lorillard
pons
argued
december
decided
february
private
civil
action
lost
wages
age
discrimination
employment
act
adea
trial
jury
available
sought
one
parties
since
although
adea
contains
provision
expressly
granting
right
jury
trial
cases
adea
structure
demonstrates
congressional
intent
grant
right
pp
directive
adea
act
enforced
accordance
powers
remedies
procedures
fair
labor
standards
act
flsa
significant
indication
congress
intent
long
adea
enacted
courts
uniformly
interpreted
flsa
afford
right
jury
trial
private
actions
pursuant
act
congress
presumed
aware
interpretation
incorporating
certain
remedial
procedural
provisions
flsa
adea
congress
demonstrated
intention
afford
right
jury
trial
pp
directing
adea
actions
lost
wages
treated
actions
unpaid
minimum
wages
overtime
compensation
flsa
congress
dictated
jury
trial
right
available
enforce
flsa
liability
also
available
private
actions
adea
conclusion
supported
language
empowering
grant
legal
equitable
relief
authorizing
individuals
bring
actions
legal
equitable
relief
inferred
congress
knew
significance
term
legal
providing
specifically
legal
relief
intended
jury
trial
demand
enforce
liability
amounts
deemed
unpaid
minimum
wages
overtime
compensation
pp
contrary
congressional
intent
found
comparing
adea
title
vii
civil
rights
act
assuming
arguendo
congress
intend
jury
trials
private
actions
title
vii
material
difference
adea
title
vii
contrast
adea
title
vii
many
words
authorize
legal
relief
availability
backpay
matter
equitable
discretion
appears
moreover
congress
rejected
course
adopting
title
vii
procedures
adea
actions
favor
incorporating
flsa
procedures
pp
marshall
delivered
opinion
members
joined
except
blackmun
took
part
consideration
decision
case
thornton
brooks
argued
cause
petitioner
brief
daniel
mcginn
norman
smith
argued
cause
filed
brief
respondent
justice
marshall
delivered
opinion
case
presents
question
whether
right
jury
trial
private
civil
actions
lost
wages
age
discrimination
employment
act
adea
act
stat
amended
stat
et
seq
ed
supp
respondent
commenced
action
petitioner
former
employer
alleging
discharged
age
violation
adea
sought
reinstatement
lost
wages
liquidated
damages
attorney
fees
costs
respondent
demanded
jury
trial
issues
fact
petitioner
moved
strike
demand
district
granted
motion
strike
certified
issue
interlocutory
appeal
pursuant
appeals
fourth
circuit
allowed
appeal
vacated
trial
order
ruling
adea
seventh
amendment
afford
respondent
right
jury
trial
claim
lost
wages
granted
certiorari
resolve
conflict
circuits
important
issue
administration
adea
affirm
adea
broadly
prohibits
arbitrary
discrimination
workplace
based
age
although
adea
contains
provision
expressly
granting
right
jury
trial
respondent
nonetheless
contends
structure
act
demonstrates
congressional
intent
grant
right
alternatively
argues
seventh
amendment
requires
private
action
lost
wages
adea
parties
must
given
option
case
heard
jury
turn
first
statutory
question
since
cardinal
principle
first
ascertain
whether
construction
statute
fairly
possible
constitutional
question
may
avoided
photographs
quoting
crowell
benson
accord
pernell
southall
realty
find
statutory
issue
dispositive
need
address
constitutional
issue
enforcement
scheme
statute
complex
product
considerable
attention
legislative
debates
preceding
passage
act
several
alternative
proposals
considered
congress
administration
submitted
bill
modeled
national
labor
relations
act
granted
power
secretary
labor
issue
orders
enforceable
courts
appeals
granted
private
right
action
aggrieved
individuals
sess
senator
javits
introduced
alternative
proposal
make
discrimination
based
age
unlawful
fair
labor
standards
act
flsa
et
seq
normal
enforcement
provisions
flsa
et
seq
ed
supp
applicable
permitting
suits
either
secretary
labor
injured
individual
sess
third
alternative
considered
adopted
statutory
pattern
title
vii
civil
rights
act
utilized
equal
employment
opportunity
commission
ed
supp
bill
ultimately
enacted
something
hybrid
reflecting
one
hand
congress
desire
use
existing
statutory
scheme
bureaucracy
employers
employees
familiar
hand
dissatisfaction
elements
preexisting
schemes
pursuant
act
violations
adea
generally
treated
violations
flsa
amounts
owing
result
violation
adea
treated
unpaid
minimum
wages
unpaid
overtime
compensation
flsa
rights
created
adea
enforced
accordance
powers
remedies
procedures
specified
sections
flsa
following
model
flsa
adea
establishes
two
primary
enforcement
mechanisms
flsa
provisions
incorporated
adea
secretary
labor
may
bring
suit
behalf
aggrieved
individual
injunctive
monetary
relief
ed
supp
incorporated
flsa
provisions
together
adea
addition
authorize
private
civil
actions
legal
equitable
relief
effectuate
purposes
adea
although
required
flsa
prior
initiation
adea
