alabama
shelton
argued
february
decided
may
shelton
represented
alabama
circuit
criminal
trial
repeatedly
warned
shelton
problems
entailed
time
offered
assistance
counsel
state
expense
convicted
misdemeanor
assault
sentenced
jail
term
trial
immediately
suspended
placing
shelton
two
years
unsupervised
probation
alabama
reversed
shelton
suspended
jail
sentence
reasoning
decisions
argersinger
hamlin
scott
illinois
require
provision
counsel
petty
offense
misdemeanor
felony
prosecution
argersinger
actually
leads
imprisonment
even
brief
period
state
concluded
inter
alia
defendant
may
imprisoned
absent
provision
counsel
shelton
suspended
sentence
never
activated
therefore
invalid
held
suspended
sentence
may
end
actual
deprivation
person
liberty
may
imposed
unless
defendant
accorded
guiding
hand
counsel
prosecution
crime
charged
argersinger
pp
controlling
rule
absent
knowing
intelligent
waiver
person
may
imprisoned
offense
unless
represented
counsel
trial
argersinger
pp
applying
actual
imprisonment
rule
rejects
argument
invited
amicus
curiae
failure
appoint
counsel
indigent
defendant
bar
imposition
suspended
probationary
sentence
upon
conviction
misdemeanor
even
though
defendant
might
incarcerated
event
probation
revoked
pp
sixth
amendment
permit
activation
suspended
sentence
upon
indigent
defendant
violation
terms
probation
state
provide
counsel
prosecution
offense
imprisoned
suspended
sentence
prison
term
imposed
offense
conviction
prison
term
triggered
defendant
incarcerated
probation
violation
underlying
offense
uncounseled
conviction
point
result
imprisonment
nichols
end
actual
deprivation
person
liberty
argersinger
precisely
sixth
amendment
interpreted
argersinger
scott
allow
rejects
first
two
grounds
amicus
resists
reasoning
amicus
attempt
align
case
nichols
gagnon
scarpelli
decisions
stand
broad
proposition
sequential
proceedings
must
analyzed
separately
sixth
amendment
purposes
right
counsel
triggered
proceedings
result
immediate
actual
imprisonment
dispositive
factor
gagnon
nichols
whether
incarceration
occurred
immediately
delay
rather
critical
point
defendant
recognized
right
counsel
adjudicated
guilty
felony
imprisoned
see
nichols
even
acquitted
misdemeanor
aid
appointed
counsel
watts
relaxed
standard
application
question
whether
defendant
may
jailed
absent
conviction
credited
reliable
defendant
access
counsel
pp
also
unpersuasive
amicus
contention
practical
considerations
weigh
extension
sixth
amendment
right
defendant
shelton
situation
based
figures
suggesting
conditional
sentences
commonly
imposed
rarely
activated
amicus
argues
appropriate
rule
permit
imposition
suspended
sentence
uncounseled
defendant
require
appointment
counsel
probation
revocation
stage
incarceration
imminent
regime
unduly
reduce
sixth
amendment
domain
alabama
probation
revocation
hearing
informal
proceeding
defendant
right
counsel
obligation
observe
customary
rules
evidence
significant
defendant
may
challenge
validity
reliability
underlying
conviction
hearing
timed
structured
compensate
absence
trial
counsel
thereby
bring
shelton
sentence
within
constitutional
bounds
agree
amicus
holding
substantially
limit
ability
impose
probation
jurisdictions
already
provide
right
appointed
counsel
generous
afforded
federal
constitution
simultaneously
preserving
option
probationary
punishment
see
even
amicus
correct
afford
costs
rule
jurisdictions
recourse
option
pretrial
probation
whereby
prosecutor
defendant
agree
defendant
participation
pretrial
rehabilitation
program
includes
conditions
typical
probation
adjudication
guilt
imposition
sentence
underlying
offense
occur
defendant
breaches
conditions
system
reserves
requirement
cases
incarceration
proves
necessary
see
gagnon
respecting
constitutional
imperative
person
imprisoned
unless
represented
counsel
argersinger
pp
rule
alabama
argument
although
sixth
amendment
bars
activation
suspended
sentence
uncounseled
conviction
constitution
prohibit
method
effectuating
probationary
punishment
imposition
suspended
sentence
never
enforced
much
hint
alabama
decision
shelton
probation
term
separable
prison
term
tethered
absent
prior
presentation
novel
position
state
takes
resists
passing
first
instance
state
consider
whether
suspended
sentence
alone
invalid
leaving
shelton
probation
term
freestanding
independently
effective
see
hortonville
joint
school
dist
hortonville
ed
pp
affirmed
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
stevens
souter
breyer
joined
scalia
filed
dissenting
opinion
rehnquist
kennedy
thomas
joined
alabama
petitioner
lereed
shelton
writ
certiorari
alabama
may
justice
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
case
concerns
sixth
amendment
right
indigent
