lorelyn
penero
miller
madeleine
albright
secretary
state
argued
november
decided
april
held
judgment
affirmed
affirmed
justice
stevens
joined
chief
justice
concluded
requirement
children
born
abroad
wedlock
citizen
fathers
citizen
mothers
obtain
formal
proof
paternity
age
violate
fifth
amendment
pp
foregoing
issue
presented
case
facts
certain
issues
need
resolved
whether
fiallo
bell
dictates
outcome
validity
distinction
drawn
residency
requirements
unmarried
citizen
fathers
unmarried
citizen
mothers
wishing
transmit
citizenship
birth
children
validity
impose
additional
requirements
citizen
fathers
wishing
transmit
citizenship
petitioner
contesting
government
refusal
register
treat
citizen
judgment
favor
confirm
citizenship
rather
grant
rights
possess
appeals
therefore
correct
standing
invoke
federal
courts
jurisdiction
moreover
claim
relies
heavily
proposition
citizen
father
right
transmit
citizenship
citizen
mother
evaluate
alleged
discrimination
well
impact
see
craig
boren
pp
rule
applicable
class
children
born
abroad
eminently
reasonable
justified
important
government
interests
ensuring
reliable
proof
person
born
wedlock
claims
citizenship
birth
actually
shares
blood
relationship
american
citizen
encouraging
development
healthy
relationship
citizen
parent
child
child
minor
fostering
ties
child
male
female
parents
children
differently
situated
several
pertinent
respects
child
blood
relationship
birth
mother
immediately
obvious
typically
established
hospital
records
birth
certificates
relationship
unmarried
father
may
often
undisclosed
unrecorded
contemporary
public
record
similarly
child
birth
mother
certainly
knows
child
existence
typically
immediate
custody
whereas
due
normal
intercite
syllabus
val
nine
months
conception
birth
unmarried
father
may
even
know
child
exists
child
may
know
father
identity
section
children
born
wedlock
citizen
fathers
obtain
formal
proof
paternity
age
either
legitimation
written
acknowledgment
father
oath
adjudication
competent
well
tailored
address
concerns
conclusion
congress
may
require
affirmative
act
unmarried
fathers
children
mothers
children
directly
supported
lehr
robertson
pp
argument
unconstitutional
stereotypical
classification
must
rejected
none
governmental
interests
underlying
fairly
characterized
accidental
byproduct
traditional
way
thinking
members
either
sex
biological
differences
single
men
single
women
provide
relevant
basis
differing
rules
governing
ability
confer
citizenship
children
born
wedlock
foreign
lands
impartial
analysis
differences
rebuts
strong
presumption
legal
distinctions
suspect
pp
justice
joined
justice
kennedy
concluded
petitioner
accorded
standing
raise
father
gender
discrimination
claim
applies
presumption
standing
prudential
limitation
exercise
federal
jurisdiction
see
singleton
wulff
presumption
may
rebutted
particular
circumstances
litigant
suffered
injury
fact
close
relation
third
party
hindrance
third
party
ability
protect
interests
exists
see
powers
ohio
petitioner
demonstrated
genuine
obstacle
father
ability
assert
rights
rises
level
hindrance
accordingly
precluded
raising
equal
protection
claims
case
although
petitioner
may
still
assert
rights
invoke
gender
discrimination
claim
trigger
heightened
scrutiny
section
draws
distinction
based
gender
parent
child
claim
discrimination
based
differential
treatment
illegitimate
versus
legitimate
children
presented
question
certiorari
granted
thus
petitioner
constitutional
challenge
subject
rational
basis
scrutiny
even
though
withstand
heightened
scrutiny
sustainable
lower
standard
pp
justice
scalia
joined
justice
thomas
agreed
outcome
case
ground
complaint
must
dismissed
albright
syllabus
cause
power
provide
relief
requested
conferral
citizenship
basis
prescribed
congress
petitioner
born
outside
territory
become
citizen
naturalization
congressional
authority
see
wong
kim
ark
congressional
enactment
granting
citizenship
remains
alien
plain
language
sets
forth
precondition
acquisition
citizenship
petitioner
admittedly
met
thus
even
agree
difference
treatment
illegitimate
children
citizenfathers
unconstitutional
consistent
extremely
limited
judicial
power
area
see
fiallo
bell
remedy
constitutional
infirmity
declaring
petitioner
citizen
ordering
state
department
approve
application
citizenship
see
ins
pangilinan
case
may
remedy
alleged
violation
either
expanding
limiting
benefits
conferred
deny
grant
equally
pp
stevens
announced
judgment
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
joined
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
kennedy
joined
scalia
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
thomas
joined
ginsburg
filed
dissenting
opinion
souter
breyer
joined
breyer
filed
dissenting
opinion
souter
ginsburg
joined
children
born
wedlock
outside
specific
challenge
distinction
drawn
immigration
nationality
act
ina
stat
amended
legal
information
institute
project
hermes
image
parts
opinion
pdf
versions
related
documents
bench
copy
opinion
stevens
notice
opinion
subject
formal
revision
publication
preliminary
print
reports
readers
requested
notify
reporter
decisions
ington
typographical
formal
errors
order
corrections
may
made
preliminary
print
goes
press
albright
opinion
stevens
child
alien
father
citizen
mother
one
hand
child
alien
mother
citizen
father
subject
residence
requirements
citizen
parent
citizenship
former
established
birth
citizenship
latter
established
unless
either
father
child
takes
certain
affirmative
steps
create
confirm
relationship
petitioner
contends
statutory
requirement
steps
taken
child
minor
violates
fifth
amendment
statute
contains
limitation
time
within
child
citizen
mother
may
prove
became
citizen
birth
find
merit
challenge
statute
impose
limitation
time
within
members
either
class
children
may
prove
qualify
citizenship
establish
different
qualifications
citizenship
two
classes
dren
persuaded
qualifications
members
classes
far
cated
facts
case
well
supported
valid
governmental
interests
therefore
conclude
statutory
distinction
neither
arbitrary
invidious
petitioner
born
june
angeles
city
republic
philippines
records
local
civil
registrar
disclose
birth
registered
days
later
named
lorena
peñero
mother
luz
peñero
filipino
national
birth
illegitimate
spaces
form
referring
name
nationality
father
blank
petitioner
grew
received
high
school
college
education
philippines
least
birthday
never
lived
app
evidence
either
cite
opinion
stevens
mother
ever
resided
outside
philippines
petitioner
father
charlie
miller
american
zen
residing
texas
apparently
served
air
force
stationed
pines
time
petitioner
conception
never
married
petitioner
mother
dence
philippines
time
tioner
birth
ever
returned
pleting
tour
duty
miller
filed
petition
texas
establish
relationship
petitioner
petition
unopposed
entered
untary
paternity
decree
finding
biological
legal
father
lorelyn
penero
miller
decree
father
child
child
born
father
mother
marriage
app
pet
cert
november
petitioner
filed
application
registration
citizen
state
partment
application
denied
march
petitioner
reapplied
father
obtained
nity
decree
texas
july
reapplication
also
denied
ground
texas
decree
satisfy
requirements
section
ina
requires
child
born
wedlock
legitimated
mother
born
leyte
several
years
petitioner
birth
mother
married
man
named
frank
raspotnik
raised
family
angeles
city
app
although
formal
finding
paternity
established
clear
convincing
evidence
undisputed
letter
petitioner
attorney
state
department
acknowledged
satisfied
charlie
miller
putative
father
citizen
possesses
sufficient
physical
presence
transmit
citizenship
sufficient
evidence
access
applicant
mother
probable
time
conception
app
pet
cert
age
eighteen
order
acquire
citizenship
section
ina
formerly
section
ina
explanation
reliance
denial
letter
added
without
legitimation
age
eighteen
legally
recognized
relationship
ina
child
acquires
rights
citizenship
american
citizen
parent
ibid
ii
petitioner
father
filed
amended
complaint
secretary
state
district
eastern
district
texas
seeking
judgment
declaring
petitioner
citizen
therefore
right
possess
american
passport
alleged
ina
different
treatment
citizen
mothers
citizen
fathers
violated
miller
right
equal
protection
laws
utilizing
suspect
classification
gender
without
justification
app
response
motion
dismiss
filed
government
district
concluded
miller
standing
dismissed
party
venue
texas
therefore
improper
see
transferred
case
district
district
columbia
site
secretary
residence
government
renewed
motion
forum
concluded
even
though
petitioner
suffered
injury
caused
secretary
refusal
register
citizen
injury
redressable
federal
courts
power
grant
citizenship
supp
citing
ins
pangilinan
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
affirmed
different
grounds
first
held
petitioner
standing
challenge
constitutionality
challenge
succeed
enter
judgment
declaring
already
citizen
pursuant
provisions
ina
cadc
merits
however
concluded
requirements
imposed
illegitimate
child
american
citizen
father
child
citizen
mother
justified
interest
