thornton
argued
march
decided
may
officer
nichols
pull
petitioner
petitioner
parked
got
car
nichols
parked
accosted
petitioner
arrested
finding
drugs
pocket
incident
arrest
nichols
searched
petitioner
car
found
handgun
driver
seat
petitioner
charged
federal
drug
firearms
violations
denying
motion
suppress
firearm
fruit
unconstitutional
search
district
found
inter
alia
automobile
search
valid
new
york
belton
held
police
officer
makes
lawful
custodial
arrest
automobile
occupant
fourth
amendment
allows
officer
search
vehicle
passenger
compartment
contemporaneous
incident
arrest
petitioner
appealed
conviction
arguing
belton
limited
situations
officer
initiated
contact
arrestee
still
car
fourth
circuit
affirmed
held
belton
governs
even
officer
make
contact
person
arrested
left
vehicle
belton
placed
reliance
fact
officer
ordered
occupants
vehicle
initiated
contact
remained
within
simply
basis
conclude
span
area
generally
within
arrestee
immediate
control
determined
whether
arrestee
exited
vehicle
officer
direction
whether
officer
initiated
contact
car
relevant
aspects
arrest
suspect
next
vehicle
presents
identical
concerns
regarding
officer
safety
evidence
destruction
one
inside
petitioner
proposed
contact
initiation
rule
officers
decide
may
safer
effective
conceal
presence
suspect
left
car
unable
search
passenger
compartment
event
custodial
arrest
potentially
compromising
safety
placing
incriminating
evidence
risk
concealment
destruction
fourth
amendment
require
gamble
belton
allows
police
search
car
passenger
compartment
incident
lawful
arrest
occupants
recent
occupants
ibid
arrestee
status
recent
occupant
may
turn
temporal
spatial
relationship
car
time
arrest
search
certainly
turn
whether
inside
outside
car
officer
first
initiated
contact
although
contraband
passenger
compartment
likely
accessible
recent
occupant
need
clear
rule
readily
understood
police
depending
differing
estimates
items
within
arrestee
reach
particular
moment
justifies
sort
generalization
belton
enunciated
petitioner
rule
officer
determine
whether
actually
confronted
signaled
confrontation
suspect
car
whether
suspect
exited
car
unaware
reasons
unrelated
officer
presence
rule
inherently
subjective
highly
fact
specific
require
precisely
sort
ad
hoc
determinations
part
officers
field
reviewing
courts
belton
sought
avoid
pp
affirmed
rehnquist
delivered
opinion
except
kennedy
thomas
breyer
joined
opinion
full
joined
filed
opinion
concurring
part
scalia
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
ginsburg
joined
stevens
filed
dissenting
opinion
souter
joined
marcus
thornton
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
may
chief
justice
rehnquist
delivered
opinion
except
new
york
belton
held
police
officer
made
lawful
custodial
arrest
occupant
automobile
fourth
amendment
allows
officer
search
passenger
compartment
vehicle
contemporaneous
incident
arrest
granted
certiorari
twice
determine
whether
belton
rule
limited
situations
officer
makes
contact
occupant
occupant
inside
vehicle
whether
applies
well
officer
first
makes
contact
arrestee
latter
stepped
vehicle
reach
merits
either
two
cases
arizona
gant
vacating
remanding
reconsideration
light
state
dean
florida
thomas
dismissing
lack
jurisdiction
reach
question
conclude
belton
governs
even
officer
make
contact
person
arrested
left
vehicle
officer
deion
nichols
norfolk
virginia
police
department
uniform
driving
unmarked
police
car
first
noticed
petitioner
marcus
thornton
petitioner
slowed
avoid
driving
next
nichols
suspected
petitioner
knew
police
officer
reason
want
pull
next
suspicions
aroused
nichols
pulled
onto
side
street
petitioner
passed
petitioner
passed
nichols
ran
check
petitioner
license
tags
revealed
tags
issued
chevy
lincoln
town
car
model
car
petitioner
driving
nichols
opportunity
pull
petitioner
drove
parking
lot
parked
