largely
presence
constitutional
question
observed
legal
relief
granted
litigation
private
parties
seventh
amendment
guarantees
right
jury
reasoned
congress
must
aware
significance
word
legal
context
seventh
amendment
application
actions
law
government
congress
always
recognized
thus
particular
significance
attributed
word
legal
moreover
another
basis
decision
lorillard
congress
chose
incorporate
enforcement
scheme
fair
labor
standards
act
flsa
adea
adopted
adea
flsa
practice
making
jury
trials
available
reasoning
relevance
case
congress
incorporate
flsa
enforcement
scheme
see
supp
iii
rather
patterned
civil
rights
act
amended
march
see
pub
stat
extend
protection
title
vii
federal
employees
see
cong
rec
remarks
bentsen
principal
sponsor
adea
course
contrast
flsa
right
trial
jury
cases
arising
title
vii
see
lorillard
supra
great
american
federal
savings
loan
assn
novotny
respondent
also
infers
right
trial
jury
fact
congress
conferred
jurisdiction
adea
suits
upon
federal
district
courts
jury
trials
ordinarily
available
rather
upon
claims
little
logical
support
inference
legislative
history
offers
support
either
moreover
rule
federal
rules
civil
procedure
provides
right
jury
trial
declared
seventh
amendment
constitution
given
statute
shall
preserved
parties
inviolate
emphasis
added
language
hardly
general
rule
jury
trials
presumed
whenever
congress
provides
cases
brought
federal
district
courts
indeed
rule
requires
affirmative
statutory
grant
right
case
seventh
amendment
apply
already
indicated
unnecessary
go
beyond
language
statute
conclude
congress
intend
confer
right
trial
jury
adea
plaintiffs
proceeding
federal
government
helpful
briefly
explore
legislative
history
demonstrate
supports
holding
appeals
statutory
language
respondent
point
single
reference
legislative
history
subject
jury
trials
cases
brought
federal
government
none
nothing
indicate
congress
mean
plainly
indicated
expressly
provided
jury
trials
cases
cases
fact
inferences
may
drawn
legislative
history
inconsistent
respondent
position
adea
originally
applied
actions
private
employers
section
incorporated
enforcement
scheme
used
employee
actions
private
employers
flsa
lorillard
found
incorporation
flsa
scheme
indicated
flsa
right
trial
jury
also
incorporated
lorillard
holding
codified
amended
provide
expressly
jury
trials
actions
brought
section
congress
expanded
scope
adea
include
state
local
government
federal
government
employers
state
local
governments
added
potential
defendants
simple
expansion
term
employer
adea
existing
substantive
procedural
provisions
act
including
thereby
extended
cover
state
local
government
employees
contrast
congress
added
entirely
new
section
address
problems
age
discrimination
federal
employment
congress
deliberately
prescribed
distinct
statutory
scheme
applicable
federal
sector
one
based
flsa
already
indicated
title
vii
unlike
flsa
right
trial
jury
finally
amendment
adea
congress
declined
opportunity
extend
right
trial
jury
federal
employee
plaintiffs
announcement
lorillard
senate
house
included
amendment
provide
jury
trials
pending
bill
revise
adea
lorillard
conference
committee
recommended
congress
enacted
present
closely
resembling
jury
trial
amendment
passed
senate
conference
recommend
congress
enact
corresponding
amendment
provide
jury
trials
cases
federal
government
indeed
conferees
recommended
congress
enacted
new
supp
iii
providing
federal
personnel
actions
covered
subject
section
adea
one
exception
relevant
see
conf
see
also
section
complete
since
new
subsection
clearly
emphasized
unaffected
sections
including
governing
procedures
applicable
actions
private
employers
judge
tamm
dissenting
appeals
surely
correct
concluded
amending
sections
congress
overlooked
need
amend
allow
jury
trials
government
employees
wished
app
even
legislative
history
ambiguous
affect
proper
resolution
case
plaintiff
action
right
trial
jury
congress
affirmatively
unambiguously
granted
right
statute
congress
obviously
done
neither
provision
federal
employer
cases
brought
district
courts
rather
claims
use
word
legal
section
evinces
congressional
intent
adea
plaintiffs
proceed
trial
federal
government
