chambers
nasco
argued
february
decided
june
petitioner
chambers
sole
shareholder
director
company
operated
television
station
louisiana
agreed
sell
station
facilities
broadcast
license
respondent
nasco
inc
chambers
soon
changed
mind
nasco
filed
diversity
action
specific
performance
district
engaged
series
actions
within
without
proceedings
federal
communications
commission
appeals
designed
frustrate
sale
consummation
remand
following
appeals
affirmance
judgment
merits
nasco
district
nasco
motion
following
full
briefing
hearing
imposed
sanctions
chambers
form
attorney
fees
expenses
totaling
almost
million
representing
entire
amount
nasco
litigation
costs
paid
attorneys
noted
alleged
sanctionable
conduct
chambers
attempted
deprive
jurisdiction
acts
fraud
nearly
performed
outside
confines
filed
false
frivolous
pleadings
attempted
tactics
delay
oppression
harassment
massive
expense
reduce
nasco
exhausted
compliance
deemed
federal
rule
civil
procedure
provides
imposition
attorney
fees
sanction
improper
filing
papers
insufficient
support
sanction
chambers
since
rule
reach
conduct
foregoing
first
third
categories
since
impossible
assess
sanctions
time
papers
second
category
filed
falsity
become
apparent
trial
merits
likewise
declined
impose
sanctions
statute
authorization
attorney
fees
sanction
applies
attorneys
unreasonably
vexatiously
multiply
proceedings
therefore
reach
chambers
statute
broad
enough
reach
acts
degrade
judicial
system
therefore
relied
inherent
power
imposing
sanctions
affirming
appeals
inter
alia
rejected
chambers
argument
federal
sitting
diversity
must
look
state
law
inherent
power
assess
attorney
fees
sanction
conduct
litigation
held
district
properly
invoked
inherent
power
assessing
sanction
chambers
conduct
attorney
fees
related
expenses
paid
nasco
pp
federal
courts
inherent
power
manage
proceedings
control
conduct
appear
invoking
inherent
power
punish
conduct
abuses
judicial
process
must
exercise
discretion
fashioning
appropriate
sanction
may
range
dismissal
lawsuit
assessment
attorney
fees
although
american
rule
prohibits
shifting
attorney
fees
cases
see
alyeska
pipeline
service
wilderness
society
exception
allows
federal
courts
exercise
inherent
power
assess
fees
sanction
party
acted
bad
faith
vexatiously
wantonly
oppressive
reasons
party
practices
fraud
upon
universal
oil
products
root
refining
delays
disrupts
litigation
hampers
order
enforcement
hutto
finney
pp
nothing
rule
federal
rules
civil
procedure
authorizing
attorney
fees
sanction
decisions
interpreting
sanctioning
mechanisms
warrants
conclusion
taken
alone
together
mechanisms
displace
courts
inherent
power
impose
attorney
fees
sanction
conduct
although
ordinarily
rely
rules
conduct
course
litigation
adequately
sanctioned
rules
may
safely
rely
inherent
power
informed
discretion
neither
statutes
rules
task
district
abuse
discretion
resorting
inherent
power
circumstances
case
although
chambers
conduct
might
reached
sanctioning
mechanisms
conduct
sanctionable
requiring
apply
mechanisms
discrete
occurrences
invoking
inherent
power
address
remaining
instances
sanctionable
conduct
serve
foster
extensive
needless
satellite
litigation
contrary
aim
rules
reliance
inherent
power
thwart
mandatory
terms
rules
rules
merely
require
appropriate
sanction
imposed
without
specifying
sanction
required
bank
nova
scotia
distinguished
pp
merit
chambers
assertion
federal
sitting
diversity
use
inherent
power
assess
attorney
fees
sanction
unless
applicable
state
law
recognizes
exception
general
american
rule
although
alyeska
tied
diversity
inherent
power
award
fees
existence
state
law
giving
right
thereto
limitation
applies
rules
embody
substantive
policy
statute
permits
prevailing
party
certain
classes
litigation
recover
fees
district
attempt
sanction
chambers
breach
contract
rather
imposed
sanctions
fraud
perpetrated
bad
faith
displayed
toward
nasco
throughout
litigation
inherent
power
tax
fees
conduct
made
subservient
state
policy
without
transgressing
boundaries
set
erie
tompkins
guaranty
trust
york
hanna
plumer
matter
substantive
remedy
matter
vindicating
judicial
authority
thus
although
louisiana
law
prohibits
punitive
damages
breach
contract
substantive
state
policy
implicated
pp
based
circumstances
case
district
acted
within
discretion
assessing
sanction
chambers
conduct
entire
amount
nasco
attorney
fees
chambers
arguments
contrary
without
merit
first
although
sanction
assessed
conclusion
litigation
reliance
inherent
power
represent
end
run
around
rule
notice
requirements
since
chambers
received
repeated
timely
warnings
nasco
conduct
sanctionable
second
fact
entire
amount
fees
awarded
mean
failed
tailor
sanction
particular
wrong
light
frequency
severity
chambers
abuses
judicial
system
resulting
need
ensure
abuses
repeated
third
abuse
discretion
failing
require
nasco
mitigate
expenses
since
chambers
made
swift
conclusion
litigation
means
summary
judgment
impossible
continuing
assert
material
factual
disputes
existed
fourth
err
imposing
sanctions
conduct
tribunals
since
long
chambers
received
appropriate
hearing
may
sanctioned
abuses
process
beyond
courtroom
finally
claim
award
personalized
chambers
responsibility
challenged
conduct
flatly
contradicted
detailed
factual
findings
concerning
chambers
involvement
sequence
events
issue
pp
white
delivered
opinion
marshall
blackmun
stevens
joined
scalia
filed
dissenting
opinion
post
kennedy
filed
dissenting
opinion
rehnquist
souter
joined
post
mack
barham
argued
cause
petitioner
briefs
robert
arceneaux
russell
tritico
joel
klein
argued
cause
respondent
brief
christopher
cerf
david
bono
aubrey
harwell
jon
ross
john
scofield
david
hoskins
justice
white
delivered
opinion
case
requires
us
explore
scope
inherent
power
federal
sanction
litigant
conduct
specifically
asked
determine
whether
district
sitting
diversity
properly
invoked
inherent
power
assessing
sanction
party
conduct
attorney
fees
related
expenses
paid
party
opponent
attorneys
hold
district
acted
within
discretion
therefore
affirm
judgment
appeals
case
began
simple
action
specific
performance
contract
remain
petitioner
russell
chambers
sole
shareholder
director
calcasieu
television
radio
ctr
operated
television
station
lake
charles
louisiana
august
chambers
acting
individual
capacity
behalf
ctr
entered
purchase
agreement
sell
station
facilities
broadcast
license
respondent
nasco
purchase
price
million
agreement
recorded
parishes
two
properties
housing
station
facilities
located
consummation
agreement
subject
approval
federal
communications
commission
fcc
parties
obligated
file
necessary
documents
fcc
later
september
late
august
however
chambers
changed
mind
tried
talk
nasco
consummating
sale
nasco
refused
september
chambers
counsel
informed
nasco
file
necessary
papers
fcc
nasco
decided
take
legal
action
friday
october
nasco
counsel
informed
counsel
chambers
ctr
nasco
file
suit
following
monday
district
western
district
louisiana
seeking
specific
performance
agreement
well
temporary
restraining
order
tro
prevent
alienation
encumbrance
properties
issue
nasco
provided
notice
accordance
federal
rule
civil
procedure
rule
district
local
rules
