hartford
underwriters
insurance
union
planters
bank
argued
march
decided
may
attempted
reorganization
chapter
bankruptcy
code
debtor
hen
house
interstate
obtained
workers
compensation
insurance
petitioner
hartford
underwriters
although
hen
house
repeatedly
failed
make
monthly
premium
payments
required
policy
hartford
continued
provide
insurance
reorganization
ultimately
failed
converted
case
chapter
liquidation
proceeding
appointed
trustee
learning
bankruptcy
proceedings
conversion
recognizing
estate
lacked
unencumbered
funds
pay
premiums
owed
hartford
attempted
charge
premiums
respondent
bank
secured
creditor
pursuant
bankruptcy
ruled
hartford
district
affirmed
en
banc
eighth
circuit
reversed
concluding
invoked
administrative
claimant
held
section
provide
administrative
claimant
bankruptcy
estate
independent
right
seek
payment
claim
property
encumbered
secured
creditor
lien
pp
administrative
claimant
petitioner
proper
party
seek
recovery
provides
trustee
may
recover
property
securing
allowed
secured
claim
costs
expenses
preserving
disposing
property
statute
appears
quite
plain
specifying
may
use
trustee
although
statutory
text
actually
say
persons
trustee
may
seek
recovery
several
contextual
features
support
conclusion
first
situation
statute
authorizes
specific
action
designates
particular
party
empowered
take
surely
among
least
appropriate
presume
nonexclusivity
second
fact
sole
party
named
trustee
unique
role
bankruptcy
proceedings
makes
entirely
plausible
congress
provide
power
others
congress
intended
provision
broadly
available
simply
said
describing
parties
act
sections
code
rejects
unpersuasive
petitioner
arguments
text
use
code
provisions
expressly
restrictive
language
specifying
parties
issue
means
party
interest
excluded
right
nontrustee
recover
evidenced
pp
also
rejects
arguments
based
practice
policy
considerations
petitioner
advances
support
assertion
available
parties
trustee
questionable
whether
precedents
relied
petitioner
establish
bankruptcy
practice
sufficiently
widespread
well
recognized
justify
conclusion
implicit
adoption
congress
enacting
code
event
meaning
code
text
clear
operation
unimpeded
contrary
prior
practice
also
unavailing
petitioner
argument
reading
necessary
matter
policy
since
cases
trustee
may
lack
incentive
pursue
payment
far
clear
relevant
policy
implications
favor
petitioner
position
event
achieving
better
policy
outcome
petitioner
urges
task
congress
courts
pp
affirmed
scalia
delivered
opinion
unanimous
hartford
underwriters
insurance
company
petitioner
union
planters
bank
writ
certiorari
appeals
eighth
circuit
may
justice
scalia
delivered
opinion
case
consider
whether
allows
administrative
claimant
bankruptcy
estate
seek
payment
claim
property
encumbered
secured
creditor
lien
case
arises
bankruptcy
proceedings
hen
house
interstate
one
time
owned
operated
several
restaurants
service
stations
well
firm
september
hen
house
filed
voluntary
petition
chapter
bankruptcy
code
bankruptcy
eastern
district
missouri
chapter
hen
house
retained
possession
assets
continued
operating
business
respondent
hen
house
primary
time
chapter
petition
filed
held
security
interest
essentially
hen
house
real
personal
property
securing
indebtedness
million
chapter
proceedings
commenced
agreed
lend
hen
house
additional
help
finance
reorganization
bankruptcy
entered
financing
order
approving
loan
agreement
authorizing
hen
house
use
loan
proceeds
cash
collateral
pay
expenses
including
workers
compensation
expenses
attempted
reorganization
hen
house
obtained
workers
compensation
insurance
petitioner
hartford
underwriters
unaware
bankruptcy
proceedings
although
policy
required
monthly
premium
payments
hen
house
repeatedly
failed
make
hartford
continued
provide
insurance
nonetheless
reorganization
ultimately
failed
january
bankruptcy
converted
case
liquidation
proceeding
chapter
appointed
trustee
time
conversion
hen
house
owed
hartford
unpaid
premiums
hartford
learned
hen
house
bankruptcy
proceedings
conversion
march
recognizing
estate
lacked
unencumbered
funds
pay
premiums
hartford
attempted
charge
premiums
respondent
secured
creditor
filing
bankruptcy
application
allowance
administrative
