midwest
oil
co
argued
may
decided
february
certificate
circuit
appeals
eighth
circuit
presenting
following
questions
prior
act
june
stat
chap
comp
stat
president
secretary
interior
lawful
power
aid
proposed
legislation
affecting
use
disposition
petroleum
deposits
public
domain
withdraw
public
lands
containing
petroleum
chiefly
valuable
therefor
forms
location
selection
filing
entry
disposal
public
laws
petroleum
withdrawal
date
september
effect
preventing
lawful
location
acquisition
lands
described
said
withdrawal
order
contained
petroleum
mineral
oils
chiefly
valuable
therefor
persons
authorized
enter
lands
mining
laws
provisions
act
congress
entitled
act
authorize
entry
patenting
lands
containing
petroleum
mineral
oils
laws
approved
february
stat
chap
comp
stat
must
efficacy
order
september
reserve
land
controversy
subsequent
initiation
acquisition
rights
act
february
supra
held
depend
upon
nature
purpose
purposes
made
question
answered
affirmative
essential
validity
reservation
withdrawal
purpose
purposes
expressed
order
specific
purposes
actuating
order
september
sufficient
law
sustain
consistent
appearing
language
incumbent
plaintiff
allege
specific
purposes
bill
order
advantage
defendant
motion
dismiss
assuming
general
purposes
expressed
order
september
suffice
alone
determine
validity
invalidity
might
another
consistent
purpose
sufficient
sustain
order
presumed
valid
absence
allegation
proof
purpose
exist
suit
originated
bill
equity
filed
district
district
wyoming
seeking
recover
certain
tracts
petroleum
lands
obtain
accounting
petroleum
alleged
illegally
extracted
therefrom
sustained
defendant
demurrer
dismissed
bill
whereupon
government
took
case
circuit
appeals
rendered
decision
certified
questions
case
remanded
district
directions
reverse
decree
dismissing
bill
facts
stated
opinion
solicitor
general
davis
assistant
attorney
general
knaebel
joel
vaile
henry
mcallister
william
vaile
karl
schuyler
walter
schuyler
stevenson
lee
champion
midwest
oil
company
et
al
aldis
browne
alexander
britton
evans
browne
francis
clements
frederic
kellogg
pillsbury
oscar
sutro
frank
short
amici
curioe
justice
lamar
delivered
opinion
public
lands
containing
petroleum
mineral
oils
chiefly
valuable
therefor
declared
congress
open
occupation
exploration
purchase
citizens
regulations
prescribed
law
act
february
stat
chap
comp
stat
rev
stat
comp
stat
regulations
permitted
exploration
location
without
payment
sum
title
obtained
merely
nominal
amount
many
persons
availed
provisions
statute
large
areas
california
explored
petroleum
found
locations
made
discoverer
others
adjoining
land
flow
well
one
lot
might
exhaust
oil
adjacent
land
interest
operator
extract
oil
soon
possible
share
otherwise
taken
owners
nearby
wells
result
oil
rapidly
extracted
september
director
geological
survey
made
report
secretary
interior
inclosures
called
attention
fact
limited
supply
coal
pacific
coast
value
oil
fuel
fully
demonstrated
yet
rate
oil
lands
california
patented
private
parties
impossible
people
continue
ownership
oil
lands
months
government
obliged
repurchase
oil
practically
given
away
view
increasing
use
fuel
american
navy
appear
immediate
necessity
assuring
conservation
proper
supply
petroleum
government
use
enactment
adequate
legislation
subject
filing
claims
oil
lands
state
california
suspended
recommendation
approved
secretary
interior
shortly
afterwards
brought
matter
attention
president
september
issued
following
proclamation
temporary
petroleum
withdrawal
aid
proposed
legislation
affecting
use
disposition
petroleum
deposits
public
domain
public
lands
accompanying
lists
hereby
temporarily
withdrawn
forms
location
settlement
selection
filing
entry
disposal
mineral
nonmineral
laws
locations
claims
existing
valid
date
may
proceed
entry
usual
manner
filing
investigation
examination
list
attached
described
area
aggregating
acres
california
course
order
applied
public
lands
therein
acreage
shown
march
six
months
publication
proclamation
william
henshaw
others
entered
upon
quarter
section
public
land
wyoming
withdrawn
made
explorations
bored
well
discovered
oil
thereafter
assigned
interest
appellees
took
possession
extracted
large
quantities
oil
may
filed
location
certificate
explorations
original
claimants
subsequent
operation
well
long
date
president
proclamation
government
filed
district
district
wyoming
bill
equity
midwest
oil
company
appellees
seeking
recover
land
obtain
accounting
barrels
oil
alleged
illegally
extracted
sustained
defendant
demurrer
dismissed
bill
thereupon
government
took
case
circuit
appeals
eighth
circuit
rendered
decision
certified
certain
questions
order
subsequently
passed
directing
entire
record
sent
consideration
case
twice
fully
argued
parties
well
persons
interested
oil
lands
similarly
affected
submitted
lengthy
elaborate
briefs
single
controlling
question
validity
withdrawal
order
part
government
urged
president
commander
chief
army
navy
power
make
order
purpose
retaining
preserving
source
supply
fuel
navy
instead
allowing
oil
land
taken
nominal
sum
government
obliged
purchase
great
cost
previously
owned
argued
president
charged
care
public
domain
virtue
executive
power
vested
constitution
art
also
conformity
tacit
consent
congress
withdraw
public
interest
public
land
entry
location
private
parties
appellees
hand
insist
dispensing
power
executive
suspend
statute
withdraw
entry
location
land
congress
affirmatively
declared
free
open
acquisition
citizens
insist
withdrawal
order
absolutely
void
since
appears
face
mere
attempt
suspend
order
allow
congress
pass
another
accordance
executive
thought
public
interest
need
consider
whether
original
question
president
withdrawn
private
acquisition
congress
made
free
open
occupation
purchase
case
determined
grounds
light
legal
consequences
flowing
practice
make
orders
like
one
involved
president
proclamation
september
means
first
instance
executive
special
order
withdrawn
lands
congress
general
statute
thrown
open
acquisition
citizens
known
first
orders
made
certain
practice
dates
early
period
history
government
grisar
mcdowell
wall
ed
scores
hundreds
orders
made
treating
must
wolsey
chapman
ed
act
president
examination
official
publications
show
excluding
made
virtue
special
congressional
action
donnelly
ed
sup
ann
cas
past
eighty
years
without
express
statutory
claim
power
multitude
executive
orders
operated
withdraw
public
land
otherwise
open
private
acquisition
affected
every
kind
nonmineral
size
tracts
varied
square
rods
many
square
miles
amount
withdrawn
aggregated
millions
acres
number
instances
course
accurately
given
extent
practice
best
appreciated
consideration
believed
correct
enumeration
executive
orders
mentioned
public
documents
show
prior
year
issued
executive
orders
establishing
enlarging
indian
reservations
executive
orders
establishing
enlarging
military
reservations
setting
apart
land
water
timber
fuel
hay
signal
stations
target
ranges
rights
way
use
connection
military
reservations
executive
orders
establishing
bird
reserves
sense
lands
may
intended
public
use
reserved
public
purpose
reserved
pursuance
law
virtue
general
special
statutory
authority
specially
noted
act
congress
providing
bird
reserves
indian
reservations
law