fostering
child
ties
country
explained
conclude
ninth
circuit
desire
promote
early
ties
country
relatives
citizens
country
ir
rational
basis
requirements
made
sections
ablang
reno
furthermore
find
entirely
reasonable
congress
require
special
evidence
ties
illegitimate
child
father
mother
far
less
likely
ignore
child
carried
womb
natural
father
may
even
aware
existence
recognized
fathers
illegitimate
children
similarly
situated
parham
hughes
putative
father
often
goes
way
unconscious
birth
child
even
conscious
often
totally
unconcerned
absence
ties
mother
id
internal
quotation
marks
citation
omitted
distinction
seems
especially
warranted
applicant
citizenship
fathered
serviceman
serving
tour
duty
overseas
judge
wald
concurred
judgment
despite
opinion
rational
basis
law
requires
citizen
father
citizen
mother
formally
legitimate
child
reaches
majority
well
agree
writing
provide
financial
support
date
forever
forfeit
right
transmit
citizenship
id
agreed
requiring
sort
minimal
ties
parent
child
well
fostering
early
connection
child
country
rational
government
policy
agree
goals
justify
set
procedural
hurdles
wish
confer
citizenship
children
id
nevertheless
regretfully
concurred
judgment
believed
decision
fiallo
bell
required
uphold
constitutionality
granted
certiorari
address
following
question
distinction
children
citizen
mothers
children
citizen
fathers
violation
fifth
amendment
constitution
iii
explaining
answer
single
question
agreed
address
useful
put
one
side
certain
issues
need
resolved
first
need
decide
whether
fiallo
bell
dictates
outcome
case
case
involved
claims
several
aliens
special
immigration
preference
whereas
peti
tioner
claims
years
american
citizen
additionally
fiallo
involved
challenges
statutory
distinctions
illegitimate
legitimate
children
encompassed
question
presented
case
therefore
consider
statutory
provision
issue
case
draws
two
types
distinctions
citizen
fathers
citizen
mothers
children
born
wedlock
first
relates
class
unmarried
persons
may
transmit
citizenship
birth
offspring
second
defines
affirmative
steps
required
transmit
citizenship
respect
eligible
class
parents
unmarried
father
may
transmit
citizenship
child
born
abroad
alien
mother
unless
satisfies
residency
requirement
applies
citizen
parent
married
alien
provision
citizen
parent
must
resided
total
least
five
years
least
two
attaining
age
years
citizen
parent
unmarried
mother
however
rather
applies
subsection
need
one
year
continuous
residence
order
confer
citizenship
offspring
since
petitioner
father
satisfied
residency
requirement
validity
distinction
requirement
unusually
generous
provision
issue
affirmative
steps
amended
imposes
four
requirements
concerning
unmarried
citizen
fathers
must
satisfied
confer
citizenship
date
birth
person
born
wedlock
alien
mother
another
country
citizenship
persons
established
blood
relationship
person
father
established
clear
convincing
evidence
father
nationality
time
person
birth
father
unless
deceased
agreed
writing
provide
financial
support
person
person
reaches
age
years
person
age
years
person
legitimated
law
person
residence
domicile
father
acknowledges
paternity
person
writing
oath
paternity
person
established
adjudication
competent
second
four
requirements
expressly
included
provision
applicable
unwed
citizen
mothers
see
supra
petitioner
relying
heavily
judge
wald
separate
opinion
argues
rational
basis
imposing
three
requirements
children
citizen
fathers
citizen
mothers
first
requirement
issue
however
government
question
miller
blood
relationship
petitioner
moreover
even
though
parties
disputed
validity
third
condition
even
though
condition
repeatedly
targeted
justice
breyer
need
resolve
debate
unclear
whether
requirement
even
applies
petitioner
case
added
birth
falls
within
special
interim
provision
allows
elect
application
required
legitimation
age
see
supra
even
condition
apply
claim
citizenship
state
department
refusal
register
petitioner
citizen
expressly
based
indeed
since
subsection
written
disjunctive
necessary
uphold
least
onerous
three
alternative
methods
compliance
sustain
government
position
thus
issue
presented
facts
case
whether
requirement
children
born
wedlock
citizen
fathers
citizen
mothers
obtain
formal
proof
paternity
age
either
legitimation
written
acknowledgment
father
oath
adjudication
competent
fifth
amendment
significance
petitioner
case
unlike
petitioners
fiallo
see
challenging
denial
application
special
status
contesting
government
refusal
register
treat
citizen
prevail
judgment
favor
confirm
preexisting
citizenship
rather
grant
rights
possess
therefore
agree
appeals
standing
invoke
jurisdiction
federal
courts
see
distinguishing
ins
pangilinan
moreover
claim
relies
heavily
proposition
citizen
father
right
transmit
citizenship
citizen
mother
shall
evaluate
alleged
discrimination
well
impact
see
craig
boren
iv
terms
ina
joint
conduct
citizen
alien
results
conception
sufficient
produce
american
citizen
regardless
whether
citizen
parent
male
female
partner
two
parties
engage
second
joint
agree
marry
one
follow
provision
issue
case
however
deals
cases
relevant
joint
conduct
occurs
conception
determines
ability
parties
acting
separately
confer
citizenship
child
born
outside
citizen
unmarried
female
must
first
choose
carry
pregnancy
term
reject
native
alternative
available
law
many
reality
women
around
world
must
actually
give
birth
child
section
rewards
choice
labor
conferring
citizenship
child
citizen
unmarried
male
need
participate
decision
give
birth
rather
choose
abortion
need
present
birth
least
years
thereafter
need
provide
parental
support
either
moral
financial
either
mother
child
order
preserve
right
confer
citizenship
child
pursuant
order
retroactively
transmit
citizenship
child
date
child
birth
requires
willing
able
acknowledge
paternity
writing
oath
child
still
minor
fact
requires
even
less
unmarried
provision
alternatively
satisfied
child
turns
paternity
established
adjudication
competent
appear
child
obtain
adjudication
absent
affirmative
act
father
perhaps
even
express
objection
thus
vast
difference
burdens
imposed
respective
parents
potential
citizens
born
wedlock
foreign
land
seems
obvious
burdens
imposed
female
citizen
severe
imposed
male
citizen
provision
issue
case
nevertheless
argued
male
citizen
offspring
victims
irrational
discrimination
product
stereotypes
relative
abilities
men
women
brief
peti
tioner
find
argument
singularly
unpersuasive
insofar
argument
rests
fact
male
citizen
parent
forever
forfeit
right
transmit
citizenship
come
forward
child
minor
whereas
limit
time
within
citizen
mother
may
prove
blood
relationship
argument
overlooks
difference
substantive
condition
procedural
limitation
substantive
conduct
unmarried
citizen
mother
qualifies
child
citizenship
completed
moment
birth
relevant
conduct
unmarried
citizen
father
child
may
occur
time
within
years
thereafter
however
procedural
hurdle
limits
time
method
either
parent
child
may
provide
state
department
evidence
necessary
steps
taken
transmit
citizenship
child
substantive
requirement
embodied
serves
least
part
ensure
person
born
wedlock
claims
citizenship
birth
actually
shares
blood
relationship
american
citizen
originally
enacted
required
simply
paternity
child
born
wedlock
established
child
age
years
legitimation
stat
section
offered
means
proving
biological
relationship
time
modified
ina
provisions
issue
fiallo
favor
unmarried
fathers
children
see
supra
congress
expanded
allow
two
alternatives
found
subsections
pub
stat
purpose
amendment
simplify
facilitate
determinations
acquisition
citizenship
children
born
wedlock
american
citizen
father
eliminating
necessity
determining
father
residence
domicile
establishing
satisfaction
legitimation
provisions
jurisdiction
hearings
amendment
also
added
requires
paternity
established
clear
convincing
evidence
order
deter
fraudulent
claims
standard
proof
viewed
ancillary
measure
replacement
proof
paternity
legitimation
formal
alternative
see
id
doubt
ensuring
reliable
proof
biological
relationship
potential
citizen
citizen
parent
important
governmental
objective
see
trimble
gordon
fiallo
denied
male
female
parents
differently
situated
respect
blood
relationship
birth
mother
immediately
obvious
typically
established
hospital
records
birth
certificates
relationship
unmarried
father
may
often
undisclosed
unrecorded
contemporary
public
record
thus
requirement
father
make
timely
written
acknowledgment
oath
child
obtain
adjudication
paternity
produces
rough
equivalent
documentation
already
available
evidence
blood
relationship
mother
child
statute
required
citizen
parent
whether
male
female
obtain
appropriate
formal
documentation
within
days
birth
face
even
though
practical
operation
disfavor
unmarried
males
virtually
every
case
requirement
superfluous
mother
surely
fact
statute
allows
years
provide
evidence
comparable
mother
provides
immediately
birth
viewed
discriminating
father
child
nevertheless
petitioner
reiterates
suggestion
irrational
require
formal
act
written
acknowledgment
