bnsf
railway
tyrrell
special
administrator
estate
tyrrell
deceased
et
argued
april
decided
may
federal
employers
liability
act
fela
et
makes
railroads
liable
money
damages
employees
injuries
respondent
robert
nelson
north
dakota
resident
brought
fela
suit
petitioner
bnsf
railway
company
bnsf
montana
state
alleging
sustained
injuries
working
bnsf
respondent
kelli
tyrrell
appointed
south
dakota
administrator
husband
brent
tyrrell
estate
also
sued
bnsf
fela
montana
state
alleging
brent
developed
fatal
cancer
exposure
carcinogenic
chemicals
working
bnsf
neither
worker
injured
montana
neither
incorporated
headquartered
bnsf
maintains
less
work
force
total
track
mileage
state
contending
home
montana
required
exercise
general
personal
jurisdiction
daimler
ag
bauman
bnsf
moved
dismiss
suits
motion
granted
nelson
case
denied
tyrrell
consolidating
two
cases
montana
held
montana
courts
exercise
general
personal
jurisdiction
bnsf
railroad
id
business
state
within
meaning
found
within
state
within
compass
mont
rule
civ
proc
due
process
limits
articulated
daimler
added
control
daimler
involve
fela
claim
railroad
defendant
held
section
address
personal
jurisdiction
railroads
pp
section
first
relevant
sentence
provides
action
may
brought
district
among
places
district
defendant
shall
business
time
commencing
action
comprehended
sentence
venue
prescription
one
governing
personal
jurisdiction
baltimore
ohio
kepner
congress
generally
uses
expression
suit
may
brought
indicate
federal
districts
venue
proper
see
typically
provides
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
authorizing
service
process
see
nelson
tyrrell
contend
judiciary
act
provision
prompted
enactment
concerned
personal
jurisdiction
venue
long
read
judiciary
act
provision
concern
venue
see
green
chicago
pp
second
relevant
sentence
jurisdiction
courts
chapter
shall
concurrent
courts
several
refers
concurrent
jurisdiction
state
federal
courts
fela
actions
see
second
employers
liability
cases
congress
added
clarification
connecticut
held
congress
intended
confine
fela
litigation
federal
courts
state
courts
obligation
entertain
fela
claims
pp
none
cases
featured
montana
reaching
contrary
conclusion
resolved
question
personal
jurisdiction
pope
atlantic
coast
line
miles
illinois
central
kepner
denver
rio
grande
western
terte
distinguished
moreover
cases
save
pope
decided
transformative
decision
personal
jurisdiction
international
shoe
washington
pp
montana
courts
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
montana
law
comport
fourteenth
amendment
due
process
clause
propriety
general
personal
jurisdiction
issue
neither
nelson
tyrrell
alleges
injury
work
related
montana
state
may
exercise
general
jurisdiction
corporations
affiliations
state
systematic
render
essentially
home
forum
state
daimler
paradigm
forums
corporate
defendant
home
corporation
place
incorporation
principal
place
business
exceptional
case
corporate
defendant
operations
another
forum
may
substantial
nature
render
corporation
home
state
daimler
involved
fela
claim
railroad
defendant
due
process
constraint
described
applies
assertions
general
jurisdiction
nonresident
defendants
constraint
vary
type
claim
asserted
business
enterprise
sued
bnsf
incorporated
headquartered
montana
activity
substantial
nature
render
corporation
home
state
ibid
pp
mont
reversed
remanded
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
roberts
kennedy
thomas
breyer
alito
kagan
gorsuch
joined
sotomayor
filed
opinion
concurring
part
dissenting
part
opinion
notice
opinion
subject
formal
revision
publication
preliminary
print
reports
readers
requested
notify
reporter
decisions
washington
typographical
formal
errors
order
corrections
may
made
preliminary
print
goes
press
bnsf
railway
petitioner
kelli
tyrrell
special
administrator
estate
brent
tyrrell
deceased
et
al
writ
certiorari
montana
may