may
jury
congress
expressly
provided
jury
trials
section
act
applicable
privatesector
employers
state
local
governmental
entities
section
applicable
federal
government
employer
indeed
patterned
section
provisions
another
act
right
trial
jury
conclusion
inescapable
congress
depart
normal
practice
providing
right
trial
jury
waived
sovereign
immunity
reasons
judgment
appeals
reversed
ordered
footnotes
section
amended
provides
pertinent
part
personnel
actions
affecting
employees
applicants
employment
least
years
age
military
departments
enumerated
government
agencies
shall
made
free
discrimination
based
age
supp
iii
ed
supp
iii
section
amended
set
forth
supp
iii
provides
person
aggrieved
may
bring
civil
action
competent
jurisdiction
legal
equitable
relief
effectuate
purposes
chapter
provided
right
person
bring
action
shall
terminate
upon
commencement
action
commission
enforce
right
employee
chapter
action
brought
paragraph
person
shall
entitled
trial
jury
issue
fact
action
recovery
amounts
owing
result
violation
chapter
regardless
whether
equitable
relief
sought
party
action
see
supra
difficult
appreciate
congress
reluctance
provide
jury
trials
fashioning
narrow
exception
permit
jury
trials
tax
refund
cases
federal
district
courts
legislation
congress
recognized
established
wholly
new
precedent
congress
expressed
concern
juries
might
tend
overly
generous
virtually
unlimited
ability
government
pay
verdict
ibid
indeed
firm
opposition
breaking
precedent
house
conferees
took
almost
year
acceding
passage
bill
containing
exception
much
debate
conferees
became
convinced
danger
excessive
verdicts
result
jury
trials
unique
context
recoveries
limited
amount
taxes
illegally
erroneously
collected
bill
passed
see
conf
respondent
argues
strong
presumption
waiver
sovereign
immunity
relevance
question
right
trial
jury
clear
doctrine
sovereign
immunity
attendant
presumptions
must
inform
decision
case
reason
seventh
amendment
presumption
favor
jury
trials
apply
actions
law
immune
suit
seventh
amendment
right
jury
trial
therefore
never
existed
respect
suit
since
generally
applicable
jury
trial
right
attaches
consents
suit
accepted
principles
sovereign
immunity
require
jury
trial
right
clearly
provided
legislation
creating
cause
action
dissenters
contend
argument
made
expense
overruling
lorillard
decision
hereafter
indicated
lorillard
little
relevance
course
position
taken
dissent
totally
loses
force
view
amendments
adea
see
infra
congress
expressly
extended
jury
trial
right
decisions
cited
lorillard
proposition
right
jury
trial
flsa
actions
appear
rested
seventh
amendment
flsa
thus
reason
seventh
amendment
apply
suits
federal
government
comparable
right
trial
jury
flsa
suits
federal
government
accordingly
even
congress
intended
incorporate
flsa
enforcement
scheme
adea
basis
inferring
right
jury
trial
adea
cases
employer
federal
government
number
reasons
congress
may
chosen
limit
jurisdiction
federal
district
courts
along
state
courts
already
jurisdiction
adea
cases
congress
may
decided
follow
course
federal
sector
cases
confined
jurisdiction
federal
district
courts
trials
state
courts
actions
federal
government
exclusive
district
jurisdiction
also
consistent
jurisdictional
references
title
vii
civil
rights
act
see
congress
may
also
believed
appropriate
trials
federal
district
courts
unlike
claims
accustomed
awarding
equitable
relief
sort
authorized
respondent
relies
pfitsch
language
relied
pfitsch
dicta
since
parties
case
agreed
trial
sitting
without
jury
jury
trial
issue
therefore
directly
event
pfitsch
plainly
distinguishable
congress
specifically
rejected
proposal
presented
attention
precise
form
confer
concurrent
jurisdiction
district
courts
claims
tucker
act
instead
conferred
new
exclusive
jurisdiction
district
courts
given
particular
legislative
history
case
found
difficult
conceive
rational
ground
conferring
exclusive
jurisdiction
district
courts
except
provide
jury
trials
ibid
course
true
see
supra
moreover
pfitsch
arose
rule
federal
rules
civil
procedure
rule
made
clear
general
right
trial
jury
civil
actions
federal
district
courts
rule
establishes
mechanism
determining
right
seventh
amendment
