granfinanciera
nordberg
argued
january
decided
june
respondent
bankruptcy
trustee
corporation
undergoing
chapter
reorganization
filed
suit
district
petitioners
seeking
avoid
allegedly
fraudulent
monetary
transfers
bankrupt
corporation
predecessor
recover
damages
costs
expenses
interest
referred
proceedings
bankruptcy
shortly
colombian
government
nationalized
petitioner
granfinanciera
petitioners
requested
jury
trial
bankruptcy
judge
denied
request
deeming
suit
recover
fraudulent
transfer
core
action
understanding
english
common
law
issue
district
affirmed
bankruptcy
judgment
respondent
without
discussing
petitioners
jury
trial
request
appeals
also
affirmed
ruling
inter
alia
seventh
amendment
supplied
right
jury
trial
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
equitable
nature
even
plaintiff
seeks
monetary
relief
bankruptcy
proceedings
inherently
equitable
nature
congress
displaced
right
jury
trial
designating
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
core
proceedings
triable
bankruptcy
judges
sitting
without
juries
held
address
respondent
contention
judgment
affirmed
petitioner
granfinanciera
commercial
instrumentality
colombian
government
made
request
jury
trial
therefore
entitled
trial
seventh
amendment
applicable
statutory
provisions
difficult
question
neither
raised
adequately
briefed
argued
exceptional
case
consider
arguments
raised
moreover
petitioners
claim
uncontradicted
affirmance
ground
respondent
urges
enlarge
respondent
rights
judgment
decrease
granfinanciera
pp
provided
congress
permissibly
assigned
resolution
claim
iii
adjudicative
body
use
jury
factfinder
seventh
amendment
entitles
person
submitted
claim
bankruptcy
estate
jury
trial
sued
bankruptcy
trustee
recover
allegedly
fraudulent
monetary
transfer
pp
since
decisions
early
english
cases
scholarly
authority
demonstrate
respondent
bring
action
law
england
equity
adjudicated
must
concluded
preliminarily
action
sui
common
law
jury
trial
required
seventh
amendment
pp
importantly
nature
relief
respondent
seeks
recovery
money
payments
ascertained
definite
amounts
conclusively
demonstrates
cause
action
characterized
legal
rather
equitable
petitioners
prima
facie
entitled
jury
trial
amendment
schoenthal
irving
trust
pp
seventh
amendment
entitles
petitioners
requested
jury
trial
notwithstanding
designation
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
core
proceedings
iii
bankruptcy
judges
may
adjudicate
pp
although
seventh
amendment
prohibit
congress
assigning
resolution
statutory
claim
legal
nature
iii
tribunal
use
jury
factfinder
long
claim
asserts
public
right
congress
lacks
power
strip
parties
contesting
matters
private
right
constitutional
right
jury
trial
see
atlas
roofing
occupational
safety
health
review
northern
pipeline
construction
marathon
pipe
line
purposes
public
right
limited
matter
arising
government
others
extends
seemingly
private
right
closely
intertwined
federal
regulatory
program
congress
power
enact
thomas
union
carbide
agricultural
products
pp
bankruptcy
trustee
right
recover
fraudulent
conveyance
accurately
characterized
private
rather
public
right
although
plurality
northern
pipeline
construction
supra
noted
restructuring
relations
bankruptcy
may
well
public
right
also
emphasized
causes
action
breach
contract
paradigmatic
private
rights
even
asserted
insolvent
corporation
midst
chapter
reorganization
proceedings
trustees
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
quintessentially
suits
nearly
resemble
contract
claims
bankrupt
corporation
augment
bankruptcy
estate
creditors
claims
pro
rata
share
bankruptcy
res
analysis
confirmed
katchen
landy
must
read
hold
creditor
seventh
amendment
right
jury
trial
bankruptcy
trustee
preference
claim
depends
upon
whether
creditor
submitted
claim
estate
since
petitioners
filed
claims
respondent
suit
neither
part
claims
adjudication
process
integral
restructuring
relations
congress
therefore
divest
petitioners
seventh
amendment
right
merely
relabeling
cause
action
right
attaches
assigning
specialized
equity
particularly
evidence
congress
considered
constitutional
implications
designation
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
core
proceedings
pp
permitting
jury
trials
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
significantly
impair
functioning
legislative
scheme
seriously
argued
allowing
actions
trustee
suit
person
entered
claim
estate
go
far
dismantle
statutory
scheme
phrase
used
atlas
roofing
supra
since
atlas
plainly
assumed
claims
carried
right
jury
trial
addition
easily
said
jury
incompatible
bankruptcy
proceedings
since
congress
expressly
provided
jury
trials
certain
actions
arising
bankruptcy
litigation
claim
juries
may
serve
usefully
checks
judges
decisions
overlooks
potential
juries
exercise
beneficial
restraint
decisions
judges
may
beholden
congress
executive
moreover
although
providing
jury
trials
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
might
impede
swift
resolution
bankruptcy
proceedings
increase
expense
chapter
reorganizations
considerations
insufficient
overcome
seventh
amendment
clear
command
pp
brennan
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
marshall
stevens
kennedy
joined
parts
ii
iii
scalia
joined
scalia
filed
opinion
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
post
white
filed
dissenting
opinion
post
blackmun
filed
dissenting
opinion
joined
post
adam
lawrence
argued
cause
petitioners
briefs
boyce
ezell
iii
laurence
tribe
argued
cause
respondent
brief
gary
jones
saturnino
lucio
ii
justice
brennan
delivered
opinion
question
presented
whether
person
submitted
claim
bankruptcy
estate
right
jury
trial
sued
trustee
bankruptcy
recover
allegedly
fraudulent
monetary
transfer
hold
seventh
amendment
entitles
person
trial
jury
notwithstanding
congress
designation
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
core
proceedings
supp
chase
sanborn
corporation
filed
petition
reorganization
chapter
bankruptcy
code
plan
reorganization
approved
bankruptcy
southern
district
florida
vested
respondent
nordberg
trustee
bankruptcy
causes
action
fraudulent
conveyances
app
pet
cert
respondent
filed
suit
petitioners
granfinanciera
medex
district
southern
district
florida
complaint
alleged
petitioners
received
million
chase
sanborn
corporate
predecessor
within
one
year
date
bankruptcy
petition
filed
without
receiving
consideration
reasonably
equivalent
value
return
respondent
sought
avoid
alleged
constructively
actually
fraudulent
transfers
recover
damages
costs
expenses
interest
ed
supp
app
pet
cert
district
referred
proceedings
bankruptcy
five
months
later
shortly
colombian
government
nationalized
granfinanciera
respondent
served
summons
petitioners
bogota
colombia
answer
complaint
following
granfinanciera
nationalization
petitioners
requested
trial
jury
issues
triable
app
bankruptcy
judge
denied
petitioners
request
jury
trial
deeming
suit
recover
fraudulent
transfer
core
action
originally
english
common
law
understand
issue
app
pet
cert
following
bench
trial
dismissed
prejudice
respondent
actual
fraud
claim
entered
judgment
respondent
constructive
fraud
claim
amount
granfinanciera
medex
district
affirmed
without
discussing
petitioners
claim
entitled
jury
trial
appeals
eleventh
circuit
also
affirmed
found
petitioners
lacked
statutory
right
jury
trial
constructive
fraud
provision
suit
brought
supp
contains
mention
right
jury
trial
supp
affords
jury
trials
personal
injury
wrongful
death
suits
appeals
ruled
seventh
amendment
supplied
right
jury
trial
actions
recover
fraudulent
conveyances
equitable
nature
even
plaintiff
seeks
monetary
relief
bankruptcy
equitable
nature
thus
bankruptcy
proceedings
inherently
equitable
read
opinion
katchen
landy
say
congress
may
convert
creditor
legal
right
equitable
claim
displace
seventh
amendment
right
trial
jury
held
congress
done
designating
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
core
proceedings
triable
bankruptcy
judges
sitting
without
juries
granted
certiorari
decide
whether
petitioners
entitled
jury
trial
reverse
ii
considering
petitioners
claim
jury
trial
must
confront
preliminary
argument
respondent
contends
judgment
affirmed
respect
granfinanciera
though
medex
granfinanciera
commercial
instrumentality
colombian
government
made
request
jury
trial
respondent
argues
seventh
amendment
preserves
jury
trial
rights
recognized
england
common
law
late
century
foreign
sovereigns
instrumentalities
immune
suit
common
law
suits
foreign
sovereigns
possible
respondent
asserts
accordance
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
fsia
respondent
reads
prohibit
trial
jury
case
foreign
state
respondent
concludes
granfinanciera
right
jury
trial
regardless
merits
medex
seventh
amendment
claim
decline
address
argument
respondent
failed
raise
question
poses
adequately
briefed
argued
without
certiorari
prevailing
party
may
course
defend
judgment
ground
properly
raised
whether
ground
relied
upon
rejected
even
considered
district
appeals
washington
yakima
indian
nation
provided
affirmance
alternative
ground
neither
expand
contract
rights
either
party
established
judgment
see
blum
bacon
new
york
telephone
respondent
present
defense
judgment
however
one
advanced
although
consider
grounds
supporting
judgment
different
appeals
rested
decision
ground
presented
raised
exercise
authority
exceptional
cases
heckler
campbell
quoting
mcgoldrick
compagnie
generale
transatlantique
exceptional
case
lack
guidance
district
appeals
issue
difficult
questions
remain
whether
jury
trial
available
foreign
state
upon
request
circumstances
business
enterprise
since
become
arm
foreign
state
may
entitled
jury
trial
compare
gould
pechiney
ugine
kuhlmann
jurisdiction
determined
party
status
act
complained
occurred
morgan
guaranty
trust
republic
palau
supp
sdny
status
time
complaint
filed
decisive
jurisdiction
callejo
bancomer
fsia
applies
even
though
bank
nationalized
suit
filed
wolf
banco
nacional
de
mexico
cert
denied
moreover
petitioners
alleged
reply
brief
without
contradiction
respondent
oral
argument
affirmance
ground
respondent
urges
unquestionably
enlarge
respondent
rights
circuit
decision
concomitantly
decrease
petitioner
open
ing
new
areas
discovery
aid
execution
allowing
respondent
first
time
recover
judgment
wins
granfinanciera
colombia
central
banking
institutions
possibly
colombian
governmental
instrumentalities
reply
brief
petitioners
whatever
merits
claims
plausibility
coupled
respondent
failure
offer
rebuttal
furnishes
