lamie
trustee
argued
november
decided
january
bankruptcy
code
authorized
award
trustee
examiner
professional
person
employed
section
debtor
attorney
reasonable
compensation
services
rendered
trustee
examiner
professional
person
attorney
emphasis
added
highlight
text
later
deleted
congress
amended
code
reform
act
act
altered
deleting
debtor
attorney
change
created
apparent
legislative
drafting
error
current
section
section
left
missing
infects
grammar
inclusion
attorney
defeats
neat
parallelism
otherwise
marks
relationship
current
trustee
examiner
professional
person
trustee
examiner
professional
person
attorney
case
petitioner
filed
application
bankruptcy
seeking
attorney
fees
time
spent
working
behalf
debtor
chapter
proceeding
government
objected
application
argued
makes
provision
estate
compensate
attorney
employed
estate
trustee
approved
petitioner
admitted
employed
trustee
approved
nonetheless
contended
authorized
fee
award
debtor
attorney
denying
petitioner
application
bankruptcy
district
fourth
circuit
held
chapter
proceeding
authorize
payment
attorney
fees
unless
attorney
appointed
held
code
plain
language
authorize
compensation
awards
debtors
attorneys
estate
funds
unless
employed
authorized
attorney
paid
estate
funds
chapter
case
must
employed
trustee
approved
pp
petitioner
argues
must
look
legislative
history
determine
congress
intent
existing
statutory
text
ambiguous
light
predecessor
claims
subsection
attorney
facially
irreconcilable
section
first
part
since
two
parts
lists
previously
parallel
claims
also
drafting
error
explain
missing
conjunction
examiner
professional
person
since
text
previously
grammatically
correct
starting
point
discerning
congressional
intent
however
existing
statutory
text
hughes
aircraft
jacobson
predecessor
statutes
begins
present
statute
pp
present
statute
awkward
even
ungrammatical
make
ambiguous
point
issue
debtor
attorney
engaged
fall
within
eligible
class
persons
first
part
authorizes
receive
compensation
trustees
examiners
professional
persons
subsection
allows
compensation
services
rendered
four
types
persons
three
plus
attorneys
unless
applicant
one
classes
named
first
part
kind
service
rendered
irrelevant
missing
change
conclusion
numerous
federal
statutes
inadvertently
lack
conjunction
read
plain
meaning
missing
neither
alters
text
substance
obscures
meaning
subsection
nonparalleled
fourth
category
also
cloud
statute
meaning
attorney
straightforwardly
read
refer
attorneys
qualify
professional
persons
likewise
neighboring
permits
debtors
attorneys
professional
persons
receive
interim
compensation
straightforwardly
refers
debtors
attorneys
reading
may
make
attorney
surplusage
surplusage
always
produce
ambiguity
two
ways
read
text
either
attorney
surplusage
makes
text
plain
attorney
nonsurplusage
makes
text
ambiguous
applying
rule
surplusage
inappropriate
pp
plain
meaning
sets
forth
lead
absurd
results
petitioner
arguments
interpretation
lead
departure
principle
prompt
effectual
administration
bankruptcy
law
attributes
congress
intent
eliminate
compensation
essential
debtors
receipt
legal
services
overstate
effect
compensation
remains
available
various
permitted
means
compensation
debtors
attorneys
chapter
bankruptcies
example
much
disturbed
whole
moreover
compensation
debtors
attorneys
chapter
proceedings
altogether
prohibited
sections
taken
together
allow
chapter
trustees
engage
attorneys
including
debtors
counsel
allow
courts
award
fees
section
limitation
debtor
incurring
debts
professional
services
without
trustee
approval
also
advances
trustee
responsibility
preserving
chapter
estate
add
apparent
sound
functioning
bankruptcy
system
fifth
eleventh
circuits
adopted
plain
meaning
approach
petitioner
arguments
become
unconvincing
prevent
debtor
engaging
common
practice
