commonwealth
puerto
rico
sanchez
valle
et
argued
january
decided
june
respondents
luis
sánchez
valle
jaime
gómez
vázquez
sold
gun
undercover
police
officer
puerto
rican
prosecutors
indicted
illegally
selling
firearms
violation
puerto
rico
arms
act
charges
pending
federal
grand
juries
also
indicted
based
transactions
violations
analogous
gun
trafficking
statutes
defendants
pleaded
guilty
federal
charges
moved
dismiss
pending
commonwealth
charges
double
jeopardy
grounds
trial
case
dismissed
charges
rejecting
prosecutors
arguments
puerto
rico
separate
sovereigns
double
jeopardy
purposes
bring
successive
prosecutions
defendant
puerto
rico
appeals
consolidated
cases
reversed
puerto
rico
granted
review
held
line
trial
puerto
rico
gun
sale
prosecutions
violated
double
jeopardy
clause
held
double
jeopardy
clause
bars
puerto
rico
successively
prosecuting
single
person
conduct
equivalent
criminal
laws
pp
ordinarily
person
prosecuted
twice
offense
doctrine
double
jeopardy
clause
bar
successive
prosecutions
brought
separate
sovereigns
see
lanza
yet
sovereignty
context
bear
ordinary
meaning
examine
extent
control
one
prosecuting
entity
wields
degree
entity
exercises
government
particular
ability
enact
enforce
criminal
laws
rather
test
hinges
single
criterion
ultimate
source
power
undergirding
respective
prosecutions
wheeler
two
entities
derive
power
punish
independent
sources
may
bring
successive
prosecutions
conversely
entities
draw
power
ultimate
source
may
approach
separate
sovereigns
federal
government
one
another
rely
authority
originally
belonging
admission
union
preserved
tenth
amendment
state
prosecutions
roots
inherent
sovereignty
unconnected
congress
heath
alabama
similar
reasons
indian
tribes
also
count
separate
sovereigns
tribe
power
punish
union
tribal
prosecution
like
state
attributable
way
delegation
federal
authority
wheeler
conversely
municipality
count
sovereign
distinct
state
receives
power
first
instance
state
see
waller
florida
pertinent
concluded
early
century
territories
including
earlier
incarnation
puerto
rico
sovereigns
distinct
grafton
reasoned
territorial
federal
laws
creations
emanating
sovereignty
puerto
rico
shell
federal
territorial
prosecutors
derive
powers
independent
sources
authority
pp
grafton
shell
decisions
control
century
puerto
rico
became
new
kind
political
entity
still
closely
associated
governed
accordance
exercising
constitution
magnitude
change
requires
consideration
question
anew
yet
result
reached
given
historical
test
applied
ends
going
back
far
doctrine
demands
ultimate
source
puerto
rico
prosecutorial
power
reveals
congress
wheeler
pp
congress
enacted
public
law
authorized
people
puerto
rico
organize
government
pursuant
constitution
adoption
puerto
rican
people
capitalized
opportunity
calling
constitutional
convention
overwhelmingly
approving
charter
drafted
congress
approved
proposal
subject
several
important
conditions
accepted
convention
commonwealth
puerto
rico
new
political
entity
came
constitutional
developments
great
significance
indeed
made
puerto
rico
sovereign
one
commonly
understood
sense
term
point
congress
granted
puerto
rico
degree
autonomy
comparable
possessed
doctrine
hinged
measuring
entity
emergence
commonwealth
resulted
well
capacity
bring
kind
successive
prosecutions
attempted
pp
test
focuses
fact
first
came
identifying
prosecuting
entity
wellspring
authority
insisted
going
way
back
beyond
immediate
even
intermediate
locus
power
termed
ultimate
source
settled
approach
puerto
rico
benefit
doctrine
true
enough
commonwealth
power
enact
enforce
criminal
law
proceeds
petitioner
says
puerto
rico
constitution
ordain
ed
establish
ed
people
preamble
back
puerto
rican
people
constitution
ultimate
source
prosecutorial
power
remains
congress
congress
public
law
authorized
puerto
rico
process
first
instance
congress
later
legislation
amended
draft
charter
gave
indispensable
stamp
approval
put
simply
congress
conferred
authority
create
puerto
rico
constitution
turn
confers
authority
bring
criminal
charges
makes
congress
original
source
power
puerto
rico
prosecutors
federal
government
island
constitution
significant
though
break
chain
pp
affirmed
kagan
delivered
opinion
roberts
kennedy
ginsburg
alito
joined
ginsburg
filed
concurring
opinion
thomas
joined
thomas
filed
opinion
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
breyer
filed
dissenting
opinion
sotomayor
joined
opinion
notice
opinion
subject
formal
revision
publication
preliminary
print
reports
readers
requested
notify
reporter
decisions
washington
typographical
formal
errors
order
corrections
may
made
preliminary
print
goes
press
commonwealth
puerto
rico
petitioner
luis
sanchez
valle
et
al
writ
certiorari
puerto
rico
june
justice
kagan
delivered
opinion
double
jeopardy
clause
fifth
amendment
prohibits
one
prosecution
offence
known
doctrine
single
act
gives
rise
distinct
offenses
thus
may
subject
person
successive
prosecutions
violates
laws
separate
sovereigns
determine
whether
two
prosecuting
authorities
different
sovereigns
double
jeopardy
purposes
asks
narrow
historically
focused
question
inquiry
turn
term
sovereignty
sometimes
suggests
degree
second
entity
autonomous
first
sets
political
course
rather
issue
whether
prosecutorial
powers
two
jurisdictions
independent
origins
said
conversely
whether
powers
derive
ultimate
source
wheeler
case
must
decide
test
puerto
rico
may
successively
prosecute
single
defendant
criminal
conduct