additional
reason
consider
respondent
novel
argument
support
judgment
late
stage
litigation
therefore
leave
another
day
questions
respondent
argument
raises
fsia
iii
petitioners
rest
claim
jury
trial
seventh
amendment
alone
seventh
amendment
provides
suits
common
law
value
controversy
shall
exceed
twenty
dollars
right
trial
jury
shall
preserved
consistently
interpreted
phrase
suits
common
law
refer
suits
legal
rights
ascertained
determined
contradistinction
equitable
rights
alone
recognized
equitable
remedies
administered
parsons
bedford
pet
although
thrust
amendment
preserve
right
jury
trial
existed
seventh
amendment
also
applies
actions
brought
enforce
statutory
rights
analogous
causes
action
ordinarily
decided
english
law
courts
late
century
opposed
customarily
heard
courts
equity
admiralty
curtis
loether
form
analysis
familiar
first
compare
statutory
action
actions
brought
courts
england
prior
merger
courts
law
equity
second
examine
remedy
sought
determine
whether
legal
equitable
nature
tull
citations
omitted
second
stage
analysis
important
first
balance
two
factors
indicate
party
entitled
jury
trial
seventh
amendment
must
decide
whether
congress
may
assign
assigned
resolution
relevant
claim
iii
adjudicative
body
use
jury
factfinder
dispute
actions
recover
preferential
fraudulent
transfers
often
brought
law
late
england
noted
schoenthal
irving
trust
omitted
england
long
prior
enactment
first
judiciary
act
common
law
actions
trover
money
received
resorted
recovery
preferential
payments
bankrupts
see
smith
payne
eng
trover
barnes
freeland
eng
trover
smith
hodson
eng
assumpsit
goods
sold
delivered
vernon
hanson
eng
assumpsit
money
received
thompson
freeman
eng
trover
rust
cooper
cowp
eng
trover
harman
fishar
cowp
eng
trover
martin
pewtress
burr
eng
trover
alderson
temple
burr
eng
trover
actions
like
suits
law
conducted
juries
respondent
challenge
proposition
even
contend
actions
recover
fraudulent
conveyances
preferential
transfers
occasionally
tried
courts
equity
asserts
courts
equity
concurrent
jurisdiction
courts
law
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
brief
respondent
respondent
assertion
courts
equity
sometimes
provided
relief
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
true
however
hardly
suffices
undermine
petitioners
submission
present
action
monetary
relief
sounded
equity
years
ago
england
parsons
bedford
supra
emphasis
added
contrasted
suits
law
equitable
rights
alone
recognized
holding
seventh
amendment
right
jury
trial
applies
latter
actions
respondent
adduces
authority
buttress
claim
suits
recover
allegedly
fraudulent
transfer
money
sort
brought
typically
indeed
ever
entertained
english
courts
equity
seventh
amendment
adopted
fact
prior
decisions
see
buzard
houston
scholarly
authority
compel
contrary
conclusion
hether
trustee
suit
law
equity
judged
standards
applied
owner
property
wrongfully
withheld
subject
matter
chattel
still
grantee
possession
action
trover
replevin
trustee
remedy
fraudulent
transfer
cash
trustee
action
money
received
actions
law
available
trustee
english
courts
long
ago
hand
subject
matter
land
intangible
trustee
needs
equitable
aid
accounting
like
may
invoke
equitable
process
also
beyond
dispute
glenn
fraudulent
conveyances
preferences
pp
rev
ed
footnotes
omitted
hobbs
hull
cox
eng
ch
also
fails
advance
respondent
case
assignees
bankruptcy
sued
set
aside
alleged
fraudulent
conveyance
real
estate
trust
husband
wife
return
relinquishment
cause
action
divorce
upon
discovering
adultery
dismissed
suit
finding
transfer
fraudulent
allowed
assignees
bring
ejectment
legal
action
law
courts
salient
point
bankruptcy
assignees
sought
traditional
equitable
remedy
setting
aside
conveyance
land
trust
rather
recovery
money
goods
refused
decide
legal
claim
ejectment
ruled
equitable
remedy
lie
sweeping
statement
courts
equity
certainly
habit
exercising
concurrent
jurisdiction
courts
law
statutes
elizabeth
respecting
fraudulent
conveyances
eng
supported
reference
cases
sought
recovery
fixed
sum
money
without
need
accounting
equitable
relief
respondent
repaired
deficit
therefore
conclude
respondent
bring
action
recover
alleged
fraudulent
conveyance
determinate
sum
money
law
england
equity
adjudicated
nature
relief
respondent
seeks
strongly
supports
preliminary
finding
right
invokes
denominated
legal
rather
equitable
decisions
establish
beyond
peradventure
cases
fraud
mistake
head
chancery
jurisdiction
sustain
bill
equity
obtain
decree
payment
money
way
damages
like
amount
recovered
law
action
sounding
tort
money
received
buzard
houston
citing
parkersburg
brown
ambler
choteau
litchfield
ballou
see
also
atlas
roofing
occupational
safety
health
review
otherwise
legal
issues
voidable
preferences
pernell
southall
realty
action
simply
recovery
money
judgment
action
one
law
quoting
whitehead
shattuck
dairy
queen
wood
petitioner
contention
insofar
complaint
requests
money
judgment
presents
claim
unquestionably
legal
agree
contention
gaines
miller
whenever
one
person
hands
money
equitably
belonging
another
person
may
recover
assumpsit
money
received
remedy
law
adequate
complete
citations
omitted
indeed
view
schoenthal
irving
trust
removes
doubt
respondent
cause
action
characterized
legal
rather
equitable
schoenthal
trustee
bankruptcy
sued
equity
recover
alleged
preferential
payments
claiming
adequate
remedy
law
case
recipients
payments
apparently
file
claims
bankruptcy
estate
held
suit
proceed
law
instead
rule
suits
equity
sustained
complete
remedy
exists
law
codified
serves
guard
right
trial
jury
preserved
seventh
amendment
end
liberally
construed
found
trustee
suit
indistinguishable
respondent
suit
relevant
respects
go
forward
equity
adequate
remedy
available
law
preferences
sued
money
payments
ascertained
definite
amounts
bill
discloses
facts
call
accounting
equitable
relief
respondent
fraudulent
conveyance
action
plainly
seeks
relief
traditionally
provided
law
courts
law
side
courts
legal
equitable
dockets
unless
congress
may
permissibly
withdrawn
jurisdiction
action
courts
law
assigned
exclusively
iii
tribunals
sitting
without
juries
seventh
amendment
guarantees
petitioners
jury
trial
upon
request
iv
prior
passage
bankruptcy
reform
act
pub
stat
act
uits
recover
preferences
constitute
part
proceedings
bankruptcy
schoenthal
irving
trust
supra
although
related
bankruptcy
proceedings
fraudulent
conveyance
preference
actions
brought
trustee
bankruptcy
deemed
separate
plenary
suits
seventh
amendment
applied
act
brought
actions
within
jurisdiction
bankruptcy
courts
preserved
parties
rights
trial
jury
existed
prior
effective
date
act
repealed
amendments
however
designated
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
core
proceedings
supp
bankruptcy
judges
may
adjudicate
may
issue
final
judgments
district
referred
matter
obliged
decide
today
whether
bankruptcy
courts
may
conduct
jury
trials
fraudulent
conveyance
suits
brought
trustee
person
entered
claim
estate
either
rare
procedural
posture
case
see
supra
current
statutory
scheme
see
supp
need
decide
whether
congress
authorized
bankruptcy
courts
hold
jury
trials
actions
authorization
comports
article
iii
iii
judges
preside
actions
subject
review
withdrawal
district
courts
also
need
consider
whether
jury
trials
conducted
bankruptcy
satisfy
seventh
amendment
command
fact
tried
jury
shall
otherwise
according
rules
common
law
given
district
courts
may
presently
set
aside
clearly
erroneous
factual
findings
bankruptcy
courts
bkrtcy
rule
sole
issue
us
whether
seventh
amendment
confers
petitioners
right
jury
trial
face
congress
decision
allow
iii
tribunal
adjudicate
claims
atlas
roofing
noted
congress
creates
new
statutory
public
rights
may
assign
adjudication
administrative
agency
jury
trial
incompatible
without
violating
seventh
amendment
injunction
jury
trial
preserved
suits
common
law
omitted
emphasized
however
congress
power
block
application
seventh
amendment
cause
action
limits
congress
may
deny
trials
jury
actions
law
said
cases
public
rights
litigated
prior
cases
support
administrative
factfinding
situations
involving
public
rights
government
involved
sovereign
capacity
otherwise
valid
statute
creating
enforceable
public
rights
wholly
private
tort
contract
property
cases
well
vast
range
cases
implicated
adhere
general
teaching
said
atlas
roofing
common
law
side
federal
courts
aid
juries
deemed
appropriate
required
constitution
quoting
crowell
benson
congress
may
devise
novel
causes
action
involving
public
rights
free
strictures
seventh
amendment
assigns
adjudication
tribunals
without
statutory
authority
employ
juries
factfinders
lacks
power
strip
parties
contesting
matters
private
right
constitutional
right
trial
jury
recognized
atlas
roofing
hold
otherwise
permit
congress
eviscerate
seventh
amendment
guarantee
assigning
administrative
agencies
courts
equity
causes
action
grounded
state
law
whether
originate
newly
fashioned
regulatory
scheme
possess
long
line
forebears
constitution
nowhere
grants
congress
puissant
authority
egal
claims
magically
converted
equitable
issues
presentation
equity
ross
bernhard
congress
conjure
away
seventh
amendment
mandating
traditional
legal
claims
brought
taken
administrative
tribunal
certain
situations
course
congress
may
fashion
causes
action
closely
analogous
claims
place
beyond
ambit
seventh
amendment
assigning
resolution
forum
jury
trials
unavailable
see
atlas
roofing
supra
workplace
safety
regulations
block
hirsh
temporary
emergency
regulation
rental
real
estate
see
also
pernell
southall
realty
discussing
cases
murray
lessee
hoboken
land
improvement
congress
may
may
bring
within
cognizance
courts
may
deem
proper
matters
involving
public
rights
congress
power
limited
however
power
place
adjudicative
authority
iii
tribunals
circumscribed
see
thomas
union
carbide
agricultural
products
brennan
concurring
judgment
northern
pipeline
construction
marathon
pipe
line
opinion
brennan
rehnquist
concurring
judgment
unless
legal
cause
action
involves
public
rights
congress
may
deprive
parties
litigating
right
seventh
amendment
guarantee
jury
trial
atlas
roofing
supra
noted
congress
may
effectively
supplant
cause
action
carrying
right
jury
trial
statutory
cause
action
shorn
jury
trial
right
statutory
cause
action
inheres
lies
federal
government
sovereign
capacity
case
law
makes
plain
however
class
public
rights
whose
adjudication
congress
may
assign
administrative
agencies
courts
equity
sitting
without
juries
expansive
atlas
roofing
discussion
suggests
