harper
row
nation
enterprises
argued
november
decided
may
former
president
ford
contracted
petitioners
publish
yet
unwritten
memoirs
agreement
gave
petitioners
exclusive
first
serial
right
license
prepublication
excerpts
two
years
later
memoirs
nearing
completion
petitioners
copyright
holders
negotiated
prepublication
licensing
agreement
time
magazine
time
agreed
pay
advance
balance
publication
exchange
right
excerpt
words
ford
account
pardon
former
president
nixon
shortly
time
article
scheduled
release
unauthorized
source
provided
nation
magazine
unpublished
ford
manuscript
working
directly
manuscript
editor
nation
produced
article
least
words
consisted
verbatim
quotes
copyrighted
expression
taken
manuscript
timed
scoop
time
article
result
publication
nation
article
time
canceled
article
refused
pay
remaining
petitioners
petitioners
brought
suit
federal
district
respondent
publishers
nation
alleging
inter
alia
violations
copyright
act
act
district
held
ford
memoirs
protected
copyright
time
nation
publication
respondents
use
copyrighted
material
constituted
infringement
act
awarded
actual
damages
appeals
reversed
holding
nation
publication
words
identified
copyrightable
expression
sanctioned
fair
use
copyrighted
material
act
section
provides
notwithstanding
provisions
giving
copyright
owner
exclusive
right
reproduce
copyrighted
work
prepare
derivative
works
based
copyrighted
work
fair
use
copyrighted
work
purposes
comment
news
reporting
infringement
copyright
section
provides
determining
whether
use
fair
factors
considered
shall
include
purpose
character
use
nature
copyrighted
work
substantiality
portion
used
relation
copyrighted
work
whole
effect
potential
market
value
copyrighted
work
held
nation
article
fair
use
sanctioned
pp
using
generous
verbatim
excerpts
ford
unpublished
expression
lend
authenticity
account
forthcoming
memoirs
nation
effectively
arrogated
right
first
publication
important
marketable
subsidiary
right
pp
though
right
first
publication
like
rights
enumerated
expressly
made
subject
fair
use
provisions
fair
use
analysis
must
always
tailored
individual
case
nature
interest
stake
highly
relevant
whether
given
use
fair
unpublished
nature
work
key
though
necessarily
determinative
factor
tending
negate
defense
fair
use
ordinary
circumstances
author
right
control
first
public
appearance
undisseminated
expression
outweigh
claim
fair
use
pp
view
first
amendment
protections
embodied
act
distinction
copyrightable
expression
uncopyrightable
facts
ideas
latitude
scholarship
comment
traditionally
afforded
fair
use
warrant
expanding
respondents
contend
done
fair
use
doctrine
amounts
public
figure
exception
copyright
whether
verbatim
copying
public
figure
manuscript
given
case
fair
must
judged
according
traditional
equities
fair
use
pp
taking
account
four
factors
enumerated
especially
relevant
determining
fair
use
leads
conclusion
use
question
fair
fact
news
reporting
general
purpose
nation
use
simply
one
factor
nation
every
right
first
publish
information
went
beyond
simply
reporting
uncopyrightable
information
actively
sought
exploit
headline
value
infringement
making
news
event
unauthorized
first
publication
fact
publication
commercial
opposed
nonprofit
separate
factor
tending
weigh
finding
fair
use
fair
use
presupposes
good
faith
nation
unauthorized
use
undisseminated
manuscript
merely
incidental
effect
intended
purpose
supplanting
copyright
holders
commercially
valuable
right
first
publication
ii
may
greater
need
disseminate
works
fact
works
fiction
nation
taking
copyrighted
expression
exceeded
necessary
disseminate
facts
infringed
copyright
holders
interests
confidentiality
creative
control
first
public
appearance
work
iii
although
verbatim
quotes
question
insubstantial
portion
ford
manuscript
qualitatively
embodied
ford
distinctive
expression
played
key
role
infringing
article
iv
effect
nation
article
market
copyrighted
work
time
cancellation
projected
article
refusal
pay
direct
effect
infringing
publication
copyright
holder
establishes
causal
connection
infringement
loss
revenue
burden
shifts
infringer
show
damage
occurred
taking
copyrighted
expression
petitioners
established
prima
facie
case
actual
damage
respondents
failed
rebut
important
negate
claim
fair
use
need
shown
challenged
use
become
widespread
adversely
affect
potential
market
copyrighted
work
nation
liberal
use
verbatim
excerpts
posed
substantial
potential
damage
marketability
first
serialization
rights
copyrighted
work
pp
delivered
opinion
burger
blackmun
powell
rehnquist
stevens
joined
brennan
filed
dissenting
opinion
white
marshall
joined
post
edward
miller
argued
cause
petitioners
briefs
barbara
hufham
david
otis
fuller
floyd
abrams
argued
cause
respondents
brief
devereux
chatillon
carol
rinzler
andrew
deutsch
leon
friedman
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
association
american
publishers
jon
baumgarten
charles
lieb
volunteer
lawyers
arts
fred
koenigsberg
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
affirmance
filed
pen
american
center
stephen
gillers
gannett
et
al
melville
nimmer
benjamin
heineman
alice
neff
lucan
robert
lobdell
justice
delivered
opinion
case
requires
us
consider
extent
fair
use
provision
copyright
revision
act
hereinafter
copyright
act
sanctions
unauthorized
use
quotations
public
figure
unpublished
manuscript
march
undisclosed
source
provided
nation
magazine
unpublished
manuscript
time
heal
autobiography
gerald
ford
working
directly
purloined
manuscript
editor
nation
produced
short
piece
entitled
ford
memoirs
behind
nixon
pardon
piece
timed
scoop
article
scheduled
shortly
appear
time
magazine
time
agreed
purchase
exclusive
right
print
prepublication
excerpts
copyright
holders
harper
row
publishers
hereinafter
harper
row
reader
digest
association
hereinafter
reader
digest
result
nation
article
time
canceled
agreement
petitioners
brought
successful
copyright
action
nation
appeal
second
circuit
reversed
lower
finding
infringement
holding
nation
act
sanctioned
fair
use
copyrighted
material
granted
certiorari
reverse
february
shortly
leaving
white
house
former
president
gerald
ford
contracted
petitioners
harper
row
reader
digest
publish
yet
unwritten
memoirs
memoirs
contain
significant
hitherto
unpublished
material
concerning
watergate
crisis
ford
pardon
former
president
nixon
ford
reflections
period
history
morality
personalities
involved
app
pet
cert
addition
right
publish
ford
memoirs
book
form
agreement
gave
petitioners
exclusive
right
license
prepublication
excerpts
known
trade
first
serial
rights
two
years
later
memoirs
nearing
completion
petitioners
negotiated
prepublication
licensing
agreement
time
weekly
news
magazine
time
agreed
pay
advance
additional
publication
exchange
right
excerpt
words
ford
account
nixon
pardon
issue
featuring
excerpts
timed
appear
approximately
one
week
shipment
full
length
book
version
bookstores
exclusivity
important
consideration
harper
row
instituted
procedures
designed
maintain
confidentiality
manuscript
time
retained
right
renegotiate
second
payment
material
appear
print
prior
release
excerpts
two
three
weeks
time
article
scheduled
release
unidentified
person
secretly
brought
copy
ford
manuscript
victor
navasky
editor
nation
political
commentary
magazine
navasky
knew
possession
manuscript
authorized
manuscript
must
returned
quickly
source
avoid
discovery
supp
sdny
hastily
put
together
believed
real
hot
news
story
composed
quotes
paraphrases
facts
drawn
exclusively
manuscript
ibid
navasky
attempted
independent
commentary
research
criticism
part
need
speed
make
news
publish
ing
advance
publication
ford
book
app
article
reprinted
appendix
opinion
appeared
april
result
nation
article
time
canceled
piece
refused
pay
remaining
petitioners
brought
suit
district
southern
district
new
york
alleging
conversion
tortious
interference
contract
violations
copyright
act
bench
trial
district
judge
found
time
heal
protected
copyright
time
nation
publication
respondents
use
copyrighted
material
constituted
infringement
copyright
act
protecting
respectively
right
reproduce
work
right
license
preparation
derivative
works
right
first
distribution
copyrighted
work
public
app
pet
cert
district
rejected
respondents
argument
nation
piece
fair
use
sanctioned
act
though
billed
hot
news
article
contained
new
facts
magazine
published
article
profit
taking
heart
published
work
unauthorized
use
caused
time
agreement
aborted
thus
diminished
value
copyright
although
certain
elements
ford
memoirs
historical
facts
memoranda
per
se
copyrightable
district
held
totality
facts
memoranda
collected
together
ford
reflections
made
value
nation
totality
protected
copyright
laws
awarded
actual
damages
divided
panel
appeals
second
circuit
reversed
majority
recognized
ford
verbatim
reflections
original
expression
protected
copyright
held
district
erred
assuming
coupling
reflections
uncopyrightable
fact
transformed
information
copyrighted
totality
majority
noted
copyright
attaches
expression
facts
ideas
concluded
avoid
granting
copyright
monopoly
facts
underlying
history
news
expression
works
must
confined
barest
elements
ordering
choice
words
thus
similarities
original
challenged
work
traceable
copying
paraphrasing
uncopyrightable
material
historical
facts
memoranda
public
documents
quoted
remarks
third
parties
must
disregarded
evaluating
whether
second
author
use
fair
infringing
uncopyrighted
material
stripped
away
article
nation
contains
approximately
words
copyrighted
remaining
paragraphs
scattered
phrases
verbatim
quotations
memoirs
appeared
previously
publications
include
short
segment
ford
conversations
henry
kissinger
several
individuals
ford
impressionistic
depictions
nixon
ill
phlebitis
resignation
pardon
nixon
character
constitute
major
portion
material
parts
magazine
piece
must
focus
examination
question
whether
fair
use
copyrighted
matter
ii
agree
appeals
copyright
intended
increase
impede
harvest
knowledge
believe
second
circuit
gave
insufficient
deference
scheme
established
copyright
act
fostering
original
works
provide
seed
substance
harvest
rights
conferred
copyright
designed
assure
contributors
store
knowledge
fair
return
labors
twentieth
century
music
aiken
article
constitution
provides
congress
shall
power
promote
progress
science
useful
arts
securing
limited
times
authors
inventors
exclusive
right
respective
writings
discoveries
section
copyright
act
confers
bundle
exclusive
rights
owner
copyright
copyright
act
rights
publish
copy
distribute
author
work
vest
author
original
work
time
creation
practice
author
commonly
sells
rights
publishers
offer
royalties
exchange
services
producing
marketing
author
work
copyright
owner
