ohio
akron
center
argued
november
decided
june
enacted
ohio
amended
substitute
house
bill
makes
crime
physician
person
perform
abortion
unmarried
unemancipated
minor
woman
unless
inter
alia
physician
provides
timely
notice
one
minor
parents
juvenile
issues
order
authorizing
minor
consent
obtain
judicial
bypass
notice
requirement
minor
must
present
clear
convincing
proof
sufficient
maturity
information
make
abortion
decision
one
parents
engaged
pattern
physical
emotional
sexual
abuse
notice
best
interests
among
things
also
allows
physician
give
constructive
notice
actual
notice
parent
proves
impossible
reasonable
effort
requires
minor
file
bypass
complaint
juvenile
prescribed
forms
requires
appoint
guardian
ad
litem
attorney
minor
retained
counsel
mandates
expedited
bypass
hearings
decisions
expedited
review
appeals
provides
constructive
authorization
minor
consent
abortion
either
fails
act
timely
fashion
specifies
courts
must
maintain
minor
anonymity
confidentiality
papers
shortly
effective
date
appellees
abortion
facility
one
doctors
unmarried
unemancipated
minor
woman
seeking
abortion
others
filed
facial
challenge
statute
constitutionality
federal
district
ultimately
issued
injunction
preventing
enforcement
appeals
affirmed
concluding
various
statute
provisions
constitutionally
defective
held
judgment
reversed
reversed
justice
kennedy
delivered
opinion
respect
parts
ii
iii
iv
concluding
face
impose
undue
otherwise
unconstitutional
burden
minor
seeking
abortion
pp
house
bill
accords
cases
addressing
constitutionality
parental
notice
consent
statutes
abortion
context
planned
parenthood
central
mo
danforth
bellotti
baird
matheson
planned
parenthood
assn
kansas
city
ashcroft
akron
akron
center
reproductive
health
pp
whether
fourteenth
amendment
requires
parental
notice
statutes
opposed
parental
consent
statutes
contain
judicial
bypass
procedures
bypass
procedure
sufficient
meets
requirements
identified
danforth
bellotti
ashcroft
akron
intrusive
consent
statutes
particularly
four
criteria
set
forth
plurality
bellotti
supra
opinion
powell
first
statute
satisfies
requirement
minor
allowed
show
maturity
make
abortion
decision
without
regard
parents
wishes
second
requiring
juvenile
authorize
consent
upon
determining
abortion
best
interests
cases
shown
pattern
abuse
satisfies
requirement
allowed
show
even
make
decision
abortion
best
interests
third
requirement
bypass
procedure
ensure
minor
anonymity
satisfied
since
prohibits
juvenile
notifying
parents
complainant
pregnant
wants
abortion
requires
state
courts
preserve
anonymity
confidentiality
papers
since
state
law
makes
crime
state
employee
disclose
documents
designated
public
records
neither
mere
possibility
unauthorized
illegal
disclosure
state
employees
fact
complaint
forms
require
minor
provide
identifying
information
administrative
purposes
dispositive
complete
anonymity
critical
decisions
takes
reasonable
steps
prevent
public
learning
minor
identity
fourth
time
limits
judicial
action
satisfy
requirement
bypass
procedure
conducted
expedition
even
appellees
contend
bypass
procedure
take
calendar
days
including
weekends
legal
holidays
possibility
suffice
invalidate
statute
face
see
ashcroft
supra
pp
bellotti
criteria
need
extended
imposing
appellees
suggested
additional
requirements
bypass
procedures
first
rendered
unconstitutional
fact
constructive
authorization
provisions
require
affirmative
order
authorizing
physician
act
event
either
state
fails
act
within
prescribed
time
limits
absent
showing
limits
ignored
state
may
expect
judges
follow
mandated
procedural
requirements
moreover
ashcroft
supra
require
constructive
authorization
provisions
added
ohio
abundance
caution
concern
minor
interests
second
bypass
procedure
ohio
violate
due
process
placing
burden
proof
issues
maturity
best
interests
minor
requiring
heightened
clear
convincing
evidence
standard
proof
justice
powell
bellotti
supra
indicated
state
may
require
minor
bear
burden
proof
issues
moreover
state
may
require
heightened
standard
proof
bypass
procedure
contemplates
ex
parte
proceeding
one
opposes
minor
testimony
assisted
attorney
guardian
ad
litem
third
statutory
scheme
bypass
complaint
forms
deny
unwary
unrepresented
minor
opportunity
prove
case
requiring
choose
among
three
forms
first
relates
maturity
second
best
interests
third
even
assuming
initial
confusion
unlikely
ohio
courts
treat
minor
choice
forms
without
due
care
understanding
unrepresented
status
moreover
make
binding
election
initial
form
choice
since
provides
appointed
counsel
filing
complaint
allows
move
amend
pleadings
pp
even
assuming
gives
minor
substantive
liberty
property
right
avoid
unnecessary
hostile
parental
involvement
upon
proof
maturity
best
interests
statute
deprive
right
without
due
process
since
confidentiality
provisions
expedited
procedures
pleading
form
requirements
clear
convincing
evidence
standard
constructive
authorization
provisions
valid
face
pp
house
bill
facially
invalid
simply
requires
parental
notice
given
physician
rather
qualified
person
since
physician
superior
ability
garner
use
important
medical
psychological
data
supplied
parent
upon
receiving
notice
state
may
require
physician
take
reasonable
steps
notify
parent
see
matheson
supra
addition
conversation
experienced
detached
physician
may
assist
parent
approaching
problem
mature
balanced
way
thereby
enable
provide
better
advice
minor
conversation
less
experienced
person
imposition
physician
schedule
diminished
provisions
allowing
give
notice
mail
reach
parent
reasonable
effort
forgo
notice
event
certain
emergencies
provisions
constitute
adequate
recognition
professional
status
akron
supra
distinguished
pp
justice
kennedy
joined
chief
justice
justice
white
justice
scalia
concluded
part
constitutes
rational
way
legitimate
ends
free
enlightened
society
may
decide
members
attain
clearer
tolerant
understanding
profound
philosophic
choices
confronting
woman
considering
abortion
decision
affect
destiny
dignity
origins
human
life
within
embryo
rational
fair
state
conclude
instances
beginnings
understanding
within
family
strive
give
lonely
even
terrified
minor
advice
compassionate
mature
pp
justice
stevens
agreeing
unconstitutional
face
concluded
applications
notice
requirement
reasonably
state
legitimate
interest
protecting
welfare
minor
citizens
question
whether
judicial
bypass
obviously
inadequate
exceptional
situations
entire
statute
invalidated
must
await
statute
implementation
evaluation
significance
restrictions
light
administration
state
must
provide
adequate
mechanism
avoiding
parental
notification