indeed
decisions
point
conclusion
statutory
cause
action
legal
nature
question
whether
seventh
amendment
permits
congress
assign
adjudication
tribunal
employ
juries
factfinders
requires
answer
question
whether
article
iii
allows
congress
assign
adjudication
cause
action
iii
tribunal
statutory
cause
action
respondent
right
recover
fraudulent
conveyance
public
right
article
iii
purposes
congress
may
assign
adjudication
specialized
iii
lacking
essential
attributes
judicial
power
crowell
benson
supra
action
must
tried
auspices
article
iii
seventh
amendment
affords
parties
right
jury
trial
whenever
cause
action
legal
nature
conversely
congress
may
assign
adjudication
statutory
cause
action
iii
tribunal
seventh
amendment
poses
independent
bar
adjudication
action
nonjury
factfinder
see
atlas
roofing
supra
pernell
southall
realty
supra
block
hirsh
supra
addition
seventh
amendment
precedents
therefore
rely
decisions
exploring
restrictions
article
iii
places
congress
choice
adjudicative
bodies
resolve
disputes
statutory
rights
determine
whether
petitioners
entitled
jury
trial
recent
discussion
public
rights
doctrine
bears
congress
power
commit
adjudication
statutory
cause
action
iii
tribunal
rejected
view
matter
public
rights
must
minimum
arise
government
others
northern
pipeline
construction
supra
opinion
brennan
quoting
ex
parte
bakelite
held
instead
federal
government
need
party
case
revolve
around
public
rights
thomas
union
carbide
agricultural
products
brennan
concurring
judgment
crucial
question
cases
involving
federal
government
whether
congress
acting
valid
legislative
purpose
pursuant
constitutional
powers
article
create
seemingly
private
right
closely
integrated
public
regulatory
scheme
matter
appropriate
agency
resolution
limited
involvement
article
iii
judiciary
see
brennan
concurring
judgment
challenged
provision
involves
public
rights
dispute
arises
context
federal
regulatory
scheme
virtually
occupies
field
statutory
right
closely
intertwined
federal
regulatory
program
congress
power
enact
right
neither
belongs
exists
federal
government
must
adjudicated
article
iii
right
legal
nature
carries
seventh
amendment
guarantee
jury
trial
although
issue
admits
debate
bankruptcy
trustee
right
recover
fraudulent
conveyance
seems
us
accurately
characterized
private
rather
public
right
used
terms
article
iii
decisions
northern
pipeline
construction
plurality
noted
restructuring
relations
bankruptcy
may
well
public
right
plurality
also
emphasized
causes
action
breach
contract
warranty
paradigmatic
private
rights
even
asserted
insolvent
corporation
midst
chapter
reorganization
proceedings
plurality
said
matters
nature
subject
suit
common
law
equity
admiralty
lie
protected
core
article
iii
judicial
power
see
rehnquist
concurring
judgment
point
reaffirmed
thomas
supra
little
doubt
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
bankruptcy
trustees
suits
said
schoenthal
irving
trust
citation
omitted
constitute
part
proceedings
bankruptcy
concern
controversies
arising
quintessentially
suits
common
law
nearly
resemble
contract
claims
brought
bankrupt
corporation
augment
bankruptcy
estate
creditors
hierarchically
ordered
claims
pro
rata
share
bankruptcy
res
see
gibson
therefore
appear
matters
private
rather
public
right
decision
katchen
landy
seventh
amendment
rather
article
iii
confirms
analysis
petitioner
officer
bankrupt
corporation
made
payments
corporate
funds
within
four
months
bankruptcy
corporate
notes
accommodation
maker
petitioner
later
filed
claims
bankruptcy
estate
trustee
counterclaimed
arguing
payments
petitioner
made
constituted
voidable
preferences
reduced
potential
personal
liability
notes
held
bankruptcy
jurisdiction
order
petitioner
surrender
preferences
rule
trustee
claim
without
according
petitioner
jury
trial
holding
depend
however
fact
bankruptcy
courts
essentially
courts
equity
characteristically
proceed
summary
fashion
deal
assets
bankrupt
administering
notwithstanding
fact
bankruptcy
courts
characteristically
supervised
summary
proceedings
statutorily
invested
jurisdiction
law
well
also
oversee
plenary
proceedings
see
atlas
roofing
katchen
rested
ground
bankruptcy
exercising
summary
jurisdiction
specialized
equity
emphasis
added
pepper
litton
many
purposes
courts
bankruptcy
essentially
courts
equity
emphasis
added
decision
turned
rather
bankruptcy
actual
constructive
possession
bankruptcy
estate
power
obligation
consider
objections
trustee
deciding
whether
allow
claims
estate
citing
schoenthal
irving
trust
supra
approvingly
expressly
stated
petitioner
submitted
claim
bankruptcy
trustee
recovered
preference
plenary
action
petitioner
entitled
jury
trial
trustee
brought
plenary
action
federal
see
made
plainer
holding
schoenthal
retained
vitality
lthough
petitioner
might
entitled
jury
trial
issue
preference
presented
claim
bankruptcy
proceeding
awaited
federal
plenary
action
trustee
schoenthal
irving
trust
issue
arises
part
process
allowance
disallowance
claims
triable
equity
unlike
justice
white
see
post
view
conclusion
katchen
resting
accident
statutory
history
read
schoenthal
katchen
holding
seventh
amendment
creditor
right
jury
trial
bankruptcy
trustee
preference
claim
depends
upon
whether
creditor
submitted
claim
estate
upon
congress
precise
definition
bankruptcy
estate
upon
whether
congress
chanced
deny
jury
trials
creditors
filed
claims
sued
trustee
recover
alleged
preference
petitioners
like
petitioner
schoenthal
filed
claims
estate
respondent
fraudulent
conveyance
action
arise
part
process
allowance
disallowance
claims
action
integral
restructuring
relations
congress
therefore
divest
petitioners
seventh
amendment
right
trial
jury
katchen
thus
supports
result
reach
today
certainly
compel
opposite
act
abolished
statutory
distinction
plenary
summary
bankruptcy
proceedings
relied
schoenthal
katchen
although
act
preserved
parties
rights
jury
trials
existed
prior
day
took
effect
repealed
amendments
congress
drew
new
distinction
core
proceedings
classified
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
core
proceedings
triable
bankruptcy
judges
supp
whether
supp
purports
abolish
jury
trial
rights
formerly
plenary
actions
unclear
rate
question
need
decide
see
supra
decisive
point
neither
act
amendments
congress
creat
new
cause
action
remedies
therefor
unknown
common
law
traditional
rights
remedies
inadequate
cope
manifest
public
problem
atlas
roofing
rather
congress
simply
reclassified
cause
action
integrally
related
reformation
relations
apparently
suffer
grave
deficiencies
purely
taxonomic
change
alter
seventh
amendment
analysis
congress
eliminate
party
seventh
amendment
right
jury
trial
merely
relabeling
cause
action
attaches
placing
exclusive
jurisdiction
administrative
agency
specialized
equity
see
gibson
congress
assignment
justified
ground
jury
trials
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
go
far
dismantle
statutory
scheme
atlas
roofing
bankruptcy
proceedings
placed
administrative
forum
jury
incompatible
sure
owe
deference
congress
judgment
given
careful
consideration
constitutionality
legislative
provision
see
northern
pipeline
construction
opinion
brennan
respondent
adduced
evidence
congress
considered
constitutional
implications
designation
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
core
proceedings
seriously
argued
permitting
jury
trials
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
brought
trustee
person
entered
claim
estate
go
far
dismantle
statutory
scheme
used
phrase
atlas
roofing
opinion
case
following
schoenthal
plainly
assumed
claims
carried
right
jury
trial
addition
one
easily
say
jury
incompatible
bankruptcy
proceedings
view
congress
express
provision
jury
trials
certain
actions
arising
bankruptcy
litigation
see
supp
gibson
warner
katchen
bankruptcy
new
jury
trial
right
bankr
hereinafter
warner
justice
white
claim
juries
may
serve
usefully
checks
decisions
judges
enjoy
life
tenure
see
post
overlooks
extent
judges
appointed
fixed
terms
may
beholden
congress
executive
officials
thus
ignores
potential
juries
exercise
beneficial
restraint
decisions
may
providing
jury
trials
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
particular
case
respondent
suit
commenced
bankruptcy
approved
debtor
plan
reorganization
impede
swift
resolution
bankruptcy
proceedings
increase
expense
chapter
reorganizations
considerations
insufficient
overcome
clear
command
seventh
amendment
curtis
loether
see
also
bowsher
synar
fact
given
law
procedure
efficient
convenient
useful
facilitating
functions
government
standing
alone
save
contrary
constitution
quoting
ins
chadha
pernell
southall
realty
discounting
arguments
jury
trials
unduly
burdensome
rejecting
notion
necessary
inconsistency
desire
speedy
justice
right
jury
trial
decide
today
whether
current
jury
trial
provision
supp
permits
bankruptcy
courts
conduct
jury
trials
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
like
one
respondent
initiated
express
view
whether
seventh
amendment
article
iii
allows
jury
trials
actions
held
iii
bankruptcy
judges
subject
oversight
provided
district
courts
pursuant
amendments
leave
issues
future
decisions
hold
however
whatever
answers
questions
seventh
amendment
entitles
petitioners
jury
trial
requested
accordingly
judgment
appeals
reversed
case
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
footnotes
district
courts
shall
original
jurisdiction
without
regard
amount
controversy
nonjury
civil
action
foreign
state
defined
section
title
claim
relief
personam
respect
foreign
state
entitled
immunity
either
sections
title
applicable
international
agreement
emphasis
added
indeed
respondent
strenuously
supported
appeals
conclusion
echoed
district
see
app
pet
cert
fsia
inapplicable
case
bar
rationale
transfers
question
suit
recover
transfers
occurred
granfinanciera
nationalized
sweeping
rationale
granfinanciera
never
proved
instrumentality
foreign
state
never
really
nationalized
see
brief
appellee
pp
brief
appellee
sd
pp
admittedly
respondent
present
position
fsia
confer
immunity
granfinanciera
instrumentality
foreign
state
alleged
wrongs
occurred
respondent
filed
suit
necessarily
incompatible
claim
granfinanciera
qualify
jury
trial
fsia
requested
jury
trial
nationalized
respondent
attempted
however
reconcile
views
make
second
claim
filed
merits
brief
current
statutory
provision
jury
trials
bankruptcy
proceedings
supp
enacted
part
bankruptcy
amendments
federal
judgeship
act
amendments
pub
stat
notoriously
ambiguous
section
provides