hold
may
oldest
roots
puerto
rico
power
prosecute
lie
federal
soil
puerto
rico
became
territory
result
war
treaty
concluding
conflict
ceded
island
spanish
colony
tasked
congress
determining
civil
rights
political
status
inhabitants
treaty
paris
art
stat
ensuing
years
puerto
rico
forged
unique
political
relationship
built
island
evolution
constitutional
democracy
exercising
local
acting
pursuant
constitution
territory
clause
congress
initially
established
civil
government
puerto
rico
possessing
significant
authority
internal
affairs
organic
act
ch
stat
see
art
iv
cl
granting
congress
power
dispose
make
needful
rules
regulations
respecting
territory
property
belonging
president
advice
consent
senate
appointed
governor
upper
house
legislature
puerto
rican
people
elected
lower
house
see
stat
federal
statutes
generally
applied
still
puerto
rico
newly
constituted
legislature
enact
local
laws
much
way
see
puerto
rico
shell
time
congress
granted
puerto
rico
additional
autonomy
federal
statute
passed
addition
giving
island
inhabitants
citizenship
replaced
upper
house
legislature
popularly
elected
senate
see
organic
act
puerto
rico
ch
stat
amendment
law
empowered
puerto
rican
people
elect
governor
right
never
accorded
territory
see
act
ch
stat
three
years
later
congress
enabled
puerto
rico
embark
project
constitutional
public
law
recognizing
principle
government
consent
authorized
island
people
organize
government
pursuant
constitution
adoption
act
july
stat
describing
nature
compact
statute
submitted
terms
referendum
puerto
rico
voters
ibid
according
terms
eventual
constitution
provide
republican
form
government
include
bill
rights
else
hashed
constitutional
convention
stat
people
puerto
rico
first
decide
still
another
referendum
whether
adopt
convention
proposed
charter
see
stat
congress
cast
dispositive
vote
constitution
public
law
declared
become
effective
pon
approval
congress
ibid
thus
began
two
years
island
puerto
rican
people
first
voted
accept
public
law
thereby
triggering
constitutional
convention
body
completed
work
island
voters
ratified
draft
constitution
congress
took
turn
document
giving
approval
congress
removed
provision
recognizing
various
social
welfare
rights
including
entitlements
food
housing
medical
care
employment
added
sentence
prohibiting
certain
constitutional
amendments
including
restore
section
inserted
language
guaranteeing
children
freedom
attend
private
schools
see
act
july
stat
draft
constitution
commonwealth
puerto
rico
documents
constitutional
relationship
puerto
rico
ramirez
lavandero
ed
finally
constitution
became
law
manner
congress
specified
convention
formally
accepted
conditions
governor
issue
proclamation
effect
ch
stat
puerto
rico
constitution
created
new
political
entity
commonwealth
puerto
rico
spanish
estado
libre
asociado
de
puerto
rico
see
art
like
constitution
divides
political
power
three
branches
legislative
judicial
executive
art
resonant
american
founding
principles
puerto
rico
constitution
describes
tripartite
government
republican
form
subordinate
sovereignty
people
puerto
rico
ibid
commonwealth
power
constitution
proclaims
emanates
people
shall
exercised
accordance
within
terms
compact
agreed
upon
people
puerto
rico
art
leave
lofty
sphere
constitutionalism
grittier
precincts
criminal
law
respondents
luis
sánchez
valle
jaime
gómez
vázquez
separate
occasions
sold
gun
undercover
police
officer
commonwealth
prosecutors
indicted
among
things
selling
firearm
without
permit
violation
puerto
rico
arms
act
see
laws
ann
charges
pending
federal
grand
juries
indicted
sánchez
valle
gómez
vázquez
based
transactions
violations
analogous
gun
trafficking
statutes
see
defendants
pleaded
guilty
federal
charges
following
pleas
sánchez
valle
gómez
vázquez
moved
dismiss
pending
commonwealth
charges
double
jeopardy
grounds
prosecutors
cases
opposed
motions
arguing
puerto
rico
different
sovereigns
double
jeopardy
purposes
bring
successive
prosecutions
two
defendants
trial
courts
rejected
view
dismissed
charges
see
app
pet
cert
puerto
rico
appeals
consolidating
two
cases
reversed
decisions
see
puerto
rico
granted
review
held
puerto
rico
gun
sale
prosecutions
violated
double
jeopardy
clause
see
majority
reasoned
doctrine
crucial
ultimate
source
puerto
rico
power
prosecute
see
use
word
contexts
purposes
irrelevant
power
originally
derived
congress
source
federal
prosecutors
rely
commonwealth
retry
sánchez
valle
gómez
vázquez
unlawfully
selling
firearms
three
justices
disagreed
believing
commonwealth
separate
sovereigns
see
granted
certiorari
determine
whether
double
jeopardy
clause
bars
federal
government
puerto
rico
successively
prosecuting
defendant
like
charges
conduct
hold
affirm
ii
case
involves
double
jeopardy
clause
ordinary
rule
clause
person
prosecuted
twice
offense
see
amdt
shall
person
subject
offence
twice
put
jeopardy
life
limb
two
prosecutions
long
held
offense
brought
different
sovereigns
even
actions
target
identical
criminal
conduct
equivalent
criminal
laws
see
lanza
put
point
hen
act
transgresses
laws
two
sovereigns
truly
averred
offender
twice
punished
offence
one
act
committed
two
offences
heath
alabama
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
double
jeopardy
clause
thus
drops
picture
entities
seek
successively
prosecute
defendant
course
conduct
separate
sovereigns
ibid
truth
told
however
sovereignty
context
bear
ordinary
meaning
whatever
reason
test
devised
decide
whether
two
governments