defendant
charged
misdemeanor
punishable
imprisonment
fine
assistance
counsel
two
prior
decisions
control
judgment
first
argersinger
hamlin
held
defense
counsel
must
appointed
criminal
prosecution
whether
classified
petty
misdemeanor
felony
actually
leads
imprisonment
even
brief
period
later
scott
illinois
drew
line
actual
imprisonment
holding
counsel
need
appointed
defendant
fined
charged
crime
sentenced
term
imprisonment
lereed
shelton
convicted
assault
sentenced
jail
term
days
trial
immediately
suspended
placing
shelton
probation
two
years
question
presented
whether
sixth
amendment
right
appointed
counsel
delineated
argersinger
scott
applies
defendant
shelton
situation
hold
suspended
sentence
may
end
actual
deprivation
person
liberty
may
imposed
unless
defendant
accorded
guiding
hand
counsel
prosecution
crime
charged
argersinger
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
representing
bench
trial
district
etowah
county
alabama
shelton
convicted
assault
class
misdemeanor
carrying
maximum
punishment
one
year
imprisonment
fine
code
invoked
right
new
trial
jury
circuit
code
appeared
without
lawyer
convicted
repeatedly
warned
shelton
problems
entailed
see
app
time
offered
assistance
counsel
state
expense
circuit
sentenced
shelton
serve
days
county
prison
authorized
alabama
law
however
code
suspended
sentence
placed
shelton
two
years
unsupervised
probation
conditioned
payment
costs
fine
reparations
restitution
amount
shelton
appealed
conviction
sentence
sixth
amendment
grounds
alabama
criminal
appeals
initially
held
indigent
defendant
receives
suspended
prison
sentence
constitutional
right
counsel
remanded
determination
whether
shelton
made
knowing
intelligent
voluntary
waiver
right
app
case
returned
remand
however
appeals
reversed
course
suspended
sentence
concluded
trigger
sixth
amendment
right
appointed
counsel
unless
evidence
record
defendant
actually
deprived
liberty
shelton
remained
probation
held
denied
sixth
amendment
right
trial
alabama
reversed
criminal
appeals
relevant
part
referring
decisions
argersinger
scott
alabama
reasoned
defendant
may
sentenced
term
imprisonment
absent
provision
counsel
app
alabama
high
view
suspended
sentence
constitutes
term
imprisonment
within
meaning
argersinger
scott
even
though
incarceration
immediate
inevitable
state
constitutionally
barred
activating
conditional
sentence
alabama
concluded
threat
hollow
considered
nullity
ibid
quoting
reilley
accordingly
affirmed
shelton
conviction
monetary
portion
punishment
invalidated
aspect
sentence
imposing
days
suspended
jail
time
app
reversing
shelton
suspended
sentence
state
informs
us
also
vacated
term
probation
see
brief
petitioner
courts
divided
sixth
amendment
question
presented
case
agreed
decision
appointment
counsel
constitutional
prerequisite
imposition
conditional
suspended
prison
sentence
see
reilley
foster
white
others
rejected
proposition
see
cottle
wainwright
vacated
grounds
griswold
commonwealth
state
hansen
mont
granted
certiorari
resolve
conflict
ii
three
positions
us
case
line
decision
alabama
shelton
argues
indigent
defendant
may
receive
suspended
sentence
unless
offered
waives
assistance
counsel
brief
respondent
alabama
concedes
sixth
amendment
bars
activation
suspended
sentence
uncounseled
conviction
maintains
constitution
prohibit
imposition
sentence
method
effectuating
probationary
punishment
reply
brief
assure
full
airing
question
presented
invited
amicus
curiae
amicus
argue
support
third
position
one
alabama
abandoned
failure
appoint
counsel
indigent
defendant
bar
imposition
suspended
probationary
sentence
upon
conviction
misdemeanor
even
though
defendant
might
incarcerated
event
probation
revoked
gideon
wainwright
held
sixth
amendment
guarantee
right
counsel
firmly
established
proceedings
johnson
zerbst
applies
state
criminal
prosecutions
fourteenth
amendment
clarified
scope
right
argersinger
holding
indigent
defendant
must
offered
counsel
misdemeanor
case
actually
leads
imprisonment
seven
terms
later
scott
confirmed
argersinger
delimit
ation
although
governing
statute
scott
authorized
jail
sentence
one
year
see
held
defendant
right
counsel
sole
sentence
actually
imposed
fine
even
matter
res
nova
stated
central
premise
argersinger
actual
imprisonment
penalty
different
kind
fines
mere
threat
imprisonment
eminently
sound
warrants
adoption
actual
imprisonment
line
defining
constitutional
right
appointment
counsel
nonfelony
cases
ibid
subsequent
decisions
reiterated
actual
imprisonment
standard
see
glover
amount
actual
jail
time
sixth
amendment
significance
nichols
constitutional
line
criminal
proceedings
resulted
imprisonment
souter
concurring
judgment
scott
relying
argersinger
drew
bright