chapter
title
affect
right
trial
jury
individual
applicable
nonbankruptcy
law
regard
personal
injury
wrongful
death
tort
claim
although
section
might
suggest
jury
trials
available
personal
injury
wrongful
death
actions
conclusion
debatable
section
provides
district
may
order
issues
arising
connection
involuntary
bankruptcy
petitions
tried
without
jury
suggesting
lacks
similar
discretion
deny
jury
trials
least
issues
presented
connection
voluntary
petitions
confused
legislative
history
provisions
puzzled
commentators
see
gibson
jury
trials
bankruptcy
obeying
commands
article
iii
seventh
amendment
rev
hereinafter
gibson
note
bankruptcy
amendments
federal
judgeship
act
impact
right
jury
trial
bankruptcy
tex
tech
rev
whatever
proper
construction
petitioners
concede
section
entitle
jury
trial
section
amendments
stat
bars
application
cases
title
code
pending
date
enactment
act
proceedings
arising
related
cases
chase
sanborn
petition
reorganization
pending
date
predecessor
stated
chapter
title
affect
right
trial
jury
case
title
proceeding
arising
title
arising
related
case
title
provided
statute
effect
september
seem
afford
petitioners
statutory
basis
claim
recognize
apparently
repealed
amendments
see
gibson
king
jurisdiction
procedure
bankruptcy
amendments
vand
rev
brief
respondent
petitioners
therefore
appear
correct
concluding
absent
specific
legislation
force
providing
jury
trials
cases
filed
july
tried
afterwards
right
jury
trial
proceeding
must
necessarily
predicated
entirely
seventh
amendment
brief
petitioners
see
also
brief
respondent
quite
distinct
inquiry
whether
congress
permissibly
entrusted
resolution
certain
disputes
administrative
agency
specialized
equity
whether
jury
trials
impair
functioning
legislative
scheme
appears
contemplated
ross
bernhard
identified
practical
abilities
limitations
juries
additional
factor
consulted
determining
whether
seventh
amendment
confers
jury
trial
right
see
tull
atlas
roofing
occupational
safety
health
review
consider
issue
part
iv
infra
contrary
justice
white
contention
see
post
declare
seventh
amendment
provides
right
jury
trial
legal
rather
equitable
claims
claim
legal
nature
asserts
public
right
define
term
part
iv
seventh
amendment
entitle
parties
jury
trial
congress
assigns
adjudication
administrative
agency
specialized
equity
see
infra
seventh
amendment
protects
litigant
right
jury
trial
cause
action
legal
nature
involves
matter
private
right
rather
list
english
cases
support
contention
fraudulent
monetary
transfers
traditionally
cognizable
equity
respondent
cites
three
recent
cases
courts
appeals
cases
however
weaken
rather
bolster
respondent
argument
graham
held
seventh
amendment
jury
trial
right
suit
equitable
remedy
setting
aside
alleged
fraudulent
conveyance
real
estate
bankrupt
respect
suits
like
respondent
expressly
noted
action
creditor
seeking
money
damages
action
law
citations
omitted
damsky
zavatt
also
involved
conveyance
real
estate
acknowledged
jury
trials
ordinarily
available
respect
monetary
claims
see
holdings
questionable
moreover
extent
tension
decision
whitehead
shattuck
although
scholarly
support
claim
actions
recover
real
property
quintessentially
equitable
actions
see
glenn
fraudulent
conveyances
preferences
pp
rev
ed
whitehead
stated
action
simply
recovery
possession
specific
real
personal
property
recovery
money
judgment
action
one
law
action
recovery
real
property
including
damages
withholding
always
class
right
case
plaintiff
wishes
assert
title
certain
real
property
remedy
wishes
obtain
possession
enjoyment
contest
title
parties
constitutional
right
call
jury
finally
respondent
misreads
harbour
fourth
circuit
relied
case
authorities
referred
distinguishing
suits
recover
fraudulent
transfers
bankruptcy
proceedings
holding
seventh
amendment
right
jury
trial
longer
extends
actions
based
historical
analysis
accords
erroneous
belief
congress
possesses
power
assign
jurisdiction
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
bankruptcy
courts
sitting
without
juries
case
therefore
lends
support
respondent
historical
argument
citing
several
authorities
justice
white
contends
ther
scholars
looked
history
come
different
conclusion
post
assertion
however
lacks
support
claims
exception
justice
gray
opinion
drake
rice
mass
roberts
treatise
none
authorities
cited
much
mentions
english
practice
although
collier
offers
opinion
actions
set
aside
fraudulent
transfers
equitable
nature
collier
bankruptcy
ed
refers
recent
cases
defending
opinion
acknowledging
courts
disagreed
bump
wait
limit
citations
decisions
refusing
analyze
earlier
english
cases
see
bump
conveyances
made
debtors
defraud
creditors
ed
wait
fraudulent
conveyances
creditors
bills
sure
drake
rice
justice
gray
says
law
england
american
revolution
fraudulent
conveyances
choses
action
though
specified
statute
elizabeth
equally
void
nature
subject
remedy
creditor
must
sought
equity
reason
suits
recover
fraudulent
transfers
choses
action
brought
equity
justice
gray
points
attached
levied
upon
see
also
bump
supra
remedy
law
property
taken
execution
attachment
justice
gray
summary
english
practice
extend
cases
involving
monetary
transfers
adequate
remedy
existed
law
passage
justice
white
cites
roberts
treatise
obscure
speak
squarely
question
whether
english
courts
equity
hear
cases
legal
remedies
sufficient
see
roberts
voluntary
fraudulent
conveyances
ed
respondent
claims
seek
avoidance
allegedly
fraudulent
transfers
restitution
funds
actually
transferred
maintains
petitioners
made
restitution
impossible
transferred
funds
distinguished
dollars
petitioners
bank
accounts
see
brief
respondent
avoidance
restitution
classical
equitable
remedies
says
petitioners
entitled
trial
jury
find
strained
attempt
circumvent
precedent
unpersuasive
dollars
fungible
respondent
requested
accounting
specifically
equitable
form
relief
complete
remedy
available
law
equity
countenance
action
complete
relief
may
obtained
law
see
schoenthal
irving
trust
moreover
plaintiff
entitled
return
funds
transferred
violation
supp
judge
lacks
equitable
discretion
refuse
enter
award
less
amount
transfer
distinction
might
exist
damages
monetary
relief
different
label
purely
semantic
relevance
adjudication
petitioners
seventh
amendment
claim
cf
albemarle
paper
moody
rehnquist
concurring
indeed
even
checks
respondent
seeks
recover
lay
untouched
petitioners
offices
legal
remedies
apparently
sufficed
see
adams
champion
whitehead
shattuck
although
left
term
public
rights
undefined
atlas
roofing
occupational
safety
health
review
cited
crowell
benson
approvingly
crowell
defined
private
right
liability
one
individual
another
law
defined
contrast
cases
arise
government
persons
subject
authority
connection
performance
constitutional
functions
executive
legislative
departments
proposition
firmly
established
atlas
roofing
supra
omitted
congress
required
seventh
amendment
choke
already
crowded
federal
courts
new
types
litigation
prevented
committing
new
types
litigation
administrative
agencies
special
competence
relevant
field
case
even
seventh
amendment
required
jury
adjudication
rights
assigned
federal
law
instead
administrative
agency
atlas
roofing
stated
cases
involve
private
rights
accepted
factfinding
administrative
agency
without
intervention
jury
adjunct
art
iii
analogizing
agency
jury
special
master
permitting
admiralty
cases
perform
function
special
master
statement
however
must
read
context
first
referred
explicitly
congress
power
disputes
concern
private
rights
provide
administrative
factfinding
instead
jury
trials
admiralty
cases
civil
causes
action
admiralty
however
suits
common
law
seventh
amendment
purposes
thus
constitutional
right
jury
trial
attaches
waring
clarke
second
statement
taken
mean
congress
may
assign
least
initial
factfinding
cases
involving
controversies
entirely
private
parties
administrative
agencies
tribunals
involving
juries
long
established
adjuncts
article
iii
courts
congress
render
seventh
amendment
nullity
rather
statement
citing
crowell
benson
means
cases
involving
private
rights
term
defined
crowell
used
atlas
roofing
namely
encompassing
disputes
federal
government
party
sovereign
capacity
may
congress
dispense
juries
factfinders
choice
adjudicative
forum
cases
congress
may
decline
provide
jury
trials
ones
involving
statutory
rights
integral
parts
public
regulatory
scheme
whose
adjudication
congress
assigned
administrative
agency
specialized
equity
whatever
terminological
distinctions
atlas
roofing
may
suggested
refer
rights
public
rather
private
suggest
restructuring
relations
fact
public
right
thesis
met
substantial
scholarly
criticism
see
gibson
currie
bankruptcy
judges
independent
judiciary
creighton
rev
baird
bankruptcy
procedure
rights
lessons
gibbons
marathon
sup
rev
need
seek
defend
point
even
one
accepts
thesis
seventh
amendment
entitles
petitioners
jury
trial
see
northern
pipeline
construction
marathon
pipe
line
opinion
brennan
restructuring
relations
core
federal
bankruptcy
power
must
distinguished
adjudication
private
rights
right
recover
contract
damages
issue
case
former
may
well
public
right
latter
obviously
although
said
katchen
landy
petitioner
might
entitled
jury
trial
presented
claim
bankruptcy
estate
approving
references
schoenthal
also
adams
champion
buffum
barceloux
see
demonstrate
intend
cast
doubt
proposition
petitioner
katchen
entitled
jury
trial
entered
claim
estate
bankruptcy
trustee
requested
solely
legal
relief
merely
left
open
possibility
jury
trial
might
required
cases
preference
avoidance
actions
equitable
character
katchen
supra
adopted
rationale
articulated
alexander
hillman
citations
omitted
presenting
claims
respondents
subjected
consequences
attach
appearance
respondents
contention
means
invoking
jurisdiction
establish
right
participate
distribution
may
deny
power
require
account
misappropriated
behalf
creditors
stockholders
receivers
reasonably
may
insist
taking
aught
respondents
may
receivership
required
make
restitution
requirement
harmony
rule
generally
followed
courts
equity
jurisdiction
parties
controversies
brought
decide
matters
dispute
decree
complete
relief
hardly
needs
pointing
justice
white
assertion
see
post
case
controlled
statement
katchen
makes
difference
far
petitioner
seventh
amendment
claim
concerned
whether
bankruptcy
trustee
urges
objection
also
seeks
affirmative
relief
entirely
unfounded
read
context
statement
merely
means
creditor
filed
claim
estate
bankruptcy
trustee
may
recover
full
amount
preference
