hibbs
director
arizona
department
revenue
winn
et
argued
january
decided
june
counsel
record
petitioner
hibbs
joseph
kanefield
arizona
attorney
general
office
phoenix
az
respondents
winn
et
al
marvin
cohen
sacks
tierney
pa
scottsdale
az
arizona
taxpayers
filed
suit
federal
director
arizona
department
revenue
director
seeking
enjoin
operation
rev
stat
ann
establishment
clause
grounds
arizona
law
authorizes
credit
payments
nonprofit
school
tuition
organizations
stos
award
scholarships
students
private
elementary
secondary
schools
section
provides
stos
may
designate
schools
discriminate
basis
race
color
handicap
familial
status
national
origin
preclude
stos
designating
schools
provide
religious
instruction
give
admissions
preferences
district
granted
director
motion
dismiss
ground
tax
injunction
act
tia
barred
suit
tia
prohibits
lower
federal
courts
restraining
assessment
levy
collection
tax
state
law
plain
speedy
efficient
remedy
may
courts
state
ninth
circuit
reversed
holding
tia
bar
actions
challenging
state
tax
credits
held
rejects
respondents
contention
director
certiorari
petition
jurisdictionally
untimely
rule
section
instructs
petition
must
filed
within
ninety
days
entry
judgment
rule
elaborates
statute
instruction
days
elapsed
date
ninth
circuit
first
entered
judgment
date
director
petition
filed
time
lapse
respondents
assert
made
filing
untimely
rule
first
sentence
time
file
runs
date
entry
judgment
order
sought
reviewed
moreover
respondents
submit
party
petitioned
rehearing
extended
filing
periods
prescribed
rule
second
sentence
never
came
play
case
however
follow
typical
course
ninth
circuit
initiative
recalled
mandate
ordered
parties
brief
question
whether
case
reheard
en
banc
order
holds
suspended
judgment
finality
timely
filed
rehearing
petition
appropriate
decision
consider
rehearing
petition
see
missouri
jenkins
appeals
order
raised
question
whether
modify
judgment
alter
parties
rights
thus
briefing
order
pending
judgment
reviewed
see
director
certiorari
petition
timely
statute
filed
within
days
date
ninth
circuit
denied
rehearing
en
banc
read
rule
sole
guide
party
rehearing
petition
reset
statute
count
lose
sight
congressional
objective
underpinning
appellate
final
adjudication
congress
indicated
marks
time
filing
period
begins
run
statute
takes
priority
procedural
rules
adopted
orderly
transaction
business
schacht
petition
timely
jurisdiction
pp
tia
bar
respondents
suit
pp
determine
whether
tia
bars
litigation
appropriate
first
identify
relief
sought
respondents
seek
prospective
relief
injunctive
relief
prohibiting
director
allowing
taxpayers
utilize
tax
credit
payments
stos
make
tuition
grants
declaration
face
applied
violates
establishment
clause
order
director
inform
stos
funds
possession
order
date
must
paid
state
general
fund
taking
account
prospective
nature
relief
requested
reaches
dispositive
question
whether
respondents
suit
seeks
enjoin
suspend
restrain
assessment
levy
collection
tax
state
law
answer
turns
meaning
term
assessment
employed
tia
internal
revenue
code
irc
purposes
assessment
involves
recording
amount
taxpayer
owes
government
focus
word
assessment
isolation
however
follows
cardinal
rule
statutory
language
must
read
context
general
dynamics
land
systems
cline
tia
tax
law
generally
assessment
closely
tied
collection
tax
assessment
official
recording
liability
triggers
levy
collection
efforts
complementing
cardinal
rule
stated
rule
superfluities
instructs
courts
interpret
statute
effectuate
provisions
part
rendered
superfluous
director
asserts
term
assessment
signified
entire
taxing
plan
tia
need
words
levy
collection
term
assessment
alone
necessary
work
briefing
galletti
government
made
clear
irc
definition
assessment
serves
trigger
levy
collection
efforts
government
describe
assessment
synonymous
entire
taxation
plan
disassociate
word
company
levy
collection
keeps
instead
accord
understanding
government
related
assessment
term
function
pp
congress
modeled
earlier
federal
statutes
similar
import
turn
paralleled
state
provisions
proscribing
actions
enjoin
collection
state
local
taxes
congress
drew
particularly
act
aia
bars
entertaining
suit
brought
purpose
restraining
assessment
collection
federal
tax
recognized
aia
text
measure
serves
twin
purposes
responds
government
need
assess
collect
taxes
expeditiously
minimum
preenforcement
judicial
interference
requires
legal
right
disputed
sums
determined
refund
suit
bob
jones
univ
simon
lower
federal
courts
similarly
comprehended
aia
shields
federal
tax
collections
injunctions
tia
shields
state
tax
collections
restraints
congress
directed
taxpayers
pursue
refund
suits
instead
attempting
restrain
collections
suits
seeking
stop
collection
contest
validity
tax
imposed
plaintiffs
outside
congress
purview
tia
legislative
history
shows
enacting
statute
congress
focused
taxpayers
sought
avoid
paying
state
tax
bill
pursuing
challenge
route
one
specified
taxing
authority
nowhere
history
announce
sweeping
congressional
direction
prevent
interference
aspects
state
tax
administration
foregoing
understanding
tia
purposes
legislative
history
underpins
previous
applications
statute
see
california
grace
brethren
church
distinguished
contrary
director
assertion
arkansas
farm
credit
servs
central
national
private
truck
council
oklahoma
tax
fair
assessment
real
estate
mcnary
rosewell
lasalle
nat
bank
hold
state
tax
administration
matters
must
kept
entirely
free
lower
interference
like
grace
brethren
church
cases
fall
within
undisputed
compass
involved
plaintiffs
mounted
federal
litigation
avoid
paying
state
taxes
gain
refund
taxes
relief
therefore
operated
reduce
flow
state
tax
revenue
decisions
fairly
portrayed
cut
loose
secure
moorings
see
grace
brethren
church
interpreted
applied
tia
cases
congress
wrote
statute
address
cases
state
taxpayers
seek
orders
enabling
avoid
paying
state
taxes
read
harmoniously
instruction
conditioning
jurisdictional
bar
availability
plain
speedy
efficient
remedy
state
remedy
inspected
decisions
designed
universe
plaintiffs
sue
state
taxpayers
see
pp
federal
courts
well
read
restrain
taxpayers
instituting
federal
actions
contest
liability
state
taxes
stop
third
parties
pursuing
constitutional
challenges
state
tax
benefits
federal
forum
numerous
decisions
including
decisions
reviewing
lower
judgments
reached
merits
constitutional
challenges
tax
benefits
without
mentioning
tia
see
byrne
public
funds
public
schools
new
jersey
griffin
school
bd
prince
edward
consistent
understanding
prevailing
issue
respondents
suit
may
proceed
without
tia
impediment
pp
affirmed
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
stevens
souter
breyer
joined
stevens
filed
concurring
opinion
kennedy
filed
dissenting