line
imprisonment
lesser
criminal
penalties
lassiter
department
social
servs
durham
thus
controlling
rule
absent
knowing
intelligent
waiver
person
may
imprisoned
offense
unless
represented
counsel
trial
argersinger
applying
actual
imprisonment
rule
case
us
take
first
question
asked
amicus
address
state
provides
counsel
indigent
defendant
sixth
amendment
permit
activation
suspended
sentence
upon
defendant
violation
terms
probation
conclude
suspended
sentence
prison
term
imposed
offense
conviction
prison
term
triggered
defendant
incarcerated
probation
violation
underlying
offense
uncounseled
conviction
point
result
imprisonment
nichols
end
actual
deprivation
person
liberty
argersinger
precisely
sixth
amendment
interpreted
argersinger
scott
allow
amicus
resists
reasoning
primarily
two
grounds
first
attempts
align
case
decisions
nichols
gagnon
scarpelli
see
brief
amicus
curiae
invitation
hereinafter
fried
brief
conclude
shelton
case
properly
bracketed
dispositions
nichols
presented
question
whether
sixth
amendment
barred
consideration
defendant
prior
uncounseled
misdemeanor
conviction
determining
sentence
subsequent
felony
offense
nichols
pleaded
guilty
federal
felony
drug
charges
several
years
earlier
unrepresented
counsel
fined
incarcerated
state
misdemeanor
driving
influence
dui
including
dui
conviction
federal
sentencing
guidelines
calculation
allowed
trial
impose
sentence
felony
drug
conviction
months
longer
misdemeanor
conviction
considered
upheld
result
concluding
uncounseled
misdemeanor
conviction
valid
scott
prison
term
imposed
also
valid
used
enhance
punishment
subsequent
conviction
gagnon
question
whether
defendant
placed
probation
pursuant
suspended
sentence
armed
robbery
due
process
right
representation
appointed
counsel
probation
revocation
hearing
held
counsel
invariably
required
parole
probation
revocation
proceedings
directed
instead
approach
turning
character
issues
involved
considered
together
amicus
contends
nichols
gagnon
establish
principle
sequential
proceedings
must
analyzed
separately
sixth
amendment
purposes
fried
brief
proceedings
result
ing
immediate
actual
imprisonment
trigger
right
counsel
emphasis
added
thus
defendant
nichols
right
appointed
counsel
dui
proceeding
immediately
imprisoned
conclusion
proceeding
uncounseled
dui
valid
imposed
later
become
invalid
used
enhance
length
imprisonment
followed
separate
subsequent
felony
proceeding
amicus
contends
shelton
right
appointed
counsel
circuit
incarcerated
immediately
trial
conviction
suspended
sentence
thus
valid
serve
proper
predicates
actual
imprisonment
later
hearing
revoke
probation
see
fried
brief
gagnon
nichols
stand
broad
proposition
amicus
extract
dispositive
factor
cases
whether
incarceration
occurred
immediately
delay
rather
critical
point
defendant
recognized
right
counsel
adjudicated
guilty
felony
offense
imprisoned
see
nichols
absent
waiver
right
appointed
counsel
felony
cases
absolute
unlike
case
revocation
probation
trigger
prison
term
imposed
misdemeanor
shelton
found
guilty
without
aid
counsel
sentences
imposed
nichols
gagnon
felony
convictions
federal
drug
conviction
nichols
state
armed
robbery
conviction
gagnon
right
counsel
unquestioned
see
nichols
relevant
sentencing
provisions
punished
last
offense
committed
defendant
constitute
change
penalty
imposed
earlier
uncounseled
misdemeanor
gagnon
distinguishing
right
accused
counsel
criminal
prosecution
limited
due
process
right
one
probationer
parolee
convicted
crime
thus
neither
nichols
gagnon
altered
diminished
argersinger
command
person
may
imprisoned
offense
unless
represented
counsel
trial
emphasis
added
far
supporting
amicus
position
gagnon
nichols
simply
highlight
sixth
amendment
inquiry
trains
stage
proceedings
corresponding
shelton
cuit
trial
guilt
adjudicated
eligibity
imprisonment
established
prison
sentence
determined
nichols
distinguishable
related
reason
applied
less
exacting
standard
consistent
traditional
understanding
sentencing
process
even
acquitted
misdemeanor
aid
appointed
counsel
watts
per
curiam
relaxed
standard
application
case
question
whether
defendant
may
jailed
absent
conviction
credited
reliable
defendant
access
guiding
hand
counsel
argersinger
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
amicus
also
contends
practical
considerations
clearly
weigh
extension
sixth
amendment
right
defendant
shelton
situation
fried
brief
cites
figures
suggesting
although
conditional
sentences
commonly
imposed
rarely
activated
tr
oral
arg
speculating
hundreds
thousands
uncounseled
defendants
receive
suspended
sentences
thousands
large
number
incarcerated
upon
violating
terms
probation
based
estimations
amicus
argues
rule
requiring
appointed