justice
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
two
cases
decide
today
arise
federal
employers
liability
act
fela
stat
amended
et
makes
railroads
liable
money
damages
employees
injuries
suits
pursued
montana
state
courts
although
injured
workers
reside
montana
injured
defendant
railroad
bnsf
railway
company
bnsf
although
business
montana
litigation
commenced
incorporated
montana
maintain
principal
place
business
state
justify
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
bnsf
montana
relied
provides
relevant
part
chapter
action
may
brought
district
district
residence
defendant
cause
action
arose
defendant
shall
business
time
commencing
action
jurisdiction
courts
chapter
shall
concurrent
courts
several
hold
address
personal
jurisdiction
railroads
first
relevant
sentence
venue
prescription
governing
proper
locations
fela
suits
filed
federal
provision
second
relevant
sentence
using
term
concurrent
jurisdiction
refers
jurisdiction
personal
jurisdiction
simply
clarifies
federal
courts
exclusive
jurisdiction
fela
suits
state
courts
hear
montana
alternative
relied
state
law
personal
jurisdiction
asserted
persons
found
within
montana
mont
rule
civ
proc
bnsf
fit
bill
stated
miles
railroad
track
employs
workers
montana
precedent
however
explains
fourteenth
amendment
due
process
clause
permit
state
hale
corporation
courts
corporation
home
state
occurred
elsewhere
daimler
ag
bauman
slip
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
therefore
reverse
judgment
montana
march
respondent
robert
nelson
north
dakota
resident
brought
fela
suit
bnsf
montana
state
recover
damages
knee
injuries
nelson
allegedly
sustained
working
bnsf
driver
mont
may
respondent
kelli
tyrrell
appointed
south
dakota
administrator
husband
brent
tyrrell
estate
similarly
sued
bnsf
fela
montana
state
brent
tyrrell
widow
alleged
developed
fatal
kidney
cancer
exposure
carcinogenic
chemicals
working
bnsf
neither
plaintiff
alleged
injuries
arising
related
work
performed
montana
indeed
neither
nelson
brent
tyrrell
appears
ever
worked
bnsf
montana
bnsf
incorporated
delaware
principal
place
business
texas
operates
railroad
lines
dv
jud
yellowstone
app
pet
cert
bnsf
miles
railroad
track
montana
total
track
mileage
employs
workers
less
total
work
force
generates
less
total
revenue
state
maintains
one
automotive
facilities
montana
ibid
contending
home
montana
required
exercise
general
personal
jurisdiction
daimler
ag
bauman
slip
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
bnsf
moved
dismiss
suits
lack
personal
jurisdiction
motion
granted
nelson
case
denied
tyrrell
consolidating
two
cases
montana
held
montana
courts
exercise
general
personal
jurisdiction
bnsf
section
determined
authorizes
state
courts
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
railroads
business
state
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
addition
observed
montana
law
provides
exercise
general
jurisdiction
persons
found
within
state
quoting
mont
rule
civ
proc
view
railroad
many
employees
miles
track
montana
concluded
bnsf
business
found
within
state
fela
montana
law
authorized
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
due
process
limits
articulated
daimler
added
control
daimler
involve
fela
claim
railroad
defendant
justice
mckinnon
dissented
section
wrote
venue
prescription
also
confers
jurisdiction
state
courts
fela
cases
concurrent
federal
courts
maintained
touch
concern
personal
jurisdiction
ibid
furthermore
concluded
daimler
controls
rendering
montana
courts
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
impermissible
bnsf
home
montana
granted
certiorari
resolve
whether
authorizes
state
courts
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
railroads
business
incorporated
headquartered
whether
montana
courts
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
cases
comports
due
process
