pierson
ray
argued
january
decided
april
together
ray
et
al
pierson
et
also
certiorari
petitioners
fn
members
group
white
negro
clergymen
prayer
pilgrimage
promote
racial
integration
attempted
use
segregated
interstate
bus
terminal
waiting
room
jackson
mississippi
arrested
respondent
policemen
charged
conduct
breaching
peace
violation
mississippi
code
held
unconstitutional
thomas
mississippi
applied
similar
facts
petitioners
waived
jury
trial
convicted
respondent
municipal
police
justice
appeal
one
petitioner
accorded
trial
de
novo
following
directed
verdict
favor
cases
petitioners
dropped
petitioners
brought
action
district
damages
makes
liable
every
person
color
law
deprives
another
person
civil
rights
common
law
false
arrest
imprisonment
evidence
showed
ministers
expected
arrested
entering
segregated
area
though
witnesses
agreed
petitioners
entered
waiting
room
peacefully
petitioners
testified
crowd
terminal
whereas
police
testified
threatening
crowd
followed
petitioners
jury
found
respondents
appeal
appeal
held
respondent
police
justice
immunity
judicial
acts
state
common
law
policemen
immunity
state
common
law
false
arrest
probable
cause
believe
valid
since
required
predict
laws
constitutional
virtue
monroe
pape
immunity
state
statute
subsequently
declared
invalid
remanded
case
officers
new
trial
prejudicial
petitioners
ruled
recover
shown
new
trial
gone
mississippi
anticipation
illegally
arrested
held
settled
principle
judge
immune
liability
damages
judicial
acts
abolished
cf
tenney
brandhove
pp
defense
good
faith
probable
cause
available
police
officers
action
false
arrest
imprisonment
also
available
action
monroe
pape
supra
distinguished
pp
though
officers
required
predict
ruling
thomas
mississippi
supra
unconstitutional
applied
defense
good
faith
probable
cause
available
action
follow
count
based
thereon
dismissed
since
evidence
conflicting
whether
police
acted
good
faith
probable
cause
arresting
petitioners
pp
petitioners
consent
arrest
deliberately
exercising
right
use
waiting
room
peaceful
manner
expectation
illegally
arrested
fn
see
infra
carl
rachlin
argued
cause
petitioners
respondents
briefs
melvin
wulf
elizabeth
watkins
hulen
grayson
argued
cause
respondents
petitioners
brief
thomas
watkins
chief
justice
warren
delivered
opinion
cases
present
issues
involving
liability
local
police
officers
judges
civil
rights
act
stat
petitioners
members
group
white
negro
episcopal
clergymen
attempted
use
segregated
facilities
interstate
bus
terminal
jackson
mississippi
arrested
respondents
ray
griffith
nichols
policemen
city
jackson
charged
violating
mississippi
code
makes
guilty
misdemeanor
anyone
congregates
others
public
place
circumstances
breach
peace
may
occasioned
thereby
refuses
move
ordered
police
officer
petitioners
waived
jury
trial
convicted
offense
respondent
spencer
municipal
police
justice
given
maximum
sentence
four
months
jail
fine
appeal
petitioner
jones
accorded
trial
de
novo
county
city
produced
evidence
granted
motion
directed
verdict
cases
petitioners
dropped
vindicated
county
petitioners
brought
action
damages
district
southern
district
mississippi
jackson
division
alleging
respondents
violated
supra
respondents
liable
common
law
false
arrest
imprisonment
jury
returned
verdicts
respondents
counts
appeal
appeals
fifth
circuit
held
respondent
spencer
immune
liability
common
law
mississippi
acts
committed
within
judicial
jurisdiction
police
officers
noted
mississippi
code
held
unconstitutional
applied
similar
facts
thomas
mississippi
although
thomas
decided
years
arrest
involved
trial
held
policemen
liable
suit
unconstitutional
arrest
even
acted
good
faith
probable
cause
making
arrest
state
statute
yet
held
invalid
believed
stern
result
required
monroe
pape
count
based
common
law
mississippi
however
held
policemen
liable
probable
cause
believe
statute
violated
mississippi