counsel
every
case
involving
suspended
sentence
unduly
hamper
attempts
impose
effective
probationary
punishment
workable
solution
contends
permit
imposition
suspended
sentence
uncounseled
defendant
require
appointment
counsel
probation
revocation
stage
incarceration
imminent
fried
brief
amicus
observes
probation
critical
tool
law
enforcement
low
level
cases
even
follow
preservation
tool
warrants
reduction
sixth
amendment
domain
result
regime
amicus
hypothesizes
amicus
describe
contours
hearing
suggests
might
precede
revocation
term
probation
imposed
uncounseled
defendant
see
raising
endeavoring
answer
several
potential
questions
nature
revocation
hearing
amicus
contemplates
alabama
however
character
probation
revocation
hearing
currently
afforded
doubt
proceeding
informal
one
buckelew
state
app
crim
app
defendant
right
counsel
obligation
observe
customary
rules
evidence
martin
state
app
crim
app
significant
sole
issue
hearing
apart
determinations
necessity
confinement
see
code
whether
defendant
breached
terms
probation
see
martin
ala
required
hearing
character
evidence
reasonably
satisfy
judge
exercise
sound
discretion
defendant
violated
valid
condition
upon
sentence
suspended
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
validity
reliability
underlying
conviction
beyond
attack
see
buckelew
ala
probation
hearing
entertain
collateral
attack
judgment
another
circuit
think
plain
hearing
timed
structured
compensate
absence
trial
counsel
even
address
key
sixth
amendment
inquiry
whether
adjudication
guilt
corresponding
prison
sentence
sufficiently
reliable
permit
incarceration
deprived
counsel
tried
convicted
sentenced
unable
challenge
original
judgment
subsequent
probation
revocation
hearing
defendant
shelton
circumstances
faces
incarceration
conviction
never
subjected
crucible
meaningful
adversarial
testing
cronic
sixth
amendment
countenance
result
variation
amicus
position
dissent
limit
review
case
question
whether
imposition
shelton
suspended
sentence
required
appointment
counsel
answering
question
plainly
step
deprive
defendant
personal
liberty
post
sentence
later
activated
dissent
contends
need
ask
whether
procedural
safeguards
attending
imposition
shelton
sentence
comply
constitution
severing
analysis
manner
makes
little
sense
one
assess
constitutionality
imposing
suspended
sentence
simultaneously
walling
procedures
precede
activation
dissent
imagines
set
safeguards
alabama
might
provide
probation
revocation
stage
sufficient
cure
failure
appoint
counsel
prior
sentencing
including
perhaps
complete
retrial
misdemeanor
violation
assistance
counsel
cause
speculation
alabama
procedures
established
alabama
statute
decisional
law
see
supra
bear
resemblance
dissent
invents
effort
sanction
prospect
shelton
imprisonment
uncounseled
assessing
issue
us
light
actual
circumstances
comprehend
procedures
alabama
fact
provides
probation
revocation
hearing
bring
shelton
sentence
within
constitutional
agree
amicus
dissent
holding
substantially
limit
ability
impose
probation
fried
brief
encumber
large
new
burden
post
jurisdictions
already
provide
right
appointed
counsel
generous
afforded
federal
constitution
see
nichols
example
provide
counsel
defendant
shelton
circumstances
either
received
substantial
state
law
authorized
incarceration
charged
provided
maximum
prison
term
one
see
code
thus
scant
reason
believe
rule
conditioning
imposition
suspended
sentence
provision
appointed
counsel
affect
existing
practice
large
majority
given
current
commitment
jurisdictions
affording
counsel
indigent
misdemeanants
simultaneously
preserving
option
probationary
punishment
share
amicus
concern
may
lack
capacity
resources
moreover
even
amicus
correct
courts
jurisdictions
least
bear
costs
rule
confirm
today
fried
brief
need
abandon
probation
equivalent
measures
viable
forms
punishment
although
may
attach
probation
imposed
suspended
prison
sentence
unable
unwilling
routinely
provide
appointed
counsel
misdemeanants
shelton
situation
without
recourse
another
option
capable
yielding
similar
result
option
pretrial
probation
employed
form
least
see
app
reply
brief
national
association
criminal
defense
lawyers
amicus
curiae
collecting
state
statutes
arrangement
prosecutor
defendant
agree
defendant
participation
pretrial
rehabilitation
includes
conditions
typical
probation
adjudication
guilt
imposition
sentence
underlying
offense
occur
defendant
breaches
conditions
ibid
see
stat
rules
crim
proc
conditions
pretrial
rehabilitation
program
may
may
imposed
respect
probation
conviction
crime
crim
proc
law
mckinney
supp
pretrial
adjournment
contemplation
dismissal
may
require
defendant
observe
certain
specified
conditions
conduct
like
regime
