graham
county
soil
water
conservation
district
et
al
ex
rel
wilson
argued
november
decided
march
false
claims
act
fca
authorizes
attorney
general
private
qui
tam
relators
recover
persons
make
false
fraudulent
payment
claims
bars
qui
tam
actions
based
upon
public
disclosure
allegations
transactions
inter
alia
congressional
administrative
government
accounting
office
gao
report
hearing
audit
investigation
federal
contracts
provided
two
north
carolina
counties
remediate
areas
damaged
flooding
federal
government
shoulder
costs
respondent
wilson
employee
local
government
body
involved
effort
alerted
local
federal
officials
possible
fraud
county
state
issued
reports
identifying
potential
irregularities
contracts
administration
subsequently
wilson
filed
qui
tam
action
alleging
relevant
petitioners
county
conservation
districts
local
federal
officials
knowingly
submitted
false
payment
claims
violation
fca
district
ultimately
dismissed
lack
jurisdiction
wilson
refuted
action
based
upon
allegations
publicly
disclosed
county
state
reports
held
administrative
reports
fca
public
disclosure
bar
reversing
fourth
circuit
concluded
federal
administrative
reports
may
trigger
public
disclosure
bar
held
reference
administrative
reports
audits
investigations
encompasses
disclosures
made
state
local
sources
well
federal
sources
pp
section
specifies
three
categories
disclosures
deprive
federal
courts
jurisdiction
qui
tam
suits
language
issue
contained
second
category
category
pp
fca
plain
text
limit
administrative
federal
sources
term
modifies
report
hearing
audit
investigation
provision
public
disclosure
fraud
naturally
read
describe
government
agency
activities
since
administrative
modified
federal
immediately
apparent
basis
excluding
state
local
agency
activities
ambit
interpretive
maxim
noscitur
sociis
word
may
known
company
keeps
russell
motor
car
support
fourth
circuit
limited
view
category
administrative
sandwiched
federal
terms
congressional
gao
items
disparate
qualify
string
statutory
terms
warren
maine
bd
environmental
protection
items
list
beecham
noscitur
sociis
purposes
furthermore
evaluating
administrative
within
public
disclosure
bar
larger
scheme
observes
category
terms
sandwiched
phrases
category
criminal
civil
administrative
hearing
category
news
media
generally
understood
include
nonfederal
sources
category
contains
term
administrative
issue
even
category
best
understood
refer
adjudicative
proceedings
category
legislative
activities
state
local
administrative
sources
character
presumably
public
likely
put
federal
government
notice
potential
fraud
state
local
administrative
hearings
adjudicatory
character
fca
overall
federal
focus
shines
light
specific
question
whether
public
disclosure
bar
extends
nonfederal
contexts
fact
state
legislative
sources
included
carries
clear
implications
status
state
administrative
sources
pp
legislative
record
support
exclusively
federal
interpretation
administrative
current
enacted
strike
balance
encouraging
private
persons
root
fraud
stifling
parasitic
lawsuits
exactly
statute
came
strike
balance
uncertain
significant
substantive
changes
including
introduction
administrative
category
inserted
without
floor
debate
discussion
technical
amendments
though
congress
wanted
strengthen
government
hand
fighting
false
claims
cook
county
ex
rel
chandler
encourage
qui
tam
suits
also
determined
bar
subset
suits
deemed
unmeritorious
downright
harmful
question
concerns
subset
precise
scope
matter
record
opaque
leaving
evident
legislative
purpose
guide
resolution
discrete
issue
bornstein
pp
respondent
additional
arguments
favor
limiting
administrative
federal
sources
unpersuasive
pp
reversed
remanded
stevens
delivered
opinion
roberts
kennedy
thomas
ginsburg
alito
joined
scalia
joined
except
part
iv
scalia
filed
opinion
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
sotomayor
filed
dissenting
opinion
breyer
joined
graham
county
soil
water
tion
district
et
petitioners
ex
rel
karen
wilson
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
march
justice
stevens
delivered
opinion
since
enactment
civil
war
false
claims
act
authorized
attorney
general
private
qui
tam
relators
recover
persons
make
false
fraudulent
claims
payment
act
contains
provision
barring
qui
tam
actions
based
upon
public
disclosure
allegations
transactions
certain
specified
sources
question
us
whether
reference
administrative
reports
audits
investigations
provision
encompasses
disclosures
made
state
local
sources
well
federal
sources
hold
department
agriculture
usda
entered
contracts
two
counties
north
carolina
authorizing
perform
hire
others
perform
cleanup
repair
work
areas
suffered
extensive
flooding
federal
government
agreed
shoulder
percent
contract
costs
respondent
karen
wilson
time
employee
graham
county
soil
conservation
district
government
body
delegated
partial
responsibility
coordinating
performing
remediation
effort
suspecting
possible
fraud
connection
effort
wilson
voiced
concerns
local
officials
summer
also
sent
letter
meeting
agents
usda
graham
county
officials
began
investigation
accounting
firm
hired
county
performed
audit
issued
report
audit
report
identified
several
potential
irregularities
county
administration
contracts
shortly
thereafter
north
carolina
department
environment
health
natural
resources
issued
report
dehnr
report
identifying
similar
problems
usda
office
inspector
general
eventually
issued
third
report
contained
additional
findings
wilson
filed
action
alleging
petitioners
graham
county
cherokee
county
soil
water
conservation
districts
number
local
federal
officials
violated
false
claims
act
fca
knowingly
submitting
false
claims
payment
pursuant
contracts
alleged
petitioners
retaliated
aiding
federal
investigation
false
claims
following
review
statute
limitations
applicable
wilson
retaliation
claim
graham
county
soil
water
conservation
dist
ex
rel
wilson
appeals
ordered
claim
dismissed