cases
minor
mature
notice
best
interests
see
akron
akron
center
reproductive
health
pp
rita
eppler
assistant
attorney
general
ohio
argued
cause
appellant
briefs
anthony
celebrezze
attorney
general
thomas
suzanne
mohr
assistant
attorneys
general
linda
sogg
argued
cause
appellees
brief
dara
klassel
roger
evans
barbara
otten
eve
paul
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
american
family
association
peggy
coleman
association
american
physicians
surgeons
lohr
paige
comstock
cunningham
kent
masterson
brown
concerned
women
america
jordan
lorence
cimron
campbell
wendell
bird
knights
columbus
brendan
sullivan
kevin
hasson
carl
anderson
catholic
conference
mark
chopko
representative
jerome
luebbers
et
al
patrick
perotti
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
affirmance
filed
organizations
support
roe
wade
kathleen
sullivan
susan
estrich
barbara
jordan
estelle
rogers
american
college
obstetricians
gynecologists
et
al
carter
phillips
elizabeth
esty
ann
allen
stephan
lawton
laurie
rockett
joel
klein
american
psychological
association
et
al
donald
bersoff
briefs
amici
curiae
filed
american
indian
health
care
association
et
al
rhonda
copelon
nadine
taub
focus
family
et
al
robert
showers
save
america
youth
lynn
wardle
individual
members
panel
adolescent
pregnancy
childbearing
committee
child
development
research
public
policy
hannah
lieberman
pamela
anderson
justice
kennedy
announced
judgment
delivered
opinion
respect
parts
ii
iii
ivfn
opinion
respect
part
chief
justice
justice
white
justice
scalia
join
appeals
held
invalid
ohio
statute
certain
exceptions
prohibits
person
performing
abortion
unmarried
unemancipated
minor
woman
absent
notice
one
woman
parents
order
approval
reverse
determine
statute
accords
precedents
parental
notice
consent
abortion
context
violate
fourteenth
amendment
ohio
legislature
november
enacted
amended
substitute
house
bill
amended
ohio
rev
code
ann
created
supp
section
cornerstone
legislation
makes
criminal
offense
except
four
specified
circumstances
physician
person
perform
abortion
unmarried
unemancipated
woman
eighteen
years
age
see
making
first
offense
misdemeanor
subsequent
offenses
felonies
imposing
civil
liability
first
second
circumstances
physician
may
perform
abortion
relate
parental
notice
consent
first
physician
may
perform
abortion
provides
least
hours
actual
notice
person
telephone
one
women
parents
guardian
custodian
intention
perform
abortion
physician
alternative
may
notify
minor
adult
brother
sister
stepparent
grandparent
minor
relative
file
affidavit
juvenile
stating
minor
fears
physical
sexual
severe
emotional
abuse
one
parents
see
physician
give
notice
reasonable
effort
may
perform
abortion
least
hours
constructive
notice
ordinary
certified
mail
second
physician
may
perform
abortion
minor
one
parents
guardian
custodian
consented
abortion
writing
see
ii
third
fourth
circumstances
depend
judicial
procedure
allows
minor
bypass
notice
consent
provisions
described
statute
allows
physician
perform
abortion
without
notifying
one
minor
parents
receiving
parent
consent
juvenile
issues
order
authorizing
minor
consent
iii
juvenile
appeals
inaction
provides
constructive
authorization
minor
consent
iv
bypass
procedure
requires
minor
file
complaint
juvenile
stating
pregnant
unmarried
years
age
unemancipated
desires
abortion
without
notifying
one
parents
sufficient
maturity
information
make
intelligent
decision
whether
abortion
without
notice
one
parents
engaged
pattern
physical
sexual
emotional
abuse
notice
best
interests
retained
attorney
ohio
discussed
prescribed
pleading
forms
minor
use
see
app
juvenile
must
hold
hearing
earliest
possible
time
later
fifth
business
day
minor
files
complaint
must
render
decision
immediately
conclusion
hearing
ibid
failure
hold
hearing
within
time
results
constructive
authorization
minor
consent
abortion
ibid
hearing
must
appoint
guardian
ad
litem
attorney
represent
minor
retained
counsel
minor
must
prove
allegation
maturity
pattern
abuse
best
interests
clear
convincing
evidence
juvenile
must
conduct
hearing
preserve
anonymity
complainant
keeping
papers
confidential
minor
right
expedited
review
statute
provides
within
four
days
minor
files
notice
appeal
clerk
juvenile
shall
deliver
notice
appeal
record
state
appeals
clerk
appeals
dockets
appeal
upon
receipt
items
ibid
minor
must
file
brief
within
four
days
docketing
ibid
desires
oral
argument
appeals
must
hold
one
within
five
days
docketing
must
issue
decision
immediately
oral
argument
ibid
waives
right
oral
argument
appeals
must
issue
decision
within
five
days
docketing
ibid
appeals
comply
time
limits
constructive
order
results
authorizing
minor
consent
abortion
ibid
appellees
action
include
akron
center
reproductive
health
facility
provides
abortions
max
pierre
gaujean
physician
performs
abortions
akron
center
rachael
roe
unmarried
unemancipated
minor
woman
sought
abortion
facility
march
days
effective
date
appellees
others
brought
facial
challenge
constitutionality
statute
district
northern
district
ohio
district
various
proceedings
issued
preliminary
injunction
later
permanent
injunction
preventing
state
ohio
enforcing
statute
akron
center
reproductive
health
rosen
supp
appeals
sixth
circuit
affirmed
concluding
six
constitutional
defects
points
discussed
related
sufficiency
expedited
procedures
guarantee
anonymity
constructive
authorization
provisions
clear
convincing
evidence
standard
pleading
requirements
physician
personal
obligation
give
notice
one
minor
parents
akron
center
reproductive
health
slaby
state
ohio
appeal
ed
prob
juris
noted
challenges
appeals
decision
entirety
appellees
seek
affirmance
grounds
adopted
appeals
grounds
ii
decided
five
cases
addressing
constitutionality
parental
notice
parental
consent
statutes
abortion
context
see
planned
parenthood
central
mo
danforth
bellotti
baird
matheson
planned
parenthood
assn
kansas
city
ashcroft
akron
akron
center
reproductive
health
need
determine
whether
statute
accord
cases
violate
constitution
conclude
consistent
dispute
turns
large
extent
adequacy
judicial
bypass
procedure
analyzing
aspect
dispute
note
although
cases
required
bypass
procedures
parental
consent
statutes
decided
whether
parental
notice
statutes
must
contain
procedures
see
matheson
supra
upholding
notice
statute
without
bypass
procedure
applied
immature
dependent
minors
leave
question
open
whether
fourteenth
amendment
requires
notice
statutes
contain
bypass
procedures
bypass
procedure
meets
requirements
identified
parental
consent
statutes
danforth
bellotti
ashcroft
akron
danforth
established
order