urged
amicus
system
reserves
requirement
small
percentage
cases
incarceration
proves
necessary
fried
brief
thus
allowing
state
supervise
course
rehabilitation
without
providing
lawyer
every
time
wishes
pursue
course
gagnon
unlike
amicus
position
however
pretrial
probation
also
respects
constitutional
imperative
person
may
imprisoned
offense
unless
represented
counsel
trial
argersinger
alabama
concedes
activation
suspended
sentence
results
imprisonment
uncounseled
defendant
term
relates
original
offense
therefore
crosses
line
actual
established
argersinger
scott
reply
brief
amicus
curiae
professor
charles
fried
shelton
imprisoned
alabama
thus
acknowledges
unless
state
afforded
right
assistance
appointed
counsel
defense
scott
see
reply
brief
alabama
maintains
however
constitutional
barrier
imposition
suspended
sentence
never
enforced
state
therefore
urges
reversal
alabama
judgment
insofar
vacated
term
probation
shelton
ordered
serve
effect
alabama
invites
us
regard
two
years
probation
shelton
separate
independent
sentence
state
power
enforce
judgment
mere
fine
tr
oral
arg
scott
alabama
emphasizes
squarely
held
sentence
trigger
right
counsel
ibid
similarly
alabama
maintains
probation
uncoupled
prison
sentence
trigger
immediate
right
appointed
counsel
seen
freestanding
sentence
alabama
asserts
probation
enforced
criminal
fine
restitution
order
contempt
proceeding
see
reply
brief
reply
brief
amicus
curiae
professor
charles
fried
tr
oral
arg
alabama
describes
contempt
proceeding
envisions
one
shelton
receive
full
panoply
due
process
including
assistance
counsel
reply
brief
sanction
imposed
wrongdoing
offense
conviction
reply
brief
amicus
curiae
professor
charles
fried
maximum
penalty
faced
fine
five
days
imprisonment
reply
brief
citing
code
days
ordered
suspended
alabama
circuit
see
supra
much
hint
however
decision
alabama
shelton
probation
term
separable
prison
term
tethered
absent
prior
presentation
position
state
resist
passing
first
instance
resistance
acting
first
view
instead
one
review
heightened
alabama
attorney
general
acknowledgment
oral
argument
know
state
imposes
postconviction
par
fine
term
probation
unattached
suspended
sentence
tr
oral
arg
novelty
state
current
position
marked
unqualified
statement
alabama
opening
brief
reversing
shelton
suspended
sentence
alabama
ingly
vacated
probationary
term
brief
petitioner
short
alabama
developed
position
late
litigation
wrong
forum
alabama
consider
whether
suspended
sentence
alone
invalid
leaving
shelton
probation
term
freestanding
independently
effective
see
hortonville
joint
school
dist
hortonville
ed
course
bound
accept
interpretation
state
law
highest
confine
review
ruling
alabama
made
case
presented
defendant
receives
suspended
probated
sentence
imprisonment
constitutional
right
counsel
app
emphasis
added
see
brief
petitioner
find
infirmity
holding
satisfied
shelton
entitled
appointed
counsel
critical
stage
guilt
innocence
charged
crime
decided
vulnerability
imprisonment
determined
affirm
judgment
alabama
ordered
alabama
petitioner
lereed
shelton
writ
certiorari
alabama
may
justice
scalia
chief
justice
justice
kennedy
justice
thomas
join
dissenting
argersinger
hamlin
held
absent
knowing
intelligent
waiver
person
may
imprisoned
offense
unless
represented
counsel
trial
emphasis
added
although
said
run
misdemeanors
affected
rule
end
actual
deprivation
person
liberty
accused
receive
benefit
appointed
counsel
emphasis
added
affirmed
rule
scott
illinois
drawing
bright
line
imprisonment
mere
threat
imprisonment
central
premise
argersinger
actual
imprisonment
penalty
different
kind
fines
mere
threat
imprisonment
eminently
sound
warrants
adoption
actual
imprisonment
line
defining
constitutional
right
appointment
counsel
emphasis
added
repeatedly
emphasized
actual
imprisonment
touchstone
entitlement
appointed
counsel
see
glover
amount
actual
jail
time
sixth
amendment
significance
emphasis
added
right
appointed
counsel
extend
nonfelony
trials
term
imprisonment
actually
imposed
emphasis
added
lassiter
department
social
servs
durham
refused
extend
right
appointed
counsel
include
prosecutions
though
criminal
result
defendant
loss
personal
liberty
emphasis
added
today
decision
ignores
long
consistent
jurisprudence
extending
misdemeanor
right
counsel
cases
bearing
mere
threat
imprisonment
respondent
suspended
sentence
accompanying
term
probation
invalidated
lack
appointed
counsel
even
though
respondent
suffered
may
never
suffer
deprivation
liberty
holds
suspended
sentence
violates
respondent
sixth
amendment
right
counsel
may
end
actual
deprivation
respondent
liberty
ante
emphasis
added
someday
violates
terms
probation
determines
violation
merits
revocation