opinion
rehnquist
scalia
thomas
joined
elliott
hibbs
director
arizona
ment
revenue
petitioner
kathleen
winn
et
al
writ
certiorari
appeals
ninth
circuit
june
justice
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
arizona
law
authorizes
credits
payments
organizations
award
educational
scholarships
tuition
grants
children
attending
private
schools
see
rev
stat
ann
west
supp
plaintiffs
respondents
brought
action
federal
challenging
seeking
enjoin
operation
establishment
clause
grounds
question
presented
whether
tax
injunction
act
tia
act
prohibits
lower
federal
restraining
assessment
levy
collection
tax
state
law
bars
suit
contest
tax
liability
seek
impede
arizona
receipt
tax
revenues
suit
hold
kind
proscribes
decisions
spanning
near
half
century
courts
federal
system
including
entertained
challenges
tax
credits
authorized
state
law
without
conceiving
jurisdictional
barrier
first
occasion
squarely
confront
issue
confirm
authority
federal
courts
exercised
cases
hardly
ancient
history
bent
maintaining
racial
segregation
public
schools
allocating
resources
disproportionately
benefit
white
students
detriment
black
students
fastened
tion
grants
tax
credits
promising
means
circumvent
brown
board
education
federal
courts
among
adjudicated
ensuing
challenges
instituted
upheld
constitution
equal
protection
requirement
see
griffin
school
bd
prince
edward
faced
unconstitutional
closure
county
public
schools
tuition
grants
tax
credits
contributions
private
segregated
schools
district
require
county
levy
taxes
fund
nondiscriminatory
public
schools
abstention
required
state
courts
determine
validity
grants
tax
credits
closing
allen
county
school
bd
prince
edward
supp
ed
county
enjoined
paying
grants
providing
tax
credits
support
private
schools
exclude
students
based
race
public
schools
remain
closed
supp
ed
closure
public
schools
enjoined
see
also
moton
lambert
supp
nd
miss
challenge
tax
exemptions
racially
discriminatory
private
schools
may
proceed
federal
instant
case
petitioner
hibbs
director
arizona
department
revenue
argues
effect
federal
courts
wrong
cases
tia
petitioner
maintains
trumps
act
according
petitioner
bars
lower
interference
state
tax
systems
even
challengers
endeavoring
avoid
tax
imposed
matter
whether
state
revenues
raised
lowered
plaintiffs
prevail
alleged
jurisdictional
bar
petitioner
asserts
existed
since
tia
enactment
even
imagined
jurists
pathmarking
cases
cited
defendants
cases
litigants
every
interest
defeating
adjudicatory
authority
prior
decisions
command
respect
petitioner
urges
constitute
mere
sub
silentio
holdings
reply
brief
petitioner
reject
assessment
examine
opinion
scope
term
assessment
used
tia
question
whether
act
intended
insulate
state
tax
laws
constitutional
challenge
lower
federal
courts
even
suit
negative
impact
tax
collection
concluding
suit
implicates
neither
conception
assessment
statute
underlying
purposes
affirm
judgment
appeals
arizona
taxpayers
filed
suit
district
district
arizona
challenging
rev
stat
ann
west
supp
incompatible
establishment
clause
section
provides
credit
taxpayers
contribute
money
school
tuition
organizations
stos
sto
nonprofit
organization
directs
moneys
form
scholarship
grants
students
enrolled
private
elementary
secondary
schools
stos
must
disburse
scholarship
grants
least
percent
contributions
received
may
allow
donors
direct
scholarships
individual
students
may
allow
donors
name
dependents
must
designate
least
two
schools
whose
students
receive
funds
must
designate
schools
discriminate
basis
race
color
handicap
familial
status
national
origin
see
stos
precluded
arizona
statute
designating
schools
provide
religious
instruction
give
admissions
preference
basis
religion
religious
affiliation
taxpayers
donate
money
qualified
sto
allows
calculating
arizona
tax
liability
credit
donation
married
couple
filing
jointly
effect
gives
arizona
taxpayers
election
may
direct
filers
sto
arizona
department
revenue
long
donors
give
stos
total
tax
liability
contributions
costless
arizona
vote
rejected
facial
challenge
statute
went
effect
kotterman
killian
en
banc
case
took
form
special
discretionary
action
invoking
original
jurisdiction
see
kotterman
undisputed
preclusive
effect
instant
challenge
brought
different
plaintiffs
respondents
complaint
director
arizona
department
revenue
director
alleged
authorizes
formation
agencies
sole
purpose
distribution
state
funds
children
particular
religious
denomination
children
attending
schools
particular
religious
denomination
complaint
app
respondents
sought
injunctive
declaratory
relief
order
requiring
stos
pay
funds
still
possession
state
general
fund
app
director
moved
dismiss
action
relying
tia
reads
entirety
district
courts
shall
enjoin
suspend
restrain
assessment
levy
collection
tax
state
law
plain
speedy
efficient
remedy
may
courts
state
director
assert
order
enjoining
interfere
state
tax
levy
collection
efforts
urged
federal
injunction
restrain
assessment
taxes
state
law
agreeing
director
district
held
tia
required
dismissal
suit
app
pet
cert
appeals
ninth
circuit
reversed
holding
federal
action
challenging
granting
state
tax
credit
prohibited
tia
winn
killian
far
adversely
affect
ing
state
ability
raise
revenue
appeals
observed
relief
requested
respondents
result
state
receiving
funds
used
public
benefit
granted
certiorari
view
division
opinion
whether
tia
bars
constitutional
challenges
state
tax
credits
federal
compare
aclu
foundation
bridges
tia
bars
federal
action
seeking
part
state
tax
system
declared
unconstitutional
affirm
judgment
ninth
circuit
ii
reaching
merits
case
must
address
respondents
contention
director
petition
certiorari
jurisdictionally
untimely
rules
see
brief
opposition
section
instructs
petition
certiorari
must
filed
within
ninety
days
entry
judgment
rule
elaborates
time
file
petition
writ
certiorari
runs
date
entry
judgment
order
sought
reviewed
issuance
date
mandate
equivalent
local
practice
petition
rehearing
timely
filed
lower
party
time
file
petition
writ
certiorari
parties
whether
requested
rehearing
joined
petition
rehearing
runs
date
denial
petition
rehearing
petition
rehearing
granted
subsequent
entry
judgment
respondents
assert
director
petition
missed
rule
deadlines
days
elapsed
date
appeals
first
entered
judgment
date
petition
filed
rendering
filing
untimely
first
sentence
rule
party
petitioned
rehearing
extended
periods
prescribed
rule
second
sentence
never
came
play
case
however
follow
typical
course
appeals
motion
recalled
mandate
ordered
parties
brief
question
whether
case
reheard
en
banc
order
conclude
suspended
judgment
finality
timely
filed
rehearing
petition
appropriate
decision
consider
rehearing
petition
compare
young
harper
appeals
agreed