distinct
double
jeopardy
purposes
overtly
disregards
common
indicia
sovereignty
standard
examine
extent
control
one
prosecuting
authority
wields
wheeler
degree
entity
exercises
whether
autonomously
managing
affairs
continually
submitting
outside
direction
plays
role
analysis
see
shell
care
government
particular
ability
enact
enforce
criminal
laws
see
waller
florida
short
inquiry
despite
label
probe
whether
government
possesses
usual
attributes
acts
common
manner
sovereign
rather
puerto
rico
acknowledges
test
hinges
single
criterion
ultimate
source
power
undergirding
respective
prosecutions
wheeler
see
brief
petitioner
whether
two
prosecuting
entities
dual
sovereigns
double
jeopardy
context
stated
depends
whether
draw
authority
punish
offender
distinct
sources
power
heath
inquiry
thus
historical
functional
looking
deepest
wellsprings
current
exercise
prosecutorial
authority
two
entities
derive
power
punish
wholly
independent
sources
imagine
pair
parallel
lines
may
bring
successive
prosecutions
conversely
entities
draw
power
ultimate
source
imagine
two
lines
emerging
common
point
even
later
diverging
may
approach
separate
sovereigns
federal
government
one
another
see
abbate
bartkus
illinois
heath
powers
undertake
criminal
prosecutions
explained
derive
federal
government
instead
rely
authority
originally
belonging
admission
union
preserved
tenth
amendment
ibid
see
amdt
powers
delegated
constitution
reserved
blatchford
native
village
noatak
noting
entered
union
sovereignty
intact
said
otherwise
prior
forming
union
possessed
separate
independent
sources
power
authority
continue
draw
upon
enacting
enforcing
criminal
laws
heath
state
prosecutions
therefore
ancient
roots
inherent
sovereignty
unconnected
indeed
congress
similar
reasons
indian
tribes
also
count
separate
sovereigns
double
jeopardy
clause
originally
noted
tribes
sovereign
political
communities
possessing
among
capacities
inherent
power
prescribe
laws
members
punish
infractions
laws
wheeler
formation
tribes
became
domestic
dependent
nations
subject
plenary
control
congress
hardly
sovereign
one
common
sense
lara
quoting
cherokee
nation
georgia
pet
see
santa
clara
pueblo
martinez
congress
plenary
authority
limit
modify
eliminate
tribes
powers
local
unless
congress
withdraws
tribal
power
including
power
prosecute
indian
community
retains
authority
earliest
form
see
wheeler
ultimate
source
tribe
power
punish
tribal
offenders
thus
lies
primeval
rate
sovereignty
tribal
prosecution
like
state
attributable
way
delegation
federal
authority
santa
clara
pueblo
alone
matters
double
jeopardy
inquiry
conversely
held
municipality
qualify
sovereign
distinct
state
matter
much
autonomy
criminal
punishment
city
maintains
see
waller
florida
law
recognized
pivotal
case
subject
treated
municipality
separate
sovereign
entit
relevant
purposes
city
possessed
broad
authority
including
power
enact
criminal
ordinances
prosecute
offenses
functional
control
enough
escape
double
jeopardy
bar
indeed
wholly
beside
point
crucial
legal
inquiry
city
state
ultimately
derive
powers
prosecute
independent
sources
authority
heath
describing
waller
reasoning
municipality
first
instance
received
power
state
two
entities
bring
successive
prosecutions
like
offense
pertinent
concluded
early
decades
last
century
territories
including
earlier
incarnation
puerto
rico
sovereigns
distinct
grafton
held
philippine
islands
territory
also
acquired
war
prosecute
defendant
murder
federal
tribunal
acquitted
crime
reasoned
whereas
state
derive
powers
territory
philippine
courts
exert
ed
powers
authority
federal
government
shell
stated
situation
puerto
rico
essentials
commenting
puerto
rican
statute
overlapped
federal
law
explained
legislative
duplication
gave
rise
danger
second
prosecution
territorial
federal
laws
creations
emanating
sovereignty
see
also
heath
noting
federal
territorial
prosecutors
derive
powers
prosecute
independent
sources
authority
background
established
turn
question
presented
prosecutorial
powers
belonging
puerto
rico
federal
government
derive
wholly
independent
sources
see
brief
petitioner
agreeing
framing
issue
criminal
charges
issue
go
forward
addressing
inquiry
view
decisions
grafton
shell
controlling
following
puerto
rico
became
new
kind
political
entity
still
closely
associated
governed
accordance
exercising
popularly
ratified
constitution
magnitude
change
requires
us
consider
question
anew
yet
result
reach
given
legal
test
apply
ends
puerto
rico
today
distinctive
indeed
exceptional
status
commonwealth
approach
historical
go
back
far
doctrine
demands
ultimate
source
puerto
rico
prosecutorial
power
wheeler
discover
congress
recall
events
century
puerto
rico
petitioner
contends
underwent
profound
change
political
system
see
brief
petitioner
people
puerto
rico
engaged
exercise
popular
sovereignty
adopting
constitution
establishing
government
enact
laws
supra
time
congress
enacted
public
law
authorize
puerto
rico
adoption
constitution
designed
replace
federal
statute
structured
island
governance
people
puerto
rico
capitalized
opportunity
calling
constitutional
convention
overwhelmingly
approving
charter
drafted
congress
approved
proposal
subject
several
important
conditions
accepted
convention
commonwealth
new
political
entity
came
constitutional
developments
great
significance
indeed
made
puerto
rico
sovereign
one
commonly
understood
sense
term
recognized
congress
relinquished
control
commonwealth
local
affairs