paying
counsel
compensation
advance
ensure
bankruptcy
filing
order
pp
plain
nonabsurd
meaning
view
read
attorney
refer
debtors
attorneys
effect
enlarging
statute
scope
see
iselin
unwillingness
soften
import
congress
chosen
words
even
believes
words
lead
harsh
outcome
longstanding
though
unnecessary
rely
act
legislative
history
instructive
note
history
creates
confusion
clarity
congressional
intent
history
policy
considerations
lend
support
petitioner
interpretation
holding
reached
uncertainty
illustrates
difficulty
relying
legislative
history
advantage
resting
statutory
text
pp
affirmed
kennedy
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
souter
thomas
ginsburg
breyer
joined
scalia
joined
except
part
iii
stevens
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
souter
breyer
joined
john
lamie
petitioner
trustee
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
january
justice
kennedy
delivered
opinion
section
bankruptcy
code
regulates
awards
professional
fees
including
fees
services
rendered
attorneys
connection
bankruptcy
proceedings
petitioner
bankruptcy
attorney
sought
compensation
section
legal
services
provided
bankrupt
debtor
proceeding
converted
chapter
bankruptcy
application
fees
denied
bankruptcy
district
appeals
fourth
circuit
held
chapter
proceeding
authorize
payment
attorney
fees
unless
attorney
appointed
code
see
et
seq
petitioner
appointed
fee
request
denied
granted
petition
certiorari
review
holding
affirm
congress
amended
bankruptcy
code
bankruptcy
reform
act
act
stat
subject
professional
fees
addressed
comprehensive
changes
made
see
collier
bankruptcy
pp
rev
ed
changes
served
clarify
standards
award
professional
fees
various
courts
disagree
proper
interpretation
portion
statute
relevant
dispute
concerning
attorney
fees
act
replaced
predecessor
section
one
issue
compare
stat
act
amending
act
read
follows
notice
parties
interest
trustee
hearing
subject
sections
title
may
award
trustee
examiner
professional
person
employed
section
title
debtor
attorney
reasonable
compensation
actual
necessary
services
rendered
trustee
examiner
professional
person
attorney
paraprofessional
persons
employed
trustee
professional
person
attorney
reimbursement
actual
necessary
expenses
ibid
emphasis
added
highlight
text
later
deleted
pursuant
act
reads
follows
notice
parties
interest
trustee
hearing
subject
sections
may
award
trustee
examiner
professional
person
employed
section
reasonable
compensation
actual
necessary
services
rendered
trustee
examiner
professional
person
attorney
paraprofessional
person
employed
person
reimbursement
actual
necessary
expenses
noted
enactment
principal
substantive
alteration
deletion
five
words
end
debtor
attorney
deletion
created
apparent
legislative
drafting
error
left
current
missing
infects
grammar
examiner
professional
person
furthermore
act
inclusion
word
attorney
defeats
neat
parallelism
otherwise
marks
relationship
trustee
examiner
professional
person
trustee
examiner
professional
person
attorney
casts
doubt
proper
presence
attorney
text
grammatical
error
parallel
structure
strengthens
sense
error
exists
new
text
courts
appeals
fifth
eleventh
circuits
asked
interpret
current
concluded
language
plain
irrespective
quirks
history
statutory
language
written
courts
held
fees
may
awarded
attorneys
services
rendered
extent
payments
professional
person
employed
see
authorizing
appointed
trustee
chapter
bankruptcy
action
employ
one
attorneys
represent
assist
trustee
carrying
trustee
duties
title
authorizing
appointed
trustee
chapter
bankruptcy
action
employ
specified
special
purpose
represent
trustee
conducting
case
attorney
represented
debtor
see
distributors
american
steel
product
courts
appeals
second
third
ninth
circuits
contrast
concluded
text
apparent
errors
rendered