applies
statute
provides
respondent
also
relies
law
statement
law
regarding
jury
trials
fact
cite
pfitsch
also
dictum
virtually
relevance
context
bill
introduced
senator
bentsen
march
cong
rec
represented
first
attempt
prohibit
age
discrimination
federal
employment
bill
simply
amended
definition
employer
act
include
federal
government
well
state
local
governments
result
presumably
bring
federal
employees
procedural
provisions
senator
bentsen
subsequently
submitted
revised
version
bill
form
amendment
pending
flsa
amendments
see
cong
rec
contrast
senator
bentsen
original
bill
amendment
adea
proposed
expansion
definition
term
employer
respect
state
local
governments
adea
coverage
federal
employees
accomplished
addition
entirely
new
separate
section
act
presently
senator
bentsen
amendment
included
flsa
bill
reported
committee
labor
public
welfare
pp
remained
form
bill
enacted
law
sections
adea
offered
senator
bentsen
finally
enacted
patterned
directly
civil
rights
act
amended
march
see
pub
stat
extend
title
vii
protections
federal
employees
senator
bentsen
acknowledged
measures
used
protect
federal
employees
age
discrimination
substantially
similar
incorporated
recently
enacted
amendments
title
vii
cong
rec
fact
floor
consideration
amendments
title
vii
senate
rejected
amendment
conferred
statutory
right
trial
jury
title
vii
cases
id
senator
javits
opposing
amendment
observed
impose
special
requirement
cases
distinguished
antidiscrimination
field
generally
jury
trial
justice
brennan
justice
marshall
justice
blackmun
justice
stevens
join
dissenting
lorillard
pons
held
employee
brings
action
private
employer
age
discrimination
employment
act
adea
act
entitled
trial
jury
question
presented
case
whether
plaintiff
right
trial
jury
action
federal
government
adea
today
holds
jury
trial
available
actions
believe
congress
unmistakably
manifested
intention
accord
jury
trial
right
dissent
respondent
brought
lawsuit
district
district
columbia
secretary
navy
alleging
violations
adea
demanded
jury
trial
secretary
moved
strike
demand
district
denied
motion
strike
certified
interlocutory
appeal
question
whether
jury
trial
available
adea
action
federal
government
see
appeals
granted
secretary
petition
interlocutory
review
affirmed
ruling
district
respondent
entitled
jury
trial
nakshian
claytor
app
relying
principally
fact
congress
vested
jurisdiction
adea
suits
federal
government
federal
district
courts
rather
claims
authorization
act
award
legal
equitable
relief
appeals
construed
statute
accord
jury
trial
ii
well
settled
sovereign
immune
suit
save
consents
sued
testan
quoting
sherwood
consent
suit
must
unequivocally
expressed
mitchell
king
adea
expressly
waived
immunity
ed
supp
iii
doubt
consent
sued
requirement
waiver
immunity
unequivocally
expressed
however
suggests
carry
presumption
jury
trial
cases
waived
immunity
indeed
previously
declined
adopt
presumption
see
law
pfitsch
moreover
view
presumption
jury
trials
suits
federal
government
belied
statutes
cites
indicate
congress
often
conditioned
waiver
immunity
upon
plaintiff
relinquishing
claim
jury
trial
ante
fact
congress
found
necessary
state
expressly
jury
trial
right
broad
range
cases
government
see
demonstrates
congress
legislate
backdrop
presumption
jury
trial
right
suits
believe
therefore
government
unequivocally
waives
immunity
suit
plaintiff
right
jury
trial
question
statutory
construction
proper
inquiry
whether
statute
expressly
fair
implication
provides
jury
trial
see
law
supra
pfitsch
supra
moore
lucas
wicker
moore
federal
practice
wright
miller
federal
practice
procedure
turn
therefore
statute
congress
passed
adea
protect
older
workers
discrimination
workplace
basis
age
see
oscar
mayer
evans
lorillard
pons
see
generally
note
age
discrimination
employment
rev
act
protection
originally
limited
employees
private
sector
see
pub
stat
ed
congress
amended
act
adding
extended
protection
federal
employees
well
section
provides
personnel
actions
affecting
federal
employees
shall
made
free
discrimination
based
age
grants
equal
employment
opportunity
commission
authority
enforce
statutory
provisions
although
provision
expressly
grants
precludes