expense
pursuant
charge
collateral
pursuant
bankruptcy
ruled
favor
hartford
district
eighth
circuit
panel
affirmed
hen
house
interstate
eighth
circuit
subsequently
granted
en
banc
review
however
reversed
concluding
invoked
administrative
claimant
hen
house
interstate
granted
certiorari
ii
petitioner
effort
recover
unpaid
premiums
involves
two
provisions
section
provides
actual
necessary
costs
expenses
preserving
estate
including
wages
salaries
commissions
services
rendered
commencement
case
treated
administrative
expenses
rule
entitled
priority
prepetition
unsecured
claims
see
respondent
dispute
cost
workers
compensation
insurance
hen
house
purchased
petitioner
administrative
expense
within
meaning
provision
administrative
expenses
however
priority
secured
claims
see
sav
assn
tex
timbers
inwood
forest
associates
respondent
held
security
interest
essentially
estate
assets
unencumbered
funds
available
pay
even
administrative
claimants
petitioner
therefore
looked
constitutes
important
exception
rule
secured
claims
superior
administrative
claims
section
provides
follows
trustee
may
recover
property
securing
allowed
secured
claim
reasonable
necessary
costs
expenses
preserving
disposing
property
extent
benefit
holder
claim
petitioner
argued
provision
entitled
recover
property
subject
respondent
security
interest
unpaid
premiums
owed
hen
house
since
furnishing
workers
compensation
insurance
benefited
respondent
allowing
continued
operation
hen
house
business
thereby
preserving
value
respondent
collateral
alternatively
benefit
presumed
respondent
consent
postpetition
financing
order
although
contested
whether
either
theory
workers
compensation
insurance
constituted
benefit
holder
within
meaning
issue
us
assume
purposes
decision
consider
whether
petitioner
administrative
claimant
proper
party
seek
recovery
answering
question
begin
understanding
congress
says
statute
means
means
statute
says
connecticut
nat
bank
germain
previously
noted
construing
another
provision
statute
language
plain
sole
function
least
disposition
required
text
absurd
enforce
according
terms
ron
pair
enterprises
quoting
caminetti
statute
appears
quite
plain
specifying
may
use
trustee
true
however
petitioner
notes
actually
says
trustee
may
seek
recovery
section
others
may
question
thus
becomes
whether
proper
inference
trustee
party
empowered
invoke
little
difficulty
answering
yes
several
contextual
features
support
conclusion
exclusivity
intended
first
situation
statute
authorizes
specific
action
designates
particular
party
empowered
take
surely
among
least
appropriate
presume
nonexclusivity
statute
names
parties
granted
right
invoke
provisions
parties
may
act
singer
sutherland
statutory
construction
ed
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
see
also
federal
election
national
conservative
political
action
second
fact
sole
party
named
trustee
unique
role
bankruptcy
proceedings
makes
entirely
plausible
congress
provide
power
others
indeed
particular
parties
specified
read
simply
may
recovered
property
securing
allowed
secured
claim
reasonable
necessary
costs
expenses
etc
trustee
obvious
party
thought
empowered
use
provision
thus
far
sensible
view
provision
answering
question
may
use
provision
trustee
view
simply
answering
question
may
trustee
use
provision
yes
argued
point
provision
simply
establish
certain
costs
may
recovered
collateral
say
anything
may
recover
congress
intention
easily
used
formulation
suggested
similarly
congress
intended
provision
broadly
available
simply
said
describing
parties
act
sections
code
section
example
provides
claim
allowed
unless
party
interest
objects
allows
entity
file
request
payment
administrative
expense
broad
phrasing
sections
contrasted
use
trustee
supports
conclusion
entities
trustee
entitled
use
russello
petitioner
primary
argument
text
matters
section
say
trustee
may
enforce
provisions
brief
petitioner
bolster
argument
petitioner
cites
provisions
bankruptcy
code
use
expressly
restrictive
language
specifying
parties
issue
see
nly
person
resides
domicile
place
business
property
municipality
may
debtor
title
providing
case
may
dismissed
substantial
abuse
motion
motion
trustee
request