adjudication
advent
reliable
genetic
testing
fully
addresses
problem
proving
paternity
subsection
already
requires
proof
paternity
clear
convincing
evidence
see
respectfully
disagree
nothing
subsection
requires
citizen
father
child
obtain
genetic
paternity
test
difficult
moreover
understand
signing
paternity
acknowledgment
oath
prior
child
birthday
burdensome
obtaining
genetic
test
relatively
expensive
normally
requires
physical
intrusion
putative
father
child
often
available
foreign
countries
congress
fairly
conclude
despite
recent
scientific
advances
still
remains
preferable
require
formal
legal
act
establish
paternity
coupled
evidence
standard
deter
fraud
time
limitation
turn
provides
assurance
formal
act
based
upon
reliable
evidence
also
deters
fraud
congress
course
free
revise
collective
judgment
permit
genetic
proof
paternity
rather
requiring
formal
legal
act
father
constitution
require
change
section
also
serves
two
important
purposes
unrelated
determination
paternity
interest
encouraging
development
healthy
relationship
citizen
parent
child
child
minor
related
interest
fostering
ties
child
child
born
wedlock
outside
citizen
mother
unlike
citizen
father
certainly
knows
child
existence
typically
custody
child
immediately
birth
child
thus
opportunity
develop
ties
citizen
mother
early
age
may
even
grow
mother
returns
contrast
due
normal
interval
nine
months
conception
birth
unmarried
father
may
even
know
child
exists
child
may
know
father
identity
section
requires
relatively
easy
formal
step
either
citizen
father
child
shows
beyond
doubt
least
one
two
knows
blood
relationship
thus
assuring
least
opportunity
develop
personal
relationship
facts
case
provide
ready
example
concern
miller
petitioner
failed
take
steps
establish
legal
relationship
petitioner
birthday
indication
record
contact
whatsoever
applied
passport
given
size
american
military
establishment
stationed
various
parts
world
past
half
century
reasonable
assume
case
unusual
petitioner
born
service
personnel
stationed
far
east
philippines
dept
commerce
statistical
abstract
ed
americans
military
time
one
percent
female
figures
coupled
interval
conception
birth
fact
military
personnel
regularly
return
tour
duty
ends
suggest
congress
legitimate
concerns
class
children
born
abroad
wedlock
alien
mothers
american
men
necessarily
know
known
children
surely
reasonable
ina
enacted
remains
equally
reasonable
today
congress
condition
award
citizenship
children
act
demonstrates
minimum
possibility
become
citizens
develop
ties
requirement
performs
meaningful
purpose
citizen
fathers
normally
superfluous
citizen
mothers
course
possible
child
born
foreign
country
may
ultimately
fail
establish
ties
citizen
parent
country
even
though
child
citizen
parent
engaged
conduct
qualifies
child
citizenship
citizen
mother
may
abandon
child
returning
citizen
father
even
acknowledging
paternity
may
die
abscond
child
opportunity
bond
visit
country
fact
interest
fostering
ties
country
may
fully
achieved
either
class
children
qualify
legitimacy
importance
interest
congress
reasonably
may
assumed
formal
requirements
tend
make
likely
fathers
opportunity
develop
meaningful
relationship
children
fact
mother
knows
baby
existence
often
custody
birth
statute
effect
reduce
rather
aggravate
disparity
two
classes
children
convinced
strong
governmental
interests
justify
additional
requirement
imposed
children
citizen
fathers
also
particular
means
used
well
tailored
serve
interests
perfectly
appropriate
require
formal
act
evidence
father
child
know
existence
formal
act
whether
legitimation
written
acknowledgment
father
adjudication
lessens
risk
fraudulent
claims
made
years
relevant
conduct
required
requirement
formal
act
take
place
child
minor
congress
obviously
powerful
interest
fostering
ties
child
citizen
parent
formative
years
reliable
contemporaneous
proof
child
citizen
father
opportunity
form
familial
bonds
child
turned
congress
reasonably
may
demand
child
show
sufficient
ties
country
rather
citizen
parent
order
citizen
conclusion
congress
may
require
affirmative
act
unmarried
fathers
children
mothers
children
directly
supported
decision
lehr
robertson
case
involved
new
york
law
automatically
provided
mothers
illegitimate
children
prior
notice
adoption
proceeding
right
veto
adoption
extended
rights
unmarried
fathers
whose
claim
paternity
supported
formal
public
act
adjudication
filing
notice
intent
claim
paternity
written
acknowledgment
mother
id
petitioner
lehr
unmarried
putative
father
need
mailed
postcard
state
putative
father
registry
enjoy
rights
child
undisputed
mother
id
yet
argued
requirement
violated
equal
protection
clause
rejected
argument
find
comparable
claim
case
anything
even
less
persuasive
whereas
putative
father
lehr
deprived
certain
rights
failed
take
affirmative
step
within
two
years
child
birth
adoption
proceeding
took
place
unfavorable
treatment
attributable
miller
failure
take
appropriate
action
within
years
petitioner
birth
petitioner
failure
obtain
paternity
adjudication
competent
turned
even
though
rule
applicable
class
children
born
abroad
eminently
reasonable
justified
important
government
policies
petitioner
amici
argue
unconstitutional
classification
shall
comment
briefly
argument
words
stereotype
stereotyping
stereotypical
used
repeatedly
petitioner
amici
briefs
note
condemned
statutory
classifications
rest
assumption
gender
may
serve
proxy
relevant
qualifications
serve
administrator
estate
reed
reed
engage
professional
nursing
mississippi
univ
women
hogan
train
military
service
virginia
name
examples
moreover
expressly
repudiated
cases
rested
assumption
members
one
sex
suitably
practice
law
tend
bar
see
hogan
commenting
bradwell
state
wall
goesaert
cleary
discrimination
merely
accidental
byproduct
traditional
way
thinking
females
unacceptable
califano
goldfarb
stevens
concurring
judgment
gender
equality
principle
implicated
cases
indirectly
involved
case
two
reasons
first
conclusion
petitioner
citizen
rests
several
coinciding
factors
gender
citizen
parent
facts
case
even
petitioner
mother
citizen
father
alien
petitioner
qualify
citizenship
mother
never
alternatively
citizen
parent
female
member
air
force
like
miller
returned
end
tour
duty
quite
probably
irrelevant
petitioner
become
citizen
birth
force
constitution
second
merely
sex
citizen
parent
determines
whether
child
citizen
terms
statute
rather
event
creating
legal
relationship
parent
birth
citizen
mothers
postbirth
conduct
citizen
fathers
offspring
nevertheless
may
assume
classification
merely
product
outmoded
stereotype
invalid
gender
stereotypes
supposedly
premised
american
father
never
anything
proverbial
breadwinner
remains
aloof
child
rearing
duties
mother
closer
child
born
wedlock
father
even
disregarding
statute
separate
purpose
ensuring
reliable
proof
blood
relationship
neither
propositions
fairly
reflects
justifications
classification
actually
issue
section
concerned
either
average
father
even
average
father
child
born
wedlock
concerned
father
whose
child
born
foreign
country
unwilling
unable
acknowledge
paternity
whose
child
unable
unwilling
obtain
paternity
adjudication
congressional
assumption
father
child
especially
unlikely
develop
relationship
thus
foster
child
ties
country
solid
basis
even
assume
fathers
made
effort
become
acquainted
children
good
better
parents
members
opposite
sex
statute
assume
mothers
illegitimate
children
necessarily
closer
relationship
children
fathers
assume
present
event
transmits
citizenship
child
hospital
records
birth
certificates
normally
make
acknowledgment
formal
proof
parentage
unnecessary
initial
custody
least
give
opportunity
develop
caring
relationship
child
section
provision
need
therefore
supported
undisputed
assumption
fathers
less
likely
mothers
opportunity
develop
relationships
simply
justice
breyer
contends
post
less
likely
take
advantage
opportunity
exists
assumptions
firmly
grounded
adequately
explain
congress
found
unnecessary
impose
requirements
mother
entirely
appropriate
father
none
premises
statutory
classification
grounded
fairly
characterized
accidental
byproduct
traditional
way
thinking
members
either
sex
biological
differences
single
men
single
women
provide
relevant
basis
differing
rules
governing
ability
confer
citizenship
children
born
foreign
lands
indeed
suggestion
simply
congress
authorized
citizenship
birth
children
born
abroad
unmarried
mothers
impose
conditions
upon
granting
citizenship
children
zen
fathers
might
characterized
merely
byproduct
strong
presumption
legal
distinctions
suspect
impartial
analysis
relevant
differences
citizen
mothers
citizen
fathers
plainly
rebuts
presumption
judgment
appeals
affirmed
ordered
see
michael
superior
sonoma
stevens
dissenting
justice
scalia
argues
petitioner
suit
must
dismissed
courts
power
provide
relief
requested
post
conclude
constitutional
violation
remedy
express
ion
question
writ
certiorari
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
april
justice
justice
kennedy
joins
concurring
judgment
long
applied