time
barred
remand
district
subsequently
dismissed
wilson
qui
tam
action
lack
jurisdiction
app
pet
cert
found
wilson
failed
refute
action
based
upon
allegations
publicly
disclosed
audit
report
dehnr
report
reports
district
determined
constituted
administrative
report
audit
investigation
within
meaning
fca
public
disclosure
bar
appeals
reversed
judgment
district
reports
generated
state
local
entities
nly
federal
administrative
reports
audits
investigations
fourth
circuit
concluded
qualify
public
disclosures
fca
emphasis
added
circuits
divided
granted
certiorari
resolve
conflict
ii
examined
fca
qui
tam
provisions
several
recent
issue
case
fca
public
disclosure
bar
deprives
courts
jurisdiction
qui
tam
suits
relevant
information
already
entered
public
domain
certain
channels
statute
contains
three
categories
disclosures
following
example
appeals
see
inserted
arabic
numerals
identify
categories
shall
jurisdiction
action
section
based
upon
public
disclosure
allegations
transactions
criminal
civil
administrative
hearing
congressional
administrative
government
accounting
office
gao
report
hearing
audit
investigation
news
media
unless
action
brought
attorney
general
person
bringing
action
original
source
information
omitted
dispute
turns
meaning
adjective
administrative
second
category
category
whether
embraces
forums
federal
nature
respondent
alleges
whether
extends
disclosures
made
state
local
sources
dehnr
report
audit
report
petitioners
allege
debating
question
petitioners
relied
primarily
statute
text
whereas
respondent
solicitor
general
amicus
relied
heavily
considerations
history
policy
although
overlap
among
three
types
argument
useful
discuss
separately
begin
text
iii
term
administrative
may
various
contexts
bear
range
related
meanings
chandler
judicial
council
tenth
circuit
harlan
concurring
denial
writ
pertaining
private
bodies
well
governmental
bodies
used
modify
nouns
report
hearing
audit
investigation
context
statutory
provision
public
disclosure
fraud
term
naturally
read
describe
activities
governmental
agencies
see
black
law
dictionary
ed
hereinafter
black
defining
administration
public
law
practical
management
direction
executive
department
agencies
given
administrative
modified
federal
immediately
apparent
textual
basis
excluding
activities
state
local
agencies
contractors
ambit
appeals
recognized
statute
express
terms
limit
reach
federal
administrative
reports
investigations
nothing
inherently
federal
word
congress
define
term
fca
appeals
conclusion
administrative
nevertheless
reaches
federal
sources
rested
application
interpretive
maxim
noscitur
sociis
see
maxim
literally
translated
known
associates
black
counsels
lawyers
reading
statutes
word
may
known
company
keeps
russell
motor
car
participants
litigation
acknowledge
terms
congressional
gao
federal
nature
congress
legislative
branch
federal
gao
federal
relying
opinions
warren
maine
bd
environmental
protection
beecham
appeals
reasoned
placement
squarely
middle
list
obviously
federal
sources
strongly
suggests
likewise
restricted
federal
administrative
reports
hearings
audits
investigations
holding
appeals
embraced
might
call
sandwich
theory
third
circuit
courts
ou
nd
hard
believe
drafters
provision
intended
word
administrative
refer
state
federal
reports
lies
sandwiched
modifiers
unquestionably
federal
character
ibid
quoting
ex
rel
dunleavy
county
delaware
find
use
noscitur
sociis
unpersuasive
list
three
items
quite
distinct
matter
construed
short
particularly
illuminating
although
list
may
completely
disjunctive
refers
congressional
administrative
gao
sources
rather
congressional
administrative
gao
sources
neither
completely
harmonious
substantive
connection
fit
terms
congressional
administrative
gao
tight
demand
rob
one
independent
ordinary
significance
reiter
sonotone
see
also
russell
word
may
known
company
keeps
invariable
rule
word
may
character
submerged
association
adjectives
category
disparate
qualify
string
statutory
terms
warren
items
list
beecham
sense
used
phrases
cited
important
need
evaluate
administrative
within
larger
scheme
public
disclosure
bar
parties
acknowledge
must
tatutory
language
meaning
context
graham
county
soil
differ
determining
relevant
context
sandwich
theory
presupposes
category
piece
matters
agree
petitioners
however
sources
listed
provide
interpretive
guidance
sources
drive
end
specifying
types
disclosures
foreclose
qui
tam
actions
light
public
disclosure
bar
grammatical
structure
may
convenient
even
clarifying
parse
list
sources
three
categories
follow
treat
categories
islands
unto
courts
duty
construe
statutes
isolated
provisions
gustafson
alloyd
consider
entire
text
public
disclosure
bar
case
limiting
administrative
federal
sources
becomes
significantly
weaker
news
media
referenced
category
plainly
broader
sweep
federal
government
funds
certain
media
outlets
certain
private
outlets
national
focus
one
contends
category
limited
sources
likewise
textual
basis
assuming
criminal
civil
administrative
hearing
listed
category
must
federal
numerous
types
sources
serve
common
function
two
distinctly
federal
nature
one
news
media
distinctly
nonfederal
nature
appeals
correct
term
administrative
encompasses
state
local
sources
category
see
becomes
even
harder
see
term
category
see
erlenbaugh
legislative
body
generally
uses
particular
word
consistent
meaning
given
context
respondent
solicitor
general
assert
two
references
administrative
distinguished
category
best
understood
refer
adjudicative
proceedings
whereas
category
best
understood
refer
legislative
activities
rulemaking
oversight
investigations
see
brief
respondent
brief
amicus
curiae
hereinafter
brief
yet
even
reading
correct
state
local
administrative
reports
hearings
audits
investigations
character
presumably
public
likely
put
federal
government
notice
potential
fraud
state
local
administrative
hearings
adjudicatory
respondent
solicitor
general
try