establishment
military
reservations
defining
size
location
statute
empowering
president
withdraw
lands
settlement
reserve
purposes
indicated
appeared
public
interest
served
withdrawing
reserving
parts
public
domain
nothing
natural
retain
government
already
owned
making
orders
thus
useful
public
private
interest
injured
prior
initiation
right
given
law
citizen
enforceable
interest
public
statute
private
right
land
property
people
president
position
know
public
interest
required
particular
portions
people
lands
withdrawn
entry
location
action
inflicted
wrong
upon
private
citizen
subject
disaffirmance
congress
occasion
harm
interest
public
large
congress
repudiate
power
claimed
withdrawal
orders
made
contrary
uniformly
repeatedly
acquiesced
practice
shown
records
prior
least
executive
orders
making
reservations
useful
though
nonstatutory
purposes
right
president
make
thus
withdraw
land
private
expressly
recognized
grisar
mcdowell
wall
ed
said
early
period
history
government
practice
president
order
time
time
exigencies
public
service
required
parcels
land
belonging
reserved
sale
set
apart
public
uses
notwithstanding
decision
continuity
practice
absence
express
statutory
authority
occasion
doubt
expressed
power
president
make
orders
matter
therefore
several
times
referred
law
officers
government
opinion
subject
one
stated
ops
atty
validity
orders
rested
power
president
withhold
sale
settlement
discretion
portions
public
domain
another
reported
power
president
recognized
congress
recognition
equivalent
grant
ops
atty
claim
made
power
withdraw
extend
mineral
land
attorney
general
gave
opinion
power
must
extending
lands
belong
public
domain
capable
exercised
respect
lands
long
remain
unappropriated
ops
atty
similar
views
expressed
officers
land
department
indeed
one
strongest
assertions
existence
power
frequently
quoted
statement
secretary
teller
made
power
resides
executive
early
period
history
country
make
reservations
never
denied
either
legislatively
judicially
contrary
recognized
constitutes
fact
part
land
office
law
existe
ex
necessitate
rei
indispensable
public
weal
light
different
laws
enacted
herein
indicated
referred
existing
undisputed
power
well
settled
ever
disputed
land
may
argued
facts
rulings
prove
usage
establish
validity
government
practical
affair
intended
practical
men
officers
lawmakers
citizens
naturally
adjust
action
executive
department
presumption
unauthorized
acts
allowed
often
repeated
crystallize
regular
practice
presumption
reasoning
circle
basis
wise
quieting
rule
determining
meaning
statute
existence
power
weight
shall
given
usage
validity
practice
subject
investigation
principle
recognized
every
jurisdiction
first
applied
case
stuart
laird
cranch
ed
answering
objection
act
stat
chap
unconstitutional
far
gave
circuit
powers
judges
said
acquiescence
period
several
years
commencing
organization
judicial
system
affords
irresistible
answer
indeed
fixed
construction
contemporary
interpretation
forcible
nature
practical
exposition
strong
obstinate
shaken
controlled
mcpherson
blacker
ed
sup
question
validity
state
law
providing
appointment
presidential
electors
held
terms
provision
constitution
left
question
power
doubt
continuous
subsequent
practical
construction
treated
decisive
fairbank
ed
sup
crim
cooley
port
wardens
ed
see
also
grisar
mcdowell
wall
ed
practice
executive
department
referred
evidence
validity
orders
making
reservations
public
land
even
practice
means
general
extensive
since
become
decisions
course
mean
private
rights
created
officer
withdrawing
railroad
authorized
congress
land
grant
act
southern
bell
ed
sup
brandon
ard
ed
sup
decisions
mean
executive
course
action
create
power
clearly
indicate
practice
known
acquiesced
congress
raise
presumption
withdrawals
made
pursuance
consent
recognized
administrative
power
executive
management
public
lands
particularly
true
view
fact
land
property
land
laws
legislative
character
highest
sense
term
art
savor
somewhat
mere
rules
prescribed
owner
property
disposal
butte
city
water
baker
ed
sup
rules
laws
disposal
public
land
necessarily
general
nature
emergencies
may
occur
conditions
may
change
require
agent
charge
public
interest
withhold
land
sale
express
authority
granted
nothing
nature
power
exercised
prevents
congress
granting
implication
done
owner
property
similar
conditions
power
executive
agent
charge
retain
property
sale
need
necessarily
expressed
writing
lockhart
johnson
ed
sup
bronson
chappell
wall
ed
campbell
kenosha
wall
ed
must
borne
mind
congress
legislative
power
public
domain
also
exercises
powers
proprietor
therein
congress
deal
lands
precisely
ordinary
individual
may
deal
farming
property
may
sell
withhold
sale
camfield
ed
sup
light
ed
sup
like
owner
may
provide
land
sold
permit
withdrawn
sale
like
owner
waive
strict
rights
valuable
privilege
grazing
cattle
public
land
held
based
upon
license
growing
custom
nearly
hundred
years
buford
houtz
ed
sup
early
days
silent
acquiescence
assented
general
occupation
public
lands
mining
atchison
peterson
wall
ed
private
persons
acquire
privilege
public
land
virtue
implied
congressional
consent
much
stronger
reason
implied
grant
power
preserve
public
interest
arise
like
congressional
acquiescence
executive
agent
charge
public
domain
multitude
orders
extending
long
period
time
affecting
vast
bodies
land
many
territories
withdrew
large
areas
public
interest
orders
known
congress
principal
single
instance
act
agent
disapproved
acquiescence
readily
operated
implied
grant
power
view
fact
exercise
useful
public
interfere
vested
right
citizen
appellees
however
argue
practice
thus
approved
related
reservations
cases
land
reserved
military
special
public
purposes
contend
even
president
reserve
land
public
purpose
naval
uses
follow
withdraw
land
aid
legislation
analyzed
proposition
effect
seeks
make
distinction
reservation
withdrawal
reservation
purpose
provided
existing
legislation
withdrawal
made
aid
future
legislation
mean
permanent
reservation
purpose
designated
president
provided
statute
valid
merely
temporary
withdrawal
enable
congress
legislate
public
interest
invalid
necessary
point
greater
includes
less
power
make
permanent
reservations
includes
power
make
temporary
withdrawals
distinction
principle
two
character
power
exerted
cases
order
made
serve
public
interest
effect
intending
settler
miner
question
need
left
solely
inference
since
validity
withdrawal
orders
aid
legislation
expressly
recognized
series
cases
involving
number
orders
made
dubuque
litchfield
ed
wolcott
des
moines
nav
wall
ed
wolsey
chapman
ed
litchfield
webster
county
ed
bullard
des
moines
ed
sup
appears
decisions
others
cited
therein
congress
made
territory
iowa
grant
land
sides
des
moines
purpose
improving
navigation
mouth
river
raccoon
fork
wall
outset
difference
opinion
whether
grant
extended
throughout
entire
course
river
limited
land
opposite
portion
stream
improved
dubuque
litchfield
ed
decided
held
grant
included
land
mouth
river
raccoon
fork
eleven
years
prior
decision
various
conflicting
rulings
land
department
first
held
grant
included
land
fork
certificates
issued
territory
work
progressed
ruling
shortly
followed
another
grant
extended
fork
april
secretary
ewing
concurring
attorney
general