rights
however
subject
certain
statutory
exceptions
among
codifies
traditional
privilege
authors
make
fair
use
earlier
writer
work
addition
author
may
copyright
facts
ideas
copyright
limited
aspects
work
termed
expression
display
stamp
author
originality
creation
nonfiction
work
even
compilation
pure
fact
entails
originality
see
schroeder
william
morrow
copyright
gardening
directory
cf
lithographic
sarony
originator
photograph
may
claim
copyright
work
copyright
holders
time
heal
complied
relevant
statutory
notice
registration
procedures
see
app
pet
cert
thus
dispute
unpublished
manuscript
time
heal
whole
protected
unauthorized
reproduction
respondents
dispute
verbatim
copying
excerpts
manuscript
original
form
expression
constitute
infringement
unless
excused
fair
use
see
nimmer
copyright
hereinafter
nimmer
yet
copyright
prevent
subsequent
users
copying
prior
author
work
constituent
elements
original
example
quotations
borrowed
rubric
fair
use
copyrighted
works
facts
materials
public
domain
long
use
unfairly
appropriate
author
original
contributions
ibid
latman
fair
use
copyrighted
works
reprinted
study
copyright
law
revision
studies
nos
prepared
senate
committee
judiciary
hereinafter
latman
perhaps
controversy
lower
courts
case
copyrightability
aptly
styled
dispute
whether
nation
appropriation
unoriginal
uncopyrightable
elements
encroached
originality
embodied
work
whole
especially
realm
factual
narrative
law
currently
unsettled
regarding
ways
uncopyrightable
elements
combine
author
original
contributions
form
protected
expression
compare
wainwright
securities
wall
street
transcript
protection
accorded
author
analysis
structuring
material
marshaling
facts
hoehling
universal
city
studios
limiting
protection
ordering
choice
words
see
nimmer
need
reach
issues
however
nation
admitted
lifting
verbatim
quotes
author
original
language
totaling
words
constituting
nation
article
using
generous
verbatim
excerpts
ford
unpublished
manuscript
lend
authenticity
account
forthcoming
memoirs
nation
effectively
arrogated
right
first
publication
important
marketable
subsidiary
right
reasons
set
forth
find
use
copyrighted
manuscript
even
stripped
verbatim
quotes
conceded
nation
copyrightable
expression
fair
use
within
meaning
copyright
act
iii
fair
use
traditionally
defined
privilege
others
owner
copyright
use
copyrighted
material
reasonable
manner
without
consent
ball
law
copyright
literary
property
hereinafter
ball
statutory
formulation
defense
fair
use
copyright
act
reflects
intent
congress
codify
doctrine
nimmer
section
requires
determination
whether
particular
use
fair
statute
notes
four
nonexclusive
factors
considered
approach
intended
restate
judicial
doctrine
fair
use
change
narrow
enlarge
way
hereinafter
house
report
author
consent
reasonable
use
copyrighted
works
ha
always
implied
courts
necessary
incident
constitutional
policy
promoting
progress
science
useful
arts
since
prohibition
use
inhibit
subsequent
writers
attempting
improve
upon
prior
works
thus
frustrate
ends
sought
attained
ball
professor
latman
study
doctrine
fair
use
commissioned
congress
revision
effort
see
sony
america
universal
city
studios
dissenting
opinion
summarized
prior
law
turning
importance
material
copied
performed
point
view
reasonable
copyright
owner
words
reasonable
copyright
owner
consented
use
latman
reviewer
may
fairly
cite
largely
original
work
design
really
truly
use
passages
purposes
fair
reasonable
criticism
hand
clear
thus
cites
important
parts
work
view
criticise
supersede
use
original
work
substitute
review
use
deemed
law
piracy
folsom
marsh
cas
cc
mass
perhaps
fair
use
doctrine
predicated
author
implied
consent
reasonable
customary
use
released
work
public
consumption
fair
use
traditionally
recognized
defense
charges
copying
author
yet
unpublished
works
copyright
property
author
intellectual
creation
absolute
voluntarily
part
ed
american
tobacco
werckmeister
nimmer
absolute
rule
however
tempered
practice
equitable
nature
fair
use
doctrine
given
case
factors
implied
consent
de
facto
publication
performance
dissemination
work
may
tip
balance
equities
favor
prepublication
use
see
copyright
law
revision
part
discussion
comments
report
register
copyrights
general
revision
copyright
law
comm
print
discussion
suggesting
works
disseminated
public
form
constituting
technical
publication
nevertheless
subject
fair
use
nimmer
never
seriously
disputed
fact
plaintiff
work
unpublished
factor
tending
negate
defense
fair
use
ibid
publication
author
expression
authorized
dissemination
seriously
infringes
author
right
decide
whether
made
public
factor
present
fair
use
published
works
respondents
contend
however
congress
including
first
publication
among
rights
enumerated
expressly
subject
fair
use
intended
fair
use
apply
pari
materia
published
unpublished
works
copyright
act
support
proposition
copyright
act
represents
culmination
major
legislative
reexamination
copyright
doctrine
see
mills
music
snyder
sony
america
universal
city
studios
dissenting
opinion
among
innovations
eliminated
publication
dividing
line
common
law
statutory
protection
house
report
extending
statutory
protection
works
time
creation
also
recognized
first
time
distinct
statutory
right
first
publication
previously
element
protections
afforded
unpublished
works
report
house
committee
judiciary
confirms
clause
section
establishes
exclusive
right
publications
provision
copyright
owner
right
control
first
public
distribution
authorized
copy
work
though
right
first
publication
like
rights
enumerated
expressly
made
subject
fair
use
provision
fair
use
analysis
must
always
tailored
individual
case
nimmer
nature
interest
stake
highly
relevant
whether
given
use
fair
beginning
entrusted
task
revision
recognized
overbalancing
reasons
preserve
common
law
protection
undisseminated
works
author
successor
chooses
disclose
copyright
law
revision
report
register
copyrights
general
revision
copyright
law
comm
print
right
first
publication
implicates
threshold
decision
author
whether
form
release
work
first
publication
inherently
different
rights
one
person
first
publisher
contract
time
illustrates
commercial
value
right
lies
primarily
exclusivity
potential
damage
author
judicially
enforced
sharing
first
publication
right
unauthorized
users
manuscript
substantial
balance
equities
evaluating
claim
fair
use
inevitably
shifts
senate
report
confirms
congress
intended
unpublished
nature
work
figure
prominently
fair
use
analysis
discussing
fair
use
photocopied
materials
classroom
committee
report
key
though
necessarily
determinative
factor
fair
use
whether
work
available
potential
user
work
print
unavailable
purchase
normal
channels
user
may
justification
reproducing
applicability
fair
use
doctrine
unpublished
works
narrowly
limited
since
although
work
unavailable
result
deliberate
choice
part
copyright
owner
ordinary
circumstances
copyright
owner
right
first
publication
outweigh
needs
reproduction
classroom
purposes
senate
report
even
legislative
history
entirely
silent
bound
conclude
congress
characterization
restatement
effect
preserve
existing
law
concerning
fair
use
unpublished
works
types
protected
works
change
narrow
enlarge
conclude
unpublished
nature
work
key
though
necessarily
determinative
factor
tending
negate
defense
fair
use
senate
report
see
nimmer
patry
fair
use
privilege
copyright
law
hereinafter
patry
also
find
unpersuasive
respondents
argument
fair
use
may
made
manuscript
ground
author
demonstrated
interest
nonpublication
argument
assumes
unpublished
nature
copyrighted
material
relevant
letters
confidential
writings
intended
dissemination
true
copyright
often
enlisted
service
personal
privacy
see
brandeis
warren
right
privacy
harv
rev
commercial
guise
however
author
right
choose
publish
less
deserving
protection
period
encompassing
work
initiation
preparation
grooming
public
dissemination
crucial
one
literary
endeavor
copyright
act
accords
copyright
owner
right
control
first
public
distribution
work
house
report
echos
common
law
concern
author
copyright
owner
retain
control
throughout
critical
stage
see
generally
comment
stage
publication
fair
use
factor
harper
row
publishers
nation
enterprises
john
rev
obvious
benefit
author
public
alike
assuring
authors
leisure
develop
ideas
free
fear
expropriation
outweighs
news
value
gained
premature
publication
author
expression
see
goldstein
copyright
first
amendment
colum
rev
absolute
protection
common
law
accorded
published
works
justified
brevity
expedience
author
control
first
public
distribution
implicates
personal
interest
creative
control
property
interest
exploitation
prepublication
rights
valuable
serve
valuable
adjunct
publicity
marketing
see
belushi
woodward
supp
dc
successful
marketing
depends
coordination
serialization
release
public
marks
subsidiary
rights
permissions
happens
book
publishing
grannis
ed
exploitation
subsidiary
rights
necessary
financial
success
new
books
ordinary
circumstances
author
right
control
first
public
appearance
undisseminated
expression
outweigh
claim
fair
use
respondents
however
contend
first
amendment
values
require
different
rule
circumstances
case
thrust
decision
scope
fair
use
undoubtedly
wider
information
conveyed
relates
matters
high
public
concern
consumers
union
general
signal
construing
case
allowing
advertiser
quote
consumer
reports
cert
denied
respondents
advance
substantial
public
import
subject
matter
ford
memoirs
grounds
excusing
use
ordinarily
pass
muster
fair
use
piracy
verbatim
quotations
purpose
scooping
authorized
first
serialization
respondents
explain
copying
ford
expression
essential
reporting
news
story
claims
book
represents
respondents
view
facts
contained
ford
memoirs
precise
manner
expressed
newsworthy
say
brief
respondents
respondents
argue
public
interest
learning
news
fast
possible
outweighs
right
author
control
first
publication
second
circuit
noted
correctly
copyright
dichotomy
strike
definitional
balance
first
amendment
copyright
act
permitting
free
communication
facts
still
protecting
author
expression
author
may
copyright
ideas
facts
narrates
see
new
york
times
brennan
concurring
copyright
laws
restrictions
freedom
speech
copyright
protects
form
expression
ideas
expressed
nimmer
long
ago
observed
news
element
information
respecting
current
events
contained
literary
production
creation
writer
report
matters
ordinarily
publici
juris
history
day
international
news
service
associated
press
copyright
assures
write
publish
factual
narratives
time
heal
may
least
enjoy
right
market
original
expression
contained
therein
compensation
investment
cf
zacchini
broadcasting
respondents
theory
however
expand
fair
use
effectively
destroy