avoid
inference
turn
weakness
strength
averring
sources
listed
category
federal
see
brief
respondent
brief
ever
taken
view
sources
see
citing
cases
third
fourth
fifth
ninth
eleventh
circuits
stating
courts
easily
concluded
category
applies
hearings
sylvia
citing
additional
cases
arguments
favor
reading
federal
limitation
category
supported
legislative
history
policy
find
support
statute
text
moving
narrow
lens
sandwich
theory
bird
eye
view
respondent
solicitor
general
also
maintain
exclusively
federal
focus
fca
counsels
reading
public
disclosure
bar
encompass
nonfederal
sources
brief
respondent
brief
fca
undoubtedly
federal
focus
every
federal
statute
respondent
solicitor
general
elsewhere
acknowledge
quite
aspects
fca
including
reference
administrative
proceedings
reference
news
media
federal
event
federal
focus
statute
whole
shine
light
specific
question
whether
public
disclosure
bar
extends
certain
nonfederal
contexts
fact
public
disclosure
federal
government
creation
receipt
touchstone
respondent
solicitor
general
make
one
last
argument
grounded
statutory
text
anomalous
say
state
local
administrative
reports
count
public
disclosures
state
legislative
reports
see
brief
respondent
brief
yet
neither
respondent
solicitor
general
disputes
contention
petitioners
amici
time
public
disclosure
bar
enacted
congress
rarely
gave
state
legislatures
meaningful
role
administering
overseeing
federally
funded
programs
see
brief
petitioners
brief
national
league
cities
et
al
amici
curiae
instant
case
federal
government
far
likely
enter
contracts
provide
moneys
state
local
executive
agencies
whether
state
legislative
sources
included
exclusion
therefore
carries
clear
implications
status
state
administrative
sources
sum
although
term
administrative
may
sandwiched
category
terms
federal
nature
terms
sandwiched
phrases
generally
understood
include
nonfederal
sources
one
phrases
category
contains
exact
term
subject
inquiry
textual
clues
negate
force
noscitur
sociis
canon
applied
persuaded
associates
administrative
keeps
company
endow
exclusively
federal
character
iv
originally
enacted
fca
limit
sources
relator
acquire
information
bring
qui
tam
action
ex
rel
marcus
hess
upheld
relator
recovery
even
though
discovered
fraud
reading
federal
criminal
indictment
quintessential
parasitic
suit
see
even
government
suggests
petitioner
contributed
nothing
discovery
crime
contributed
much
accomplishing
one
purposes
act
passed
congress
promptly
reacted
decision
amending
statute
preclude
qui
tam
actions
based
upon
evidence
information
possession
agency
officer
employee
thereof
time
suit
brought
act
stat
codified
amendment
erected
came
known
government
knowledge
bar
nce
learned
false
claim
government
assert
rights
fca
false
claimant
hughes
aircraft
ex
rel
schumer
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
years
followed
amendment
volume
efficacy
qui
tam
litigation
dwindled
seeking
golden
mean
adequate
incentives
insiders
genuinely
valuable
information
discouragement
opportunistic
plaintiffs
significant
information
contribute
ex
rel
springfield
terminal
quinn
cadc
congress
overhauled
statute
make
fca
useful
tool
fraud
modern
times
cook
county
ex
rel
chandler
quoting
hereinafter
present
text
enacted
part
larger
reform
congress
apparently
concluded
total
bar
qui
tam
actions
based
information
already
government
possession
thwarted
significant
number
potentially
valuable
claims
rather
simply
repeal
government
knowledge
bar
however
congress
replaced
public
disclosure
bar
effort
strike
balance
encouraging
private
persons
root
fraud
stifling
parasitic
lawsuits
one
hess
exactly
came
strike
balance
way
matter
considerable
uncertainty
house
senate
judiciary
committees
reported
bills
contained
different
public
disclosure
bars
one
emerged
statutes
large
senate
bill
example
include
words
administrative
audit
investigation
version
category
contain
original
source
exception
see
text
proposed
respondent
amici
view
background
counsels
favor
exclusively
federal
interpretation
administrative
three
separate
reasons
first
drafting
history
public
disclosure
bar
suggests
congress
intended
result
second
major
aim
amendments
limit
scope
government
knowledge
bar
onstruing
limited
disclosures
federal
proceedings
furthers
congress
purpose
encourage
private
enforcement
suits
brief
quoting
third
whereas
federal
administrative
proceedings
presumed
provide
attorney
general
fair
opportunity
decide
whether
bring
fca
action
based
revelations
made
therein
attorney
general
much
less
likely
learn
fraud
disclosed
state
proceedings
respondent
amici
maintain
perverse
include
nonfederal
sources
category
local
governments
able
shield
qui
tam
liability
discretely
disclosing
evidence
fraud
public
arguments
reasonable
far
go
go
far
many
observed
drafting
history
public
disclosure
bar
raises
questions
significant
substantive
changes
including
introduction
term
construing
case
inserted
without
floor
debate
technical
amendments
original
senate
bill
mentioned
congressional
gao
sources
category
therefore
little
moment
neither
house
senate
committee
report
explained
federal
limitation
appropriate
subsequent
addition
administrative
sources
category
might
taken
sign
limitation
rejected
full
respondent
amici
place
particular
emphasis
remark
made
lead
sponsor
senate
bill
senator
grassley
see
brief
respondent
brief
brief
american
center
law
justice
amicus
curiae
brief
taxpayers
fraud
education
fund
amicus
curiae
floor
statement
grassley
said
term
definition
original
source
meant
include
government
source
disclosures
cited
public
disclosure
bar
government
includes
congress
general
accounting
office
executive
independent
agency
well
governmental
bodies
may
publicly
disclosed
allegations
cong
rec
yet
even
single
sentence
single
legislator
entitled
meaningful
weight
senator
grassley
remark
merely
begs
question
us
formulation
fails
indicate
whether
governmental
bodies
may
state
local