rule
designed
give
defendant
tro
application
notice
hearing
opportunity
heard
reaction
chambers
attorney
gray
iii
later
described
district
emasculated
frustrated
purposes
rules
powers
district
utilizing
notice
prevent
nasco
access
remedy
specific
performance
nasco
calcasieu
television
radio
sunday
october
pair
acted
place
properties
issue
beyond
reach
district
means
louisiana
public
records
doctrine
purchase
agreement
never
recorded
determined
properties
sold
third
party
deeds
recorded
issuance
tro
district
lack
jurisdiction
properties
end
chambers
gray
created
trust
chambers
sister
trustee
chambers
three
adult
children
beneficiaries
pair
directed
president
ctr
later
became
chambers
wife
execute
warranty
deeds
conveying
two
tracts
issue
trust
recited
consideration
million
early
monday
morning
deeds
recorded
trustee
purchaser
signed
deeds
none
consideration
paid
ctr
remained
possession
properties
later
morning
nasco
counsel
appeared
district
file
complaint
seek
tro
nasco
counsel
present
district
judge
telephoned
gray
despite
judge
queries
concerning
possibility
ctr
negotiating
sell
properties
third
person
gray
made
mention
recordation
deeds
earlier
morning
nasco
calcasieu
television
radio
afternoon
chambers
met
sister
sign
trust
documents
million
note
ctr
next
morning
gray
informed
district
letter
recordation
deeds
day
admitted
intentionally
withheld
information
within
next
days
chambers
attorneys
prepared
leaseback
agreement
trustee
ctr
ctr
remain
possession
properties
continue
operate
station
following
week
district
granted
preliminary
injunction
chambers
ctr
entered
second
tro
prevent
trustee
alienating
encumbering
properties
hearing
district
judge
warned
gray
chambers
conduct
unethical
despite
early
warning
chambers
often
acting
attorneys
continued
abuse
judicial
process
november
defiance
preliminary
injunction
refused
allow
nasco
inspect
ctr
corporate
records
ensuing
civil
contempt
proceedings
resulted
assessment
fine
chambers
personally
nasco
calcasieu
television
radio
two
subsequent
appeals
contempt
order
dismissed
lack
final
judgment
see
nasco
calcasieu
television
radio
may
nasco
calcasieu
television
radio
undeterred
chambers
proceeded
series
meritless
motions
pleadings
delaying
actions
actions
triggered
warnings
one
point
acting
sua
sponte
district
judge
called
status
conference
find
bankers
deposed
informed
chambers
counsel
purpose
learn
whether
nasco
afford
pay
station
canceled
depositions
consistent
authority
federal
rule
civil
procedure
status
conference
nine
days
april
trial
date
district
judge
warned
counsel
misconduct
tolerated
finally
eve
trial
chambers
ctr
stipulated
purchase
agreement
enforceable
chambers
breached
agreement
september
failing
file
necessary
papers
fcc
trial
defense
presented
chambers
public
records
doctrine
interlude
trial
entry
judgment
district
prepared
opinion
chambers
sought
render
purchase
agreement
meaningless
seeking
permission
fcc
build
new
transmission
tower
station
relocate
transmission
facilities
site
covered
agreement
nasco
sought
contempt
sanctions
chambers
withdraw
application
district
entered
judgment
merits
nasco
favor
finding
transfer
properties
trust
simulated
sale
deeds
purporting
convey
property
null
void
effect
chambers
motions
filed
district
appeals
stay
judgment
pending
appeal
denied
undeterred
chambers
convinced
ctr
officials
file
formal
oppositions
nasco
pending
application
fcc
approval
transfer
station
license
contravention
district
injunctive
orders
judgment
merits
nasco
sought
contempt
sanctions
third
time
oppositions
withdrawn
chambers
refused
prepare
close
sale
nasco
sought
help
hearing
set
july
determine
whether
certain
equipment
included
sale
beginning
hearing
informed
chambers
new
attorney
edwin
mccabe
sanctionable
conduct
tolerated
hearing
recessed
several
days
chambers
without
notice
nasco
removed
service
station
equipment
issue
forcing
district
order
equipment
returned
service
immediately
following
oral
argument
chambers
appeal
district
judgment
merits
appeals
ruling
bench
found
appeal
frivolous
imposed
appellate
sanctions
form
attorney
fees
double
costs
pursuant
federal
rule
appellate
procedure
remanded
case
district
orders
fix
amount
appellate
sanctions
determine
whether
sanctions
imposed
manner
litigation
conducted
nasco
calcasieu
television
radio
per
curiam
unpublished
order
remand
nasco
moved
sanctions
invoking
district
inherent
power
full
briefing
hearing
see
district
determined
sanctions
appropriate
manner
proceeding
conducted
district
october
time
plaintiff
gave
notice
intention
file
suit
date
end
extensive
opinion
recounting
deemed
sanctionable
conduct
period
imposed
sanctions
chambers
form
attorney
fees
expenses
totaling
represented
entire
amount
nasco
litigation
costs
paid
attorneys
rejected
chambers
argument
merely
followed
advice
counsel
labeling
strategist
behind
scheme
devised
first
deprive
jurisdiction
second
devise
plan
obstruction
delay
harassment
expense
sufficient
reduce
nasco
condition
exhausted
compliance
imposing
sanctions
district
first
considered
federal
rule
civil
procedure
noted
alleged
sanctionable
conduct
chambers
defendants
attempted
deprive
jurisdiction
acts
fraud
nearly
performed
outside
confines
filed
false
frivolous
pleadings
attempted
tactics
delay
oppression
harassment
massive
expense
reduce
plaintiff
exhausted
compliance
recognized
conduct
first
third
categories
reached
rule
governs
papers
filed
second
category
explained
falsity
pleadings
issue
become
apparent
trial
merits
impossible
assess
sanctions
time
papers
filed
consequently
district
deemed
rule
insufficient
purposes
likewise
declined
impose
sanctions
statute
applies
attorneys
therefore
reach
chambers
statute
broad
enough
reach
acts
degrade
judicial
system
including
attempts
deprive
jurisdiction
fraud
misleading
lying
ibid
therefore
relied
inherent
power
imposing
sanctions
stressing
wielding
inherent
power
particularly
appropriate
offending
parties
practiced
fraud
upon
ibid
appeals
affirmed
nasco
calcasieu
television
radio
rejected
chambers
argument
federal
sitting
diversity
must
look
state
law
inherent
power
assess
attorney
fees
sanction
conduct
litigation
found
neither
federal
rule
civil
procedure
limits
inherent
authority
sanction
conduct
party
conduct
within
reach
rule
statute
although
observing
inherent
power
broad
reservoir
power
ready
imperial
hand
limited
source
implied
power
squeezed
need
make
function
also
concluded
district
abuse
discretion
awarding
nasco
fees
litigation
costs
paid
attorneys
importance
issues
granted
certiorari
ii
chambers
maintains
various
sanctioning
provisions
federal
rules
civil
procedure
reflect
legislative
intent
displace
inherent
power
least
argues
obviate
foreclose
resort
inherent
power
case
agree
appeals
neither
proposition
persuasive
long
understood
ertain
implied
powers
must
necessarily
result
courts
justice
nature
institution
powers
dispensed
necessary
exercise
others
hudson
cranch
see
also
roadway
express
piper
citing
hudson
reason
courts
justice
universally
acknowledged
vested
creation
power
impose
silence
respect
decorum
presence
submission
lawful
mandates
anderson
dunn
wheat
see
also
ex
parte