expectation
copyright
protection
work
public
figure
absent
protection
little
incentive
create
profit
financing
memoirs
public
denied
important
source
significant
historical
information
promise
copyright
empty
one
avoided
merely
dubbing
infringement
fair
use
news
report
book
see
wainwright
securities
wall
street
transcript
cert
denied
respondents
assert
actual
necessity
circumventing
copyright
scheme
respect
types
works
users
issue
author
publisher
invested
extensive
resources
creating
original
work
poised
release
public
legitimate
aim
served
right
first
publication
fact
words
author
chosen
clothe
narrative
may
newsworthy
independent
justification
unauthorized
copying
author
expression
prior
publication
paraphrase
another
recent
second
circuit
decision
respondent
possessed
unfettered
right
use
factual
information
revealed
memoirs
purpose
enlightening
audience
claim
need
bodily
appropriate
ford
expression
information
utilizing
portions
actual
manuscript
public
interest
free
flow
information
assured
law
refusal
recognize
valid
copyright
facts
fair
use
doctrine
license
corporate
theft
empowering
ignore
copyright
whenever
determines
underlying
work
contains
material
possible
public
importance
iowa
state
university
research
foundation
american
broadcasting
citations
omitted
haste
disseminate
news
forgotten
framers
intended
copyright
engine
free
expression
establishing
marketable
right
use
one
expression
copyright
supplies
economic
incentive
create
disseminate
ideas
stated
mazer
stein
economic
philosophy
behind
clause
empowering
congress
grant
patents
copyrights
conviction
encouragement
individual
effort
personal
gain
best
way
advance
public
welfare
talents
authors
inventors
science
useful
arts
immediate
effect
copyright
law
secure
fair
return
author
creative
labor
ultimate
aim
incentive
stimulate
creation
useful
works
general
public
good
moreover
freedom
thought
expression
includes
right
speak
freely
right
refrain
speaking
wooley
maynard
burger
suggest
right
speak
sanction
abuse
copyright
owner
monopoly
instrument
suppress
facts
words
new
york
chief
judge
fuld
essential
thrust
first
amendment
prohibit
improper
restraints
voluntary
public
expression
ideas
shields
man
wants
speak
publish
others
wish
quiet
necessarily
within
suitably
defined
areas
concomitant
freedom
speak
publicly
one
serves
ultimate
end
freedom
speech
affirmative
aspect
estate
hemingway
random
house
view
first
amendment
protections
already
embodied
copyright
act
distinction
copyrightable
expression
uncopyrightable
facts
ideas
latitude
scholarship
comment
traditionally
afforded
fair
use
see
warrant
expanding
doctrine
fair
use
create
amounts
public
figure
exception
copyright
whether
verbatim
copying
public
figure
manuscript
given
case
fair
must
judged
according
traditional
equities
fair
use
iv
fair
use
mixed
question
law
fact
pacific
southern
duncan
district
found
facts
sufficient
evaluate
statutory
factors
appellate
need
remand
factfinding
may
conclude
matter
law
challenged
use
es
qualify
fair
use
copyrighted
work
thus
whether
nation
article
constitutes
fair
use
must
reviewed
light
principles
discussed
factors
enumerated
section
meant
exclusive
ince
doctrine
equitable
rule
reason
generally
applicable
definition
possible
case
raising
question
must
decided
facts
house
report
four
factors
identified
congress
especially
relevant
determining
whether
use
fair
purpose
character
use
nature
copyrighted
work
substantiality
portion
used
relation
copyrighted
work
whole
effect
potential
market
value
copyrighted
work
address
one
separately
purpose
use
second
circuit
correctly
identified
news
reporting
general
purpose
nation
use
news
reporting
one
examples
enumerated
give
idea
sort
activities
courts
might
regard
fair
use
circumstances
senate
report
listing
intended
exhaustive
see
ibid
definition
including
single
particular
use
presumptively
fair
use
drafters
resisted
pressures
special
interest
groups
create
presumptive
categories
fair
use
structured
provision
affirmative
defense
requiring
analysis
see
patry
hether
use
referred
first
sentence
section
fair
use
particular
case
depend
upon
application
determinative
factors
including
mentioned
second
sentence
senate
report
fact
article
arguably
news
therefore
productive
use
simply
one
factor
fair
use
analysis
agree
second
circuit
trial
erred
fixing
whether
information
contained
memoirs
actually
new
public
judge
meskill
wisely
noted
ourts
chary
deciding
news
dissenting
cf
gertz
robert
welch
issue
constitutes
news
whether
claim
newsreporting
valid
fair
use
defense
infringement
copyrightable
expression
patry
nation
every
right
seek
first
publish
information
nation
went
beyond
simply
reporting
uncopyrightable
information
actively
sought
exploit
headline
value
infringement
making
news
event
unauthorized
first
publication
noted
figure
copyrighted
expression
fact
publication
commercial
opposed
nonprofit
separate
factor
tends
weigh
finding
fair
use
commercial
use
copyrighted
material
presumptively
unfair
exploitation
monopoly
privilege
belongs
owner
copyright
sony
america
universal
city
studios
arguing
purpose
news
reporting
purely
commercial
nation
misses
point
entirely
crux
distinction
whether
sole
motive
use
monetary
gain
whether
user
stands
profit
exploitation
copyrighted
material
without
paying
customary
price
see
roy
export
co
establishment
columbia
broadcasting
system
nimmer
evaluating
character
purpose
ignore
nation
stated
purpose
scooping
forthcoming
time
abstracts
app
pet
cert
nation
use
merely
incidental
effect
intended
purpose
supplanting
copyright
holder
commercially
valuable
right
first
publication
see
meredith
harper
row
publishers
supp
sdny
purpose
text
compete
original
aff
also
relevant
character
use
propriety
defendant
conduct
nimmer
fair
use
presupposes
good
faith
fair
dealing
time
bernard
geis
associates
supp
sdny
quoting
schulman
fair
use
revision
copyright
act
iowa
rev
trial
found
nation
knowingly
exploited
purloined
manuscript
app
pet
cert
unlike
typical
claim
fair
use
nation
offer
even
fiction
consent
justification
like
competitor
free
bid
right
abstracting
excerpts
time
heal
fair
use
distinguishes
true
scholar
chiseler
infringes
work
personal
profit
wainwright
securities
wall
street
transcript
quoting
hearings
bills
general
revision
copyright
law
house
committee
judiciary
ser
pt
statement
john
schulman
nature
copyrighted
work
second
act
directs
attention
nature
copyrighted
work
time
heal
may
characterized
unpublished
historical
narrative
autobiography
law
generally
recognizes
greater
need
disseminate
factual
works
works
fiction
fantasy
see
gorman
fact
fancy
implications
copyright
copyright
soc
ven
within
field
fact
works
gradations
relative
proportion
fact
fancy
one
may
move
sparsely
embellished
maps
directories
elegantly
written
biography
extent
one
must
permit
expressive
language
copied
order
assure
dissemination
underlying
facts
thus
vary
case
case
fact
work
unpublished
critical
element
nature
nimmer
comment
john
prior
discussion
establishes
scope
fair
use
narrower
respect
unpublished
works
even
substantial
quotations
might
qualify
fair
use
review
published
work
news
account
speech
delivered
public
disseminated
press
see
house
report
author
right
control
first
public
appearance
expression
weighs
use
work
release
right
first
publication
encompasses
choice
whether
publish
also
choices
form
first
publish
work
case
ford
manuscript
copyright
holders
interest
confidentiality
irrefutable
copyright
holders
entered
contractual
undertaking
keep
manuscript
confidential
required
manuscript
shown
also
sign
agreement
keep
manuscript
confidential
app
pet
cert
copyright
holders
contract
time
required
time
submit
proposed
article
seven
days
publication
nation
clandestine
publication
afforded
opportunity
creative
quality
control
hastily
patched
together
contained
number
inaccuracies
app
testimony
victor
navasky
use
clearly
infringes
copyright
holder
interests
confidentiality
creative
control
difficult
characterize
fair
amount
substantiality
portion
used
next
act
directs
us
examine
amount
substantiality
portion
used
relation
copyrighted
work
whole
absolute
terms
words
actually
quoted
insubstantial
portion
time
heal
district
however
found
nation
took
essentially
heart
book
believe
appeals
erred
overruling
district
judge
evaluation
qualitative
nature
taking
see
roy
export
co
establishment
columbia
broadcasting
system
taking
seconds
hour
film
deemed
qualitatively
substantial
time
editor
described
chapters
pardon
interesting
moving
parts
entire
manuscript
reply
brief
petitioners
portions
actually
quoted
selected
navasky
among
powerful
passages
chapters
testified
used
verbatim
excerpts
simply
reciting
information
adequately
convey
absolute
certainty
ford
expressed
app
show
comes
president
ford
carry
definitive
quality
original
short
quoted
passages
precisely
qualitatively
embodied
ford
distinctive
expression
statutory
language
indicates
taking
may
excused
merely
insubstantial
respect
infringing
work
judge
learned
hand
cogently
remarked
plagiarist
excuse
wrong
showing
much
work
pirate
sheldon
pictures
cert
denied
conversely
fact
substantial
portion
infringing
work
copied
verbatim
evidence
qualitative
value
copied
material
originator
plagiarist
seeks
profit
marketing
someone
else
copyrighted
expression
stripped
verbatim
quotes
direct
takings
unpublished
manuscript
constitute
least
infringing
article
see
meeropol
nizer
copyrighted
letters
constituted
less
infringing
work
prominently
featured
nation
article
structured
around
quoted
excerpts
serve
dramatic
focal
points
see
appendix
opinion
post
view
expressive
value
excerpts
key
role
infringing
work
agree
second
circuit
magazine
took
meager
indeed
infinitesimal
amount
ford
original
language
effect
market
finally
act
focuses
effect
use
upon
potential
market
value
copyrighted
work
last
factor
undoubtedly
single
important
element
fair
use
see
nimmer
cases
cited
therein
fair
use
properly
applied
limited
copying
others
materially
impair
marketability
work
copied
nimmer
trial
found
merely
potential
actual
effect
market
time
cancellation
projected
serialization
refusal
pay
direct
effect
infringement
appeals
rejected
factfinding
clearly
erroneous
noting
record
establish
causal
relation
time
nonperformance
respondents
unauthorized
publication
ford
expression
opposed
facts
taken
memoirs
disagree
rarely
case
copyright
infringement
present
evidence
actual
damage
petitioners
assured
time
authorized
publication
portion
unpublished
manuscript
prior
april
publication
material
chapters
permit
time
renegotiate
final
payment
time
cited
nation
article
contained
verbatim
quotes
unpublished
manuscript
reason
nonperformance
respect
apportionment