crittenden
opinion
grant
extend
beyond
raccoon
fork
issued
order
withholding
lands
controversy
market
close
session
congress
order
continued
ever
since
italicize
order
give
state
opportunity
petitioning
extension
grant
congress
bullard
des
moines
ed
sup
withdrawal
made
legislation
passed
several
years
later
dates
various
private
citizens
made
settlements
various
statutes
initiated
rights
acquired
interest
withdrawal
order
void
settlements
obtained
rights
withdrawal
order
valid
subsequent
ratification
related
back
withdrawal
originally
void
ratification
course
cut
intervening
rights
settlers
cook
tullis
wall
ed
litigation
settlers
claiming
existing
land
laws
whose
title
depended
upon
original
validity
withdrawals
made
aid
legislation
riley
welles
ed
sup
bullard
des
moines
ed
sup
wolcott
des
moines
nav
wall
ed
suits
withdrawal
orders
treated
derived
validity
legislation
subsequently
passed
aid
iowa
assignees
treated
effective
dates
regardless
fact
land
included
therein
originally
granted
iowa
one
said
decided
number
cases
regard
thses
lands
withdrawal
operated
exclude
sale
purchase
lands
controversy
bullard
des
moines
ed
sup
beginning
order
secretary
ewing
aid
legislation
behalf
iowa
continuance
even
decided
land
fork
passed
territory
practice
making
withdrawals
continued
reasons
making
withdrawal
orders
varied
power
exerted
supported
implied
consent
congress
distinction
drawn
principle
decided
iowa
cases
power
involved
making
reservation
differ
exercised
making
withdrawal
executive
practice
congressional
acquiescence
operated
grant
implied
power
make
permanent
reservations
also
present
operate
grant
implied
power
make
temporary
withdrawals
may
well
refer
public
records
showing
existence
extent
practice
withdrawals
aid
legislation
made
particular
cases
land
land
land
many
others
general
nature
much
extensive
operation
example
land
department
passed
order
suspending
location
settlement
certain
islands
isolated
tracts
containing
less
acres
view
submitting
congress
question
whether
legislation
subject
needed
land
reports
congresses
doc
house
doc
contained
list
withdrawals
made
prevent
disposal
land
pending
consideration
question
advisability
setting
apart
forest
reservations
phosphate
land
withdrawn
pending
action
congress
house
doc
cong
sess
also
temporary
withdrawals
oil
land
agricultural
entry
aid
subsequent
legislation
doc
house
doc
pursuance
like
practice
power
public
land
containing
coal
withdrawn
enactment
new
legislation
land
doc
message
president
session
congress
attention
called
withdrawal
coal
lands
aid
legislation
repudiation
order
practice
either
session
succeeding
session
congress
claimed
argument
act
stat
chap
comp
stat
legislation
contemplated
executive
coal
lands
temporarily
withdrawn
order
reference
already
made
act
stat
concerning
iowa
lands
withdrawn
instances
congressional
action
less
remote
period
order
temporary
withdrawal
land
wind
cave
park
withdrawn
park
established
stat
chap
comp
stat
bird
reserves
established
stat
chap
comp
stat
act
passed
making
offense
interfere
birds
reserves
established
law
proclamation
executive
order
see
also
land
stat
chap
majority
cases
subsequent
legislation
reference
lands
although
withdrawal
orders
prevented
acquisition
private
interest
land
order
revoked
whether
particular
case
congress
acted
nothing
done
way
construed
denial
right
executive
make
temporary
withdrawals
public
land
public
interest
considering
size
tracts
affected
length
time
remained
force
without
objection
orders
islands
isolated
tracts
coal
phosphate
oil
lands
withdrawn
aid
legislation
furnish
ample
proof
congressional
recognition
power
withdraw
existence
power
recognized
exercise
executive
assented
congress
emphasized
fact
withdrawals
issued
report
secretary
interior
made
response
resolution
senate
calling
information
public
lands
withdrawn
disposition
settlement
laws
order
commissioner
general
land
office
authority
law
exists
order
withdrawal
answer
specific
inquiry
returned
march
senate
doc
cong
sess
vol
date
secretary
transmitted
senate
elaborate
detailed
report
commissioner
land
office
response
inquiry
authority
withdrawals
made
answered
power
executive
department
government
make
reservations
land
public
use
temporarily
withdraw
lands
appropriation
individuals
exigencies
might
demand
prevent
fraud
aid
proper
administration
aid
pending
legislation
one
long
recognized
acts
congress
decisions
power
long
exercised
commissioner
general
land
office
shown
reference
date
withdrawals
enumerated
attached
list
embraces
lands
withdrawn
office
acting
motion
cases
emergencies
appeared
demand
action
furtherance
public
interest
include
lands
withdrawn
express
statutes
directed
list
attached
refers
withdrawal
orders
number
issued
many
aid
administration
land
laws
correct
boundaries
prevent
fraud
make
classification
land
like
made
prevent
settlements
question
considered
whether
lands
might
included
forest
reservation
thereafter
established
one
referred
also
land
made
order
afford
state
nebraska
opportunity
procure
legislative
relief
iowa
cases
cited
report
refers
withdrawals
reservations
important
connection
present
inquiry
whether
congress
knew
practice
make
temporary
withdrawals
knowingly
assented
thereto
noted
resolution
called
department
state
extent
withdrawals
authority
made
officer
land
department
answer
shows
large
number
withdrawals
made
good
nonstatutory
reasons
shows
orders
made
virtue
practice
claim
right
take
action
public
interest
exigencies
might
demand
congress
notice
practice
claim
authority
received
report
neither
session
afterwards
ever
repudiate
action
taken
power
claimed
silence
acquiescence
acquiescence
equivalent
consent
continue
practice
power
revoked
subsequent
action
congress
position
appellees
strengthened
act
june
stat
chap
comp
stat
authorize
president
make
withdrawals
public
lands
requiring
list
filed
congress
passed
president
proclamation
september
months
occupation
attempted
location
virtue
appellees
claim
acquired
right
land
statute
expressly
provided
construed
recognition
abridgment
enlargement
asserted
rights
claims
initiated
upon
oil
gas
bearing
lands
withdrawal
lands
made
prior
passage
act
true
argued
act
provides
shall
construed
asserted
rights
initiated
oil
lands
withdrawn
likewise
provides
shall
considered
rights
however
nothing
said
indicating
slightest
intent
repudiate
withdrawals
already
made
legislative
history
statute
shows
intent
purpose
make
act
retroactive
disaffirm
agent
charge
already
done
proclamation
september
withdrawing
oil
lands
private
acquisition
consequence
individuals
public
gave
rise
much
discussion
old
question
authority
president
make
orders
raised
various
bills
introduced
subject
president
sent
message
congress
calling
attention
existence
doubt
suggesting
desirability
legislation
expressly
grant
power
ratify
done
bill
passed
house
containing
ratification
authorizing
future
withdrawals
bill
came
senate
referred
committee
members
agree
view
law
two
reports
made
majority
review
practice
department
acquiescence
congress
practice
decisions
courts
reported
president
already
general
power
withdrawal
recommended
passage
pending
bill
inasmuch
operated
restrict
greater
power
already
possessed
cong
session
regard
fact
private
persons