grant
ing
puerto
rico
measure
autonomy
comparable
possessed
examining
bd
engineers
architects
surveyors
flores
de
otero
see
purpose
congress
legislation
accord
puerto
rico
degree
autonomy
independence
normally
union
rodriguez
popular
cratic
party
puerto
rico
like
state
autonomous
political
entity
sovereign
matters
ruled
federal
constitution
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
newfound
authority
including
local
criminal
laws
brought
mutual
benefit
puerto
rican
people
entire
see
brief
amicus
curiae
double
jeopardy
decisions
hinged
measuring
entity
emergence
commonwealth
resulted
well
capacity
bring
kind
successive
prosecutions
attempted
already
explained
test
adopted
focuses
different
question
fact
came
see
supra
care
example
exercise
autonomous
control
criminal
law
local
affairs
instead
treat
separate
sovereigns
possessed
control
original
matter
rather
deriving
federal
government
see
supra
identifying
prosecuting
entity
wellspring
authority
insisted
going
way
back
beyond
immediate
even
intermediate
locus
power
termed
ultimate
source
wheeler
emphasized
inherent
primeval
capacities
tribes
power
enjoyed
prior
union
formation
heath
santa
clara
pueblo
see
supra
cities
fail
test
even
enact
enforce
criminal
laws
ratified
charters
state
must
initially
authorize
charter
state
source
prosecutorial
power
see
waller
supra
settled
approach
puerto
rico
benefit
doctrine
starters
one
argues
gained
possession
puerto
rico
people
possessed
independent
power
way
tribes
upon
becoming
part
country
puerto
rico
colony
spanish
sovereignty
treaty
paris
art
stat
local
prosecutors
ensuing
decades
petitioner
acknowledges
exercised
power
delegated
congress
statutes
brief
petitioner
see
shell
supra
authority
derived
rather
association
federal
government
contrary
petitioner
claim
puerto
rico
transformative
constitutional
moment
lead
different
conclusion
true
enough
commonwealth
power
enact
enforce
criminal
law
proceeds
petitioner
says
puerto
rico
constitution
ordain
ed
establish
ed
people
preamble
see
brief
petitioner
makes
puerto
rican
populace
immediate
source
authority
decisions
make
relevant
back
puerto
rican
people
constitution
ultimate
source
prosecutorial
power
remains
congress
back
city
charter
lies
state
government
wheeler
congress
public
law
authorized
puerto
rico
process
first
instance
people
territory
legally
initiated
process
see
simms
simms
congress
later
legislation
amended
draft
charter
gave
indispensable
stamp
approval
popular
ratification
however
meaningful
turned
convention
handiwork
put
simply
congress
conferred
authority
create
puerto
rico
constitution
turn
confers
authority
bring
criminal
charges
makes
congress
original
source
power
puerto
rico
prosecutors
government
island
constitution
significant
though
break
chain
petitioner
urges
support
different
view
congress
recognized
new
constitution
democratic
manifestation
people
brief
petitioner
far
disputing
point
readily
acknowledge
petitioner
notes
public
law
affirmed
principle
government
consent
offered
puerto
rican
public
compact
organize
government
pursuant
constitution
adoption
stat
see
brief
petitioner
supra
constitution
congress
approved
petitioner
underscores
declares
people
puerto
rico
create
commonwealth
new
political
entity
republican
form
people
sovereign
government
preamble
art
see
brief
petitioner
supra
language
congress
allow
ed
people
puerto
rico
petitioner
words
begin
new
chapter
democratic
reply
brief
separates
view
petitioner
congressional
recognition
means
puerto
rico
ability
bring
successive
prosecutions
agree
congress
broad
latitude
develop
innovative
approaches
territorial
governance
see
art
iv
cl
congress
may
thus
enable
territory
people
make
choices
political
institutions
congress
exactly
enacting
public
law
approving
puerto
rico
constitution
prime
examples
felix
frankfurter
termed
inventive
statesmanship
respecting
island
memorandum
secretary
war
hearings
senate
committee
pacific
islands
porto
rico
see
reply
brief
one
power
congress
nature
things
capacity
magic
wand
airbrush
erase
otherwise
rewrite
foundational
role
conferring
political
authority
otherwise
said
delegator
make
less
matter
much
authority
opts
hand
test
makes
historical
fact
dispositive
entity
authority
enact
enforce
criminal
law
ultimately
comes
congress
follow
federal
prosecution
true
puerto
rico
congress
authorized
approved
constitution
prosecutorial
power
flows
double
jeopardy
clause
bars
puerto
rico
prosecuting
single
person
conduct
equivalent
criminal
laws
iii
puerto
rico
boasts
relationship
parallel
history
examining
since
events
early
integral
aspect
association
commonwealth
exercised
constitution
result
charter
puerto
rico
today
avail
wide
variety
futures
purposes
double
jeopardy
clause
future
matters
getting
away
past
ultimate
source
puerto
rico
prosecutorial
power
federal
government
trace
authority
way
back
arrive
doorstep
capitol
commonwealth
separate
sovereigns
means
two
governments
twice
put
respondents
sánchez
valle
gómez
vázquez
jeopardy
offence
amdt
accordingly
affirm
judgment
puerto
rico
ordered
ginsburg
concurring
commonwealth
puerto
rico
petitioner
luis
sanchez
valle
et
al
writ
certiorari
puerto
rico
june
justice
ginsburg
justice
thomas
joins
concurring
join
full
opinion
cogently
applies
long
prevailing
doctrine
write
flag
larger
question
bears
fresh
examination
appropriate
case
double
jeopardy
proscription
intended
shield
individuals
harassment
multiple
prosecutions
misconduct