presumption
standing
prudential
limitation
exercise
federal
jurisdiction
federal
courts
held
must
hesitate
resolving
controversy
even
one
within
constitutional
power
resolve
basis
rights
third
persons
parties
litigation
singleton
wulff
see
also
warth
seldin
contrary
prudential
rule
recognizes
petitioner
standing
raise
equal
protection
challenge
statute
however
accords
differential
treatment
fathers
mothers
sons
daughters
thus
although
petitioner
clearly
injured
fact
denied
citizenship
discriminatory
impact
provision
falls
petitioner
father
charlie
miller
longer
party
suit
consequently
believe
consider
petitioner
gender
discrimination
claim
recognizes
petitioner
claim
turns
proposition
citizen
father
right
transmit
citizenship
citizen
mother
resolves
evaluate
alleged
discrimination
petitioner
father
well
impact
petitioner
ante
even
allegedly
illegal
act
affects
litigant
also
affects
third
party
plaintiff
rest
claim
relief
legal
rights
interests
third
part
department
labor
triplett
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
party
raising
constitutional
challenge
statute
must
demonstrate
alleged
unconstitutional
feature
statute
injures
also
within
class
persons
respect
act
unconstitutional
heald
district
columbia
requirement
arises
understanding
thirdparty
rightholder
may
fact
wish
assert
claim
question
well
belief
third
parties
usually
best
proponents
rights
singleton
supra
see
also
holden
hardy
support
decision
consider
charlie
miller
claim
justice
stevens
writing
justice
breyer
dissent
cite
craig
boren
case
allowed
vendor
challenge
state
law
permitted
sales
beer
females
reached
age
prohibited
sales
males
turned
law
proscribed
sale
rather
consumption
beer
determined
vendor
least
awkward
challenger
distinction
id
reasoned
prudential
objectives
served
rejecting
standing
lower
already
ha
entertained
relevant
constitutional
challenge
id
however
expressly
take
account
charlie
miller
equal
protection
rights
instead
reviewing
petitioner
challenge
claim
gender
discrimination
children
citizen
fathers
opposed
children
citizen
mothers
see
cadc
importantly
since
decided
craig
articulated
contours
standing
inquiry
greater
detail
powers
ohio
stated
litigant
seeking
assert
rights
another
party
must
satisfy
three
interrelated
criteria
litigant
must
suffered
injury
fact
thus
giving
sufficiently
concrete
interest
outcome
issue
dispute
litigant
must
close
relation
third
party
must
exist
hindrance
third
party
ability
protect
interests
id
internal
quotation
marks
citations
omitted
see
also
campbell
louisiana
slip
seems
clear
petitioner
significant
stake
challenging
statute
close
relationship
father
demonstrated
substantial
hindrance
father
ability
assert
rights
powers
earlier
precedents
suggest
absence
obstacle
precludes
standing
see
explaining
three
important
criteria
must
satisfied
must
exist
hindrance
third
party
ability
protect
interests
presumption
rebutted
see
also
singleton
supra
even
relationship
close
reasons
requiring
persons
assert
rights
generally
still
apply
petitioner
demonstrated
charlie
miller
confronted
genuine
obstacle
assertion
rights
rises
level
hindrance
see
also
barrows
jackson
standing
accorded
difficult
impossible
persons
whose
rights
asserted
present
grievance
fact
charlie
miller
originally
filed
suit
asserted
rights
opted
pursue
claim
throughout
litigation
true
wrongly
dismissed
action
eastern
district
texas
government
made
misguided
argument
rights
injured
lorelyn
penero
miller
true
plaintiff
action
see
motion
dismiss
plaintiff
first
amended
complaint
alternative
transfer
venue
failed
appeal
erroneous
dismissal
claim
hindrance
vindication
charlie
miller
constitutional
rights
ultimately
self
imposed
reluctant
accept
government
litigation
strategy
unfavorable
ruling
lower
courts
sufficiently
severe
obstacle
assertion
litigant
rights
warrant
exception
prudential
standing
requirements
requirements
adopted
serve
institutional
interests
federal
courts
convenience
litigants
see
dallas
bender
williamsport
area
school
justice
breyer
asserts
appeals
take
time
money
change
venue
left
charlie
miller
uncertain
appeal
see
post
obstacle
inconvenience
caused
normal
course
litigation
often
involves
transfer
venue
charlie
miller
never
indicated
intent
challenge
dismissal
suit
suggestion
faced
unusual
practical
legal
barriers
filing
notice
appeal
instituting
suit
burdensomearguably
burdensome
filing
appeal
denial
conclude
course
events
transpired
case
constituted
hindrance
charlie
miller
ability
assert
rights
step
toward
eliminating
hindrance
prong
altogether
thus
far
permitted
standing
daunting
barriers
deterred
rightholder
powers
supra
take
extreme
example
hodel
irving
concluded
plaintiffs
standing
assert
rights
deceased
parents
id
powers
noted
potential
jurors
parties
proceeding
easily
obtain
declaratory
injunctive
relief
prosecutor
exercise
peremptory
challenges
find
difficult
demonstrate
likelihood
discrimination
recur
economic
disincentives
filing
suit
privacy
concerns
may
also
provide
compelling
explanation
third
party
absence
litigation
carey
population
services
determined
vendor
challenge
law
prohibiting
distribution
contraceptives
minors
desire
avoid
publicity
deter
potential
purchasers
defending
rights
id
see
also
eisenstadt
baird
likewise
innaacp
alabama
ex
rel
patterson
held
organization
raise
privacy
rights
members
litigation
initiated
members
disclose
identity
destroy
privacy
sought
protect
id
insurmountable
procedural
obstacles
preclude
rightholder
suit
also
accorded
standing
singleton
concluded
physicians
assert
rights
indigent
women
denied
funding
abortion
imminent
mootness
prevented
women
bringing
claims
see
similarly
barrows
involved
constitutional
rights
prospective
victims
racially
restrictive
real
estate
covenant
unidentified
thus
see
craig
case
garners
sole
support
according
standing
named
plaintiff
turned
course
litigation
mooted
challenge
striction
see
legitimate
obstacles
exist
lie
beyond
control
rightholder
party
absence
suit
likely
stems
disability
disinterest
hindrance
signals
rightholder
simply
decline
bring
claim
behalf
fact
see
singleton
supra
genuine
obstacle
third
party
absence
loses
tendency
suggest
right
truly
stake
truly
important
party
becomes
default
right
best
available
proponent
furthermore
hindrance
impedes
assertion
claim
right
likely
thus
relevant
law
recognizes
standing
barrows
example
permitted
thirdparty
standing
reasons
underlie
rule
denying
standing
raise
another
rights
outweighed
need
protect
fundamental
rights
otherwise
denied
moreover
contrast
case
white
property
owner
contesting
racially
restrictive
covenant
barrows
effective
adversary
one
whose
charge
keeping
repose
power
continue
use
property
discriminate
discontinue
use
id
although
injured
party
us
party
actually
discriminated
best
suited
challenging
statute
available
undertake
task
see
gladstone
realtors
village
bellwood
prudential
barriers
seek
limit
access
federal
courts
litigants
best
suited
assert
particular
claim
light
petitioner
uncertain
constitutional
status
potential
problems
fashioning
remedy
injury
see
post
scalia
concurring
judg
ment
allowing
assert
charlie
miller
claim
likely
dilute
rather
protect
constitutional
rights
although
petitioner
raise
father
rights
may
raise
unclear
whether
alien
may
assert
constitutional
objections
outside
territory
see
johnson
eisentrager
assume
petitioner
may
challenge
constitutionality
challenge
however
triggers
rational
basis
scrutiny
pointed
see
supra
draw
distinction
based
gender
child
petitioner
claim
injured
gender
discrimination
see
allen
wright
injury
arising
discrimination
accords
basis
standing
persons
personally
denied
equal
treatment
challenged
discriminatory
conduct
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
moreover
grant
certiorari
limited
question
whether
discriminates
children
citizen
mothers
children
citizen
fathers
claim
discrimination
based
differential
treatment
illegitimate
versus
legitimate
children
presented
see
given
petitioner
raise
claim
discrimination
triggering
heightened
scrutiny
argue
irrationally
discriminates
illegitimate
children
citizen
fathers
citizen
mothers
although
share
justice
stevens
assessment
provision
withstands
heightened
scrutiny
ante
believe
passes
rational
scrutiny
reasons
gives
sustaining
higher
standard
unlikely
opinion
gender
classifications
based
stereotypes
survive
heightened
scrutiny
rational
scrutiny
statute
may
defended
based
generalized
classifications
unsupported
empirical
evidence
see
heller
doe
classification
must
upheld
equal
protection
challenge
reasonably
conceivable
state
facts
provide
rational
basis
classification
state
moreover
obligation
produce
evidence
sustain
rationality
statutory
classification
internal
quotation
marks
citations
omitted
particularly
true
classification
adopted
reference
immigration
area
congress
frequently
must
base
decisions
generalizations
groups
people
adopted
presumption
standing
preserve
properly
limited
role
warth
identified
particular
set
circumstances
rebut
presumption
believe
treat
considerations
