burgett
texas
argued
october
decided
november
petitioner
charged
indictment
read
jury
beginning
trial
convicted
assault
malice
aforethought
intent
murder
repetition
offense
first
count
charged
assault
counts
pursuant
texas
recidivist
statutes
alleged
prior
felony
convictions
one
texas
burglary
three
tennessee
forgery
proved
made
petitioner
subject
life
imprisonment
upon
convicted
count
one
jury
presence
prosecution
offered
evidence
two
differing
certified
copies
one
tennessee
convictions
certified
copy
indictment
prior
texas
prosecution
admitted
texas
conviction
evidence
later
sustained
petitioner
objection
judgment
struck
evidence
upheld
petitioner
objection
first
version
tennessee
conviction
ground
judgment
showed
face
petitioner
represented
counsel
violation
sixth
amendment
made
applicable
fourteenth
amendment
overruled
objection
ground
second
version
stated
petitioner
appeared
proper
person
add
first
version
without
counsel
explanation
discrepancy
two
versions
reference
also
made
second
version
jury
retired
consider
verdict
argument
counsel
indication
whether
word
used
singular
plural
testimony
heard
substantive
offense
instructed
jury
consider
prior
offenses
purpose
whatsoever
arriving
verdict
petitioner
convicted
appealed
urging
error
reading
jury
indictment
containing
prior
felony
conviction
counts
failure
sustain
objection
admission
evidence
second
version
tennessee
conviction
appellate
upheld
conviction
holding
error
since
trial
instructed
jury
disregard
prior
offenses
petitioner
received
enhanced
punishment
prescribed
recidivist
statutes
held
certified
records
tennessee
conviction
raise
presumption
petitioner
denied
right
counsel
proceeding
conviction
void
gideon
wainwright
permit
conviction
obtained
violation
gideon
used
either
support
guilt
enhance
punishment
another
offense
erode
principle
case
allow
unconstitutional
procedure
injure
defendant
twice
pp
admission
evidence
constitutionally
invalid
prior
conviction
inherently
prejudicial
said
instructions
disregard
error
made
harmless
beyond
reasonable
doubt
within
meaning
chapman
california
spencer
texas
distinguished
pp
gordon
gooch
appointment
argued
cause
filed
briefs
petitioner
leon
douglas
argued
cause
respondent
brief
crawford
martin
attorney
general
texas
george
cowden
first
assistant
attorney
general
carubbi
lattimore
justice
douglas
delivered
opinion
petitioner
convicted
assault
malice
aforethought
intent
murder
repetition
offense
jury
fixed
punishment
years
texas
state
penitentiary
appeal
texas
criminal
appeals
affirmed
petitioner
conviction
granted
certiorari
petitioner
charged
indictment
first
count
state
alleged
cut
one
bradley
knife
stabbed
bradley
throat
intent
kill
pursuant
texas
recidivist
statutes
remaining
counts
indictment
consisted
allegations
petitioner
incurred
four
previous
felony
convictions
texas
conviction
burglary
three
tennessee
convictions
forgery
allegations
found
true
petitioner
subject
term
life
imprisonment
upon
conviction
offense
charged
count
one
petitioner
counsel
filed
pretrial
motion
quash
four
counts
indictment
referring
prior
convictions
failure
apprise
defense
state
attempt
prove
record
silent
action
motion
indictment
read
jury
beginning
trial
evidence
introduced
four
counts
relating
prior
convictions
included
course
trial
jury
present
state
offered
evidence
certified
copy
one
tennessee
convictions
conviction
read
part
came
assistant
state
defendant
proper
person
without
counsel
petitioner
counsel
objected
introduction
record
ground
judgment
face
showed
petitioner
represented
counsel
violation
fourteenth
amendment
indication
record
counsel
waived
stated
reserve
ruling
objection
apparently
give
state
opportunity
offer
convictions
evidence
state
offered
second
version
tennessee
conviction
stated
petitioner
appeared
proper
person
contain
additional
words
without
counsel
second
version
also
stated
said
jury
heard
evidence
argument
counsel
charge
retired
consider
verdict
clear
however
whether
counsel
used
singular
plural
event
explanation
offered
discrepancy
two
records
petitioner
counsel
objected
second
version
ground
reserved
ruling
state
offered
evidence
certified
copy
indictment
prior
texas
case
petitioner
counsel
indicated
objection
record
received
evidence
thereafter
testimony
offered
concerning
judgment
sentence
prior
texas
case
testimony
given
jury
excused
hearing
continued
presence
conclusion
hearing
petitioner
attorney
objected
texas
judgment
void
face
state
law
sustained
objection
record
texas
conviction
stricken
evidence
time
sustained
petitioner
objection
first
version
tennessee
conviction
overruled
objection
second
version
conviction
jury
recalled
testimony
heard
substantive
offense
charged
next
reference
prior
convictions
instructed
jury
consider
prior
offenses
purpose