ii
nelson
tyrrell
contend
first
relevant
sentence
confers
personal
jurisdiction
federal
courts
section
second
relevant
sentence
extends
grant
jurisdiction
state
courts
neither
contention
tenable
section
first
relevant
sentence
concerns
venue
next
sentence
speaks
first
sentence
action
may
brought
district
among
places
district
defendant
shall
business
time
commencing
action
baltimore
ohio
kepner
comprehended
clause
establish
ing
venue
action
congress
explained
designed
expand
venue
beyond
limits
judiciary
act
general
venue
provision
allowed
suit
districts
defendant
inhabitant
see
act
stat
nowhere
kepner
decision
intimate
might
affect
personal
jurisdiction
congress
generally
uses
expression
suit
may
brought
indicate
federal
districts
venue
proper
see
general
venue
statute
specifying
civil
action
may
brought
oakley
ali
fed
judicial
code
rev
project
listing
special
venue
statutes
many
similar
language
see
also
kepner
frankfurter
dissenting
phrasing
follows
familiar
pattern
generally
employed
congress
framing
venue
contrast
congress
typical
mode
providing
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
authorize
service
process
see
clayton
act
provision
stating
process
cases
corporation
arising
federal
antitrust
laws
may
served
district
defendant
inhabitant
wherever
defendant
may
found
federal
trade
commission
act
process
may
served
person
partnership
corporation
wherever
may
found
see
also
omni
capital
rudolf
wolff
discussing
statutes
authorize
fail
authorize
nationwide
service
process
cf
schlanger
seamans
though
congress
provided
nationwide
service
process
supp
statute
meant
expand
venue
personal
jurisdiction
congress
uses
terminology
absent
consent
basis
service
summons
defendant
prerequisite
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
see
omni
capital
nelson
tyrrell
however
argue
relates
personal
jurisdiction
view
judiciary
act
provision
prompted
enactment
stat
concerned
personal
jurisdiction
venue
according
house
senate
reports
contend
two
cases
brought
congress
attention
problem
prior
provision
namely
cases
authorized
suit
district
defendant
residence
brief
respondents
see
citing
macon
grocery
atlantic
coast
line
cound
atchison
wd
tex
cases
courts
dismissed
fela
suits
want
jurisdiction
macon
grocery
cound
avert
jurisdictional
dismissals
urge
congress
enacted
legislative
history
throws
little
light
kepner
driving
today
decision
long
read
judiciary
act
provision
concern
venue
see
green
chicago
analyzing
personal
jurisdiction
separately
concluding
venue
proper
judiciary
act
provision
see
also
lee
chesapeake
ohio
noting
materially
identical
successor
judiciary
act
provision
act
mar
stat
relates
venue
suits
indeed
reading
judiciary
act
provision
authorize
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
yielded
anomalous
result
diversity
cases
provision
allowed
suit
district
residence
either
plaintiff
defendant
stat
interpreting
clause
provide
jurisdiction
allowed
plaintiff
hale
defendant
plaintiff
home
district
even
district
one
defendant
affiliation
connection
second
sentence
point
provides
jurisdiction
courts
chapter
shall
concurrent
courts
several
nelson
tyrrell
argue
sentence
extends
state
courts
first
sentence
alleged
conferral
personal
jurisdiction
federal
courts
discussed
first
sentence
concerns
venue
confers
personal
jurisdiction
understood
second
sentence
provide
concurrent
jurisdiction
state
federal
courts
actions
fela
see
second
employers
liability
cases
nelson
tyrrell
acknowledge
congress
added
provision
confirm
concurrent
jurisdiction
connecticut
held
congress
intended
confine
fela
litigation
federal
courts
state
courts
obligation
entertain
fela
claims
see
brief
respondents
citing
hoxie
new
york
justice
mckinnon
recognized
dissent
montana
decision
nelson
tyrrell
cases
phrase
jurisdiction
term
art
long
employed
congress
courts
refer
jurisdiction
personal
jurisdiction