suggestion
party
interest
petitioner
argues
absence
restrictive
language
party
interest
excluded
theory
expression
one
thing
indicates
inclusion
others
unless
exclusion
made
explicit
contrary
common
sense
common
usage
many
provisions
bankruptcy
code
contain
express
exclusion
sensibly
read
extend
parties
interest
see
providing
trustee
notice
hearing
may
use
sell
lease
property
estate
providing
trustee
may
incur
debt
behalf
bankruptcy
estate
giving
trustee
power
abandon
property
bankruptcy
estate
petitioner
argues
evidences
right
nontrustee
recover
persuaded
section
provides
party
interest
may
raise
may
appear
heard
issue
case
chapter
terms
inapplicable
since
petitioner
attempt
use
came
bankruptcy
proceeding
converted
chapter
chapter
event
read
general
provision
right
heard
broadly
allowing
creditor
pursue
substantive
remedies
code
provisions
make
available
specific
parties
cf
king
collier
bankruptcy
rev
ed
general
section
bestow
right
usurp
trustee
role
representative
estate
respect
initiation
certain
types
litigation
belong
exclusively
estate
iii
believe
far
natural
reading
extends
trustee
petitioner
burden
persuading
us
section
must
read
allow
use
parties
exceptionally
heavy
patterson
shumate
quoting
union
bank
wolas
support
proffered
reading
petitioner
advances
arguments
based
practice
policy
considerations
address
arguments
turn
section
provision
charge
certain
administrative
expenses
lienholders
continues
practice
existed
bankruptcy
act
see
tyne
collier
bankruptcy
supra
found
text
act
traced
origin
early
cases
establishing
equitable
principle
custody
property
costs
administering
preserving
property
dominant
charge
see
bronson
la
crosse
milwaukee
wall
atlantic
trust
chapman
norm
recovery
costs
secured
creditor
sought
trustee
see
textile
banking
widener
tyne
supra
petitioner
cites
number
lower
cases
however
without
meaningful
discussion
point
parties
trustee
permitted
pursue
charges
act
sometimes
simultaneously
trustee
pursuit
expenses
see
first
western
savings
loan
assn
anderson
louisville
storage
supp
wd
aff
sometimes
independently
see
chapman
coal
rotary
tire
rubber
petitioner
also
relies
early
decisions
allowing
individual
claimants
seek
recovery
secured
assets
see
louisville
wilson
burnham
bowen
new
york
dock
poznan
wilson
burnham
involved
equity
receiverships
predate
bankruptcy
act
code
replaced
new
york
dock
case
arising
admiralty
questionable
whether
precedents
establish
bankruptcy
practice
sufficiently
widespread
well
recognized
justify
conclusion
implicit
adoption
code
confidence
allowance
recovery
collateral
nontrustees
type
rule
congress
aware
enacting
code
ron
pair
enterprises
relying
clearly
established
practice
kelly
robinson
giving
weight
practice
widely
accepted
established
event
practice
informs
understanding
language
code
overcome
language
tool
construction
extratextual
supplement
applied
construction
provisions
subject
interpretation
contained
ambiguity
text
dewsnup
supra
meaning
bankruptcy
code
text
clear
operation
unimpeded
contrary
prior
practice
bfp
resolution
trust
corporation
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
see
pennsylvania
dept
public
welfare
davenport
ron
pair
enterprises
supra
case
think
language
code
leaves
room
clarification
practice
provided
certain
costs
expenses
recovered
property
securing
secured
claim
without
specifying
particular
party
recovery
pursued
case
akin
used
prior
practice
fill
details
concept
code
adopted
without
elaboration
see
noland
looking
practice
interpreting
code
reference
principles
equitable
subordination
midlantic
nat
bank
new
jersey
dept
environmental
protection
codification
trustee
abandonment
power
held
incorporate
established
exceptions
however
unelaborated
concept
specifically
narrowed
one
adopted
rule
allowing
charge
costs
secured
assets
trustee
practice
transform
reference
trustee
trustee
parties
interest
finally
petitioner
argues
reading
necessary
matter
policy
since
cases
trustee
may
lack
incentive
pursue
payment
section
must
open
nontrustees
petitioner
asserts
lest
secured
creditors
enjoy
benefit
services
without
paying
moreover
ensuring
administrative
claimants
compensated
may
also
serve
purposes
beyond