got
vehicle
nichols
saw
petitioner
leave
vehicle
pulled
behind
parked
patrol
car
accosted
petitioner
asked
driver
license
also
told
license
tags
match
vehicle
driving
petitioner
appeared
nervous
began
rambling
licking
lips
sweating
concerned
safety
nichols
asked
petitioner
narcotics
weapons
vehicle
petitioner
said
nichols
asked
petitioner
pat
petitioner
agreed
nichols
felt
bulge
petitioner
left
front
pocket
asked
illegal
narcotics
time
petitioner
stated
reached
pocket
pulled
two
individual
bags
one
containing
three
bags
marijuana
containing
large
amount
crack
cocaine
nichols
handcuffed
petitioner
informed
arrest
placed
back
seat
patrol
car
searched
petitioner
vehicle
found
bryco
handgun
driver
seat
grand
jury
charged
petitioner
possession
intent
distribute
cocaine
base
stat
possession
firearm
previously
convicted
crime
punishable
term
imprisonment
exceeding
one
year
possession
firearm
furtherance
drug
trafficking
crime
petitioner
sought
suppress
inter
alia
firearm
fruit
unconstitutional
search
hearing
district
denied
petitioner
motion
suppress
holding
automobile
search
valid
new
york
belton
supra
alternatively
nichols
conducted
inventory
search
automobile
jury
convicted
petitioner
three
counts
sentenced
months
imprisonment
years
supervised
release
petitioner
appealed
challenging
district
denial
suppression
motion
argued
belton
limited
situations
officer
initiated
contact
arrestee
still
occupant
car
appeals
fourth
circuit
affirmed
held
historical
rationales
search
incident
arrest
doctrine
need
disarm
suspect
order
take
custody
need
preserve
evidence
later
use
trial
quoting
knowles
iowa
require
belton
limited
solely
situations
suspects
still
vehicles
approached
police
noting
petitioner
conceded
close
proximity
temporally
spatially
vehicle
concluded
car
within
petitioner
immediate
control
thus
nichols
search
reasonable
granted
certiorari
affirm
belton
officer
overtook
speeding
vehicle
new
york
thruway
ordered
driver
pull
suspecting
occupants
possessed
marijuana
officer
directed
get
car
arrested
unlawful
possession
searched
searched
passenger
compartment
car
considered
constitutionally
permissible
scope
search
circumstances
sought
lay
workable
rule
governing
situation
first
referred
chimel
california
case
arrestee
arrested
home
described
scope
search
incident
lawful
arrest
person
arrestee
area
immediately
surrounding
case
dealing
scope
search
arrestee
person
rejected
suggestion
must
litigated
case
issue
whether
present
one
reasons
supporting
conduct
search
quoting
robinson
supra
similarly
courts
ha
found
workable
definition
within
immediate
control
arrestee
area
arguably
include
interior
automobile
arrestee
wa
recent
occupant
sought
set
forth
clear
rule
police
officers
citizens
alike
therefore
held
policeman
made
lawful
custodial
arrest
occupant
automobile
may
contemporaneous
incident
arrest
search
passenger
compartment
automobile
ibid
footnotes
omitted
holding
placed
reliance
fact
officer
belton
ordered
occupants
vehicle
initiated
contact
remained
within
find
factor
persuasive
distinguishing
current
situation
bears
logical
relationship
belton
rationale
simply
basis
conclude
span
area
generally
within
arrestee
immediate
control
determined
whether
arrestee
exited
vehicle
officer
direction
whether
officer
initiated
contact
remained
car
recognized
much
albeit
dicta
michigan
long
officers
observed
speeding
car
swerve
ditch
driver
exited
officers
met
rear
car
although
indication
officers
initiated
contact
driver
still
vehicle
observed
clear
officers
arrested
respondent
searched
passenger
compartment
new
york
belton
relevant
aspects
arrest
suspect
next
vehicle
presents
identical
concerns
regarding
officer
safety
destruction
evidence
arrest
one
inside
vehicle
officer
may
search
suspect
vehicle
belton
suspect
arrested
see
knowles
supra
custodial
arrest
fluid
danger
police