received
even
amount
exceeds
amount
creditor
claim
statement
says
nothing
creditor
seventh
amendment
right
jury
trial
trustee
preference
action
creditor
entered
claim
estate
adventitious
relation
trustee
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
reorganization
proceedings
recognized
schoenthal
katchen
federal
bankruptcy
legislation
acknowledged
treating
plenary
actions
defendant
made
claim
estate
congress
expressly
provided
jury
trial
rights
evidenced
events
case
respondent
fraudulent
conveyance
action
filed
well
bankruptcy
approved
plan
reorganization
chase
sanborn
tangible
assets
business
liquidated
reply
brief
petitioner
course
amendments
altered
statutory
scheme
formed
backdrop
discussion
atlas
roofing
connection
depriving
persons
filed
claims
estate
statutory
right
jury
trial
trustee
sues
recover
alleged
fraudulent
conveyance
preferential
transfer
amendments
alter
nature
trustee
claim
relief
entitled
say
failure
respect
congress
reclassification
causes
action
go
far
dismantle
statutory
scheme
simply
partly
define
new
statutory
scheme
render
test
empty
tautology
say
course
contrary
justice
white
assertion
see
post
regard
congress
amendments
bankruptcy
statutes
act
whimsy
sweeping
changes
congress
instituted
clearly
intended
make
reorganization
process
efficient
justice
white
quotation
senate
report
indicates
radical
reforms
whose
legislative
history
dissent
relies
work
slightest
alteration
right
jury
trial
alleged
recipients
fraudulent
conveyances
change
came
although
enhanced
efficiency
likely
congress
aim
neither
justice
white
justice
blackmun
points
statement
legislative
history
amendments
confirming
supposition
respect
preference
actions
particular
important
offer
evidence
congress
considered
propriety
action
seventh
amendment
house
report
cited
justice
blackmun
see
post
advocated
conferring
article
iii
status
bankruptcy
judges
favored
approach
therefore
eliminated
problem
us
clearly
entitling
petitioners
jury
trial
seventh
amendment
see
pt
pp
approach
rejected
senate
defending
alternative
proposal
ultimately
prevailed
however
senate
report
justice
blackmun
refers
neglects
discuss
specifically
inclusion
preference
actions
class
core
proceedings
potential
difficulties
seventh
amendment
assignment
might
give
rise
see
pp
apparently
senate
judiciary
committee
overlooked
problem
entirely
thus
amendments
denial
right
jury
trial
preference
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
hardly
said
represent
congress
considered
judgment
constitutionality
change
respondent
argues
example
prompt
resolution
fraudulent
transfer
claims
brought
bankruptcy
trustees
often
crucial
reorganization
process
demanding
jury
trial
party
delay
proceedings
alter
negotiating
framework
unfairly
extract
favorable
terms
brief
respondent
warrants
notice
however
provision
jury
trials
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
apparently
attended
substantial
difficulties
previous
bankruptcy
statutes
respondent
pointed
discussion
allegedly
serious
problem
legislative
history
act
amendments
many
cases
defendants
likely
request
jury
trials
causes
action
recover
preferences
may
assigned
pursuant
plan
reorganization
rather
pursued
prior
plan
approval
done
case
congress
enacting
supp
explicitly
provided
jury
trials
personal
injury
claims
likely
take
much
longer
try
preference
actions
often
involve
large
sums
money
one
commentator
noted
interpretation
katchen
delay
expense
exception
seventh
amendment
negated
rejection
argument
delay
even
significant
problem
jury
prejudice
override
seventh
amendment
katchen
reference
delay
expense
must
therefore
read
part
consideration
whether
legal
remedy
become
sufficiently
adequate
result
shifting
boundaries
law
equity
minimum
delay
expense
language
katchen
must
read
light
petitioner
demand
stay
bankruptcy
action
institution
separate
suit
different
qualitatively
different
type
delay
expense
delay
expense
providing
jury
trial
action
latter
never
override
beacon
theatres
dairy
queen
wood
warner
footnotes
omitted
see
justice
white
accuses
us
rather
coy
statute
invalidating
post
preferring
obtuse
must
preside
jury
trial
petitioners
entitled
post
however
helpful
might
us
adjudge
every
pertinent
statutory
constitutional
issue
presented
act
amendments
properly
reach
decide
matters
us
question
called
upon
answer
case
whether
seventh
amendment
grants
petitioners
right
jury
trial
hold
unequivocally
justice
scalia
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
join
part
iv
opinion
make
exception
agree
premise
discussion
federal
government
need
party
case
revolve
around
public
rights
ante
quoting
thomas
union
carbide
agricultural
products
view
matter
public
rights
whose
adjudication
congress
may
assign
tribunals
lacking
essential
characteristics
article
iii
courts
must
minimum
arise
government
others
northern
pipeline
construction
marathon
pipe
line
plurality
opinion
quoting
ex
parte
bakelite
quite
recently
also
consistent
view
see
presence
proper
party
necessary
sufficient
means
distinguishing
private
rights
public
rights
atlas
roofing
occupational
safety
health
review
public
rights
cases
cases
government
sues
sovereign
capacity
enforce
public
rights
created
statutes
noting
distinction
cases
private
right
arise
government
persons
subject
authority
situations
involving
public
rights
government
involved
sovereign
capacity
otherwise
valid
statute
creating
enforceable
public
rights
crowell
benson
public
rights
arise
government
persons
subject
authority
connection
performance
constitutional
functions
executive
legislative
departments
ex
parte
bakelite
supra
public
rights
arising
government
others
nature
require
judicial
determination
yet
susceptible
murray
lessee
hoboken
land
improvement
plaintiff
argument
controversy
susceptible
judicial
determination
must
judicial
controversy
heard
article
iii
leaves
view
fact
party
notion
power
adjudicate
legal
controversy
two
private
parties
may
assigned
iii
yet
federal
tribunal
entirely
inconsistent
origins
public
rights
doctrine
language
article
iii
course
admits
exceptions
directs
unambiguously
judicial
power
shall
vested
one
inferior
courts
congress
may
time
time
ordain
establish
murray
lessee
supra
however
recognized
category
public
rights
whose
adjudication
though
judicial
act
congress
may
assign
tribunals
lacking
essential
characteristics
article
iii
courts
case
involved
act
may
stat
established
summary
procedure
obtaining
collectors
federal
revenue
funds
owed
treasury
procedure
federal
auditor
made
determination
funds
due
distress
warrant
issued
solicitor
treasury
authorizing
marshal
seize
sell
personal
property
collector
convey
real
property
satisfaction
debt
lien
upon
real
property
effective
upon
marshal
filing
distress
warrant
district
district
property
located
debtor
however
bring
challenge
distress
warrant
district
judicial
challenge
every
fact
upon
legality
remedy
depends
may
drawn
question
murray
lessee
involved
dispute
title
lands
owned
former
collector
customs
treasury
auditor
adjudged
deficient
remittances
defendant
purchased
land
marshal
sale
pursuant
duly
issued
distress
warrant
apparently
contested
collector
district
proceeding
plaintiff
acquired
land
pursuant
execution
judgment
collector
execution
occurred
marshal
sale
marshal
filing
distress
warrant
establish
lien
brought
action
ejectment
try
title
argued
inter
alia
process
defendant
obtained
title
violated
article
iii
adjudication
collector
indebtedness
inherently
judicial
act
lawfully
performed
treasury
auditor
article
iii
rejected
contention
observing
although
auditing
accounts
receiver
public
moneys
may
enlarged
sense
judicial
act
english
american
traditions
established
without
consent
congress
give
rise
judicial
controversy
within
meaning
article
iii
course
answering
plaintiff
rejoinder
holding
uttered
words
giving
birth
public
rights
doctrine
plaintiff
argued
correct
matter
nature
judicial
controversy
congress
make
give
jurisdiction
district
courts
bills
permitted
filed
collectors
challenging
distress
warrants
fact
congress
enabled
district
pass
upon
conclusive
evidence
judicial
controversy
argument
said
leaves
view
fact
party
unlike
private
party
acts
extrajudicially
recapture
property
marshal
executes
distress
warrant
made
responsible
judicial
tribunal
obeying
lawful
command
government
government
gave
command
sued
without
consent
even
though
issue
question
appropriate
matter
judicial
controversy
ibid
congress
however
waive
immunity
permit
challenges
factual
bases
officers
actions
article
iii
courts
waiver
place
proceeding
courts
unconditionally
ab
initio
may
consent
sued
may
yield
consent
upon
terms
restrictions
may
think
ibid
thus
summed
passage
establishing
doctrine
issue
matters
involving
public
rights
may
presented
form
judicial
power
capable
acting
susceptible
judicial
determination
congress
may
may
bring
within
cognizance
courts
may
deem
proper
emphasis
added
thomas
union
carbide
agricultural
products
however
decided
interpret
phrase
public
rights
though
developed
context
discussed
bear
meaning
described
pronounced
far
tell
sheer
force
office
applies
right
closely
integrated
public
regulatory
scheme
matter
appropriate
agency
resolution
limited
involvement
article
iii
judiciary
emphasis
added
doctrine
reflects
announced
simply
pragmatic
understanding
congress
selects
method
resolving
matters
conclusively
determined
executive
legislative
branches
danger
encroaching
judicial
powers
reduced
quoting
northern
pipeline
supra
without
pointing
murray
lessee
adjudications
private
rights
conclusively
determined
executive
legislative
branches
select
category
private
rights
government
thus
held
thomas
first
time
purely
private
federally
created
action
require
article
iii
courts
view
constitutional
basis
decision
purport
faithful
origins
public
rights
doctrine
murray
lessee
replace
careful
analysis
case
reasoning
identifies
discrete
category
judicial
acts
time
constitution
adopted
thought
implicate
judicial
controversy
lines
sought
established
constitution
matter
pragmatic
understanding
counted
evaluation
whether
danger
encroaching
judicial
powers
phrase
drained
constant
content
much
term
thomas
commodity
futures
trading
schor
reconfirmed
error
embracing
analysis
thomas
describing
greater
length
new
article
iii
standard
established
seems
standard
reviewing
article
iii
challenges
weighed
number
factors
none
deemed
determinative
eye
practical
effect
congressional
action
constitutionally
assigned
role
federal
judiciary
among
factors