green
current
separate
sovereigns
doctrine
hardly
serves
objective
nation
kindred
systems
yet
parts
one
whole
federalist
hopkins
ed
reprint
within
whole
affront
human
dignity
abbate
black
dissenting
inconsistent
spirit
bill
rights
developments
law
criminal
conspiracy
harv
rev
try
punish
person
twice
offense
several
jurists
commentators
suggested
question
answered
resounding
yes
ordinarily
final
judgment
criminal
case
final
judgment
civil
case
preclude
renewal
fray
anyplace
nation
see
bartkus
illinois
black
dissenting
assets
automotive
calabresi
franck
international
lawyer
looks
bartkus
rule
rev
grant
successive
prosecutions
state
nation
common
law
british
empire
comparisons
ucla
rev
grant
lanza
rule
successive
prosecutions
colum
rev
see
also
lafave
israel
king
kerr
criminal
procedure
ed
criticism
abbate
separate
sovereign
exception
intensified
held
double
jeopardy
clause
fifth
amendment
also
applicable
citing
inter
alia
braun
praying
false
sovereigns
rule
permitting
successive
prosecutions
age
cooperative
federalism
crim
matter
warrants
attention
future
case
defendant
faces
successive
prosecutions
parts
whole
usa
opinion
thomas
commonwealth
puerto
rico
petitioner
luis
sanchez
valle
et
al
writ
certiorari
puerto
rico
june
justice
thomas
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
today
concludes
commonwealth
puerto
rico
separate
sovereigns
federal
government
ultimate
source
puerto
rico
authority
prosecute
crimes
ante
agree
holding
hews
precedents
concerning
double
jeopardy
clause
territories
continue
concerns
precedents
regarding
indian
law
see
lara
opinion
concurring
judgment
join
portions
opinion
concerning
application
double
jeopardy
clause
successive
prosecutions
involving
indian
tribes
aside
caveat
join
opinion
breyer
dissenting
commonwealth
puerto
rico
petitioner
luis
sanchez
valle
et
al
writ
certiorari
puerto
rico
june
justice
breyer
justice
sotomayor
joins
dissenting
agree
case
poses
special
general
question
puerto
rico
sovereignty
asks
whether
prosecutorial
powers
belonging
puerto
rico
federal
government
derive
wholly
independent
sources
ante
agree
however
majority
answer
question
believe
go
back
history
far
doctrine
demands
way
back
source
prosecutorial
power
discover
puerto
rico
federal
government
share
source
power
namely
congress
ante
reasons
disagreeing
majority
part
conceptual
part
historical
conceptually
speaking
mean
literally
find
source
entity
criminal
law
must
seek
source
power
ante
emphasis
added
trace
puerto
rico
source
power
back
spain
rome
justinian
trace
federal
government
source
power
back
english
parliament
william
conqueror
king
arthur
rather
statement
means
trace
source
power
back
time
previously
nonexistent
entity
previously
dependent
entity
became
independent
least
sufficiently
independent
considered
sovereign
purposes
double
jeopardy
clause
viewed
approach
explains
decisions
fairly
well
federal
government
became
independent
entity
constitution
first
took
effect
document
gave
federal
government
authority
enact
criminal
laws
congress
document
created
consequently
source
laws
original
dependents
britain
became
independent
entities
perhaps
time
declaration
independence
perhaps
signing
treaty
paris
perhaps
creation
articles
confederation
need
precise
see
wood
creation
american
republic
problem
sovereignty
solved
declaration
independence
continued
important
theoretical
question
politics
throughout
following
decade
independent
colony
system
consequently
source
original
state
criminal
laws
source
question
becomes
difficult
respect
entities
congress
active
role
play
respect
creation
thus
congressional
activity
appears
highly
relevant
double
jeopardy
question
consider
philippines
one
doubt
philippines
current
possession
sovereign
authority
enact
criminal
laws
yet
trace
power
back
history
must
find
source
islands
lawmaking
authority
longstanding
independent
philippine
institutions
philippines
dependent
independent
decision
congress
president
well
philippines
change
philippines
status
one
independence
congress
authorized
president
withdraw
surrender
right
sovereignty
philippines
stat
codified
authorization
culminated
treaty
manila
signed
approved
congress
year
formally
recognized
philippines
independent
see
stat
obvious
sense
term
source
philippines
independence
ability
enact
enforce
criminal
laws
congress
true
usual
course
territory
becomes
state
within
union
invitation
congress
fact
parallels
admission
new
creation
commonwealth
case
significant
congress
passes
law
allowing
inhabitants
territory
form
constitution
state
government
assume
name
shall
deem
proper
act
apr
ch
stat
illinois
see
also
act
june
ch
stat
new
mexico
qualified
electors
territory
hereby
authorized
vote
choose
delegates
form
constitutional
convention
said
territory
purpose
framing
constitution
proposed
state
new
mexico
territory
develops
proposes
constitution
congress
president
review
approve
allowing
territory
become
state
see
res
stat
illinois
pub
res
stat
new
mexico
presidential
proclamation
stat
william
howard
taft
declare
proclaim
fact
fundamental
conditions
imposed
congress
state
new
mexico
entitle
state
admission
ratified
accepted
federal
government
thus
important
sense
source
legislative
powers
one
might
argue
argued
source
new
sovereign
authority
enact
criminal
laws
lies
constitution
doctrine
doctrine
constitution
treats
new
original
see
ante
difficult
however
characterize
constitutional
insistence
upon
equality
relevant
sense