law
require
police
officers
predict
peril
state
laws
constitutional
apparently
dismissing
claim
appeals
reversed
remanded
new
trial
claim
police
officers
defense
counsel
allowed
ministers
various
irrelevant
prejudicial
matters
particularly
including
alleged
convergence
views
racial
justice
communist
party
new
trial
however
held
ministers
recover
proved
went
mississippi
anticipating
illegally
arrested
action
constitute
consent
arrest
principle
volenti
non
fit
injuria
consents
wrong
injured
granted
certiorari
consider
whether
local
judge
liable
damages
unconstitutional
conviction
whether
ministers
denied
recovery
police
officers
acted
anticipation
illegally
arrested
also
granted
police
officers
petition
determine
appeals
correctly
held
assert
defense
good
faith
probable
cause
action
unconstitutional
arrest
evidence
federal
trial
showed
petitioners
negro
white
episcopal
clergymen
undertook
prayer
pilgrimage
new
orleans
detroit
purpose
pilgrimage
visit
church
institutions
places
north
south
promote
racial
equality
integration
finally
report
church
convention
detroit
letters
leader
group
members
indicate
clergymen
intended
beginning
go
jackson
attempt
use
segregated
facilities
bus
terminal
fully
expected
arrested
group
made
plans
based
assumption
arrested
attempted
peacefully
exercise
right
interstate
travelers
use
waiting
rooms
facilities
bus
terminal
letters
discussed
arrangements
bail
matters
relevant
arrests
ministers
stayed
one
night
jackson
went
bus
terminal
next
morning
depart
chattanooga
tennessee
entered
waiting
room
disobeying
sign
entrance
announced
white
waiting
room
order
police
department
turned
enter
small
terminal
restaurant
stopped
two
jackson
police
officers
respondents
griffith
nichols
awaiting
arrival
ordered
move
ministers
replied
wanted
eat
refused
move
respondent
ray
police
captain
deputy
chief
police
arrived
minutes
later
ministers
placed
arrest
taken
jail
witnesses
including
police
officers
agreed
ministers
entered
waiting
room
peacefully
engaged
boisterous
objectionable
conduct
white
area
conflicting
testimony
number
bystanders
present
behavior
petitioners
testified
crowd
station
one
followed
waiting
room
one
uttered
threatening
words
made
threatening
gestures
police
testified
persons
followed
ministers
terminal
persons
crowd
dissatisfied
ugly
mood
mumbling
making
unspecified
threatening
gestures
police
describe
specific
threatening
incidents
testified
took
action
persons
crowd
threatening
violence
determined
ministers
cause
violence
might
occur
although
ministers
concededly
orderly
polite
police
claim
beyond
power
control
allegedly
disorderly
crowd
arrests
convictions
followed
lawsuit
find
difficulty
agreeing
appeals
judge
spencer
immune
liability
damages
role
convictions
record
barren
proof
specific
allegation
judge
spencer
played
role
arrests
convictions
adjudge
petitioners
guilty
cases
came
doctrines
solidly
established
common
law
immunity
judges
liability
damages
acts
committed
within
judicial
jurisdiction
recognized
adopted
doctrine
bradley
fisher
wall
immunity
applies
even
judge
accused
acting
maliciously
corruptly
protection
benefit
malicious
corrupt
judge
benefit
public
whose
interest
judges
liberty
exercise
functions
independence
without
fear
consequences
scott
stansfield
ex
quoted
bradley
fisher
supra
note
judge
duty
decide
cases
within
jurisdiction
brought
including
controversial
cases
arouse
intense
feelings
litigants
errors
may
corrected
appeal
fear
unsatisfied
litigants
may
hound
litigation
charging
malice
corruption
imposing
burden
judges
contribute
principled
fearless
intimidation
believe
settled
principle
law
abolished
makes
liable
every
person
color
law
deprives
another
person
civil
rights
legislative
record
gives
clear
indication
congress
meant
abolish
wholesale
immunities
accordingly
held
tenney
brandhove
immunity
legislators
acts
within
legislative