upon
focused
extent
essential
attributes
judicial
power
reserved
article
iii
courts
conversely
extent
iii
forum
exercises
range
jurisdiction
powers
normally
vested
article
iii
courts
origins
importance
right
adjudicated
concerns
drove
congress
depart
requirements
article
iii
citing
thomas
supra
return
longstanding
principle
public
rights
doctrine
requires
minimum
party
adjudication
basis
concur
conclusion
part
iv
opinion
article
iii
concomitant
jury
trial
eliminated
since
join
remainder
opinion
concur
judgment
well
justice
white
dissenting
decision
today
calls
question
several
previous
decisions
strikes
least
one
federal
statute
potentially
concludes
first
time
seventh
amendment
guarantees
litigants
specialized
iii
forum
right
jury
trial
accept
departures
established
law
respectfully
dissent
explore
approach
analyzing
issues
presented
case
first
take
question
precedent
directly
disregards
today
katchen
landy
though
professes
overrule
decision
curiously
acting
reliance
see
ante
simply
way
reconcile
decision
katchen
holds
today
katchen
petitioner
filed
claim
bankruptcy
proceeding
recover
funds
alleged
due
bankrupt
estate
respondent
trustee
resisted
paying
claims
based
old
bankruptcy
act
forbade
payments
creditors
holding
void
voidable
preferences
petitioner
claimed
much
petitioners
question
whether
prior
payments
preferences
matter
adjudicated
without
benefit
jury
trial
rejected
claim
holding
seventh
amendment
right
jury
trial
claims
katchen
katchen
issue
preference
tried
without
jury
purpose
denying
filed
claim
pursuant
money
judgment
amount
preference
entered
without
jury
trial
makes
difference
far
petitioner
seventh
amendment
claim
concerned
whether
bankruptcy
trustee
urges
objection
also
seeks
affirmative
relief
holding
dispositively
settles
question
us
today
like
petitioner
katchen
petitioners
case
seventh
amendment
right
jury
trial
respondent
trustee
seeks
avoid
allegedly
fraudulent
transfers
received
order
escape
force
katchen
holding
exploits
circumstances
decision
made
notably
time
katchen
decided
bankruptcy
act
force
act
include
actions
set
aside
voidable
preferences
among
proceedings
covered
act
thus
clause
opinion
katchen
supra
today
puts
much
weight
petitioner
might
entitled
jury
trial
issue
preference
presented
claim
bankruptcy
proceeding
awaited
federal
plenary
action
trustee
see
ante
simply
stated
truism
act
force
time
petitioner
presented
claim
bankruptcy
jurisdiction
perform
summary
adjudication
preference
entitlement
however
heavily
relies
solely
product
statutory
scheme
existence
time
next
phrase
appearing
katchen
decision
make
little
sense
hen
issue
validity
preference
arises
part
process
allowance
disallowance
claims
triable
equity
katchen
supra
katchen
makes
clear
congress
commit
issue
recovery
preference
adjudication
bankruptcy
proceeding
seventh
amendment
inapplicable
limits
act
prevented
case
instances
thereby
left
katchen
possibility
jury
trial
right
today
bankruptcy
code
markedly
different
specifically
bankruptcy
amendments
federal
judgeship
act
amendments
action
recover
fraudulently
transferred
property
classified
core
bankruptcy
proceeding
see
supp
katchen
day
special
circumstances
adjudicating
preference
committed
bankruptcy
proceedings
today
congress
expressly
designated
adjudication
preference
fraudulent
transfer
core
bankruptcy
proceeding
portion
katchen
relies
petitioner
might
entitled
jury
trial
issue
preference
presented
claim
bankruptcy
proceeding
awaited
federal
plenary
action
trustee
see
ante
therefore
relic
history
true
decision
schoenthal
irving
trust
holding
uits
recover
preferences
constitute
part
proceedings
bankruptcy
merely
reflected
statutory
scheme
recognizes
distinction
earlier
law
present
code
calls
change
purely
taxonomic
one
alter
seventh
amendment
analysis
ante
disagree
two
reasons
first
change
significant
illustrates
state
law
time
katchen
explains
case
came
hypocritical
rely
katchen
statement
existence
jury
trial
entitlement
petitioner
claim
dismiss
taxonomic
change
wiped
jury
entitlement
least
profoundly
shifted
basis
fundamentally
inclusion
actions
recover
fraudulently
conveyed
property
among
core
bankruptcy
proceedings
meaning
beyond
taxonomic
explain
detail
see
part
infra
long
recognized
forum
claim
heard
plays
substantial
role
determining
extent
seventh
amendment
jury
trial
right
exists
put
katchen
cases
bankruptcy
many
incidental
questions
arise
course
administering
bankrupt
estate
ordinarily
pure
cases
law
respect
facts
triable
jury
belonging
bankruptcy
proceedings
become
cases
bankruptcy
acts
equity
exercises
exclusive
control
thus
claim
debt
damages
bankrupt
investigated
chancery
methods
katchen
supra
quoting
barton
barbour
essence
rejection
katchen
classification
change
effected
act
taxonomic
comes
conclusion
fraudulent
conveyance
action
issue
part
process
allowance
disallowance
claims
ante
quoting
katchen
misses
katchen
point
however
fact
congress
committed
determination
recovery
preferences
bankruptcy
proceedings
determinative
case
bare
fact
action
happened
take
place
process
adjudicating
claims
determinative
element
present
amendments
congress
unmistakably
intended
fraudulent
conveyances
adjudicated
recovered
bankruptcy
accordance
usual
procedures
perhaps
respect
means
something
akin
later
restatement
position
namely
amendments
simply
reclassified
cause
action
integrally
related
reformation
relations
ante
indicates
pay
little
heed
congressional
inclusion
avoidance
recovery
proceedings
core
bankruptcy
jurisdiction
since
choice
made
congress
found
traditional
rights
remedies
inadequate
cope
manifest
public
problem
ibid
misguided
view
congressional
enactment
crux
problem
approach
determine
action
recover
fraudulently
conveyed
property
integrally
related
essence
bankruptcy
proceedings
certainly
reference
current
statutory
definition
core
bankruptcy
proceedings
enacted
congress
plenary
constitutional
power
see
art
cl
establish
bankruptcy
laws
discussed
preceding
paragraph
vision
integrally
related
resolution
conflicts
includes
sort
action
us
today
see
supp
find
support
contrary
understanding
petitioners
submission
concedes
action
question
brought
recover
monies
properly
part
debtor
estate
ratably
distributed
among
creditors
fraudulent
transfers
put
risk
basic
policy
distribution
underlies
bankruptcy
law
brief
petitioners
seems
belie
view
actions
set
aside
fraudulent
conveyances
integrally
related
reforming
relations
conclusion
nature
actions
recover
fraudulently
transferred
property
supportable
either
reference
state
american
bankruptcy
law
prior
adoption
code
reference
practice
english
courts
draws
conclusions
based
fact
actions
considered
part
bankruptcy
proceedings
bankruptcy
acts
generally
federal
bankruptcy
statutes
predating
code
treated
power
given
congress
article
cl
disposable
battery
good
limited
period
power
consumed
use
discarded
considered
future
value
power
congress
clause
plainly
limited
merely
congress
scheme
actions
one
solely
heard
plenary
proceedings
article
iii
courts
seventh
amendment
attached
impugn
legality
every
possible
arrangement
see
also
part
infra
perhaps
instead
rests
conclusion
practice
english
courts
take
issue
view
old
english
law
even
correct
see
article
power
restricted
see
ibid
one
final
observation
respect
katchen
attempts
distinguish
katchen
saying
jury
trial
needed
funds
dispute
part
bankruptcy
estate
ante
decision
katchen
turned
bankruptcy
actual
constructive
possession
bankruptcy
estate
writes
ibid
quoting
obviously
case
bankruptcy
similarly
actual
constructive
possession
bankruptcy
estate
certainly
much
constructive
possession
property
sought
preference
recovered
katchen
thus
true
katchen
funds
dispute
part
bankruptcy
estate
bankruptcy
code
defines
estate
comprised
following
property
wherever
located
whomever
held
including
ny
interest
property
trustee
recovers
provision
authorizing
actions
recover
fraudulently
transferred
property
supp
consequently
even
accurate
pinpointing
dispositive
fact
katchen
decision
fact
equally
points
towards
ruling
trustee
sum
find
holding
katchen
underlying
logic
dictate
affirmance
decision
today
amounts
nothing
less
sub
silentio
overruling
precedent
ii
even
question
us
one
first
impression
however
decision
katchen
guide
us
dissent
decision
cases
determination
whether
seventh
amendment
guarantees
jury
trial
petitioners
claims
must
turn
two
questions
first
forum
claims
heard
second
nature
claims
weighing
factors
must
point
toward
application
seventh
amendment
guarantee
attach
read
opinion
one
might
think
seventh
amendment
concerned
nature
claim
claim
legal
announces
seventh
amendment
guarantees
jury
trial
claim
ante
wrong
istory
cases
support
proposition
right
jury
trial
turns
solely
nature
issue
resolved
also
forum
resolved
atlas
roofing
occupational
safety
health
review
perhaps
like
katchen
atlas
roofing
longer
good
law
today
decision
examination
issue
us
reveals
though
decision
today
prior
rulings
error
obvious
case
held
seventh
amendment
apply
suit
common
law
heard
state
minneapolis
bombolis
woods
holy
cross
hospital
even
exclusive
focus
claim
issue
purport
hold
fraudulent
conveyance
action
brought
state
covered
seventh
amendment
action
one
common
law
view
seventh
amendment
apply
federal
forums
seventh
amendment
applicable
administrative
proceedings
example
tull
forums
jury
trials
incompatible
whole
concept
administrative
adjudication
seventh
amendment
application
atlas
roofing
supra
emphasis
deleted
quoting
pernell
southall
realty
thus
often
looked
character
federal
forum
claim
heard
asking
jury
place
forum
determining
seventh
amendment
guarantee
jury
trial
apply
specifically
relevant
case
indicated
several
previous
occasions
bankruptcy
courts
nature
courts
equity
forums
jury
place
bankruptcy
specialized
equity
forum
jury
place
atlas
roofing
supra
consequently
seventh
amendment
application
courts
recognized
bankruptcy
traditionally
viewed
equity
jury
trials
dismember
statutory
scheme
bankruptcy
act
curtis
loether
atlas
roofing
curtis
countless
cases
recognized
congress
power
entrust
enforcement
statutory
rights
specialized
equity
free
strictures
seventh
amendment
curtis
supra
prior
cases
emphatically
hold
bankruptcy
courts
specialized
courts
equity
indeed
stated
bankruptcy
courts
inherently
proceedings
equity
katchen
landy
see
also
local
loan
hunt
today
never
held
party
bankruptcy
seventh
amendment
right
jury
trial
claims
course
actually
hold
today
preferring
obtuse
petitioners
going
obtain
jury
trial
deems
entitled
see
ante
blithely