robinson
wall
powers
governed
rule
statute
control
necessarily
vested
courts
manage
affairs
achieve
orderly
expeditious
disposition
cases
link
wabash
prior
cases
outlined
scope
inherent
power
federal
courts
example
held
federal
power
control
admission
bar
discipline
attorneys
appear
see
ex
parte
burr
wheat
power
exercised
great
caution
nevertheless
incidental
courts
ibid
addition
firmly
established
power
punish
contempts
inherent
courts
robinson
supra
power
reaches
conduct
beyond
confines
underlying
concern
gave
rise
contempt
power
merely
disruption
proceedings
rather
disobedience
orders
judiciary
regardless
whether
disobedience
interfered
conduct
trial
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
citations
omitted
particular
relevance
inherent
power
also
allows
federal
vacate
judgment
upon
proof
fraud
perpetrated
upon
see
glass
universal
oil
products
root
refining
historic
power
equity
set
aside
fraudulently
begotten
judgments
necessary
integrity
courts
tampering
administration
justice
manner
involves
far
injury
single
litigant
wrong
institutions
set
protect
safeguard
public
moreover
power
conduct
independent
investigation
order
determine
whether
victim
fraud
universal
oil
supra
facets
federal
inherent
power
may
bar
courtroom
criminal
defendant
disrupts
trial
illinois
allen
may
dismiss
action
grounds
forum
non
conveniens
gulf
oil
gilbert
may
act
sua
sponte
dismiss
suit
failure
prosecute
link
supra
potency
inherent
powers
must
exercised
restraint
discretion
see
roadway
express
supra
primary
aspect
discretion
ability
fashion
appropriate
sanction
conduct
abuses
judicial
process
recognized
roadway
express
outright
dismissal
lawsuit
upheld
link
particularly
severe
sanction
yet
within
discretion
consequently
less
severe
sanction
assessment
attorney
fees
undoubtedly
within
inherent
power
well
ibid
see
also
hutto
finney
indeed
ample
grounds
recognizing
narrowly
defined
circumstances
federal
courts
inherent
power
assess
attorney
fees
counsel
roadway
express
supra
even
though
american
rule
prohibits
cases
see
alyeska
pipeline
service
wilderness
society
explained
alyeska
exceptions
fall
three
categories
first
known
common
fund
exception
derives
power
control
litigants
historic
equity
jurisdiction
see
sprague
ticonic
national
bank
allows
award
attorney
fees
party
whose
litigation
efforts
directly
benefit
others
alyeska
second
may
assess
attorney
fees
sanction
willful
disobedience
order
quoting
fleischmann
distilling
maier
brewing
thus
discretion
determine
degree
punishment
contempt
permits
impose
part
fine
attorney
fees
representing
entire
cost
litigation
toledo
scale
computing
scale
third
relevant
may
assess
attorney
fees
party
acted
bad
faith
vexatiously
wantonly
oppressive
reasons
alyeska
supra
quoting
rich
ex
rel
industrial
lumber
see
also
hall
cole
newman
piggie
park
enterprises
per
curiam
regard
finds
fraud
practiced
upon
temple
justice
defiled
may
assess
attorney
fees
responsible
party
universal
oil
supra
may
party
shows
bad
faith
delaying
disrupting
litigation
hampering
enforcement
order
hutto
imposition
sanctions
instance
transcends
equitable
power
concerning
relations
parties
reaches
inherent
power
police
thus
serving
dual
purpose
vindicat
ing
judicial
authority
without
resort
drastic
sanctions
available
contempt
mak
ing
prevailing
party
whole
expenses
caused
opponent
obstinacy
ibid
discern
basis
holding
sanctioning
scheme
statute
rules
displaces
inherent
power
impose
sanctions
conduct
described
mechanisms
taken
alone
together
substitutes
inherent
power
power
broader
narrower
means
imposing
sanctions
first
whereas
mechanisms
reaches
certain
individuals
conduct
inherent
power
extends
full
range
litigation
abuses
least
inherent
power
must
continue
exist
fill
interstices
even
justice
kennedy
dissent
concedes
see
post
second
narrow
exceptions
american
rule
effectively
limit
inherent
power
impose
attorney
fees
sanction
cases
litigant
engaged
conduct
willful
disobedience
orders
many
mechanisms
permit
impose
attorney
fees
sanction
conduct
merely
fails
meet
reasonableness
standard
rule
example
imposes
objective
standard
reasonable
inquiry
mandate
finding
bad
faith
see
business
guides
chromatic
communications
enterprises
true
exercise
inherent
power
lower
federal
courts
limited
statute
rule
hese
courts
created
act
congress
robinson
nevertheless
lightly
assume
congress
intended
depart
established
principles
scope
inherent
power
weinberger
see
also
link
alyeska
determined
congress
ha
repudiated
judicially
fashioned
exceptions
american
rule
founded
inherent
power
courts
nothing
since
changed
assessment
thus
reaffirmed
scope
existence
exceptions
since
recent
amendments
rule
sanctioning
mechanisms
invoked
nasco
see
pennsylvania
delaware
valley
citizen
council
clean
air
appeals
recognized
amendment
allowing
assessment
fees
attorney
says
nothing
power
assess
fees
party
likewise
advisory
committee
notes
amendment
rule
declare
rule
build
upon
expand
equitable
doctrine
permitting
award
expenses
including
attorney
fees
litigant
whose
opponent
acts
bad
faith
instituting
conducting
litigation
citing
support
decisions
roadway
express
hall
thus
appeals
ninth
circuit
recognized
rule
repeal
modify
existing
authority
federal
courts
deal
abuses
inherent
power
zaldivar
los
angeles
prior
cases
indicated
inherent
power
invoked
even
procedural
rules
exist
sanction
conduct
link
recognized
federal
district
inherent
power
dismiss
case
sua
sponte
failure
prosecute
even
though
language
federal
rule
civil
procedure
appeared
require
motion
party
authority
dismiss
sua
sponte
lack
prosecution
generally
considered
inherent
power
governed
rule
statute
control
necessarily
vested
courts
manage
affairs
achieve
orderly
expeditious
disposition
cases
long
gone
unquestioned
apparent
many
state
decisions
sustaining
dismissals
even
language
opinion
redfield
ystalyfera
iron
also
sanction
wide
usage
among
district
courts
require
much
clearer
expression
purpose
rule
provides
us
assume
intended
abrogate
proposition
footnotes
omitted
therefore
nothing
sanctioning
mechanisms
prior
cases
interpreting
warrants
conclusion
federal
may
matter
law
resort
inherent
power
impose
attorney
fees
sanction
conduct
plainly
case
conduct
issue
covered
one
sanctioning
provisions
neither
federal
forbidden
sanction
conduct
means
inherent
power
simply
conduct
also
sanctioned
statute
rules
must
course
exercise
caution
invoking
inherent
power
must
comply
mandates
due
process
determining
requisite
bad
faith
exists
assessing
fees
see
roadway
express
supra
furthermore
conduct
course
litigation
adequately
sanctioned
rules
ordinarily
rely
rules
rather
inherent
power
informed
discretion
neither
statute
rules
task
may
safely
rely
inherent
power
like
appeals
find
abuse
discretion
resorting
inherent
power
circumstances
case
true
district
employed
rule
sanction
chambers
filing
false
frivolous
pleadings
conduct
might
reached
rules
much
conduct
chambers
however
beyond
reach
rules
entire
course
conduct
throughout
lawsuit
evidenced
bad
faith
attempt
perpetrate
fraud
conduct
sanctionable
rules
intertwined
within
conduct
inherent
power
address
circumstances
litigant
conduct
deemed