prevent
another
person
absolute
veto
power
minor
decision
abortion
state
must
provide
sort
bypass
procedure
elects
require
parental
consent
see
hold
today
hodgson
minnesota
ante
corollary
greater
intrusiveness
consent
statutes
bypass
procedure
suffice
consent
statute
suffice
also
notice
statute
see
also
matheson
supra
notice
statutes
equivalent
consent
statutes
give
anyone
veto
power
minor
abortion
decision
principal
opinion
bellotti
stated
four
criteria
bypass
procedure
consent
statute
must
satisfy
appellees
contend
bypass
procedure
satisfy
criteria
disagree
first
bellotti
principal
opinion
indicated
procedure
must
allow
minor
show
possesses
maturity
information
make
abortion
decision
consultation
physician
without
regard
parents
wishes
see
opinion
powell
reaffirmed
requirement
akron
holding
state
presume
immaturity
girls
age
case
us
difficulty
concluding
allows
minor
show
maturity
conformity
principal
opinion
bellotti
statute
permits
minor
show
sufficiently
mature
well
enough
informed
decide
intelligently
whether
abortion
ohio
rev
code
ann
supp
second
bellotti
principal
opinion
indicated
procedure
must
allow
minor
show
even
make
abortion
decision
desired
abortion
best
interests
believe
satisfies
bellotti
language
quoted
statute
requires
juvenile
authorize
minor
consent
determines
abortion
minor
best
interest
cases
minor
shown
pattern
physical
sexual
emotional
abuse
see
third
bellotti
principal
opinion
indicated
procedure
must
insure
minor
anonymity
see
satisfies
standard
section
provides
juvenile
shall
notify
parents
guardian
custodian
complainant
pregnant
wants
abortion
section
hearing
section
shall
conducted
manner
preserve
anonymity
complainant
complaint
papers
records
pertain
action
commenced
section
shall
kept
confidential
public
records
appellees
argue
complaint
forms
prescribed
ohio
require
minor
disclose
identity
unless
minor
counsel
must
sign
complaint
form
initiate
bypass
procedure
even
counsel
must
supply
name
one
parents
four
different
places
see
app
pleading
forms
appellees
prefer
protections
similar
included
statutes
reviewed
bellotti
ashcroft
statute
bellotti
protected
anonymity
permitting
use
pseudonym
see
planned
parenthood
league
massachusetts
bellotti
statute
ashcroft
allowed
minor
sign
petition
initials
see
appellees
also
maintain
ohio
laws
requiring
employees
disclose
public
documents
irrelevant
right
anonymity
broader
right
officials
reveal
one
identity
public
large
confidentiality
differs
anonymity
believe
distinction
constitutional
significance
present
context
distinction
played
part
previous
decisions
even
bellotti
principal
opinion
taken
setting
standard
find
complete
anonymity
critical
like
statutes
bellotti
ashcroft
takes
reasonable
steps
prevent
public
learning
minor
identity
refuse
base
decision
facial
validity
statute
mere
possibility
unauthorized
illegal
disclosure
state
employees
like
many
sophisticated
judicial
procedures
requires
participants
provide
identifying
information
administrative
purposes
public
disclosure
fourth
bellotti
plurality
indicated
courts
must
conduct
bypass
procedure
expedition
allow
minor
effective
opportunity
obtain
abortion
see
noted
requires
trial
make
decision
within
five
business
day
minor
files
complaint
requires
appeals
docket
appeal
within
four
days
minor
files
notice
appeal
requires
appeals
render
decision
within
five
days
docketing
appeal
ibid
district
appeals
assumed
references
days
meant
business
days
opposed
calendar
days
cf
ohio
rule
app
proc
excluding
nonbusiness
days
computations
less
seven
days
calculated
result
procedure
take
calendar
days
minor
file
time
year
business
days
needed
bypass
procedure
encompass
three
saturdays
three
sundays
two
legal
holidays
appellees
maintain
basis
affidavit
included
record
delay
increase
substantial
measure
costs
medical
risks
abortion
see
app
conclude
courts
satisfy
bellotti
principal
opinion
expedition
requirement
preliminary
matter
calculation
conflicts
two
rules
construction
discussed
abortion
cases
elsewhere
fairly
possible
courts
construe
statute
avoid
danger
unconstitutionality
ashcroft
opinion
powell
although
recognize
federal
courts
better
schooled
able
interpret
laws
respective
frisby
schultz
appeals
decision
strikes
us
dubious
interpreting
term
days
mean
business
days
instead
calendar
days
seems
inappropriate
unnecessary
express
contrasting
use
business
day
addition
appellees
making
facial
challenge
statute
must
show
set
circumstances
exists
act
valid
webster
reproductive
health
services
concurring
appeals
invalidated
ohio
statute
facial
challenge
based
upon
analysis
may
never
occur
cf
ohio
rev
code
supp
allowing
appeals
upon
minor
motion
shorten
extend
time
periods
moreover
precedents
mere
possibility
procedure
may
require
days
rare
case
plainly
insufficient
invalidate
statute
face
ashcroft
example
upheld
missouri
statute
contained
bypass
procedure
require
calendar
days
plus
sufficient
time
deliberation
decisionmaking
trial
appellate
levels
see
appellees
ask
us
effect
extend
criteria
used
members
bellotti
cases
following
imposing
three
additional
requirements
bypass
procedures
first
challenge
constructive
authorization
provisions
enable
minor
obtain
abortion
without
notifying
one
parents
either
juvenile
appeals
fails
act
within
prescribed
time
limits
see
ohio
rev
code
ann
iv
supp
speculate
absence
affirmative
order
fails
process
minor
complaint
deter
physician
acting
discern
constitutional
defect
statute
absent
demonstrated
pattern
abuse
defiance
state
may
expect
judges
follow
mandated
procedural
requirements
showing
time
limitations
imposed
ignored
abundance
caution
concern
minor
interests
ohio
added
constructive
authorization
provision
ensure
expedition
bypass
procedures
even
time
limits
met
state
attorney
general
represents
physician
obtain
certified
documentation
juvenile
appellate
constructive
authorization
occurred
brief
appellant
require
similar
safety
net
bypass
procedures
ashcroft
supra
find
defect
procedures
ohio
provided
second
appellees
ask
us
rule
bypass
procedure
require
minor
prove
maturity
best
interests
standard
clear
convincing
evidence
maintain
state
seeks
deprive
individual
liberty
interests
must
take
upon
risk
error
see
santosky
kramer
house
bill
violates
standard
opinion
placing
burden
proof
upon
minor
also
imposing
heightened
standard
proof
contention
lacks
merit
state
bear
burden
proof
issues
maturity
best
interests
principal
opinion
bellotti
indicates
state
may
require
minor
prove
facts
bypass
procedure
see
opinion
powell
state
moreover
may
require
heightened
standard
proof
bypass
procedure
contemplates
ex
parte