profits
flowing
copyright
infringement
held
infringer
commingles
infringing
noninfringing
elements
must
abide
consequences
unless
make
separation
profits
assure
injured
party
justly
belongs
sheldon
pictures
cf
infringer
required
prove
elements
profits
attributable
infringed
work
similarly
copyright
holder
establishes
reasonable
probability
existence
causal
connection
infringement
loss
revenue
burden
properly
shifts
infringer
show
damage
occurred
taking
copyrighted
expression
see
nimmer
petitioners
established
prima
facie
case
actual
damage
respondents
failed
rebut
see
stevens
linen
associates
mastercraft
trial
properly
awarded
actual
damages
accounting
profits
see
important
negate
fair
use
one
need
show
challenged
use
become
widespread
adversely
affect
potential
market
copyrighted
work
sony
america
universal
city
studios
emphasis
added
collecting
cases
dissenting
opinion
inquiry
must
take
account
harm
original
also
harm
market
derivative
works
see
iowa
state
university
research
foundation
american
broadcasting
meeropol
nizer
supra
roy
export
columbia
broadcasting
system
defendant
work
adversely
affects
value
rights
copyrighted
work
case
adaptation
serialization
right
use
fair
nimmer
omitted
undisputed
factual
material
balance
nation
article
besides
verbatim
quotes
issue
drawn
exclusively
chapters
pardon
excerpts
employed
featured
episodes
story
nixon
pardon
precisely
use
petitioners
licensed
time
borrowing
verbatim
quotes
unpublished
manuscript
lent
nation
piece
special
air
authenticity
navasky
expressed
reader
know
ford
speaking
nation
app
thus
directly
competed
share
market
prepublication
excerpts
senate
report
certain
special
exceptions
use
supplants
part
normal
market
copyrighted
work
ordinarily
considered
infringement
senate
report
appeals
erred
concluding
nation
use
copyrighted
material
excused
public
interest
subject
matter
erred
well
overlooking
unpublished
nature
work
resulting
impact
potential
market
first
serial
rights
permitting
unauthorized
prepublication
excerpts
rubric
fair
use
finally
finding
taking
infinitesimal
appeals
accorded
little
weight
qualitative
importance
quoted
passages
original
expression
sum
traditional
doctrine
fair
use
embodied
copyright
act
sanction
use
made
nation
copyrighted
materials
copyright
infringer
may
claim
benefit
public
increasing
public
access
copyrighted
work
see
pacific
southern
duncan
congress
designed
see
warrant
judicially
imposing
compulsory
license
permitting
unfettered
access
unpublished
copyrighted
expression
public
figures
nation
conceded
verbatim
copying
words
direct
quotation
ford
manuscript
constitute
infringement
unless
excused
fair
use
find
nation
use
verbatim
excerpts
unpublished
manuscript
fair
use
judgment
appeals
reversed
case
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
appendix
opinion
ford
memoirs
behind
nixon
pardon
ford
also
writes
misunderstanding
might
selected
ronald
reagan
running
mate
washington
lawyer
edward
bennett
williams
democrat
choice
head
central
intelligence
agency
nixon
one
first
proposed
rockefeller
vice
president
regretted
cowardice
allowing
rockefeller
remove
vice
presidential
contention
ford
also
describes
often
prickly
relations
henry
kissinger
nation
obtained
typescript
publication
advance
excerpts
book
appear
time
reader
digest
thereafter
although
initial
print
order
decided
figure
tentatively
set
change
depending
upon
public
reaction
serialization
ford
account
nixon
pardon
contains
significant
new
detail
negotiations
considerations
surrounded
according
ford
version
subject
first
broached
general
haig
august
week
nixon
resigned
general
haig
revealed
newly
transcribed
white
house
tapes
equivalent
smoking
gun
ford
prepare
become
president
ford
deeply
hurt
haig
revelation
past
several
months
nixon
repeatedly
assured
involved
watergate
evidence
prove
innocence
matter
fade
view
ford
believed
let
haig
explain
president
alternatives
ride
resign
haig
said
listed
different
ways
nixon
might
resign
concluded
pointing
nixon
agree
leave
return
agreement
new
president
ford
pardon
although
ford
said
improper
make
recommendation
basically
agreed
haig
assessment
adds
references
pardon
authority
ask
haig
extent
president
pardon
power
understanding
white
house
lawyer
haig
replied
president
authority
grant
pardon
even
criminal
action
taken
individual
ford
consulted
white
house
special
counsel
james
clair
advice
one
way
matter
pointing
lawyer
given
haig
opinion
pardon
ford
also
discussed
matter
jack
marsh
felt
mention
pardon
context
time
bomb
bryce
harlow
served
six
presidents
agreed
mere
mention
pardon
cause
lot
trouble
result
various
conversations
vice
president
ford
called
haig
read
written
statement
want
understand
intention
recommending
president
resigning
resigning
nothing
talked
yesterday
afternoon
given
consideration
whatever
decision
president
may
wish
make
despite
haig
told
smoking
gun
tapes
ford
told
jackson
luncheon
audience
later
day
president
guilty
impeachable
offense
said
otherwise
moment
writes
whole
house
cards
might
collapsed
justifying
pardon
ford
goes
way
assure
reader
compassion
nixon
individual
prompted
decision
rather
get
monkey
back
one
way
precipitating
factor
decision
series
secret
meetings
general
counsel
phil
buchen
held
watergate
special
prosecutor
leon
jaworski
jefferson
hotel
staying
time
ford
attributes
jaworski
providing
crucial
information
nixon
investigation
ten
separate
areas
process
take
years
ford
cites
memorandum
jaworski
assistant
henry
ruth
especially
persuasive
ruth
written
decide
recommend
indictment
think
fair
proper
notify
jack
miller
white
house
sufficiently
advance
pardon
action
taken
indictment
went
say
one
make
strong
argument
leniency
president
ford
inclined
think
early
rather
late
buchen
haig
henry
kissinger
agreed
hartmann
sure
buchen
wanted
condition
pardon
nixon
agreeing
settle
question
retain
custody
control
tapes
presidential
papers
might
relevant
various
watergate
proceedings
ford
reluctant
one
point
plan
considered
whereby
presidential
materials
kept
vault
federal
facility
near
san
clemente
vault
require
two
keys
open
one
retained
general
services
administration
richard
nixon
white
house
however
want
nixon
make
full
confession
occasion
pardon
minimum
express
true
contrition
ford
tells
negotiation
jack
miller
nixon
lawyer
wording
nixon
statement
ford
reports
miller
response
nixon
likely
yield
meetings
client
shown
former
president
ability
discuss
watergate
objectively
almost
nonexistent
statement
really
wanted
never
forthcoming
soon
ford
emissary
arrived
san
clemente
confronted
ultimatum
ron
zeigler
nixon
former
press
secretary
lets
get
one
thing
straight
immediately
zeigler
said
president
nixon
issuing
statement
whatsoever
regarding
watergate
whether
jerry
ford
pardons
zeigler
proposed
draft
turned
ground
statement
better
went
three
drafts
agreed
statement
nixon
finally
made
stopped
far
short
full
confession
ford
aide
benton
becker
tried
explain
nixon
acceptance
pardon
admission
guilt
felt
president
really
listening
instead
nixon
wanted
talk
washington
redskins
becker
left
nixon
pressed
cuff
links
tiepin
jewelry
box
ultimately
ford
sums
philosophy
underlying
decision
one
picked
student
yale
law
school
many
years
learned
public
policy
often
took
precedence
rule
law
although
respected
tenet
man
law
public
policy
demanded
put
nixon
watergate
behind
us
quickly
possible
later
ford
learned
nixon
phlebitis
acted
health
seriously
impaired
debated
whether
pay
ailing
former
president
visit
made
trip
remind
everybody
watergate
pardon
people
say
lacked
compassion
ford
went
stretched
flat
back
tubes
nose
mouth
wires
led
arms
chest
legs
machines
orange
lights
blinked
face
ashen
thought
never
seen
anyone
closer
death
manuscript
made
available
nation
includes
many
references
henry
kissinger
personalities
played
major
role
ford
years
kissinger
immediately
informed
nixon
intention
resign
ford
returned
executive
office
building
phoned
henry
kissinger
let
know
felt
henry
said
need
country
needs
want
stay
everything
work
sir
kissinger
replied
job
get
along
get
along
get
along
ford
said
know
get
along
referring
kissinger
joint
jobs
secretary
state
national
security
adviser
president
ford
said
want
make
change
think
worked
well
let
keep
way
john
connally
ford
informed
nixon
wanted
replace
agnew
told
president
ambition
hold
office
january
nixon
replied
good
since
choice
running
mate
john
connally
excellent
observed
nixon
ford
says
problem
decision
run
ford
tells
us
sincere
intention
run
thought
announce
enhance
credibility
country
congress
well
keep
promise
made
wife
betty
kissinger
talked
ca
disastrous
foreign
policy
point
view
next
two
half
years
foreign
governments
know
dealing
president
initiatives
dead
water
able
implement
foreign
policy
probably
consequences
dealing
congress
domestic
issues
ca
reassert
authority
presidency
leave
hanging
dead
limb
got
affirmative
president
david
kennerly
white
house
photographer
schlesinger
arguing
kissinger
ford
appropriate
response
seizure
mayaguez
issue
whether
airstrikes
cambodians
desirable
schlesinger
opposed
bombings
following
lull
conversation
ford
reports
spoke
white
house
photographer
david
kennerly
taking
pictures
last
hour
anyone
considered
kennerly
asked
might
act
local
cambodian
commander
taken
hands
stop
ship
comes
nobody
apparently
considered
following
several
seconds
silence
ford
tells
us
view
carried
day
massive
airstrikes
constitute
overkill
ford
decided
far
better
navy
jets
coral
sea
make
surgical
strikes
specific
targets
nixon
felt
disdain
democratic
leadership
house
also
regarded
weak
according
ford
pride
personal
contempt
weakness
overcome
ability
tell
difference
right
wrong
leads
ford
wonder
whether
nixon
known
advance
watergate
hearing
nixon
resignation
speech
ford
felt
lacked
adequate
plea
forgiveness
persuaded
nixon
touch
reality
february
last
year
washington
post
obtained
printed
advance
excerpts
haldeman
memoir
ends
power
eve
publication
times
books
new
york
times
called
post
feat
burglary
post
disagreed
claiming
coup
represented
enterprise
arguing
burglarized
nothing
publication
haldeman
memoir
came
fair
comment
doctrine
long
recognized
courts
fundamental
journalistic
principle
first
amendment
principle
central
pentagon
papers
case
issue
nation
dated
may
special
spring
books
number
discuss
ethical
problems
raised
issue
disclosure
footnotes
subject
sections
owner
copyright
title
exclusive
rights
authorize
following
reproduce
copyrighted
work
copies
prepare
derivative
works
based
upon
copyrighted
work
distribute
copies
copyrighted
work
public
section
notwithstanding
provisions
section
fair
use
copyrighted
work
purposes
criticism
comment
news
reporting
teaching
including
multiple