role
abolished
immunity
judges
acts
within
judicial
role
equally
well
established
presume
congress
specifically
provided
wished
abolish
doctrine
common
law
never
granted
police
officers
absolute
unqualified
immunity
officers
case
claim
entitled
one
claim
rather
liable
acted
good
faith
probable
cause
making
arrest
statute
believed
valid
prevailing
view
country
peace
officer
arrests
someone
probable
cause
liable
false
arrest
simply
innocence
suspect
later
proved
restatement
second
torts
harper
james
law
torts
ward
fidelity
deposit
maryland
cir
policeman
lot
unhappy
must
choose
charged
dereliction
duty
arrest
probable
cause
mulcted
damages
although
matter
entirely
free
doubt
consideration
seem
require
excusing
liability
acting
statute
reasonably
believed
valid
later
held
unconstitutional
face
applied
appeals
held
officers
limited
privilege
common
law
mississippi
indicated
recognized
similar
privilege
except
felt
compelled
hold
otherwise
decision
monroe
pape
monroe
pape
presented
question
immunity
however
none
decided
complaint
case
alleged
chicago
police
officers
broke
petitioners
home
early
morning
routed
bed
made
stand
naked
living
room
ransacked
every
room
emptying
drawers
ripping
mattress
covers
allege
monroe
taken
police
station
detained
open
charges
hours
interrogated
murder
taken
magistrate
though
one
accessible
permitted
call
family
attorney
subsequently
released
without
criminal
charges
preferred
police
officers
choose
go
trial
defend
case
hope
convince
jury
believed
good
faith
duty
assault
monroe
family
manner
instead
sought
dismissal
complaint
contending
principally
activities
plainly
illegal
state
law
act
color
statute
ordinance
regulation
custom
usage
state
territory
required
rejecting
argument
way
intimated
defense
good
faith
probable
cause
foreclosed
statute
also
held
complaint
dismissed
failure
state
officers
specific
intent
deprive
person
federal
right
holding
related
requirements
pleading
carried
implications
defenses
available
police
officers
went
say
paragraph
read
background
tort
liability
makes
man
responsible
natural
consequences
actions
part
background
tort
liability
case
police
officers
making
arrest
defense
good
faith
probable
cause
hold
defense
good
faith
probable
cause
appeals
found
available
officers
action
false
arrest
imprisonment
also
available
action
holding
however
mean
count
based
thereon
dismissed
appeals
ordered
dismissal
count
theory
police
officers
required
predict
decision
thomas
mississippi
agree
police
officer
charged
predicting
future
course
constitutional
law
petitioners
case
simply
argue
arrested
statute
later
held
unconstitutional
claimed
attempted
prove
police
officers
arrested
solely
attempting
use
white
waiting
room
crowd
present
one
threatened
violence
seemed
cause
disturbance
officers
defend
theory
believed
good
faith
constitutional
arrest
ministers
solely
using
waiting
room
rather
claimed
attempted
prove
arrest
ministers
purpose
preserving
custom
segregation
mississippi
solely
purpose
preventing
violence
testified
contradiction
ministers
crowd
gathered
imminent
violence
likely
jury
believed
testimony
officers
disbelieved
ministers
jury
found
officers
reasonably
believed
good
faith
arrest
constitutional
verdict
officers
follow
even
though
arrest
fact
unconstitutional
jury
resolve
factual
issues
favor
officers
reasons
previously
stated
verdict
influenced
irrelevant
prejudicial
evidence
accordingly
case
must
remanded
trial
new
trial
necessary
decide
importance
given
new
trial
substantially
undisputed
fact
petitioners
went
jackson
expecting
illegally
arrested
agree
appeals
somehow
consented
arrest
anticipation
illegally
arrested
even
assuming
went
jackson
bus
terminal
sole
purpose
testing
rights
unsegregated
public
accommodations
case
contains
proof
allegation
way
tricked
goaded
officers
arresting
petitioners
right
use
waiting
room
jackson
bus