probation
code
determines
punishment
adequately
protect
community
criminal
activity
avoid
depreciating
seriousness
violation
contingencies
must
yet
added
decision
makes
sense
element
rank
speculation
contingencies
occur
speculates
alabama
mechanically
apply
decisional
law
applicable
routine
probation
revocation
establishes
procedures
finds
inadequate
rather
adopt
special
procedures
situations
raise
constitutional
questions
light
argersinger
scott
ante
miraculously
divined
alabama
justices
resolve
constitutional
question
one
us
business
offering
advisory
opinion
answer
asked
decide
whether
imposition
suspended
conditional
sentence
misdemeanor
case
invoke
defendant
sixth
amendment
right
counsel
pet
cert
since
imposition
suspended
sentence
deprive
defendant
personal
liberty
answer
question
plainly
future
state
alabama
seeks
imprison
respondent
previously
suspended
sentence
ask
whether
procedural
safeguards
attending
imposition
sentence
comply
constitution
question
us
given
longstanding
refusal
issue
advisory
opinions
hayburn
case
dall
particularly
respect
constitutional
questions
seek
avoid
even
opinions
ashwander
tva
brandeis
concurring
amazed
conclusion
makes
little
sense
limit
today
decision
question
presented
constitutionality
imposing
suspended
sentence
uncounseled
misdemeanants
avoid
question
presented
constitutionality
procedures
precede
activation
ante
although
one
point
purports
limit
decision
suspended
sentences
imposed
uncounseled
misdemeanants
like
alabama
offer
minimal
procedures
probation
revocation
hearings
see
ante
text
today
opinion
repudiates
limitation
answering
question
asked
amicus
address
whether
sixth
amendment
permit
activation
suspended
sentence
upon
defendant
violation
terms
probation
without
qualification
ante
thus
says
doubt
procedures
attending
reimposition
suspended
sentence
satisfy
sixth
amendment
ante
must
using
doubt
euphemism
certitude
basis
moreover
doubt
surely
procedures
attending
reimposition
suspended
sentence
adequate
required
upon
defendant
request
complete
retrial
misdemeanor
violation
assistance
counsel
right
deprive
state
option
may
well
sensible
option
since
defendants
induced
comply
terms
probation
mere
threat
retrial
send
jail
since
expense
rare
counseled
retrials
may
much
less
expense
providing
counsel
initially
misdemeanor
cases
bear
possible
sentence
imprisonment
may
well
cases
even
procedures
short
complete
retrial
prior
opinions
placed
considerable
weight
practical
consequences
expanding
right
appointed
counsel
beyond
cases
actual
imprisonment
see
scott
extension
argersinger
impose
unpredictable
necessarily
substantial
costs
quite
diverse
see
also
argersinger
powell
concurring
result
today
gives
consideration
back
hand
observation
already
appoint
counsel
defendants
like
respondent
ante
interesting
quite
irrelevant
since
today
holding
confined
defendants
like
respondent
appointed
counsel
must
henceforth
offered
defendant
awarded
suspended
sentence
matter
short
announced
rule
thus
decision
imposes
large
new
burden
majority
including
poorest
alabama
arkansas
mississippi
see
census
bureau
statistical
abstract
burden
consists
cost
providing
counsel
cases
insignificance
even
financially
prosperous
defendants
sometimes
forgo
expense
hired
counsel
also
cost
enabling
courts
prosecutors
respond
minor
cases
see
argersinger
supra
powell
concurring
result
discount
burden
placed
minority
currently
provide
counsel
keep
current
disposition
forever
place
however
imprudent
experience
proves
today
imposition
upon
finds
justification
neither
text
constitution
settled
practices
people
prior
jurisprudence
respectfully
dissent
footnotes
shelton
also
appealed
number
grounds
criminal
appeals
rejected
one
challenges
concluding
procedurally
defaulted
trial
see
app
one
challenge
remanded
proceedings
affirmed
trial
ruled
shelton
remand
justice
maddox
dissented
stating
shelton
constitutionally
entitled
counsel
received
suspended
sentence
incarcerated
app
judge
maddox
also
construed
trial
record
establishing
shelton
waiver
right
appointed
counsel
might
enjoyed
ibid
shelton
also
urges
overrule
argersinger
hamlin
scott
illinois
extent
cases
guarantee
right
counsel
cases
imprisonment
authorized
penalty
brief
respondent
entertain
contention
shelton
first
raised
brief
merits
normally
expect
notice
intent
make
argument
respondent
opposition
petition
certiorari
cf
rule
thereby
assuring
adequate
preparation
time
likely
affected
wishing
participate
south
central
bell
telephone
alabama
charles
fried
member
bar
accepted
invitation
well
fulfilled
assigned
responsibility
event
dissent
simply
incorrect
decision
today
effectively
deprive
state
th
option
placing
uncounseled
defendant
probation
incarceration