jury
trial
congress
provided
stat
ny
federal
employee
aggrieved
may
bring
civil
action
federal
district
competent
jurisdiction
legal
equitable
relief
effectuate
purposes
act
emphasis
added
provision
believe
demonstrates
congressional
intent
allow
jury
trial
adea
suits
federal
government
lorillard
pons
supra
construed
provision
identical
relevant
respects
afford
age
discrimination
plaintiffs
right
jury
trial
private
employers
reached
result
two
reasons
first
found
language
provisions
chapter
shall
enforced
accordance
powers
remedies
procedures
certain
provisions
fair
labor
standards
act
flsa
suggested
congress
intended
grant
jury
trial
right
ong
congress
enacted
adea
well
established
right
jury
trial
private
actions
pursuant
flsa
second
significant
case
found
authorization
courts
grant
individuals
seek
legal
equitable
relief
emphasis
added
strongly
suggested
congress
intended
grant
jury
trial
right
thus
held
matter
statutory
construction
adea
allows
jury
trials
actions
private
employers
instant
case
congress
similarly
authorized
aggrieved
persons
seek
district
courts
grant
legal
equitable
relief
effectuate
purposes
chapter
emphasis
added
thereby
suggesting
federal
employees
entitled
jury
trial
adea
unanimous
emphasized
lorillard
word
legal
term
art
cases
legal
relief
available
legal
rights
determined
seventh
amendment
provides
right
jury
trial
see
curtis
loether
words
employed
statute
time
meaning
common
law
law
country
presumed
used
sense
unless
context
compels
contrary
standard
oil
see
gilbert
montclair
ramsdell
infer
therefore
providing
specifically
legal
relief
congress
knew
significance
term
legal
intended
jury
trial
demand
strong
inference
congress
intended
legislate
jury
trial
right
reinforced
congress
decision
vest
jurisdiction
district
courts
rather
claims
decide
adea
suits
brought
federal
government
previously
observed
vesting
jurisdiction
district
courts
rather
claims
supports
inference
right
jury
trial
pfitsch
stated
right
jury
trial
incident
grant
exclusive
jurisdiction
district
courts
similarly
law
held
district
erred
denying
right
jury
trial
war
risk
insurance
act
concluded
jurisdiction
exceptional
jurisdiction
concurrent
claims
rather
exercised
accordance
laws
governing
usual
procedure
actions
law
money
compensation
congress
vesting
jurisdiction
federal
district
courts
adea
suggests
therefore
intended
provide
jury
trial
right
federal
adea
plaintiffs
legislative
history
adea
amendments
extending
protection
federal
employees
consistent
conclusion
congress
intended
allow
jury
trials
congress
failure
include
federal
employees
adea
act
first
passed
represent
conscious
decision
congress
limit
adea
employment
private
sector
reflects
fact
adea
enacted
government
employees
outside
scope
flsa
wage
hour
public
contracts
divisions
department
labor
enforces
fair
labor
standards
act
assigned
responsibility
enforcing
age
discrimination
employment
act
strong
manifestation
congressional
intent
language
legislative
history
amendments
enhanced
total
absence
persuasive
evidence
contrary
legislative
intent
argues
nonetheless
congress
decision
amend
adea
provide
explicitly
jury
trials
private
employer
cases
brought
without
also
amending
demonstrates
intention
preclude
jury
trials
government
completely
unpersuaded
bill
led
codification
jury
trial
right
introduced
senator
kennedy
decided
lorillard
order
settle
conflict
among
courts
appeals
availability
jury
trials
adea
suits
private
employers
senator
kennedy
proposed
amendment
adea
state
haec
verba
jury
trials
allowed
cong
rec
senator
kennedy
amendment
adopted
senate
without
debate
lorillard
subsequently
decided
thereafter
congress
passed
kennedy
amendment
modification
proposed
house
conference
extending
jury
trial
right
beyond
proposed
senator
kennedy
passed
senate
include
claims
liquidated
damages
discern
congressional
intent
preclude
right
jury
trial
adea
actions
federal
government
sequence
events
plausible
explanation
one
textual
support
relevant
legislative
history
conf
pp
congress
understood
lorillard
opinion
conferring
power
award
legal
relief
suggested
jury
trial
right
reason
congress
proceeded
kennedy
amendment
make
clear