officer
flows
fact
arrest
attendant
proximity
stress
uncertainty
robinson
supra
emphasis
added
see
washington
chrisman
every
arrest
must
presumed
present
risk
danger
arresting
officer
stress
less
merely
arrestee
exited
car
officer
initiated
contact
arrestee
less
likely
attempt
lunge
weapon
destroy
evidence
outside
still
control
vehicle
either
case
officer
faces
highly
volatile
situation
make
little
sense
apply
two
different
rules
bottom
situation
circumstances
may
safer
effective
officers
conceal
presence
suspect
left
vehicle
certainly
judgment
officers
free
make
strictures
petitioner
proposed
contact
initiation
rule
officers
unable
search
car
passenger
compartment
event
custodial
arrest
potentially
compromising
safety
placing
incriminating
evidence
risk
concealment
destruction
fourth
amendment
require
gamble
petitioner
argues
however
belton
fail
provide
rule
applies
vehicle
occupants
brief
petitioner
belton
allows
police
search
passenger
compartment
vehicle
incident
lawful
custodial
arrest
occupants
recent
occupants
indeed
respondent
belton
inside
car
time
arrest
search
standing
highway
event
arrestee
status
recent
occupant
may
turn
temporal
spatial
relationship
car
time
arrest
certainly
turn
whether
inside
outside
car
moment
officer
first
initiated
contact
sure
contraband
passenger
compartment
likely
readily
accessible
recent
occupant
unlikely
case
petitioner
reached
driver
seat
gun
outside
automobile
firearm
passenger
compartment
general
inaccessible
contraband
passenger
compartment
belton
need
clear
rule
readily
understood
police
officers
depending
differing
estimates
items
within
reach
arrestee
particular
moment
justifies
sort
generalization
belton
officer
determines
probable
cause
make
arrest
reasonable
allow
officers
ensure
safety
preserve
evidence
searching
entire
passenger
compartment
rather
clarifying
constitutional
limits
belton
search
petitioner
contact
initiation
rule
obfuscate
petitioner
proposed
rule
officer
approaching
suspect
alighted
vehicle
determine
whether
actually
confronted
signaled
confrontation
suspect
remained
car
whether
suspect
exited
vehicle
unaware
reasons
unrelated
officer
presence
determination
inherently
subjective
highly
fact
specific
require
precisely
sort
ad
hoc
determinations
part
officers
field
reviewing
courts
belton
sought
avoid
experience
shown
rule
impracticable
refuse
adopt
long
arrestee
sort
recent
occupant
vehicle
petitioner
officers
may
search
vehicle
incident
judgment
appeals
affirmed
ordered
marcus
thornton
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
may
justice
concurring
part
join
opinion
although
opinion
logical
extension
holding
new
york
belton
write
separately
express
dissatisfaction
state
law
area
justice
scalia
forcefully
argues
post
opinion
concurring
judgment
lower
decisions
seem
treat
ability
search
vehicle
incident
arrest
recent
occupant
police
entitlement
rather
exception
justified
twin
rationales
chimel
california
erosion
direct
consequence
belton
shaky
foundation
approach
justice
scalia
proposes
appears
built
firmer
ground
reluctant
adopt
context
case
neither
government
petitioner
chance
speak
merit
marcus
thornton
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
may
justice
scalia
justice
ginsburg
joins
concurring
judgment
chimel
california
held
search
incident
arrest
justified
means
find
weapons
arrestee
might
use
evidence
might
conceal
destroy
accordingly
limited
searches
area
within
suspect
area
arrestee
might
reach
order
grab
weapon
evidentiary
ite
new
york
belton
set
forth
rule
arrests
automobile
occupants
holding
vehicle
entire
passenger
compartment
fact
generally
even
inevitably
within
arrestee
immediate
control
search
whole
compartment
justified
every
case
petitioner
car
searched
case
neither
anywhere
near
passenger
compartment
vehicle
rather
handcuffed
secured
back
officer
squad