see
mims
arrow
financial
services
llc
federal
state
courts
concurrent
jurisdiction
private
suits
arising
telephone
consumer
protection
act
claflin
houseman
state
courts
retain
concurrent
jurisdiction
suits
bankrupt
party
involved
notwithstanding
exclusive
federal
jurisdiction
bankruptcy
matters
pointing
quartet
cases
montana
observed
consistently
interpreted
allow
state
courts
hear
cases
brought
fela
even
basis
jurisdiction
railroad
business
forum
tate
citing
pope
atlantic
coast
line
miles
illinois
central
kepner
denver
rio
grande
western
terte
none
decisions
featured
montana
resolved
question
personal
jurisdiction
terte
held
fela
plaintiff
injured
colorado
bring
suit
missouri
state
railroad
incorporated
elsewhere
dispute
however
dormant
commerce
clause
personal
jurisdiction
railroad
defendants
argued
suit
unduly
burden
interstate
commerce
decision
rested
two
commerce
clause
decisions
michigan
central
mix
hoffman
missouri
ex
rel
foraker
interpretation
see
terte
kepner
miles
held
state
may
based
inconvenience
railroad
defendant
enjoin
residents
bringing
fela
suit
another
state
federal
kepner
state
miles
courts
kepner
miles
pope
held
provision
transfer
one
federal
another
bear
question
decided
miles
state
still
enjoin
fela
action
brought
another
state
courts
moreover
cases
save
pope
decided
transformative
decision
personal
jurisdiction
international
shoe
washington
see
daimler
slip
cautioning
reliance
cases
decided
era
dominated
territorial
thinking
pennoyer
neff
iii
fela
authorize
state
courts
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
railroad
solely
ground
railroad
business
montana
courts
assertion
personal
jurisdiction
bnsf
must
rest
mont
rule
civ
proc
state
provision
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
persons
found
montana
see
supra
bnsf
contest
found
within
montana
state
courts
comprehend
rule
therefore
inquire
whether
montana
courts
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
montana
law
comports
due
process
clause
fourteenth
amendment
international
shoe
explained
state
may
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
defendant
certain
minimum
contacts
state
maintenance
suit
offend
notions
fair
play
substantial
justice
elaborating
guide
distinguished
specific
jurisdiction
general
jurisdiction
see
daimler
slip
goodyear
dunlop
tires
operations
brown
helicopteros
nacionales
de
colombia
hall
nn
neither
nelson
tyrrell
alleges
injury
work
related
montana
propriety
general
jurisdiction
issue
goodyear
daimler
clarified
may
assert
general
jurisdiction
foreign
corporations
hear
claims
affiliations
state
systematic
render
essentially
home
forum
state
daimler
slip
quoting
goodyear
paradigm
forums
corporate
defendant
home
explained
corporation
place
incorporation
principal
place
business
daimler
slip
goodyear
exercise
general
jurisdiction
limited
forums
exceptional
case
corporate
defendant
operations
another
forum
may
substantial
nature
render
corporation
home
state
daimler
slip
suggested
perkins
benguet
consol
mining
exemplified
case
daimler
slip
perkins
war
forced
defendant
corporation
owner
temporarily
relocate
enterprise
philippines
ohio
ohio
became
center
corporation
wartime
activities
daimler
slip
suit
proper
perkins
montana
distinguished
daimler
ground
confront
fela
claim
railroad
defendant
fourteenth
amendment
due
process
constraint
described
daimler
however
applies
assertions
general
jurisdiction
nonresident
defendants
constraint
vary
type
claim
asserted
business
enterprise
bnsf
repeat
incorporated
montana
maintain
principal
place
business
bnsf
heavily
engaged
activity
montana
render
essentially
home
state
see
daimler
slip
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
earlier
noted
bnsf
miles
railroad
track
employees
montana
observed
daimler
general
jurisdiction
inquiry
focus
solely
magnitude
defendant
contacts
slip
internal
quotation