copies
classroom
use
scholarship
research
infringement
copyright
determining
whether
use
made
work
particular
case
fair
use
factors
considered
shall
include
purpose
character
use
including
whether
use
commercial
nature
nonprofit
educational
purposes
nature
copyrighted
work
amount
substantiality
portion
used
relation
copyrighted
work
whole
effect
use
upon
potential
market
value
copyrighted
work
professor
nimmer
notes
perhaps
precise
guide
stated
joseph
mcdonald
clever
paraphrase
golden
rule
take
others
extent
manner
resentful
took
nimmer
quoting
mcdonald
uses
bull
copyright
soc
equitable
rule
reason
sony
america
universal
city
studios
permits
courts
avoid
rigid
application
copyright
statute
occasion
stifle
creativity
law
designed
foster
iowa
state
university
research
foundation
american
broadcasting
see
generally
seltzer
exemptions
fair
use
copyright
see
latman
strauss
protection
unpublished
works
reprinted
study
copyright
law
revision
studies
nos
prepared
senate
committee
judiciary
citing
cases
shaw
literary
property
fair
use
unpublished
material
ball
doctrine
fair
use
apply
unpublished
works
weil
american
copyright
law
author
unpublished
work
probably
right
prevent
even
fair
use
work
others
cf
flint
user
guide
copyright
kingdom
fair
dealing
unpublished
works
beloff
pressdram
ch
see
wheaton
peters
pet
distinguishing
author
right
obtain
redress
anyone
improperly
obtaining
copy
unpublished
work
endeavors
realize
profit
publication
rights
published
work
prescribed
statute
press
publishing
monroe
writ
error
dism
stanley
columbia
broadcasting
system
cal
en
banc
golding
rko
radio
pictures
cal
app
unauthorized
appropriation
unpublished
work
neutralized
plea
little
one
aff
cal
fendler
morosco
since
plaintiff
published
produced
play
perhaps
use
others
made
might
unfair
rehearing
denied
bears
noting
congress
copyright
act
recognized
public
interest
warranting
specific
exemptions
number
areas
within
traditional
fair
use
see
compulsory
license
records
copyright
government
works
exemption
limits
copyright
personal
narratives
written
public
servants
leave
government
service
dissent
excuses
nation
unconsented
use
unpublished
manuscript
standard
journalistic
practice
taking
judicial
notice
new
york
times
articles
regarding
memoirs
john
erlichman
john
dean
blind
ambition
bernstein
woodward
final
days
proof
practice
post
amici
curiae
sought
bring
alleged
practice
attention
appeals
second
circuit
citing
articles
appeals
harper
row
motion
struck
exhibits
failure
proof
trial
record
doc
thus
proper
subject
judicial
notice
see
appendix
opinion
post
appeals
found
approximately
words
copyrightable
specify
words
discussion
however
indicates
excluded
consideration
portions
nation
piece
although
copied
verbatim
ford
manuscript
quotes
attributed
ford
third
persons
quotations
government
documents
oral
argument
counsel
nation
dispute
verbatim
quotes
close
paraphrase
constitute
infringement
tr
oral
arg
thus
appendix
identifies
potentially
infringing
verbatim
quotes
close
paraphrase
excludes
consideration
government
documents
words
attributed
third
persons
appendix
intended
endorse
particular
rule
copyrightability
intended
merely
aid
facilitate
discussion
economists
addressed
issue
believe
fair
use
exception
come
play
situations
market
fails
price
copyright
holder
ask
near
zero
see
brennan
harper
row
nation
copyrightability
fair
use
dept
justice
economic
policy
office
discussion
paper
gordon
fair
use
market
failure
structural
economic
analysis
betamax
case
predecessors
colum
rev
facts
demonstrate
fully
functioning
market
encourages
creation
dissemination
memoirs
public
figures
economists
view
permitting
fair
use
displace
normal
copyright
channels
disrupts
copyright
market
without
commensurate
public
benefit
angry
showing
cowardice
saying
going
ford
rockefeller
whatever
consequences
contained
smoking
gun
ver
past
several
months
nixon
repeatedly
assured
involved
watergate
evidence
prove
innocence
matter
fade
view
first
option
try
ride
letting
impeachment
take
natural
course
house
senate
trial
fighting
conviction
way
finally
haig
said
according
nixon
white
house
staff
nixon
agree
leave
return
agreement
new
president
gerald
ford
pardon
references
pardon
authority
ask
haig
extent
president
pardon
power
pp
finished
bryce
harlow
let
know
uncertain
terms
agreed
bob
jack
mere
mention
pardon
option
cause
lot
trouble
days
ahead
luncheon
repeated
assertion
president
guilty
impeachable
offense
said
otherwise
moment
whole
house
cards
might
collapsed
compassion
nixon
individual
prompted
decision
get
monkey
back
one
way
another
jaworski
gave
phil
several
crucial
pieces
information
verdict
guilty
one
assume
nixon
appeal
process
take
years
entire
process
doubt
require
years
minimum
two
maximum
six
nixon
spend
time
quietly
san
clemente
virtually
impossible
direct
public
attention
anything
else
miller
optimistic
getting
statement
meetings
client
shown
former
president
ability
discuss
watergate
objectively
almost
nonexistent
zeigler
asked
becker
thought
becker
replied
statement
better
years
yale
law
school
learned
public
policy
often
took
precedence
rule
law
although
respected
tenet
man
law
public
policy
demanded
put
nixon
watergate
behind
us
quickly
possible
staff
debated
whether
visit
nixon
long
beach
hospital
half
hour
away
made
trip
remind
everyone
watergate
pardon
people
say
lacked
compassion
ended
debate
soon
found
begun
course
go
stretched
flat
back
tubes
nose
mouth
wires
led
arms
chest
legs
machines
orange
lights
blinked
face
ashen
thought
never
seen
anyone
closer
death
henry
said
came
line
need
country
needs
want
stay
everything
work
get
along
said
know
get
along
talked
two
hats
wore
secretary
state
national
security
adviser
president
want
make
change
said
think
worked
well
let
keep
way
told
promise
betty
said
ambitions
hold
office
january
subjectively
felt
kennerly
said
made
lot
sense
massive
airstrikes
constitute
overkill
far
better
navy
jets
coral
sea
make
surgical
strikes
specific
targets
vicinity
kompong
som
nixon
case
flaw
pride
terribly
proud
man
detested
weakness
people
often
heard
speak
disparagingly
felt
soft
expedient
curiously
feel
press
weak
reporters
sensed
adversaries
knew
like
responded
reciprocal
disdain
pride
personal
contempt
weakness
overcome
ability
tell
difference
right
wrong
speech
lasted
fifteen
minutes
end
convinced
nixon
touch
reality
justice
brennan
justice
white
justice
marshall
join
dissenting
holds
nation
quotation
words
unpublished
manuscript
president
gerald
ford
infringed
copyright
manuscript
even
though
quotations
related
historical
event
undoubted
significance
resignation
pardon
president
richard
nixon
although
pursues
laudable
goal
protecting
economic
incentive
create
disseminate
ideas
ante
zealous
defense
copyright
owner
prerogative
fear
stifle
broad
dissemination
ideas
information
copyright
intended
nurture
protection
copyright
owner
economic
interest
achieved
case
exceedingly
narrow
definition
scope
fair
use
progress
arts
sciences
robust
public
debate
essential
enlightened
citizenry
ill
served
constricted
reading
fair
use
doctrine
see
therefore
respectfully
dissent
case
presents
two
issues
first
nation
use
material
ford
manuscript
forms
direct
quotation
manuscript
infringe
harper
row
copyright
second
quotation
approximately
words
manuscript
infringe
copyright
quotation
constitute
fair
use
within
meaning
copyright
act
finds
need
resolve
threshold
copyrightability
issue
use
words
quotation
finds
beyond
scope
fair
use
thus
copyright
infringement
disagree
fair
use
holding
necessary
decide
threshold
copyrightability
question
enactment
copyright
legislation
congress
terms
constitution
based
upon
natural
right
author
writings
upon
ground
welfare
public
served
progress
science
useful
arts
promoted
securing
authors
limited
periods
exclusive
rights
writings
congress
thus
seeks
define
rights
included
copyright
serve
public
welfare
necessarily
maximize
author
control
product
challenge
copyright
strike
difficult
balance
interests
authors
inventors
control
exploitation
writings
discoveries
one
hand
society
competing
interest
free
flow
ideas
information
commerce
hand
sony
america
universal
city
studios
supposed
framers
constitution
empowered
congress
promote
progress
science
useful
arts
securing
limited
times
authors
inventors
exclusive
right
respective
writings
discoveries
art
par
intended
confer
upon
one
might
happen
first
report
historic
event
exclusive
right
period
spread
knowledge
international
news
service
associated
press
promotion
science
useful
arts
requires
limit
scope
author
control
author
able
prevent
subsequent
authors
using
concepts
ideas
facts
contained
work
creative
process
wither
scholars
forced
unproductive
replication
research
predecessors
see
hoehling
universal
city
studios
limitation
copyright
also
ensures
consonance
important
first
amendment
values
cf
zacchini
broadcasting
profound
national
commitment
principle
debate
public
issues
uninhibited
robust
new
york
times
sullivan
leaves
room
statutory
monopoly
information
ideas
arena
public
debate
quiet
indeed
politician
copyright
speeches
philosopher
treatises
thus
obtain
monopoly
ideas
contained
lee
runge
douglas
dissenting
denial
certiorari
broad
dissemination
principles
ideas
factual
information
crucial
robust
public
debate
informed
citizenry
essence
garrison
louisiana
every
citizen
must
permitted
freely
marshal
ideas
facts
advocacy
particular
political
choices
follows
infringement
copyright
must
based
taking
literary
form
opposed
ideas
information
contained
copyrighted
work
deciding
whether
infringing
appropriation
literary
occurred
difficult
least
two
reasons
first
distinction
literary
form
information
ideas
often
elusive
practice
second
infringement
must
based
substantial
appropriation
literary
form
determination
equally
challenging
surprisingly
test
infringement
defied
precise
formulation
general
though
inquiry
proceeds
along
two
axes
closely
second
author
tracked
first
author
particular
language
structure
presentation
much
first
author
language
structure
second
author
appropriated
present
case
infringement
analysis
must
applied
historical
biography
author
chronicled
events
white
house
tenure
commented
events
unique
perspective
apart
quotations
virtually
material
nation
article
indirectly
recounted
ford
factual
narrative
nixon
resignation
pardon
reflections
events
presidency
perceptions
personalities
center
events
see
ante
copyright
claimed
information
qua
information
infringement
thus
based
close
substantial
tracking
ford
expression
information
language
much
information
nation
conveyed
form
paraphrase
took
form
synopsis
lengthy
discussions
ford
manuscript
course
summary
presentation
nation
use
occasional