withdrawn
land
raised
question
validity
order
question
presented
matter
judicial
determination
congress
studious
avoid
anything
affect
either
public
private
rights
therefore
used
language
showed
statute
intended
retrospective
construed
either
recognition
enlargement
repudiation
rights
like
asserted
appellees
words
notwithstanding
withdrawal
locator
initiated
right
however
perfected
congress
undertake
take
away
rights
hand
withdrawal
order
legally
made
existing
power
needed
ratification
location
made
withdrawal
gave
appellees
right
congress
statute
legislate
public
validate
invalid
location
act
left
rights
parties
position
appellees
determined
state
law
proclamation
issued
heretofore
pointed
practice
acquiescence
congress
well
decisions
courts
show
president
power
make
order
said
wolsey
chapman
ed
sufficient
defeat
settlement
order
force
case
therefore
remanded
district
directions
decree
dismissing
bill
reversed
justice
mcreynolds
took
part
decision
case
justice
day
concurred
justice
mckenna
justice
van
devanter
dissenting
case
originated
bill
filed
district
district
wyoming
restrain
trespasses
certain
tract
public
petroleum
lands
state
wyoming
obtain
accounting
petroleum
claimed
wrongfully
extracted
therefrom
bill
sets
ownership
land
question
tract
acres
alleges
land
chiefly
valuable
petroleum
september
tract
controversy
common
many
others
withdrawn
mineral
exploration
forms
location
settlement
selection
filing
entry
disposal
mineral
nonmineral
public
land
laws
done
order
promulgated
day
secretary
interior
pursuant
direction
president
order
listed
townships
sections
aggregating
acres
situated
wyoming
california
terms
order
styled
petroleum
withdrawal
aid
proposed
legislation
affecting
use
disposition
petroleum
deposits
public
domain
public
lands
accompanying
lists
hereby
temporarily
withdrawn
forms
location
settlement
selection
filing
entry
disposal
mineral
nonmineral
public
land
laws
locations
claims
existing
valid
date
may
proceed
entry
usual
manner
field
investigation
examination
appears
averments
bill
lands
originally
located
certain
individuals
order
withdrawal
march
entered
upon
explored
well
drilled
thereby
rendering
subject
ready
extraction
large
deposits
petroleum
great
value
original
claimants
caused
filed
recorded
records
natrona
county
wyoming
certain
location
certificate
evidencing
claim
location
land
petroleum
mining
claim
pursuance
mining
laws
parties
subsequently
assigned
rights
defendant
midwest
oil
company
certain
persons
named
bill
also
avers
withdrawal
order
september
july
order
withdrawal
described
withdrawal
petroleum
reserve
made
president
expressly
affirming
order
september
law
location
question
made
stat
chap
comp
stat
reads
person
authorized
enter
lands
mining
laws
may
enter
obtain
patent
lands
containing
petroleum
mineral
oils
chiefly
valuable
therefor
provisions
laws
relating
placer
mineral
claims
rev
stat
comp
stat
provision
made
entering
patenting
claims
like
manner
vein
lode
claims
rev
stat
comp
stat
valuable
mineral
deposits
opened
exploration
purchase
lands
containing
occupation
purchase
regulations
prescribed
law
according
local
customs
rules
miners
allegations
bill
set
steps
led
president
order
withdrawal
september
may
look
allegations
read
light
public
documents
embodying
history
transaction
may
take
judicial
notice
september
secretary
interior
direction
president
issued
temporary
petroleum
withdrawal
order
set
forth
making
order
preceded
certain
correspondence
leading
february
director
geological
survey
addressed
letter
scretary
inerior
setting
forth
opinion
superiority
liquid
fuel
navy
inadequacy
coal
supply
pacific
coast
fact
demand
oil
greater
supply
little
oil
land
remained
governmental
control
rapidly
patented
recommendation
filing
claims
oil
lands
california
suspended
order
government
might
continue
ownership
valuable
supplies
liquid
fuel
september
director
sent
another
letter
secretary
interior
inclosing
copy
earlier
letter
saying
substance
arguments
contained
letter
reinforced
survey
conservation
report
petroleum
resources
showed
time
production
exceeded
demand
trade
inasmuch
disposal
public
petroleum
lands
nominal
prices
encouraged
overproduction
legislation
providing
sane
development
resources
enacted
also
stated
conservation
petroleum
supply
demanded
law
providing
disposal
oil
remaining
public
lands
terms
barrels
oil
rather
acres
land
considering
use
lubricating
oil
fuel
oil
navy
immediate
necessity
conserving
proper
supply
petroleum
government
use
recommended
suspension
filing
claims
oil
lands
california
pending
legislation
subject
also
called
attention
fact
commissioner
general
land
office
acting
upon
report
classifying
certain
oil
lands
california
issued
instructions
withholding
oil
lands
agricultural
entry
pending
consideration
legislation
day
secretary
interior
addressed
letter
president
calling
attention
subject
conservation
petroleum
resources
public
domain
especially
reference
requirements
navy
repeating
substance
director
letter
stating
lands
mentioned
director
letter
also
withdrawn
entry
california
concluding
legislation
needed
assure
conservation
adequate
supply
petroleum
government
needs
believed
interfere
private
development
california
oil
pools
therefore
necessity
temporary
withdrawals
land
entry
shortly
thereafter
september
secretary
interior
telegraphed
acting
secretary
salt
lake
city
seen
president
follows
conferred
president
respecting
temporary
withdrawals
covering
oil
lands
present
withdrawals
permit
mining
entries
made
lands
wish
withdrawals
modified
prohibit
disposition
pending
legislation
following
day
acting
secretary
telegraphed
secretary
helena
montana
received
california
wyoming
petroleum
withdrawals
heretofore
made
permit
mining
locations
following
direction
temporarily
withdrawn
forms
location
entry
acres
california
acres
wyoming
heretofore
withdrawn
classification
withdrawal
prevents
forms
acquisition
future
holds
land
statu
quo
pending
legislation
thereupon
withdrawal
order
september
set
forth
promulgated
observed
lands
controversy
situated
state
wyoming
suggestion
lands
ever
needed
basis
oil
supply
navy
withdrawn
solely
upon
suggestion
better
disposition
made
found
existing
acts
congress
controlling
subject
statement
evident
first
question
decided
concerns
validity
president
withdrawal
order
september
necessary
determine
whether
order
within
authority
president
effect
withdraw
land
controversy
location
mineral
land
law
whether
held
order
force
effect
prevent
persons
acquiring
rights
statutes
concerning
subject
constitution
article
provides
congress
shall
power
dispose
make
needful
rules
regulations
respecting
territory
property
belonging
section
power
dispose
lands
belonging
broadly
conferred
upon
congress
power
therein
given
system
land
laws
disposition
public
domain
enacted
gratiot
pet
ed
fitzgerald
pet
ed
van
brocklin
tennessee
van
brocklin
anderson
ed
sup
wisconsin
price
county
ed
sup
last
case
said
constitution
vests
congress
power
make
needful
rules
regulations
respecting
territory
property
belonging
implies
exclusion
authority
property
interfere
right
obstruct
exercise
contended
behalf
government
power
president
make
orders
question
grown
authorization
congress
legislation
long
sanction
acquiescence