proceeding
one
opposes
minor
testimony
find
clear
convincing
standard
used
acceptable
ohio
stated
clear
convincing
evidence
measure
degree
proof
produce
mind
trier
facts
firm
belief
conviction
allegations
sought
established
intermediate
mere
preponderance
extent
certainty
required
beyond
reasonable
doubt
criminal
cases
mean
clear
unequivocal
cross
ledford
ohio
emphasis
deleted
third
appellees
contend
pleading
requirements
create
trap
unwary
minor
statutory
scheme
requirements
prescribed
ohio
must
choose
among
three
pleading
forms
see
ohio
rev
code
supp
app
first
alleges
maturity
second
alleges
best
interests
may
attempt
prove
maturity
best
interests
unless
chooses
third
form
alleges
facts
appellees
contend
complications
imposed
scheme
deny
minor
opportunity
required
principal
opinion
bellotti
prove
either
maturity
best
interests
see
even
assumption
pleading
scheme
produce
initial
confusion
minors
counsel
pleading
simple
straightforward
procedure
deprive
minor
opportunity
prove
case
seems
unlikely
ohio
courts
treat
minor
choice
complaint
form
without
due
care
understanding
unrepresented
status
addition
note
minor
make
binding
election
initial
choice
pleading
form
minor
receives
appointed
counsel
filing
complaint
may
move
leave
amend
pleadings
see
ohio
rule
juvenile
proc
see
also
hambleton
barry
ohio
finding
liberal
amendment
policy
state
civil
rules
regardless
whether
ohio
written
simpler
statute
survives
facial
challenge
iii
appellees
contend
inquiry
end
even
decide
conforms
danforth
bellotti
matheson
ashcroft
akron
maintain
gives
minor
state
law
substantive
right
avoid
unnecessary
hostile
parental
involvement
demonstrate
maturity
best
interests
favor
abortion
without
notifying
one
parents
argue
deprives
minor
right
without
due
process
pleading
requirements
alleged
lack
expedition
anonymity
clear
convincing
evidence
standard
make
bypass
procedure
unfair
see
mathews
eldridge
find
merit
argument
confidentiality
provisions
expedited
procedures
pleading
form
requirements
face
satisfy
dictates
minimal
due
process
see
little
risk
erroneous
deprivation
provisions
need
require
additional
procedural
safeguards
clear
convincing
evidence
standard
reasons
described
place
unconstitutional
burden
types
proof
presented
minor
assisted
attorney
guardian
ad
litem
proceeding
ex
parte
standard
ensures
judge
take
special
care
deciding
whether
minor
consent
abortion
proceed
without
parental
notification
final
matter
given
statute
provides
definite
reasonable
deadlines
ohio
rev
code
ann
supp
constructive
authorization
provision
also
comports
due
process
face
iv
appellees
final
matter
contend
invalidate
entirety
statute
requires
parental
notice
given
physician
perform
abortion
akron
found
unconstitutional
requirement
attending
physician
provide
information
counseling
relevant
informed
consent
see
although
disapprove
informing
woman
health
risks
abortion
explained
state
interest
ensuring
woman
consent
informed
unpressured
critical
factor
whether
obtains
necessary
information
counseling
qualified
person
identity
person
obtains
appellees
maintain
similar
fashion
ohio
reason
requiring
minor
physician
rather
qualified
person
notify
one
minor
parents
appellees
however
failed
consider
precedent
matter
upheld
matheson
statute
required
physician
notify
minor
parents
see
distinction
notifying
minor
parents
informing
woman
routine
risks
abortion
ample
justification
although
counselors
may
provide
information
general
risks
akron
appellees
contest
superior
ability
physician
garner
use
information
supplied
minor
parents
upon
receiving
notice
continue
believe
state
may
require
physician
take
reasonable
steps
notify
minor
parent
parent
often
provide
important
medical
data
physician
explained
matheson
medical
emotional
psychological
consequences
abortion
serious
lasting
particularly
patient
immature
adequate
medical
psychological
case
history
important
physician
parents
provide
medical
psychological
data
refer
physician
sources
medical
history
family
physicians
authorize
family
physicians
give
relevant
data
omitted
imposition
physician
schedule
requiring
give
notice
minor
consent
one
parents
authorization
must
evaluated
light
complete
statutory
scheme
statute
allows
physician
send
notice
mail
reach
minor
parent
reasonable
effort
ohio
rev
code
ann
also
allows
forgo
notice
event
certain
emergencies
see
provisions
adequate
recognition
physician
professional
status
facial
challenge
find
physician
notification
requirement
unobjectionable
ohio
statute
sum
impose
undue
otherwise
unconstitutional
burden
minor
seeking
abortion
believe
addition
legislature
acted
rational
manner
enacting
free
enlightened
society
may
decide
members
attain
clearer
tolerant
understanding
profound
philosophic
choices
confronted
woman
considering
whether
seek
abortion
decision
embrace
destiny
personal
dignity
origins
human
life
lie
within
embryo
state
entitled
assume
people
beginnings
understanding
within
family
society
intimate
association
rational
fair
state
conclude
instances
family
strive
give
lonely
even
terrified
minor
advice
compassionate
mature
statute
issue
rational
way
ends
deny
dignity
family
say
state
take
reasonable
step
regulating
health
professions
ensure
cases
young
woman
receive
guidance
understanding
parent
uphold
face
reverse
appeals
ordered
justice
scalia
concurring
join
opinion
agree
ohio
statute
neither
deprives
minors
procedural
due
process
contradicts
holdings
regarding
constitutional
right
abortion
continue
believe
however
said
separate
concurrence
last
term
webster
reproductive
health
services
constitution
contains
right
abortion
found
longstanding
traditions
society
logically
deduced
text
constitution
without
volunteering
judicial
answer
nonjusticiable
question
human
life
begins
leaving
matter
political
process
legally
correct
pragmatically
alone
lawyerly
dissection
federal
judicial
precedents
produce
compromises
satisfying
sufficient
mass
electorate
deeply
felt
issue
cease
distorting
remainder
democratic
process
end
disruptive
intrusion
field
soon
possible
justice
stevens
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
emphasizes
appellees
challenged
ohio
statute
face
state
may
presume
applications
statute
reasonably
legitimate
interest
protecting
welfare
minor
citizens
see
matheson
stevens
concurring
judgment
applications
however
notice
requirement
reasonably
interest
exceptional
situations
notice
cause
realistic
risk
physical
harm
pregnant
woman
cause
trauma
ill
parent
enable
parent
prevent
abortion
reasons
unrelated
best
interests
minor
ohio
statute
recognizes
possibility
providing
judicial
bypass