sentences
closely
resembled
language
original
ford
manuscript
linguistic
similarities
insufficient
constitute
infringement
three
reasons
first
leeway
must
given
subsequent
authors
seeking
convey
facts
wishing
express
ideas
contained
factual
work
often
choose
narrow
range
expression
landsberg
scrabble
crossword
game
players
second
much
nation
paraphrased
material
harper
row
claim
copyright
third
nation
paraphrased
nothing
approximating
totality
single
paragraph
much
less
chapter
work
whole
nation
paraphrased
disparate
isolated
sentences
original
finding
infringement
based
paraphrase
generally
requires
far
close
substantial
tracking
original
language
occurred
case
see
wainwright
securities
wall
street
transcript
structure
presentation
article
mimic
ford
structure
information
nation
presents
drawn
scattered
sections
ford
work
appear
sequence
ford
presented
nation
discussion
pardon
roughly
track
order
ford
manuscript
presents
information
pardon
respect
similarity
however
ford
done
present
facts
chronologically
claim
infringement
subsequent
author
similarly
presents
facts
history
chronological
manner
also
difficult
suggest
article
bodily
appropriate
structure
book
ford
created
history
recounted
simply
represented
nation
article
nation
quoting
ford
therefore
efforts
convey
historical
information
ford
manuscript
closely
substantially
track
ford
language
structure
constitute
appropriation
literary
form
ii
nation
thus
liable
copyright
quotation
words
infringed
harper
row
exclusive
rights
act
section
explicitly
makes
grant
exclusive
rights
ubject
section
section
notwithstanding
provisions
section
fair
use
copyrighted
work
purposes
criticism
comment
news
reporting
teaching
including
multiple
copies
classroom
use
scholarship
research
infringement
copyright
question
whether
nation
quotation
noninfringing
fair
use
within
meaning
congress
eschewed
rigid
approach
fair
use
sony
america
universal
city
studios
apply
equitable
rule
reason
analysis
guided
four
statutorily
prescribed
factors
purpose
character
use
including
whether
use
commercial
nature
nonprofit
educational
purposes
nature
copyright
work
amount
substantially
portion
used
relation
copyrighted
work
whole
effect
use
upon
potential
market
value
copyrighted
work
respect
work
history
particularly
memoirs
public
official
statutorily
prescribed
analysis
properly
conducted
without
constant
attention
copyright
crucial
distinction
protected
literary
form
unprotected
information
ideas
question
must
always
subsequent
author
use
literary
form
fair
use
within
meaning
light
purpose
use
nature
copyrighted
work
amount
literary
form
used
effect
use
literary
form
value
market
original
limiting
inquiry
propriety
subsequent
author
use
copyright
owner
literary
form
easy
case
work
history
protection
substantial
appropriation
literary
form
ensure
historians
return
commensurate
full
value
labors
literary
form
contained
works
like
time
heal
reflects
part
labor
goes
book
labor
collecting
sifting
organizing
reflecting
predominates
creation
works
history
one
value
labor
produces
lies
primarily
information
ideas
revealed
particular
collocation
words
information
ideas
expressed
copyright
thus
protect
often
value
work
history
courts
must
resist
tendency
reject
fair
use
defense
basis
feeling
author
history
deprived
full
value
labor
subsequent
author
taking
information
ideas
sense
piratical
copyright
law
simply
create
property
interest
information
ideas
urge
compensate
subsequent
use
information
ideas
perhaps
understandable
inequity
seems
lurk
idea
much
fruit
historian
labor
may
used
without
compensation
however
unforeseen
byproduct
statutory
scheme
intended
primarily
ensure
return
works
imagination
congress
made
affirmative
choice
copyright
laws
apply
way
copyright
preclude
others
using
ideas
information
revealed
author
work
pertains
literary
form
author
expressed
intellectual
concepts
distinction
essence
copyright
copyright
laws
serve
engine
free
expression
ante
statutory
monopoly
choke
multifarious
indirect
uses
consequent
broad
dissemination
information
ideas
ensure
progress
arts
sciences
integrity
first
amendment
values
ideas
information
must
freighted
claims
proprietary
right
judgment
fair
use
analysis
fallen
temptation
find
copyright
violation
based
minimal
use
literary
form
order
provide
compensation
appropriation
information
work
history
failure
distinguish
information
literary
form
permeates
every
aspect
fair
use
analysis
leads
wrong
result
case
application
statutorily
prescribed
analysis
attention
distinction
information
literary
form
leads
straightforward
finding
fair
use
within
meaning
purpose
use
nation
purpose
quoting
words
ford
manuscript
acknowledges
news
reporting
see
ante
ford
work
contained
information
important
events
recent
history
two
principals
ford
general
alexander
haig
time
nation
publication
widely
thought
candidates
presidency
nation
objectively
reported
information
ford
manuscript
without
independent
commentary
way
diminishes
conclusion
reporting
news
typical
newsstory
differs
editorial
precisely
presents
newsworthy
information
straightforward
unelaborated
manner
source
information
render
nation
article
less
news
report
often
books
manuscripts
solicited
unsolicited
subject
matter
news
reports
new
york
times
frequently
manuscripts
unpublished
time
news
report
section
lists
news
reporting
prime
example
fair
use
another
expression
like
criticism
purposes
congress
explicitly
approved
news
reporting
informs
public
language
makes
clear
congress
saw
spread
knowledge
information
strongest
justification
properly
limited
appropriation
expression
appeals
therefore
correct
conclude
purpose
nation
use
dissemination
information
contained
quotations
ford
work
furthered
public
interest
light
explicit
congressional
endorsement
purpose
ford
literary
form
borrowed
strongly
favors
finding
fair
use
concedes
validity
news
reporting
purpose
quickly
offsets
three
purportedly
countervailing
considerations
first
asserts
nation
publishes
profit
publication
ford
quotes
presumptively
unfair
commercial
use
second
claims
nation
stated
desire
create
news
event
signaled
illegitimate
purpose
supplanting
copyright
owner
right
first
publication
ante
third
nation
acted
bad
faith
claims
editor
knowingly
exploited
purloined
manuscript
ante
reliance
commercial
nature
nation
use
separate
factor
tends
weigh
finding
fair
use
ante
inappropriate
present
context
many
uses
lists
paradigmatic
examples
fair
use
including
criticism
comment
news
reporting
generally
conducted
profit
country
fact
congress
obviously
aware
enacted
negate
argument
favoring
fair
use
based
news
reporting
criticism
reporting
criticism
published
profit
render
meaningless
congressional
imprimatur
placed
uses
nation
intent
create
news
event
weigh
finding
fair
use
rule
like
automatic
presumption
news
reporting
profit
undermine
congressional
validation
news
reporting
purpose
news
business
earns
reputation
therefore
readership
consistent
prompt
publication
news
often
scooping
rivals
importantly
failure
maintain
distinction
information
literary
form
colors
analysis
point
harper
row
legitimate
copyright
interest
information
ideas
ford
manuscript
nation
every
right
seek
first
disclose
facts
ideas
public
record
suggests
nation
sought
first
reveal
information
ford
manuscript
nation
stated
purpose
scooping
competition
circumstances
negative
bearing
claim
fair
use
indeed
reliance
factor
seem
amount
little
distaste
standard
journalistic
practice
seeking
first
publish
news
reliance
nation
putative
bad
faith
equally
unwarranted
found
nation
possessed
ford
manuscript
illegally
violation
interest
harper
row
causes
action
abandoned
dismissed
case
even
manuscript
purloined
someone
nothing
record
imputes
culpability
nation
basis
record
case
said
nation
made
use
contents
manuscript
knowing
copyright
owner
sanction
use
several
points
brands
conduct
thievery
see
ante
judgment
unsupportable
perhaps
influenced
unspoken
tendency
case
find
infringement
based
taking
information
ideas
respect
appropriation
information
ideas
quoted
words
nation
use
perfectly
legitimate
despite
copyright
owner
objection
copyright
claimed
ideas
information
whether
quotation
words
infringement
fair
use
within
meaning
close
question
produced
sharp
division
appeals
copyright
act
held
prohibit
use
copyright
owner
basis
law
objecting
nation
awareness
objection
significant
chance
adjudged
unfounded
amount
bad
faith
imputing
bad
faith
basis
knowledge
objection
impermissibly
prejudices
inquiry
impedes
arrival
proper
conclusion
purpose
factor
statutorily
prescribed
analysis
strongly
favors
finding
fair
use
case
nature
copyrighted
work
sony
america
universal
city
studios
stated
copyrights
fungible
opying
news
broadcast
may
stronger
claim
fair
use
copying
motion
picture
statements
reflect
principle
suggested
act
scope
fair
use
generally
broader
source
borrowed
expression
factual
historical
work
see
nimmer
nformational
works
like
ford
manuscript
readily
lend
productive
use
others
less
protected
sony
america
universal
city
studios
blackmun
dissenting
thus
second
statutory
factor
also
favors
finding
fair
use
case
acknowledges
law
generally
recognizes
greater
need
disseminate
factual
works
works
fiction
fantasy
ante
ome
briefer
quotations
memoir
arguably
necessary
convey
facts
ibid
discounts
force
consideration
primarily
ground
fact
work
unpublished
crucial
element
nature
ante
point
introduces
analysis
case
categorical
presumption
prepublication
fair
use
see
ante
ordinary
circumstances
author
right
control
first
public
appearance
undisseminated
expression
outweigh
claim
fair
use
categorical
presumption
unwarranted
terms
unfaithful
congressional
intent
whether
particular
prepublication
use
impair
interest
identifies
encompassed
within
right
first
publication
see
ante
depend
nature
copyrighted
work
timing
prepublication
use
amount
expression
used
medium
second
author
communicates
also
certain
uses
might
tolerable
purposes
others
see
sony
america
universal
city
studios
supra
ambiguous
whether
relies
force
presumption
prepublication
fair
use
analysis
purpose
effect
particular
use
compare
ante
ante
extent
relies
presumption
presumes
intolerable
injury
particular
usurpation
economic
interest
based
quick
litmus
test
prepublication
timing
congress
plainly
instructed
us
fair
use
analysis
calls
sensitive
balancing
interests
held
last
term
fair
use
inquiry
never
resolved
basis
two
dimensional
categorical
approach
see
sony
america
universal
city
studios
rejecting
categorical
requirement
productive
use
extent
purports
evaluate
facts
case
analysis
relies
sheer
speculation
quotation
words
manuscript
infringed
privacy
interest
ford
author
intended
words
manuscript