terminal
deliberate
exercise
right
peaceful
orderly
inoffensive
manner
disqualify
seeking
damages
judgment
appeals
affirmed
part
reversed
part
cases
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
every
person
color
statute
ordinance
regulation
custom
usage
state
territory
subjects
causes
subjected
citizen
person
within
jurisdiction
thereof
deprivation
rights
privileges
immunities
secured
constitution
laws
shall
liable
party
injured
action
law
suit
equity
proper
proceeding
redress
whoever
intent
provoke
breach
peace
circumstances
breach
peace
may
occasioned
thereby
crowds
congregates
others
hotel
motel
store
restaurant
lunch
counter
cafeteria
sandwich
shop
place
business
engaged
selling
serving
members
public
around
free
entrance
place
business
public
building
building
owned
another
individual
corporation
partnership
association
fails
refuses
disperse
move
disperse
move
ordered
law
enforcement
officer
municipality
county
act
acts
committed
law
enforcement
officer
state
mississippi
authorized
person
shall
guilty
disorderly
conduct
made
misdemeanor
upon
conviction
thereof
shall
punished
fine
two
hundred
dollars
imprisonment
county
jail
four
months
fine
imprisonment
ministers
involved
designated
petitioners
throughout
opinion
although
respondents
thomas
various
freedom
riders
arrested
convicted
circumstances
substantially
similar
facts
cases
police
testified
ordered
freedom
riders
leave
feared
onlookers
might
breach
peace
reversed
without
argument
opinion
citing
boynton
virginia
boynton
held
racial
discrimination
bus
terminal
restaurant
utilized
integral
part
transportation
interstate
passengers
violates
interstate
commerce
act
state
enforcement
discrimination
barred
supremacy
clause
respondents
read
opinion
remanding
new
trial
claim
stated
however
officers
immune
liability
false
imprisonment
common
law
liability
violations
federal
statutes
civil
rights
therefore
follows
new
trial
civil
rights
claim
appellee
police
officers
may
determination
fact
issue
whether
appellants
invited
consented
arrest
imprisonment
respondents
challenge
petition
holding
appeals
new
trial
necessary
prejudicial
belatedly
devoted
section
brief
contention
proper
argument
meritorious
timely
views
communist
party
racial
equality
issue
cases
transcript
record
testimony
officer
griffith
petitioners
attempted
suggest
conspiracy
judge
spencer
police
officers
questioning
reasons
finding
petitioners
guilty
cases
showing
found
freedom
riders
guilty
similar
circumstances
previous
cases
proof
conspiracy
never
went
beyond
suggestion
inferences
drawn
judge
spencer
judicial
decisions
see
transcript
record
since
decision
tenney
brandhove
supra
courts
appeals
consistently
held
judicial
immunity
defense
action
see
bauers
heisel
cir
cases
cited
therein
see
caveat
restatement
second
torts
miller
stinnett
cir
see
golden
thompson
miss
petition
certiorari
also
presented
question
whether
appeals
correctly
dismissed
count
based
common
law
mississippi
ordinarily
review
holding
appeals
matter
state
law
find
reason
departing
tradition
case
state
claim
case
merely
cumulative
petitioners
right
recover
invasion
civil
rights
subject
defense
good
faith
probable
cause
adequately
secured
justice
douglas
dissenting
think
judges
circumstances
matter
outrageous
conduct
immune
suit
stat
ruling
justified
admitted
need
vigorous
independent
judiciary
commanded
doctrine
judicial
immunity
follow
inexorably
prior
decisions
statute
came
books
ku
klux
klan
act
april
stat
provides
every
person
color
state
law
custom
subjects
causes
subjected
citizen
deprivation
rights
privileges
immunities
secured
constitution
laws
shall
liable
party
injured
action
law
suit
equity
proper
proceeding
redress
every
person
mean
every
person
every
person
except
judges
despite
plain
import
words
decided
tenney
brandhove
state
legislators
immune
suit
long
deprivation
civil
rights
caused