car
risk
nevertheless
grab
weapon
evidentiary
ite
car
remote
extreme
effort
apply
current
doctrine
search
stretches
beyond
breaking
point
reason
join
opinion
see
three
reasons
search
case
might
justified
protect
officer
safety
prevent
concealment
destruction
evidence
none
ultimately
persuades
first
despite
handcuffed
secured
back
squad
car
petitioner
might
escaped
retrieved
weapon
evidence
vehicle
theory
calls
mind
judge
goldberg
reference
mythical
arrestee
possessed
skill
houdini
strength
hercules
frick
opinion
concurring
part
dissenting
part
endeavoring
ground
seemingly
speculative
fear
reality
points
total
seven
instances
past
years
state
federal
officers
attacked
weapons
handcuffed
formerly
handcuffed
arrestees
brief
instances
however
justify
search
authority
claimed
three
involved
arrestees
retrieved
weapons
concealed
person
see
sanders
two
instances
dept
justice
federal
bureau
investigation
uniform
crime
reports
law
enforcement
officers
killed
assaulted
three
involved
arrestees
seized
weapon
arresting
officer
see
sanders
supra
two
instances
dept
justice
federal
bureau
investigation
uniform
crime
reports
law
enforcement
officers
killed
assaulted
authority
search
arrestee
person
beyond
question
course
search
prevent
seizure
officer
gun
one
seven
instances
involved
handcuffed
arrestee
escaped
squad
car
retrieve
weapon
somewhere
else
plakas
drinski
suspect
jumped
squad
car
ran
forest
house
still
handcuffs
struck
officer
wrist
fireplace
poker
ultimately
shot
dead
course
government
need
document
specific
instances
order
justify
measures
avoid
obvious
risks
risk
far
obvious
context
frequently
recurring
roadside
arrests
government
inability
come
even
single
example
handcuffed
arrestee
retrieval
arms
evidence
vehicle
undermines
claims
risk
suspect
handcuffed
back
squad
car
might
escape
recover
weapon
vehicle
surely
greater
risk
suspect
handcuffed
residence
might
escape
recover
weapon
next
room
danger
held
insufficient
justify
search
chimel
supra
second
defense
search
case
since
officer
conducted
search
time
arrest
suspect
still
near
car
penalized
taken
sensible
precaution
securing
suspect
squad
car
first
one
appeals
put
make
sense
prescribe
constitutional
test
entirely
odds
safe
sensible
police
procedures
mitchell
quoting
karlin
see
also
wesley
cadc
weakness
argument
assumes
one
way
another
search
must
take
place
conducting
chimel
search
government
right
exception
justified
necessity
rule
otherwise
render
search
unlawful
sensible
police
procedures
require
suspects
handcuffed
put
squad
cars
police
handcuff
suspects
put
squad
cars
conduct
search
indeed
officer
leaves
suspect
unrestrained
nearby
manufacture
authority
search
one
argue
search
unreasonable
precisely
dangerous
conditions
justifying
existed
virtue
officer
failure
follow
sensible
procedures
third
defense
search
even
though
arrestee
posed
risk
belton
searches
general
reasonable
benefits
rule
justify
upholding
small
minority
searches
particular
facts
reasonable
validity
argument
rests
accuracy
belton
claim
passenger
compartment
fact
generally
even
inevitably
within
suspect
immediate
control
admission
however
practice
restraining
arrestee
scene
searching
car
occupied
prevalent
holding
belton
apply
setting
render
belton
dead
letter
brief
quoting
wesley
supra
reported
cases
involving
precise
factual
scenario
motorist
handcuffed
secured
back
squad
car
search
takes
place
legion
see
doward
white
mitchell
supra
snook
mclaughlin
humphrey
wesley
supra
see
also
lafave
search
seizure
pp
ed
supp
citing
cases
courts
uphold
searches
even
squad
car
carrying
handcuffed
arrestee
already
left
scene
see
mclaughlin
supra
upholding
search
five
minutes
elapsed
since
squad
car
left
popularity
practice
hard
fathom
belton
entitles
officer
search
vehicle
upon
arresting
driver
despite
taken
measures
eliminate
danger
rational
officer
