yates
argued
november
decided
february
conducting
offshore
inspection
commercial
fishing
vessel
gulf
mexico
federal
agent
found
ship
catch
contained
undersized
red
grouper
violation
federal
conservation
regulations
officer
instructed
ship
captain
petitioner
yates
keep
undersized
fish
segregated
rest
catch
ship
returned
port
officer
departed
yates
instead
told
crew
member
throw
undersized
fish
overboard
offense
yates
charged
destroying
concealing
covering
undersized
fish
impede
federal
investigation
violation
section
provides
person
may
fined
imprisoned
years
knowingly
alters
destroys
mutilates
conceals
covers
falsifies
makes
false
entry
record
document
tangible
object
intent
impede
obstruct
influence
federal
investigation
trial
yates
moved
judgment
acquittal
charge
pointing
origin
provision
act
law
designed
protect
investors
restore
trust
financial
markets
following
collapse
enron
corporation
yates
argued
reference
tangible
object
subsumes
objects
used
store
information
computer
hard
drives
fish
district
denied
yates
motion
jury
found
guilty
violating
eleventh
circuit
affirmed
conviction
concluding
applies
destruction
concealment
fish
objects
physical
form
fish
fall
within
dictionary
definition
tangible
object
held
judgment
reversed
case
remanded
reversed
remanded
justice
ginsburg
joined
chief
justice
justice
breyer
justice
sotomayor
concluded
tangible
object
within
compass
one
used
record
preserve
information
pp
although
dictionary
definitions
words
tangible
object
bear
consideration
determining
meaning
tangible
object
dispositive
whether
statutory
term
unambiguous
determined
reference
language
also
specific
context
language
used
broader
context
statute
whole
robinson
shell
oil
identical
language
may
convey
varying
content
used
different
statutes
sometimes
even
different
provisions
statute
see
faa
cooper
pp
familiar
interpretive
guides
aid
construction
tangible
object
though
commanding
heading
destruction
alteration
falsification
records
federal
investigations
bankruptcy
conveys
suggestion
section
prohibits
spoliation
physical
evidence
however
remote
records
section
position
within
title
chapter
signals
intended
serve
ban
destruction
physical
evidence
congress
placed
end
chapter
following
immediately
specialized
provisions
expressly
aimed
corporate
fraud
financial
audits
contemporaneous
passage
prohibits
person
alter
ing
destroy
ing
mutilat
ing
conceal
ing
record
document
object
intent
impair
object
integrity
availability
use
official
proceeding
also
instructive
government
argues
reference
object
includes
every
physical
object
reference
tangible
object
already
included
physical
objects
government
also
contends
congress
reason
enact
section
read
render
superfluous
entire
provision
passed
proximity
part
act
see
marx
general
revenue
words
immediately
surrounding
tangible
object
falsifies
makes
false
entry
record
document
also
cabin
contextual
meaning
term
applying
canons
noscitur
sociis
ejusdem
generis
tangible
object
last
list
terms
begins
record
document
appropriately
read
refer
tangible
object
specifically
subset
tangible
objects
used
record
preserve
information
moderate
interpretation
accords
list
actions
proscribes
verbs
falsif
mak
false
entry
typically
take
grammatical
objects
records
documents
things
used
record
preserve
information
logbooks
hard
drives
see
gustafson
alloyd
use
traditional
tools
statutory
interpretation
examine
markers
congressional
intent
within
act
thus
call
rejection
aggressive
interpretation
tangible
object
furthermore
meaning
record
document
thing
provision
model
penal
code
mpc
interpreted
prohibit
tampering
kind
physical
evidence
reliable
indicator
meaning
congress
assigned
record
document
tangible
object
significant
differences
offense
described
mpc
provision
offense
created
pp
finally
recourse
traditional
tools
statutory
construction
leaves
doubt
meaning
tangible
object
appropriate
invoke
rule
lenity
pp
justice
alito
concluded
traditional
rules
statutory
construction
confirm
yates
better
argument
title
list
nouns
list
verbs
title
combined
tip
case
favor
yates
applying
canons
noscitur
sociis
ejusdem
generis
list
nouns
record
document
tangible
object
term
tangible
object
refer
something
similar
records
documents
many
verbs
alters
destroys
mutilates
conceals
covers
falsifies
makes
false
entry
apply
nouns
salamanders
sand
dunes
term
makes
false
entry
makes
sense
outside
filekeeping
finally
title
destruction
alteration
falsification
records
federal
investigations
bankruptcy
also
points
toward
filekeeping
rather
fish
pp
ginsburg
announced
judgment
delivered
opinion
roberts
breyer
sotomayor
joined
alito
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
kagan
filed
dissenting
opinion
scalia
kennedy
thomas
joined
opinion
ginsburg
notice
opinion
subject
formal
revision
publication
preliminary
print
reports
readers
requested
notify
reporter
decisions
washington
typographical
formal
errors
order
corrections
may
made
preliminary
print
goes
press
john
yates
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
eleventh
circuit
february
justice
ginsburg
announced
judgment
delivered
opinion
chief
justice
justice
breyer
justice
sotomayor
join
john
yates
commercial
fisherman
caught
undersized
red
grouper
federal
waters
gulf
mexico
prevent
federal
authorities
confirming
harvested
undersized
fish
yates
ordered
crew
member
toss
suspect
catch
sea
offense
charged
convicted
violating
provides
whoever
knowingly
alters
destroys
mutilates
conceals
covers
falsifies
makes
false
entry
record
document
tangible
object
intent
impede
obstruct
influence
investigation
proper
administration
matter
within
jurisdiction
department
agency
case
filed
title
relation
contemplation
matter
case
shall
fined
title
imprisoned
years
yates
also
indicted
convicted
provides
destruction
removal
property
prevent
whoever
search
seizure
property
person
authorized
make
search
seizure
knowingly
destroys
damages
wastes
disposes
transfers
otherwise
takes
action
knowingly
attempts
destroy
damage
waste
dispose
transfer
otherwise
take
action
purpose
preventing
impairing
government
lawful
authority
take
property
custody
control
continue
holding
property
lawful
custody
control
shall
fined
title
imprisoned
years
yates
contest
conviction
violating
maintains
fish
trapped
within
term
tangible
object
term
used
section
enacted
part
act
stat
legislation
designed
protect
investors
restore
trust
financial
markets
following
collapse
enron
corporation
fish
doubt
object
tangible
fish
seen
caught
handled
catch
case
illustrates
vulnerable
destruction
cut
loose
mooring
hold
encompasses
objects
whatever
size
significance
destroyed
obstructive
intent
mindful
congress
trained
attention
corporate
accounting
deception
conclude
matching
construction
order
tangible
object
captured
hold
must
one
used
record
preserve
information
august
miss
katie
commercial
fishing
boat
six
days
expedition
gulf
mexico