sanctionable
requiring
first
apply
rules
statutes
containing
sanctioning
provisions
discrete
occurrences
invoking
inherent
power
address
remaining
instances
sanctionable
conduct
serve
foster
extensive
needless
satellite
litigation
contrary
aim
rules
see
advisory
committee
notes
amendment
rule
pp
likewise
find
district
reliance
inherent
power
thwarted
purposes
sanctioning
mechanisms
although
justice
kennedy
dissent
makes
much
fact
rule
rule
cast
mandatory
terms
post
mandate
provisions
extends
whether
must
impose
sanctions
sanction
must
impose
indeed
language
rules
requires
impose
appropriate
sanction
thus
case
distinguishable
bank
nova
scotia
held
district
rely
supervisory
power
means
circumventing
clear
mandate
procedural
rule
iii
chambers
asserts
even
federal
courts
use
inherent
power
assess
attorney
fees
sanction
cases
free
sit
diversity
unless
applicable
state
law
recognizes
exception
general
rule
relies
alyeska
stated
regard
exceptions
american
rule
different
situation
presented
federal
sits
diversity
case
ordinary
diversity
case
state
law
run
counter
valid
federal
statute
rule
usually
state
law
denying
right
attorney
fees
giving
right
thereto
reflects
substantial
policy
state
followed
moore
federal
practice
pp
ed
footnotes
omitted
agree
nasco
chambers
misinterpreted
limitation
inherent
power
described
applies
rules
embody
substantive
policy
statute
permits
prevailing
party
certain
classes
litigation
recover
fees
precisely
issue
sioux
county
national
surety
case
cited
state
statute
mandated
actions
enforce
insurance
policy
award
plaintiff
reasonable
attorney
fee
see
enforcing
statute
treated
provision
part
statutory
liability
created
substantive
right
indeed
alyeska
concerned
substantive
nature
public
policy
choices
involved
deciding
whether
vindication
rights
afforded
particular
statute
important
enough
warrant
award
fees
see
conflict
state
federal
substantive
law
concerns
erie
tompkins
issue
explained
hanna
plumer
outcome
determinative
test
erie
guaranty
trust
york
read
without
reference
twin
aims
erie
rule
discouragement
avoidance
inequitable
administration
laws
despite
chambers
protestations
contrary
neither
twin
aims
implicated
assessment
attorney
fees
sanction
conduct
involved
disobedience
orders
attempt
defraud
recent
decision
business
guides
chromatic
communications
enterprises
stated
rule
sanctions
constitute
kind
issue
alyeska
tied
outcome
litigation
relevant
inquiry
whether
specific
filing
successful
least
likewise
imposition
sanctions
exception
depends
party
wins
lawsuit
parties
conduct
litigation
consequently
risk
exception
lead
inequitable
apply
exception
citizens
noncitizens
alike
party
controlling
conduct
litigation
power
determine
whether
sanctions
assessed
appeals
expressed
erie
guarantees
litigant
takes
state
law
cause
action
federal
abides
rules
result
case
brought
state
allow
waste
time
resources
cantankerous
conduct
even
unlikely
event
state
allow
chambers
recognized
see
brief
petitioner
case
exception
american
rule
underlying
rationale
course
punitive
hall
cf
pavelic
leflore
marvel
entertainment
group
award
attorney
fees
bad
faith
serve
purpose
remedial
fine
imposed
civil
contempt
vindicate
district
authority
recalcitrant
litigant
hutto
award
ha
compensatory
effect
event
distinguish
fine
civil
contempt
also
compensates
private
party
consequences
contemnor
disobedience
chambers
argues
primary
purpose
sanction
punitive
assessing
attorney
fees
violates
state
prohibition
punitive
damages
louisiana
law
punitive
damages
breach
contract
even
party
acted
bad
faith
breaching
agreement
lancaster
petroleum
delaware
cf
art
west
indeed
general
rule
attorney
fees
allowed
successful
litigant
louisiana
except
authorized
statute
contract
rutherford
impson
clear
though
general
rule
focuses
award
attorney
fees
party
success
underlying
claim
thus
frank
beier
radio
black
gold
marine
la
state
considered
scope
statute
permitted
award
attorney
fees
suit
seeking
collect
open
account
substantive
state
policy
implicated
sanctions
imposed
conduct
litigation
district
attempt
sanction
petitioner
breach
contract
rather
imposed
sanctions
fraud
perpetrated
bad
faith
displayed
toward
adversary
throughout
course
litigation
see
agree
appeals
see
district
inherent
power
tax
fees
conduct
made
subservient
state
policy
without
transgressing
boundaries
set
erie
guaranty
trust
hanna
matter
substantive
remedy
vindicating
judicial
authority
iv
review
imposition
sanctions
inherent
power
abuse
discretion
link
see
also
cooter
gell
hartmarx
rule
based
circumstances
case
find
district
acted
within
discretion
assessing
sanction
chambers
conduct
entire
amount
nasco
attorney
fees
relying
cases
imposing
sanctions
rule
chambers
proffers
five
criteria
imposing
attorney
fees
sanction
inherent
power
argues
district
acted
improperly
regard
first
asserts
sanctions
must
timely
order
desired
deterrent
affect
sanction
imposed
fails
achieve
aim
nasco
points
however
made
clear
even
rule
sanctions
may
imposed
years
judgment
merits
interrupting
proceedings
merits
conduct
sanctions
hearings
may
serve
reward
party
seeking
delay
importantly
sanction
assessed
conclusion
litigation
chambers
received
repeated
timely
warnings
nasco
conduct
sanctionable
cf
thomas
capital
security
services
en
banc
consequently
district
reliance
inherent
power
represent
end
run
around
notice
requirements
rule
fact
chambers
obstinately
refused
deterred
render
district
action
abuse
discretion
second
chambers
claims
fact
entire
amount
fees
awarded
means
district
failed
tailor
sanction
particular
wrong
nasco
points
however
district
concluded
full
attorney
fees
warranted
due
frequency
severity
chambers
abuses
judicial
system
resulting
need
ensure
abuses
repeated
indeed
found
chambers
actions
part
sordid
scheme
deliberate
misuse
judicial
process
designed
defeat
nasco
claim
harassment
repeated
endless
delay
mountainous
expense
waste
financial
resources
within
discretion
vindicate
compensate
nasco
requiring
chambers
pay
attorney
fees
cf
toledo
scale
third
chambers
maintains
district
abused
discretion
failing
require
nasco
mitigate
expenses
asserts
nasco
sought
summary
disposition
case
litigation
concluded
much
sooner
nasco
notes
chambers
made
swift
conclusion
litigation
means
summary
judgment
impossible
continuing
assert
material
factual
disputes
existed
fourth
chambers
challenges
district
imposition
sanctions
conduct
tribunals
including
fcc
appeals
asserting
may
sanction
conduct
occurring
presence
cases
contrary
however
long
party
receives
appropriate
hearing
chambers
see
party
may
sanctioned
abuses
process
occurring
beyond
courtroom
disobeying
orders
see
young
toledo
scale
supra
example
chambers
attempt
gain
fcc
permission
build
new
transmission
tower
direct
contravention
district
orders
maintain
status
quo
pending
outcome
litigation
therefore
within
scope
district
sanctioning
power
finally
chambers
claims
award
personalized
district
failed
conduct
inquiry
whether
personally
responsible
challenged
conduct
assertion
flatly
contradicted
district
detailed
factual
findings
concerning
chambers
involvement
sequence
events
issue
indeed
specifically
held
extraordinary
amount