marks
alterations
omitted
rather
inquiry
calls
appraisal
corporation
activities
entirety
corporation
operates
many
places
scarcely
deemed
home
ibid
short
business
bnsf
montana
sufficient
subject
railroad
specific
personal
jurisdiction
state
claims
related
business
montana
business
clarified
daimler
goodyear
suffice
permit
assertion
general
jurisdiction
claims
like
nelson
tyrrell
unrelated
activity
occurring
iv
nelson
tyrrell
present
argument
bnsf
consented
personal
jurisdiction
montana
see
brief
respondents
montana
address
contention
see
reach
see
cutter
wilkinson
review
first
reasons
stated
judgment
montana
reversed
cases
remanded
proceedings
inconsistent
opinion
ordered
sotomayor
concurring
part
dissenting
part
bnsf
railway
petitioner
kelli
tyrrell
special
administrator
estate
brent
tyrrell
deceased
et
al
writ
certiorari
montana
may
justice
sotomayor
concurring
part
dissenting
part
concur
conclusion
federal
employers
liability
act
fela
et
confer
personal
jurisdiction
railroads
state
courts
also
agree
montana
erred
concluded
nature
claim
fela
claim
railroad
answers
question
whether
due
process
clause
allows
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
bnsf
agreement
majority
ends
continue
disagree
path
struck
daimler
ag
bauman
limits
general
jurisdiction
corporate
defendant
home
slip
even
insists
adhering
standard
dissent
decision
apply
first
instance
rather
remanding
montana
conduct
analysis
proper
legal
framework
accordingly
join
parts
ii
opinion
dissent
part
iii
judgment
well
adhere
faithfully
direction
international
shoe
washington
instructed
general
jurisdiction
proper
corporation
continuous
corporate
operations
within
state
substantial
nature
justify
suit
causes
action
arising
dealings
entirely
distinct
activities
international
shoe
words
courts
ask
whether
benefits
defendant
attained
forum
state
warranted
burdens
associated
general
personal
jurisdiction
see
majority
acknowledges
international
shoe
govern
describing
question
whether
defendant
affiliations
state
sufficiently
warrant
exercise
general
jurisdiction
ante
analysis
today
reflected
directive
instead
majority
opinion
goes
reaffirm
restrictive
home
test
set
daimler
test
explained
home
precedents
creates
serious
inequities
see
sotomayor
concurring
judgment
slip
majority
approach
grants
jurisdictional
windfall
large
multistate
multinational
corporations
operate
across
many
jurisdictions
reasoning
virtually
inconceivable
corporations
ever
subject
general
jurisdiction
location
principal
places
business
incorporation
foreign
businesses
principal
places
business
outside
may
never
subject
general
jurisdiction
country
even
though
continuous
systematic
contacts
within
see
slip
holistic
nuanced
contacts
analysis
backed
considerations
fairness
reasonableness
effectively
replaced
rote
identification
corporation
principal
place
business
place
result
individual
plaintiffs
harmed
actions
farflung
foreign
corporation
bear
brunt
majority
approach
forced
sue
distant
jurisdictions
contacts
connection
moreover
comparative
contacts
analysis
invented
daimler
resurfaces
proves
dispositive
majority
makes
much
fact
bnsf
contacts
montana
percentage
contacts
jurisdictions
ante
international
shoe
majority
agrees
springboard
modern
personal
jurisdiction
jurisprudence
ante
applied
comparative
contacts
test
analyzed
whether
delaware
corporation
activities
state
washington
rendered
amenable
proceedings
state
evaluated
whether
corporation
offices
forum
state
made
contracts
delivered
goods
employed
salesmen
see
despite
acknowledging
corporation
maintained
places
business
several
engage
comparison
international
shoe
contacts
within
state
washington
noted
corporation
employed
salesmen
washington
query
number
compared
number
salesmen
ibid
well
relative
percentage
contacts
irrelevant
focus
quality
quantity
defendant
contacts
forum
majority
even
daimler