take
measures
cf
moskovitz
rule
search
reason
empirical
reexamination
chimel
belton
rev
citing
police
training
materials
ever
true
passenger
compartment
fact
generally
even
inevitably
within
arrestee
immediate
control
time
search
certainly
true
today
one
judge
put
search
clarity
abandoned
constitutional
moorings
floated
place
law
approves
purely
exploratory
searches
vehicles
officers
definite
objective
reason
search
allowed
rummage
around
car
see
might
find
mclaughlin
supra
trott
concurring
agree
entirely
assessment
ii
belton
searches
justifiable
arrestee
might
grab
weapon
evidentiary
item
car
simply
car
might
contain
evidence
relevant
crime
arrested
general
sort
search
without
antecedent
example
rabinowitz
upheld
search
suspect
place
business
arrested
restrict
officers
search
authority
area
arrestee
might
reach
order
grab
weapon
evidentiary
ite
chimel
marron
agnello
cf
weeks
numerous
earlier
authorities
support
approach
referring
general
interest
gathering
evidence
related
crime
arrest
mention
specific
interest
preventing
concealment
destruction
see
wilson
cc
sdny
smith
jerome
misc
thornton
state
ex
parte
hurn
thatcher
weeks
wharton
criminal
procedure
pp
kerr
ed
bishop
criminal
procedure
ed
cf
spalding
preston
seizure
authority
queen
frost
car
king
kinsey
car
king
car
king
barnett
car
bishop
articulation
typical
officer
arrests
man
criminal
charge
consider
nature
charge
finds
prisoner
person
otherwise
possession
either
goods
moneys
reason
believe
connected
supposed
crime
fruits
instruments
committed
directly
furnishing
evidence
relating
transaction
may
take
hold
disposed
may
direct
bishop
supra
years
leading
chimel
start
consistently
referring
narrower
interest
frustrating
concealment
destruction
evidence
see
sibron
new
york
preston
nothing
irrational
broader
police
authority
search
evidence
perpetrator
crime
lawfully
arrested
fact
prior
lawful
arrest
distinguishes
arrestee
society
large
distinguishes
search
evidence
crime
general
rummaging
moreover
illogical
assume
evidence
crime
likely
found
suspect
apprehended
nevertheless
chimel
narrower
focus
concealment
destruction
evidence
also
historical
support
see
holker
hennessey
mo
dillon
cox
ex
div
ire
reifsnyder
lee
iowa
welch
essay
office
constable
authorities
supporting
broader
rule
address
searches
arrestee
person
chimel
limitation
might
fairly
implicit
moreover
carried
logical
end
broader
rule
hard
reconcile
influential
case
entick
carrington
tr
disapproving
search
plaintiff
private
papers
general
warrant
despite
arrest
cf
dillon
supra
distinguishing
entick
warden
md
penitentiary
hayden
short
rabinowitz
chimel
plausible
accounts
constitution
requires
neither
persuasive
justify
departing
settled
law
going
continue
allow
belton
searches
stare
decisis
grounds
least
honest
belton
reasonably
explained
mere
application
chimel
rather
return
broader
sort
search
incident
arrest
allowed
chimel
limited
course
searches
motor
vehicles
category
effects
give
rise
reduced
expectation
privacy
see
wyoming
houghton
heightened
law
enforcement
needs
see
rabinowitz
frankfurter
dissenting
recasting
belton
terms
least
one
important
practical
consequence
robinson
held
authority
search
arrestee
person
depend
actual
presence
one
chimel
two
rationales
particular
case
rather
fact
arrest
alone
justifies
search
holding
stands
contrast
rabinowitz
treat
fact
arrest
alone
sufficient
upheld
search
noting
general
exploratory
whatever
might
turned
reflected
reasonable
belief
evidence
found
cf
knowles
iowa
therefore
limit
belton
searches
cases
reasonable
believe
evidence
relevant
crime
arrest
might
found
vehicle
case
belton
petitioner
lawfully
arrested
drug
offense
reasonable
officer
nichols
believe
contraband
similar
evidence
relevant
crime
arrested
might
found
vehicle
alighted
still
within
vicinity
time
arrest
affirm
decision
marcus
thornton