question
case
whether
statutory
protection
exceptional
case
obviously
inadequate
entire
statute
invalidated
willing
reach
conclusion
statute
implemented
significance
restrictions
evaluated
light
administration
therefore
agree
appeals
judgment
must
reversed
join
parts
opinion
correctly
decided
specific
question
whether
judicial
bypass
procedure
necessary
order
save
constitutionality
single
parent
notice
statute
see
ante
however
squarely
held
requirement
preabortion
parental
notice
cases
involving
pregnant
minors
unconstitutional
although
need
take
form
judicial
bypass
state
must
provide
adequate
mechanism
cases
minor
mature
notice
best
interests
akron
akron
center
reproductive
health
city
argued
constitutionality
ordinance
requiring
parental
consent
saved
minor
opportunity
invoke
state
juvenile
procedures
held
day
planned
parenthood
assn
kansas
city
mo
ashcroft
opinion
powell
similar
provision
require
parental
notification
avoided
constitutional
infirmities
statute
rejected
argument
akron
however
procedures
case
required
parent
given
notice
minor
petition
filed
writing
six
justices
including
author
opinion
matheson
supra
justice
powell
explained
even
assuming
ohio
courts
construe
provisions
permitting
minor
obtain
judicial
approval
proper
necessary
medical
surgical
care
abortion
parents
refused
provide
care
statute
makes
provision
mature
emancipated
minor
completely
avoid
hostile
parental
involvement
demonstrating
satisfaction
capable
exercising
constitutional
right
choose
abortion
contrary
statute
requires
minor
parents
notified
petition
filed
ohio
rev
code
ann
supp
requirement
case
mature
minor
seeking
abortion
unconstitutional
see
matheson
powell
concurring
marshall
dissenting
ohio
statute
face
provides
sufficient
procedure
cases
pleading
requirements
constructive
authorization
confidentiality
provisions
act
satisfy
standards
established
ashcroft
supra
judicial
bypass
minor
bound
initial
choice
pleading
form
ante
constructive
authorization
provision
functions
additional
safety
net
statutory
deadlines
met
ante
state
taken
reasonable
steps
ensure
confidentiality
ante
requirement
minor
prove
maturity
best
interests
clear
convincing
evidence
supported
presumption
notification
parent
circumstances
minor
best
interests
unreasonable
require
minor
assisted
counsel
guardian
ad
litem
ante
overcome
presumption
clear
convincing
evidence
cf
parham
resumption
parents
act
best
interests
child
relevant
determining
process
due
commitment
proceeding
concern
possible
delay
bypass
procedure
statute
permits
ohio
courts
expedite
procedure
upon
showing
good
cause
see
ante
citing
ohio
rev
code
ann
supp
sensitive
administration
deadlines
may
demonstrate
concern
unwarranted
tension
statutory
requirement
treating
physician
notify
minor
parent
decision
akron
state
may
require
attending
physician
personally
counsel
abortion
patient
one
overlook
possibility
provision
motivated
legislative
interest
placing
obstacles
woman
path
abortion
see
maher
roe
genuine
interest
fostering
informed
decisionmaking
agree
however
ohio
statute
requires
physician
take
reasonable
steps
notify
minor
parent
notification
may
contribute
decisionmaking
process
ante
accordingly
unable
conclude
provision
unconstitutional
face
footnotes
standard
proof
minor
abortion
decision
onerous
medical
procedure
parents
may
disapprove
ohio
law
determination
child
neglected
dependent
necessary
guardian
ad
litem
may
authorize
proper
necessary
medical
surgical
care
must
made
clear
convincing
evidence
see
ohio
ann
supp
see
also
willmann
ohio
app
bibb
ohio
app
justice
blackmun
justice
brennan
justice
marshall
join
dissenting
constitutional
right
control
quintessentially
intimate
personal
decision
whether
carry
fetus
term
webster
reproductive
health
services
opinion
concurring
part
dissenting
part
mature
come
magically
one
attains
age
majority
minors
well
adults
protected
constitution
possess
constitutional
rights
planned
parenthood
central
mo
danforth
hodgson
minnesota
ante
constitutional
protection
unjustified
state
intrusion
process
deciding
whether
bear
child
extends
pregnant
minors
well
adult
women
although
recognized
state
somewhat
broader
authority
regulate
activities
children
adults
state
nevertheless
must
demonstrate
significant
state
interest
conditioning
abortion
present
case
adult
danforth
emphasis
added
independent
interest
parent
may
termination
minor
daughter
pregnancy
weighty
right
privacy
competent
minor
mature
enough
become
pregnant
abortion
decision
differs
important
ways
decisions
may
made
minority
need
protect
constitutional
right
unique
nature
abortion
decision
especially
made
minor
require
state
act
particular
sensitivity
legislates
foster
parental
involvement
matter
bellotti
baird
opinion
powell
emphasis
added
bellotti
ii
articular
sensitivity
mandated
situations
denying
minor
right
make
important
decision
consequences
grave
indelible
ibid
obvious
considering
probable
education
employment
skills
financial
resources
emotional
maturity
unwanted
motherhood
may
exceptionally
burdensome
minor
ibid
ii
majority
decide
whether
ohio
parental
notice
statute
must
contain
judicial
bypass
procedure
majority
concludes
bypass
procedure
statute
meets
requirements
identified
parental
consent
statutes
danforth
bellotti
ashcroft
akron
ante
conclude
however
minor
emotional
vulnerability
financial
dependency
parents
unique
nature
abortion
decision
bellotti
ii
consequences
parental
notice
statute
tantamount
parental
consent
statute
practical
matter
notification
requirement
deterrent
effect
pregnant
minor
seeking
exercise
constitutional
right
consent
statute
see
akron
akron
center
reproductive
health
matheson
concurring
opinion
thus
notice
statute
like
consent
statute
must
contain
bypass
procedure
comports
standards
set
forth
bellotti
ii
disagree
conclusion
ohio
bypass
procedure
complies
dictates
bellotti
ii
progeny
strike
ohio
amended
substitute
house
bill
bellotti
ii
principal
opinion
stated
pregnant
minor
entitled
proceeding
show
either
mature
enough
well
enough
informed
make
abortion
decision
consultation
physician
independently
parents
wishes
even
able
make
decision
independently
desired
abortion
best
interests
opinion
powell
omitted
language
ohio
statute
purports
follow
standards
bypass
procedure
set
forth
bellotti
ii
stage
along
way
statute
deliberately
places
substantial
obstacles
pregnant
minor
path
abortion
maher
roe
legislative
hope
stumble
perhaps
fall
least
ensuring
conquer
obstacle
course
able
exercise
constitutional
right
abortion
dellinger
sperling
abortion
retreat
roe
wade
rev
majority
considers
provision
piecemeal