suits
wages
tried
jury
also
suits
liquidated
damages
tried
jury
issue
explicitly
left
unresolved
lorillard
moreover
congress
add
provision
added
indicative
intent
prohibit
jury
trials
additional
reason
conflict
courts
appeals
whether
employees
jury
trial
private
employers
prompted
senator
kennedy
introduce
bill
parallel
development
courts
interpreting
legislative
history
therefore
support
conclusion
seeks
draw
also
argues
absence
reference
flsa
powers
remedies
procedures
refers
upon
lorillard
partially
relied
suggests
congress
intend
allow
jury
trials
federal
government
decision
lorillard
rested
equally
provision
legal
equitable
relief
strong
independent
indication
congressional
intent
allow
jury
trials
addition
likely
explanation
absence
reference
flsa
sections
referred
congress
intended
use
existing
administrative
procedures
enforce
provisions
appropriate
remedies
including
reinstatement
hiring
employees
without
backpay
supp
iii
prior
amendments
extending
adea
coverage
federal
employees
employment
discrimination
complaints
federal
employees
processed
civil
service
commission
surprising
congress
decided
use
existing
administrative
machinery
enforce
adea
provisions
protecting
federal
employees
see
fed
reg
reprinted
amended
cfr
failure
refer
flsa
procedures
apparently
derives
desire
limit
jury
trials
intention
employ
different
administrative
procedures
age
discrimination
complaints
brought
federal
government
seen
light
strained
interpretation
failure
refer
flsa
procedures
totally
unpersuasive
iii
based
language
legislative
history
consistent
interpretation
language
hold
congress
intended
allow
jury
trials
adea
suits
federal
government
appeals
correctly
noted
since
sovereign
immunity
bars
actions
government
actions
tried
well
tried
jury
difficult
see
doctrine
create
presumption
particular
method
trial
nce
congress
waived
government
immunity
explicitly
specified
trial
procedure
followed
sovereign
immunity
drops
picture
courts
must
scrutinize
available
indicia
legislative
intent
see
trial
procedure
congress
authorized
nakshian
claytor
app
course
seventh
amendment
right
jury
trial
federal
government
galloway
mcelrath
rule
federal
rules
civil
procedure
contrary
provides
right
trial
jury
declared
seventh
amendment
constitution
given
statute
shall
preserved
parties
inviolate
requirement
rule
congress
make
intent
authorize
jury
trials
express
provided
congress
otherwise
makes
intent
known
indeed
rule
fully
applicable
time
lorillard
pons
found
jury
trial
right
even
though
words
trial
jury
appear
statute
argue
otherwise
stating
rule
requires
affirmative
statutory
grant
jury
trial
right
ante
argue
rule
requires
jury
trial
right
express
obviously
argument
frivolous
since
lorillard
found
jury
trial
right
absence
express
provision
conferring
right
either
rule
require
grant
express
suggest
unanimous
holding
lorillard
wrong
still
misapprehends
thrust
argument
rule
hardly
general
rule
jury
trials
presumed
whenever
congress
provides
cases
brought
federal
district
courts
ante
simply
argued
conferral
jurisdiction
district
courts
raises
inference
jury
trial
right
suits
claims
jury
trial
right
available
alternative
forum
cases
congress
chose
cases
federal
district
courts
claims
appropriate
forum
originally
passed
definition
term
employer
expressly
excluded
political
subdivisions
adea
coverage
pub
stat
equal
employment
opportunity
commission
assumed
enforcement
authority
civil
service
commission
pursuant
reorganization
plan
cfr
app
supp
iii
section
adea
read
lorillard
decided
stated
full
person
aggrieved
may
bring
civil
action
competent
jurisdiction
legal
equitable
relief
effectuate
purposes
chapter
provided
right
person
bring
action
shall
terminate
upon
commencement
action
secretary
enforce
right
employee
chapter
construing
statute
allow
jury
trial
decide
whether
seventh
amendment
requires
private
action
lost
wages
adea
parties
must
given
option
case
heard
jury
statement
lorillard
authorization
award
legal
relief
significant
largely
presence
constitutional
question
correct
ante
sure
constitutional
question
present
lorillard
specifically
declined
ground
decision
seventh
amendment
see
supra
rather