costs
expenses
expended
proceeding
caused
lack
diligence
delays
trial
matter
nasco
nasco
counsel
solely
relentless
repeated
fraudulent
brazenly
unethical
efforts
chambers
others
appeals
saw
reason
disturb
finding
neither
foregoing
reasons
judgment
appeals
fifth
circuit
affirmed
footnotes
trial
date
reflected
delaying
tactics
trial
set
february
january
gray
behalf
chambers
filed
motion
recuse
judge
motion
denied
subsequent
writ
mandamus
filed
appeals
make
point
clear
district
judge
gave
counsel
copies
judge
schwarzer
article
sanctions
new
federal
rule
closer
look
gray
resigned
counsel
chambers
ctr
several
months
previously
calculating
award
district
deducted
amounts
previously
awarded
compensatory
damages
contempt
well
amount
awarded
appellate
sanctions
also
sanctioned
individuals
parties
action
chambers
sister
trustee
sanctioned
reprimand
attorney
gray
disbarred
prohibited
seeking
readmission
three
years
attorney
richard
curry
represented
trustee
suspended
practice
six
months
attorney
mccabe
suspended
five
years
although
sanctions
affect
bank
accounts
individuals
nevertheless
substantial
sanctions
proportionate
conduct
issue
monetary
sanction
imposed
chambers
indeed
case
disbarment
attorney
gray
recognized
penalty
among
harshest
possible
sanctions
one
derived
authority
supervise
admitted
practice
see
statute
provides
attorney
multiplies
proceedings
case
unreasonably
vexatiously
may
required
satisfy
personally
excess
costs
expenses
attorneys
fees
reasonably
incurred
conduct
remanded
reconsideration
proper
sanction
attorney
mccabe
number
rules
provide
imposition
attorney
fees
sanction
see
certification
requirement
papers
pretrial
conferences
certification
requirement
discovery
requests
oral
depositions
sanctions
failure
cooperate
discovery
affidavits
accompanying
summary
judgment
motions
instances
assessment
fees
one
range
possible
sanctions
see
others
must
award
fees
see
case
fees
may
assessed
limited
incurred
result
rules
violation
case
rule
however
violation
conceivably
warrant
imposition
fees
covering
entire
litigation
example
complaint
answer
filed
violation
rule
generally
may
act
sua
sponte
imposing
sanctions
rules
see
also
pennsylvania
delaware
valley
citizens
council
clean
air
summit
valley
industries
carpenters
rich
ex
rel
industrial
lumber
regard
exception
resembles
third
prong
rule
certification
requirement
mandates
signer
paper
filed
warrant
paper
interposed
improper
purpose
harass
cause
unnecessary
delay
needless
increase
cost
litigation
indeed
rule
amended
precisely
subjective
standard
difficult
establish
courts
therefore
reluctant
invoke
means
imposing
sanctions
see
advisory
committee
notes
amendment
rule
pp
consequently
little
risk
courts
invoke
inherent
power
chill
advocacy
litigants
attempting
vindicate
important
federal
rights
see
post
kennedy
dissenting
extent
risk
exist
less
present
invokes
rule
see
cooter
gell
hartmarx
chambers
also
asserts
inherent
powers
created
equal
relying
eash
riggins
trucking
en
banc
suggests
inherent
powers
fall
three
tiers
irreducible
powers
derived
article
iii
exist
despite
contrary
legislative
direction
essential
powers
arise
nature
legislatively
regulated
abrogated
powers
necessary
sense
useful
exist
absent
legislation
contrary
brief
petitioner
chambers
acknowledges
never
classified
inherent
powers
need
even
assuming
arguendo
power
shift
fees
falls
bottom
tier
alleged
hierarchy
inherent
powers
chambers
argument
unavailing
find
legislative
intent
limit
scope
power
advisory
committee
notes
amendments
rules
reflect
similar
intent
preserve
scope
inherent
power
notes
rule
point
sanctioning
provisions
designed
obviate
dependence
upon
rule
inherent
power
indication
intent
displace
inherent
power
rather
simply
provide
courts
additional
tool
control
judicial
process
notes
rule
point
rule
makes
explicit
authority
judges
impose
appropriate
sanctions
quires
use
authority
derives
rule
inherent
power
citations
omitted
decision
societe
internationale
pour
participations
industrielles
et
commerciales
rogers
contrary
held
appeals
erred
relying
district
inherent
power
rule
rather
federal
rule
civil
procedure
iii
dismissing
complaint
plaintiff
failure
comply
discovery
order
rule
dealt
specifically
discovery
sanctions
need
resort
rule
pertains
trials
inherent
power
ibid
moreover
individual
rules
address
specific
problems
many
instances
might
improper
invoke
one
another
directly
applies
cf
zaldivar
los
angeles
consequently
chambers
reformulated
argument
reply
brief
primary
purpose
fee
shift
exception
always
compensatory
reply
petitioner
fails
utterly
therefore
express
opinion
whether
district
inherent
power
sanction
chambers
conduct
relating
underlying
breach
contract
whether
sanctions
might
implicate
concerns
erie
contrary
chambers
assertion
district
sanction
failing
file
requisite
papers
fcc
september
although
district
find
conduct
deliberate
violation
agreement
done
absolute
bad
faith
noted
allegedly
sanctionable
acts
committed
conduct
trial
proceeding
sanctions
sought
thus
sanctions
imposed
appl
ied
sanctionable
acts
occurred
connection
proceedings
trial
although
fraudulent
transfer
assets
took
place
suit
filed
occurred
chambers
given
notice
pursuant
rule
pending
suit
consequently
sanctions
imposed
chambers
aimed
punishing
harm
done
nasco
also
harm
done
indeed
district
made
clear
policing
abuse
process
imposed
sanctions
manner
proceeding
conducted
district
october
time
plaintiff
gave
notice
intention
file
suit
see
kunstler
cert
denied
white
general
motors
thomas
capital
security
services
en
banc
cf
advisory
committee
notes
amendment
rule
app
time
sanctions
imposed
rests
discretion
trial
judge
however
anticipated
case
pleadings
sanctions
issue
rule
normally
determined
end
litigation
case
motions
time
motion
decided
shortly
thereafter
particular
chambers
challenges
assessment
attorney
fees
connection
nasco
claim
delay
damages
closing
sale
nasco
points
however
chambers
conduct
course
litigation
caused
delay
damages
sought
greatly
complicated
closing
sale
cloud
title
caused
fraudulent
transfer
justice
scalia
dissenting
agree
article
iii
courts
independent
coequal
branch
government
derive
constitution
created
jurisdiction
established
authority
courts
traditionally
done
order
accomplish
assigned
tasks
elements
inherent
authority
essential
judicial
power
art
iii
indefeasible
among
ability
enter
orders
protecting
integrity
proceedings
certain
implied
powers
must
necessarily
result
courts
justice
nature
institution
fine
contempt
imprison
contumacy
inforce
observance
order
powers
dispensed
necessary
exercise
others
far
courts
doubt
possess
powers
immediately
derived
statute
hudson
cranch
authority
dismiss
sua
sponte
lack
prosecution
generally
considered
inherent
power
governed
rule
statute
control
necessarily
vested
courts
manage
affairs
achieve
orderly
expeditious
disposition
cases
link
wabash
congress
may
degree
specify
manner
inherent
constitutionally
assigned
powers
president
exercised
long
effectiveness
powers
impaired
cf
myers
also
congress
may
prescribe
means
courts
may
protect
integrity
proceedings
must
use
prescribed
means
unless
reason
inadequate
present
case