particular
hindrance
prong
meaningful
criteria
consequently
accord
petitioner
standing
raise
father
claim
gender
discrimination
petitioner
constitutional
challenge
triggers
rational
basis
scrutiny
sustainable
standard
accordingly
concur
judgment
affirming
appeals
decision
writ
certiorari
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
april
justice
scalia
justice
thomas
joins
curring
judgment
agree
outcome
case
reason
fundamental
one
relied
upon
justice
stevens
view
makes
difference
whether
passes
heightened
scrutiny
test
members
might
choose
apply
complaint
must
dismissed
power
provide
relief
requested
conferral
citizenship
basis
prescribed
congress
constitution
contemplates
two
sources
citizenship
two
birth
naturalization
wong
kim
ark
fourteenth
amendment
person
born
subject
jurisdiction
thereof
becomes
citizen
needs
naturalization
ibid
petitioner
born
outside
territory
alien
far
constitution
concerned
become
citizen
naturalized
either
treaty
case
annexation
foreign
territory
authority
congress
id
see
also
rogers
bellei
authority
congress
appealed
power
art
cl
establish
uniform
rule
naturalization
congressional
enactment
granting
petitioner
citizenship
remains
alien
enactment
petitioner
relies
immigration
nationality
act
ina
stat
amended
establishes
requirements
acquisition
citizenship
child
born
wedlock
child
father
citizen
section
provides
relevant
part
confers
citizenship
children
one
parent
alien
citizen
shall
apply
date
birth
person
born
wedlock
blood
relationship
person
father
established
clear
convincing
evidence
father
nationality
time
person
birth
father
unless
deceased
agreed
writing
provide
financial
support
person
person
reaches
age
years
person
age
years
person
legitimated
law
person
residence
domicile
father
acknowledges
paternity
person
writing
oath
paternity
person
established
adjudication
competent
plain
language
sets
forth
precondition
acquisition
citizenship
illegitimate
child
petitioner
come
federal
claiming
met
precondition
state
department
conclusion
contrary
factually
error
rather
acknowledges
meet
last
two
requirements
precondition
nonetheless
asks
declaratory
judgment
citizen
order
secretary
state
requiring
state
department
grant
application
citizenship
app
requirements
meet
also
imposed
upon
illegitimate
children
therefore
violate
equal
protection
clause
even
agree
difference
treatment
illegitimate
children
unconstitutional
consistent
limited
judicial
power
area
remedy
constitutional
infirmity
declaring
petitioner
citizen
ordering
state
department
approve
application
citizenship
determined
person
qualify
citizenship
district
discretion
ignore
defect
grant
citizenship
ins
pangilinan
internal
quotation
marks
citation
omitted
judicial
power
immigration
naturalization
extremely
limited
cases
long
recognized
power
expel
exclude
aliens
fundamental
sovereign
attribute
exercised
government
political
departments
largely
immune
judicial
control
fiallo
bell
quoting
shaughnessy
ex
rel
mezei
see
also
landon
plasencia
power
admit
exclude
aliens
sovereign
prerogative
mathews
diaz
exercise
broad
power
naturalization
immigration
congress
regularly
makes
rules
unacceptable
applied
citizens
kleindienst
mandel
lenary
congressional
power
make
policies
rules
exclusion
aliens
long
firmly
established
galvan
press
formulation
policies
pertaining
entry
aliens
right
remain
entrusted
exclusively
congress
become
firmly
imbedded
legislative
judicial
tissues
body
politic
aspect
government
congress
power
set
requirements
acquisition
citizenship
persons
born
within
territory
federal
courts
exercise
power
guise
remedial
authority
neither
application
doctrine
estoppel
invocation
equitable
powers
means
power
confer
citizenship
violation
statutory
limitations
pangilinan
supra
alien
seeks
political
rights
member
nation
rightfully
obtain
upon
terms
conditions
specified
congress
courts
without
authority
sanction
changes
ginsberg
emphasis
added
petitioner
argues
justice
breyer
dissent
seems
agree
see
post
breyer
dissenting
meets
requirements
may
declare
citizen
birth
provision
ignore
entirely
allegedly
unconstitutionally
takes
away
citizenship
brief
petitioner
argument
adopts
fanciful
view
statute
whereby
takes
away
unconditionally
though
sort
condition
subsequent
conveyance
real
estate
anything
course
condition
precedent
since
says
shall
apply
date
birth
person
born
wedlock
person
meets
requirements
set
forth
emphasis
added
unitary
statute
picked
apart
fashion
sure
read
isolation
might
refer
married
unmarried
parents
however
read
statutory
provisions
isolation
provisions
act
exist
see
king
vincent
hospital
section
confer
citizenship
upon
children
born
wedlock
unless
requirements
satisfied
argued
exempting
applicant
unconstitutional
requirement
either
part
rewriting
law
simply
ignoring
portion
law
nullity
see
post
breyer
dissenting
assumes
however
judicial
power
sever
unconstitutional
portion
remainder
apply
remainder
unencumbered
power
exists
exercised
basis
assessment
whether
congress
enacted
remainder
law
without
invalidated
provision
see
new
york
know
instance
however
severed
unconstitutional
restriction
upon
grant
immigration
citizenship
view
incompatible
plenary
power
congress
fields
judges
speculate
congress
enacted
enacted
example
preferred
extend
requirements
mothers
instead
eliminating
fathers
even
deny
citizenship
illegitimate
children
entirely
specifically
recognized
power
congress
grant
citizen
right
transmit
citizenship
descent
rogers
moreover
mere
character
naturalization
power
enough
render
severing
limitation
upon
citizenship
improper
ina
contains
clear
statement
congressional
intent
person
may
naturalized
citizen
manner
conditions
prescribed
subchapter
otherwise
emphasis
added
justice
breyer
reliance
upon
ina
general
severability
clause
stat
misplaced
specific
governs
general
see
morales
trans
world
airlines
question
severance
ultimately
turns
whether
provisions
inseparable
virtue
inherent
character
carter
carter
coal
must
gleaned
structure
nature
act
another
obstacle
judicial
deletion
challenged
requirements
fact
statutory
violation
equal
protection
occurred
foreordained
particular
statutory
provision
invalid
constitutional
vice
consists
unequal
treatment
may
logically
attributed
disparately
generous
provi
sion
supposedly
provision
governing
citizenship
illegitimate
children
citizen
mothers
disparately
parsimonious
one
provision
governing
citizenship
illegitimate
children
citizen
fathers
noted
sustaining
equal
protection
claim
faces
remedial
alternatives
may
either
declare
statute
nullity
order
benefits
extend
class
legislature
intended
benefit
may
extend
coverage
statute
include
aggrieved
exclusion
heckler
mathews
quoting
welsh
harlan
concurring
result
given
nature
law
issue
given
clear
command
conditions
prescribed
subchapter
otherwise
doubt
alternatives
must
employ
confer
citizenship
congress
done
event
like
ordinary
equal
protection
case
one
class
subjected
restriction
class
exempt
see
craig
boren
men
served
alcoholic
beverages
years
age
whereas
women
need
class
subjected
restrictions
exempt
illegitimate
children
citizen
fathers
must
meet
requirements
illegitimate
children
citizen
mothers
exempt
illegitimate
children
citizen
mothers
must
meet
quite
different
requirements
illegitimate
children
citizen
fathers
exempt
situation
eliminating
strictions
fathers
produce
law
complies
equal
protection
clause
assuming
initially
violation
rather
produces
law
treats
fathers
favorably
mothers
way
fix
law
merely
disregarding
one
provision
unconstitutional
disregard
either
leaving
restrictions
whatever
upon
citizenship
illegitimate
children
think
proper
course
denying
naturalization
illegitimate
children
entirely
since
meant
apply
unqualified
terms
illegitimate
children
even
outside
particularly
sensitive
area
immigration
naturalization
aware
case
engaged
radical
statutory
surgery
certainly
engaged
sum
case
power
remedy
alleged
equal
protection
violation
either
expanding
limiting
benefits
conferred
deny
grant
equally
dealing
exercise
nation
sovereign
power
admit
exclude
foreigners
accordance
perceived
national
interests
fiallo
federal
judges
may
decide
national
interests
requirements
citizenship
best
serve
petitioner
citizen
act
congress
give
declaratory
judgment
affirmative
relief
requests
therefore
concur
judgment
writ
certiorari
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
april
justice
ginsburg
justice
souter
justice
breyer
join
dissenting
justice
breyer
convincingly
demonstrates
classifies
unconstitutionally
basis
gender
determining
capacity
parent
qualify
child
citizenship
section
rests
familiar
generalizations
mothers
rule
responsible
child
born
wedlock
fathers
unmarried
child
mother
ordinarily
law
issue
might
made
custody
support
relevant
criterion
instead
treats
mothers
one
way
fathers
another
shaping
government
policy
fit
reinforce
stereotype
historic
pattern
characteristic
classifications
stereotypes
underlying
legislation
may
hold
true
many
even
individuals
prior
decisions
rejected
official
actions
classify
unnecessarily