crew
numbered
three
including
yates
captain
engaged
routine
offshore
patrol
inspect
recreational
commercial
vessels
officer
john
jones
florida
fish
wildlife
conservation
commission
decided
board
miss
katie
check
vessel
compliance
fishing
rules
although
miss
katie
far
enough
florida
coast
exclusively
federal
waters
nevertheless
within
officer
jones
jurisdiction
deputized
federal
agent
national
marine
fisheries
service
officer
jones
authority
enforce
federal
well
state
fishing
laws
upon
boarding
miss
katie
officer
jones
noticed
three
red
grouper
appeared
undersized
hanging
hook
deck
time
federal
conservation
regulations
required
immediate
release
red
grouper
less
inches
long
cfr
ii
effective
april
violation
regulations
civil
offense
punishable
fine
fishing
license
suspension
see
suspecting
undersized
fish
might
board
officer
jones
proceeded
inspect
ship
catch
setting
aside
measuring
fish
appeared
shorter
inches
officer
jones
ultimately
determined
fish
fell
short
mark
fellow
officer
recorded
length
undersized
fish
catch
measurement
verification
form
exceptions
measured
fish
inches
three
less
inches
none
less
inches
separating
fish
measuring
inches
rest
catch
placing
wooden
crates
officer
jones
directed
yates
leave
fish
thus
segregated
crates
miss
katie
returned
port
departing
officer
jones
issued
yates
citation
possession
undersized
fish
four
days
later
miss
katie
docked
cortez
florida
officer
jones
measured
fish
contained
wooden
crates
time
however
measured
fish
although
still
less
inches
slightly
exceeded
lengths
recorded
board
jones
surmised
fish
brought
port
detected
initial
inspection
questioning
one
crew
members
admitted
yates
direction
thrown
overboard
fish
officer
jones
measured
sea
yates
replaced
tossed
grouper
fish
rest
catch
reasons
disclosed
record
us
months
passed
criminal
charges
lodged
yates
may
indicted
destroying
property
prevent
federal
seizure
violation
destroying
concealing
covering
undersized
fish
impede
federal
investigation
violation
time
indictment
minimum
legal
length
gulf
red
grouper
lowered
inches
inches
see
cfr
iv
effective
may
measured
fish
yates
catch
fell
limit
record
reveal
civil
penalty
yates
received
possession
fish
undersized
regulation
see
yates
tried
criminal
charges
august
end
government
case
chief
moved
judgment
acquittal
charge
pointing
title
origin
provision
act
yates
argued
section
sets
forth
documents
offense
reference
tangible
object
subsumes
computer
hard
drives
logbooks
things
nature
fish
app
yates
acknowledged
criminal
code
contains
sections
appropriate
overnment
pursue
wished
prosecute
tampering
evidence
app
section
set
supra
fit
description
yates
insisted
government
countered
tangible
object
within
compass
simply
something
document
record
app
trial
judge
expressed
misgivings
reading
tangible
object
broadly
government
urged
latin
phrase
construction
statute
gist
take
look
line
words
interpret
words
consistently
talking
documents
records
tangible
objects
tangible
objects
nature
document
record
opposed
fish
ibid
judge
nonetheless
followed
controlling
eleventh
circuit
precedent
recognizing
passed
part
legislation
targeting
corporate
fraud
appeals
instructed
broad
language
limited
corporate
fraud
cases
free
pass
laws
language
covering
areas
well
beyond
particular
crisis
du
jour
initially
prompted
legislative
action
md
app
quoting
hunt
accordingly
trial
read
tangible
object
term
independent
record
document
app
violating
sentenced
yates
imprisonment
days
followed
supervised
release
three
years
app
life
bear
stigma
federal
felony
conviction
appeal
eleventh
circuit
found
text
plain
tangible
object
undefined
statute
appeals
gave
term
ordinary
natural
meaning
dictionary
definition
aving
possessing
physical
form
ibid
quoting
black
law
dictionary
ed
granted
certiorari
reverse
eleventh
circuit
judgment
ii
act
agree
prompted
exposure
enron
massive
accounting
fraud
revelations
company
outside
auditor
arthur
andersen
llp
systematically
destroyed
potentially
incriminating
documents
government
acknowledges
intended
prohibit
particular
corporate
hide
evidence
financial
wrongdoing
brief
prior
law
made
offense
intimidat
threate
corruptly
persuad
another
person
shred
documents
emphasis
added
section
cured
conspicuous
omission
imposing
liability
person
destroys
records
see
describing
new
general
anti
shredding
provision
explaining
certain
current
provisions
make
crime
persuade
another
person
destroy
documents
crime
actually
destroy
documents
new
section
also
expanded
prior
law
including
within
provision
reach
matter
within
jurisdiction
department
agency
government
view
extends
beyond
principal
evil
motivating
passage
words
government
argues
support
reading
provision
general
ban
spoliation
evidence
covering
physical
items
might
relevant
matter
federal
investigation
yates
urges
contextual
reading
tying
tangible
object
surrounding
words
placement
provision
within
act
related
provisions
enacted
time
particular
see
infra
section
maintains
targets
manner
evidence
records
documents
tangible
objects
used
preserve
computers
servers
media
information
stored
agree
yates
reject
government
unrestrained
reading
tangible
object
conclude
better
read
cover
objects
one
use
record
preserve
information
objects
physical
world
ordinary
meaning
object
tangible
stated
dictionary
definitions
discrete
thing
webster
third
new
international
dictionary
possess
es
physical
form
black
law
dictionary
ed
premise
government
concludes
tangible
object
term
appears
covers
waterfront
including
fish
sea
whether
statutory
term
unambiguous
however
turn
solely
dictionary
definitions
component
words
rather
plainness
ambiguity
statutory
language
determined
reference
language
well
specific
context
language
used
broader
context
statute
whole
robinson
shell
oil
see
also
deal
fundamental
principle
statutory
construction
indeed
language
meaning
word
determined
isolation
must
drawn
context
used
ordinarily
word
usage
accords
dictionary
definition
law
life
however
words
placed
different
contexts
sometimes
mean
different
things
several
times
affirmed
identical
language
may
convey
varying
content
used
different
statutes
sometimes
even
different
provisions
statute
see
faa
cooper
slip
actual
damages
different
meanings
different
statutes
wachovia
bank
schmidt
located
different
meanings
different
provisions
national
bank
act
general
dynamics
land
systems
cline
age
different
meanings
different
provisions
age
discrimination
employment
act
cleveland
indians
baseball
wages
paid
different
meanings
different
provisions
title
robinson
employee
different
meanings
different
sections
title
vii
civil
rights
act
merrell
dow
pharmaceuticals
thompson
arising
different
meanings
art
iii
district
columbia
carter
state
territory
different
meanings
atlantic
cleaners
dyers
trade
commerce
different
meanings
different
sections
sherman
act
observed
atlantic
cleaners
dyers
words
different
shades
meaning