section
ambiguous
requiring
consideration
provision
legislative
history
history
courts
held
shows
congress
intended
continue
allow
compensation
chapter
debtors
attorneys
irrespective
qualification
ames
dept
stores
top
grade
sausage
century
cleaning
services
see
also
collier
bankruptcy
supra
interpretive
divide
became
relevant
petitioner
representation
equipment
services
esi
esi
retained
petitioner
prepare
file
prosecute
chapter
bankruptcy
proceeding
behalf
representing
esi
approval
see
equipment
services
case
see
also
authorizing
exercise
statutory
rights
powers
estate
trustee
including
retain
counsel
three
months
chapter
reorganization
trustee
government
filed
motion
convert
action
chapter
liquidation
proceeding
granted
government
motion
appointed
estate
trustee
pursuant
terminated
esi
status
terminated
petitioner
service
attorney
yet
petitioner
continued
provide
legal
services
esi
debtor
even
though
trustee
authorization
prepared
reports
detailing
debts
incurred
property
acquired
since
initial
filing
amended
asset
schedules
appeared
hearing
adversary
complaint
due
course
petitioner
filed
application
seeking
fees
time
spent
esi
behalf
chapter
conversion
government
objected
application
argued
makes
provision
estate
compensate
attorney
authorized
agreed
denied
fees
equipment
services
bkrtcy
wd
petitioner
paid
fees
services
provided
esi
conversion
proceeding
chapter
esi
parties
contest
fees
petitioner
unsuccessfully
sought
reversal
bankruptcy
determination
first
district
see
equipment
services
wd
appeals
see
courts
concluded
plain
language
controlled
attorneys
provide
services
debtors
chapter
proceedings
must
hired
trustee
eligible
compensation
appeals
acknowledged
holding
deepened
divide
among
various
circuits
held
fast
statute
plain
language
particularly
application
plain
language
supports
reasonable
interpretation
bankruptcy
code
granted
petition
certiorari
resolve
issue
ii
petitioner
argues
existing
statutory
text
ambiguous
requires
us
consult
legislative
history
determine
whether
congress
intended
allow
fees
services
rendered
debtor
attorney
chapter
proceeding
attorney
authorized
makes
case
ambiguity
part
comparing
present
statute
predecessor
thus
says
statute
ambiguous
subsection
attorney
facially
irreconcilable
section
first
part
since
ither
congress
inadvertently
omitted
attorney
list
appeals
relied
inadvertently
retained
reference
attorney
latter
brief
petitioner
similarly
respect
missing
conjunction
says
apparent
reason
drafting
error
congress
rewritten
statute
produce
grammatically
incorrect
provision
ibid
analysis
followed
courts
appeals
hold
statute
ambiguous
see
top
grade
sausage
supra
noting
search
ambiguity
rior
amendment
undisputed
repetition
officers
meant
parallel
officers
previously
listed
see
also
century
cleaning
services
supra
engaging
resort
previous
enactment
inquire
current
text
ambiguity
one
determines
ambiguity
contention
relying
grammatical
soundness
prior
statute
contention
wrong
starting
point
discerning
congressional
intent
existing
statutory
text
see
hughes
aircraft
jacobson
predecessor
statutes
well
established
statute
language
plain
sole
function
courts
least
disposition
required
text
absurd
enforce
according
terms
hartford
underwriters
ins
union
planters
bank
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
quoting
ron
pair
enterprises
turn
quoting
caminetti
begin
present
statute
statute
awkward
even
ungrammatical
make
ambiguous
point
issue
first
part
statute
authorizes
award
compensation
one
three
types
persons
trustees
examiners
professional
persons
debtor
attorney
engaged
provided
simply
included
within
class
persons
eligible
compensation
subsection
statute
defines
type
compensation
may
awarded
compensation
reasonable
actual
necessary
services
rendered
four
types
persons