construed
language
legal
equitable
relief
adea
concluded
congress
used
words
legal
relief
equally
present
intended
jury
trial
right
available
congress
used
words
legal
relief
differently
way
used
words
implausible
moreover
erroneously
suggests
identical
title
vii
civil
rights
act
ante
fails
note
title
vii
authorize
courts
award
legal
relief
pfitsch
construed
lever
act
conferred
exclusive
jurisdiction
district
courts
hear
lawsuits
brought
persons
dissatisfied
president
award
compensation
supplies
requisitioned
federal
government
deciding
judgment
rendered
reviewable
direct
writ
error
stated
congress
issue
clearly
drawn
granting
adjudication
cases
arising
concurrent
jurisdiction
claims
district
courts
without
trial
jury
establishing
exclusive
jurisdiction
district
courts
right
jury
trial
incident
emphasis
added
congress
far
legislative
history
indicates
expressly
debate
vesting
concurrent
jurisdiction
claims
adea
suits
federal
government
weaken
force
pfitsch
despite
protestations
contrary
indeed
law
important
case
virtually
ignores
see
ante
significance
whether
congress
specifically
considered
vesting
jurisdiction
claims
order
conclude
war
risk
insurance
act
authorized
jury
trial
suit
federal
government
significant
instant
case
allowing
suits
government
adea
congress
expressly
opted
jurisdiction
district
courts
claims
lawsuits
government
alternative
forum
congress
undoubtedly
aware
one
leading
commentator
concluded
congress
may
confer
jurisdiction
actions
upon
district
sitting
law
equity
claims
admiralty
particular
grant
jurisdiction
determine
method
trial
jury
absence
express
provision
dealing
method
trial
thus
absent
provision
method
trial
grant
jurisdiction
district
law
carries
right
jury
trial
moore
lucas
wicker
moore
federal
practice
emphasis
added
footnotes
omitted
senator
bentsen
also
stated
reason
private
enterprise
subject
restrictions
applicable
federal
government
legislation
give
workers
coverage
age
discrimination
law
give
procedure
pursue
complaints
cong
rec
section
adea
supp
iii
provides
person
aggrieved
may
bring
civil
action
competent
jurisdiction
legal
equitable
relief
effectuate
purposes
chapter
provided
right
person
bring
action
shall
terminate
upon
commencement
action
secretary
enforce
right
employee
chapter
action
brought
paragraph
person
shall
entitled
trial
jury
issue
fact
action
recovery
amounts
owing
result
violation
chapter
regardless
whether
equitable
relief
sought
party
action
compare
rogers
exxon
research
engineering
right
jury
trial
cert
denied
pons
lorillard
aff
morelock
ncr
right
jury
trial
vacated
remanded
senator
kennedy
explained
uries
likely
open
issues
raised
plaintiffs
sometimes
judge
may
slightly
callous
perhaps
protected
life
tenure
somewhat
removed
usual
relationship
jury
may
neutral
circumstances
cong
rec
indeed
conference
report
specifically
noted
recently
decided
lorillard
pons
went
state
liquidated
damages
nature
legal
relief
manifest
party
entitled
factual
issues
underlying
claim
decided
jury
conf
recently
ruled
plaintiff
entitled
jury
trial
adea
actions
lost
wages
decide
whether
right
jury
trial
claim
liquidated
damages
suggests
adea
patterned
significant
respects
title
vii
since
title
vii
held
lower
federal
courts
allow
jury
trial
right
follows
contemplate
right
find
argument
unpersuasive
lorillard
previously
said
despite
important
similarities
title
vii
adea
remedial
procedural
provisions
two
laws
crucial
find
significant
differences
lorillard
pons
congress
specifically
provided
legal
equitable
relief
adea
authorize
legal
relief
many
words
title
vii
ibid
interpretation
supported
congress
extension
adea
protection
employees
state
local
governments
occurred
time
congress
extended
coverage
federal
employees
definitional
section
act
amended
include
state
local
governments
within
definition
employer
age
discrimination
complaints
state
local
governments
tried
jury
reason
complaints
private
entities
nowhere
legislative
history
congress
evince
desire
allow
state
local
government
employees
jury
trial
right
withholding
right
federal
employees
rather
federal
employees
covered
separate
section
act
apparently
existing
administrative
machinery
used