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
may
justice
stevens
justice
souter
joins
dissenting
prior
decision
new
york
belton
widespread
conflict
among
federal
state
courts
question
whether
course
search
incident
lawful
custodial
arrest
occupants
automobile
police
may
search
inside
automobile
arrestees
longer
answering
question
expanded
authority
police
two
important
respects
allowed
police
conduct
broader
search
decision
chimel
california
authorized
open
closed
containers
might
found
vehicle
passenger
belton
basic
rationale
expansions
rested
concern
officer
safety
rather
overriding
desire
hew
straightforward
rule
easily
applied
predictably
enforced
dissenting
opinion
remain
convinced
aspect
belton
opinion
unnecessary
erroneous
whether
one
agrees
disagrees
view
however
interest
certainty
supports
belton
rule
surely
justify
expansion
rule
blurs
clear
lines
neither
rule
chimel
belton
modification
rule
allowed
search
petitioner
car
fair
reading
belton
opinion
conflicting
cases
gave
rise
grant
certiorari
makes
clear
concerned
situation
presented
case
belton
noted
lower
courts
discovered
chimel
principle
difficult
apply
context
automobile
searches
incident
arrest
straightforward
rule
ha
emerged
litigated
cases
none
cases
cited
demonstrate
disarray
lower
courts
involved
pedestrian
vicinity
outside
reaching
distance
decisions
cited
petition
writ
present
thus
belton
demonstrably
concerned
narrow
common
circumstance
search
occasioned
arrest
suspect
seated
driving
automobile
time
law
enforcement
official
approached
normally
arrest
occurred
officer
safety
longer
jeopardy
must
decide
search
incriminating
evidence
conduct
belton
provided
previously
unavailable
therefore
necessary
guidance
category
cases
rule
crafted
belton
needed
cases
arrestee
first
accosted
pedestrian
chimel
provides
guidance
necessary
genuine
justification
extending
belton
cover
circumstances
interest
uncovering
potentially
valuable
evidence
opinion
goal
must
give
way
citizen
constitutionally
protected
interest
privacy
already
place
rule
limiting
permissible
scope
search
arrested
pedestrian
chimel
rule
provide
protection
recent
occupant
vehicle
recent
occupant
house
unwilling
confine
belton
rule
narrow
class
cases
designed
address
extends
belton
reach
without
supplying
guidance
future
application
swollen
rule
told
officers
may
search
vehicle
incident
arrest
long
arrestee
sort
occupant
vehicle
petitioner
ante
told
recent
recent
close
close
perhaps
case
record
clear
cautioned
belton
hen
person
know
apply
settled
principle
recurring
factual
situation
person
know
scope
constitutional
protection
policeman
know
scope
authority
without
limiting
principle
fear
today
decision
contribute
massive
broadening
automobile
exception
robbins
stevens
dissenting
officers
probable
cause
arrest
individual
search
car
accordingly
respectfully
dissent
footnotes
appeals
reach
district
alternative
holding
nichols
conducted
lawful
inventory
search
petitioner
argues
reject
proposed
contact
initiation
rule
limit
scope
belton
recent
occupants
within
reaching
distance
car
brief
petitioner
decline
address
petitioner
argument
however
outside
question
granted
certiorari
see
rule
addressed
appeals
see
peralta
heights
medical
center
note
unlikely
petitioner
even
meet
standard
apparently
conceded
appeals
close
proximity
temporally
spatially
vehicle
approached
nichols
justice
stevens
contends
belton
rule
needed
cases
arrestee
first
accosted
pedestrian
chimel
california
provides
guidance
necessary
post
dissenting
opinion
justice
stevens
approach
however
even
car
within
arrestee
reaching
distance
chimel
police
officers
courts
still
determine
whether
particular
object
within
passenger
compartment
also
within
arrestee
reaching
distance
chimel
exactly
type
unworkable
inquiry
belton
rejected
holding
entire
passenger
compartment
may
searched