person
occurred
legislators
acting
field
legislators
traditionally
power
act
dissented
creation
judicial
exception
creation
present
one
congressional
purpose
seems
clear
condition
lawlessness
existed
certain
people
denied
civil
rights
congress
intended
provide
remedy
wrongs
perpetrated
members
unaware
certain
members
judiciary
implicated
state
affairs
statute
intended
rectify
often
noted
mmunity
given
crime
records
public
tribunals
searched
vain
evidence
effective
redress
cong
globe
rainey
south
carolina
noted
courts
many
instances
control
wholly
inimical
impartial
administration
law
equity
congressman
beatty
ohio
claimed
duty
congress
listen
appeals
reason
popular
sentiment
secret
organizations
prejudiced
juries
bribed
judges
obtain
rights
privileges
due
american
citizen
members
supporting
proposed
measure
apprehensive
complete
breakdown
administration
justice
certain
laws
nondiscriminatory
face
applied
discriminatory
manner
newly
civil
rights
negro
ignored
constitution
defied
background
section
passed
background
interpreted
said
time
statute
enactment
doctrine
judicial
immunity
well
settled
congress
presumed
intended
abrogate
doctrine
since
clearly
evince
purpose
view
beset
many
difficulties
assumes
congress
specify
advance
possible
circumstances
remedial
statute
might
apply
state
cases
within
scope
underlying
view
atomistic
conception
intention
coupled
may
called
pointer
theory
meaning
view
conceives
mind
directed
toward
individual
things
rather
toward
general
ideas
toward
distinct
situations
fact
rather
toward
significance
human
affairs
situations
may
share
view
taken
seriously
regard
intention
draftsman
statute
directed
dangerous
weapons
directed
toward
endless
series
individual
objects
revolvers
automatic
pistols
daggers
bowie
knives
etc
applies
statute
weapon
draftsman
thought
legislating
interpreting
even
obviously
apply
statute
weapon
yet
invented
statute
passed
fuller
morality
law
position
congress
intend
change
rule
judicial
immunity
ignores
fact
every
member
congress
spoke
issue
assumed
words
statute
meant
said
judges
liable
many
members
congress
objected
statute
imposed
liability
members
judiciary
arthur
kentucky
opposed
measure
hitherto
judge
held
liable
civilly
criminally
judicial
acts
provisions
section
every
judge
state
enter
upon
pursue
call
official
duty
sword
damocles
suspended
cong
globe
two
three
instances
already
civil
rights
bill
state
judges
taken
district
sometimes
upon
indictment
offense
honestly
conscientiously
deciding
law
understood
section
intended
perpetuate
intended
enlarge
intended
extend
longer
judge
sitting
bench
decide
causes
decide
free
fear
except
impeachment
never
lies
absence
corrupt
motive
extended
every
judge
state
may
liable
dragged
federal
judge
vindicate
opinion
mulcted
damages
federal
judge
shall
think
opinion
erroneous
language
bill
cong
globe
appendix
first
section
certain
cases
judge
state
though
acting
oath
office
made
liable
suit
federal
subject
damages
decision
suitor
cong
globe
section
purpose
provide
redress
deprivation
civil
rights
recognized
certain
members
judiciary
instruments
oppression
partially
responsible
wrongs
remedied
parade
cases
coming
shows
similar
condition
obtains
state
courts
instruments
suppression
civil
rights
methods
may
changed
means
may
become
subtle
wrong
remedied
still
exists
today
decision
dictated
prior
decisions
ex
parte
virginia
held
judge
excluded
negroes
juries
held
liable
act
march
stat
one
civil
rights
acts
assumed
judge
merely
performing
ministerial
function
went
state
judge
liable
statute
even
actions
judicial
one
thing
say
doctrine
judicial
immunity
defense
cause
action
quite
another
say
immunity
rule
defense
liability
congress
imposed
upon
officer
person
ex
parte
virginia
upon
every
person
cases
immunity
today
grants
judiciary
necessary
preserve
independent
judiciary
threat
civil
action
lies
background