consider
rehearing
petition
timeliness
petition
certiorari
measured
date
disposed
rehearing
petition
missouri
jenkins
time
applying
certiorari
tolled
appears
lower
granted
rehearing
amended
order
solely
purpose
extending
timely
rehearing
petition
appropriate
decision
entertain
untimely
rehearing
petition
direction
initiative
parties
address
whether
rehearing
ordered
share
key
characteristic
three
raise
question
whether
modify
judgment
alter
parties
rights
see
timely
petition
rehearing
operates
suspend
finality
judgment
pending
determination
whether
judgment
modified
alter
adjudication
rights
parties
quoting
department
banking
neb
pink
per
curiam
alterations
original
words
petition
rehearing
pending
considering
initiative
whether
rehearing
ordered
reviewed
jenkins
light
hold
director
petition
writ
certiorari
timely
appeals
ordered
briefing
rehearing
issue
days
yet
passed
issuance
panel
opinion
limit
yet
expired
clock
still
reset
order
left
unresolved
whether
modify
judgment
briefing
order
effect
genuinely
final
judgment
critical
statute
must
treat
date
order
denying
rehearing
en
banc
date
judgment
entered
petition
filed
within
days
date
thus
timely
statute
read
rule
sole
guide
rehearing
petition
filed
party
reset
statute
count
lose
sight
congressional
objective
underpinning
appellate
final
adjudication
congress
indicated
marks
time
period
allowed
certiorari
petition
begins
run
statute
takes
priority
procedural
rules
adopted
orderly
transaction
business
schacht
rules
fail
anticipate
unusual
circumstances
fit
securely
within
federal
statute
compass
statute
controls
decision
see
kontrick
ryan
slip
axiomatic
procedural
rules
create
withdraw
federal
jurisdiction
quoting
owen
equipment
erection
kroger
petition
writ
certiorari
timely
jurisdiction
decide
whether
tia
bars
respondents
suit
iii
determine
whether
litigation
falls
within
tia
prohibition
appropriate
first
identify
relief
sought
respondents
seek
prospective
relief
specifically
complaint
requests
injunctive
relief
prohibiting
director
allowing
taxpayers
utilize
tax
credit
authorized
payments
made
stos
make
tuition
grants
children
attending
religious
schools
children
attending
schools
one
religious
denomination
children
selected
basis
religion
complaint
app
respondents
ask
declaration
face
applied
violates
establishment
clause
affirmatively
authorizing
stos
use
state
revenues
pay
tuition
students
attending
religious
schools
schools
discriminate
basis
religion
ibid
finally
respondents
seek
order
director
inform
stos
funds
possession
date
order
must
paid
state
general
fund
complaint
app
taking
account
prospective
nature
relief
requested
respondents
suit
words
seek
enjoin
suspend
restrain
assessment
levy
collection
tax
state
law
answer
question
turns
meaning
term
assessment
employed
used
internal
revenue
code
irc
term
assessment
involves
recording
amount
taxpayer
owes
government
assessment
essentially
bookkeeping
notation
laing
section
irc
authorizes
secretary
treasury
make
assessments
taxes
imposed
title
assessment
made
recording
liability
taxpayer
office
secretary
accordance
rules
regulations
prescribed
secretary
see
also
saltzman
irs
practice
procedure
pp
ed
internal
revenue
service
signs
summary
list
assessment
record
amount
tax
liability
official
act
assessment
occurred
purposes
code
focus
word
assessment
isolation
however
instead
follow
cardinal
rule
statutory
language
must
read
context
since
phrase
gathers
meaning
words
around
general
dynamics
land
systems
cline
slip
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
tax
law
generally
assessment
closely
tied
collection
tax
assessment
official
recording
liability
triggers
levy
collection
efforts
rule
superfluities
complements
principle
courts
interpret
words
statute
context
see
singer
statutes
statutory
construction
pp
rev
ed
statute
construed
effect
given
provisions
part
inoperative
superfluous
void
insignificant
footnotes
omitted
director
asserts
term
assessment
signified
entire
plan
scheme
fixed
upon
charging
taxing
brief
petitioner
quoting
webster
new
international
dictionary
english
language
ed
tia
need
words
levy
collection
term
assessment
alone
necessary
work
earlier
term
galletti
government
identified
two
important
consequences
follow
irs
timely
tax
assessment
irs
may
employ
administrative
enforcement
methods
tax
liens
levies
collect
outstanding
tax
see
time
within
irs
may
collect
tax
either
administratively
extended
years
years
date
assessment
see
brief
galletti
pp
government
thus
made
clear
briefing
galletti
irc
definition
tax
assessment
serves
trigger
levy
collection
efforts
government
describe
term
synonymous
entire
plan
taxation
disassociate
word
assessment
company
levy
collection
word
instead
accord
understanding
government
related
assessment
term
function
iv
congress
modeled
upon
earlier
federal
statutes
similar
import
laws
turn
paralleled
state
provisions
proscribing
actions
state
courts
enjoin
collection
state
county
taxes
hereinafter
composing
tia
text
congress
drew
particularly
measure
sometimes
called
act
aia
bars
entertaining
suit
brought
purpose
restraining
assessment
collection
federal
tax
act
mar
ch
stat
codified
see
jefferson
county
acker
apparently
recorded
legislative
history
bob
jones
univ
simon
recognized
aia
text
measure
serves
twin
purposes
responds
government
need
assess
collect
taxes
expeditiously
possible
minimum
preenforcement
judicial
interference
legal
right
disputed
sums
determined
suit
refund
ibid
quoting
enochs
williams
packing
nav
lower
federal
courts
similarly
comprehended
see
mcglotten
connally
supp
dc
bar
action
seeking
enjoin
exemptions
fraternal
orders
exclude
nonwhites
membership
action
plaintiff
contest
amount
tax
seek
limit
amount
tax
revenue
collectible
omitted
tax
analysts
advocates
shultz
supp
dc
bar
challenge
irs
revenue
ruling
allowing
contributors
political
candidate
committees
avoid
federal
gift
tax
contributions
excess
ceiling
precludes
suits
restrain
assessment
collection
taxes
proscription
apply
plaintiffs
seek
restrain
commissioner
ing
taxes
rather
require
collect
additional
taxes
according
mandates
law
emphases
original
aia
shields
federal
tax
collections
injunctions
tia
shields
state
tax
collections
restraints
congress
directed
taxpayers
pursue
refund
suits
instead
attempting
restrain
collections
suits
seeking
stop
collection
contest
validity
tax
imposed
plaintiffs
mcglotten
tax
analysts
explained
outside
congress
purview
tia
legislative
history
silent
regard
act
designed
expressly
restrict
jurisdiction
district
courts
suits
relating
collection
state
taxes
specifically
senate
report
commented
act
two
closely
related
objectives
eliminate
disparities
taxpayers
seek
injunctive
relief
federal
usually
corporations
asserting