overbroadly
gender
accurate
impartial
functional
lines
drawn
divided
lorelyn
miller
standing
sue
solid
majority
adheres
vital
understanding
justice
opinion
makes
plain
distinctions
based
gender
trigger
heightened
scrutiny
unlikely
gender
classifications
based
stereotypes
survive
heightened
scrutiny
ante
opinion
concurring
judgment
post
breyer
dissenting
surface
treats
females
favorably
indeed
might
seen
benign
preference
affirmative
action
sorts
compare
mississippi
univ
women
hogan
id
powell
dissenting
two
justices
today
apparently
take
view
justice
stevens
opinion
chief
justice
joins
portrays
helpfully
recognizing
different
situations
unmarried
mothers
fathers
period
birth
fairly
equalizing
burdens
parent
bears
see
ante
pages
history
place
provision
perspective
section
one
provisions
remaining
code
uses
sex
criterion
delineating
citizens
rights
innovation
respect
nation
past
laws
transmission
citizenship
parent
child
discriminated
adversely
citizen
mothers
citizen
fathers
first
statute
citizenship
children
born
abroad
enacted
stated
children
citizens
may
born
beyond
sea
limits
shall
considered
natural
born
citizens
provided
right
citizenship
shall
descend
persons
whose
fathers
never
resident
act
mar
ch
stat
statutes
passed
similarly
conditioned
citizenship
child
born
abroad
father
least
residence
act
stat
act
apr
stat
father
residence
requirement
suggests
congress
intended
child
born
abroad
gain
citizenship
father
citizen
indeed
law
england
time
see
kent
commentaries
american
law
hereinafter
kent
commentaries
geo
ch
statutory
language
congress
adopted
however
ambiguous
one
read
words
children
citizens
mean
child
citizen
mother
foreign
father
qualify
citizenship
father
point
resided
country
see
binney
alienigenae
reg
chancellor
kent
observed
words
might
mean
parents
citizens
citizenship
pass
kent
commentaries
legislation
children
born
abroad
become
citizens
unless
parents
citizens
meant
years
passed
foreignborn
persons
qualify
daniel
webster
among
others
proposed
remedial
legislation
bill
granted
citizenship
children
born
abroad
citizen
mothers
well
fathers
effort
unsuccessful
see
cong
globe
franklin
legislative
history
naturalization
reprint
ed
instead
congress
clarified
citizenship
pass
children
born
abroad
father
citizen
act
stat
codified
revised
statutes
provision
originating
read
children
heretofore
born
hereafter
born
limits
jurisdiction
whose
fathers
may
time
birth
citizens
thereof
declared
citizens
rights
citizenship
shall
descend
children
whose
fathers
never
resided
rev
stat
early
statutes
congress
differentiate
children
born
abroad
married
parents
born
wedlock
section
applied
allowed
transmission
citizenship
children
born
wedlock
father
legitimated
child
see
op
atty
see
also
guyer
smith
md
foreign
born
children
remain
illegitimate
qualify
citizenship
several
reported
instances
children
legitimated
fathers
gained
citizenship
even
though
legitimation
occurred
lorelyn
miller
case
child
reached
majority
see
gordon
mailman
immigration
law
procedure
pp
hereinafter
gordon
see
hackworth
digest
international
law
noting
case
legitimation
deemed
sufficient
maintaining
ormally
legitimation
must
take
place
minority
child
early
part
century
state
department
permitted
transmission
citizenship
unwed
mother
child
reasoning
child
born
wedlock
mother
stands
place
father
house
committee
immigration
naturalization
report
proposing
revision
codification
nationality
laws
part
one
proposed
code
explanatory
comments
comm
print
hereinafter
proposed
code
ultimately
however
attorney
general
rejected
department
reasoning
finding
incompatible
exclusive
reference
fathers
see
op
atty
women
inability
transmit
citizenship
children
born
abroad
one
among
many
distinctions
drawn
immigration
nationality
laws
woman
married
foreign
citizen
risked
losing
nationality
early
days
marriage
alien
whether
friend
enemy
produce
dissolution
native
allegiance
wife
shanks
dupont
pet
story
end
nineteenth
century
however
courts
adopted
view
woman
nationality
followed
husband
see
pequignot
detroit
cc
ed
particularly
woman
resided
abroad
husband
country
see
ruckgaber
moore
cc
ed
ny
see
generally
bredbenner
toward
independent
citizenship
married
women
nationality
rights
ph
dissertation
university
virginia
hereinafter
bredbenner
sapiro
women
citizenship
nationality
immigration
naturalization
policies
politics
soc
state
department
officials
inclined
towards
view
well
see
gettys
law
citizenship
congress
settled
matter
provided
statute
female
citizen
automatically
lost
citizenship
upon
marriage
alien
act
mar
stat
upheld
statute
noting
identity
husband
wife
ancient
principle
jurisprudence
mackenzie
hare
statutory
rule
women
relinquished
citizenship
upon
marriage
alien
encountered
increasing
opposition
fueled
large
part
women
suffrage
movement
enhanced
importance
citizenship
women
obtained
right
vote
see
bredbenner
sapiro
supra
response
congress
provided
measure
relief
cable
act
marriage
alien
longer
stripped
woman
citizenship
automatically
act
cable
act
ch
stat
equal
respect
woman
nationality
remained
partially
realized
woman
still
lost
citizenship
married
alien
ineligible
citizenship
become
citizen
naturalization
husband
qualify
citizenship
presumed
renounced
citizenship
lived
abroad
husband
country
two
years
lived
abroad
elsewhere
five
years
id
see
also
sapiro
supra
woman
became
naturalized
citizen
unable
transmit
citizenship
children
noncitizen
husband
remained
alive
separated
see
citizenship
status
minor
children
nj
status
wife
dependent
upon
husband
therefore
children
acquired
citizenship
source
theretofore
existent
common
law
see
also
gettys
supra
restrictions
like
kind
applied
male
citizens
instead
congress
treated
wives
children
male
citizens
immigrants
benevolently
legislation
automatically
granted
citizenship
women
married
citizens
act
ch
stat
see
also
kelly
owen
wall
act
confers
privileges
citizenship
upon
women
married
citizens
without
action
statute
male
alien
died
completing
residence
requirement
actual
naturalization
widow
children
considered
citizens
act
mar
stat
measure
granted
corresponding
dispensation
husband
children
alien
woman
addition
congress
provided
statutory
exemptions
entry
requirements
wives
children
men
husbands
children
women
see
act
mar
stat
wives
children
enter
ing
country
join
permanent
resident
aliens
found
contracted
contagious
diseases
transit
shall
deported
diseases
easily
curable
present
danger
others
wives
exempt
literacy
quota
requirements
congress
moved
new
direction
terminated
discrimination
citizen
mothers
regard
children
born
abroad
specifically
congress
amended
read
child
hereafter
born
limits
jurisdiction
whose
father
mother
time
birth
child
citizen
declared
citizen
rights
citizenship
shall
descend
child
unless
citizen
father
citizen
mother
case
may
resided
previous
birth
child
act
may
stat
senate
house
reports
act
stated
change
made
establish
complete
equality
american
men
women
matter
citizenship
children
accord
see
generally
orfield
citi
zenship
act
chi
rev
congress
speak
children
born
wedlock
act
construed
authorizing
transmission
american
citizenship
descent
american
citizen
mother
child
born
abroad
wedlock
conditions
child
born
wedlock
gordon
see
also
id
iii
act
equal
respect
citizenship
stature
mothers
fathers
children
born
abroad
remain
unmodified
six
years
later
congress
passed
nationality
act
replaced
revised
statutes
single
provision
citizenship
children
born
abroad
array
provisions
turned
whether
child
born
outlying
possession
whether
one
child
parents
citizens
whether
child
born
wedlock
act
preserved
congress
earlier
recognition
parental
equality
regard
children
born
wedlock
established
different
regime
children
born
wedlock
one
disadvantaged
citizen
fathers
children
act
mother
child
born
abroad
wedlock
held
citizenship
previously
resided
country
possession
child
gained
mother
nationality
birth
provided
child
paternity
established
legitimation
order
father
mother
held
citizenship
child
qualify
citizenship
upon
legitimation
adjudication
paternity
child
minority
furthermore
child
generally
live
five
years
age
residency
requirement
applied
children
born
abroad
married
couples
one
citizen
parent
whether
parent
mother
father
nationality
act
stat
subsequent
legislation
retained
gender
lines
drawn
act
immigration
nationality
act
made
one
significant
change
regarding
citizenship
children
born
abroad
wedlock
removed
provision
mother
pass
nationality
child
paternity
child
established
immigration
nationality
act
stat
however
congress
added
differentials
legislature
year
permitted
substitution
written
acknowledgment
oath
adjudication
paternity
prior
age
place
formal
legitimation
extent
congress
eased
access
citizenship
child
born
abroad
wedlock
citizen
father
time
however
congress
imposed
child
two
requirements
production
clear
convincing
evidence
paternity
also
written
statement
father
promising
support
child
turned
requirements
child
citizen
mother
remained
child
obtained
mother
nationality
mother
resided
territorial
possessions
least
year
child
birth