exercise
executive
authority
admitted
authority
president
deal
public
lands
must
come
congress
sanction
action
executive
received
course
many
years
legislation
congressional
acquiescence
effective
though
express
authority
conferred
law
aid
argument
general
course
legislation
pointed
decisions
opinions
attorneys
general
connection
certain
acts
cited
upon
hand
contended
acts
taken
general
declaration
congressional
intent
upon
subject
contain
express
authorization
president
make
withdrawals
congress
wishes
confer
power
instances
referred
set
margin
thus
explicitly
recognized
already
apparent
terms
constitution
sole
authority
dispose
public
lands
vested
congress
branch
federal
government
right
executive
withdraw
lands
congress
declared
shall
open
free
settlement
upon
terms
congress
prescribed
said
arise
tacit
consent
congress
long
acquiescence
executive
action
resulting
implied
authority
congress
make
withdrawals
public
interest
executive
deems
proper
necessary
nothing
constitution
suggesting
authorizing
augmentation
executive
authority
justifying
thus
acting
aid
power
framers
constitution
saw
fit
vest
exclusively
legislative
branch
government
true
many
withdrawals
made
president
sustained
may
fairly
said
within
limitations
hereinafter
stated
executive
withdrawals
sanction
judicial
approval
read
cases
instance
sustained
withdrawal
public
lands
congress
provided
system
disposition
except
withdrawal
pursuance
policy
already
declared
congress
one
public
lands
might
used
military
indian
reservations
purposes
congress
authorized
use
public
lands
early
day
cases
grants
congress
conflict
purpose
congress
known
therefore
secretary
interior
sustained
withdrawing
lands
entry
congress
opportunity
relieve
ambiguity
laws
specifically
declaring
policy
undoubtedly
true
withdrawals
made
without
specific
authority
act
congress
sustained
believed
found
one
categories
stated
hand
executive
authority
exceeded
hesitated
declare
sustain
superior
exclusive
authority
congress
deal
public
lands
first
decision
come
attention
matter
dealt
wilcox
jackson
pet
ed
decided
case
involved
controversy
concerning
lands
occupied
military
post
called
fort
dearborn
cook
county
illinois
lands
used
many
years
military
post
indian
agency
reserved
commissioner
general
land
office
request
secretary
war
military
purposes
also
appears
prior
may
government
built
lighthouse
part
land
suit
brought
jackson
recover
possession
wilcox
commander
post
claimed
right
hold
officer
orders
secretary
war
claim
asserted
jackson
arose
preemption
allowed
lessor
predecessor
title
act
june
stat
chap
revived
act
may
stat
chap
provided
entry
sale
land
shall
made
provisions
act
shall
reserved
use
either
several
reserved
sale
act
congress
order
president
may
appropriated
purpose
whatsoever
stating
lands
appropriated
purpose
whatsoever
exempt
lands
question
fact
appropriated
reviewed
lagislation
authorizing
president
erect
fortifications
establish
trading
houses
concluding
appropriation
made
authority
law
said
thus
see
establishing
trading
houses
indian
tribes
erection
fortifications
west
purposes
authorized
law
established
erected
president
place
question
one
trading
house
established
fortification
military
post
erected
doubted
suppose
anyone
congress
law
directed
trading
house
established
military
post
erected
fort
dearborn
name
authority
law
instead
place
left
discretion
president
precisely
thing
effect
appropriation
one
two
purposes
place
authority
law
third
appropriation
case
authority
law
congress
law
authorized
erection
lighthouse
mouth
chicago
river
within
limits
land
question
appropriated
erection
case
agreed
lighthouse
built
part
land
dispute
may
think
appropriation
fact
law
remarking
congress
must
known
authority
given
president
former
laws
establish
trading
houses
military
posts
military
post
long
established
fort
dearborn
said
seem
therefore
studious
use
language
comprehensive
kind
exemption
right
embrace
every
description
reservation
appropriation
previously
made
public
purposes
reference
reservation
merely
said
consider
done
authority
law
amongst
provisions
act
lands
exempted
emption
reserved
sale
order
president
held
act
secretary
war
executive
later
laid
rule
lands
legally
appropriated
immediately
become
severed
mass
public
lands
subsequent
law
proclamation
embrace
although
reservation
made
case
therefore
following
propositions
deduced
legal
appropriation
reservation
unnecessary
reservation
case
ratified
subsequent
act
congress
appropriation
land
controversy
case
authority
law
power
placed
president
congress
acts
passed
exertion
power
president
grisar
mcdowell
wall
ed
another
case
relied
upon
controversy
city
san
francisco
reference
extent
pueblo
lands
belonging
former
determined
order
confirming
title
city
subject
exception
lands
dedicated
public
uses
act
congress
march
stat
chap
relinquishing
claim
subject
reservation
decree
grisar
claiming
title
city
sought
recover
possession
land
reserved
order
president
public
purposes
held
defendant
officer
army
commanding
military
department
california
entered
upon
premises
held
order
secretary
war
part
public
property
reserved
military
purposes
dealing
right
president
make
reservation
first
held
made
difference
whether
president
possessed
sufficient
authority
make
reservation
part
public
domain
excluded
lands
affirmed
state
plaintiff
claimed
dealing
power
president
said
early
period
history
government
practice
president
order
time
time
exigencies
public
service
required
parcels
land
belonging
reserved
sale
set
apart
public
uses
connection
cited
acts
congress
recognizing
authority
president
among
others
act
may
supra
provided
right
extend
lands
reserved
sale
act
congress
order
president
act
september
stat
chap
exempting
lands
reserved
treaty
law
proclamation
president
march
stat
chap
excepting
lands
appropriated
authority
act
reserved
competent
authority
held
reservation
competent
authority
meant
authority
president
acting
direction
furthermore
held
action
president
making
reservations
indirectly
approved
congress
appropriating
moneys
construction
fortifications
public
works
upon
reservations
embraced
lands
upon
public
buildings
erected
language
justice
field
quoted
authority
president
frequently
quoted
subsequent
opinions
attorneys
general
made
basis
opinions
broad
authority
president
observed
however
case
law
recited
opinion
giving
power
reservation
contained
congressional
authority
directly
president
competent
authority
held
meant
president
statement
added
action
president
approved
congress
appropriating
money
fortifications
public
works
government
also
relied
upon
series
cases
may
called
des
moines
river
cases
beginning
wolcott
des
moines
nav
wall
ed
followed
riley
welles
ed
sup
williams
baker
cedar
rapids
martindale
wall
ed
iowa
homestead
valley
wall
ed
wolsey
chapman
ed
litchfield
webster
county
ed
dubuque
des
moines
valley
ed
sup
bullard
des
moines
ed
sup
des
moines
nav
ed
sup
original
case
wall
shown
cases
grew
act
congress
august
stat
chap
granting
territory
iowa
purpose
aiding
improving
navigation
des
moines
river
mouth
raccoon
fork
equal
moiety
alternate
sections
public
lands
strip
five
miles
width
side
said
river
ambiguous
description
gave
rise
controversy
appeared
time
time
cases
mentioned
arose