bodies
also
turns
term
government
capital
appear
codified
version
public
disclosure
bar
congress
subsequently
revised
numerous
respects
prior
passage
fact
one
item
legislative
record
squarely
corroborates
respondent
reading
statute
letter
sent
primary
sponsors
amendments
attorney
general
see
cong
rec
reproducing
text
letter
berman
grassley
state
intend
fair
reading
statute
confirm
disclosure
must
federal
criminal
civil
administrative
hearing
disclosure
state
proceeding
kind
bar
subsequent
qui
tam
suit
needless
say
letter
qualify
legislative
history
given
written
years
amendments
enacted
consequently
scant
value
doubt
congress
passed
amendments
fca
strengthen
government
hand
fighting
false
claims
cook
county
encourage
private
enforcement
suits
equally
beyond
cavil
however
congress
passed
public
disclosure
bar
bar
subset
suits
deemed
unmeritorious
downright
harmful
question
us
concerns
precise
scope
subset
matter
record
opaque
absence
specific
legislative
history
way
modifies
conventional
judicial
duty
give
faithful
meaning
language
congress
adopted
light
evident
legislative
purpose
enacting
law
question
bornstein
evident
legislative
purpose
guide
resolution
discrete
issue
confronts
us
respondent
amici
likewise
fail
prove
case
petitioners
reading
statute
lead
results
congress
intended
argument
rests
empirical
proposition
federal
inquiries
outcomes
readily
available
department
justice
doj
attorneys
many
state
local
reports
investigations
never
come
attention
federal
authorities
brief
see
also
federal
government
unlikely
learn
state
local
investigations
large
number
fraudulent
claims
government
go
unremedied
without
financial
incentives
offered
qui
tam
provisions
fca
proposition
implausible
sheer
conjecture
numerous
federal
investigations
may
occurring
given
time
doj
attorneys
may
reliably
learn
findings
doj
attorneys
may
learn
quite
state
local
inquiries
especially
inquiries
conducted
pursuant
joint
program
financed
part
federal
dollars
program
issue
accessible
attorney
general
typical
state
local
source
compared
federal
source
open
question
even
right
question
statutory
touchstone
whether
allegations
fraud
public
ly
disclos
ed
whether
landed
desk
doj
lawyer
respondent
argument
also
gives
insufficient
weight
congress
decision
bar
qui
tam
actions
based
disclosures
news
media
ibid
bar
prior
addition
news
media
category
forecloses
suggestion
amendments
implemented
intent
increase
availability
qui
tam
litigation
since
news
media
include
large
number
local
newspapers
radio
stations
category
likely
describes
multitude
sources
seldom
come
attention
attorney
general
respondent
amici
concern
local
governments
insulate
qui
tam
liability
careful
low
key
potential
fraud
brief
american
center
law
justice
amicus
curiae
argument
rests
speculation
indeed
rather
strained
speculation
disclosure
immunize
local
government
fca
liability
action
brought
see
rockwell
contrary
tip
attorney
general
action
might
fruitful
seems
us
petitioners
view
assert
iven
fact
submission
false
claim
subjects
defendant
criminal
liability
fines
debarment
treble
damages
attorneys
fees
rational
entity
prepare
report
fraud
sole
purpose
cutting
qui
tam
actions
reply
brief
petitioners
see
also
ex
rel
premo
fear
disclosures
unfounded
general
unlikely
agency
trying
cover
fraud
reveal
requisite
transactions
underlying
fraud
public
document
conclusion
buttressed
fact
congress
carefully
preserved
rights
deserving
qui
tam
plaintiffs
qualify
original
sources
notwithstanding
public
disclosure
allegations
made
qui
tam
plaintiff
case
may
go
forward
original
source
information
therefore
flat
wrong
suggest
finding
petitioners
effect
return
us
unduly
restrictive
government
knowledge
prevailed
prior
brief
quoting
dunleavy
see
brief
respondent
asserting
petitioners
construction
reimpose
form
knowledge
bar
capitalization
omitted
today
ruling
merely
confirms
disclosures
made
one
type
context
state
local
report
audit
investigation
may
trigger
public
disclosure
bar
bearing
disclosures
made
contexts
leaves
intact
ability
original
sources
prosecute
qui
tam
actions
irrespective
state
government
knowledge
whether
respondent
qualify
original
source
term
defined
one
many
issues
remain
open
remand
vi
respondent
solicitor
general
given
numerous
reasons
believe
reading
fca
moves
closer
golden
mean
inadequate
excessive
scope
private
enforcement
congress
may
well
endorsed
views
recent
amendment
public
disclosure
bar
see
supra
respect
version
us
however
conclude
term
administrative
category
limited
federal
sources
judgment
appeals
reversed
case
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
graham
county
soil
water
conservation
district
et
petitioners
ex
rel
karen
wilson
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
march
justice
scalia
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
join
parts
opinion
part
iv
agree
stray
snippets
legislative
history
respondent
solicitor
general
dissent
collected
prove
nothing
congress
purpose
enacting
ante
share
premise
history
make
difference
ante
quoting
bornstein
constitution
gives
legal
effect
laws
congress
enacts
art
vi
cl
objectives
members
aimed
achieve
voting
see
oncale
sundowner
offshore
services
text
includes
state
local
administrative
reports
audits
correctly
concludes
utterly
irrelevant
whether
members
congress
intended
otherwise
anyway
utterly
impossible
discern
members
congress
intended
except
extent
intent
manifested
remnant
history
bears
unanimous
endorsement
majority
house
text
enrolled
bill
became
law
graham
county
soil
water
conservation
district
et
petitioners
ex
rel
karen
wilson
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
march
justice
sotomayor
justice
breyer
joins
dissenting
false
claims
act
fca
divests
federal
courts
jurisdiction
hear
qui
tam
lawsuits
based
allegations
transactions
publicly
disclosed
congressional
administrative
government
accounting
office
gao
report
hearing
audit
investigation