act
stat
codified
amended
substantive
change
made
since
law
governing
citizenship
children
born
abroad
wedlock
ii
history
treatment
children
born
abroad
citizen
parents
counsels
skeptical
examination
government
prime
explanation
gender
line
drawn
close
connection
mother
child
contrast
distant
fleeting
link
justice
stevens
puts
mother
presence
birth
identification
birth
certificate
likely
initial
custody
child
give
opportunity
develop
caring
relationship
child
ante
congress
legitimately
assume
father
lacks
nation
past
congress
demonstrated
high
regard
respect
affiliation
bears
emphasis
congress
allowed
citizen
mothers
transmit
citizenship
children
congress
simultaneously
first
time
required
children
unless
parents
citizens
fulfill
residence
requirement
right
citizenship
shall
descend
unless
child
comes
resides
therein
least
five
years
continuously
immediately
previous
eighteenth
birthday
act
may
stat
commentary
underscores
text
conveys
congress
largely
relied
residence
requirement
sex
child
citizen
parent
assure
abiding
affiliation
see
proposed
code
even
one
accepts
face
value
government
current
rationale
surely
based
generalizations
stereotypes
way
women
men
generalizations
pervade
opinion
justice
stevens
constantly
relates
relies
typically
normally
probably
happens
often
ante
repeatedly
cautioned
however
government
controls
gates
opportunity
may
exclude
qualified
individuals
based
notions
concerning
roles
abilities
males
females
virginia
slip
quoting
mississippi
univ
women
hogan
see
also
orr
orr
state
purposes
well
served
classification
one
gender
classifies
therefore
carries
baggage
sexual
stereotypes
state
permitted
classify
basis
persuasive
justification
kirchberg
feenstra
quoting
personnel
administrator
mass
feeney
one
rely
overbroad
generalizations
different
talents
capacities
preferences
males
females
virginia
slip
support
differential
treatment
men
women
see
alabama
ex
rel
kennedy
concurring
judgment
noting
prevail
ing
case
law
reveal
strong
presumption
gender
classifications
invalid
one
demur
government
observation
citizen
mothers
children
born
abroad
wedlock
actually
raise
children
citizen
fathers
children
justice
breyer
elucidated
observation
justify
distinctions
male
female
citizens
take
responsibility
avoid
responsibility
raising
children
justify
reliance
gender
distinctions
alleged
close
ties
achieved
without
reference
gender
judge
wald
commented
discussing
analogous
claim
case
appeals
congress
free
promote
close
family
ties
ensuring
citizenship
conferred
children
least
minimal
contact
citizen
parents
early
formative
years
putative
interest
provides
absolutely
basis
requiring
fathers
fathers
formally
declare
parentage
agree
provide
financial
support
child
reaches
age
miller
christopher
cadc
wald
concurring
judgment
doubt
true
many
female
citizens
gave
birth
abroad
married
foreigners
moved
husbands
country
children
marriages
brought
natives
foreign
land
female
citizen
married
citizen
children
born
abroad
obtain
citizenship
father
thus
historic
restriction
citizenship
children
born
abroad
citizen
fathers
may
affected
many
women
words
one
woman
testified
favor
act
later
became
first
woman
sit
federal
district
judge
hether
lot
people
suffer
whether
suffer
seems
us
principle
equal
application
law
men
women
receive
recognition
hearings
house
committee
immigration
naturalization
testimony
burnita
shelton
matthews
congress
recognized
equality
principle
positioned
restore
impartiality
century
note
feasible
syllabus
headnote
released
done
connection
case
time
opinion
issued
syllabus
constitutes
part
opinion
prepared
reporter
decisions
convenience
reader
see
detroit
timber
lumber
co
syllabus
certiorari
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
argued
november
decided
april
petitioner
born
wedlock
philippines
mother
filipino
national
father
charlie
miller
american
citizen
residing
texas
served
military
philippines
time
petitioner
conception
never
married
petitioner
mother
evidence
philippines
time
birth
ever
returned
completing
tour
duty
state
department
denied
petitioner
application
registration
citizen
texas
granted
miller
petition
paternity
decree
finding
father
petitioner
reapplied
citizenship
status
denied
ground
texas
decree
satisfy
requirement
child
born
wedlock
outside
alien
mother
american
father
legitimated
age
order
acquire
citizenship
petitioner
miller
sued
secretary
state
federal
district
texas
seeking
judgment
declaring
citizen
emphasized
citizenship
child
alien
father
american
mother
established
birth
alleged
different
treatment
citizen
fathers
citizen
mothers
violated
miller
fifth
amendment
equal
protection
right
utilizing
suspect
classification
gender
without
justification
concluding
miller
standing
dismissed
party
transferred
venue
district
district
columbia
dismissed
suit
ground
federal
courts
power
grant
citizenship
appeals
affirmed
holding
petitioner
standing
sue
concluding
require
ments
imposed
child
like
child
american
mother
justified
governmental
interests
fostering
child
ties
country
citizen
parent
held
judgment
affirmed
affirmed
justice
stevens
joined
chief
justice
concluded
requirement
children
born
abroad
wedlock
citizen
fathers
citizen
mothers
obtain
formal
proof
paternity
age
violate
fifth
amendment
pp
foregoing
issue
presented
case
facts
certain
issues
need
resolved
whether
fiallo
bell
dictates
outcome
validity
distinction
drawn
residency
requirements
unmarried
citizen
fathers
unmarried
citizen
mothers
wishing
transmit
citizenship
birth
children
validity
impose
additional
requirements
citizen
fathers
wishing
transmit
citizenship
petitioner
contesting
government
refusal
register
treat
citizen
judgment
favor
confirm
citizenship
rather
grant
rights
possess
appeals
therefore
correct
standing
invoke
federal
courts
jurisdiction
moreover
claim
relies
heavily
proposition
citizen
father
right
transmit
citizenship
citizen
mother
evaluate
alleged
discrimination
well
impact
see
craig
boren
pp
rule
applicable
class
children
born
abroad
eminently
reasonable
justified
important
government
interests
ensuring
reliable
proof
person
born
wedlock
claims
citizenship
birth
actually
shares
blood
relationship
american
citizen
encouraging
development
healthy
relationship
citizen
parent
child
child
minor
fostering
ties
child
male
female
parents
children
differently
situated
several
pertinent
respects
child
blood
relationship
birth
mother
immediately
obvious
typically
established
hospital
records
birth
certificates
relationship
unmarried
father
may
often
undisclosed
unrecorded
contemporary
public
record
similarly
child
birth
mother
certainly
knows
child
existence
typically
immediate
custody
whereas
due
normal
intercite
syllabus
val
nine
months
conception
birth
unmarried
father
may
even
know
child
exists
child
may
know
father
identity
section
children
born
wedlock
citizen
fathers
obtain
formal
proof
paternity
age
either
legitimation
written
acknowledgment
father
oath
adjudication
competent
well
tailored
address
concerns
conclusion
congress
may
require
affirmative
act
unmarried
fathers
children
mothers
children
directly
supported
lehr
robertson
pp
argument
unconstitutional
stereotypical
classification
must
rejected
none
governmental
interests
underlying
fairly
characterized
accidental
byproduct
traditional
way
thinking
members
either
sex
biological
differences
single
men
single
women
provide
relevant
basis
differing
rules
governing
ability
confer
citizenship
children
born
wedlock
foreign
lands
impartial
analysis
differences
rebuts
strong
presumption
legal
distinctions
suspect
pp
justice
joined
justice
kennedy
concluded
petitioner
accorded
standing
raise
father
gender
discrimination
claim
applies
presumption
standing
prudential
limitation
exercise
federal
jurisdiction
see
singleton
wulff
presumption
may
rebutted
particular
circumstances
litigant
suffered
injury
fact
close
relation
third
party
hindrance
third
party
ability
protect
interests
exists
see
powers
ohio
petitioner
demonstrated
genuine
obstacle
father
ability
assert
rights
rises
level
hindrance
accordingly
precluded
raising
equal
protection
claims
case
although
petitioner
may
still
assert
rights
invoke
gender
discrimination
claim
trigger
heightened
scrutiny
section
draws
distinction
based
gender
parent
child
claim
discrimination
based
differential
treatment
illegitimate
versus
legitimate
children
presented
question
certiorari
granted
thus
petitioner
constitutional
challenge
subject
rational
basis
scrutiny
even
though
withstand
heightened
scrutiny
sustainable
lower
standard
pp
justice
scalia
joined
justice
thomas
agreed
outcome
case
ground
complaint
must
dismissed
albright
syllabus
cause
power
provide
relief
requested
conferral
citizenship
basis
prescribed
congress
petitioner
born
outside
territory
become
citizen
naturalization
congressional
authority
see
wong
kim
ark
congressional
enactment
granting
citizenship
remains
alien
plain
language
sets
forth
precondition
acquisition
citizenship
petitioner
admittedly
met
thus
even
agree
difference
treatment
illegitimate
children