three
plus
attorneys
unless
applicant
compensation
one
named
classes
persons
first
part
kind
service
rendered
irrelevant
missing
conjunction
change
conclusion
government
points
numerous
federal
statutes
inadvertently
lack
conjunction
read
nonetheless
plain
meaning
see
brief
respondent
missing
conjunction
neither
alters
text
substance
obscures
meaning
case
missing
inadvertently
substitutes
sentence
may
awkward
yet
straightforward
subsection
nonparalleled
fourth
category
persons
render
compensable
services
cloud
statute
meaning
petitioner
reasons
since
section
single
sentence
since
appears
strive
parallelism
authorized
receive
fees
whose
services
compensable
ambiguity
attorney
refers
also
points
neighboring
provides
debtors
attorneys
professional
persons
receive
interim
compensation
order
relief
entered
application
fees
filed
argues
since
contemplates
debtors
attorneys
receiving
interim
compensation
reason
conclude
attorney
refers
debtors
attorneys
though
go
unmentioned
clause
subsection
attorney
however
read
straightforward
fashion
refer
attorneys
whose
fees
authorized
attorneys
qualified
professional
persons
chapter
context
employed
trustee
approved
see
appointed
trustee
may
employ
one
attorneys
represent
assist
trustee
carrying
trustee
duties
title
appointed
trustee
may
employ
specified
special
purpose
represent
trustee
conducting
case
attorney
represented
debtor
likewise
reference
interim
compensation
debtors
attorneys
straightforwardly
refers
debtors
attorneys
authorized
must
acknowledged
reading
text
word
attorney
subsection
may
well
surplusage
subsection
reference
professional
persons
undoubtedly
includes
attorneys
much
reference
professional
persons
controlling
however
surplusage
always
produce
ambiguity
preference
avoiding
surplusage
constructions
absolute
see
chickasaw
nation
preference
sometimes
offset
canon
permits
reject
words
surplusage
inserted
repugnant
rest
two
ways
read
text
either
attorney
surplusage
case
text
plain
attorney
nonsurplusage
refers
ambiguous
component
case
text
ambiguous
applying
rule
surplusage
absent
indications
inappropriate
prefer
plain
meaning
since
approach
respects
words
congress
manner
avoid
pitfalls
plague
quick
turn
controversial
realm
legislative
history
plain
meaning
sets
forth
lead
absurd
results
requiring
us
treat
text
ambiguous
see
supra
citing
hartford
underwriters
petitioner
disagrees
argues
interpretation
entail
inexplicable
wholesale
departure
guiding
principle
effectual
administration
federal
bankruptcy
law
brief
petitioner
says
reading
attribute
congress
illogical
determination
eliminate
entirely
purportedly
measure
compensation
essential
debtors
receipt
legal
services
arguments
overstate
effect
text
instruction
compensation
remains
available
debtors
attorneys
various
permitted
means
first
requires
proper
authorization
payment
attorneys
estate
funds
chapter
filings
extend
throughout
bankruptcy
law
compensation
debtors
attorneys
chapter
bankruptcies
example
much
disturbed
whole
see
chapter
chapter
case
debtor
individual
may
allow
reasonable
compensation
debtor
attorney
compensation
debtors
attorneys
working
chapter
bankruptcies
moreover
altogether
prohibited
sections
taken
together
allow
chapter
trustees
engage
attorneys
including
debtors
counsel
allow
courts
award
fees
see
section
limitation
debtors
incurring
debts
professional
services
without
chapter
trustee
approval
absurd
context
chapter
liquidation
advances
trustee
responsibility
preserving
estate
add
apparent
sound
functioning
bankruptcy
system
plain
meaning
approach
petitioner
arguments
become
unconvincing
seeming
order
attended
rule
application
five
years
fifth
circuit
four
years
eleventh
circuit
see
american
steel
product
distributors
appears
routine
debtors
pay
reasonable
fees
legal
services
filing