diversity
jurisdiction
taxpayers
recourse
state
courts
generally
required
taxpayers
pay
first
litigate
later
stop
taxpayers
aid
federal
injunction
withholding
large
sums
thereby
disrupting
state
government
finances
see
fallon
meltzer
shapiro
hart
wechsler
federal
courts
federal
system
ed
citing
rosewell
lasalle
nat
bank
nn
see
also
jefferson
county
observing
tia
shaped
state
federal
provisions
barring
anticipatory
actions
taxpayers
stop
tax
collector
initiating
collection
proceedings
short
enacting
tia
congress
trained
attention
taxpayers
sought
avoid
paying
tax
bill
pursuing
challenge
route
one
specified
taxing
authority
nowhere
legislative
history
announce
sweeping
congressional
direction
prevent
interference
aspects
state
tax
administration
brief
petitioner
post
understanding
act
purposes
legislative
history
set
underpins
previous
applications
tia
california
grace
brethren
church
example
recognized
principal
purpose
tia
limit
drastically
interference
collection
state
taxes
quoting
rosewell
brennan
concurring
part
dissenting
part
complainants
grace
brethren
church
several
california
churches
religious
schools
sought
relief
unemployment
compensation
tax
state
law
imposed
federal
action
bypassed
state
remedies
exactly
tia
designed
ward
director
dissent
endeavor
reconstruct
grace
brethren
church
precedent
proposition
tia
totally
immunizes
lower
review
aspects
state
tax
administration
interference
collection
revenue
brief
petitioner
see
post
endeavor
unavailing
given
issue
grace
brethren
church
context
words
state
tax
administration
appear
director
invokes
several
decisions
alleged
keep
matters
state
tax
administration
entirely
free
lower
interference
brief
petitioner
accord
post
like
grace
brethren
church
fall
within
undisputed
compass
involved
plaintiffs
mounted
federal
litigation
avoid
paying
state
taxes
gain
refund
taxes
relief
therefore
operated
reduce
flow
state
tax
revenue
see
arkansas
farm
credit
servs
central
corporations
chartered
federal
law
claimed
exemption
arkansas
sales
income
taxation
national
private
truck
council
oklahoma
tax
action
seeking
prevent
oklahoma
collecting
taxes
state
imposed
nonresident
motor
carriers
fair
assessment
real
estate
mcnary
taxpayers
alleging
unequal
taxation
real
property
sought
inter
alia
damages
measured
alleged
tax
overassessments
rosewell
state
taxpayer
alleging
property
inequitably
assessed
refused
pay
state
taxes
prior
decisions
fairly
portrayed
cut
loose
secure
moorings
see
grace
brethren
church
federal
declaratory
relief
available
test
state
tax
assessments
state
tax
administration
might
thrown
disarray
taxpayers
might
escape
ordinary
procedural
requirements
imposed
state
law
pendency
federal
suit
collection
revenue
challenged
law
might
obstructed
consequent
damage
state
budget
perhaps
shift
state
risk
taxpayer
insolvency
quoting
ledesma
brennan
concurring
part
dissenting
part
emphases
added
rosewell
compelling
nature
considerations
identified
justice
brennan
perez
underscored
dependency
state
budgets
receipt
local
tax
revenues
may
readily
appreciate
difficulties
encountered
county
substantial
portion
rightful
tax
revenue
tied
injunction
actions
sum
interpreted
applied
tia
cases
congress
wrote
act
address
cases
state
taxpayers
seek
orders
enabling
avoid
paying
state
taxes
see
supra
read
harmoniously
instruction
conditioning
jurisdictional
bar
availability
plain
speedy
efficient
remedy
state
remedy
inspected
decisions
one
designed
universe
plaintiffs
sue
state
rather
remedy
taxpayers
see
rosewell
illinois
legal
remedy
provides
property
owners
paying
property
taxes
protest
refund
without
interest
two
years
speedy
efficient
remedy
tia
grace
brethren
church
remedy
speedy
efficient
taxpayer
hearing
judicial
determination
may
raise
constitutional
objections
tax
quoting
rosewell
federal
courts
well
read
restrain
state
taxpayers
instituting
federal
actions
contest
liability
state
taxes
stop
third
parties
pursuing
constitutional
challenges
tax
benefits
federal
forum
relevant
distinction
taxpayer
claims
reduce
state
revenues
claims
enlarge
state
receipts
seventh
circuit
judge
easterbrook
wrote
trenchantly
although
district
concluded
applies
federal
litigation
touching
subject
state
taxes
neither
language
legislative
history
statute
supports
interpretation
text
suggest
federal
courts
tread
lightly
issuing
orders
might
allow
local
governments
raise
additional
taxes
legislative
history
shows
designed
ensure
federal
courts
interfere
collection
taxes
long
taxpayers
opportunity
present
federal
defenses
imposition
collection
taxes
legislative
history
filled
concern
federal
judgments
emptying
state
coffers
corporations
access
diversity
jurisdiction
obtain
remedies
unavailable
resident
taxpayers
articulated
concern
federal
courts
flogging
state
local
governments
collect
additional
taxes
dunn
carey
emphasis
added
second
circuit
judge
friendly
earlier
expressed
similar
view
tia
context
legislative
history
lead
us
conclude
speaking
congress
referring
methods
similar
assessment
levy
distress
execution
produce
money
property
directly
rather
indirectly
general
use
coercive
power
congress
thinking
cases
taxpayers
repeatedly
using
federal
courts
raise
questions
state
federal
law
going
validity
particular
taxes
imposed
upon
wells
malloy
emphasis
added
see
also
jackson
county
observing
held
inapplicable
efforts
require
collection
additional
taxes
opposed
efforts
inhibit
collection
taxes
numerous
decisions
including
decisions
reviewing
lower
judgments
reached
merits
constitutional
challenges
tax
benefits
without
mentioning
tia
see
byrne
public
funds
public
schools
new
jersey
summarily
state
tax
deduction
taxpayers
children
attending
nonpublic
schools
violates
establishment
clause
supp
nj
franchise
tax
board
california
americans
public
schools
summarily
affirming
judgment
striking
state
statute
provided
reductions
taxpayers
sending
children
nonpublic
schools
committee
public
ed
religious
liberty
nyquist
state
tax
benefits
parents
children
attending
nonpublic
schools
violates
establishment
clause
relevant
part
supp
sdny
grit
wolman
summarily
kosydar
wolman
supp
sd
ohio
state
tax
credits
expenses
relating
children
enrollment
nonpublic
schools
violate
establishment
clause
finlator
powers
state
statute
exempting
christian
bibles
holy
books
religions
books
state
tax
violates
establishment
clause
luthens
bair
supp
sd
iowa
state
law
authorizing
tax
benefit
tuition
payments
textbook
purchases
violate
establishment
clause
minnesota
civil
liberties
union
roemer
supp
state
law
allowing
parents
public
private
school
students
claim
part
tuition
transportation
expenses
tax
deduction
violate
establishment
clause
procession
cases
rationally
distinguishable
one
justice
member