citizenfathers
unconstitutional
consistent
extremely
limited
judicial
power
area
see
fiallo
bell
remedy
constitutional
infirmity
declaring
petitioner
citizen
ordering
state
department
approve
application
citizenship
see
ins
pangilinan
case
may
remedy
alleged
violation
either
expanding
limiting
benefits
conferred
deny
grant
equally
pp
stevens
announced
judgment
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
joined
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
kennedy
joined
scalia
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
thomas
joined
ginsburg
filed
dissenting
opinion
souter
breyer
joined
breyer
filed
dissenting
opinion
souter
ginsburg
joined
footnotes
comment
course
related
cases
child
born
wedlock
claims
citizenship
father
moreover
reference
age
inaccurate
petitioner
born
prior
amended
change
relevant
age
see
pub
stat
falls
within
narrow
age
bracket
whose
members
may
elect
law
apply
see
note
following
effective
date
amendment
quoting
added
pub
stat
oversight
affect
case
however
texas
decree
entered
sections
ina
challenged
fiallo
defined
terms
child
parent
determine
eligibility
special
preference
immigration
status
accorded
children
parents
citizens
lawful
permanent
residents
fiallo
bell
child
defined
include
illegitimate
child
whose
behalf
status
privilege
benefit
sought
virtue
relationship
child
natural
mother
id
quoting
thus
statute
permit
illegitimate
child
seek
preference
virtue
relationship
citizen
resident
father
alien
father
seek
preference
based
illegitimate
child
citizenship
residence
following
decision
fiallo
upholding
provisions
congress
amended
ina
recognize
child
parent
status
preference
sought
based
relationship
child
born
wedlock
natural
father
father
bona
fide
relationship
person
pub
stat
amended
supp
iv
see
directing
shall
apply
specified
conditions
met
title
provides
following
shall
nationals
citizens
birth
person
born
outside
geographical
limits
outlying
possessions
parents
one
alien
citizen
prior
birth
person
physically
present
outlying
possessions
period
periods
totaling
less
five
years
least
two
attaining
age
fourteen
years
prior
amendment
section
required
residence
total
years
least
attaining
age
see
stat
section
ina
codified
provides
notwithstanding
provision
subsection
section
person
born
december
outside
wedlock
shall
held
acquired
birth
nationality
status
mother
mother
nationality
time
person
birth
mother
previously
physically
present
one
outlying
possessions
continuous
period
one
year
government
offered
two
explanations
special
rule
applicable
unmarried
citizen
mothers
give
birth
abroad
first
assumption
citizen
mother
probably
custody
second
foreign
countries
nationality
illegitimate
child
mother
unless
paternity
established
government
submits
special
rule
minimize
risk
child
might
otherwise
stateless
see
brief
respondent
government
asserts
purpose
facilitate
enforcement
child
support
order
thus
lessen
chance
child
become
financial
burden
brief
respondent
quoting
hearings
et
al
subcommittee
immigration
refugees
international
law
house
committee
judiciary
statement
joan
clark
assistant
secretary
state
consular
affairs
hereinafter
hearings
threshold
matter
government
never
asserted
position
opposition
alien
outside
territory
substantive
rights
cognizable
fifth
amendment
brief
respondent
even
question
decided
whether
petitioner
alien
whether
claims
citizen
thus
must
address
merits
determine
whether
predicate
argument
accurate
cases
government
relies
johnson
eisentrager
perfectly
clear
complaining
aliens
citizens
nationals
though
petitioner
claims
citizen
birth
rather
claiming
immigration
preference
citizenship
pass
descent
rogers
bellei
thus
must
still
meet
statutory
requirements
set
congress
citizenship
id
ginsberg
deference
political
branches
dictates
narrow
standard
review
decisions
made
congress
president
area
immigration
naturalization
mathews
diaz
even
petitioner
amici
argue
heightened
scrutiny
normally
governs
gender
discrimination
claims
applied
context
see
virginia
slip
persuaded
requirement
imposed
children
unmarried
male
female
citizens
substantially
related
important
governmental
objectives
see
dept
state
foreign
affairs
manual
hereinafter
foreign
affairs
manual
commercially
available
testing
presently
appears
cost
per
test
see
hotaling
los
angeles
times
magazine
pp
hereinafter
hotaling
mirabella
lab
tests
give
answers
genetic
questions
baltimore
sun
pp
cols
hereinafter
mirabella
laboratories
conduct
genetic
paternity
testing
typically
use
either
blood
samples
cells
scraped
inside
cheek
putative
father
child
often
mother
well
see
faigman
kaye
saks
sanders
modern
scientific
evidence
pp
hotaling
pp
mirabella
cols
state
department
observed
competence
integrity
availability
blood
testing
physicians
facilities
vary
around
world
foreign
affairs
manual
presently
dna
testing
laboratories
accredited
american
association
blood
banks
hotaling
child
reaches
legal
age
majority
male
citizen
make
fraudulent
claim
paternity
person
behalf
without
risk
liability
child
support
different
context
congress
already
recognized
value
genetic
paternity
testing
see
cadc
discussing
child
support
enforcement
amendments
office
assistant
secretary
defense
background
study
use
women
military
ed
proportion
military
personnel
female
dropped
high
id
since
proportion
steadily
increased
present
level
percent
see
dept
defense
selected
manpower
statistics
policy
presently
applies
persons
eligible
citizenship
birth
child
may
obtain
special
immigration
preference
immediate
issuance
visa
based
parent
citizenship
lawful
residence
age
justice
breyer
questions
relevance
lehr
decided
advances
genetic
testing
see
post
however
question
paternity
father
case
case
father
failed
act
promptly
establish
relationship
child
course
sex
person
claiming
citizenship
irrelevant
male
petitioner
case
stronger
theoretically
might
child
american
soldier
stationed
philippines
world
war
ii
see
ablang
reno
cert
denied
persons
born
naturalized
subject
jurisdiction
thereof
citizens
state
wherein
reside
amdt
brief
american
civil
liberties
union
et
al
amici
curiae
wald
concurring
judgment
justice
breyer
dispute
fact
unmarried
father
child
born
abroad
less
likely
unmarried
mother
opportunity
develop
relationship
child
nevertheless
replace
distinction
either
requirement
distinction
caretaker
parents
post
neither
substitute
seems
likely
candidate
serious
congressional
consideration
former
practice
present
requirement
surely
every
mother
knowledge
birth
occurs
option
eliminate
need
formal
steps
time
limits
ensure
parent
truly
knowledge
child
youth
latter
confusing
best
justice
breyer
tell
us
decide
whether
father
like
miller
qualify
caretaker
also
far
less
protective
families
present
statute
deny
citizenship
children
relationships
citizen
parents
primary
care
custody
parents
petitioner
makes
claim
behalf
father
behalf
justice
breyer
finds
standing
make
claim
relevant
relationship
father
hindrance
father
asserting
rights
post
quoting
powers
ohio
original
matter
agree
justice
ground
inadequate
read
cases
demanding
significant
impairment
rightholder
ability
sue
example
craig
boren
although
rightholder
one
named
plaintiffs
indeed
lost
ability
sue
turned
barrier
whatever
assertion
constitutional
claim
oklahoma
males
id
burger
dissenting
certainly
craig
petitioner
least
awkward
challenger
id
since
right
citizenship
stake
law
subject
need
may
charitably
called
clarification
leave
another
day
since
accept
petitioner
standing
need
reach
government
claim
asserts
first
time
brief
merits
petitioner
invoke
equal
protection
clause
behalf
within
jurisdiction
brief
respondent
title
provides
illegitimate
child
born
citizen
mother
shall
citizen
mother
previously
physically
present
one
outlying
possessions
continuous
period
one
year
bill
contained
similar
provision
allowing
citizen
women
transmit
citizenship
children
born
abroad
bill
provided
child
born
time
without
either
parent
time
birth
citizen
may
citizen
section
revised
statutes
derive
citizenship
section
bill
precursor
cable
act
passed
house
committee
immigration
naturalization
proceeded
see
bredbenner
nationality
citizenship
entirely
synonymous
one
national
yet
citizen
distinction
little
practical
impact
today
however
remaining
noncitizen
nationals
residents
american
samoa
swains
island
see
aleinikoff
martin
motomura
immigration
process
policy
ed
provision
child
born
abroad
wedlock
citizen
mother
gains
nationality
interpreted
mean
child
gains
citizenship
well
thus
mother
national
also
citizen
child
citizen
see
gordon
viii
provision
granting
citizenship
children
born
abroad
wedlock
applied
retroactively
provision
granting
citizenship
children
born
wedlock
act
nonretroactive
net
result
child
born
abroad
wedlock
citizen
mother
earlier
citizenship
act
child
born
wedlock
congress
enacted
legislation
making
act
retroactive
pub
tit
stat
codified
act
also
provided
periods
service
armed
forces
abroad
count
towards
satisfying
parental
residency
requirement
regard
child
born
january
immigration
nationality
act
stat
codified
amended