source
independent
legislative
powers
one
thing
doctrine
requirement
imposed
constitution
see
coyle
smith
reason
constitution
ultimately
source
even
new
equal
powers
source
congress
powers
suggest
alike
power
dignity
authority
ante
quoting
coyle
supra
course
recognize
merely
ask
without
constitution
federal
source
claim
new
lawmaking
power
equal
earliest
counterparts
ante
another
thing
doctrine
means
going
forward
new
must
enjoy
rights
obligations
original
example
equally
restricted
first
amendment
equally
competent
exert
residuum
sovereignty
delegated
constitution
coyle
supra
current
future
equality
destroy
fact
federal
source
rights
obligations
spring
congress
agreed
admit
new
union
accordance
constitution
terms
see
stat
territor
new
mexico
hereby
admitted
union
upon
equal
footing
original
respect
indian
tribes
congressional
action
relevant
double
jeopardy
analysis
explained
tribes
possess
independent
authority
enact
criminal
laws
tracing
source
power
back
time
tribal
existence
tribes
sovereign
political
communities
ante
quoting
wheeler
today
recognizes
prelapsarian
independence
must
read
light
congressional
action
inaction
whatever
tribe
history
congress
maintains
plenary
authority
limit
modify
eliminate
tribes
powers
local
santa
clara
pueblo
martinez
thus
tribes
remain
sovereign
purposes
double
jeopardy
clause
congress
chooses
withdraw
power
ante
sense
congress
pattern
inaction
choice
refrain
withdrawing
dual
sovereignty
amounts
implicit
decision
grant
sovereignty
tribes
congress
way
source
indian
tribes
power
examples
illustrate
complexity
question
us
believe
majority
seems
believe
double
jeopardy
question
answered
simply
tracing
puerto
rico
current
legislative
powers
back
congress
enactment
public
law
calling
congress
enacted
law
source
island
authority
philippines
new
indian
tribes
congressional
activity
historic
circumstances
combine
establish
new
source
power
therefore
must
consider
public
law
broader
context
puerto
rico
history
lens
decide
whether
commonwealth
years
gained
sufficient
sovereign
authority
become
source
power
behind
criminal
laws
ii
treaty
paris
signed
spain
said
civil
rights
political
status
puerto
rico
inhabitants
shall
determined
congress
art
stat
view
congress
enacting
puerto
rican
federal
relations
act
public
law
determined
political
status
puerto
rico
double
jeopardy
purposes
subsequently
encompass
sovereign
authority
enact
enforce
pursuant
powers
criminal
laws
several
considerations
support
conclusion
first
timing
public
law
enactment
suggests
congress
intended
work
significant
change
nature
puerto
rico
political
status
prior
puerto
rico
initially
subject
foraker
act
provided
federal
government
virtually
complete
control
island
affairs
puerto
rico
became
subject
jones
act
provided
citizenship
permitted
puerto
ricans
elect
local
legislators
required
submission
local
laws
congress
approval
signing
nations
charter
promised
change
told
world
develop
territories
art
stat
june
charter
contemporary
observers
referred
public
law
taking
significant
step
direction
change
granting
puerto
rico
special
status
carrying
considerable
autonomy
see
magruder
commonwealth
status
puerto
rico
pitt
rev
see
also
kalman
abe
fortas
biography
puerto
rico
according
fortas
although
federal
government
retained
power
union
second
public
law
uses
language
says
implies
significant
shift
source
many
local
laws
act
points
progressively
recognized
right
people
puerto
rico
stat
ully
recogniz
es
principle
government
consent
describes
nature
compact
people
puerto
rico
may
organize
government
pursuant
constitution
adoption
ibid
specifies
island
new
constitution
must
provide
republican
form
government
characterized
form
government
including
right
people
choose
officers
governmental
administration
pass
laws
virtue
legislative
power
reposed
representative
bodies
whose
legitimate
acts
may
said
people
duncan
third
public
law
created
process
led
puerto
rico
convene
constitutional
convention
write
constitution
assuring
puerto
rico
independent
authority
enact
many
local
laws
specifies
source
much
local
lawmaking
shall
henceforth
people
puerto
rico
constitution
begins
stating
people
puerto
rico
order
organize
politically
fully
democratic
basis
promote
general
welfare
secure
posterity
complete
enjoyment
human
rights
placing
trust
almighty
god
ordain
establish
constitution
commonwealth
understand
democratic
system
government
one
people
source
public
power
preamble
constitution
adds
commonwealth
political
power
emanates
people
shall
exercised
accordance
art
government
commonwealth
puerto
rico
shall
republican
form
legislative
judicial
executive
branches
shall
equally
subordinate
sovereignty
people
puerto
rico
art
criminal
actions
courts
commonwealth
shall
conducted
name
authority
people
puerto
rico
art
vi
time
constitutional
convention
adopted
resolution
stating
puerto
rico
known
officially
commonwealth
puerto
english
estado
libre
asociado
de
puerto
spanish
resolution
documents
constitutional
relationship
puerto
rico
ramirez
lavandero
ed
resolution
explained
names
signified
politically
organized
community
political
power
resides
ultimately
people
hence
free
state
one
time
linked
broader
political
system
federal
type
association
therefore
independent
separate
existence
fourth
puerto
rico
ratified
puerto
rico
constitution
puerto
rico
initially
referendum
held
soon
constitution
written
second
referendum
held
convention
revised
constitution
minor
ways
ways