doubt
whether
grant
iowa
included
lands
raccoon
fork
early
year
commissioner
general
land
office
decided
grant
extended
beyond
raccoon
fork
later
year
president
proclamation
ordered
sale
land
fork
following
october
june
however
secretary
treasury
construed
grant
include
lands
fork
directed
reserved
sale
control
general
land
office
passed
secretary
interior
april
reversed
decision
secretary
treasury
directed
lands
embraced
within
state
selections
reserved
sale
matter
two
presidents
cabinets
different
results
finally
octor
secretary
interior
held
view
great
conflict
among
executive
officers
government
view
opinion
eminent
jurists
presented
favor
construction
contended
state
willing
recognize
claim
state
approve
selections
without
prejudice
rights
parties
history
subsequent
legislation
necessary
recite
given
opinion
act
may
stat
chap
upon
plaintiff
relied
considered
found
provision
lands
heretofore
reserved
act
congress
manner
competent
authority
purpose
aiding
object
internal
improvement
purpose
whatsoever
reserved
operation
act
grant
made
railroads
admitted
covered
tract
controversy
unless
excluded
proviso
held
lands
reserved
competent
authority
saying
argued
lands
reserved
competent
authority
hence
reservation
nugatory
seen
reserved
sale
special
purpose
aiding
improvement
des
moines
secretary
treasury
land
department
supervision
control
secretary
interior
establishment
department
duties
assigned
afterwards
continued
department
instructions
president
cabinet
besides
power
competent
think
ever
since
establishment
land
department
exercised
present
time
grant
august
carried
along
necessary
implication
power
duty
land
office
reserve
sale
lands
embraced
grant
otherwise
object
might
utterly
defeated
hence
immediately
upon
grant
made
congress
public
purposes
state
notice
given
commissioner
land
office
registers
receivers
stop
sales
either
public
private
entry
notice
given
day
grant
made
benefit
railroads
dispute
existing
extent
grant
way
affects
question
serious
conflict
opinion
among
public
authorities
subject
made
duty
land
officers
withhold
sales
reserve
till
ultimately
disposed
therefore
apparent
reservation
sanctioned
become
duty
officers
law
charged
administration
grants
required
give
effect
withhold
lands
sale
reserve
doubt
extent
grant
words
lands
granted
state
iowa
possibly
intention
congress
subject
selection
grant
laws
said
power
reserve
arose
necessary
implication
grant
riley
welles
ed
sup
involving
claim
title
section
act
september
land
covered
withdrawal
act
followed
wolcott
des
moines
nav
wall
ed
repeated
decision
effect
reservation
williams
baker
cedar
rapids
martindale
wall
ed
iowa
homestead
valley
wall
ed
involving
title
lands
claimed
grant
titles
founded
act
wolcott
case
affirmed
validity
reservation
act
reason
proviso
act
prevented
railroad
acquiring
land
wolsey
chapman
ed
controversy
whether
grant
territory
iowa
act
september
supra
right
select
quantity
lands
internal
improvement
purposes
excepting
might
sale
law
congress
proclamation
president
permitted
selection
certain
lands
covered
reservation
cases
held
pp
reserved
also
consequence
act
proper
executive
department
government
determined
doubts
extent
operation
act
nothing
done
impair
rights
state
raccoon
fork
differences
settled
either
congress
judicial
decision
purpose
authoritative
order
issued
directing
local
land
officers
withhold
disputed
lands
sale
withdrew
lands
private
entry
held
riley
welles
sufficient
defeat
settlement
purpose
order
force
notwithstanding
afterwards
found
law
reason
action
taken
contemplate
withdrawal
truth
reservation
public
lands
sale
except
reason
treaty
law
authorized
act
executive
department
government
litchfield
webster
county
ed
involved
question
whether
title
lands
fork
vested
state
act
purpose
taxation
affirming
previous
cases
held
action
executive
department
general
government
reserved
land
fork
pass
state
selected
school
lands
act
railroad
lands
grant
open
emption
entry
executive
order
retained
ownership
case
dubuque
des
moines
valley
ed
sup
also
involved
controversy
whether
title
vested
river
railroad
grant
held
validity
reservation
longer
open
question
history
matter
restated
bullard
des
moines
ed
sup
made
appear
especially
order
withdrawing
land
effect
time
passage
act
july
stat
chap
decision
case
dubuque
litchfield
ed
determined
congress
act
granted
land
fork
iowa
commissioner
general
land
office
notice
may
continued
reservation
notwithstanding
decision
referred
held
resolution
congress
march
stat
end
reservation
claims
inaugurated
resolution
passage
act
july
subject
reservation
said
decided
number
cases
regard
lands
withdrawal
operated
exclude
sale
purchase
lands
controversy
unless
case
consider
constitutes
exception
never
revoked
controversy
remained
order
department
control
matter
withdrawing
lands
dispute
public
sale
settlement
withdrawal
held
effectual
grant
made
congress
railroad
companies
act
contained
following
proviso
lands
heretofore
reserved
act
congress
manner
competent
authority
purpose
aiding
object
internal
improvement
purpose
whatsoever
hereby
reserved
operation
act
except
far
may
found
necessary
locate
routes
said
railroads
reserved
lands
case
right
way
shall
granted
subject
approval
president
quoted
notice
commissioner
general
land
office
may
land
fork
reserved
sale
heretofore
account
claim
state
thereto
continue
reserved
time
sale
location
species
script
warrants
notwithstanding
recent
decision
claim
action
deemed
necessary
afford
time
congress
consider
upon
memorial
otherwise
case
actual
bona
fide
settlers
holding
titles
state
make
provision
confirmation
adjustment
claims
settlers
may
appear
right
proper
said
thus
seen
notwithstanding
decision
winter
land
office
determined
reservation
lands
continue
purpose
securing
action
congress
state
iowa
soliciting
disputed
counsel
appellant
case
valid
continuation
reservation
continuance
plaintiff
claims
made
think
joint
resolution
effect
end
reservation
lands
public
entry
way
reservation
sale
public
lands
removed
almost
every
instance
reservation
terminated
proclamation
president
lands
open
entry
sale
instances
first
offered
sale
public
auction
seen
anything
joint
resolution
congress
either
considered
controversy
ended
intended
remove
reservation
instituted
department
immediate
procedure
next
session
full
consideration
whole
subject
shows
ceased
deal
reason
withdrawal
reservation
continued
strongly
doubted
subject
congress
well
committees
act
july
first
time
conclusion
end
matter
far
congress
concerned
last
des
moines
river
cases
des
moines
nav
ed
sup
suit
instituted
quiet
title
certain
lands
conveyed
state
iowa
navigation
company
others
claiming
trust
performed
reviewing
history
matter
previous
cases
considerable
length
stated
effect
reservation
validity
reservation
sustained
case
wolcott
des
moines
nav
wall
ed
decided
december
term
case
held
even
absence
command
effect
statute
duty
officers
land
department
immediately
upon
grant
made
congress
reserve
settlement
sale
lands
within
grant
dispute
extent
duty
reserve
lands
upon
either
construction
might
become
necessary
make
good
purposes
grant
ruling
power
duty
officers
land
department
since
followed
many
cases
bullard
des
moines
supra
cases
cited
opinion
case
us
congress
statutes