bankruptcy
ensure
compliance
statutory
requirements
see
generally
collier
compensation
employment
appointment
trustees
professionals
bankruptcy
cases
majority
cases
debtor
counsel
accept
individual
joint
consumer
chapter
case
paid
retainer
covers
fee
cost
filing
petition
interpretation
accords
common
practice
section
prevent
debtor
engaging
counsel
chapter
conversion
paying
reasonable
compensation
advance
ensure
filing
order
indeed
code
anticipates
arrangements
see
debtors
attorneys
must
disclose
fees
receive
debtor
year
prior
bankruptcy
filing
courts
may
order
excessive
payments
returned
estate
petitioner
argument
stumbles
still
harder
ground
face
another
canon
interpretation
interpretation
act
reading
word
attorney
refer
debtors
attorneys
us
read
absent
word
statute
argument
result
construction
statute
effect
enlargement
omitted
presumably
inadvertence
may
included
within
scope
iselin
plain
nonabsurd
meaning
view
need
proceed
way
basic
difference
filling
gap
left
congress
silence
rewriting
rules
congress
affirmatively
specifically
enacted
mobil
oil
higginbotham
unwillingness
soften
import
congress
chosen
words
even
believe
words
lead
harsh
outcome
longstanding
results
deference
supremacy
legislature
well
recognition
congressmen
typically
vote
language
bill
locke
citing
richards
adhering
conventional
doctrines
statutory
interpretation
hold
authorize
compensation
awards
debtors
attorneys
estate
funds
unless
employed
authorized
attorney
paid
estate
funds
chapter
case
must
employed
trustee
approved
iii
though
find
unnecessary
rely
legislative
history
behind
enactment
find
instructive
history
creates
confusion
clarity
congressional
intent
history
policy
considerations
lend
support
petitioner
interpretation
holding
reach
based
plain
language
statute
petitioner
instance
cites
evidence
supporting
conclusion
scrivener
error
obscures
congress
real
intent
years
debtors
attorneys
considered
congress
courts
integral
part
bankruptcy
process
see
bankruptcy
act
ch
stat
see
also
kross
sdny
fair
doubt
congress
rework
longstanding
role
without
announcing
change
congressional
record
cf
cohen
de
la
cruz
read
bankruptcy
code
erode
past
bankruptcy
practice
absent
clear
indication
congress
intended
departure
internal
quotation
marks
citation
omitted
legislative
processes
behind
change
also
lend
support
petitioner
claim
original
proposed
draft
new
featured
two
changes
stylistic
changes
throughout
section
addition
new
provision
giving
government
right
object
fee
applications
see
sess
reprinted
right
object
provision
added
end
thus
came
immediately
critical
text
debtor
attorney
draft
edited
read
debtors
sic
attorney
ibid
voting
act
law
however
congress
amended
proposed
draft
see
cong
rec
setting
amendment
amendment
made
two
changes
deleted
government
right
object
provision
critical
words
debtors
sic
attorney
rest
original
proposed
draft
remained
intact
legislative
history
explains
first
deletion
provision
installed
elsewhere
new
nothing
however
explains
second
government
right
object
deleted
reinstated
reorganized
words
issue
preceded
moved
provision
deleted
notation
legislative
history
suggests
scrivener
reached
far
deletion
factors
combined
convince
leading
treatise
bankruptcy
law
collier
deletion
scrivener
error
effect
see
collier
bankruptcy
aspects
legislative
record
however
undermine
interpretation
considerations
suggest
congress
may
intended
change
scrivener
worked
example
amendment
part
reform
act
designed
curtail
abuses
fee
awards
according
statements
amendment
sponsor
see
cong
statement
metzenbaum
abuses
ghosts
seen
congress
bankruptcy
courts
reached
conclusion
see
nrg
resources
bkrtcy
wd
la
deletion
issue
furthered
reform
ensuring
chapter
debtors
attorneys
receive
estate
compensation
absent
trustee
authorization
work
objective