unless
qui
tam
relator
original
source
information
omitted
today
reads
phrase
administrative
report
hearing
audit
investigation
encompass
federal
also
state
local
government
sources
view
misreads
statutory
text
gives
insufficient
weight
contextual
historical
evidence
congress
purpose
enacting
affirm
judgment
appeals
hold
administrative
provision
refers
federal
government
section
sets
forth
three
categories
public
disclosure
trigger
fca
jurisdictional
bar
allegations
transactions
criminal
civil
administrative
hearing
congressional
administrative
gao
report
hearing
audit
investigation
news
media
like
majority
inserted
arabic
numerals
refer
three
phrases
categories
canon
statutory
construction
words
statute
must
read
context
view
place
overall
statutory
scheme
fda
brown
williamson
tobacco
quoting
davis
michigan
dept
treasury
party
disputes
congressional
gao
refer
federal
government
sources
ante
nn
acknowledges
ante
word
administrative
capacious
potentially
reaching
federal
state
local
government
sources
also
disclosures
private
entities
see
black
law
dictionary
ed
defining
administrative
pertain
ing
administration
especially
management
execution
application
conduct
persons
things
like
appeals
view
congress
choice
two
clearly
federal
terms
bookend
federal
term
strong
contextual
cue
meaning
maxim
noscitur
sociis
inescapable
rule
often
wisely
applied
word
capable
many
meanings
order
avoid
giving
unintended
breadth
acts
congress
gutierrez
ada
quoting
jarecki
searle
immediate
proximity
congressional
gao
suggests
administrative
read
like
neighbors
referring
federal
government
sources
congress
intended
include
state
local
government
administrative
materials
said
instance
referring
generically
governmental
sources
see
applies
logic
underlies
noscitur
sociis
canon
concluding
administrative
refer
private
entities
meaning
suggested
slightly
distant
neighbors
report
hearing
audit
investigation
see
ante
agree
majority
administrative
context
reach
private
entities
view
congressional
gao
provide
better
textual
grounding
conclusion
see
reason
administrati
private
university
instance
issue
report
order
audit
investigation
conduct
hearing
contrary
majority
suggestion
private
entities
particularly
receiving
federal
funds
participating
federal
programs
incapable
making
public
disclosure
fraud
federal
government
despite
implicit
reliance
canon
nevertheless
rejects
appeals
application
noscitur
sociis
interpret
three
terms
category
concluding
list
three
items
quite
distinct
matter
construed
short
particularly
illuminating
ante
three
terms
category
concludes
disparate
justify
invocation
noscitur
sociis
ante
previously
constrained
canon
way
take
one
example
jarecki
construed
statutory
term
income
statute
defined
include
income
resulting
discovery
prospecting
quoting
internal
revenue
code
recognizing
word
usable
many
contexts
various
shades
meaning
observed
gathers
meaning
words
around
concluded
three
words
conjunction
describe
activity
oil
gas
mining
industries
result
light
contextual
evidence
supporting
conclusion
held
sales
newly
invented
drugs
camera
equipment
give
rise
abnormal
income
even
inventions
might
otherwise
understood
discover
ies
see
view
three
terms
category
distinct
disparate
ante
phrase
issue
jarecki
particularly
given
expansive
plain
meaning
discovery
cf
ante
application
noscitur
sociis
principle
readily
yields
common
feature
sources
issue
federal
nature
related
state
local
governments
private
entities
see
third
nat
bank
nashville
impac
limited
applying
principle
words
grouped
list
given
related
meaning
term
sandwiched
two
words
statutory
phrase
injunction
draws
additional
support
conclusion
reference
provision
larger
scheme
ante
sources
enumerated
categories
although
scope
category
us
today
although
never
addressed
question
believes
reading
category
limited
federal
government
sources
inconsistent
decisions
lower
courts
interpreted
criminal
civil
administrative
hearing
category
include
state
federal
proceedings
conflict
however
categories
read
respondent
solicitor
general
urge
exclusively
federal
see
brief
respondent
brief
amicus
curiae
even
reading
category
broadly
however
change
exclusively
federal
nature
congressional
gao
undermines
whatever
inference
might
drawn
taking
statutory
terms
strict
succession
treating
entirety
undifferentiated
list
items
gives
short
shrift
syntactical
choices
congress
made
offsetting
category
commas
prepositions
providing
distinct
classes
adjectives
modify
different
nouns
finally
also
views
news
media
distinctly
nonfederal
nature
ante
news
media
seem
particularly
illuminating
context
appeals
observed
although
media
sources
may
national
local
scope
distinction
analogous
difference
federal
state
government
sources
ii
view
statutory
context
legislative
history
also
less
opaque
cf
ante
supportive
reading
adopted
appeals
majority
today
acknowledges
legislative
record
concededly
incomplete
provide
reason
exercise
caution
giving
statutory
text
broadest
possible
meaning
encompass
federal
also
state
local
government
sources
three
points
particularly
salient
first
prior
amendments
government
knowledge
bar
unquestionably
referred
information
possession
federal
even
still
bar
criticized
overly
restrictive
senate
report
initial
version
legislation
instance
described
fca
history
need
legislative
reform
noting
several
restrictive
interpretations
act
tend
thwart
effectiveness
statute
hereinafter
instance
courts
applied
government
knowledge
bar
even
government
makes
effort
investigate
take
action
original
allegations
received
citing
ex
rel
lapin
international
business
machines
supp
haw
second
support
recognizes
proposition
congress
sought
amendments
broaden
availability
qui
tam
relief
senate
report
characterized
reform
effort
intended
enhance
government
ability
recover
losses
sustained
result
fraud
government
dwelt
length
severe
growing
problem
fraud
federal
programs
accord
evidence
fraud