whatsoever
arriving
verdict
petitioner
motion
new
trial
denied
criminal
appeals
petitioner
argued
inter
alia
erred
permitting
counts
two
five
indictment
read
jury
beginning
trial
failing
sustain
petitioner
objection
admission
evidence
second
version
tennessee
conviction
criminal
appeals
held
since
petitioner
suffered
enhanced
punishment
provided
recidivist
statutes
since
instruction
disregard
prior
offenses
given
error
presented
sit
criminal
appeals
review
state
cases
free
provide
procedures
choose
including
rules
evidence
provided
none
infringes
guarantee
federal
constitution
recent
cases
starting
gideon
wainwright
illustrative
limitations
constitution
places
state
criminal
procedures
limitations
sometimes
touch
rules
evidence
exclusion
coerced
confessions
one
example
chambers
florida
exclusion
evidence
seized
violation
fourth
fourteenth
amendments
another
mapp
ohio
still
another
illustrated
pointer
texas
case
held
transcript
preliminary
hearing
excluded
state
criminal
trial
defendant
lawyer
hearing
therefore
opportunity
principal
witness
since
time
left
state
exclusionary
rule
fashioned
designed
protect
privilege
confrontation
guaranteed
sixth
amendment
made
applicable
fourteenth
result
must
follow
gideon
wainwright
established
rule
right
counsel
guaranteed
sixth
amendment
applicable
virtue
fourteenth
making
unconstitutional
try
person
felony
state
unless
lawyer
validly
waived
one
ruling
limited
prospective
applications
see
doughty
maxwell
pickelsimer
wainwright
case
certified
records
tennessee
conviction
face
raise
presumption
petitioner
denied
right
counsel
tennessee
proceeding
therefore
conviction
void
presuming
waiver
counsel
silent
record
impermissible
carnley
cochran
permit
conviction
obtained
violation
gideon
wainwright
used
person
either
support
guilt
enhance
punishment
another
offense
see
greer
beto
erode
principle
case
worse
yet
since
defect
prior
conviction
denial
right
counsel
accused
effect
suffers
anew
deprivation
sixth
amendment
right
admission
prior
criminal
conviction
constitutionally
infirm
standards
gideon
wainwright
inherently
prejudicial
unable
say
instructions
disregard
made
constitutional
error
harmless
beyond
reasonable
doubt
within
meaning
chapman
california
decision
last
term
spencer
texas
relevant
present
problem
spencer
prior
convictions
presumptively
void
moreover
contention
guilt
phase
trial
prejudiced
introduction
evidence
prior
crimes
noted
procedures
us
specific
federal
right
dealing
confessions
involved
reliance
placed
solely
general
fairness
approach
case
however
petitioner
right
counsel
specific
federal
right
denied
anew
permit
result
unless
gideon
wainwright
suffer
serious
erosion
reversed
footnotes
burgett
state
statutes
involved
articles
tex
pen
code
article
provides
shown
trial
felony
less
capital
defendant
convicted
offense
one
nature
punishment
second
subsequent
conviction
shall
highest
affixed
commission
offenses
ordinary
cases
article
provides
whoever
shall
three
times
convicted
felony
less
capital
shall
third
conviction
imprisoned
life
penitentiary
tex
pen
code
art
petitioner
amended
motion
new
trial
denied
explained
purpose
pretrial
motion
defendant
establish
previous
convictions
alleged
enhancement
admissibility
read
record
presence
jury
reading
record
presence
jury
prejudicial
defendant
herein
apparently
withdrew
consideration
prior
convictions
jury
since
record
one
prior
tennessee
conviction
forgery
accepted
thus
article
applied
petitioner
since
forgery
considered
offense
nature
assault
intent
murder
article
applicable
see
supra
state
apparently
attempt
introduce
records
two
tennessee
convictions
forgery
indictment
showed
convictions
occurred
date
invoke
provisions
article
succeeding
conviction
must
subsequent
time
previous
conviction
respect
commission
offense
conviction
cowan
state
tex
cr
see
boyd
clarke
cir
cf
waldron
waldron
throckmorton
holt
lawrence
cir
dedominicis
cir
justice
jackson
said
krulewitch
concurring
opinion
sensitive
area
conspiracy
equally
applicable
sensitive
area
repetitive
crimes
naive
assumption
prejudicial
effects
overcome
instructions
jury
practicing
lawyers
know
unmitigated
fiction
chief
justice
warren
concurring
full
agreement
opinion
reasons
stated
therein
reversing
conviction
case
however
view
terse
dissent
entered
brother
harlan
feel
constrained
add
observations
dissent
refers
decision
spencer
texas
entire
thrust
dissent
reminiscent
decision
last
term
placed
stamp
approval
texas
recidivist
procedures
case
evolves
dissent
reminds
us
sit
errors
appeals
state
cases
disagree
statement
abstract
proposition
dealing
abstracts
case
dealing
real
denial
state
criminal
defendant
rights
guaranteed
federal
constitution
also
told
dissent
case
shows
prosecutorial
bad
faith
intentional
misconduct
misses
mark
limited