litigation
argument
goes
judges
reluctant
exercise
discretion
judgment
inherent
position
vital
effective
operation
judiciary
course
protect
member
judiciary
fact
guilty
using
powers
vent
spleen
upon
others
personal
motive
connected
public
good
gregoire
biddle
deny
recovery
person
injured
ruling
judge
acting
personal
gain
personal
motives
monstrous
ibid
argued
absolute
immunity
necessary
prevent
chilling
effects
judicial
inquiry
threat
inquiry
whether
fact
judge
unfaithful
oath
office
thus
necessary
protect
guilty
well
innocent
doctrine
separation
powers
course
applicable
relations
coordinate
branches
government
relations
branches
federal
government
see
baker
carr
argument
congress
impose
liability
state
judges
deprivation
civil
rights
thus
based
upon
claim
violate
theory
division
powers
federal
state
governments
claim
foreclosed
cases
recognizing
congress
power
enforce
provisions
fourteenth
amendment
carry
badge
authority
state
monroe
pape
terms
power
congress
see
difference
imposing
liability
state
police
officer
monroe
pape
supra
state
judge
question
presented
constitutional
dimension
solely
question
statutory
interpretation
argument
actions
public
officials
must
subjected
judicial
scrutiny
inhibiting
effect
work
sophisticated
manner
saying
king
wrong
chief
justice
cockburn
long
ago
disposed
argument
liability
deter
judges
believe
judges
fail
discharge
duty
faithfully
fearlessly
according
oaths
consciences
fear
exposing
actions
law
persuaded
number
actions
infinitely
small
easily
disposed
hand
easily
conceive
cases
judicial
opportunity
might
perverted
abused
purpose
injustice
sound
principles
authors
wrong
responsible
parties
wronged
dawkins
lord
paulet
cockburn
dissenting
far
different
saying
judge
shall
immune
consequences
judicial
actions
shall
liable
knowing
intentional
deprivation
person
civil
rights
judge
conspires
local
law
enforcement
officers
railroad
dissenter
judge
knowingly
turns
trial
kangaroo
one
intentionally
flouts
constitution
order
obtain
conviction
congress
think
concluded
evils
allowing
intentional
knowing
deprivations
civil
rights
go
unredressed
far
outweighed
speculative
inhibiting
effects
might
attend
inquiry
judicial
deprivation
civil
rights
plight
oppressed
indeed
serious
city
greenwood
peacock
defendant
remove
federal
prevent
state
depriving
civil
rights
rule
announced
today
person
recover
damages
deprivation
remedial
statutes
liberally
construed
see
generally
llewellyn
remarks
theory
appellate
decision
rules
canons
statutes
construed
vand
rev
llewellyn
common
law
tradition
appendix
altered
reviser
prepared
revised
statutes
printed
statute
refers
every
person
rather
person
opinion
ex
parte
virginia
supra
mention
bradley
fisher
wall
held
judge
held
liable
causing
name
attorney
struck
rolls
bradley
action
brought
civil
rights
acts
justifications
doctrine
absolute
immunity
advanced
preventing
threat
suit
influencing
decision
protecting
judges
liability
honest
mistakes
relieving
judges
time
expense
defending
suits
removing
impediment
responsible
men
entering
judiciary
necessity
finality
appellate
review
satisfactory
remedy
judge
duty
public
individual
judicial
separation
powers
see
generally
jennings
tort
liability
administrative
officers
rev
historically
judicial
immunity
corollary
theory
since
king
wrong
judges
delegates
dispensing
justice
drawn
question
supposed
corruption
tends
slander
justice
king
floyd
barker
eng
star
chamber
judges
personal
delegates
king
answerable
alone
randall
brigham
wall
judge
liable
injury
caused
ministerial
act
immunity
judge
must
performing
judicial
function
see
ex
parte
virginia
harper
james
law
torts
presence
malice
intention
deprive
person
civil
rights
wholly
incompatible
judicial
function
judge
acts
intentionally
knowingly
deprive
person
constitutional
rights
exercises
discretion
individual
judgment
acts
longer
judge
minister
prejudices