government
programs
procurement
steady
rise
senate
report
also
articulated
desire
encourage
individual
knowing
government
fraud
bring
information
forward
identified
perhaps
serious
problem
plaguing
effective
enforcement
antifraud
laws
lack
resources
part
federal
enforcement
agencies
consistent
expressed
views
enacted
legislation
replete
provisions
encouraging
qui
tam
actions
replacing
government
knowledge
bar
current
text
including
exception
original
source
congress
allowed
private
parties
sue
even
based
information
already
government
possession
cook
county
ex
rel
chandler
amendments
also
established
right
qui
tam
relators
continue
party
suit
government
intervenes
ed
increased
percentage
recovery
available
incentive
private
suits
created
cause
action
employers
retaliate
qui
tam
relators
sure
congress
also
concerned
guarding
purely
opportunistic
parasitic
qui
tam
relators
see
describing
history
parasitic
suits
amendments
ante
lower
courts
viewed
amendments
striking
balance
twin
goals
rejecting
suits
government
capable
pursuing
promoting
government
equipped
bring
ex
rel
springfield
terminal
quinn
cadc
evidence
congress
sought
balance
two
competing
goals
supports
moderation
interpreting
arguably
ambiguous
statutory
text
rather
woodenly
reading
statutory
language
fullest
possible
extent
third
legislative
record
hint
bar
suits
based
disclosures
state
local
government
sources
brief
amicus
curiae
quoting
ex
rel
center
metro
westchester
supp
sdny
inclusion
state
local
government
sources
constituted
significant
departure
federal
government
knowledge
bar
existed
four
decades
neither
initial
bills
reported
senate
house
committees
statements
individual
members
congress
subsequent
versions
legislation
suggest
consideration
debate
expanding
bar
apply
state
local
government
although
points
definitively
resolve
question
presented
today
mind
counsel
reading
ed
broadly
disturb
balance
congress
evidently
sought
achieve
amendments
today
decision
risks
result
imposes
jurisdictional
bar
appearances
restrictive
qui
tam
suits
regime
construing
encompass
thousands
state
local
government
administrative
reports
produced
year
effectively
imputes
federal
government
knowledge
sources
whether
government
aware
information
position
act
solicitor
general
specifically
warns
information
federal
administrative
audits
investigations
readily
available
attorneys
department
justice
many
state
local
reports
investigations
never
come
attention
federal
authorities
brief
amicus
curiae
dismisses
concern
sheer
conjecture
postulating
government
lawyers
may
fact
learn
quite
state
local
reports
investigations
particularly
joint
ante
perhaps
absent
concrete
reason
believe
otherwise
readily
dismiss
formal
representation
executive
branch
entity
responsibility
practical
experience
litigating
fca
claims
behalf
sum
statute
plain
text
evidence
congress
intent
expand
qui
tam
actions
practical
consequences
expansive
interpretation
together
suggest
category
reasonably
read
encompass
federal
state
local
government
reasons
given
affirm
judgment
appeals
respectfully
dissent
footnotes
march
president
signed
law
patient
protection
affordable
care
act
pub
stat
section
legislation
replaces
prior
version
new
language
legislation
makes
mention
retroactivity
necessary
application
pending
cases
given
eliminates
petitioners
claimed
defense
qui
tam
suit
see
hughes
aircraft
ex
rel
schumer
throughout
opinion
use
present
tense
discussing
statute
existed
time
case
argued
compare
limiting
portion
public
disclosure
bar
federal
sources
ex
rel
dunleavy
county
delaware
ex
rel
premo
concluding
state
local
sources
may
qualify
cert
denied
battle
board
regents
state
per
curiam
assuming
without
analysis
state
audits
may
qualify
eighth
circuit
appears
taken
middle
road
issue
holding
disclosures
made
nonfederal
forums
may
count
report
instances
relate
cooperative
program
federal
government
provides
financial
assistance
hays
hoffman
cert
denied
see
rockwell
construing
original
source
exception
cook
county
ex
rel
chandler
holding
local
governments
subject
qui
tam
liability
vermont
agency
natural
resources
ex
rel
stevens
holding
subject
private
fca
actions
separate
statutory
provision
defines
original
source
individual
direct
independent
knowledge
information
allegations
based
voluntarily
provided
information
government
filing
action
section
based
information
see
art
cl
distinguishing
state
legislature
congress
statute
refers
gao
mistakenly
government
accounting
office
undisputed
intended
referent
general
accounting
office
renamed
government
accountability
office
see
compiler
note
ex
rel
mistick
pbt
housing
authority
pittsburgh
alito
cert
denied
see
also
mistick
becker
dissenting
noting
courts
frequently
made
scrivener
error
described
gao
independent
agency
within
legislative
branch
exists
large
part
serve
needs
congress
bowsher
merck
jarecki
searle
applied
noscitur
sociis
maxim
construing
statutory
provision
referred
ncome
resulting
exploration
discovery
prospecting
quoting
internal
revenue
code
justice
sotomayor
contends
three
terms
category
phrase
issue
jarecki
post
dissenting
opinion
citation
omitted
disagree
whether
taken
isolation
context
phrase
congressional
administrative
gao
cohesive
phrase
exploration
discovery
prospecting
one
reason
noscitur
sociis
proved
illuminating
jarecki
less
helpful
case
face
terms
exploration
discovery
prospecting
describe
processes
searching
seeking
speculating
centrality
activities
oil
gas
mining
industries
gave
clue
industries
congress
mind
drafted
provision
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
terms
congressional
administrative
gao
share
comparable
core
meaning
indeed
common
feature
post
apart
governmental
connotation
takes
sandwich
theory
graft
federal
limitation
onto
administrative
number
lower
courts
concluded
used
category
roughly
synonymous
ex
rel
springfield
terminal
quinn
cadc
see
also
boese
civil
false
claims
qui
tam
actions
ed