fashion
never
acknowledging
assessing
degree
burden
entire
regime
abortion
regulations
places
minor
ibid
obstacle
course
begins
minor
first
enters
courthouse
fill
complaint
forms
pleading
trap
appropriately
described
appeals
akron
center
reproductive
health
slaby
requires
minor
choose
among
three
forms
first
alleges
maturity
second
alleges
abortion
best
interest
app
minor
chooses
third
form
alleges
may
minor
attempt
prove
maturity
best
interest
right
bellotti
ii
see
ohio
rev
code
ann
supp
majority
makes
light
acknowledges
might
initial
confusion
unsophisticated
minor
trying
deal
unfamiliar
mystifying
system
intensely
intimate
matter
ante
points
minor
counsel
appointed
filed
complaint
may
move
leave
amend
pleadings
avers
seems
unlikely
ohio
courts
treat
minor
choice
complaint
form
without
due
care
ante
take
ohio
legislature
word
however
pleading
requirement
intended
meaningful
constitutionality
procedural
provision
analyzed
basis
may
effect
pleading
requirement
prevents
minors
showing
either
mature
abortion
best
interests
plainly
unconstitutional
majority
fails
elucidate
state
interest
setting
barricade
young
pregnant
woman
barricade
serve
confuse
heighten
anxiety
thornburgh
justification
state
put
forward
appeals
absurd
contention
ny
minor
claiming
mature
well
enough
informed
independently
make
important
decision
abortion
also
mature
enough
file
complaint
appropriate
subsection
see
quoting
brief
state
ohio
proffered
justification
even
harsh
appeals
noted
excludes
mature
minor
may
intellectual
capacity
understand
tangled
forms
spurns
immature
minor
abused
contends
reason
abortion
without
parental
involvement
best
interest
surely
goal
proceeding
assist
entrap
young
pregnant
woman
state
interest
streamlining
claims
belatedly
asserted
first
time
less
absurd
ludicrous
confound
pregnant
minor
forced
go
time
crisis
life
alternative
complaint
forms
must
later
rescinded
appointed
counsel
replaced
form
constitutionally
valid
moreover
ridiculous
pleading
scheme
leaves
judge
discretion
whether
minor
may
amend
pleading
attempt
prove
maturity
best
interest
allow
resolution
vital
issue
turn
judge
discretion
comport
bellotti
ii
declaration
minor
fails
satisfy
competent
make
decision
independently
must
permitted
show
abortion
nevertheless
best
interests
opinion
powell
emphasis
added
pregnant
minor
attempts
find
way
labyrinth
set
state
ohio
encounters
yet
another
obstruction
even
completed
complaint
form
bellotti
ii
plurality
insisted
judicial
bypass
procedure
must
assure
resolution
issue
appeals
may
follow
completed
anonymity
emphasis
added
statement
idle
procedural
requirement
stems
proposition
due
process
clause
protects
woman
right
make
decision
independently
privately
hodgson
ante
zone
privacy
long
held
encompass
individual
interest
avoiding
disclosure
personal
matters
whalen
roe
ohio
statute
safeguard
right
far
keeping
identity
minor
anonymous
statute
requires
minor
sign
full
name
name
one
parents
complaint
form
see
app
pleading
forms
see
ante
unless
minor
counsel
must
sign
complaint
form
initiate
bypass
procedure
even
counsel
must
supply
name
one
parents
four
different
places
acknowledging
onfidentiality
differs
anonymity
majority
simply
asserts
complete
anonymity
critical
ante
easy
conclusion
irreconcilable
bellotti
anonymity
requirement
definition
anonymous
named
identified
webster
ninth
new
collegiate
dictionary
complete
anonymity
appears
kind
anonymity
person
possibly
majority
admits
case
law
regarding
anonymity
requirement
permitted
less
see
ante
citing
planned
parenthood
league
massachusetts
bellotti
pseudonym
planned
parenthood
assn
kansas
city
missouri
ashcroft
initials
see
also
thornburgh
decision
terminate
pregnancy
intensely
private
one
must
protected
way
assures
anonymity
majority
points
ohio
laws
requiring
employees
disclose
public
documents
blithely
assuming
mere
possibility
unauthorized
illegal
disclosure
state
employees
insufficient
establish
confidentiality
proceeding
protected
ante
fact
provisions
regarding
duty
employees
disclose
public
documents
amount
generally
stated
principles
confidentiality
american
college
obstetricians
thornburgh
aff
grounds
district
pointed
indications
clerk
office
large
small
ensure
records
abortion
cases
distinguished
records
cases
available
public
akron
center
reproductive
health
rosen
nd
ohio
cf
planned
parenthood
league
massachusetts
bellotti
minor
proceeds
pseudonym
affidavit
containing
identity
kept
separate
sealed
file
measures
sealing
record
case
closed
prevent
public
availability
planned
parenthood
assn
atlanta
area
harris
nd
noting
disapproval
georgia
statute
made
provision
documents
sealed
well
aware
unless
special
care
taken
documents
intimate
nature
find
way
press
public
see
florida
star
reporter
police
room
copied
police
report
published
article
rape
victim
full
name
state
offered
justification
failure
provide
specific
guidelines
followed
juvenile
ensure
anonymity
pregnant
minor
even
though
place
procedure
assure
anonymity
juveniles
adjudicated
delinquent
unruly
see
ohio
rev
code
ann
detailed
provision
sealing
record
expungement
record
woman
physician
necessarily
reluctant
choose
abortion
exists
possibility
decision
identity
become
known
publicly
thornburgh
minor
whose
purpose
going
judicial
bypass
proceeding
avoid
notifying
hostile
abusive
parent
alarmed
signing
name
name
parent
complaint
form
generalized
statements
concerning
confidentiality
records
small
comfort
even
aware
true
anonymity
essential
effective
meaningful
bypass
face
forms
minor
must
actually
deal
state
assurances
minor
privacy
protected
ring
hollow
permit
state
ohio
force
minor
forgo
anonymity
order
obtain
waiver
parental
notification
requirement
pregnant
adolescent
preserve
long
possibility
aborting
effectively
expires
matter
weeks
onset
pregnancy
required
state
must
assure
resolution
issue
appeals
may
follow
completed
sufficient
expedition
provide
effective
opportunity
abortion
obtained
bellotti
ii
page
opinion
powell
see
also
matheson
time
essence
abortion
decision
ohio
judicial
bypass
procedure
consume
three
weeks
young
woman
pregnancy
join
sixth
circuit
district
federal
courts
held
timespan
length
fails
guarantee
sufficiently
expedited
procedure
see
see
also
american
college
obstetricians
gynecologists
thornburgh
ed
statutory
scheme
allowing
days
judicial
proceeding
unconstitutional
glick
mckay
majority
unconcerned
procedure
may
require
days
rare
case
ante
doubt
rarity
cases
event
appeals
appropriately
pointed
minor
often
learn
pregnancy
late
stage
first
trimester
time
lost
trimester
especially
critical
ignores
facts
medical
risks
surrounding