public
statement
presidency
lacking
therefore
deliberate
choice
part
copyright
owner
keep
expression
confidential
consideration
senate
report
passage
places
great
reliance
see
ante
recognized
impetus
behind
narrowing
fair
use
unpublished
works
see
see
also
nimmer
scope
fair
use
doctrine
considerably
narrower
respect
unpublished
works
held
confidential
copyright
owners
emphasis
added
depicts
copyright
owner
confidentiality
interest
see
ante
privacy
interest
rather
economic
interest
capturing
full
value
initial
release
information
public
properly
analyzed
see
infra
lacking
suggestion
nation
use
interfered
copyright
owner
interest
editorial
control
manuscript
nation
made
use
ford
quotes
eve
official
publication
thus
interest
nation
prepublication
use
might
infringed
copyright
owner
interest
capturing
full
economic
value
initial
release
considering
interest
component
nature
copyrighted
work
analysis
deflates
nation
claim
informational
nature
work
supports
fair
use
without
inquiry
actual
potential
economic
harm
nation
particular
prepublication
use
reason
question
economic
harm
properly
considered
fourth
statutory
factor
effect
value
market
copyrighted
work
presumed
element
nature
copyright
amount
substantiality
portion
used
difficult
questions
arise
respect
judgments
importance
case
amount
substantiality
quotations
used
nation
quoted
approximately
words
manuscript
words
quotes
drawn
isolated
passages
disparate
sections
work
judgment
taking
quantitatively
infinitesimal
dispose
inquiry
however
evaluation
substantiality
qualitative
terms
also
required
much
quoted
material
ford
representation
words
others
conversations
quotations
arguably
necessary
adequately
convey
facts
ante
rich
expressive
content
beyond
quotations
portion
quoted
material
drawn
poignant
expression
ford
manuscript
particular
nation
made
use
six
examples
ford
expression
reflections
events
perceptions
president
nixon
fair
use
inquiry
turns
propriety
use
quotations
admittedly
strong
expressive
content
holds
view
expressive
value
excerpts
key
role
infringing
work
third
statutory
factor
disfavors
finding
fair
use
support
conclusion
purports
rely
district
factual
findings
nation
taken
heart
book
supp
sdny
reliance
misplaced
appear
another
result
failure
distinguish
information
literary
form
district
made
finding
evaluating
quoted
words
issue
totality
information
reflective
commentary
ford
work
ibid
vast
majority
district
considered
heart
ford
work
therefore
consisted
ideas
information
nation
free
use
may
well
qualitative
matter
value
manuscript
lie
information
ideas
nation
used
appropriation
heart
manuscript
sense
irrelevant
copyright
analysis
copyright
preclude
second
author
use
information
ideas
perhaps
tacitly
recognizing
reliance
district
finding
unjustifiable
goes
evaluate
independently
quality
expression
appearing
nation
article
portions
actually
quoted
selected
navasky
among
powerful
passages
ante
basis
observation
perhaps
also
inference
fact
quotes
important
nation
article
adheres
conclusion
nation
appropriated
heart
ford
manuscript
least
respect
six
particular
quotes
ford
observations
reflections
president
nixon
agree
conclusion
nation
appropriated
literary
form
substantial
quality
agree
however
substantiality
expression
taken
clearly
excessive
inappropriate
nation
news
reporting
purpose
quotations
used
context
critical
book
review
ford
work
little
question
use
fair
use
within
meaning
act
amount
substantiality
use
quantitative
qualitative
terms
certainly
appropriate
purpose
use
difficult
see
use
quoted
words
news
report
less
appropriate
acknowledges
much
ven
substantial
quotations
might
qualify
fair
use
review
published
work
news
account
speech
delivered
public
see
ante
respect
motivation
pardon
insights
psyche
fallen
president
example
ford
reflections
perceptions
laden
emotion
deeply
personal
value
judgments
full
understanding
immeasurably
enhanced
reproducing
limited
portion
ford
words
importance
work
lies
revelation
previously
unknown
fact
also
revelation
thoughts
ideas
motivations
fears
two
presidents
critical
moment
national
history
thus
question
easily
resolved
difficult
say
use
six
quotations
gratuitous
relation
news
reporting
purpose
conceding
even
substantial
quotation
appropriate
news
report
published
work
seem
agree
quotation
clearly
inappropriate
relation
nation
news
reporting
purpose
determinative
factor
substantiality
use
inappropriate
relation
prepublication
timing
use
really
objection
effect
use
market
copyrighted
work
properly
evaluated
effect
market
correctly
notes
effect
market
undoubtedly
single
important
element
fair
use
ante
citing
nimmer
properly
focuses
whether
nation
use
adversely
affected
harper
row
serialization
potential
merely
market
sales
ford
work
ante
unfortunately
failure
distinguish
use
information
appropriation
literary
form
badly
skews
analysis
factor
purposes
fair
use
analysis
holds
sufficient
entire
article
containing
quotes
eroded
serialization
market
potential
ford
work
ante
basis
time
cancellation
serialization
agreement
finds
arely
case
copyright
infringement
present
evidence
actual
damage
ibid
essence
finds
using
quotes
story
nixon
pardon
nation
competed
share
market
prepublication
excerpts
ante
time
planned
excerpt
chapters
pardon
nation
publication
indisputably
precipitated
time
eventual
cancellation
mean
nation
use
quoted
words
caused
injury
harper
row
wholly
apart
quoted
words
nation
published
significant
information
ideas
ford
manuscript
publication
information
publication
quotations
caused
time
abrogate
serialization
agreement
whatever
negative
effect
serialization
market
effect
product
wholly
legitimate
activity
appeals
specifically
held
evidence
support
finding
limited
use
expression
per
se
led
time
decision
print
excerpts
fully
agree
holding
nation
competed
time
competition
share
market
excerpts
literary
form
share
market
new
information
ford
work
information
literary
form
represents
real
value
work
case
perhaps
best
revealed
following
provision
contract
harper
row
ford
author
acknowledges
value
rights
granted
publisher
hereunder
substantially
diminished
author
public
discussion
unique
information
previously
disclosed
author
career
personal
life
included
work
author
agrees
author
endeavor
disseminate
information
media
including
television
radio
newspaper
magazine
interviews
prior
first
publication
work
hereunder
app
nation
first
convey
information
case
perhaps
take
harper
row
value
publisher
sought
garner
contractual
arrangement
ford
license
time
harper
row
every
right
seek
monopolize
revenue
potential
market
contractual
arrangements
right
set
copyright
shield
competition
market
copyright
protect
information
nation
every
right
seek
first
publish
information
balancing
interests
distinction
information
literary
form
made
clear
statutorily
prescribed
process
weighing
four
statutory
fair
use
factors
discussed
leads
naturally
conclusion
nation
limited
use
literary
form
infringement
purpose
use
nature
copyrighted
work
strongly
favor
fair
use
defense
nation
appropriated
ford
expression
purpose
congress
expressly
authorized
borrowed
work
whose
nature
justifies
appropriation
facilitate
spread
information
factor
perhaps
least
favorable
claim
fair
use
amount
substantiality
expression
used
without
question
portion
expression
appropriated
among
poignant
ford
manuscript
difficult
conclude
taking
excessive
relation
news
reporting
purpose
event
appropriation
literary
form
opposed
use
information
shown
injure
harper
row
economic
interest
uncertainty
respect
propriety
amount
expression
borrowed
resolved
favor
finding
fair
use
light
circumscribed
scope
quotation
nation
article
undoubted
validity
purpose
motivating
quotation
must
conclude
simply
adopted
exceedingly
narrow
view
fair
use
order
impose
liability
essence
taking
unprotected
information
iii
exceedingly
narrow
approach
fair
use
permits
harper
row
monopolize
information
holding
effect
important
extension
property
rights
corresponding
curtailment
free
use
knowledge
ideas
international
news
service
associated
press
brandeis
dissenting
perhaps
advanced
ability
historian
least
public
official
recently
left
office
capture
full
economic
value
information
possession
risking
robust
debate
public
issues
essence
garrison
louisiana
nation
providing
grist
robust
debate
imposes
liability
upon
nation
reason
nation
succeeded
first
provide
certain
information
public
dissent
bypassing
threshold
issue
certainly
intimate
nation
use
ideas
information
quoted
material
constitute
violation
copyright
laws
one
point
opinion
correctly
governing
principles
respect
copyrightability
question
see
ante
author
may
copyright
ideas
facts
narrates
section
case
copyright
protection
original
work
authorship
extend
idea
procedure
process
system
method
operation
concept
principle
discovery
regardless
form
described
explained
illustrated
embodied
work
doctrines
fair
use
see
substantial
similarity
see
nimmer
copyright
hereinafter
nimmer
also
function
accommodate
competing
considerations
see
generally
gorman
fact
fancy
implications
copyright
copyright
soc
token
author
may
claim
copyright
statements
made
others
reported
verbatim
author
work
see
suid
newsweek
magazine
supp
dc
rokeach
avco
embassy
pictures
uspq
sdny
perverse
prohibit
government
limiting
financial
resources
upon
political
speaker
may
draw
see
fec
national
conservative
political
action
committee
permit
government
limit
intellectual
resources
upon
speaker
may
draw
protection
literary
form
must
proscribe
merely
appropriation
substantial
portions
author
work
otherwise
plagiarist
avoid
infringement
immaterial
variations
nichols
universal
pictures
step
beyond
narrow
clear
prohibition
wholesale
copying
however
venture
onto
somewhat
uncertain
terrain
compare
hoehling
universal
city
studios
wainwright
securities
wall
street
transcript
see
also
nimmer
particular
selection
arrangement
ideas
well
given
specificity
form
expression
warrants
protection
chafee
reflections
law
copyright
colum
rev
line
lie
somewhere
author
idea
precise
form
wrote
protection
covers
pattern
work
gorman
supra
literal
substantial
copying
paraphrasing
language
inquiry
substantiality
appropriation
quantitative
qualitative
aspect
neither
district
dissent
appeals
approached
question
way
despite
recognizing
material
per
se
copyrightable
district
held
totality
facts
memoranda
collected
together
ford
reflections
protected
copyright
laws
supp
sdny
dissent
appeals
signaled
approval
approach
meskill
dissenting
approach
must
rejected
copyright
protection
extended
factual
information
whenever
information
interwoven
protected
expression
purportedly
case
ford
reflections
expressive
totality
works
history
biography
blend
factual
narrative