hereinafter
boese
sylvia
false
claims
act
fraud
government
hereinafter
sylvia
see
indeed
statute
seem
inconsistent
included
state
local
administrative
hearings
sources
public
disclosures
category
next
breath
excluded
state
administrative
reports
sources
natural
gas
royalties
qui
tam
litigation
supp
wyo
reason
conclude
congress
intended
limit
administrative
reports
audits
investigations
federal
actions
simultaneously
allowing
state
local
civil
litigation
state
local
administrative
hearings
state
local
news
media
treated
public
disclosures
interpret
statute
narrowly
anomalous
result
allowing
public
disclosure
status
obscure
local
news
report
obscure
state
local
civil
lawsuit
administrative
hearing
denying
public
disclosure
status
formal
public
report
state
government
agency
following
appeals
see
respondent
asserts
ninth
circuit
ambulance
california
explicitly
considered
rejected
argument
category
limited
federal
sources
brief
respondent
least
one
circuit
however
done
see
ex
rel
hafter
spectrum
emergency
care
lower
far
aware
much
suggested
alternative
construction
might
viable
moreover
third
fifth
eleventh
circuit
cases
cited
appeals
postdate
ambulance
dunleavy
put
litigants
courts
notice
possibility
might
limited
federal
sources
face
silent
whether
includes
nonfederal
proceedings
respondent
solicitor
general
suggest
though
fairly
argue
provision
relating
civil
investigative
demands
little
relevance
case
hand
see
brief
respondent
brief
appeals
repeatedly
referred
three
categories
clauses
see
fact
clauses
rather
prepositional
phrases
reliance
noscitur
sociis
might
supported
one
earliest
cases
using
term
watson
mercer
pet
reporter
statement
case
suggested
different
clauses
sentence
presumed
embrace
subject
matter
sentence
appeals
mistaken
reference
clauses
course
less
significant
failure
treat
public
disclosure
bar
integrated
whole
cf
stevens
shakespeare
canon
statutory
construction
rev
emphasizing
importance
reading
provisions
broader
statutory
context
see
also
pp
text
proposed
public
disclosure
bar
enacted
closely
resembles
version
senate
bill
state
governments
already
shielded
qui
tam
liability
precedent
stevens
see
dunleavy
congress
gave
us
little
specific
guidance
determine
scope
public
disclosure
sources
ex
rel
stinson
lyons
gerlin
bustamante
prudential
ins
bill
eventuated
amendments
underwent
substantial
revisions
legislative
path
provides
ample
opportunity
search
legislative
history
find
support
somewhere
almost
construction
many
ambiguous
terms
final
version
scirica
dissenting
one
difficulty
interpreting
amendments
congress
never
completely
clear
kind
suits
attempting
avoid
boese
present
section
enacted
without
explanation
congress
pplicable
legislative
history
explaining
versions
adopted
little
help
deciphering
provision
section
drafted
subsequent
completion
house
senate
committee
reports
proposed
false
claims
act
amendments
reports
contained
discussion
altogether
different
bars
used
interpreting
sponsors
interpretations
provision
ultimately
enacted
spare
often
incorrect
enough
provide
support
almost
construction
many
ambiguities
justice
sotomayor
makes
valiant
effort
unearth
legislative
history
balance
congress
evidently
sought
achieve
amendments
post
reconstruction
history
assigns
little
weight
side
balance
preserved
public
disclosure
bar
desire
minimize
potential
parasitic
lawsuits
learn
fraud
public
channels
seek
remuneration
although
contributed
nothing
exposure
fraud
ex
rel
doe
john
doe
narrative
contains
account
category
emerged
form
account
necessarily
exercise
speculation
record
silent
matter
view
neither
general
trajectory
fca
reform
specific
statements
made
legislative
process
clearly
point
one
way
question
us
see
consumer
product
safety
gte
sylvania
hamdan
rumsfeld
see
also
hafter
refusing
credit
letter
interpreting
public
disclosure
bar
respondent
amici
additionally
contend
enactment
program
fraud
civil
remedies
act
pfcra
stat
codified
et
seq
shortly
enactment
fca
amendments
supports
reading
latter
see
brief
respondent
brief
brief
taxpayers
fraud
education
fund
amicus
curiae
yet
question
pfcra
designed
operate
tandem
fca
stevens
pfcra
addressed
federal
administrative
agencies
also
explicit
evidence
suggest
congress
intended
limit
category
reference
administrative
sources
set
agencies
fca
public
disclosure
bar
serves
distinct
function
replicated
pfcra
text
public
disclosure
bar
contains
reference
pfcra
member
congress
far
aware
articulated
intent
instances
federal
law
dictates
state
local
governments
receiving
federal
funds
perform
audit
programs
see
requiring
nonfederal
entities
expend
federal
awards
certain
amount
undergo
single
audit
accordance
specified
conditions
brief
state
pennsylvania
et
al
amici
curiae
discussing
single
audit
act
bears
mention
extent
one
worried
federal
government
ignorance
state
local
antifraud
efforts
see
post
today
ruling
may
induce
federal
authorities
pay
closer
attention
efforts
going
forward
petitioners
amici
also
counter
public
policy
arguments
appeals
reading
statute
allege
increased
likelihood
parasitic
relators
beat
deserving
relators
courthouse
brief
petitioners
state
local
governments
find
antifraud
investigations
impeded
decline
conduct
investigations
first
place
account
opportunistic
potential
relators
trolling
state
records
reports
available
public
search
qui
tam
claim
brief
state
pennsylvania
et
al
amici
curiae
footnotes
notes
recent
legislation
amended
language
see
ante
citing
pub
stat
like
use
present
tense
throughout
opinion
discussing
statute
existed
time
case
argued
observes
enacting
congress
erroneously
referred
general
accounting
office
renamed
government
accountability
office
government
accounting
office
ante
relies
reiter
sonotone
proposition
three
terms
category
independent
ordinary
significance
ante
reiter
involved
statutory
term
business
property
two
words
less
readily
suggest
shared
limiting
principle
congressional
administrative
gao