ignoring
relevance
forum
congress
designated
hear
action
focusing
instead
exclusively
legal
nature
petitioners
claim
turns
back
long
line
cases
rested
varying
degrees
point
decision
today
ignores
statement
atlas
roofing
even
seventh
amendment
required
jury
adjudication
types
rights
assigned
federal
law
instead
administrative
agency
constitutional
provision
apply
congress
assigns
adjudication
rights
specialized
tribunals
juries
place
atlas
roofing
indeed
observed
atlas
roofing
even
true
english
american
legal
systems
time
adoption
seventh
amendment
question
whether
fact
found
jury
turned
considerable
degree
nature
forum
litigant
found
decision
also
substantially
cuts
back
congress
power
assign
selected
causes
action
specialized
forums
tribunals
bankruptcy
courts
holding
forums
employ
juries
hearing
claims
like
one
us
today
requirement
subverts
large
part
congress
decision
create
forums
first
place
past
decisions
accorded
congress
far
discretion
making
assignments
thus
block
hirsh
found
seventh
amendment
objection
amount
ed
little
congress
assigned
essence
action
ejectment
specialized
administrative
tribunal
reiterated
vitality
block
hirsh
recently
decision
pernell
southall
realty
supra
principle
reaffirmed
several
cases
two
decisions
see
infra
pernell
referring
block
hirsh
stated
seventh
amendment
bar
congressional
effort
entrust
disputes
including
right
possession
administrative
agency
pernell
supra
yet
extent
disputes
involve
matters
legal
nature
clearly
decision
today
means
congress
said
block
pernell
finally
ruling
today
ignores
several
additional
reasons
juries
place
bankruptcy
courts
specialized
courts
equity
like
first
two
principal
rationales
existence
seventh
amendment
guarantee
notions
jury
equity
juries
serving
popular
checks
judges
inapt
bankruptcy
courts
one
scholar
noted
kept
civil
jury
check
federal
judge
whose
life
tenure
makes
suspect
populist
traditions
country
function
civil
jury
diffuse
otherwise
autocratic
power
authority
judge
function
little
application
civil
proceedings
occur
bankruptcy
condition
autocracy
bring
underlying
values
seventh
amendment
force
present
right
jury
trial
therefore
application
hearings
subcommittee
constitution
senate
committee
judiciary
statement
paul
carrington
beyond
redundancy
requirement
juries
used
bankruptcy
courts
disruptive
unravel
statutory
scheme
congress
created
dismisses
prospect
scoffs
seriously
argued
permitting
jury
trials
sort
claim
undermine
statutory
bankruptcy
scheme
ante
yet
argument
seriously
made
actually
accepted
curtis
loether
curtis
observed
katchen
rejected
seventh
amendment
claim
similar
one
us
today
due
recogni
tion
bankruptcy
traditionally
viewed
equity
jury
trials
dismember
statutory
scheme
bankruptcy
act
curtis
supra
see
also
atlas
roofing
occupational
safety
health
review
fear
decision
today
desultory
effect
feared
curtis
decided
say
congress
vitiate
seventh
amendment
assigning
claim
wishes
specialized
tribunal
juries
employed
cf
atlas
roofing
supra
cases
require
second
inquiry
one
focuses
exclusively
upon
concerning
nature
claim
assigned
resolve
query
properly
begins
analysis
look
english
practice
century
see
ante
conducting
review
confidence
england
equity
adjudicated
respondent
suit
ante
conducting
review
brought
law
perhaps
even
might
litigated
common
case
review
english
cases
relevant
period
leaves
unconvinced
chancery
refused
hear
action
conclusion
today
confesses
courts
equity
sometimes
provided
relief
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
ante
chancery
put
stronger
though
courts
equity
certainly
habit
exercising
concurrent
jurisdiction
courts
law
statutes
elizabeth
respecting
fraudulent
conveyances
hobbs
hull
cox
eng
rarely
plain
statement
prevailing
english
practice
time
ratification
seventh
amendment
discovered
one
alone
enough
make
respondent
case
yet
instead
accepting
pronouncement
equity
jurisdiction
assumes
role
high
historical
review
questioning
soundness
hobbs
decision
issued
without
adequate
supporting
citations
ante
similar
criticism
levied
another
case
period
ex
parte
scudamore
ves
jun
eng
ch
even
concedes
demonstrates
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
brought
equity
ante
addition
nitpicking
respondent
supporting
case
law
oblivion
general
rejection
respondent
claim
rests
two
sources
passing
citation
wholly
inapposite
case
buzard
houston
lengthy
quotation
professor
glenn
treatise
fraudulent
conveyances
see
ante
deny
professor
glenn
work
supports
historical
view
adopts
today
notwithstanding
scholarly
eminence
professor
glenn
view
english
equity
courts
done
action
one
dispositive
scholars
looked
history
come
different
conclusion
still
others
questioned
soundness
distinction
professor
glenn
drew
suits
set
aside
monetary
conveyances
suits
avoid
conveyances
land
unwise
unsupported
see
wencl
bkrtcy
dc
indeed
pages
rests
analysis
case
law
professor
glenn
writing
dismisses
aspect
professor
glenn
historical
conclusions
see
ante
embraces
professor
glenn
treatise
agrees
calls
authoritative
rejecting
portions
finds
troublesome
trying
read
ambiguous
history
concerning
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
equity
task
finds
simple
today
perplexed
jurists
era
come
conflicting
decisions
time
question
found
relevance
even
schoenthal
time
statutory
regime
applicable
case
decided
many
courts
reviewing
historical
sources
considered
us
today
concluded
actions
one
sounded
equity
see
schoenthal
irving
trust
note
yale
recent
times
impressive
collection
courts
come
similar
conclusion
finding
actions
avoid
fraudulent
conveyances
historically
considered
equitable
nature
sum
think
fair
reading
history
understanding
inevitably
obscured
passage
time
irretrievable
loss
subtleties
interpretation
clearly
proves
disproves
respondent
action
sounded
equity
england
historical
evidence
thus
equipoise
nature
relief
sought
dispositive
either
see
supra
hesitate
defer
congress
exercise
power
express
constitutional
grant
found
article
cl
authorizing
congress
establish
uniform
laws
subject
bankruptcies
congress
exercised
power
defining
actions
one
us
among
core
bankruptcy
proceedings
triable
bankruptcy
bankruptcy
judge
without
jury
defer
decisions
however
finds
congressional
judgments
constitutionally
suspect
acknowledging
sure
owe
deference
congress
judgment
given
careful
consideration
legislative
enactment
declines
defer
respondent
adduced
evidence
congress
considered
constitutional
implications
designation
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
core
proceedings
ante
see
also
ante
statement
remarkable
assumed
congress
enacting
supp
ignored
constitutional
implications
say
draws
requirement
congress
must
provide
us
indication
considered
constitutional
dimensions
decision
acting
prerequisite
obtaining
deference
enactments
moreover
cramped
view
congress
power
bankruptcy
clause
enlarge
scope
bankruptcy
proceedings
ignoring
changing
times
dictate
changes
proceedings
stands
sharp
contrast
generous
view
expressed
years
ago
fundamental
radically
progressive
nature
congressional
extensions
scope
bankruptcy
laws
becomes
apparent
upon
mere
statement
taken
altogether
demonstrate
striking
way
capacity
bankruptcy
clause
meet
new
conditions
disclosed
result
tremendous
growth
business
development
human
activities
present
day
acts
though
may
gone
beyond
limit
congressional
power
rather
constituted
extensions
field
whose
boundaries
may
yet
fully
revealed
continental
illinois
national
bank
chicago
one
period
leading
constitutional
historians
expressed
view
saying
framers
bankruptcy
clause
clearly
understood
building
restrain
growth
shackle
spirits
descendents
time
come
rather
attempting
devise
scheme
firm
nevertheless
flexible
enough
serve
varying
social
needs
changing
generations
warren
bankruptcy
history
today
ignores
lessons
places
straitjacket
congress
power
bankruptcy
clause
straitjacket
designed
era
reader
dickens
aware
known
enlightened
thinking
relations
indeed
calls
question
longstanding
assumption
cases
bankruptcy
courts
equitable
proceedings
courts
adjudicating
disputes
adjudications
concerning
public
rights
see
northern
pipeline
construction
marathon
pipe
line
rehnquist
concurring
judgment
burger
dissenting
white
dissenting
list
lower
opinions
reasoned
assumption
lengthy
reasonably
include
text
mere
sampling
fills
margin
yet
today
calls
doubt
merely
cases
subjected
substantial
scholarly
criticism
ante
part
bankruptcy
proceedings
involve
adjudication
public
rights
implies
today
bankruptcy
proceedings
saved
strictures
seventh
amendment
extent
proceedings
descendants
earlier
analogues
heard
equity
england
almost
every
historian
observed
period
marked
far
restrictive
notion
equitable
jurisdiction
bankruptcies
see
warren
supra
decision
today
may
threaten
efficacy
bankruptcy
courts
constituted
see
reason
use
seventh
amendment
tool
achieve
dubious
result
iii
find
decision
odds
precedent
peculiarly
eager
embark
unclear
course
seventh
amendment
jurisprudence
respectfully
dissent
discuss
fully
opinion
read
overruling
severely
limiting
relevant
portions
following
cases
atlas
roofing
occupational
safety
health
review
katchen
landy
block
hirsh
barton
barbour
plus
perhaps
others
like
much
else
opinion
rather
coy
disclosing
federal
statute
invalidating
today
perhaps
supp
statute
includes
actions
avoid
recover
fraudulent
conveyances
among
core
bankruptcy
proceedings
permits
bankruptcy
judges
enter
final
judgments
core
proceedings
given
inclusion
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
among
proceedings
perhaps
supp
limiting
jury
trial
rights
bankruptcy
perhaps
part
title
combination
way
congress
lower
article
iii
courts
bankruptcy
courts
creditors
debtors
matter
know
expected
respond
decision
even
wish
diligent
conforming
behavior
today
mandate
see
especially
part
ante
though
denies
coy
obtuse
steadfastly
refuses
end
disclose
statute
finds
unconstitutional
today
see
ante
seventh
amendment
provides
suits
common
law
value
controversy
shall
exceed
twenty
dollars
right
trial
jury
shall
preserved
addition
points
make
disagree
portrayal
congress
expansion
bankruptcy
jurisdiction
include
actions
one
act
whimsy
fact
congress
first
swept
proceedings
like
fraudulent
conveyance
suit
us
jurisdiction
bankruptcy
courts
legislating
sense
traditional
rights
remedies
inadequate
cope
manifest
public
problem
major
impetus
underlying
reform
legislation
need
enlarge
jurisdiction
bankruptcy
order
eliminate
serious
delays
expense
duplications
associated
current
dichotomy
summary
plenary