consequently
may
variously
construed
subject
matter
words
refer
several
places
words
used
conditions
different
scope
legislative
power
exercised
one
case
broader
exercised
another
meaning
well
may
vary
meet
purposes
law
arrived
consideration
language
purposes
expressed
circumstances
language
employed
short
although
dictionary
definitions
words
tangible
object
bear
consideration
dispositive
meaning
tangible
object
supporting
reading
tangible
object
used
accord
dictionary
definitions
government
points
appearance
term
federal
rule
criminal
procedure
rule
requires
prosecution
grant
defendant
request
inspect
tangible
objects
within
government
control
utility
defense
see
fed
rule
crim
proc
rule
reference
tangible
objects
interpreted
include
physical
evidence
see
lafave
israel
king
kerr
criminal
procedure
pp
ed
rule
discovery
rule
designed
protect
defendants
compelling
prosecution
turn
defense
evidence
material
charges
issue
context
comprehensive
construction
tangible
objects
fitting
contrast
penal
provision
refers
tangible
object
relation
request
information
relevant
specific
proceeding
rather
relation
federal
investigations
proceedings
every
kind
including
yet
see
commissioner
national
carbide
hand
words
chameleons
reflect
color
environment
context
rule
supports
giving
tangible
object
meaning
broad
dictionary
definition
context
tugs
strongly
favor
narrower
reading
familiar
interpretive
guides
aid
construction
words
tangible
object
appear
note
first
caption
destruction
alteration
falsification
records
federal
investigations
bankruptcy
heading
conveys
suggestion
section
prohibits
spoliation
physical
evidence
however
remote
records
neither
title
section
act
placed
criminal
penalties
altering
documents
stat
furthermore
provision
passed
part
titled
destruction
corporate
audit
records
addresses
specific
subset
records
documents
headings
commanding
supply
cues
congress
intend
tangible
object
sweep
within
reach
physical
objects
every
kind
including
things
one
describe
records
documents
devices
closely
associated
see
title
statute
heading
section
tools
available
resolution
doubt
meaning
statute
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
congress
indeed
meant
make
ban
spoliation
evidence
dissent
believes
congress
one
expected
clearer
indication
intent
section
position
within
chapter
title
signals
intended
serve
ban
destruction
physical
evidence
every
kind
congress
placed
companion
provision
end
chapter
following
immediately
prohibiting
obstructive
acts
specific
contexts
see
audits
recipients
federal
funds
federal
examinations
financial
institutions
criminal
investigations
federal
health
care
offenses
see
also
observing
apply
obstruction
certain
limited
types
cases
bankruptcy
fraud
examinations
financial
institutions
healthcare
fraud
congress
direct
codification
act
additions
chapter
adjacent
specialized
provisions
instead
congress
directed
placement
additions
within
alongside
retained
provisions
address
obstructive
acts
relating
broadly
official
proceedings
criminal
trials
section
civil
action
protect
retaliation
fraud
cases
codified
inserted
addresses
civil
actions
restrain
harassment
victims
witnesses
criminal
cases
defines
terms
used
section
tampering
record
otherwise
impeding
official
proceeding
codified
inserted
within
addresses
tampering
victim
witness
informant
impede
official
proceeding
section
retaliation
informants
codified
inserted
within
addresses
retaliation
victim
witness
informant
official
proceeding
congress
thus
ranked
among
broad
proscriptions
together
specialized
provisions
expressly
aimed
corporate
fraud
financial
audits
placement
accords
view
congress
conception
coverage
considerably
limited
contemporaneous
passage
contained
section
act
discrete
section
embracing
also
instructive
section
provides
whoever
corruptly
alters
destroys
mutilates
conceals
record
document
object
attempts
intent
impair
object
integrity
availability
use
official
proceeding
shall
fined
title
imprisoned
years
legislative
history
reveals
drafted
proposed
see
cong
rec
government
argues
yates
dispute
reference
object
includes
every
physical
object
reference
tangible
object
already
included
physical
objects
government
dissent
contend
congress
reason
enact
virtually
act
violate
doubt
violate
well
applies
investigation
proper
administration
matter
within
jurisdiction
department
agency
relation
contemplation
matter
official
proceeding
government
acknowledges
reading
significantly
overlap
brief
nowhere
government
explain
independent
function
serve
government
right
sweeping
scope
resist
reading
render
superfluous
entire
provision
passed
proximity
part
see
marx
general
revenue
slip
canon
surplusage
strongest
interpretation
render
superfluous
another
part
statutory
words
immediately
surrounding
tangible
object
falsifies
makes
false
entry
record
document
also
cabin
contextual
meaning
term
explained
gustafson
alloyd
rely
principle
noscitur
sociis
word
known
company
keeps
avoid
ascribing
one
word
meaning
broad
inconsistent
accompanying
words
thus
giving
unintended
breadth
acts
congress
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
see
also
williams
word
given
precise
content
neighboring
words
associated
gustafson
interpreted
word
communication
securities
act
refer
public
communication
rather
communication
word
appeared
list
words
notably
notice
circular
advertisement
making
apparent
list
refer
red
documents
wide
dissemination
even
though
list
began
word
noscitur
sociis
canon
operates
similar
manner
tangible
object
last
list
terms
begins
record
document
term
therefore
appropriately
read
refer
tangible
object
specifically
subset
tangible
objects
involving
records
documents
objects
used
record
preserve
information
see
sentencing
commission
guidelines
manual
documents
tangible
objects
includes
records
documents
tangible
objects
stored
magnetic
optical
digital
electronic
storage
mediums
devices
wire
electronic
moderate
interpretation
tangible
object
accords
list
actions
proscribes
section
applies
anyone
alters
destroys
mutilates
conceals
covers
falsifies
makes
false
entry
record
document
tangible
object
requisite
obstructive
intent
emphasis
added
last
two
verbs
falsif
mak
false
entry
typically
take
grammatical
objects
records
documents
things
used
record
preserve
information
logbooks
hard
drives
see
black
law
dictionary
ed
defining
falsify
make
deceptive
counterfeit
forge
misrepresent
tamper
document
record
unnatural
example
describe
killer
act
wiping
fingerprints
gun
falsifying
murder
weapon
strange
refer
falsifying
data
stored
hard
drive
simply
falsifying
hard
drive
furthermore
congress
include
list
prohibited
actions
falsifies
makes
false
entry
see
making
unlawful
alte
destro
mutilat
concea
record
document
object
requisite
obstructive
intent
contemporaneous
omission
also
suggests
congress
intended
tangible
object
narrower
scope
object
canon
related
noscitur
sociis
ejusdem