inconsistent
interest
involving
debtors
attorneys
bankruptcy
proceedings
noted
act
still
allows
debtors
attorneys
compensated
different
ways
see
supra
amendment
viewed
entirety
gives
reason
think
congress
may
intended
change
amendment
added
new
section
authorizes
fee
awards
debtors
attorneys
chapter
bankruptcies
cong
setting
new
since
amendment
deletion
debtors
sic
attorney
original
proposed
draft
affected
chapter
debtors
attorneys
much
chapter
debtors
attorneys
shows
special
intent
authorize
formers
fee
awards
face
new
broad
exclusion
congress
action
prove
point
house
representatives
inaction
may
house
passed
act
deletion
well
impact
called
attention
see
bankruptcy
reform
hearing
subcommittee
economic
commercial
law
house
committee
judiciary
national
association
consumer
bankruptcy
attorneys
nacba
represents
lawyers
likely
affected
change
declined
object
deletion
ibid
noting
deletion
stating
nacba
oppose
amendment
passage
alert
followed
legislature
nonresponse
support
presumption
legislative
awareness
intention
act
may
contain
surplusage
along
grammatical
error
may
result
trying
make
substantive
change
fewest
possible
textual
alterations
error
scrivener
carrying
change
competing
interpretations
legislative
history
make
difficult
say
assurance
whether
petitioner
government
lays
better
historical
claim
congressional
intent
alert
change
policy
given
sure
house
passed
final
version
particular
circumstance
bear
much
weight
alert
subject
testimony
witness
congressional
hearing
consisted
two
sentences
contained
within
pages
written
statements
delivered
legislative
subcommittee
august
hearing
day
pages
added
pages
prepared
statements
testimony
transcribed
day
testifying
witnesses
within
nacba
filing
two
relevant
sentences
appear
page
report
nothing
legislative
history
confirms
particular
point
bore
congressional
deliberations
given
specific
consideration
uncertainties
illustrate
difficulty
relying
legislative
history
advantage
determination
rest
holding
statutory
text
congress
enacted
law
something
different
intended
amend
statute
conform
intent
beyond
province
rescue
congress
drafting
errors
provide
might
think
preferred
result
granderson
concurring
opinion
allows
branches
adhere
respected
respective
constitutional
roles
meantime
must
determine
intent
statute
us
judgment
appeals
affirmed
ordered
john
lamie
petitioner
trustee
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
january
justice
stevens
concurring
judgment
joined
justice
souter
justice
breyer
concurring
majority
recognizes
ante
leading
bankruptcy
law
treatise
concluded
amendments
contained
unintended
error
collier
bankruptcy
pp
rev
ed
whenever
plausible
basis
believing
significant
change
statutory
law
resulted
scrivener
error
believe
duty
examine
legislative
case
history
reveals
national
association
consumer
bankruptcy
attorneys
nacba
called
assumed
drafting
error
congress
attention
timely
fashion
also
deemed
error
unworthy
evidence
convinces
reading
text
surely
natural
petitioner
correct
therefore
concur
judgment
footnotes
justice
souter
justice
breyer
join
opinion
entirety
justice
scalia
joins
opinion
except
part
iii
footnotes
chief
justice
marshall
stated
mind
labours
discover
design
legislature
seizes
every
thing
aid
derived
fisher
cranch
see
ante
specifically
three
months
senate
passed
relevant
amendment
nacba
submitted
written
comments
house
subcommittee
economic
commercial
law
considering
change
comments
first
noted
amended
version
appears
minor
drafting
errors
including
apparently
inadvertent
removal
debtors
attorneys
list
professionals
whose
compensation
awards
covered
bankruptcy
reform
hearing
subcommittee
economic
commercial
law
house
committee
judiciary
proviso
alleged
errors
corrected
nacba
expressly
oppose
passage
amendment
ibid
emphasis
added