bar
ever
raised
objection
according
petitioner
case
caused
us
order
dismissal
action
want
jurisdiction
see
mueller
allen
state
tax
deduction
parents
send
children
parochial
schools
violate
establishment
clause
byrne
americans
public
schools
committee
public
ed
religious
liberty
wolman
griffin
consistent
understanding
prevailing
issue
respondents
suit
may
proceed
without
tia
reasons
stated
judgment
appeals
ninth
circuit
affirmed
elliott
hibbs
director
arizona
ment
revenue
petitioner
kathleen
winn
et
al
writ
certiorari
appeals
ninth
circuit
june
justice
stevens
concurring
part
iv
dissent
justice
kennedy
observes
years
unexamined
habit
litigants
courts
lessen
obligation
correctly
interpret
statute
post
merits
emphasis
however
prolonged
congressional
silence
response
settled
interpretation
federal
statute
provides
powerful
support
maintaining
status
quo
statutory
matters
judicial
restraint
strongly
counsels
waiting
congress
take
initiative
modifying
rules
judges
litigants
relied
see
bedroc
limited
llc
slip
stevens
dissenting
federal
election
nra
political
victory
fund
stevens
dissenting
commissioner
fink
stevens
dissenting
runyon
mccrary
stevens
concurring
contest
dictionary
doctrine
stare
decisis
latter
clearly
wins
fine
opinion
join
without
reservation
consistent
views
elliott
hibbs
director
arizona
ment
revenue
petitioner
kathleen
winn
et
al
writ
certiorari
appeals
ninth
circuit
june
justice
kennedy
chief
justice
justice
scalia
justice
thomas
join
dissenting
case
shows
great
skepticism
state
courts
ability
vindicate
constitutional
wrongs
two
points
make
clear
treats
diminished
disfavored
powers
rather
merely
applies
statutory
text
first
analysis
tax
injunction
act
tia
act
contrasts
literal
reading
terms
second
assertion
legislative
histories
support
conclusion
suits
seeking
stop
collection
contest
validity
tax
imposed
plaintiffs
outside
congress
purview
enacting
tia
provision
tia
modeled
ante
borne
sources
previously
recognized
light
points
today
holding
probably
attributed
concern
candidly
shows
animates
see
ante
noting
federal
courts
upheld
constitution
equal
protection
requirement
circumvented
brown
board
education
manipulating
tax
laws
concern
seems
state
courts
second
rate
constitutional
arbiters
unequal
federal
counterparts
state
courts
due
respect
dismissive
treatment
state
courts
particularly
unjustified
since
tia
express
terms
provides
federal
safeguard
act
lifts
bar
federal
intervention
state
courts
fail
provide
plain
speedy
efficient
remedy
view
tia
text
congressional
judgment
state
courts
qualified
constitutional
arbiters
respect
state
courts
deserve
disagree
majority
superseding
balance
act
strikes
federal
state
adjudication
agree
majority
petition
certiorari
timely
see
ante
submit
respectful
dissent
merits
decision
today
first
time
considered
whether
tia
bars
federal
district
courts
granting
injunctive
relief
prevent
giving
citizens
statutorily
mandated
state
tax
credits
cases
dating
back
almost
years
proceeded
jurisdictional
bar
apply
tax
credit
challenges
recent
decisions
said
bar
applicable
compare
mueller
allen
committee
public
ed
religious
liberty
nyquist
griffin
school
bd
prince
edward
aclu
foundation
la
bridges
gillis
unexamined
custom
favors
first
position
statutory
text
favors
latter
circumstances
careful
explanation
conclusion
necessary
end
scope
purpose
act
understood
terms
alone
question
presented
whether
tia
bars
district
granting
injunctive
relief
tax
credit
requires
two
inquiries
first
term
assessment
used
must
defined
second
must
determine
injunction
prohibiting
director
allowing
credit
enjoin
suspend
restrain
assessment
word
assessment
tia
isolated
use
another
federal
statute
tia
modeled
provision
internal
revenue
code
code
see
jefferson
county
acker
provision
specifies
specified
since
federal
courts
may
restrain
enjoin
assessment
collection
federal
tax
first
codified
act
mar
ch
stat
meaning
term
assessment
code
provision
discernible
reference
code
sections
title
et
seq
chapter
title
addresses
subject
assessments
sheds
light
meaning
term
code
section
first
instructs
secretary
internal
revenue
service
required
make
assessments
taxes
imposed
title
provides
secretary
shall
assess
taxes
determined
taxpayer
secretary
section
turn
sets
forth
method
making
assessment
assessment
shall
made
recording
liability
taxpayer
office
secretary
taken
together
provisions
title
establish
assessment
term
used
must
least
encompass
recording
taxpayer
ultimate
tax
liability
taxpayer
owes
government
see
also
laing
essentially
bookkeeping
notation
made
secretary
delegate
establishes
account
taxpayer
tax
rolls
whether
secretary
delegate
today
commissioner
makes
recording
basis
taxpayer
filing
form
instead
chooses
rely
calculation
taxpayer
liability
via
audit
irrelevant
recording
liability
government
tax
rolls
assessment
tia
modeled
provision
see
jefferson
county
supra
incorporates
terminology
employed
provision
employs
terminology
purpose
sensible
interpret
tia
terms
reference
code
use
term
cf
lorillard
pons
congress
adopts
new
law
incorporating
sections
prior
law
congress
normally
presumed
knowledge
interpretation
given
incorporated
law
least
insofar
affects
new
statute
appeals
concluded
assessment
official
estimate
value
income
property
used
calculate
tax
imposition
tax
someone
winn
killian
placed
principal
reliance
interpretation
dictionary
definition
entirely
misplaced
unless
definition
considered
context
prior
statute
advantage
statute
interpretive
guidance
lost
furthermore
defined
term
unusual
way
relied
dictionary
unavailable
tia
enacted
relied
definition
term
consideration
assessment
definition
term
related
verb
form
assess
examined
portion
terms
definition
dictionary
used
appeals
verb
defined
two
ways
noted
one
alternative
definitions
quite
relevant
fix
determine
amount
damages
tax
fine
compare
random
house
dictionary
english
language
panel
looked
different
lay
dictionary
found
definition
contrary
one
preferred
entire
plan
scheme
fixed
upon
charging
taxing
panel
considered
tax
treatises
law
dictionaries
found
much
accord
broader
definition
even
federal
income
tax
code
supports
broad
reading
winn
killian
kleinfeld
dissenting
denial
rehearing
en
banc
omitted
guided
first
internal
revenue
code
assessment
minimum
recording
taxpayers
liability
state
tax
rolls
tia
though
federal
statute
must
interpreted
matter
federal
law
operates
context
respect
act
must
interpreted
apply
evenly
various
regimes
various
recording
schemes
employ
therefore
irrelevant
whether
state
officials
record
taxpayer
liabilities
pen
specified
location
collecting
maintaining
taxpayers
filing
forms
manner
recordkeeping
equates
determination
taxpayer
liability
state
tax
rolls
assessment
whatever
method