generis
counsels
general
words
follow
specific
words
statutory
enumeration
general
words
usually
construed
embrace
objects
similar
nature
objects
enumerated
preceding
specific
words
washington
state
dept
social
health
servs
guardianship
estate
keffeler
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
begay
example
relied
principle
determine
crimes
covered
statutory
phrase
crime
burglary
arson
extortion
involves
use
explosives
otherwise
involves
conduct
presents
serious
potential
risk
physical
injury
another
ii
enumeration
specific
crimes
explained
indicates
otherwise
involves
provision
covers
similar
crimes
rather
every
crime
serious
potential
risk
physical
injury
another
congress
intended
latter
encompassing
meaning
observed
hard
see
needed
include
examples
ibid
see
also
csx
alabama
dept
revenue
slip
typically
use
ejusdem
generis
ensure
general
word
render
specific
words
congress
intended
tangible
object
interpreted
generically
capture
physical
objects
dissimilar
documents
fish
congress
reason
refer
specifically
record
document
government
unbounded
reading
tangible
object
render
words
misleading
surplusage
used
traditional
tools
statutory
interpretation
examine
markers
congressional
intent
within
act
persuaded
aggressive
interpretation
tangible
object
must
rejected
highly
improbable
congress
buried
general
spoliation
statute
covering
objects
every
kind
provision
targeting
fraud
financial
government
argues
however
inquiry
incomplete
failed
consider
origins
phrase
record
document
tangible
object
congress
drew
phrase
government
says
model
penal
code
mpc
provision
reform
proposals
based
provision
mpc
provision
proposals
prompted
imposed
liability
anyone
alters
destroys
mutilates
conceals
removes
record
document
thing
see
ali
mpc
proscriptions
understood
refer
physical
evidence
see
mpc
comment
provision
applies
physical
object
accordingly
government
reasons
dissent
exuberantly
agrees
post
congress
must
intended
apply
universe
physical
evidence
inference
unwarranted
true
mpc
provision
prohibited
tampering
kind
physical
evidence
unlike
mpc
provision
prohibit
actions
specifically
relate
records
documents
objects
used
record
preserve
information
mpc
provision
also
ranked
offense
misdemeanor
limited
liability
instances
actor
believ
es
official
proceeding
investigation
pending
instituted
mpc
yates
scant
reason
anticipate
felony
prosecution
certainly
one
instituted
time
even
smallest
fish
caught
came
within
legal
limit
see
supra
cf
bond
slip
rejecting
boundless
reading
statutory
term
given
deeply
serious
consequences
reading
entail
proposed
federal
offense
line
mpc
provision
advanced
federal
commission
similarly
qualified
see
final
report
national
commission
reform
federal
criminal
laws
pp
section
conspicuously
lacks
limits
built
mpc
provision
federal
proposal
describes
misdemeanor
felony
punishable
years
prison
section
covers
conduct
intended
impede
federal
investigation
proceeding
including
one
even
verge
commencement
given
significant
differences
meaning
record
document
thing
mpc
provision
kindred
proposal
reliable
indicator
meaning
congress
assigned
record
document
tangible
object
mpc
provision
short
tells
us
neither
congress
wrote
congress
wanted
cf
post
concerning
yates
small
fish
subject
federal
felony
prosecution
finally
recourse
traditional
tools
statutory
construction
leaves
doubt
meaning
tangible
object
term
used
invoke
rule
ambiguity
concerning
ambit
criminal
statutes
resolved
favor
lenity
cleveland
quoting
rewis
interpretative
principle
relevant
government
urges
reading
exposes
individuals
prison
sentences
tampering
physical
object
might
evidentiary
value
federal
investigation
offense
matter
whether
investigation
pending
merely
contemplated
whether
offense
subject
investigation
criminal
civil
see
liparota
application
rule
lenity
ensures
criminal
statutes
provide
fair
warning
concerning
conduct
rendered
illegal
strikes
appropriate
balance
legislature
prosecutor
defining
criminal
determining
meaning
tangible
object
appropriate
choose
harsher
alternative
require
congress
spoken
language
clear
definite
see
cleveland
quoting
universal
credit
see
also
jones
rule
lenity
reinforces
conclusion
arson
residence
subject
federal
prosecution
residence
qualify
property
used
commerce
activity
reasons
stated
resist
reading
expansively
create
coverall
spoliation
evidence
statute
advisable
measure
might
leaving
important
decision
congress
hold
tangible
object
within
compass
one
used
record
preserve
information
judgment
appeals
eleventh
circuit
therefore
reversed
case
remanded
proceedings
ordered
alito
concurring
judgment
john
yates
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
eleventh
circuit
february
justice
alito
concurring
judgment
case
resolved
narrow
grounds
though
question
close
traditional
tools
statutory
construction
confirm
john
yates
better
argument
three
features
stand
statute
list
nouns
list
verbs
title
although
perhaps
none
features
tip
case
favor
yates
three
combined
start
nouns
section
refers
record
document
tangible
object
noscitur
sociis
canon
instructs
statute
contains
list
word
list
presumptively
similar
meaning
see
gustafson
alloyd
related
canon
ejusdem
generis
teaches
general
words
following
list
specific
words
usually
read
light
specific
words
mean
something
similar
see
christopher
smithkline
beecham
slip
applying
canons
list
nouns
term
tangible
object
refer
something
similar
records
documents
fish
spring
mind
antelope
colonial
farmhouse
hydrofoil
oil
derrick
objects
tangible
raise
eyebrow
neighbor
asked
identify
something
similar
record
document
said
crocodile
reading
course
shortcomings
instance
imperfect
ejusdem
generis
case
record
document
quite
general
risk
tangible
object
may
made
superfluous
similar
record
document
yet
one
however
thing
see
sentencing
commission
guidelines
manual
comment
reading
records
documents
tangible
objects
includ
found
magnetic
optical
digital
electronic
storage
mediums
devices
might
document
traditionally
document
piece
paper
information
information
stored
computer
electronic
storage
device
medium
black
law
dictionary
ed
might
also
records
records
limited
minutes
formal
writings
designed
memorialize
past
events
hard
drive
however
tangible
contain
files
precisely
akin
even
narrow
definitions
record
document
read
expansively
adding
tangible
object
ensure
beyond
question
electronic
files
included
sure
tangible
object
presumably
capture
congress
enacts
catchall
known
unknowns
republic
iraq
beaty
noscitur
sociis
ejusdem
generis
apply
known
unknowns
similar
known
knowns
records
documents
especially
true
reading
tangible
object
broadly
render
record
document
superfluous
next
consider
list
verbs
alters
destroys
mutilates
conceals
covers
falsifies
makes
false
entry
although
many
verbs
apply
nouns
salamanders
satellites
sand
dunes
last
phrase
list
makes
false
entry
makes
sense
outside
filekeeping
one
make
false