referred
expressly
subjected
lands
operation
placer
mining
law
authorized
exploration
oil
location
entry
purchase
mineral
lands
congress
way
exercised
power
manifested
situation
withdrawal
question
made
deriving
aim
executive
various
documents
referred
may
fairly
deduced
prevailing
purpose
sole
purpose
far
lands
involved
concerned
making
withdrawal
anticipate
congress
brought
attention
might
provide
better
economical
system
disposition
public
lands
secondarily
preserve
oil
lands
california
basis
naval
supply
future
latter
purpose
time
declared
recognized
congress
purposes
president
express
authority
congress
fact
claimed
authority
may
arise
implication
think
must
limited
purposes
congress
recognized
either
direct
legislation
acquiescence
public
purposes
withdrawals
made
executive
president
might
virtue
executive
authority
take
action
preserve
public
property
aid
execution
laws
reserve
tracts
land
definitely
fixed
public
purposes
declared
congress
military
indian
reservations
may
conceded
unable
find
sanction
action
taken
withdrawing
large
part
public
domain
operation
public
land
laws
power
inherent
office
created
defined
constitution
way
conferred
upon
legislation
congress
long
acquiescence
exercise
authority
sanctioned
congress
manner
equivalent
grant
president
constitutional
authority
president
art
includes
executive
power
nation
duty
see
laws
faithfully
executed
president
take
care
laws
faithfully
executed
clause
duty
limited
enforcement
acts
congress
according
express
terms
includes
rights
obligations
growing
constitution
international
relations
protection
implied
nature
government
constitution
cooley
const
law
neagle
ed
sup
constitution
confer
upon
power
enact
laws
suspend
repeal
congress
enacts
kendall
pet
ed
president
powers
defined
constitution
government
contend
general
authority
disposition
public
land
constitution
committed
congress
freely
concedes
general
proposition
lack
authority
president
deal
laws
otherwise
see
faithfully
executed
said
sustained
certain
withdrawals
made
executive
carrying
policy
use
public
lands
indicated
congressional
legislation
sustained
right
withdrawal
conflicting
grants
made
congress
additional
legislation
needed
expressly
declare
purpose
congress
refused
sustain
withdrawals
made
executive
branch
government
contravention
policy
disposition
lands
declared
acts
congress
southern
bell
ed
sup
held
secretary
interior
authority
withdraw
lands
within
indemnity
limits
grant
sale
emption
congress
indicated
purpose
lands
might
taken
settlers
road
exercised
right
selection
brandon
ard
ed
sup
conflict
attempted
withdrawal
aid
land
grant
homestead
settlement
three
years
later
held
withdrawal
lands
sale
settlement
prior
definite
location
road
selected
supply
deficiencies
place
granted
limits
without
authority
law
homestead
settlement
existing
laws
congress
must
prevail
attempted
withdrawal
principle
declared
enforced
osborn
froyseth
ed
sup
lockhart
johnson
ed
sup
justice
peckham
speaking
tersely
stated
rule
lands
belonging
whose
sale
disposition
congress
made
provision
general
laws
regarded
legally
open
entry
sale
laws
unless
particular
lands
withdrawn
sale
congressional
authority
executive
withdrawal
authority
either
expressed
implied
think
rule
thus
stated
result
previous
decisions
properly
construed
consistent
authority
public
lands
given
congress
constitution
properly
rests
executive
power
deal
lands
way
withdrawal
upon
express
implied
authority
congress
words
may
fairly
said
given
withdrawal
must
expressly
authorized
congress
must
clear
implication
congressional
authority
equivalent
express
authority
authority
wanting
executive
withdrawal
lands
operation
act
congress
otherwise
control
message
president
january
indicates
doubted
authority
make
withdrawals
message
referring
lax
manner
government
disposing
public
lands
mining
acts
need
properly
classifying
lands
revising
mode
disposing
oil
deposits
greater
regard
public
interests
without
hindering
development
said
power
secretary
interior
withdraw
operation
existing
statutes
tracts
land
disposition
statutes
detrimental
public
interest
clear
satisfactory
power
exercised
interest
public
hope
congress
might
affirm
action
executive
laws
adapted
new
conditions
unfortunately
congress
thus
far
fully
acted
recommendations
executive
question
executive
circumstances
full
difficulty
seems
duty
congress
statute
validate
withdrawals
made
secretary
interior
president
authorize
secretary
interior
temporarily
withdraw
lands
pending
submission
congress
recommendations
legislation
meet
conditions
emergencies
arise
earnestly
recommend
suggestions
secretary
interior
made
respect
lands
shall
embodied
statutes
especially
withdrawals
already
made
shall
validated
far
necessary
authority
secretary
interior
withdraw
lands
purpose
submitting
recommendations
future
dispositions
new
legislation
needed
shall
made
complete
unquestioned
receipt
message
considerable
number
bills
senate
house
representatives
upon
subject
matter
taken
house
representatives
bill
passed
providing
withdrawals
certain
conditions
providing
withdrawals
heretofore
made
existing
hereby
ratified
confirmed
originally
made
act
bill
form
pass
senate
however
adopted
materially
modified
form
act
june
stat
chap
comp
stat
reads
enacted
senate
house
representatives
america
congress
assembled
president
may
time
discretion
temporarily
withdraw
settlement
location
sale
entry
public
lands
including
district
alaska
reserve
sites
irrigation
classification
lands
public
purposes
specified
orders
withdrawals
withdrawals
reservations
shall
remain
force
revoked
act
congress
lands
withdrawn
provisions
act
shall
times
open
exploration
discovery
occupation
purchase
mining
laws
far
apply
minerals
coal
oil
gas
phosphates
provided
rights
person
date
order
withdrawal
heretofore
hereafter
made
bona
fide
occupant
claimant
oil
gas
bearing
lands
date
diligent
prosecution
work
leading
discovery
oil
gas
shall
affected
impaired
order
long
occupant
claimant
shall
continue
diligent
prosecution
said
work
provided
act
shall
construed
recognition
abridgment
enlargement
asserted
rights
claims
initiated
upon
oil
gas
bearing
lands
withdrawal
lands
made
prior
passage
act
provided
shall
excepted
force
effect
withdrawal
made
provisions
act
lands
date
withdrawal
embraced
lawful
homestead
entry
theretofore
made
upon
valid
settlement
made
said
date
maintained
perfected
pursuant
law
terms
proviso
shall
continue
apply
particular
tract
land
unless
entryman
settler
shall
continue
comply
law
entry
settlement
made
provided
hereafter
forest
reserve
shall
created
shall
additions
made
one
heretofore
created
within
limits
oregon
washington
idaho
montana
colorado
wyoming
except
act
congress
secretary
interior
shall
report
withdrawals
congress
beginning
next
regular
session
date
withdrawals
reports
senate
committee
show
members
divided
authority
president
make
withdrawal
order
question
majority
report
stated
view
president
authority
without
additional
legislation
minority
reached
opposite
conclusion
noted
act
june
conferred
specific
authority
future
upon
president
gave
approval
withdrawal
september
containing
instead
express
provision
act
construed
recognition
abridgment
enlargement
asserted
rights
claims
initiated
upon
oil
gas