conditioned
guilty
verdict
following
trial
de
novo
post
option
functional
equivalent
pretrial
probation
entertain
constitutional
doubt
see
infra
regarding
dissent
suggestion
means
retesting
assistance
counsel
validity
original
conviction
might
suffice
post
doubt
providing
counsel
critical
guilt
adjudication
stage
much
help
defendant
die
usually
cast
judgment
entered
uncounseled
trial
record
argersinger
burger
concurring
result
large
number
misdemeanor
convictions
take
place
police
justice
courts
courts
record
without
drastic
change
procedures
courts
way
defendant
demonstrate
error
original
proceeding
reconstruct
evidence
lost
intervening
period
nichols
need
decide
whether
procedural
safeguards
short
complete
retrial
probation
revocation
stage
satisfy
sixth
amendment
post
minimal
procedures
alabama
provide
plainly
insufficient
charging
miraculously
divined
alabama
justices
resolve
constitutional
question
post
dissent
forgets
case
writ
certiorari
alabama
ruled
decision
review
shelton
sentence
violates
sixth
amendment
alabama
thus
already
spoken
issue
address
expressed
slightest
hint
stage
procedures
real
imaginary
affect
constitutional
calculus
see
stat
ann
state
hermanns
super
stat
stat
tit
see
alexander
anchorage
alaska
interpreting
alaska
art
provide
counsel
punishment
may
involve
incarceration
tracy
municipal
glendale
judicial
cal
cal
penal
code
ann
west
affords
counsel
misdemeanor
defendants
del
code
tit
code
ann
haw
rev
stat
comp
ch
brunson
state
ind
app
right
counsel
misdemeanor
proceedings
guaranteed
ind
art
rev
stat
ann
la
art
mass
rule
crim
proc
rule
crim
proc
neb
rev
stat
crim
proc
law
okla
tit
supp
rev
stat
ann
supp
sup
rule
tex
crim
proc
code
ann
supp
code
ann
super
crim
rule
code
stat
wyo
stat
ann
see
idaho
code
iowa
rule
crim
proc
wright
denato
iowa
md
ann
code
art
supp
rev
stat
rev
stat
ann
iv
supp
stat
ann
ohio
rules
crim
proc
rule
crim
proc
cons
stat
codified
laws
see
also
stat
supp
imposition
suspended
sentence
incarceration
period
probation
necessitates
appointment
counsel
ten
majority
provide
counsel
every
defendant
receives
suspended
sentence
hardly
supports
dissent
dire
predictions
practical
consequences
today
decision
see
post
circumstances
currently
allow
prosecution
misdemeanors
without
appointed
counsel
quite
narrow
pennsylvania
example
defendants
charged
misdemeanors
enjoy
right
counsel
regardless
sentence
imposed
rule
crim
proc
charged
summary
offenses
violations
technically
considered
crimes
punishable
days
imprisonment
cons
stat
may
receive
suspended
sentence
uncounseled
rule
crim
proc
commonwealth
thomas
typical
summary
offenses
pennsylvania
include
failure
return
library
book
within
days
cons
stat
fishing
sunday
cons
stat
gaps
misdemeanor
defendant
right
appointed
counsel
extend
protection
beyond
sixth
amendment
similarly
slight
see
codified
laws
defendant
charged
misdemeanor
enjoys
absolute
right
appointed
counsel
unless
offense
punishable
days
imprisonment
tex
crim
proc
code
ann
supp
counsel
must
appointed
misdemeanor
defendants
except
tried
judge
knows
sentence
include
imprisonment
typical
situation
results
suspended
sentence
think
case
like
shelton
prosecution
jury
assault
arising
fistfight
followed
minor
traffic
accident
see
app
far
quite
irrelevant
post
already
provide
attorney
situation
strongly
suggests
added
requirement
providing
counsel
routinely
suspended
sentence
cases
prove
unduly
onerous
device
conditioned
defendant
consent
raise
question
whether
imposition
probation
alone
restrains
defendant
liberty
require
provision
appointed
counsel
see
brief
national
association
criminal
defense
lawyers
amicus
curiae
cf
brief
respondent
thus
one
significant
difference
pretrial
probation
sensible
option
urged
dissent
complete
retrial
misdemeanor
violation
assistance
counsel
upon
defendant
violation
probation
terms
post
pretrial
probation
substantially
less
expensive
permits
incarceration
single
trial
whereas
dissent
regime
requires
two
one
without
counsel
place
defendant
probation
second
counsel
trigger
imprisonment
reply
brief
state
convey
comprehends
argersinger
scott
possibility
shelton
suspended
sentence
activated
violates
terms
probation
reply
brief
alabama
state
position
coincided
position
argued
amicus
see
state
brief
argument
petition
writ
certiorari
alabama
criminal
appeals
state
brief
argument
support
application
rehearing
sup
footnotes
says
alabama
already
resolved
question
since
finding
respondent
sentence
violated
sixth
amendment
expressed
slightest
hint
procedures
affect
constitutional
calculus
ante
indeed
precisely
error
answer
consider
question
whether
procedures
attending
probation
revocation
proceeding
cure
absence
counsel
trial
asserts
pretrial