entry
fish
alters
especially
falsifies
also
closely
associated
filekeeping
one
verbs
moreover
applied
filekeeping
certainly
way
makes
false
entry
always
inconsistent
aquatic
government
without
response
one
imagine
congress
trying
write
law
broadly
every
verb
lines
every
noun
failure
line
may
suggest
something
gone
awry
one
interpretation
text
statute
verbs
applies
certain
category
nouns
reason
think
congress
category
mind
categories
course
often
underinclusive
overinclusive
instance
applies
letter
bomb
mean
categories
useful
congress
enact
see
vance
bradley
focusing
verbs
category
nouns
appears
filekeeping
observation
dispositive
neither
nothing
government
also
contends
verbs
cut
ways
unnatural
apply
falsifies
tangible
objects
certainly
true
one
falsify
outside
casing
hard
drive
one
falsify
alter
data
physically
recorded
hard
drive
finally
analysis
influenced
title
destruction
alteration
falsification
records
federal
investigations
bankruptcy
emphasis
added
points
toward
filekeeping
fish
titles
useful
devices
resolve
meaning
statute
porter
nussle
quoting
see
also
lawson
fmr
llc
sotomayor
dissenting
slip
title
especially
valuable
reinforces
text
nouns
verbs
independently
suggest
matter
statutes
might
read
particular
one
cover
every
noun
universe
tangible
form
titles
course
also
dispositive
list
nouns
already
suggest
tangible
object
mean
something
similar
records
documents
especially
read
conjunction
peculiar
list
verbs
focus
filekeeping
title
enough
conjunction
two
textual
features
however
government
argument
though
colorable
becomes
implausible
accept
see
washington
state
dept
social
health
servs
guardianship
estate
keffeler
focusing
product
two
canons
construction
confirmed
interpretative
evidence
cf
obama
cadc
aggregating
evidence
kagan
dissenting
john
yates
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
eleventh
circuit
february
justice
kagan
justice
scalia
justice
kennedy
justice
thomas
join
dissenting
criminal
law
prohibits
tampering
record
document
tangible
object
attempt
obstruct
federal
investigation
case
raises
question
whether
term
tangible
object
means
thing
means
everyday
language
object
capable
touched
answer
easy
yes
term
tangible
object
broad
clear
throughout
code
many
laws
invariably
covers
physical
objects
kinds
context
confirms
bare
text
says
words
surrounding
tangible
object
show
congress
meant
term
wide
range
fits
congress
evident
purpose
enacting
punish
alter
destroy
physical
evidence
physical
evidence
intent
thwarting
federal
law
enforcement
plurality
instead
interprets
tangible
object
cover
objects
one
use
record
preserve
information
ante
concurring
opinion
similarly
vaguely
contends
tangible
object
refer
something
similar
records
documents
include
colonial
farmhouses
crocodiles
fish
ante
alito
concurring
judgment
view
conventional
tools
statutory
construction
lead
conventional
result
tangible
object
object
tangible
apply
statute
congress
enacted
affirm
judgment
plurality
starts
analysis
heading
see
ante
note
first
caption
begin
text
congress
supplied
definition
generally
give
statutory
term
ordinary
meaning
see
schindler
elevator
ex
rel
kirk
slip
plurality
must
acknowledge
ordinary
meaning
tangible
object
discrete
thing
possesses
physical
form
ante
punctuation
citation
omitted
fish
course
discrete
thing
possesses
physical
form
see
generally
seuss
one
fish
two
fish
red
fish
blue
fish
ordinary
meaning
term
tangible
object
one
disputes
covers
fish
including
red
grouper
interpretation
accords
endless
uses
term
statute
rule
books
construed
courts
dozens
federal
laws
rules
procedure
hundreds
state
enactments
include
term
tangible
object
first
cousin
tangible
thing
association
documents
others
see
referring
material
tangible
object
harbor
pest
disease
authorizing
investigative
demands
documentary
material
tangible
things
defining
museum
entity
owns
tangible
objects
exhibited
public
allowing
discovery
relevant
facts
books
papers
documents
tangible
things
knowledge
ever
read
provision
exclude
things
record
preserve
data
rather
courts
adhered
statutory
language
ordinary
expansive
meaning
example
courts
understood
phrases
tangible
objects
tangible
things
federal
rules
criminal
civil
procedure
cover
everything
guns
drugs
machinery
animals
see
obiukwu
per
curiam
handgun
acarino
supp
edny
heroin
newman
ca
fed
energy
generation
system
martin
reynolds
metals
cattle
surprise
today
courts
uniformly
applied
term
tangible
object
way
see
mcrae
corpse
maury
cement
mixer
necessarily
end
matter
agree
plurality
really
context
matters
interpreting
statutes
construe
meaning
statutory
terms
vacuum
tyler
cain
rather
interpret
particular
words
context
view
place
overall
statutory
scheme
davis
michigan
dept
treasury
sometimes
means
plurality
says
dictionary
definition
disputed
term
control
see
bloate
occasion
text
context
point
way
stepping
back
words
tangible
object
provides
evidence
congress
said
meant
meant
said
begin
way
surrounding
words
reinforce
breadth
term
issue
section
refers
tangible
object
thus
indicating
line
word
plain
meaning
tangible
object
whatever
kind
webster
third
new
international
dictionary
time
recognized
expansive
meaning
bringing
within
statute
reach
types
item
tangible
object
law
refers
department
housing
urban
development
rucker
see
republic
iraq
beaty
ali
federal
bureau
prisons
adjacent
laundry
list
verbs
alters
destroys
mutilates
conceals
covers
falsifies
makes
false
entry
shows
congress
wrote
statute
wide
scope
words
supposed
ensure
tangible
object
meant
covers
whole
world
prodigious
variety
see
rodgers
rejecting
narrow
technical
definition
statutory
term
clashes
strongly
sweeping
language
sentence
still
tangible
object
appears
part
phrase
including
also
records
documents
common
laws
always
understood
embrace
things
kinds
model
penal
code
section
drafted
years
ago
similarly
prohibits
person
alter
ing
destroy
ing
conceal
ing
remov
ing
record
document
thing
effort
thwart
official
investigation
proceeding
ali
model
penal
code
emphasis
added
code
commentary
emphasizes
offense
described
provision
limited
conduct
alters
written
instrument
comment
rather
language
extends
physical
object
ibid
consistent
statement
course
ordinary
meaning
courts
laws
based
model
code
tampering
provision
apply
tangible
objects
including
drugs
guns
vehicles
yes
animals
see
state
majors
cocaine
puckett
state
ark
gun
state
bruno
bicycle
skeleton
blood
stains
state
crites
mont
dist
lexis
deer
antlers
one
limited
phrase
scope
objects
record
preserve
information
words
record
document
tangible
object
also
track
language
federal
law
covering
even
plurality
accepts
see
ante
physical
evidence
forms
section
original
version
preceding
today
repeatedly
uses
phrase
record
document
object
notably
provision
prohibiting
use
force
threat
induce
another
person
withhold
materials
official
proceeding
victim
witness
protection
act
stat
amended
language
likely
derived