review
constitutional
errors
state
criminal
proceedings
errors
flow
prosecutorial
bad
faith
intentional
misconduct
concern
effect
errors
whether
constitutionally
protected
right
criminal
defendant
fair
impartial
trial
case
classic
example
rule
eroding
procedural
rights
criminal
defendant
trial
life
liberty
assume
avalanche
proportions
burying
beneath
integrity
process
spencer
approved
procedure
whereby
state
sole
purpose
enhancing
punishment
includes
indictment
allegations
prior
crimes
read
jury
enters
evidence
trial
prior
crimes
matter
unrelated
might
charge
defendant
tried
rule
adopted
spencer
went
far
allow
state
enter
evidence
prior
crimes
even
though
defendant
might
willing
stipulate
earlier
convictions
case
harsh
rule
expanded
degree
close
barbarism
addition
charging
petitioner
principal
crime
assault
malice
aforethought
intent
murder
indictment
alleged
four
prior
convictions
one
texas
three
tennessee
despite
efforts
petitioner
attorney
quash
portions
indictment
referring
prior
crimes
entire
indictment
read
jury
start
petitioner
trial
prosecutor
proceeded
offer
evidence
prior
convictions
petitioner
attorney
objected
evidence
one
tennessee
conviction
certified
copy
conviction
showed
petitioner
represented
counsel
trial
judge
reserved
ruling
objection
prosecution
next
offered
second
version
tennessee
conviction
omitted
reference
absence
counsel
show
waiver
counsel
petitioner
attorney
objected
trial
judge
reserved
ruling
prosecutor
offered
evidence
certified
copy
indictment
prior
texas
case
received
without
objection
occurred
presence
jury
however
petitioner
attorney
objected
evidence
concerning
judgment
sentence
prior
texas
case
jury
excused
testimony
taken
presence
jury
close
evidence
jury
returned
trial
judge
ruled
prior
texas
conviction
void
state
law
addition
trial
judge
sustained
objection
first
version
tennessee
conviction
overruled
objection
second
version
conviction
jury
returned
trial
continued
next
jury
hear
prior
convictions
brief
instruction
trial
judge
advising
jurors
consider
prior
crimes
purpose
jury
never
told
however
two
prior
convictions
charged
void
prosecution
failed
offer
testimony
validity
prior
crimes
charged
indictment
thus
jury
went
deliberations
knowing
petitioner
convicted
imprisoned
four
prior
felonies
although
one
proven
trial
expect
jury
wipe
memory
decide
petitioner
guilt
basis
evidence
assault
place
much
faith
jury
ability
detach
reality
particularly
true
since
trial
judge
gave
jurors
slightest
clue
matters
consumed
much
time
trial
suddenly
removed
consideration
suggest
procedure
accords
man
charged
crime
due
process
beyond
belief
reversed
convictions
cases
based
unfair
influences
juries
must
deemed
minor
compared
pervasive
prejudice
case
long
ago
ruled
defendant
denied
due
process
bailiff
remarked
presence
jurors
oh
wicked
fellow
guilty
anything
wrong
verdict
correct
parker
gladden
also
reversed
murder
conviction
two
prosecution
witnesses
deputy
sheriffs
assigned
accompany
jury
sequestered
turner
louisiana
transgressions
offend
constitutional
standards
fairness
doubted
petitioner
trial
stripped
vestiges
due
process
jurors
told
prior
void
convictions
error
explained
case
frightful
progeny
spencer
decision
unjustified
deviation
settled
principles
fairness
today
placed
needed
limitation
spencer
rule
nothing
except
outright
rejection
truly
serve
cause
justice
prosecutorial
bad
faith
course
irrelevant
element
review
state
criminal
convictions
often
make
even
intolerable
errors
demand
correction
see
miller
pate
napue
illinois
mooney
holohan
dissent
alone
viewing
case
solely
terms
prosecutor
good
bad
faith
texas
criminal
appeals
disposed
petitioner
objection
use
prior
void
convictions
trial
cryptic
observation
showing
bad
faith
part
state
alleging
attempting
prove
prior
convictions
boswell
tells
us
johnson
observed
hell
paved
good
intentions
boswell
life
samuel
johnson
great
books
ed
view
case
prevail
surely
petitioner
road
prison
paved
good
intentions
record
silent
concerning
second
third
tennessee
convictions
alleged
indictment
prosecution
apparently
offer
evidence
convictions
however
jury
made
aware
prior
crimes
indictment
read
start
trial
mean
express
disapproval
decisions
parker
turner
joined
opinions
doubt
practices
condemned
cases
odds
settled
principles
due
process
law
however
follows
fortiori
decisions
presented
case
violation
due
process
justice
harlan
justice
black
justice
white
join
dissenting
record
case
shows
prosecutorial
bad
faith
intentional
misconduct
extent
prosecutor
contemplated
use
prior
convictions
recidivist
trial
right
course
established
spencer
texas
decided
last
term
fact
prior
convictions
turned
inadmissible
reasons
involves
later
corrected
trial
error
admission
evidence
sit
errors
appeals
state
cases
affirm
judgment
state