disservice
paying
lipservice
question
purported
reserve
possibility
exceptional
case
general
jurisdiction
proper
forum
state
neither
corporate
defendant
place
incorporation
principal
place
business
see
slip
opinion
understood
limit
exception
exact
facts
perkins
benguet
consol
mining
see
ante
reading
narrow
read
exception
existence
entirely
certainly
defendant
significant
contacts
one
state
falls
outside
ambit
inevitable
reasoning
majority
conclude
bnsf
contacts
montana
insufficient
justify
exercise
personal
jurisdiction
result
perverse
despite
reserved
possibility
exceptional
case
daimler
majority
rejected
possibility
hand
worse
majority
reaches
conclusion
departing
normal
remanded
montana
reevaluate
due
process
question
correct
legal
standard
examined
whether
exceptional
case
instead
ruling
today
unnecessarily
sends
signal
lower
courts
inquiry
form
substance
respectfully
concur
part
dissent
part
footnotes
section
first
sentence
provides
time
bar
fela
claims
relevant
issue
hand
ease
reference
hereinafter
refer
first
relevant
sentence
describing
suit
may
brought
provision
first
sentence
sentence
immediately
follows
referring
concurrent
jurisdiction
second
note
moreover
nelson
tyrrell
overlooked
senate
report
explicit
reference
first
sentence
venue
provision
mention
personal
jurisdiction
montana
also
erred
asserting
congress
drafted
fela
make
railroad
home
jurisdictional
purposes
wherever
business
mont
discussed
supra
first
sentence
congress
dealt
venue
personal
jurisdiction
justice
sotomayor
dissenting
part
renews
debate
comprehensively
aired
daimler
ag
bauman
justice
sotomayor
treats
assertion
jurisdiction
state
washington
courts
international
shoe
washington
exercise
general
jurisdiction
post
thereby
overlooking
fundamental
difference
international
shoe
cases
international
shoe
defendant
corporation
activities
continuous
systematic
also
rise
liabilities
sued
state
courts
asserted
jurisdiction
claims
nothing
state
instead
exercised
adjudicatory
authority
hold
defendant
corporation
accountable
activity
pursued
within
state
washington
daimler
slip
therefore
occasion
international
shoe
engage
comparison
international
shoe
contacts
within
state
washington
operated
post
marked
contrast
international
shoe
nelson
tyrrell
claims
relationship
anything
occurred
principal
impact
montana
opinion
limited
montana
went
address
decide
question
montana
courts
personal
jurisdiction
bnsf
montana
law
see
also
montana
law
montana
courts
general
personal
jurisdiction
footnotes
many
commentators
observed
lower
courts
adhered
standard
decades
daimler
predecessor
goodyear
dunlop
tires
operations
brown
wrought
present
sea
change
see
cornett
hoffheimer
significant
contacts
general
personal
jurisdiction
daimler
ag
bauman
ohio
parry
rethinking
personal
jurisdiction
bauman
walden
lewis
clark
rev
doernberg
resoling
international
shoe
tex
rev
feder
goodyear
home
uncertain
future
business
jurisdiction
rev
majority
responds
language
international
shoe
informs
specific
jurisdiction
case
ante
majority
view
international
shoe
overly
restrictive
terms
specific
jurisdiction
general
jurisdiction
nowhere
found
opinion
continue
believe
noted
daimler
material
difference
continuous
systematic
terminology
international
shoe
used
call
specific
jurisdiction
continuous
substantial
terminology
used
call
general
jurisdiction
see
daimler
sotomayor
concurring
judgment
slip
indeed
neither
perkins
benguet
consol
mining
helicopteros
nacionales
de
colombia
hall
engage
analysis
montana
reached
question
wrongly
assuming
jurisdictional
statute
defendant
unique
status
railroad
company
dispositive
jurisdictional
question
remand
rather
outright
reversal
traditional
practice
lower
applies
incorrect
legal
standard
done
repeatedly
term
see
virginia
state
bd
elections
bolivarian
republic
venezuela
helmerich
payne
drilling
ante
mclane
eeoc
ante
moore
texas
ante