model
penal
code
encompasses
less
bloody
knife
incriminating
letter
courts
decades
agreed
see
kellington
boat
applewhaite
stone
wall
typically
compelling
evidence
persuade
congress
intended
nearly
identical
language
provisions
dealing
related
subjects
bear
different
meanings
communication
workers
beck
see
scalia
garner
reading
law
interpretation
legal
texts
context
thus
confirms
text
indicates
legislative
history
care
puts
extra
icing
cake
already
frosted
section
plurality
notes
see
ante
enacted
enron
corporation
collapse
part
act
stat
provision
began
life
separate
bill
drafters
emphasized
enron
case
study
exposing
shortcomings
current
laws
relating
corporate
criminal
fraud
pp
primary
loophole
congress
identified
see
arose
limits
part
described
provision
uniformly
construed
prohibited
person
inducing
another
destroy
record
document
object
every
type
see
supra
congress
even
plurality
agrees
see
ante
enacted
close
yawning
gap
fully
achieve
goal
covered
records
documents
objects
well
means
tampering
written
exactly
apply
broadly
acts
destroy
fabricate
physical
evidence
long
performed
requisite
intent
person
destroys
evidence
drafters
explained
overly
technical
legal
distinctions
neither
hinder
prevent
prosecution
ah
well
congress
meet
today
invents
distinction
effect
see
philadelphia
nat
bank
reat
ing
large
loophole
statute
designed
close
loophole
illogical
disrespectful
congressional
purpose
congress
recognized
using
broad
term
giving
immunity
destroy
evidence
sensible
basis
penal
policy
person
hides
murder
victim
body
less
culpable
one
burns
victim
diary
fisherman
like
john
yates
dumps
undersized
fish
avoid
fine
less
blameworthy
one
shreds
vessel
catch
log
reason
congress
thus
treated
offenders
way
understood
enacting
destroying
evidence
destroying
evidence
whether
evidence
takes
documentary
form
ii
plurality
searches
far
wide
anything
anything
support
interpretation
fishing
expedition
comes
empty
plurality
analysis
starts
title
destruction
alteration
falsification
records
federal
investigations
bankruptcy
see
ante
see
also
ante
opinion
alito
already
sign
something
amiss
know
case
begun
interpretation
statute
title
relied
title
override
law
clear
terms
instead
followed
wise
rule
title
statute
heading
section
limit
plain
meaning
text
trainmen
baltimore
ohio
reason
wise
rule
easy
see
title
almost
necessarily
abridgment
attempting
mention
every
term
statute
often
ungainly
well
useless
accordingly
matters
text
frequently
unreflected
headings
last
year
observed
two
titles
nearby
section
serve
reference
general
subject
matter
provision
issue
meant
take
place
detailed
provisions
text
lawson
fmr
llc
slip
quoting
trainmen
headings
stated
apparent
lawson
slip
title
refers
destruction
alteration
falsification
mutilation
concealment
covering
likewise
mentions
records
documents
objects
presumably
plurality
refuse
apply
person
conceals
evidence
rather
destroying
altering
falsifying
instead
plurality
say
title
title
undo
limit
specific
statutory
text
ibid
quoting
trainmen
holds
true
evidence
question
record
something
else
whose
destruction
alteration
intended
obstruct
justice
plurality
next
tries
divine
meaning
position
within
chapter
title
ante
move
yet
odder
last
far
tell
never
suggested
section
number
assigned
law
bears
upon
meaning
cf
scalia
supra
listing
interpretive
principles
canons
without
mentioning
plurality
new
theory
even
terms
plurality
argument
hard
fathom
plurality
claims
applied
objects
generally
congress
placed
specialized
provisions
ante
search
find
better
place
broad
ban
plurality
seems
agree
law
properly
goes
chapter
criminal
code
chapter
obstruction
justice
provision
logically
fit
chapter
sections
first
numbers
chapter
already
taken
starting
continuing
law
naturally
took
place
standard
operating
procedure
prior
act
chapter
ordered
chronologically
section
later
enacted
later
enacted
well
get
idea
congress
continued
vein
section
thus
right
expect
contemporaneously
passed
added
added
plurality
third
argument
relying
surplusage
canon
least
invokes
known
tool
statutory
construction
comes
nothing
says
plurality
read
naturally
render
superfluous
congress
passed
part
act
ante
although
two
provisions
significantly
overlap
applies
conduct
key
difference
two
protects
integrity
matter
within
jurisdiction
federal
department
agency
whereas
safeguards
official
proceeding
defined
section
language
often
applies
broadly
plurality
notes
example
fbi
investigation
counts
matter
within
federal
department
jurisdiction
falls
outside
statutory
definition
official
proceeding
construed
courts
see
gabriel
conversely
sometimes
reaches
widely
example
official
proceeding
includes
proceeding
judge
prohibits
tampering
evidence
federal
litigation
private
parties
see
burge
reich
sotomayor
contrast
ordinarily
operate
context
federal
department
agency
see
hubbard
surplusage
canon
come
overlap
even
significant
overlap
abounds
criminal
law
see
loughrin
slip
never
thought
ordinary
stuff
surplusage
made
see
ibid
connecticut
nat
bank
germain
legislative
history
plurality
appeals
see
ante
cuts
materials
show
lawmakers
knew
share
much
common
ground
minority
leader
lott
introduced
amendment
included
along
criminal
corporate
fraud
provisions
late
legislative
process
explaining
specific
request
president
see
cong
rec
remarks
lott
lott
several
senators
noted
overlap
president
package
provisions
already
bill
notably
see
remarks
lott
remarks
biden
remarks
sens
hatch
gramm
presence
final
act
may
reflected
caution
contained
flaw
serve
backstop
addition
may
derived
solely
legislators
wish
satisfy
audiences
courts
president
justice
department
gluck
bressman
statutory
interpretation
inside
stan
rev
emphasis
deleted
whichever
case
congress
consciousness
overlap
two
provisions
removes
conceivable
reason
cast
aside
ordinary
meaning
service
preventing
statutory
repetition
indeed
inclusion
creates
far
worse
problem
plurality
construction
mine
section
criminalizes
destruction
record
document
object
record
document
tangible
object
plurality
view
one
object
really
object
whereas
object
preserves
stores
information
normal
rule
statutory
construction
assumes
identical
words
used
different
parts
act
passed
time
intended
meaning
sorenson
secretary
treasury
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
especially
true
different
provisions
pertain
subject
see
supra
plurality
really
ca
explain
instead
interprets
words
used
two
provisions
act
addressing
basic
problem
mean
fundamentally
different
things
getting
nowhere
surplusage
plurality
switches
canons
hoping
noscitur
sociis
ejusdem
generis
save
see
ante
see
also
ante
opinion
alito
first
related
canons
advises
words
grouped
list
given
similar
meanings
second
counsels
general
term
following
specific
words
embraces
things
similar
kind
according
plurality
latin
maxims
change
english
meaning
tangible
object
things
like
records
documents
used
record
preserve