moreover
concern
rob
bing
word
broader
meaning
rested
desire
ignore
disjunctive
statutory
pairing
see
also
canons
construction
ordinarily
suggest
terms
connected
disjunctive
given
separate
meanings
congress
employ
completely
disjunctive
list
congressional
administrative
gao
reiter
principle
applies
less
force
cf
garcia
applying
disjunctive
principle
construing
statutory
prohibition
assault
robbery
custodian
matter
money
property
observing
three
classes
property
separated
conjunction
quoting
emphasis
deleted
originally
enacted
bar
applied
suits
based
upon
evidence
information
possession
agency
officer
employee
thereof
time
suit
brought
stat
congress
recodified
provision
apply
suits
based
evidence
information
government
action
brought
stat
senate
report
also
discussed
ex
rel
wisconsin
dean
barred
wisconsin
bringing
qui
tam
suit
medicaid
fraud
state
previously
disclosed
information
federal
government
even
state
investigation
discovered
fraud
lower
courts
observed
dean
decision
controversial
appears
motivated
inclusion
original
source
exception
jurisdictional
bar
see
wang
fmc
see
also
noting
resolution
national
association
attorneys
general
criticizing
dean
urging
congress
address
problem
introducing
later
version
bill
senator
grassley
described
reform
effort
stemming
realization
government
needs
help
lots
help
adequately
protect
taxpayer
funds
growing
increasingly
sophisticated
fraud
cong
rec
see
also
ex
rel
siller
becton
dickinson
section
enacted
congress
come
conclusion
fraud
government
apparently
rampant
difficult
identify
government
use
help
get
private
citizens
knowledge
fraud
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
see
also
boese
civil
false
claims
qui
tam
actions
supp
irtually
changes
introduced
th
section
amendments
addressing
qui
tam
actions
expanded
rights
qui
tam
relators
amendments
also
contained
number
provisions
facilitating
enforcement
generally
lowering
requisite
showing
intent
making
clear
knowing
violations
require
proof
specific
intent
defraud
ed
lengthening
statute
limitations
authorizing
treble
damages
fairly
observes
addition
news
media
jurisdictional
bar
undercuts
attributing
congress
intent
expand
availability
qui
tam
relief
ante
neither
provision
support
reading
category
broadest
possible
extent
moreover
barring
suits
based
news
media
disclosures
may
constituted
particularly
significant
expansion
existing
law
courts
applied
government
knowledge
bar
dismiss
actions
based
information
reported
news
media
ex
rel
thompson
hays
supp
dc
dismissed
suit
based
evidence
gleaned
sources
news
media
received
widespread
public
attention
alleging
fraud
member
congress
department
justice
first
obtained
information
regarding
claims
result
washington
post
article
similarly
burmah
oil
per
curiam
characterized
government
knowledge
bar
discourag
ing
filing
actions
parties
information
contribute
merely
plagiarized
information
indictments
returned
courts
newspaper
stories
congressional
investigations
congress
reasonably
assumed
news
media
report
kinds
frauds
naturally
perhaps
result
reporting
come
government
attention
thus
already
covered
existing
law
june
house
committee
judiciary
reported
bill
barred
qui
tam
actions
based
information
government
disclosed
basis
allegations
made
prior
administrative
civil
criminal
proceeding
disclosed
course
congressional
investigation
disseminated
news
media
pp
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
references
information
disclosed
government
capital
congressional
investigation
connote
federal
state
local
government
sources
july
senate
committee
judiciary
reported
version
bill
barring
actions
based
upon
allegations
transactions
subject
civil
suit
government
already
party
within
six
months
disclosure
specific
information
relating
allegations
transactions
criminal
civil
administrative
hearing
congressional
government
accounting
office
report
hearing
news
media
reference
suits
federal
government
party
absence
ambiguous
term
administrative
bill
reference
congressional
gao
reports
hearings
similarly
tend
exclude
disclosures
state
local
government
reports
enacted
legislation
differ
several
respects
reported
bills
subsequent
legislative
record
contains
reference
inclusion
state
local
government
sources
see
cong
rec
statement
grassley
statements
glickman
berman
course
ed
speaks
public
disclosure
notice
government
requirement
public
disclosure
countenances
notice
public
otherwise
indeed
number
lower
courts
look
whether
federal
government
notice
alleged
fraud
concluding
particular
source
public
disclosure
allegations
transactions
see
ex
rel
poteet
medtronic
public
disclosure
reveals
fraud
information
sufficient
put
government
notice
likelihood
related
fraudulent
activity
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
alcan
elec
similar
ex
rel
fine
sandia
similar
observes
federal
law
requires
recipients
federal
funds
conduct
audits
ante
amici
point
auditing
reporting
requirements
single
audit
act
brief
state
pennsylvania
et
al
amici
curiae
hereinafter
brief
neither
amici
rebut
solicitor
general
pragmatic
observation
vague
summary
nature
many
reports
alert
federal
government
fraud
brief
amicus
curiae
majority
notes
passing
several
policy
arguments
advanced
petitioners
amici
ante
none
merits
much
weight
petitioners
concerned
race
courthouse
parasitic
relators
capitalize
information
released
state
local
government
report
disadvantage
insider
brief
petitioners
fca
provision
reflects
congress
explicit
policy
choice
encourage
prompt
filing
turn
prompt
recovery
defrauded
funds
amici
concerned
relators
may
interfere
ongoing
state
local
government
investigations
trolling
state
records
reports
evidence
fraud
brief
state
laws
exempt
materials
related
ongoing
civil
investigations
see
stat
ann
cum
supp
stat
tit
purdon
supp
event
fca
contains
provision
giving
state
local
governments
privileged
position
qui
tam
relators
respect
local
governments
defendants