reflective
speculative
commentary
way
precluding
subsequent
use
facts
presented
squared
specific
legislative
intent
expressed
house
senate
reports
opyright
preclude
others
using
information
revealed
author
work
see
pp
pp
core
purposes
copyright
thwarted
serious
first
amendment
concerns
arise
author
obtain
monopoly
narration
historical
events
simply
first
discuss
reflective
analytical
manner
example
ford
manuscript
expends
several
hundred
words
discussing
relations
ford
ronald
reagan
weeks
republican
convention
month
convention
aides
met
reagan
representatives
discuss
need
party
unity
reached
agreement
end
presidential
balloting
winner
go
loser
hotel
suite
congratulate
opponent
waging
fine
campaign
together
appear
press
conference
urge
republicans
put
aside
differences
rally
behind
ticket
way
leave
kansas
city
hope
victory
appeared
going
win
sears
contacted
cheney
refined
scenario
insisted
two
conditions
first
see
reagan
alone
aides
either
camp
room
secondly
circumstances
offer
nomination
vice
president
reagan
said
along
interested
job
meant
said
tried
talk
turn
embarrassing
appear
refusing
help
gop
cheney
relayed
conditions
agreed
go
along
need
reagan
assistance
fall
campaign
stupid
anger
followers
moment
later
told
arrival
californian
hotel
one
closest
advisors
businessman
justin
dart
urged
say
yes
asked
running
mate
regardless
anything
said
dart
insisted
patriotic
duty
accept
number
two
post
finally
according
dart
reagan
agreed
time
one
mentioned
new
development
aware
conversation
chosen
ca
say
sure
thought
challenge
divisive
probably
hurt
party
fall
campaign
additionally
resented
things
saying
administration
policies
certainly
considered
app
example
one
point
nation
article
reads
ford
told
jackson
luncheon
audience
later
day
president
guilty
impeachable
offense
ante
portion
ford
manuscript
discussed
stated
representative
thad
cochran
escorted
luncheon
jackson
hilton
hotel
luncheon
repeated
assertion
president
guilty
impeachable
offense
app
several
places
language
nation
article
parallels
ford
original
expression
similar
degree
compare
ante
app
often
paraphrasing
statements
others
made
ford
ante
ride
resign
haig
said
see
generally
ante
copyright
asserted
verbatim
representation
statements
others
see
suid
newsweek
magazine
rokeach
avco
embassy
pictures
uspq
paraphrased
material
came
government
documents
copyright
interest
claimed
example
article
quotes
memorandum
prepared
henry
ruth
official
capacity
assistant
watergate
special
prosecutor
leon
jaworski
see
ante
document
work
government
see
according
exhibit
harper
row
introduced
trial
pages
ford
manuscript
correspond
consecutive
sections
article
follows
see
app
pet
cert
one
sense
nation
copied
ford
selection
facts
reported
facts
ford
chose
select
presentation
tracking
historian
selection
facts
generally
supply
basis
finding
infringement
see
myers
mail
express
copyright
bull
sdny
hand
hold
otherwise
require
second
author
duplicate
research
first
author
avoid
reliance
first
author
judgment
facts
particularly
pertinent
wasted
effort
proscription
copyright
ideas
facts
designed
prevent
miller
universal
city
studios
quoting
rosemont
enterprises
random
house
see
gorman
copyright
congressional
limitation
scope
copyright
threaten
production
history
limitation
results
significant
diminution
economic
incentives
far
apparent
event
noneconomic
incentives
motivate
much
historical
research
writing
example
former
public
officials
often
great
incentive
tell
side
story
much
history
product
academic
scholarship
perhaps
importantly
urge
preserve
past
old
humankind
times
article
revelations
forthcoming
biography
cardinal
spellman
times
article
revelations
forthcoming
book
john
erlichman
times
article
revelations
forthcoming
autobiography
president
nixon
times
mar
article
revelations
concerning
president
nixon
resignation
forthcoming
book
final
days
times
article
revelations
concerning
president
ford
forthcoming
book
blind
ambition
john
dean
properly
rejects
argument
legitimate
news
courts
business
making
evaluations
journalistic
quality
see
ante
also
properly
rejects
argument
use
nonproductive
see
ibid
news
reporting
encompasses
journalistic
judgment
respect
selection
organization
presentation
facts
ideas
certainly
productive
use
see
sony
america
universal
city
studios
blackmun
dissenting
support
claim
refers
language
sony
america
universal
city
studios
supra
effect
every
commercial
use
copyrighted
material
presumptively
unfair
exploitation
see
ante
properly
understood
language
support
position
case
sony
dealt
use
video
recording
copyrighted
television
programs
personal
use
congress
expressed
policy
judgment
evaluates
uses
congress
specifically
addressed
presumption
articulated
sony
appropriate
effectuate
congressional
instruction
consider
whether
use
commercial
nature
also
made
statement
course
evaluating
use
appropriated
entirety
copyrighted
work
form
identical
original
presumption
articulated
may
well
intended
apply
takings
circumstances
light
specific
language
presumption
appropriately
employed
negate
weight
congress
explicitly
gave
news
reporting
justification
limited
use
another
expression
case
far
cry
time
bernard
geis
associates
supp
sdny
case
cites
support
consideration
nation
purported
bad
faith
case
publisher
claiming
fair
use
personally
stolen
film
negatives
offices
time
published
graphic
representations
stolen
photographic
images
found
fair
use
despite
circumstances
ibid
also
discounts
factor
part
appropriation
nation
focusing
expressive
elements
work
exceeds
necessary
disseminate
facts
ante
whatever
propriety
view
nation
use
properly
analyzed
third
statutory
fair
use
factor
amount
substantiality
expression
taken
relation
copyrighted
work
whole
analyzed
opinion
lays
claim
specific
congressional
intent
supporting
presumption
prepublication
fair
use
see
ante
quoting
ante
argument
based
congressional
intent
unpersuasive
three
reasons
first
face
statute
clearly
allows
prepublication
fair
use
right
first
publication
like
rights
act
specifically
grants
copyright
owners
explicitly
made
subject
section
statutory
fair
use
provision
see
second
language
senate
report
relies
heavily
see
ante
simply
bear
weight
places
senate
report
merely
suggests
prepublication
photocopying
classroom
purposes
generally
constitute
fair
use
author
interest
confidentiality
unpublished
work
evidenced
author
deliberate
choice
publish
given
face
specifically
allows
prepublication
fair
use
unfaithful
intent
congress
draw
circumscribed
suggestion
senate
report
blanket
presumption
amount
prepublication
fair
use
purpose
irrespective
effect
use
copyright
owner
privacy
editorial
economic
interests
third
reliance
congressional
adoption
common
law
also
unpersuasive
common
law
set
monolithic
barrier
prepublication
fair
use
wishes
see
estate
hemingway
random
house
misc
cty
aff
app
div
jud
dept
aff
grounds
statements
general
principle
cites
support
contrary
representation
common
law
see
ante
unsupported
reference
substantial
judicial
authority
congressional
endorsement
common
law
fair
use
read
adoption
rigid
presumption
prepublication
use
read
way
broad
statement
copyright
act
intended
incorporate
common
law
effect
given
force
nullifying
congress
repeated
methodological
prescription
definite
rules
inappropriate
analysis
required
broad
language
adopting
approach
fair
use
best
understood
endorsement
essential
methodology
common
law
fair
use
finds
right
first
publication
particularly
weighty
encompasses
three
important
interests
privacy
interest
whether
make
expression
public
ii
editorial
interest
ensuring
control
work
groomed
public
dissemination
iii
economic
interest
capturing
full
remunerative
potential
initial
release
public
ante
perhaps
inappropriate
apocalyptic
prophesy
permitting
prepublication
use
news
reporting
effectively
destroy
expectation
copyright
protection
work
public
figure
ante
impact
prepublication
use
purposes
news
reporting
obviously
vary
circumstances
claim
news
reporting
fig
leaf
substantial
plagiarism
see
wainwright
securities
wall
street
transcript
warrant
concluding
prepublication
quotation
sentences
usually
drain
value
copyright
owner
right
first
publication
six
quotes
ompassion
nixon
individual
prompted
decision
rather
get
monkey
back
one
way
ante
nixon
spend
time
quietly
san
clemente
virtually
impossible
direct
public
attention
anything
else
ante
learned
public
policy
often
took
precedence
rule
law
although
respected
tenet
man
law
public
policy
demanded
put
nixon
watergate
behind
us
quickly
possible
ante
made
trip
remind
everybody
watergate
pardon
people
say
lacked
compassion
ibid
stretched
flat
back
tubes
nose
mouth
wires
led
arms
chest
legs
machines
orange
lights
blinked
face
ashen
thought
never
seen
anyone
closer
death
ibid
terribly
proud
man
writes
ford
detested
weakness
people
often
heard
speak
disparagingly
felt
soft
expedient
curiously
feel
press
weak
reporters
sensed
adversaries
knew
like
responded
reciprocal
disdain
pride
personal
contempt
weakness
overcome
ability
tell
difference
right
wrong
nixon
touch
reality
ante
places
emphasis
fact
quotations
ford
work
constituted
substantial
portion
nation
article
superficially
thus
appear
evaluating
nation
quotation
words
relation
amount
substantiality
expression
used
relation
second
author
work
whole
statute
directs
inquiry
amount
substantiality
portion
used
relation
copyrighted
work
whole
emphasis
added
statutory
directive
implies
matters
little
whether
second
author
use
appropriated
expression
taking
expression
adverse
effect
copyrighted
work
see
sony
america
universal
city
studios
expression
taken
presume
therefore
considered
role
expression
infringing
work
indirect
evidence
qualitative
value
expression
taken
case
read
way
point
dovetails
major
argument
nation
appropriated
valuable
sentences
work
see
supra
reliance
principle
infringer
mingles
infringing
noninfringing
elements
must
abide
consequences
ante
citation
omitted
misconceived
infringement
exclusive
right
shown
entirely
appropriate
shift
infringer
burden
showing
infringement
cause
damages
shown
question
case
whether
particular
use
infringed
rights
harper
row
may
shown
actual
damage
flowing
nation
use
information
shown
actual
damage
flowing
infringement
exclusive
right
nation
sought
justify
substantial
appropriation
expression
news
reporting
rationale
different
case
might
presented
substantiality
taking
certainly
dilute
claim
need
use
first
author
exact
words
convey
particular
thought
sentiment
even
claim
need
plausible
equities
favor
copyright
owner
order
prevent
erosion
virtually
copyright
protection
works
former
public
officials
case
however
need
manifest
integrity
copyright
protection
works
public
officials
threatened