information
ante
understood
always
canons
transformative
effect
workaday
language
congress
chose
initial
matter
uses
noscitur
sociis
ejusdem
generis
resolve
ambiguity
create
principles
useful
rule
construction
words
obscure
doubtful
meaning
russell
motor
car
words
clear
definition
contextual
clues
support
meaning
canons
properly
defeat
congress
decision
draft
broad
legislation
see
ali
rejecting
invocation
canons
attempt
create
ambiguity
statute
text
structure
suggest
none
anyway
assigning
tangible
object
ordinary
meaning
comports
noscitur
sociis
ejusdem
generis
applied
attention
subject
purpose
canons
require
identifying
common
trait
links
words
statutory
phrase
see
graham
county
soil
water
conservation
dist
ex
rel
wilson
ali
responding
demand
plurality
characterizes
records
documents
things
preserve
information
much
things
provide
information
thus
potentially
serve
evidence
relevant
matters
review
statute
pertaining
obstruction
federal
investigations
evidentiary
function
comes
fore
destruction
records
documents
prevents
law
enforcement
agents
gathering
facts
relevant
official
inquiries
destruction
tangible
objects
whatever
kind
whether
item
fisherman
ledger
undersized
fish
throwing
overboard
identical
effect
administration
justice
see
supra
purposes
records
documents
tangible
objects
therefore
alike
indeed
even
plurality
ca
fully
credit
argument
reasoning
apply
every
law
placing
word
object
thing
record
document
noted
earlier
statutes
common
phrase
appears
among
places
many
state
laws
based
model
penal
code
well
multiple
provisions
see
supra
plurality
accepts
laws
object
means
object
argument
superfluity
positively
depends
giving
broader
reading
see
ante
difference
plurality
proposes
statutes
describe
less
serious
offenses
see
ante
distinction
affects
application
noscitur
sociis
ejusdem
generis
canons
left
obscure
count
one
plurality
interpretive
theories
see
supra
event
rationale
support
plurality
willingness
give
object
natural
meaning
like
sets
felonies
penalties
years
see
canons
plurality
interpretive
world
apparently
switch
whenever
convenient
plurality
invocation
verbs
nothing
buttress
argument
see
ante
ante
opinion
alito
plurality
observes
prohibits
falsif
ying
mak
ing
false
entry
tangible
object
one
things
say
murder
weapon
fish
ante
course
someone
alter
destroy
mutilate
conceal
cover
tangible
object
prohibits
actions
never
suggested
verbs
statute
need
match
nouns
see
robers
slip
law
require
legislators
write
extra
language
specifically
exempting
phrase
phrase
applications
respect
portion
phrase
needed
good
reason
exactly
congress
sets
draft
statute
broadly
include
every
imaginable
variation
theme
mismatches
arise
respond
narrowing
law
plurality
thus
flout
congress
wrote
congress
wanted
finally
else
fails
plurality
invokes
rule
lenity
see
ante
even
robust
form
rule
kicks
legitimate
tools
interpretation
exhausted
reasonable
doubt
persists
regarding
whether
congress
made
defendant
conduct
federal
crime
abramski
scalia
dissenting
slip
quoting
moskal
doubt
lingers
plurality
points
breadth
see
ante
though
breadth
equivalent
ambiguity
section
broad
also
clear
every
traditional
tool
statutory
interpretation
points
direction
toward
object
meaning
object
lenity
offers
proper
refuge
straightforward
even
though
capacious
concurring
opinion
shorter
vaguer
version
plurality
relies
primarily
noscitur
sociis
ejusdem
generis
canons
tries
bolster
list
verbs
concludes
section
title
see
supra
addressing
arguments
notably
even
concurrence
puts
stock
plurality
superfluity
claims
familiar
materials
concurrence
arrives
following
definition
object
mean
something
similar
records
documents
ante
opinion
alito
amplifying
purported
guidance
concurrence
suggests
applying
term
tangible
object
keeping
neighbor
asked
identify
something
similar
record
document
might
answer
ante
ho
raise
eyebrow
concurrence
wonders
neighbor
said
crocodile
ante
courts
sometimes
say
explaining
latin
maxims
words
statute
interpreted
consistent
neighbors
see
locke
concurrence
takes
expression
literally
meaning
hinge
odd
game
mad
libs
concurrence
proposes
one
reading
needs
fill
blank
words
records
documents
congress
quite
helpfully
already
adding
term
tangible
object
issue
case
term
means
concurrence
wishes
ask
neighbor
question
recommend
pertinent
one
think
fish
concurrence
prefers
crocodile
tangible
object
query
raise
eyebrow
neighbor
said
insisting
different
question
concurrence
neglects
proper
function
catchall
phrases
like
tangible
object
reason
congress
uses
terms
precisely
reach
things
concurrence
words
spring
mind
mind
neighbor
important
congress
ante
opinion
alito
recently
explained
whole
value
generally
phrased
residual
term
serves
catchall
matters
specifically
contemplated
known
unknowns
beaty
congress
realizes
game
free
association
record
document
never
think
things
including
crocodiles
fish
whose
destruction
alteration
less
frequently
effectively
thwart
law
enforcement
cf
stubbs
dead
crocodiles
used
evidence
support
smuggling
conviction
congress
adds
general
term
tangible
object
exactly
things
spring
mind
concurrence
suggests
term
tangible
object
serves
catchall
physical
evidence
ensure
beyond
question
electronic
files
fall
within
compass
ante
claim
right
congress
wishing
make
certain
applies
add
phrase
tangible
object
opposed
say
electronic
communications
judge
jury
member
predictably
find
tangible
object
encompasses
something
virtual
compared
say
something
real
fish
answer
term
function
failsafe
concurrence
acknowledges
one
arguments
carry
day
rather
takes
latin
canons
plus
verbs
plus
title
tip
case
yates
ante
sum
total
three
mistaken
arguments
three
mistaken
arguments
get
better
combining
concurrence
ends
right
plurality
except
concurrence
eschewing
rule
lenity
nothing
fall
back
iii
none
traditional
tools
statutory
interpretation
produce
today
result
accounts
plurality
offers
clue
emphasizes
disproportionate
penalties
imposes
law
read
broadly
see
ante
section
plurality
objects
expose
individuals
prison
sentences
tampering
physical
object
might
evidentiary
value
federal
investigation
offense
ante
brings
surface
real
issue
overcriminalization
excessive
punishment
code
statute
think
plurality
somewhat
though
somewhat
exaggerates
matter
plurality
omits
description
requirement
person
act
knowingly
intent
impede
obstruct
influence
federal
law
enforcement
highlighting
maximum
penalty
plurality
glosses
absence
prescribed
minimum
let
forget
yates
sentence
years
days
congress
presumably
enacts
laws
high
maximums
minimums
thinks
prohibited
conduct
may
run
gamut
major
minor
assuredly
true
acts
obstructing
justice
compare
case
following
properly
come
within
fall
outside
mcrae
burning
human
body
thwart
murder
investigation
maury
altering
cement
mixer
impede
inquiry
amputation
employee
fingers
natal
dist
lexis
repainting
van
cover
evidence
fatal
arson
district
judges
congress
knows
recognize