bearing
lands
withdrawal
lands
made
prior
passage
act
order
september
withdrew
lands
form
settlement
location
sale
entry
disposal
mineral
nonmineral
public
land
laws
act
june
excepts
power
withdrawal
conferred
upon
president
lands
embraced
lawful
homestead
desertland
entry
theretofore
made
upon
valid
settlement
made
maintained
perfected
pursuant
law
furthermore
act
provides
rights
bona
fide
occupant
claimant
oil
gas
bearing
lands
complying
provisions
statute
relating
thereto
shall
affected
impaired
subsequent
order
withdrawal
statute
certainly
congressional
assent
executive
withdrawal
september
validation
ratification
asked
president
message
withheld
restricted
authority
future
granted
act
june
rights
locators
involved
case
preserved
whatever
extent
existed
absence
ratification
withdrawal
express
ratification
thus
asked
refused
view
power
implication
fairly
inferred
barden
northern
ed
sup
durousseau
cranch
ed
eyster
centennial
bd
finance
ed
act
june
neither
ratified
withdrawal
september
empowered
president
order
july
government
one
limited
powers
three
branches
government
vested
certain
authority
definite
limited
constitution
principle
often
enforced
decisions
apt
words
justice
miller
speaking
kilbourn
thompson
ed
quoted
approval
believed
one
chief
merits
american
system
written
constitutional
law
powers
intrusted
government
whether
state
national
divided
three
grand
departments
executive
legislative
judicial
functions
appropriate
branches
government
shall
vested
separate
body
public
servants
perfection
system
requires
lines
separate
divide
departments
shall
broadly
clearly
defined
also
essential
successful
working
system
persons
intrusted
power
one
branches
shall
permitted
encroach
upon
powers
confided
others
shall
law
creation
limited
exercise
powers
appropriate
department
principles
departed
judicial
determinations
enforcement
essential
administration
government
created
defined
constitution
grant
authority
executive
departments
government
amplified
judicial
decisions
constitution
legitimate
source
authority
exercise
power
sanction
provisions
equally
binding
upon
every
officer
government
highest
lowest
one
great
functions
keep
far
judicial
decisions
subserve
purpose
branch
government
within
sphere
legitimate
action
prevent
encroachments
one
branch
upon
authority
another
opinion
action
executive
department
case
originating
expressed
view
subordinate
official
interior
department
desirability
different
system
public
land
disposal
contained
lawful
enactments
congress
justify
president
withdrawing
large
body
land
operation
law
virtually
suspending
necessarily
operation
law
least
different
view
expressed
considered
congress
conclusion
reinforced
particular
instance
refusal
congress
ratify
action
president
enactment
new
statute
authorizing
disposition
public
lands
method
essentially
different
proposed
executive
reasons
expressed
constrained
dissent
opinion
judgment
case
footnotes
departmental
ruling
existence
power
report
commissioner
land
office
february
senate
doc
cong
appendix
call
reservations
decisions
department
interior
relating
public
lands
land
land
land
land
land
land
land
indian
reservations
orders
relating
indian
reservations
public
domain
report
commissioner
indian
affairs
military
reservations
public
domain
house
doc
house
doc
call
reservations
bird
reservations
house
doc
house
doc
government
asserts
reservations
executive
indian
purposes
irrespective
existence
statutory
authority
found
collected
public
domain
pp
kappler
laws
treaties
military
purposes
public
domain
pp
laws
local
temporary
character
whether
orders
preceded
congressional
authority
definitely
appear
also
recites
several
executive
withdrawals
land
uses
related
military
purposes
lands
supplying
fuel
water
military
posts
also
withdrawal
conserve
supply
building
stone
harbor
improvements
another
instance
cited
congress
appropriation
act
june
stat
chap
directed
secretary
war
cause
examination
made
sources
mississippi
river
among
others
determine
practicability
cost
reservoirs
improving
navigation
secretary
said
made
report
withdrew
certain
lands
aid
report
hope
event
affirmative
congressional
action
upon
said
report
additional
lands
withdrawn
subsequently
purpose
appropriations
construction
reservoirs
made
act
june
stat
chap
attention
also
called
withdrawals
number
purposes
correct
surveys
avoid
conflicts
private
claims
prevent
frauds
ascertain
character
land
shown
letter
acting
secretary
interior
dated
march
found
vol
congressional
record
reports
secretary
interior
commissioner
general
land
office
cited
effect
supposed
oil
lands
california
withdrawn
agricultural
entry
aid
investigation
character
prevent
unlawful
application
lieu
selections
pp
pp
large
quantities
coal
land
withdrawn
verify
existence
coal
deposits
serious
frauds
pp
temporary
reservation
made
forest
arizona
proposed
national
park
commissioner
report
temporary
withdrawals
made
state
parks
california
michigan
commissioner
report
reported
congress
land
including
wind
cave
south
dakota
reserved
commissioner
report
later
made
national
park
act
january
stat
chap
president
created
certain
reservations
protection
birds
sec
int
subsequently
act
passed
making
offense
interfere
birds
eggs
lands
set
apart
reserved
breeding
grounds
birds
law
proclamation
executive
order
stat
chap
comp
stat
secretary
interior
directed
applications
purchase
certain
isolated
tracts
suspended
land
subsequently
act
providing
desposition
disconnected
tracts
approved
congress
stat
chap
comp
stat
aid
bill
authorize
wisconsin
select
certain
lands
president
withdrew
large
area
state
bill
later
passed
land
stat
chap
coal
lands
alaska
withdrawn
entry
direction
president
land
thrown
open
entry
congress
stat
chap
comp
stat
propriety
withdrawal
approved
congress
stat
chap
comp
stat
support
statement
general
recognition
executive
authority
found
number
statutes
government
cited
law
march
stat
chap
comp
stat
contained
proviso
provisions
act
shall
apply
military
reservations
heretofore
made
reservations
lighthouses
customhouses
mints
public
purposes
interests
may
require
whether
held
reservations
land
office
title
derived
crown
spain
otherwise
act
february
stat
chap
comp
stat
providing
allotment
lands
severalty
indians
various
reservations
purposes
opening
paragraph
read
cases
tribe
band
indians
shall
hereafter
located
upon
reservation
created
use
either
treaty
stipulation
virtue
act
congress
executive
order
setting
apart
use
president
hereby
authorized
government
says
however
publication
relied
determining
whether
given
executive
order
preceded
statutory
authority
admits
possible
cases
cited
antecedent
statutory
authority
defendant
appends
brief
list
statutes
giving
discretionary
power
executive
make
withdrawals
relating
military
analogous
purposes
stat
note
stat
chap
stat
chap
stat
chap
stat
chap
stat
chap
stat
chap
stat
chap
stat
chap
stat
chap
indian
purposes
stat
chap
stat
chap
stat
chap
stat
chap
stat
chap
lighthouse
stat
chap
reference
salt
springs
stat
chap
stat
chap
stat
chap
lead
mines
stat
chap
town
sites
stat
chap
stat
chap
comp
stat
reservoirs
stat
chap
comp
stat
irrigation
work
stat
chap
comp
stat
lands
containing
timber
naval
purposes
stat
chap
forest
reserves
stat
chap
comp
stat
stat
chap