jurisdiction
jurisdictional
limitations
presently
imposed
bankruptcy
courts
embroiled
parties
voluminous
litigation
response
legislative
history
makes
two
points
first
observes
reports
concerned
code
amendments
latter
notes
stripped
petitioners
jury
trial
right
ante
analysis
technically
correct
ignores
fact
code
undertook
use
description
radical
refor
bankruptcy
law
including
absorption
fraudulent
preference
actions
used
plenary
jurisdiction
bankruptcy
courts
change
laid
groundwork
pipeline
act
issue
second
importantly
acknowledges
congress
adopted
amendments
motivated
efficiency
concerns
basis
legislation
ante
thus
concedes
fundamental
point
congress
modified
traditional
jurisdictional
scheme
concerning
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
congress
found
traditional
approach
inadequate
cope
manifest
public
problem
atlas
roofing
occupational
safety
health
review
even
description
case
ante
suffice
permit
congress
limit
jury
trial
rights
claims
instead
concluding
however
retreats
atlas
roofing
earlier
analysis
holds
congress
enactments
control
adopting
congress
failed
make
considered
judgment
constitutionality
change
ante
observe
infra
elevating
inquiry
status
unprecedented
seventh
amendment
cases
unwise
since
relevant
factors
point
application
seventh
amendment
resolving
case
require
offering
comprehensive
view
factors
balanced
ambiguity
however
creation
rather
comes
apparent
inconsistency
case
law
example
cases
brought
state
courts
never
subject
seventh
amendment
matter
nature
claim
conversely
decision
northern
pipeline
construction
marathon
pipe
line
sort
contract
claim
issue
never
assigned
congress
anything
article
iii
tribunal
seventh
amendment
apply
see
also
post
blackmun
dissenting
cases
look
factors
without
altogether
clear
relative
import
whatever
shortcomings
opinion
failing
resolve
difficult
balancing
question
remains
superior
method
balancing
concerns
amounts
balancing
instead
focuses
solely
nature
claim
whether
legal
whether
concerns
public
right
see
ante
determining
seventh
amendment
applies
decision
katchen
described
act
convert
ing
legal
claim
equitable
claim
often
cited
principle
upholding
power
congress
take
causes
action
outside
scope
seventh
amendment
providing
enforcement
specialized
see
friedenthal
kane
miller
civil
procedure
see
collier
bankruptcy
ed
bump
conveyances
made
debtors
defraud
creditors
ed
wait
fraudulent
conveyances
creditors
bills
drake
rice
mass
gray
roberts
voluntary
fraudulent
conveyances
ed
see
graham
damsky
zavatt
friendly
action
bankruptcy
trustee
set
aside
fraudulent
conveyance
long
cognizable
equity
johnson
gardner
see
also
harbour
durbin
sd
hendon
pools
michigan
ed
southern
industrial
banking
bkrtcy
ed
think
clear
seems
simply
remedy
sought
respondent
expressed
monetary
terms
relief
seeks
therefore
legal
nature
equitable
ante
accepted
view
award
monetary
relief
must
necessarily
legal
relief
curtis
loether
previously
recognized
actions
disgorge
improperly
gained
profits
tull
return
funds
rightfully
belonging
another
curtis
supra
submit
specific
funds
wrongfully
withheld
bowen
massachusetts
equitable
actions
even
though
relief
seek
monetary
restitutionary
nature
respondent
action
petitioners
class
seeking
similar
remedy
trustee
simply
ask
ing
act
public
interest
restoring
status
quo
ordering
return
rightfully
belongs
estate
uch
action
within
highest
tradition
equity
porter
warner
matter
whether
respondent
seeking
returned
precise
cashier
checks
petitioner
medex
possession
one
time
funds
yielded
medex
cashing
checks
turn
case
distinction
give
entities
medex
position
incentive
consummate
fraudulent
transfers
quickly
possible
hardly
desirable
one
host
bankruptcy
courts
recognized
much
see
wencl
dc
reda
nd
irony
rebuke
congress
congress
decision
include
actions
avoid
recover
fraudulent
conveyances
among
core
bankruptcy
proceedings
found
inspiration
emergency
rule
drafted
issued
administrative
office
courts
december
govern
practice
bankruptcy
courts
following
decision
northern
pipeline
see
emergency
rule
related
proceedings
include
proceedings
set
aside
preferences
fraudulent
conveyances
see
also
addison
ed
jurisdictional
provisions
bankruptcy
amendments
closely
parallel
emergency
reference
rule
treister
trost
forman
klee
levin
fundamentals
bankruptcy
law
ed
describing
portion
emergency
rule
forerunner
amendments
learn
today
retrospect
emergency
rule
unconstitutional
failure
include
jury
trial
right
actions
avoid
fraudulent
conveyances
appears
congress
failed
duty
give
adequate
consider
ation
constitutional
implications
actions
cf
ante
particularly
unfortunate
today
ruling
may
first
time
ever
struck
congressional
designation
particular
cause
action
equitable
nature
see
note
congressional
provision
nonjury
trials
yale
never
rejected
congressional
indication
action
equitable
nature
cf
curtis
loether
supra
congressional
enactment
respond
seventh
amendment
concerns
past
far
deferential
congress
designations
regard
see
mitchell
robert
demario
jewelry
porter
warner
supra
cases
decided
since
northern
pipeline
appeals
alone
include
harbour
wood
mankin
cert
denied
sub
nom
munn
duck
arnold
print
works
briden
foley
kaiser
many
cases
found
reports
decisions
district
courts
bankruptcy
courts
indicative
approach
throughout
opinion
virtually
every
key
holding
announced
today
rests
citation
scholarly
authority
precedent
includes
holdings
action
issue
cognizable
law
england
ante
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
nearly
resemble
contract
claims
creditors
hierarchically
ordered
claims
pro
rata
share
bankruptcy
res
ante
congress
eliminate
jury
trial
right
sort
action
placing
specialized
equity
ante
short
three
critical
holdings
issued
opinion
like
think
analysis
learned
commentators
useful
tool
enhance
understanding
law
field
bankruptcy
unlike
however
use
views
scholars
basis
disposing
case
us
particularly
views
counsel
rejection
otherwise
viable
strains
case
law
see
gibson
jury
trials
bankruptcy
rev
cited
ante
believe
either
petitioner
entitled
jury
trial
seventh
amendment
reach
question
whether
petitioner
granfinanciera
deprived
seventh
amendment
rights
might
otherwise
due
status
instrument
foreign
sovereign
like
leave
another
day
resolution
difficult
question
ante
justice
blackmun
justice
joins
dissenting
agree
generally
justice
white
said
write
separately
clarify
particularly
mind
nature
relevant
inquiry
determine
petitioners
statutory
right
jury
trial
must
embark
seventh
amendment
inquiry
set
forth
atlas
roofing
occupational
safety
health
review
first
must
determine
whether
matter
adjudicated
legal
rather
equitable
nature
determination
turns
nature
claim
relief
sought
claim
relief
deemed
equitable
need
go
seventh
amendment
right
applies
actions
law
case
historical
inquiry
made
difficult
fact
federal
rules
civil
procedure
unified
law
equity
parties
might
drawn
equity
side
needed
procedural
tools
interim
remedies
discovery
accounting
power
clear
title
like
light
frequency
tools
likely
needed
fraud
cases
kind
surprise
justice
white
points
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
even
cognizable
law
often
found
equity
docket
see
generally
bump
conveyances
made
debtors
defraud
creditors
ed
wait
fraudulent
conveyances
creditors
bills
roberts
voluntary
fraudulent
conveyances
ed
procedural
dimension
choice
law
equity
lends
tentative
quality
lessons
may
draw
history
uncertainty
historical
record
lead
us
purposes
present
inquiry
give
constitutional
right
jury
trial
benefit
doubt
indeed
difficult
otherwise
decision
schoenthal
irving
trust
schoenthal
turned
legal
nature
preference
claim
relief
sought
rather
upon
legal
nature
tribunal
plenary
proceedings
assigned
bankruptcy
act
historical
evidence
thus
equipoise
ante
white
dissenting
schoenthal
weighing
legal
side
scale
turn
second
stage
atlas
roofing
inquiry
ask
whether
assuming
claim
legal
nature
congress
assigned
adjudicated
special
tribunal
jury
incompatible
atlas
roofing
see
also
tull
agree
justice
white
katchen
landy
interpreted
atlas
roofing
requires
conclusion
courts
exercising
core
bankruptcy
functions
equitable
tribunals
jury
place
go
far
dismantle
statutory
scheme
atlas
roofing
agree
justice
white
ante
improper
employ
seventh
amendment
analysis
conception
central
bankruptcy
process
conception
congress
expressly
rejected
among
vices
trivialize
efforts
congress
engaged
decade
bring
bankruptcy
system
modern
era
nonetheless
limits
congress
constitutionally
may
designate
core
proceeding
designation
impact
constitutional
rights
congress
example
designate
core
bankruptcy
proceedings
contract
actions
brought
debtors
third
parties
otherwise
northern
pipeline
rendered
nullity
case
however
congress
exceeded
limits
although
causes
action
recover
fraudulent
conveyances
exist
outside
federal
bankruptcy
laws
problems
created
fraudulent
conveyances
particular
significance
bankruptcy
process
indeed
reason
bankruptcy
code
long
included
substantive
legislation
regarding
fraudulent
conveyances
preferences
cause
action
respondent
brought
case
arises
federal
law
see
substantive
legislation
jurisdictional
artifice
reflects
instead
congress
longstanding
view
fraudulent
conveyances
preferences
eve
bankruptcy
common
methods
debtors
creditors
act
undermine
one
central
goals
bankruptcy
process
fair
distribution
assets
among
creditors
congress
conclusion
proper
functioning
bankruptcy
system
requires
expert
judges
handle
claims
claims
given
higher
priority
receive
crowded
district
civil
jury
docket
see
senate
report
house
report
entitled
respect
fact
reorganization
plan
case
provided
creditor
representatives
bring
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
plan
approved
render
relationship
fraudulent
conveyance
actions
bankruptcy
process
adventitious
ante
majority
opinion
creditors
less
likely
approve
plan
forced
undertake
burden
collecting
fraudulently
transferred
assets
assured
claims
receive
expert
expedited
treatment
sum
must
acknowledged
congress
legislated
treacherously
close
constitutional
line
denying
jury
trial
fraudulent
conveyance
action
defendant
claim
estate
nonetheless
given
significant
federal
interests
involved
importance
permitting
congress
long
last
fashion
modern
bankruptcy
system
places
basic
rudiments
bankruptcy
process
hands
expert
equitable
tribunal
say
congress
crossed
constitutional
line
facts
case
holding
otherwise
today
throws
congress
still
another
round
bankruptcy
reform
without
compelling
reason
need
us
rock
boat
case
accordingly
dissent