undoubtedly
justice
kennedy
concedes
impairments
district
proceedings
present
case
sanctionable
federal
rules
doubt
authority
go
beyond
rules
circumstances
agree
overall
sanction
resting
least
substantial
portion
upon
inherent
power
need
broken
component
parts
actions
sustainable
rules
separately
computed
read
rules
issue
require
unreasonable
import
needless
complication
implication
disagree
however
statement
inherent
power
reaches
conduct
beyond
confines
interfer
conduct
trial
ante
quoting
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
see
scalia
concurring
judgment
bank
nova
scotia
scalia
concurring
emphatically
agree
justice
kennedy
therefore
district
power
impose
sanctions
petitioner
flagrant
breach
contract
agree
appears
done
reason
dissent
justice
kennedy
chief
justice
justice
souter
join
dissenting
today
decision
effects
vast
expansion
power
federal
courts
unauthorized
rule
statute
doubt
petitioner
engaged
sanctionable
conduct
warrants
severe
corrective
measures
outrage
conduct
obscure
boundaries
settled
legal
categories
respect
submit
commits
two
fundamental
errors
first
permits
exercise
inherent
sanctioning
powers
without
prior
recourse
controlling
rules
statutes
thereby
abrogating
federal
courts
congress
power
regulate
fees
costs
second
upholds
wholesale
shift
respondent
attorney
fees
petitioner
even
though
district
opinion
reveals
petitioner
sanctioned
least
part
bad
faith
breach
contract
extension
inherent
authority
sanction
party
prelitigation
conduct
subverts
american
rule
turns
erie
doctrine
upside
punishing
petitioner
primary
conduct
contrary
louisiana
law
believe
proper
exercise
inherent
powers
requires
exhaustion
express
sanctioning
provisions
much
greater
caution
application
redress
prelitigation
conduct
dissent
first
error
lies
failure
require
reliance
possible
panoply
express
sanctioning
provisions
provided
congress
american
rule
prohibits
federal
courts
awarding
attorney
fees
absence
statute
contract
providing
fee
award
alyeska
pipeline
service
wilderness
society
rule
recognizes
congress
defines
procedural
remedial
powers
federal
courts
sibbach
wilson
mcintire
wood
cranch
controls
costs
sanctions
fines
available
kaiser
aluminum
chemical
bonjorno
allocation
costs
accruing
litigation
matter
legislature
courts
alyeska
pipeline
supra
circumstances
attorney
fees
awarded
range
discretion
courts
making
awards
matters
congress
determine
direct
action
delegation
congress
exercised
constitutional
prerogative
provide
district
courts
comprehensive
arsenal
federal
rules
statutes
protect
abuse
district
punish
contempt
authority
including
disobedience
process
fine
imprisonment
award
costs
expenses
attorney
fees
attorneys
multiply
proceedings
vexatiously
sanction
party
party
attorney
filing
groundless
pleadings
motions
papers
sanction
party
attorney
failure
abide
pretrial
order
sanction
party
attorney
baseless
discovery
requests
objections
award
expenses
caused
failure
attend
deposition
serve
subpoena
party
deposed
award
expenses
party
fails
respond
discovery
requests
fails
participate
framing
discovery
plan
dismiss
action
claim
party
fails
prosecute
comply
federal
rules
obey
order
punish
person
fails
obey
subpoena
award
expenses
contempt
damages
party
presents
affidavit
summary
judgment
motion
bad
faith
purpose
delay
make
rules
governing
local
practice
inconsistent
federal
rules
see
also
power
award
damages
costs
affirmance
app
proc
power
award
damages
costs
frivolous
appeal
holds
nonetheless
federal
may
ignore
provisions
exercise
inherent
power
sanction
bad
faith
misconduct
even
procedural
rules
exist
sanction
conduct
ante
describes
relation
express
sanctioning
provisions
inherent
power
shift
fees
sanction
bad
faith
conduct
number
ways
one
point
neither
statute
rules
task
cover
sanctionable
conduct
may
safely
rely
inherent
power
ante
another
says
courts
may
place
exclusive
reliance
inherent
authority
whenever
conduct
sanctionable
rules
intertwined
within
conduct
inherent
power
address
ante
details
rule
remain
obscure
general
approach
clear
express
rules
statutes
provided
congress
reach
entirety
litigant
bad
faith
conduct
including
conduct
occurring
litigation
commenced
district
may
disregard
requirements
otherwise
applicable
rules
statutes
instead
exercise
inherent
power
impose
sanctions
limitation
sanctioning
authority
appears
finding
point
bad
faith
standard
fails
define
explanation
permitted
sphere
inherent
powers
shift
fees
sanction
bad
faith
litigation
conduct
illegitimate
unprecedented
american
rule
recognizes
legislature
judiciary
possesses
constitutional
responsibility
defining
sanctions
fees
bad
faith
exception
rule
allows
courts
assess
fees
provided
congress
narrowly
defined
circumstances
roadway
express
piper
allowing
courts
ignore
express
rules
statutes
point
however
treats
inherent
powers
norm
textual
bases
authority
exception
although
recognizes
congress
theory
may
channel
inherent
powers
passage
sanctioning
rules
relies
weinberger
decision
nothing
inherent
authority
create
powerful
presumption
congressional
control
judicial
sanctions
ante
presumption
backwards
inherent
powers
exception
rule
assertion
requires
special
justification
case
like
applications
inherent
power
authority
sanction
bad
faith
litigation
practices
exercised
necessary
preserve
authority
see
roadway
express
piper
supra
inherent
powers
necessary
exercise
others
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
scalia
concurring
judgment
inherent
powers
necessary
permit
courts
function
necessity
limitation
brushes
aside
almost
without
mention
ante
prescribes
rule
correct
application
inherent
powers
although
case
require
articulation
comprehensive
definition
term
necessary
least
need
exercise
inherent
power
congress
provided
mechanism
achieve
end
consistent
unaltered
admonition
inherent
powers
must
exercised
great
caution
ex
parte
burr
wheat
necessity
predicate
limits
exercise
inherent
powers
exceptional
instances
congressionally
authorized
powers
fail
protect
processes
inherent
powers
exercised
necessary
necessity
rule
statute
provides
basis
sanctions
follows
district
rely
authority
derived
congress
rather
inherent
power
every
case
authority
applies
despite
suggestion
contrary
ante
cases
recognize
rules
statutes
limit
exercise
inherent
authority
societe
internationale
pour
participations
industrielles
et
commerciales
rogers
rejected
appeals
reliance
inherent
powers
uphold
dismissal
complaint
failure
comply
production
order
noting
eliance
upon
inherent
power
obscure
analysis
problem
held
whether
power
dismiss
complaint
noncompliance
production
order
depends
exclusively
upon
rule
similarly
bank
nova
scotia
held
federal
invoke
inherent
supervisory
power
circumvent
harmless
error
inquiry
prescribed
ex
parte
robinson
wall
case
cites
proposition
power
punish
contempt
inherent
courts
ante
held
congress
defined
limited
inherent
power
enactment
contempt
statute
enactment
limitation
upon
manner
contempt
power
shall
exercised
ignores
rulings
relies
instead
two
decisions
indicat
inherent
power
invoked
even
procedural
rules
exist
sanction
conduct
ante
indications
discerns
decisions
withstand
scrutiny
roadway
express