congress
insisted
upon
relevant
see
stat
see
also
ante
describing
revisions
congress
enacting
legislation
said
constitution
commonwealth
puerto
rico
shall
become
effective
constitutional
convention
puerto
rico
shall
declared
formal
resolution
acceptance
conditions
approval
herein
contained
stat
said
convention
last
word
made
minor
amendments
puerto
rico
ratified
constitution
second
referendum
fifth
three
branches
federal
government
subsequently
recognized
public
law
puerto
rican
constitution
related
congressional
actions
granted
puerto
rico
considerable
autonomy
local
matters
sometimes
akin
state
see
regards
local
matters
sphere
action
methods
government
bear
resemblance
state
union
branch
federal
government
subsequently
took
action
consistent
view
executive
branch
president
truman
wrote
congress
commonwealth
constitution
enacted
ratified
vest
people
puerto
rico
complete
authority
responsibility
local
public
papers
presidents
apr
similarly
president
kennedy
circulated
throughout
executive
branch
memorandum
said
commonwealth
structure
relationship
nature
compact
provide
respect
internal
affairs
administration
subject
applicable
provisions
federal
constitution
puerto
rican
federal
relations
act
public
law
acts
congress
authorizing
approving
constitution
departments
agencies
officials
executive
branch
government
faithfully
carefully
observe
respect
arrangement
relation
matters
affecting
commonwealth
puerto
rico
fed
reg
subsequent
administrations
made
similar
statements
see
liebowitz
application
federal
law
commonwealth
puerto
rico
geo
citing
message
president
johnson
department
state
acting
president
nation
wrote
memorandum
nations
explaining
longer
submit
special
reports
economic
social
educational
conditions
puerto
rico
puerto
rico
longer
territory
charter
art
requiring
periodic
reports
concerning
territories
rather
memorandum
explained
puerto
rico
achieved
full
measure
memorandum
government
america
concerning
cessation
transmission
information
article
charter
regard
commonwealth
puerto
rico
original
intent
constitution
puerto
rico
ed
memorandum
added
congress
agreed
puerto
rico
shall
constitution
freedom
control
interference
congress
respect
internal
government
administration
nations
accepted
view
matter
general
assembly
noting
resolution
people
commonwealth
puerto
rico
achieved
new
political
status
resolution
viii
general
assembly
added
people
commonwealth
puerto
rico
invested
attributes
political
sovereignty
clearly
identify
status
attained
puerto
rican
people
autonomous
political
entity
ibid
see
also
nations
decolonization
trust
territories
online
http
last
visited
june
noting
puerto
rico
underwent
change
status
information
longer
submitted
nations
concerning
former
rusteeship
department
justice
add
case
argued
puerto
rico
double
jeopardy
clause
purposes
independently
sovereign
source
criminal
laws
see
lopez
andino
accepting
government
position
puerto
rico
treated
state
purposes
double
jeopardy
clause
cert
denied
judicial
branch
held
puerto
rico
laws
state
statutes
within
terms
act
see
pearson
yacht
leasing
wrote
events
led
significant
changes
puerto
rico
governmental
structure
commonwealth
body
politic
people
puerto
rico
differences
distinguish
puerto
rico
laws
territories
congressional
regulation
see
also
examining
bd
engineers
architects
surveyors
flores
de
otero
congress
granted
puerto
rico
measure
autonomy
comparable
possessed
rodriguez
popular
democratic
party
puerto
rico
like
state
autonomous
political
entity
sovereign
matters
ruled
federal
constitution
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
finally
legislative
branch
knowledge
since
congress
never
repeat
never
vetoed
modified
local
criminal
law
enacted
puerto
rico
sixth
puerto
rico
consistently
held
period
years
puerto
rico
people
congress
source
puerto
rico
local
criminal
laws
see
pueblo
castro
garcia
offic
trans
puerto
rico
criminal
laws
emanate
different
source
federal
laws
communications
government
capital
transl
puerto
rico
governmental
powers
flow
authority
merely
delegated
congress
ramirez
de
ferrer
mari
bras
wl
westlaw
transl
puerto
rico
governmental
powers
emanate
people
puerto
rico
see
also
pueblo
figueroa
finding
impossible
believe
puerto
rican
constitution
legal
effect
simply
federal
law
cf
figueroa
puerto
rico
constitution
commonwealth
another
organic
act
congress
though
congressional
approval
necessary
launch
forth
seventh
insofar
public
law
related
events
grants
puerto
rico
local
legislative
autonomy
particularly
likely
done
respect
local
criminal
law
puerto
rico
legal
system
arises
reflects
traditional
british
common
law
underlies
criminal
law
tradition
stemming
european
civil
codes
roman
law
chief
justice
trías
monge
wrote
unanimous
puerto
rico
commonwealth
laws
governed
civil
law
system
roots
spanish
legal
tradition
principles
inherent
doctrines
law
valle
american
ins
offic
trans
considerations
knowledge
custom
habit
convention
argue
special
force
autonomy
area
criminal
law
cf
diaz
gonzalez
holmes
cautioning
federal
courts
apply
common
law
conceptions
puerto
rico
island
inherit
ed
brought
different
system
prevails
add
practices
actions
statements
attitudes
described
highly
relevant
long
made
clear
face
difficult
questions
constitution
structural
requirements
longstanding
customs
practices
make
difference
see
nlrb
noel
canning
slip
equally
true
longstanding
practice
government
inform
determination
law
citation
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