abortion
increase
pregnancy
advances
delay
may
push
woman
second
trimester
medical
risks
economic
costs
state
regulation
increase
dramatically
see
roe
wade
matheson
dissenting
opinion
minors
likely
seek
later
abortions
adult
women
usually
financially
independent
suffer
acutely
delay
see
ashcroft
opinion
concurring
part
dissenting
part
increased
cost
factor
may
seem
insignificant
comfortable
perspective
equally
insignificant
unemployed
teenager
additional
cost
may
well
put
abortion
beyond
reach
delay
days
may
limit
significantly
woman
ability
obtain
abortion
agree
conclusions
district
appeals
statute
violates
command
judicial
bypass
proceeding
conducted
sufficient
speed
maintain
effective
opportunity
abortion
obtained
bellotti
ii
opinion
powell
ohio
statute
provides
juvenile
appellate
courts
fail
act
within
statutory
timeframe
abortion
without
parental
notification
constructively
authorized
although
ohio
legislature
may
intended
provision
expedite
bypass
procedure
confusion
result
constructive
authorization
provision
add
delay
judicial
bypass
proceeding
yet
one
obstruction
path
pregnant
minor
physician
risks
civil
damages
criminal
penalties
including
imprisonment
well
revocation
license
disobeying
statute
commands
statute
provides
formal
order
relief
safeguard
physician
penalties
see
state
argues
combination
copy
minor
complaint
docket
sheet
showing
entry
inform
physician
abortion
proceed
brief
appellant
yet
mere
absence
entry
docket
sheet
hardly
reassuring
physician
facing
dire
consequences
state
offers
reason
formal
order
kind
actual
notification
clerk
possible
doubt
nebulous
authorization
envisioned
statute
conjunction
statute
imposing
strict
civil
criminal
liability
profound
chilling
effect
willingness
physicians
perform
abortions
colautti
franklin
agree
appeals
practical
effect
pocket
approval
provision
frustrate
minor
right
expedient
disposition
petition
minor
able
wend
way
intricate
course
preliminaries
ohio
set
last
reaches
proceeding
state
shackles
even
tightly
still
another
extra
layer
burden
regulation
abortion
decision
danforth
minor
must
demonstrate
clear
convincing
evidence
either
maturity
one
parents
engaged
pattern
physical
sexual
emotional
abuse
notice
parent
best
interest
imposition
heightened
standard
proof
unduly
burdens
minor
right
seek
abortion
demonstrates
fundamental
misunderstanding
real
nature
bypass
proceeding
function
standard
proof
instruct
factfinder
concerning
degree
confidence
society
thinks
correctness
factual
conclusions
addington
texas
quoting
winship
concurring
opinion
societal
judgment
risk
error
distributed
litigants
santosky
kramer
imposing
stringent
standard
proof
ohio
statute
improperly
places
risk
erroneous
decision
minor
person
whose
fundamental
right
stake
cf
clear
convincing
standard
proof
usually
employed
preserve
fundamental
fairness
variety
proceedings
threaten
deprive
individual
involved
significant
deprivation
liberty
even
judge
satisfied
minor
mature
abortion
best
interest
may
authorize
procedure
unless
additionally
finds
evidence
meets
clear
convincing
standard
proof
majority
asserts
state
may
require
heightened
standard
proof
procedure
ex
parte
ante
according
majority
alternative
clear
convincing
standard
preponderance
evidence
standard
require
proof
greater
weight
evidence
majority
reasons
preponderance
standard
unsuited
bellotti
ii
bypass
minor
presents
evidence
evidence
put
forth
opposition
minor
always
present
greater
weight
evidence
yet
state
explained
argument
bypass
procedure
inquisitorial
nature
judge
questions
minor
discover
meets
requirements
set
bellotti
ii
see
tr
oral
arg
judge
making
determination
hearing
resembles
interview
evidentiary
proceeding
district
observed
judge
decision
necessarily
based
largely
subjective
standards
without
benefit
evidence
woman
testimony
thus
unlike
procedure
majority
seems
envision
quantity
evidence
presented
crucial
bypass
proceeding
rather
crucial
factors
nature
minor
statements
judge
demeanor
contrary
majority
theory
minor
presents
evidence
mature
still
must
satisfy
judge
even
without
heightened
standard
proof
use
heightened
standard
special
context
bellotti
procedure
little
facilitate
fair
reliable
result
imports
element
adversarial
process
unique
inquiry
rightful
place
although
think
provision
constitutionally
infirm
minors
particularly
concerned
effect
sexually
physically
abused
minors
agree
parental
interest
welfare
children
particularly
strong
normal
family
relationship
exists
bellotti
ii
opinion
powell
emphasis
added
minor
needs
statute
seek
support
loving
parents
trust
confidence
exist
within
family
structure
likely
communication
already
exists
compassionate
support
lacking
unwanted
pregnancy
poor
way
generate
sadly
children
country
fortunate
enough
members
loving
families
many
young
pregnant
women
parental
involvement
intimate
decision
threatens
harm
rather
promises
comfort
selective
blindness
stark
social
reality
bewildering
distressing
lacking
protection
young
people
typically
find
intimate
family
associations
minors
desperately
need
constitutional
protection
sexually
physically
abused
minor
may
indeed
lonely
even
terrified
ante
abortion
procedure
abusive
family
member
placid
reference
compassionate
mature
advice
minor
receive
within
family
must
seem
unbelievable
cruel
irony
children
trapped
violent
families
system
ohio
set
sexually
abused
minor
must
go
demonstrate
complete
stranger
clear
convincing
evidence
victim
pattern
sexual
abuse
asked
argument
kind
evidence
minor
required
adduce
bypass
hearing
state
answered
minor
tell
side
judge
judge
consider
well
minor
able
articulate
particular
concerns
tr
oral
arg
procedure
alone
many
cases
extremely
traumatic
see
hodgson
ante
state
impervious
additional
burden
imposed
abused
minor
experienced
social
worker
counselor
knows
often
afraid
ashamed
reveal
happened
anyone
outside
home
ohio
statute
forces
minor
despite
real
fears
experience
yet
one
hardship
must
attempt
public
strangers
articulate
particular
concerns
sufficient
clarity
meet
state
clear
convincing
evidence
standard
upshot
abused
minor
risk
error
entails
risk
violence
affirm
judgments
grounds
several
constitutional
defects
identified
district
appeals
pleading
requirements
fragile
guarantee
anonymity
insufficiency
expedited
procedures
constructive
authorization
provision
clear
convincing
evidence
requirement
singly
collectively
cross
limit
constitutional
acceptance
iii
even
ohio
statute
complied
bellotti
ii
requirements
constitutional
bypass
conclude
ohio
procedure
unconstitutional
requires
physician
personal
nondelegable
obligation
give
required