seems
agree
see
ante
dictionary
definition
assessment
provides
relevant
information
contemporaneous
dictionaries
time
tia
enactment
define
assessment
expansive
terms
broaden
understanding
term
act
bar
see
webster
new
international
dictionary
providing
three
context
relevant
definitions
term
assessment
act
apportioning
determining
amount
paid
valuation
property
purpose
taxation
entire
plan
scheme
fixed
upon
charging
taxing
see
also
galletti
slip
noting
code
term
assessment
refers
recordings
tax
liability
also
calculation
tax
liability
including
done
taxpayer
need
decide
full
scope
term
assessment
tia
however
present
purposes
narrow
definition
term
suffices
applying
narrowest
definition
tia
literal
text
bars
district
courts
enjoining
suspending
restraining
state
recording
taxpayer
liability
tax
rolls
whether
recordings
made
taxpayer
filing
forms
state
calculation
taxpayer
liability
terms
enjoin
suspend
restrain
require
little
scrutiny
doubt
discrete
purposes
context
tia
also
common
meaning
refer
actions
restrict
assessments
varying
degrees
noteworthy
term
enjoin
meaning
restrictive
sense
also
meaning
affirmative
sense
black
law
dictionary
current
tia
enactment
gives
definition
term
require
command
positively
direct
black
law
dictionary
ed
definition
may
well
implicated
since
order
invalidating
tax
credit
seem
command
collect
taxes
otherwise
collect
parties
however
proceed
assumption
enjoin
means
bar
unobjectionable
make
assumption
leaving
broader
definition
later
consideration
respondents
argue
tia
bar
injunction
seek
even
credit
enjoined
director
able
record
enforce
taxpayers
liabilities
see
brief
respondents
fact
respondents
say
credit
way
director
able
record
enforce
higher
level
liability
profit
state
ibid
amount
tax
payable
taxpayers
increase
hardly
characterized
injunction
restraint
assessment
process
argument
however
ignores
important
part
act
state
law
district
courts
shall
enjoin
suspend
restrain
assessment
tax
state
law
act
bars
district
courts
enjoining
suspending
restraining
state
recording
taxpayer
liabilities
altogether
also
bars
enjoining
suspending
restraining
state
recording
taxpayer
liability
state
law
mandates
section
state
law
integral
part
state
tax
statute
reflected
state
tax
forms
state
held
part
calculus
necessary
determine
tax
liability
see
kotterman
killian
recording
taxpayer
liability
state
law
must
made
accordance
said
respect
every
provision
state
tax
law
order
director
record
state
tax
rolls
taxpayer
liability
reflects
operation
state
tax
law
provision
matter
bar
director
recording
correct
taxpayer
liability
tia
language
bars
relief
bars
suit
tries
avoid
conclusion
saying
recordings
constitute
assessments
must
function
ante
recordings
issue
function
see
also
ante
dissent
disconnect
word
assessment
enforcement
process
wrong
recording
taxpayer
liability
state
tax
rolls
course
propels
collection
cases
taxpayer
payment
accompany
filing
thus
accompany
assessment
literal
collection
moneys
necessary
anyone
paid
taxes
must
know
however
owed
payment
included
tax
filing
state
recording
one
liability
state
rolls
certainly
cause
subsequent
collection
efforts
filing
recording
assessment
propel
collection
establishing
state
legal
right
taxpayer
moneys
ii
majority
offers
prior
judicial
interpretations
code
similarly
worded
provision
support
contrary
conclusions
statutory
text
see
ante
federal
courts
allowed
nontaxpayer
suits
challenging
tax
credits
proceed
face
provision
controlling
cases
quite
distinguishable
plaintiffs
cases
barred
suit
available
forum
claims
see
mcglotten
connally
supp
dc
preferred
course
raising
tax
exemption
deduction
objections
suit
refund
available
situation
read
statute
bar
present
suit
see
also
tax
analysts
advocates
shultz
supp
dc
since
plaintiffs
seeking
restrain
collection
taxes
since
obtain
relief
refund
suit
bar
injunctive
relief
seek
ratified
decisions
insofar
relied
limited
rationale
basis
exception
statutory
bar
adjudication
see
south
carolina
regan
holding
provision
inapplicable
state
challenge
constitutionality
federal
tax
exemption
provision
code
exempts
taxpayer
gross
income
interest
earned
obligations
state
amended
tax
equity
fiscal
responsibility
act
stat
provision
intended
bar
action
congress
provided
plaintiff
alternative
legal
way
challenge
validity
tax
even
strict
limitation
strict
enough
four
members
one
noted
broad
sweep
njunction
provision
blackmun
concurring
judgment
three
justices
went
still
allowed
exception
provision
literal
bar
nontaxpayer
suits
challenging
tax
exemption
provisions
due
process
rights
stake
see
concurring
judgment
bob
jones
university
recognition
complete
inaccessibility
judicial
review
might
implicate
due
process
concerns
provides
absolutely
basis
crafting
exception
act
plaintiff
due
process
right
review
claim
judicial
forum
contrast
provision
tia
terms
ensures
adequate
forum
claims
bars
tia
specially
exempts
actions
heard
state
courts
providing
exception
instances
plain
speedy
efficient
remedy
may
courts
state
tia
text
thus
already
incorporates
check
regan
concluded
read
provision
even
though
provision
language
scarcely
explicit
prohibiting
nontaxpayer
suits
like
one
practical
effect
literal
reading
tia
provides
federal
district
courts
stand
ready
litigants
encounter
legal
practical
obstacles
challenging
state
tax
credits
state
courts
course
stands
ready
review
decisions
state
courts
matters
discuss
codified
exception
yet
clause
crucial
represents
congressional
judgment
balance
exist
respect
due
administration
tax
schemes
courts
interpretation
tax
laws
need
constitutional
vindication
ignore
provision
ignore
congress
already
balanced
interests
respondents
admit
heard
state
indeed
quite
similar
action
previously
heard
see
kotterman
killian
result
tia
exception
akin
recognized
regan
apply
proceed
replace
congress
balancing
noted
interests
iii
respondents
argue
tia
policy
purposes
relatedly
federal
provision
policy
purposes
discerned
legislative
histories
justify
today
holding
two
acts
say
reflect
unitary
purpose
congress
directed
taxpayers
pursue
refund
suits
instead
attempting
restrain
tax
collections
ante
see
also
ante
concluding
act
underlying
purpose
bar
suits
taxpayers
sought
avoid
paying
tax
bill
see
also
brief
respondents
purpose
respondents
say
shows
act
intended
foreclose
relief
challenges
tax
credits
proposition
rests
premise
tia
sole
purpose
prevent
district
orders
decrease
moneys
state
fiscs
legislative
histories
acts
carefully
limited
manner
reading
suggests
policy
argument
literal
application
act
terms
fails
taking
federal
provision
first
noted
history
expressly
reflects
congressional
desire
injunctive
suits
tax
collector
prohibited
regan
concurring
judgment
provision
responded
grave
dangers