action
individual
must
give
notice
secretary
labor
intention
sue
order
secretary
attempt
eliminate
alleged
unlawful
practice
informal
methods
allowing
secretary
days
conciliate
alleged
unlawful
practice
individual
may
file
suit
right
individual
sue
terminates
however
secretary
commences
action
behalf
ii
looking
first
procedural
provisions
statute
find
significant
indication
congress
intent
directive
adea
enforced
accordance
powers
remedies
procedures
flsa
emphasis
added
long
congress
enacted
adea
well
established
right
jury
trial
private
actions
pursuant
flsa
indeed
every
consider
issue
held
congress
presumed
aware
administrative
judicial
interpretation
statute
adopt
interpretation
statute
without
change
see
albemarle
paper
moody
nlrb
gullett
gin
national
lead
sands
sutherland
statutory
construction
cases
cited
ed
congress
adopts
new
law
incorporating
sections
prior
law
congress
normally
presumed
knowledge
interpretation
given
incorporated
law
least
insofar
affects
new
statute
presumption
particularly
appropriate
since
enacting
adea
congress
exhibited
detailed
knowledge
flsa
provisions
judicial
interpretation
willingness
depart
provisions
regarded
undesirable
inappropriate
incorporation
example
construing
enforcement
sections
flsa
courts
consistently
declared
injunctive
relief
available
suits
private
individuals
suits
secretary
powell
washington
post
app
roberg
henry
phipps
estate
bowe
judson
burns
congress
made
plain
decision
follow
different
course
adea
expressly
permitting
equitable
relief
may
appropriate
effectuate
purposes
adea
including
without
limitation
judgments
compelling
employment
reinstatement
promotion
action
brought
enforce
act
emphasis
added
similarly
incorporating
adea
flsa
provisions
authorizing
awards
liquidated
damages
congress
altered
circumstances
awards
available
adea
actions
mandating
damages
awarded
violation
adea
willful
finally
congress
expressly
declined
incorporate
adea
criminal
penalties
established
violations
flsa
selectivity
congress
exhibited
incorporating
provisions
modifying
certain
flsa
practices
strongly
suggests
changes
congress
expressly
made
intended
incorporate
fully
remedies
procedures
flsa
senator
javits
one
floor
managers
bill
indicated
describing
enforcement
section
became
part
act
enforcement
techniques
provided
adea
directly
analogous
available
fair
labor
standards
act
fact
adea
incorporates
reference
greatest
extent
possible
provisions
flsa
cong
rec
directing
actions
lost
wages
adea
treated
actions
unpaid
minimum
wages
overtime
compensation
flsa
congress
dictated
jury
trial
right
available
enforce
flsa
liability
also
available
private
actions
adea
inference
buttressed
examination
language
congress
chose
describe
available
remedies
adea
section
empowers
grant
legal
equitable
relief
authorizes
individuals
bring
actions
legal
equitable
relief
emphases
added
word
legal
term
art
cases
legal
relief
available
legal
rights
determined
seventh
amendment
provides
right
jury
trial
see
curtis
loether
words
employed
statute
time
meaning
common
law
law
country
presumed
used
sense
unless
context
compels
contrary
standard
oil
see
gilbert
montclair
ramsdell
infer
therefore
providing
specifically
legal
relief
congress
knew
significance
term
legal
intended
jury
trial
demand
enforc
liability
amounts
deemed
unpaid
minimum
wages
unpaid
overtime
compensation
petitioner
strives
find
contrary
congressional
intent
comparing
adea
title
vii
civil
rights
act
et
seq
ed
supp
petitioner
maintains
provide
jury
trials
course
intimate
view
whether
jury
trial
available
title
vii
matter
either
statutory
constitutional
right
see
curtis
loether
supra
however
examining
provisions
title
vii
find
petitioner
argument
analogy
title
vii
unavailing
important
similarities
two
statutes
sure
aims
elimination
discrimination
workplace
substantive
prohibitions
fact
prohibitions
adea
derived
haec
verba
title
vii
deciding
whether
statutory
right
jury
trial
exists
remedial
procedural
provisions
two
laws
crucial
find
significant
differences
looking
first
statutory
language
defining
relief
available
note
congress
specifically
provided
legal
equitable
relief
adea
authorize
legal
relief
many
words
title
vii
compare
supp
similarly
adea
incorporates
flsa
provision
employers
shall
liable
amounts
deemed
unpaid
minimum
wages
overtime
compensation
title
vii
availability
backpay
matter
equitable
discretion
see
albemarle
paper
moody
finally
rather
adopting
procedures
title
vii
adea
actions
congress
rejected
course
favor
incorporating
flsa
procedures
even
adopting
title
vii
substantive
prohibitions
thus
even
petitioner
correct
congress
intend
jury
trials
title
vii
fact
sheds
light
congressional
intent
adea
petitioner
reliance
title
vii
therefore
misplaced
unmindful
difficulty
discerning
congressional
intent
statute