piper
supra
held
costs
recoverable
prior
version
discovery
abuse
include
attorney
fees
remand
instruction
mentioned
district
might
consider
awarding
attorney
fees
either
inherent
authority
sanction
litigation
practices
decision
discuss
relation
rule
inherent
power
federal
courts
certainly
suggest
federal
courts
rely
inherent
powers
exclusion
federal
rule
point
also
misreads
link
wabash
link
held
federal
district
possessed
inherent
power
dismiss
case
sua
sponte
failure
prosecute
majority
suggests
holding
contravened
prior
version
today
appeared
require
motion
party
ante
emphasis
added
contrary
characterization
holding
link
turned
determination
rule
contained
permissive
language
merely
authorizes
motion
defendant
emphasis
added
link
reasoned
either
permissive
language
rule
policy
meant
rule
abrogate
inherent
power
federal
courts
dismiss
sua
sponte
permissive
language
issue
link
distinguishes
present
context
sanctioning
provisions
rule
rule
cast
mandatory
terms
addition
dismissing
precedents
misreading
others
ignores
commands
federal
rules
civil
procedure
support
conclusion
rely
rules
inherent
powers
whenever
possible
like
federal
rules
criminal
procedure
federal
rules
civil
procedure
binding
statute
duly
enacted
congress
federal
courts
discretion
disregard
rule
mandate
disregard
constitutional
statutory
provisions
bank
nova
scotia
supra
see
also
federal
rules
govern
procedure
district
courts
suits
civil
nature
emphasis
added
two
prominent
sanctioning
provisions
rules
mandate
imposition
sanctions
litigants
violate
rules
certification
standards
see
shall
impose
appropriate
sanction
violation
certification
standard
see
also
business
guides
chromatic
communications
enterprises
rule
requires
sanctions
imposed
signature
present
fails
satisfy
certification
standard
rules
thus
reject
contention
may
discarded
discretion
disregard
applicable
rules
also
circumvents
rulemaking
procedures
et
congress
designed
assure
procedural
innovations
like
announced
today
shall
introduced
mature
consideration
informed
opinion
relevant
quarters
opportunities
comprehensive
integrated
treatment
consideration
affords
miner
atlass
upon
finding
bad
faith
courts
may
ignore
textual
limitations
sanctioning
power
inviting
district
courts
rely
inherent
authority
substitute
attention
careful
distinctions
contained
rules
statutes
today
decision
render
sources
authority
superfluous
many
instances
number
pernicious
practical
effects
follow
federal
rules
establish
explicit
standards
explicit
checks
exercise
judicial
authority
rule
provides
useful
illustration
requires
district
impose
reasonable
sanctions
including
attorneys
fees
party
attorney
violates
certification
standards
attach
signing
certain
legal
papers
district
must
rather
may
issue
sanctions
rule
particular
individuals
signers
file
certain
types
groundless
unwarranted
vexatious
documents
pleadings
motions
papers
rule
certification
requirements
apply
signers
documents
including
represented
parties
see
business
guides
chromatic
communications
enterprises
supra
law
firms
responsible
signatures
attorneys
see
pavelic
leflore
marvel
entertainment
group
rule
apply
papers
filed
fora
district
courts
see
cooter
gell
hartmarx
definite
standards
give
litigants
notice
proscribed
conduct
make
possible
meaningful
review
misuse
discretion
review
focuses
misapplication
legal
standards
see
misuse
discretion
standard
preclude
appellate
correction
district
legal
errors
contrast
courts
apply
inherent
powers
without
specific
definitional
procedural
limits
true
district
wishes
shift
attorney
fees
sanction
must
make
finding
bad
faith
circumvent
american
rule
today
decision
demonstrates
little
guidance
limitation
undefined
bad
faith
predicate
provides
without
elaboration
courts
must
comply
mandates
due
process
determining
requisite
bad
faith
exists
ante
bad
faith
standard
least
without
adequate
definition
thwarts
first
requirement
due
process
namely
entitled
informed
state
commands
forbids
lanzetta
new
jersey
standardless
exercise
judicial
power
may
appear
innocuous
litigation
commercial
actors
unchecked
power
also
applied
chill
advocacy
litigants
attempting
vindicate
important
federal
rights
addition
scope
sanctionable
conduct
rule
appears
unlimited
boasts
whereas
mechanisms
rules
statutes
reaches
certain
individuals
conduct
inherent
power
extends
full
range
litigation
abuses
ante
allowing
exclusive
resort
inherent
authority
whenever
conduct
sanctionable
rules
intertwined
within
conduct
inherent
power
address
ante
encourages
courts
federal
system
find
bad
faith
misconduct
order
eliminate
need
rely
specific
textual
provisions
ensure
uncertain
development
meaning
scope
express
sanctioning
provisions
encouraging
disuse
defeat
least
area
sanctions
congress
central
goal
enacting
federal
rules
uniformity
federal
courts
hanna
plumer
finally
part
iv
opinion
demonstrates
lack
legal
requirement
talismanic
recitation
phrase
bad
faith
foreclose
meaningful
review
sanctions
based
inherent
authority
see
cooter
gell
hartmarx
supra
despite
deficiencies
insists
concern
collateral
litigation
requires
courts
place
exclusive
reliance
inherent
authority
cases
like
one
involve
conduct
sanctionable
express
provisions
inherent
authority
circumstances
litigant
conduct
deemed
santionable
requiring
first
apply
rules
statutes
containing
sanctioning
provisions
discrete
occurrences
invoking
inherent
power
address
remaining
instances
sanctionable
conduct
serve
foster
extensive
needless
satellite
litigation
contrary
aim
rules
ante
nothing
foregoing
discussion
suggests
sanctioning
provisions
federal
rules
title
eliminate
inherent
power
impose
sanctions
certain
conduct
limitations
power
constitute
abrogation
cases
arise
federal
must
act
preserve
authority
manner
provided
federal
rules
title
number
scope
rules
statutes
governing
litigation
misconduct
increase
necessity
resort
inherent
authority
predicate
proper
application
lessens
indeed
difficult
imagine
case
district
rely
inherent
authority
exclusive
basis
sanctions
district
findings
concerning
abuse
processes
demonstrate
sanctionable
conduct
case
implicated
number
rules
statutes
upon
relied
rule
principal
provision
point
district
found
petitioner
counsel
filed
number
frivolous
pleadings
including
baseless
affirmative
defenses
counterclaims
contained
deliberate
untruths
fabrications
nasco
calcasieu
television
radio
wd
la
rule
sanctions
extend
person
signed
paper
represented
party
thus
nondefeasible
duty
impose
sanctions
rule
concedes
rule
applied
conduct
case
ante
even
hints
rule
might
sufficed
basis
sanctions
imposed
ante
fails
explain
however
district
discretion
ignore
rule
mandatory
language
impose
sanctions
rule
chambers
inform
us
chambers
attorneys
sanctioned
rule
although
district
referred
chambers
strategist
abusive
conduct
made
plain
petitioner
attorneys
well
petitioner
responsible
tactics
example
district
stated
petitioner
attorneys
without
investigation
whatsoever
filed
baseless
charges
counterclaims
find
attorneys
knew
time
filed
false
district
relied
well
upon
sources
authority
impose
sanctions
found
chambers
attorneys
requested
bsolutely
needless
depositions
well
continuances