accompany
intrusion
injunctive
power
courts
administration
revenue
generally
precludes
judicial
resolution
abstract
tax
controversies
whether
brought
taxpayer
nontaxpayer
see
also
reviewing
legislative
history
provision
various
amendments
related
enactments
thus
provision
object
bar
suits
might
interrupt
process
collecting
taxes
imilarly
language
history
evidence
congressional
desire
prohibit
courts
restraining
aspect
tax
laws
administration
majority
reading
tia
legislative
history
also
inconsistent
interpretation
history
earlier
cases
made
clear
tia
purpose
protect
fisc
also
protect
state
tax
system
administration
tax
policy
implementation
california
grace
brethren
church
prime
example
grace
brethren
church
held
tia
bars
actions
individuals
stop
tax
collectors
collecting
moneys
injunctive
suits
also
bars
declaratory
suits
see
explained
permitting
declaratory
suits
proceed
defea
principal
purpose
tax
injunction
act
limit
drastically
federal
district
jurisdiction
interfere
important
local
concern
collection
taxes
quoting
rosewell
lasalle
nat
bank
continued
federal
declaratory
relief
available
test
state
tax
assessments
state
tax
administration
might
thrown
disarray
taxpayers
might
escape
ordinary
procedural
requirements
imposed
state
law
pendency
federal
suit
collection
revenue
challenged
law
might
obstructed
consequent
damage
state
budget
perhaps
shift
state
risk
taxpayer
insolvency
moreover
federal
constitutional
issues
likely
turn
questions
state
tax
law
like
issues
state
regulatory
law
properly
heard
state
courts
grace
brethren
church
supra
quoting
approval
perez
ledesma
brennan
concurring
part
dissenting
part
course
demonstrates
protecting
state
fisc
damage
part
tia
purpose
equally
shows
actions
throw
state
tax
administration
disarray
also
implicate
act
purpose
concern
preventing
administrative
disarray
puts
context
explanation
tia
principal
concern
limit
federal
district
interference
collection
taxes
phrase
context
refers
operation
whole
tax
collection
system
implementation
entire
tax
policy
part
order
interfering
specific
collection
suit
disrupts
one
essential
aspects
state
tax
system
way
federal
courts
disrupt
state
tax
system
legislative
history
tax
injunction
act
demonstrates
congress
worried
much
form
relief
available
federal
courts
divesting
federal
courts
jurisdiction
interfere
state
tax
administration
grace
brethen
church
supra
decisions
fair
assessment
real
estate
mcnary
national
private
truck
council
oklahoma
tax
nptc
rosewell
supra
make
point
though
majority
says
cases
support
holding
involved
plaintiffs
mounted
federal
litigation
avoid
paying
state
taxes
ante
language
cases
clear
ignored
contrary
holding
today
fair
assessment
observed
tia
roots
equity
practice
principles
federalism
recognition
imperative
need
state
administer
fiscal
operations
last
consideration
principal
motivating
force
citation
omitted
nptc
said
congress
repeatedly
shown
aversion
federal
interference
state
tax
administration
passage
tia
one
manifestation
aversion
summing
aversion
generated
also
principles
comity
federalism
creating
background
presumption
federal
law
generally
interfere
administration
state
taxes
rosewell
described
act
language
broad
prophylactic
majority
opinion
brennan
see
also
ibid
tia
passed
limit
interference
state
tax
matters
act
designed
respect
administration
state
tax
systems
also
state
authority
say
state
law
means
ederal
constitutional
issues
likely
turn
questions
state
tax
law
like
issues
state
regulatory
law
properly
heard
state
courts
grace
brethren
church
supra
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
see
also
rosewell
supra
establishes
tia
purpose
solely
ensure
state
fisc
decreased
diminished
interest
allowing
state
courts
say
state
tax
statutes
mean
act
protected
state
fisc
tia
protects
responsibility
courts
administer
tax
systems
accountable
citizens
state
policies
decisions
majority
objects
disagreement
meaning
state
law
case
ante
initial
matter
clear
fair
conclusion
litigation
large
part
turns
state
law
requires
whether
product
requirements
violates
constitution
point
however
even
controversy
statutory
framework
arizona
tax
provision
creates
majority
ruling
implications
far
beyond
case
certainly
result
federal
courts
cases
required
interpret
state
tax
law
order
complete
review
challenges
state
tax
statutes
heretofore
consistent
interpretation
act
legislative
history
prohibit
interference
state
tax
systems
administration
accords
direct
broad
unqualified
language
statute
act
bars
orders
enjoin
suspend
restrain
assessment
tax
state
law
effecting
congressional
intent
give
full
force
simple
broad
proscriptions
statutory
language
tia
language
purpose
comprehensive
arguments
based
congressional
silence
question
whether
tia
applies
actions
increase
moneys
state
tax
system
collects
moment
contra
winn
relying
dunn
carey
see
also
ante
relying
dunn
whatever
weight
one
gives
legislative
histories
silence
legislative
record
irrelevant
plain
congressional
declaration
exists
matter
hen
terms
unambiguous
may
speculate
probabilities
intention
insurance
ritchie
wall
congress
said
district
courts
barred
disrupting
state
tax
operations
immaterial
whether
state
collection
raised
lowered
order
thwart
replace
state
chosen
tax
policy
causes
either
result
authority
supports
proposition
state
lacks
interest
reducing
citizens
tax
burden
troubling
proposition
proceed
assumption
state
interest
limiting
tax
burden
citizens
law
provides
secondary
policy
deserving
little
respect
us
iv
final
basis
majority
respondents
rest
years
unexamined
habit
litigants
courts
alike
resulted
federal
courts
entertaining
challenges
state
tax
credits
see
ante
citing
representative
cases
reverse
course
unexamined
practice
lightly
obligation
give
correct
interpretation
statute
obliged
maintain
status
quo
status
quo
unfounded
exercise
federal
jurisdiction
establish
jurisdiction
see
tucker
truck
lines
bound
prior
exercise
jurisdiction
case
questioned
passed
sub
silentio
respect
present
case
different
federal
election
nra
political
victory
fund
case
presented
question
whether
jurisdiction
consider
certiorari
petition
filed
federal
election
commission
fec
solicitor
general
behalf
fec
held
lacked
jurisdiction
see
though
answer
seemed
contradict
prior
practices
said
impressed
fec
argument
represented
several
occasions
past
without
question
raised
authority
jurisdiction
challenged
none
actions
therefore
question
open
one
us
citations
omitted
see
also
michigan
dept
state
police
never
considered
bound
subsequent
case
finally
brings
jurisdictional
issue
us
hagans
lavine
alteration
original
cases
make
clear
failure
consider
question
hardly
equates
thing
decided
contra
ante
stevens
concurring
referring
prior