probation
opinion
permits
functional
equivalent
probation
later
retrial
suspended
sentence
activated
even
see
basis
forcing
state
employ
one
functional
equivalent
rather
fact
nothing
implausible
speculation
support
proposition
pretrial
probation
yiel
similar
result
ante
certainly
curious
coincidence
inasmuch
pretrial
probation
quite
different
purpose
conserving
prosecutorial
judicial
resources
forgoing
trial
see
dept
justice
attorneys
manual
abadinsky
probation
parole
theory
practice
ed
pretrial
probation
programs
use
fact
arrest
occurred
means
identifying
defendants
need
treatment
least
need
criminal
prosecution
moreover
pretrial
probation
generally
available
minor
offenses
app
reply
brief
national
association
criminal
defense
lawyers
amicus
curiae
available
alabama
also
employ
probation
thesis
functional
equivalent
probation
true
expect
see
pretrial
probation
used
major
minor
crimes
see
used
place
addition
probation
quotes
chief
justice
burger
concurrence
argersinger
support
doubt
providing
counsel
critical
guilt
adjudication
stage
much
help
defendant
die
usually
cast
judgment
entered
uncounseled
trial
record
argersinger
hamlin
ante
passage
addressing
limited
benefits
ppeal
conviction
uncounseled
trial
argersinger
supra
emphasis
added
doubtless
correct
light
uniformly
restricted
scope
appellate
review
makes
sense
transfer
chief
justice
concerns
unknown
unknowable
forms
probation
revocation
proceedings
may
provide
various
means
retesting
assistance
counsel
validity
original
conviction
notes
large
number
misdemeanor
convictions
take
place
police
justice
courts
courts
record
making
quite
difficult
defendant
demonstrate
error
original
proceeding
ante
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
entirely
irrelevant
whether
large
number
misdemeanor
convictions
take
place
police
justice
courts
matters
whether
record
available
misdemeanor
convictions
result
suspended
prison
sentence
presumably
small
fraction
misdemeanor
convictions
reliable
information
point
experience
present
case
shows
alabama
provide
record
counsel
comb
substantive
procedural
inadequacy
respondent
tried
judge
state
district
record
subsequently
exercised
right
code
trial
de
novo
jury
state
circuit
higher
record
see
ex
parte
maye
ten
cited
offer
appointed
counsel
cases
misdemeanor
defendant
might
suffer
suspended
sentence
six
guarantee
counsel
authorized
penalty
least
three
six
months
imprisonment
see
idaho
code
state
hardman
idaho
app
md
ann
code
art
rev
stat
stat
ann
state
woodruff
ohio
rules
crim
proc
cons
stat
rules
crim
proc
commonwealth
thomas
south
dakota
provide
counsel
maximum
permissible
sentence
days
imprisonment
codified
laws
concluded
defendant
deprived
liberty
convicted
texas
statute
declares
appointed
counsel
offered
defendant
charged
misdemeanor
punishable
confinement
tex
code
crim
proc
art
vernon
supp
state
courts
construed
provision
require
appointment
knows
punishment
assess
includes
imprisonment
trial
jury
possible
punishment
includes
imprisonment
fortner
state
tex
app
emphasis
added
thus
nothing
texas
law
assures
counsel
misdemeanor
bench
trial
resulting
suspended
sentence
finally
two
appoint
counsel
imprisonment
likely
imposed
courts
yet
decided
whether
likelihood
suspended
sentence
qualifies
answer
held
respect
similarly
phrased
michigan
pennsylvania
statutes
cited
supra
probably
stat
ann
rodriguez
rosenblatt
stat
state
mccoy
district
columbia
must
also
numbered
among
tions
whose
law
altered
today
decision
code
ann
guarantees
counsel
cases
person
faces
loss
liberty
constitution
law
requires
appointment
counsel
emphasis
added
today
decision
discarding
rule
argersinger
brings
suspended
sentences
within
prescription
asserts
burden
today
decision
jurisdictions
small
circumstances
currently
allow
prosecution
misdemeanors
without
appointed
counsel
quite
narrow
ante
emphasis
added
narrowness
range
circumstances
covered
says
nothing
number
cases
covered
misdemeanors
punishable
less
six
months
imprisonment
may
narrow
category
may
well
include
vast
majority
cases
precisely
minor
nature
offense
suspended
sentence
imposed
simply
nothing
support
belief
offenders
prosecuted
crimes
counsel
already
provided
minimizes
burden
pennsylvania
observing
summary
offenses
permits
uncounseled
suspended
sentences
include
rarely
prosecuted
crimes
failing
return
library
book
within
days
fishing
sunday
ante
also
include
minor
retail
theft
driving
suspended
license
harassment
includes
minor
assault
see
thomas
supra
cons
stat
supp
cons
stat
uninformed
intuition
amicus
brief
filed
include
exceptions
calls
narrow
affirming
rule
adopted
today
impose
significant
burdens
brief
texas
ohio
montana
nebraska
delaware
louisiana
virginia
amici
curiae