trial
dates
extensions
deadlines
deferments
scheduled
discovery
simply
part
sordid
scheme
deliberate
misuse
judicial
process
defeat
nasco
claim
harassment
repeated
endless
delay
mountainous
expense
waste
financial
resources
intentional
pretrial
delays
sanctioned
federal
rule
civil
procedure
enables
courts
impose
sanctions
including
attorney
fees
party
attorney
fails
participate
good
faith
certain
pretrial
proceedings
multiple
discovery
abuses
redressed
appropriate
sanction
including
reasonable
attorney
fee
federal
rule
civil
procedure
district
also
sanctioned
chambers
attorneys
various
affidavits
presented
summary
judgment
motions
see
federal
rule
civil
procedure
rule
permits
award
expenses
attorney
fees
additional
sanction
contempt
addition
district
relied
much
greater
extent
punish
contempt
authority
isobedience
process
petitioner
counsel
displayed
throughout
proceedings
finally
district
quick
dismiss
reliance
allows
award
costs
attorney
fees
attorney
multiplies
proceedings
case
unreasonably
vexatiously
district
refused
apply
provision
reach
petitioner
conduct
nonattorney
district
discretion
apply
disregard
statute
face
attorney
misconduct
covered
provision
rely
instead
inherent
powers
definition
invoked
necessary
ii
district
imposes
sanctions
immense
power
amorphous
inherent
authority
must
ensure
order
confined
conduct
authority
jurisdiction
regulate
district
failed
discharge
obligation
allowed
sanctions
awarded
petitioner
prelitigation
breach
contract
majority
perhaps
wary
district
authority
extend
inherent
power
sanction
prelitigation
conduct
insists
district
attempt
sanction
petitioner
breach
contract
rather
imposed
sanctions
fraud
perpetrated
bad
faith
displayed
toward
adversary
throughout
course
litigation
ante
omitted
based
premise
appears
disclaim
holding
reaches
prelitigation
conduct
ante
nn
make
opinion
point
correct
course
district
opinion
view
sanctioned
petitioner
prelitigation
conduct
express
terms
disagree
characterization
district
opinion
believe
casual
analysis
inherent
authority
portends
dangerous
extension
authority
prelitigation
conduct
explain
inherent
authority
extended
district
order
reversed
district
candid
extensive
opinion
reveals
bad
faith
petitioner
sanctioned
extended
beyond
litigation
tactics
comprised
well
district
considered
bad
faith
refusing
perform
underlying
contract
three
weeks
lawsuit
began
made
explicit
reference
instance
massive
absolutely
unnecessary
lawsuit
forced
nasco
chambers
arbitrary
arrogant
refusal
honor
perform
perfectly
legal
enforceable
contract
see
also
chambers
arbitrarily
without
legal
cause
refused
perform
forcing
nasco
bring
suit
specific
performance
ibid
chambers
knowing
nasco
good
valid
contract
hired
gray
find
defense
arbitrarily
refused
perform
thereby
forcing
nasco
bring
suit
specific
performance
injunctive
relief
petitioner
unjustified
arbitrary
refusal
file
fcc
application
absolute
bad
faith
district
makes
open
express
concession
sanctioning
petitioner
breach
contract
balance
fees
expenses
included
sanctions
incurred
nasco
chambers
defaulted
forced
nasco
bring
suit
absolutely
reason
chambers
reimburse
full
attorney
fees
expenses
nasco
chambers
action
forced
pay
despite
equivocation
subject
ante
impermissible
allow
district
acting
pursuant
inherent
authority
sanction
prelitigation
primary
conduct
inherent
authority
extends
remedy
abuses
judicial
process
contrast
awarding
damages
violation
legal
norm
binding
obligation
legal
contract
matter
substantive
law
see
marek
chesny
right
attorney
fees
substantive
reasonable
definition
term
see
also
alyeska
must
defined
either
congress
cases
involving
federal
law
diversity
cases
american
rule
recognizes
principles
bars
federal
shifting
fees
matter
substantive
policy
bad
faith
exception
permits
sanction
extent
necessary
protect
judicial
process
rule
protects
person
right
go
federal
define
vindicate
substantive
rights
ince
litigation
best
uncertain
one
penalized
merely
defending
prosecuting
lawsuit
fleischmann
distilling
maier
brewing
federal
invocation
inherent
powers
sanctions
party
prelitigation
conduct
goes
well
beyond
exception
american
rule
violates
rule
careful
balance
open
access
federal
system
penalties
willful
abuse
exercising
inherent
power
sanction
prelitigation
conduct
district
exercised
authority
congress
gave
none
circumstance
exercise
power
occurred
diversity
case
compounds
error
federal
sits
diversity
jurisdiction
lacks
constitutional
authority
fashion
rules
decision
governing
primary
contractual
relations
see
erie
tompkins
hanna
plumer
see
generally
ely
irrepressible
myth
erie
erie
principle
recognizes
xcept
matters
governed
federal
constitution
acts
congress
law
applied
diversity
case
law
state
inherent
power
exercised
violates
fundamental
tenet
federalism
announced
erie
regulating
primary
behavior
constitution
leaves
exclusive
province
full
effect
district
encroachment
state
prerogatives
appreciated
recalling
rationale
bad
faith
exception
punishment
hall
cole
extent
district
imposed
sanctions
reason
breach
contract
decree
award
punitive
damages
breach
louisiana
prohibits
punitive
damages
unless
expressly
authorized
statute
international
harvester
credit
seale
la
louisiana
statute
authorizes
attorney
fees
breach
contract
part
damages
ordinary
case
ogea
loffland
brothers
rutherford
impson
one
rationale
louisiana
policy
determination
award
compensatory
damages
serve
deterrent
purpose
award
punitive
damages
ricard
state
la
respondent
brought
suit
state
recovered
extra
damages
breach
contract
reason
willful
character
breach
respondent
decision
bring
suit
federal
rather
state
resulted
significant
expansion
substantive
scope
remedy
result
prohibited
erie
principles
flow
notes
passages
district
opinion
suggesting
sanctions
confined
litigation
conduct
see
ante
sanctions
imposed
appl
ied
sanctionable
acts
occurred
connection
proceedings
trial
passages
way
contradict
statements
trial
make
express
reference
prelitigation
conduct
passages
render
order
ambiguous
district
appears
adopted
expansive
definition
acts
occurred
connection
litigation
question
sanctionable
acts
occur
problem
district
opinion
avoids
clear
delineation
acts
sanctioned
power
invoked
confusion
premises
district
order
highlights
mischief
caused
reliance
undefined
inherent
powers
rather
rules
statutes
proscribe
particular
behavior
ambiguity
scope
sanctionable
conduct
resolved
petitioner
alone
despite
conceded
conduct
attorneys
slapped
respondent
inconsiderable
attorney
fees
least
adherence
rule
law
requires
case
remanded
district
clarification
scope
sanctioned
conduct
iii
discussion
construed
approval
behavior
petitioner
attorneys
case
quite
opposite
rules
permit
sanctions
much
conduct
sort
encountered
degrades
profession
disserves
justice
district
courts
must
permit
abuse
must
hesitate
give
redress
rules
statutes
prescribed
may
district
imposed
full
sanction
petitioner
reliance
federal
rules
statutes
well
proper
exercise
inherent
authority
remand
federal
must
decide
cases
based
legitimate
sources
power
reverse
appeals
instructions
remand
district
reassessment
sanctions
consistent
principles
set
forth
reasons
dissent