silences
courts
respect
tia
stare
decisis
settled
interpretation
consequence
follow
statutory
language
today
decision
ontaxpaying
associations
taxpayers
nontaxpayers
allowed
sidestep
congress
policy
federal
judicial
resolution
abstract
state
tax
controversies
regan
concurring
judgment
unfortunate
result
deprives
state
courts
first
opportunity
hear
cases
grant
relief
constitution
requires
foregoing
reasons
respect
dissent
footnotes
state
taxation
purposes
includes
local
taxation
see
wright
miller
cooper
federal
practice
procedure
pp
ed
local
taxes
imposed
authority
state
law
courts
held
tax
injunction
act
applies
fallon
meltzer
shapiro
hart
wechsler
federal
courts
federal
system
ed
purposes
act
local
taxes
uniformly
held
collected
state
law
section
treasury
regulations
assessment
accomplished
assessment
officer
signing
summary
record
assessment
supporting
records
provides
identification
taxpayer
character
liability
assessed
taxable
period
applicable
amount
assessment
cfr
term
assessment
used
variety
ways
tax
law
setting
word
usually
refers
process
taxing
authority
assigns
taxable
value
real
personal
property
see
schoettle
state
local
taxation
law
policy
taxation
assessment
process
putting
value
real
personal
property
purposes
tax
measured
percentage
property
values
valuation
ordinarily
done
government
official
assessor
sometimes
hire
private
professional
actual
valuations
black
law
dictionary
ed
defining
assessment
inter
alia
official
valuation
property
purposes
taxation
also
termed
tax
assessment
cf
see
also
powell
real
property
wolf
ed
calculate
amount
property
taxes
owed
tax
assessor
multiplies
assessed
value
appropriate
tax
rate
see
werner
real
estate
law
ed
income
taxes
contrast
typically
anyone
filed
tax
return
unlikely
forget
taxpayer
taxing
authority
first
party
make
relevant
calculation
income
taxes
owed
word
however
technical
term
irc
indicates
internal
revenue
service
executes
formal
act
assessment
dissent
two
minds
regard
one
hand
twice
suggests
proper
definition
term
assessment
purposes
entire
plan
scheme
fixed
upon
charging
taxing
post
hand
dissent
disconnect
word
enforcement
process
levy
collection
assessment
sets
motion
see
post
congress
mind
challenges
assessments
triggering
collections
attempts
prevent
collection
revenue
borne
final
clause
added
whether
person
person
tax
assessed
emphasis
added
dissent
incorrectly
ranks
south
carolina
regan
mcglotten
tax
analysts
advocates
post
see
also
post
latter
decisions
text
notes
seek
stop
collection
taxes
contrast
south
carolina
regan
state
suit
aimed
reduce
federal
revenue
receipts
south
carolina
sought
enjoin
violation
tenth
amendment
rights
federal
tax
exemption
post
federal
income
taxation
interest
certain
bonds
held
unique
suit
bar
exercise
original
jurisdiction
case
language
tia
differs
significantly
johnson
act
provides
part
district
courts
shall
enjoin
suspend
restrain
operation
compliance
rate
orders
made
state
regulatory
bodies
emphasis
added
tia
prohibit
interference
operation
compliance
state
tax
laws
rather
proscribes
interference
aspects
state
tax
regimes
needed
produce
revenue
assessment
levy
collection
petitioner
urges
dissent
agrees
tia
safeguards
another
vital
state
interest
authority
state
courts
determine
state
law
means
brief
petitioner
post
respondents
however
asked
district
interpret
state
law
disagreement
meaning
rev
stat
ann
west
supp
whether
applied
state
law
violates
federal
constitution
see
supra
question
federal
courts
doubt
equipped
adjudicate
note
furthermore
relied
upon
principles
comity
brief
petitioner
preclude
original
jurisdiction
plaintiffs
sought
aid
order
arrest
countermand
state
tax
collection
see
fair
assessment
real
estate
mcnary
missouri
taxpayers
sought
damages
increased
taxes
caused
alleged
overassessments
great
lakes
dredge
dock
huffman
plaintiffs
challenged
louisiana
unemployment
compensation
tax
far
ignor
ing
plain
speedy
efficient
remedy
proviso
dissent
charges
post
agree
codified
exception
key
proper
understanding
act
statute
requires
state
provide
taxpayers
swift
certain
remedy
resist
tax
collections
action
dependent
discretion
example
qualify
fitting
taxpayer
remedy
cf
supra
conflict
sister
circuits
odds
prior
opinions
fifth
circuit
aclu
foundation
bridges
recently
construed
tia
way
director
bridges
involved
challenge
tax
exemptions
religious
activities
several
louisiana
statutes
district
line
earlier
fifth
circuit
decisions
held
tia
apply
plaintiff
seeking
restrain
assessment
levy
collection
state
taxes
eliminate
allegedly
unconstitutional
tax
exemptions
reversing
fifth
circuit
ruled
tia
bars
federal
suit
seeking
portion
state
tax
system
declared
unconstitutional
director
refer
four
decisions
lending
support
view
purposes
line
drawn
challenges
reduce
revenues
attacks
might
augment
collections
see
reply
brief
petitioner
citing
kraebel
new
york
city
dept
housing
preservation
development
colonial
pipeline
collins
gillis
brewers
perez
see
also
brief
amicus
curiae
two
cases
taxpayers
seeking
relief
aimed
lightening
tax
burdens
kraebel
held
barred
taxpayer
constitutional
challenge
exemption
abatement
scheme
colonial
pipeline
held
taxpayer
suit
seeking
redistribution
georgia
ad
valorem
tax
system
might
reduced
plaintiff
tax
bill
implicated
jurisdictional
bar
observe
broadly
requested
relief
granted
clearly
conflict
principle
underlying
tia
federal
courts
generally
avoid
interfering
sensitive
peculiarly
local
concerns
surrounding
state
taxation
schemes
gillis
unlike
kraebel
colonial
pipeline
action
declined
decide
hether
tia
actually
bar
availability
relief
noted
suit
seeking
enhance
state
revenues
may
nonetheless
fall
within
bar
act
language
limited
collection
taxes
emphasis
original
finally
perez
concerned
butler
act
tia
analog
applicable
puerto
rico
ordering
dismissal
case
want
jurisdiction
rested
decision
statutory
construction
underl
ying
comity
concerns
stating
order
federal
requiring
commonwealth
officials
collect
taxes
legislature
seen
fit
impose
citizens
strikes
us
particularly
inappropriate
involvement
state
management
fiscal
operations
school
desegregation
cases
last
resort
federal
courts
asserted
authority
direct
imposition
increase
local
tax
levies
even
amounts
exceeding
ceiling
set
state
law
see
missouri
jenkins
liddell
missouri
en
banc
cf
griffin
school
bd
prince
edward
controversial
measure
may
see
jenkins
kennedy
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
noteworthy
raised
cases
counsel
lower
courts
motion
confirming
cases
order
may
brought
federal
suggest
state
courts
second
rate
constitutional
arbiters
post
instead
underscore
adjudications
great
moment
discerning
barrier
see
supra
written
reflecting
nothing
unexamined
custom
post
unthinking
habit
post