differences
cases
prosecutions
like
one
try
make
punishment
fit
crime
still
tend
think
reasons
plurality
gives
bad
law
broad
undifferentiated
maximum
penalties
give
prosecutors
much
leverage
sentencers
much
discretion
go
ways
unfortunately
outlier
emblem
deeper
pathology
federal
criminal
code
whatever
wisdom
folly
get
rewrite
law
resolution
pros
cons
whether
statute
sweep
broadly
narrowly
congress
rodgers
judges
disagree
congress
choice
perfectly
entitled
say
lectures
law
review
articles
even
dicta
entitled
replace
statute
congress
enacted
alternative
design
respectfully
dissent
footnotes
yates
also
charged
making
false
statement
federal
law
enforcement
officers
violation
charge
yates
acquitted
relevant
analysis
dissent
assiduously
ignores
post
insisting
congress
wrote
cover
along
shredded
corporate
documents
red
grouper
slightly
smaller
legal
limit
reason
think
meaning
tangible
objects
tangible
things
see
fed
rule
civ
proc
discovery
prescriptions
cited
government
leads
conclusion
tangible
object
encompasses
physical
evidence
existing
land
sea
dissent
contends
nothing
drawn
placement
chapter
ordered
chronologically
post
argument
might
force
factual
premise
correct
congress
directed
insertion
last
section
chapter
dissent
argues
congress
adopted
fill
post
made
sense
congress
codify
substance
within
new
rather
placing
among
specialized
provisions
notably
congress
added
broad
ban
cf
post
even
though
preexisting
title
provisions
related
despite
sweeping
relation
language
dissent
remarkably
suggests
ordinarily
operate
th
context
federal
courts
department
agenc
ies
post
suggestion
one
expect
lacks
government
endorsement
withstand
examination
senate
committee
report
dissent
elsewhere
relies
see
post
explained
obstructive
act
within
scope
done
contemplation
relation
matter
investigation
report
informed
meant
away
distinctions
courts
read
obstruction
statutes
proceedings
investigations
regulatory
administrative
proceedings
whether
formal
less
formal
government
inquiries
regardless
title
ibid
doubt
remained
multiplicity
contexts
designed
apply
report
added
intent
provision
simple
people
destroying
altering
falsifying
documents
obstruct
government
function
ibid
furthermore
tangible
object
read
include
physical
object
prohibit
conduct
proscribed
imposes
maximum
penalty
five
years
prison
destroying
removing
property
prevent
seizure
government
see
supra
dissent
contends
record
document
tangible
object
construed
conformity
record
document
object
provisions
address
basic
problem
post
congress
prohibited
additional
actions
specific
paper
electronic
documents
records
actions
prohibit
congress
passed
courts
already
interpreted
phrase
alter
destroy
mutilate
conceal
object
apply
types
physical
evidence
see
applewhaite
affirming
conviction
persuading
another
person
paint
blood
spatter
congress
use
formulation
track
one
used
repeated
suggests
congress
designed
interpreted
apart
lockstep
dissent
cites
mcrae
maury
natal
dist
lexis
cases
covered
read
post
cases
supply
cause
concern
persons
commit
major
obstructive
acts
id
go
unpunished
defendant
mcrae
police
officer
seized
car
containing
corpse
set
fire
also
convicted
conduct
sentenced
term
months
imprisonment
offense
see
defendant
natal
repainted
van
cover
evidence
fatal
arson
also
convicted
three
counts
violating
sentenced
concurrent
terms
months
imprisonment
see
judgment
morales
defendant
maury
company
convicted
concealing
evidence
cement
mixer
safety
lock
disabled
worker
fingers
amputated
also
convicted
numerous
violations
including
three
counts
violating
concealing
evidence
worker
safety
violations
see
see
also
atlantic
cast
iron
pipe
wl
nj
setting
forth
charges
company
violations
company
fined
millions
dollars
ordered
operate
supervision
monitor
see
footnotes
alabama
alaska
wisconsin
wyoming
trust
come
similarly
use
terms
tangible
objects
tangible
things
statutes
rules
sorts
see
code
defining
landscape
architecture
include
design
certain
tangible
objects
features
alaska
rule
civ
proc
allowing
litigants
inspect
copy
test
sample
tangible
things
constitute
contain
discoverable
material
stat
requiring
production
designated
tangible
things
civil
proceedings
wyo
rule
crim
proc
defining
property
purposes
statute
include
documents
books
papers
tangible
objects
lonesome
exception
chapter
chronological
order
added
create
civil
action
protect
whistleblowers
congress
decided
place
provision
right
section
chapter
authorize
civil
action
one
protect
victims
witnesses
plurality
seizing
example
says
likewise
made
sense
congress
codify
substance
within
new
ante
titled
tampering
witness
victim
informant
provisions
almost
protect
witnesses
intimidation
harassment
makes
perfect
sense
congress
wanted
broad
ban
stand
rather
part
appendage
provision
plurality
objection
statement
difficult
understand
take
issue
hubbard
holding
federal
neither
statute
referring
matter
within
jurisdiction
department
agency
plurality
suggests
phrase
relation
matter
somehow
changes
hubbard
result
see
ante
phrase
still
demands
relate
matter
within
jurisdiction
department
agency
excluding
courts
hubbard
commands
federal
government
far
tell
never
brought
prosecution
litigation
private
parties
instead
uses
purpose
section
also
applies
broadly
proceedings
relating
insurance
regulation
term
official
proceeding
defined
include
proceeding
involving
business
insurance
whose
activities
affect
interstate
commerce
insurance
regulatory
official
agency
usually
apply
context
state
federal
agencies
handle
insurance
regulation
plurality
seeks
support
argument
sentencing
commission
construction
phrase
records
documents
tangible
objects
ante
avail
plurality
cites
note
commission
manual
clarifying
phrase
used
sentencing
guidelines
includes
various
electronic
information
communications
storage
devices
sentencing
commission
guidelines
manual
ussg
includes
following
ordinary
definition
exhaustive
commission
commentary
makes
explicit
ussg
otherwise
commission
construction
encompass
paper
documents
note
make
plain
records
documents
tangible
objects
embraces
stuff
relating
digital
well
material
world
part
lenity
argument
plurality
asserts
yates
fair
warning
conduct
amounted
felony
ante
see
ante
stating
yates
scant
reason
anticipate
felony
prosecution
throwing
fish
overboard
even
plurality
view
dumping
fish
potentially
federal
felony
rather
see
ante
event
plurality
acknowledges
ordinary
meaning
covers
yates
conduct
see
ante
provision
less
announces
broad
scope
clearest
possible
terms
ordinary
citizen
seeks
notice
statute
scope
likely
focus
plain
text
plurality
section
number
superfluity
principle
noscitur
ejusdem
canons
concurrence
contends
noscitur
ejusdem
canons
play
unknowns
similar
known
knowns
records
documents
ante
noted
records
documents
similar
crocodiles
fish
far
concerned
potentially
useful
evidence
investigation
see
supra
concurrence
never
explains
similarity
relevant
one
statute
aimed