area
within
immediate
control
arrestee
arguably
includes
interior
automobile
arrestee
recent
occupant
whatever
merits
justice
scalia
opinion
concurring
judgment
wrong
case
address
petitioner
never
argued
belton
limited
cases
reasonable
believe
evidence
relevant
crime
arrest
might
found
vehicle
post
consider
justice
scalia
reasoning
see
pennsylvania
dept
corrections
yeskey
issues
neither
raised
considered
appeals
ordinarily
consider
quoting
adickes
kress
question
presented
hether
rule
announced
new
york
belton
confined
situations
police
initiate
contact
occupant
vehicle
person
vehicle
pet
fairly
encompass
justice
scalia
analysis
see
rule
questions
set
petition
fairly
included
therein
considered
never
opportunity
respond
approach
see
yee
escondido
circumstances
imprudent
overrule
intents
purposes
established
constitutional
precedent
governs
police
authority
common
occurrence
automobile
searches
pursuant
arrest
decline
time
footnotes
characterize
entire
office
defendant
immediate
control
used
term
broader
sense
one
acquired
chimel
compare
chimel
rationale
pedigree
see
thornton
state
ex
parte
hurn
closson
morrison
leigh
cole
cox
oxford
cir
welch
essay
office
constable
asserts
opinion
goes
beyond
scope
question
presented
citing
rule
ante
rule
however
constrain
authority
reach
issues
presented
case
see
vance
terrazas
tennessee
student
assistance
hood
slip
event
apply
issue
necessary
intelligent
resolution
question
presented
see
ohio
robinette
footnotes
gleaned
case
law
generalization
articles
inside
relatively
narrow
compass
passenger
compartment
automobile
fact
generally
even
inevitably
within
area
arrestee
might
reach
order
grab
weapon
evidentiary
ite
belton
quoting
chimel
order
establish
workable
rule
category
cases
require
read
chimel
definition
limits
area
may
searched
light
generalization
thus
belton
held
policeman
made
lawful
custodial
arrest
occupant
automobile
may
contemporaneous
incident
arrest
search
passenger
compartment
automobile
omitted
police
lawfully
may
search
passenger
compartment
automobile
reasoned
followed
police
may
also
examine
contents
containers
found
within
passenger
compartment
passenger
compartment
within
reach
arrestee
also
containers
within
reach
container
may
course
searched
whether
open
closed
since
justification
search
arrestee
privacy
interest
container
lawful
custodial
arrest
justifies
infringement
privacy
interest
arrestee
may
omitted
extolled
virtues
single
familiar
standard
guide
police
officers
limited
time
expertise
reflect
balance
social
individual
interests
involved
specific
circumstances
confront
quoting
dunaway
new
york
robbins
companion
case
belton
held
police
officers
open
closed
opaque
containers
found
trunk
car
lawful
warrantless
search
plurality
opinion
officer
robbins
probable
cause
believe
car
contained
marijuana
applied
automobile
exception
sustain
search
dissenting
opinion
expressed
concern
authorizing
police
officers
search
containers
passenger
compartment
without
probable
cause
provide
constitutional
predicate
broader
vehicle
searches
neutral
magistrate
authorize
issuing
warrant
ibid
see
benson
defendant
arrested
sitting
car
sanders
occupants
car
time
officers
approached
rigales
defendant
apprehended
traffic
stop
dixon
agents
placed
appellant
arrest
still
car
frick
defendant
arrested
car
parking
lot
adjacent
apartment
building
time
arrest
attaché
case
question
lying
back
seat
car
approximately
two
feet
defendant
readily
accessible
hinkel
anchorage
alaska
defendant
arrested
car
immediately
following
collision
ulesky
state
app
defendant
arrested
car
traffic
stop
pet
cert
new
york
belton
see
agostino
suspect
car
notified
police
presence
neumann
defendant
stopped
police
car
foster
cadc
suspects
seated
parked
car
approached
officer
state
hunter
defendant
pulled
arrested
car
state
wilkens
la
defendant
arrested
automobile