statutory
notice
particularly
viewed
context
impediments
statute
places
minor
path
possibility
physician
notification
provision
motivated
legislative
interest
placing
obstacles
woman
path
abortion
see
maher
roe
genuine
interest
fostering
informed
decisionmaking
ante
stevens
concurring
judgment
telling
regard
fact
according
appeals
district
state
never
claimed
personal
notice
physician
required
effectuate
interest
minor
health
matter
reached
fact
state
taken
three
different
positions
justification
provision
see
state
interest
insuring
immature
unemancipated
minors
minors
whose
best
interests
require
notification
adequate
opportunity
parental
intervention
state
made
showing
interest
advanced
requiring
attending
physician
opposed
another
qualified
responsible
person
effectuate
notification
state
attempt
characterize
duty
merely
ministerial
advance
case
rather
suggests
interest
physician
perform
function
even
less
weighty
perform
counseling
obtain
informed
consent
struck
akron
akron
center
reproductive
health
chimerical
health
concerns
asserted
fact
true
motivation
behind
provision
seriously
doubt
state
taken
long
say
even
state
interest
health
minor
motivation
behind
provision
state
never
explains
physician
interested
obtaining
information
parent
interested
providing
information
physician
following
actual
notification
competent
professional
nurse
counselor
state
majority
never
explain
physician
ability
garner
information
parents
paramount
importance
physician
may
notify
parent
statute
allows
physician
send
notice
mail
reach
minor
parent
reasonable
effort
state
asserted
interest
minor
health
care
especially
ironic
light
statute
interference
physician
experienced
professional
judgment
physician
licensed
state
recognized
state
capable
exercising
acceptable
clinical
judgment
doe
bolton
permitted
exercise
judgment
whether
another
professional
person
notify
minor
parents
decision
terminate
pregnancy
doubt
attending
physician
better
ohio
legislature
know
consultation
parent
necessary
fails
professional
censure
deprivation
license
available
remedies
already
place
ibid
strictures
ohio
law
unduly
burden
minor
right
abortion
impinge
physician
professional
discretion
practice
medicine
iv
ohio
legislature
wisdom
enacted
antiabortion
statute
statute
subjected
facial
challenge
held
unconstitutional
district
northern
district
ohio
appeals
sixth
circuit
however
upheld
challenge
majority
majority
opinion
takes
challenged
provision
turn
concludes
brief
comment
within
bounds
principal
opinion
bellotti
ii
moves
routinely
fashion
succeeding
provisions
one
one
plurality
concludes
part
primary
opinion
hyperbole
one
result
incite
american
press
public
pulpit
already
inflamed
pronouncement
made
plurality
last
term
webster
reproductive
health
services
plurality
indulges
paternalistic
comments
profound
philosophic
choices
woman
destiny
personal
dignity
origins
human
life
lie
within
embryo
family
society
intimate
association
striving
family
give
minor
advice
compassionate
mature
desired
assumption
cases
woman
receive
guidance
understanding
parent
ante
may
cases
hoped
judges
warm
protected
nurturing
family
environments
cases
need
rely
constitutional
protections
vital
others
cautioned
another
world
either
chooses
ignore
refuses
recognize
beal
doe
unfortunate
denizens
world
often
frightened
forlorn
lacking
comfort
loving
parental
guidance
mature
advice
need
constitutional
protection
ohio
legislature
set
make
difficult
possible
obtain
legislature
set
forth
goal
evident
statute
spawned
underlying
nature
ohio
statute
proclaimed
strident
offensively
restrictive
provisions
though
legislature
said
courts
insist
upholding
limited
right
abortion
let
us
make
abortion
difficult
possible
obtain
basically
whether
professed
moral
religious
grounds
whatever
believe
way
must
often
may
way
legislation
enacted
instances
injustice
evident
impediments
gross
inflicted
ohio
legislature
vulnerable
powerless
young
women
indeed
threat
parental
notice
may
cause
minor
delay
requesting
assistance
pregnancy
see
matheson
dissenting
opinion
majority
finds
comfort
planned
parenthood
kansas
city
ashcroft
insists
upheld
missouri
statute
contained
bypass
procedure
require
calendar
days
plus
sufficient
time
deliberation
decisionmaking
trial
appellate
levels
ante
majority
disregards
limited
nature
ashcroft
holding
looked
missouri
appellate
procedure
determined
deadline
docketing
appeal
deadline
completing
record
perfecting
appeal
together
requirement
missouri
provide
expedited
appeal
rule
provided
constitutionally
sufficient
framework
complying
bellotti
mandate
expedited
appeals
see
made
ruling
whether
missouri
law
provided
constitutionally
sufficient
expedition
initial
stages
bypass
bellotti
baird
recognized
unique
nature
bypass
procedure
required
minor
merely
show
satisfy
mature
abortion
best
interests
without
imposing
standard
proof
see
also
opinion
powell
much
said
employing
procedures
forum
less
formal
associated
general
jurisdiction
said
majority
minors
voluntarily
tell
parents
pregnancy
overwhelming
majority
years
age
see
torres
forrest
eisman
telling
parents
clinic
practices
adolescents
use
family
planning
abortion
services
family
planning
perspectives
million
children
adolescents
suffered
harm
parental
abuse
neglect
including
sexual
abuse
see
brief
american
psychological
association
et
al
amici
curiae
sources
cited
therein
figure
considered
minimum
estimate
incidence
abuse
substantially
underreported
pregnancy
deter
may
even
precipitate
physical
attacks
women
ibid
regnant
minors
may
attempt
obtain
illegal
abortion
rather
risk
parental
notification
matheson
dissenting
opinion
majority
state
ohio
piously
fail
mention
happens
unwanted
babies
born
mothers
little
children
little
opportunity
education
life
skills
often
unwanted
child
becomes
trapped
cycle
poverty
despair
violence
experience
knows
well
unable
adequately
supervise
protect
vulnerable
citizens
see
baltimore
city
dept
social
services
bouknight
deshaney
winnebago
county
dept
social
services
light
asserted
interest
find
odd
ohio
allows
minors
consent
treatment
sexually
transmitted
diseases
ohio
rev
code
ann
drug
alcohol
abuse
sensitive
areas
health
care
state
apparently
trusts
physician
use
informed
medical
judgment
whether
question
inform
parent
minor
medical
psychological
condition
majority
reliance
matheson
misplaced
case
unlike
one
utah
limited
steps
physician
take
notify
minor
parents
see
contrast
akron
akron
center
reproductive
health
pointed
critical
factor
whether
obtains
necessary
information
counseling
qualified
person
identity
person
obtains
emphasis
added