see
also
mistretta
dames
moore
regan
youngstown
sheet
tube
sawyer
frankfurter
concurring
pocket
veto
case
ex
parte
grossman
midwest
oil
mcpherson
blacker
mcculloch
maryland
wheat
stuart
laird
cranch
longstanding
customs
actions
attitudes
puerto
rico
mainland
uniformly
favor
puerto
rico
position
sovereign
since
purposes
double
jeopardy
clause
history
statutes
language
organic
acts
traditions
statements
actions
taken
three
branches
federal
government
puerto
rico
convinces
entered
compact
one
terms
source
puerto
rico
criminal
law
ceased
congress
became
puerto
rico
people
constitution
evidence
grant
authority
far
stronger
evidence
congressional
silence
led
conclude
indian
tribes
maintained
similar
sovereign
authority
indeed
difficult
see
conclude
tribes
possess
authority
puerto
rico
regardless
reasons
given
hold
double
jeopardy
clause
purposes
criminal
law
puerto
rico
criminal
law
federal
government
find
origin
source
respectfully
dissent
footnotes
parties
case
agree
double
jeopardy
clause
applies
puerto
rico
occasion
consider
question
see
brief
petitioner
brief
respondents
see
also
brief
amicus
curiae
concurring
dissent
ignoring
longstanding
precedent
contrary
see
supra
infra
advances
approach
stripe
seven
considerations
go
question
whether
commonwealth
virtue
public
law
gained
sovereign
authority
enact
enforce
criminal
laws
post
opinion
breyer
disagreement
dissent
arises
entirely
use
test
question
whether
events
puerto
rico
authority
enact
enforce
criminal
laws
slightly
differently
phrased
whether
congress
decided
autonomy
answer
agree
yes
see
infra
show
inquiry
double
jeopardy
law
made
relevant
contrary
rejected
approach
reached
results
inconsistent
use
see
heath
alabama
waller
florida
see
infra
never
explained
reasons
adopting
historical
approach
doctrine
may
appear
counterintuitive
even
legalistic
compared
inquiry
focused
governmental
entity
functional
autonomy
alternative
raise
serious
problems
application
require
deciding
exactly
much
autonomy
sufficient
separate
sovereignty
whether
given
entity
exercise
exceeds
level
results
suspect
often
uncertain
introducing
error
inconsistency
double
jeopardy
law
contrast
go
show
easily
applied
ultimate
source
test
classify
broad
classes
governments
either
sovereign
purposes
barring
retrials
see
infra
literalists
might
object
original
claim
independent
source
authority
congress
played
role
establishing
territories
authorizing
approving
constitutions
least
admitting
union
see
art
iv
cl
new
may
admitted
congress
union
indeed
tack
dissent
takes
see
post
claiming
reason
federal
government
legislative
powers
long
ago
made
clear
new
state
upon
entry
necessarily
becomes
vested
legal
characteristics
capabilities
first
see
coyle
smith
noting
meaning
state
found
powers
possessed
original
adopted
constitution
principle
equal
footing
held
essential
ensure
nation
remains
union
alike
power
dignity
authority
competent
exert
residuum
sovereignty
delegated
see
northwest
austin
municipal
util
dist
one
holder
referring
fundamental
principle
equal
sovereignty
among
thus
state
exercises
authority
enact
enforce
criminal
laws
virtue
congressional
grace
independent
powers
earliest
counterparts
brought
union
chose
maintain
see
coyle
hen
new
state
admitted
union
admitted
powers
sovereignty
jurisdiction
pertain
original
dissent
contrary
view
say
texas
california
powers
including
power
make
enforce
criminal
law
derive
federal
government
contradicts
fundamental
conceptual
premises
constitutional
order
indeed
bedrock
union
dissent
theory
see
supra
explain
many
decisions
whether
involving
indian
tribes
cities
territories
already
addressed
dissent
misunderstanding
respect
including
ones
see
supra
reasoning
plainer
separate
sovereigns
double
jeopardy
purposes
dissent
claims
exercise
authority
criminal
law
instead
power
derives
source
independent
federal
government
see
heath
tribes
see
supra
indeed
dissent
contrary
reasoning
deeply
disturbing
according
dissent
congress
fact
indian
tribes
power
elected
disturb
exercise
authority
post
beginning
chief
justice
marshall
continuing
nearly
two
centuries
held
firm
fast
view
congress
power
indian
affairs
nothing
gainsay
profound
importance
tribes
sovereignty
see
worcester
georgia
pet
talton
mayes
michigan
bay
mills
indian
community
slip
stated
uncertain
terms
tribes
separate
sovereigns
precisely
inherent
authority
see
wheeler
next
dissent
even
try
explain
rule
municipality
separate
sovereign
state
see
supra
explicitly
recognized
many
cities
words
dissent
test
authority
make
enforce
criminal
laws
post
still
undertake
successive
prosecutions
received
power
state
governments
see
waller
likewise
finally
dissent
fails
face
decisions
territories
distinct
sovereigns
powers
exercise
delegations
congress
see
grafton
supra
course
makes
different
current
philippines
see
post
whose
relevance
hard
fathom
independent
nation
philippines
wields
prosecutorial
power
traceable
congressional
conferral
authority
repeat
matters
entity
capacity
make
enforce
criminal
law
ultimately
comes
another
government
two
separate
sovereigns
double
jeopardy
purposes
petitioner
statements
telling
role
congress
necessarily
played
constitutional
process
see
reply
brief
pursuant
congress
invitation
congress
consent
people
puerto
rico
engaged
exercise
popular
sovereignty
commonwealth
legal
cornerstone
public
law
tr
oral
arg
describing
adoption
puerto
rico
constitution
pursuant
invitation
congress
blessing
congress