provides
express
answer
however
assume
face
congress
extensive
knowledge
operation
flsa
illustrated
selective
incorporation
amendment
flsa
provisions
adea
congress
unaware
courts
uniformly
afforded
jury
trials
flsa
believe
using
word
legal
congress
oblivious
meaning
significance
therefore
persuaded
congress
intended
private
action
adea
trial
jury
available
sought
one
parties
judgment
appeals
accordingly
affirmed
robert
williams
frank
morris
filed
brief
equal
employment
advisory
council
amicus
curiae
urging
reversal
jonathan
weiss
filed
brief
legal
services
elderly
poor
amicus
curiae
urging
affirmance
footnotes
appeals
decide
whether
respondent
entitled
jury
trial
claim
liquidated
damages
according
district
opinion
respondent
conceded
liquidated
damages
issue
triable
jury
express
view
issue
right
jury
trial
liquidated
damages
claim
morelock
ncr
right
jury
trial
cert
pending
rogers
exxon
research
engineering
right
jury
trial
cert
denied
post
hearings
subcommittee
labor
senate
committee
labor
public
welfare
remarks
javits
remarks
smathers
statement
national
retail
merchants
hearings
general
subcommittee
labor
house
committee
education
labor
remarks
secretary
labor
statement
legislative
representative
section
set
forth
provides
provisions
chapter
shall
enforced
accordance
powers
remedies
procedures
provided
sections
except
subsection
thereof
title
subsection
section
act
prohibited
section
title
shall
deemed
prohibited
act
section
title
amounts
owing
person
result
violation
chapter
shall
deemed
unpaid
minimum
wages
unpaid
overtime
compensation
purposes
sections
title
provided
liquidated
damages
shall
payable
cases
willful
violations
chapter
action
brought
enforce
chapter
shall
jurisdiction
grant
legal
equitable
relief
may
appropriate
effectuate
purposes
chapter
including
without
limitation
judgments
compelling
employment
reinstatement
promotion
enforcing
liability
amounts
deemed
unpaid
minimum
wages
unpaid
overtime
compensation
section
instituting
action
section
secretary
shall
attempt
eliminate
discriminatory
practice
practices
alleged
effect
voluntary
compliance
requirements
chapter
informal
methods
conciliation
conference
persuasion
section
set
forth
provides
person
aggrieved
may
bring
civil
action
competent
jurisdiction
legal
equitable
relief
effectuate
purposes
chapter
provided
right
person
bring
action
shall
terminate
upon
commencement
action
secretary
enforce
right
employee
chapter
see
wirtz
jones
lewis
times
publishing
olearchick
american
steel
foundries
supp
wd
see
also
note
right
jury
trial
age
discrimination
employment
fair
labor
standards
acts
chi
rev
note
fair
labor
standards
act
trial
jury
colum
rev
however
right
jury
trial
recognized
actions
brought
secretary
labor
enjoining
violations
flsa
compelling
employers
pay
unlawfully
withheld
minimum
wages
overtime
compensation
pursuant
see
sullivan
wirtz
wirtz
jones
supra
terms
requires
liquidated
damages
awarded
matter
right
violations
flsa
however
response
dissatisfaction
judicial
interpretation
provision
congress
enacted
pay
act
stat
inter
alia
grants
courts
authority
deny
limit
liquidated
damages
employer
shows
satisfaction
act
omission
giving
rise
action
good
faith
reasonable
grounds
believing
act
omission
violation
flsa
supp
although
adea
expressly
incorporates
pay
act
ed
supp
adea
make
reference
supp
section
adea
establishes
criminal
penalties
interference
performance
authorized
representative
secretary
engaged
performance
duties
act
cf
senator
javits
made
specific
reference
legislative
history
jury
trial
said
whole
test
somewhat
like
test
accident
case
person
use
reasonable
care
jury
answer
yes
question
individual
discriminated
solely
age
alleged
discrimination
must
proved
burden
proof
upon
one
assert
actually
case
cong
rec
section
specify
listed
categories
relief
legal
equitable
however
since
clear
judgments
compelling
employment
reinstatement
promotion
equitable
see
moore
federal
practice
congress
must
meant
phrase
legal
relief
refer
judgments
enforcing
liability
amounts
deemed
unpaid
minimum
wages
unpaid
overtime
compensation
title
vii
respect
race
color
religion
sex
national
origin
adea
respect
age
make
unlawful
employer
fail
refuse
hire
discharge
individual
otherwise
discriminate
individual
respect
compensation
terms
conditions
privileges
employment
bases
compare
supp
although
held
discretionary
power
deny
backpay
used
frustrate
central
statutory
purposes
eradicating
discrimination
throughout
economy
making
persons
whole
injuries
suffered
past
discrimination
albemarle
paper
moody
nonetheless
recognized
title
vii
discretion
exists
indeed
extent
petitioner
correctly
interprets
congressional
intent
respect
jury
trials
title
vii
different
remedial
procedural
provisions
adea
suggest
congress
different
intent
mind
drafting
later
law