avoidance
unjust
enrichment
extent
circumstances
trustee
use
section
although
individual
creditor
allowing
suits
nontrustees
encourage
provision
postpetition
services
debtors
favorable
terms
turn
bankruptcy
goals
although
concerns
may
valid
far
clear
policy
implications
favor
petitioner
position
class
cases
lie
dormant
without
nontrustee
use
limited
fact
trustee
obliged
seek
recovery
section
whenever
fiduciary
duties
require
limiting
trustee
leave
provide
goods
services
benefit
secured
interests
without
means
protecting
creditors
may
insist
cash
payment
contract
directly
secured
creditor
may
able
obtain
superpriority
security
interest
course
postpetition
creditors
avoid
unnecessary
losses
simply
paying
attention
status
accounts
protection
appearances
petitioner
neglected
side
ledger
petitioner
reading
lead
results
seem
undesirable
matter
policy
particular
expanding
number
parties
use
create
possibility
multiple
administrative
claimants
seeking
recovery
section
claim
require
inquiry
necessity
services
issue
degree
benefit
secured
creditor
allowing
recovery
sought
behest
parties
trustee
therefore
impair
ability
bankruptcy
coordinate
proceedings
well
ability
trustee
manage
estate
indeed
administrative
claimants
free
seek
recovery
proceed
even
trustee
planned
see
bluffton
castings
bkrtcy
nd
ind
unencumbered
assets
scarce
creditors
might
attempt
use
even
though
claim
benefited
secured
creditor
quite
weak
possibility
targeted
claims
various
administrative
claimants
make
secured
creditors
less
willing
provide
postpetition
financing
event
sit
assess
relative
merits
different
approaches
various
bankruptcy
problems
suffices
natural
reading
text
produces
result
announce
achieving
better
policy
outcome
petitioner
urges
task
congress
courts
kawaauhau
geiger
noland
wolas
considered
points
urged
petitioner
find
without
merit
conclude
provide
administrative
claimant
independent
right
use
section
seek
payment
claim
judgment
eighth
circuit
affirmed
ordered
footnotes
respondent
union
planters
bank
successor
magna
bank
turn
successor
landmark
bank
illinois
hen
house
originally
indebted
landmark
bank
simplicity
distinguish
various
entities
addition
seeking
recovery
petitioner
argued
eighth
circuit
en
banc
entitled
recover
terms
postpetition
financing
order
petitioner
sought
enforce
order
federal
rule
bankruptcy
procedure
incorporates
federal
rule
civil
procedure
order
made
favor
person
party
action
person
may
enforce
obedience
order
process
party
eighth
circuit
declined
address
issue
since
raised
rehearing
en
banc
hen
house
interstate
similarly
reach
issue
may
also
use
section
expressly
given
rights
powers
trustee
frequency
circumstances
arise
may
depend
part
ultimately
receives
recovery
obtained
trustee
petitioner
argues
goes
party
provided
services
benefited
collateral
assuming
party
already
compensated
estate
respondent
argues
reading
like
reading
allows
creditors
use
upsets
code
priority
scheme
giving
administrative
claimants
benefit
collateral
effective
priority
others
allowing
example
chapter
administrative
creditor
like
petitioner
obtain
payment
via
chapter
administrative
creditors
remain
unpaid
despite
provision
chapter
administrative
claims
priority
chapter
administrative
claims
thus
respondent
asserts
trustee
recovery
simply
goes
estate
distributed
according
code
priority
provisions
since
case
involve
trustee
recovery
address
question
related
question
whether
trustee
may
use
provision
prior
paying
expenses
reimbursement
sought
see
lakeland
address
whether
bankruptcy
allow
terested
parties
act
trustee
stead
pursuing
recovery
amici
american
insurance
association
national
union
fire
insurance
draw
attention
practice
courts
allowing
creditors
creditors
committees
derivative
right
bring
avoidance
actions
trustee
refuses
even
though
applicable
code
provisions
see
mention
trustee
see
gibson
group
whatever
validity
practice
analogous
application
since
petitioner
ask
trustee
pursue
payment
seek
permission
bankruptcy
take
action
trustee
stead
petitioner
asserted
independent
right
use
reject
today
cf
xonics
photochemical
holding
creditor
right
bring
avoidance
action
independently
noting
might
able
seek
bring
derivative
suit